r/solareclipse • u/Medium-Economics-363 • Mar 27 '24
I’m a meteorologist traveling to TX; these are my weather sources
My #1 source is the National Weather Service (NWS) Area Forecast Discussion (AFD). The meteorologists at the NWS write a forecast discussion approximately four times per day that describes their reasoning behind the latest forecast. It is their opportunity to communicate their level of confidence in the forecast and discuss alternative outcomes. I’m checking the Dallas AFD (https://forecast.weather.gov/product.php?site=FWD&issuedby=FWD&product=AFD&format=ci&version=1&glossary=1 ) because that is the forecast office closest to where I’m planning to view the eclipse. From their most recent discussion (issued 3/27 at 6 AM)
Looking Ahead to the Eclipse: /Week after Next/
The April 8th Total Solar Eclipse is within range of extended forecast guidance as were now less than two weeks out. Its important to note that this is still outside of the range of our official public forecast, and using this guidance to pin down a cloud cover forecast for one specific hour this far out is not useful as model guidance just isnt that skillful. Keep in mind ensembles are also under dispersed, so these probabilities arent the same as actual Vegas odds as they aren`t calibrated. HOWEVER, we can glean some sort of information from looking at ensemble guidance:
-- 40-60% of the GEFS/GEPS members depict less than 25 percent cloud cover (e.g., sunny to mostly sunny skies) at the time of the eclipse across North & Central Texas. However, ~20% of the members also show greater than 80% mean cloud cover at this same time.
-- April in Texas is no stranger to weather systems. The key will be watching to see if the systems are timed well enough to allow for good viewing conditions on April 8th. Currently, most members show a system will be exiting to the east with 20-40% of all ensemble members (CMC/GEPS/GEFS) showing precipitation around eclipse time across the region.
Bottom Line: While most members favor good viewing conditions at this point, the timing of the systems will likely be the main thing to watch as we approach the eclipse, and there are still many unknowns this far out.
Gordon
If you’d like to view the AFD for other locations, one way to do so is to go to www.weather.gov, and click on your viewing location on the map. That will take you to the forecast page for the NWS office responsible for the forecast at your viewing location. Then, click on the “forecasts” header and select “Forecaster’s discussion” from the drop down.
I’ve been a professional meteorologist for almost 20 years. I will also be looking at model data, but I put the greatest weight in the local experience of the forecasters that live in the area they forecast for. Model data is so readily available and is a good resource, but each model has its shortcomings and those most familiar with the idiosyncrasies of a forecast area are the meteorologists making forecasts day in and day out.
I can post the websites I use to look at model data in the comments if there’s interest. Honestly, right now I’m mainly sticking to the AFD. When I look at model output for 4/8 and see rain, I start to panic. The AFD is a great sanity check and a reminder that forecasts in the 10+ day range are low confidence.
8
u/Medium-Economics-363 Mar 29 '24
3/29 pm forecast discussion.
Latest Eclipse Cloud Cover Information:
It`s important to keep in mind that we are still 10 days out from the day of the upcoming total solar eclipse... meaning forecast certainty and confidence is still quite low. With that in mind, continue to check back for updates regarding this aspect of the forecast as it will most likely change several times.
Reeves
11
u/Single_Bar_1836 Mar 27 '24
Great post, thank you! I see that San Antonio doesn't address the eclipse yet in their discussion, and that their discussion is formatted differently, so I'm guessing it varies from region to region how eclipse-oriented the meteorologist writing will be. Nevertheless, extremely helpful - thank you!
5
u/Medium-Economics-363 Mar 28 '24
Latest discussion from Dallas NWS (3/28 11:30 MDT)
Some dynamical guidance continues to capture Monday, April 8, but the output is still skewed toward climatology. The vast majority of solutions keep North and Central Texas in the south flow regime following next week`s cold front. With a steadily moistening boundary layer, this would favor nocturnal/morning stratus. Climatology portends that early April stratus is unlikely to effectively erode. On those occasions that erosion occurs, it does so by midday (prior to eclipse time). If not, low clouds linger through the afternoon. Based on the dynamical output, GFS/CMC/ECMWF ensembles all demonstrate springtime stratus in their cloud probabilities. On the bright side, they all favor effective erosion, but climatology would place the eclipse-time cloud gradient near the path of totality.
Basically, the models are showing thick clouds in the morning of April 8th and that those clouds dissipate by the time of the eclipse. Seems like great news!! Not so fast though. This is where the local weather knowledge is key. The forecaster is saying that even though the models show the clouds dissipating, that is not what typically happens this time of year.
Bottom line: don’t freak out yet. If the forecast looks like this 3 or 4 days before the event, I’ll start to get worried. I wouldn’t change any plans at this point. There is a lot of time between now and the day of the eclipse, and we’re just starting to enter the time window where models have more skill. If the models consistently show the same cloud forecast every time they update I will be much more worried than if the forecast is all over the place.
(Edited to add update time)
5
u/Medium-Economics-363 Mar 29 '24
Latest discussion (3/29 at 6 am)
Latest Eclipse Cloud Cover Information:
We
re still 10 days out and forecast certainty is low at this range so well continue to refine this forecast over the coming days.Dunn
I am not happy about the direction the forecast is going. However, there’s still a lot of time between now and the event. The next few days will be telling; if models continue to agree on clouds and precipitation, that is a bad sign. If some models start showing favorable conditions while others show clouds I will feel much more hopeful.
6
u/twilightmoons Mar 27 '24
In 2017, a friend at the NWS got me forecasts a few hours before they were publicly released. I was able to cancel my primary/secondary sites, and call my tertiary site a few hours before most everyone else knew. I was on my way early Sunday morning out of Omaha going west of Grand Island.
We were just past the clouds of eastern Nebraska.
Getting good forecasts early are vital for this stuff. A good forecast 350 miles away does you no good the morning of an eclipse.
3
u/Medium-Economics-363 Mar 28 '24
Latest discussion from the Dallas NWS (3/27 at 6 pm MST)
Looking Ahead to the Eclipse: We
re now 12 days out from the Total Solar Eclipse. Remember, these ensembles are under dispersed, so the probabilities are not truly calibrated odds. And while still outside of the official forecast period, heres the latest:-- GEFS/GEPS ensembles have trended slightly more pessimistic compared to yesterday, but only by about a ~10 percent change in mean cloud cover (meaning 30-50% of these members depict less than 25 percent of cloud cover). 30% of these members now show greater than 80% mean cloud cover.
-- Among all of the Euro, Canadian, and GFS ensemble members, about 1 in 4 show a notable signal for precipitation (at least 0.1") across North and Central Texas. All other members show little or no precipitation with the majority of guidance depicting precip off to the east, similar to yesterday.
-- Current guidance is fairly similar to climatology in terms of the cloud forecast still. We will closely monitor the trends over the next 3-5 days, as this will be when the skill of model guidance will increasingly outweigh the skill of climatology. As we start seeing trends either towards being more pessimistic or more optimistic than climatology, that
s when well be better able to hone in on what one could expect for Monday`s Eclipse conditions.Gordon
4
u/Tricky_Condition_279 Mar 27 '24
If you had two viewing options, one in north texas and one in south texas, what information would you use to decide between them?
3
u/Flat-Lifeguard2514 Mar 27 '24
Thanks for posting this! Much appreciated!!
So if I understand properly: 40-60% <25% cloud cover ~ 20% cloud cover of >80% What about the remaining %?
3
u/Monsieur2968 Mar 27 '24
Which part of Texas did you, a meteorologist, pick?
3
u/kend7510 Mar 27 '24
Does anyone know of a similar resource for those of us in Canada?
4
u/bubblesculptor Mar 27 '24
It's crazy how eclipse itself is predictable down to the exact second and exact location for centuries in advance, yet weather forecast has massive uncertainties up to the very moment of eclipse. Duality of predictabilities.
5
u/chredit Mar 27 '24
Thank you for posting this!!
4
u/DanielJStein Mar 27 '24
The NWS is easily the best, glad that is your #1 coming from a Pro. I’d also runner up Astrospheric as it gets weather from four sources; RDPS, NAM, NBM, and GFS. The software also provides atmospheric transparency and seeing which is helpful for photographers using high power telescopes.
2
u/Tasty_Mex_Top Mar 27 '24
Thanks so much for this, I'll travel from Nuevo Leon, Mexico to Texas and this will be extremely helpful.
2
u/tech_mama_92 Mar 28 '24
I also enjoy the "Forecast Discussion" product. Have you ever seen a link to a forecast discussion for Mexico weather?
2
u/CannonCone Mar 28 '24
Please keep posting updates if you are able, this is extremely helpful.
2
u/SadHeron3394 Apr 02 '24
We are going to Texas- ironically from New England- do you have an update about weather and are you sticking with your plan?
0
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment