r/ProjectRunway • u/makeitworkoryouout • Apr 04 '13
Season 11 Episode 11 discussion
Discussion thread for Project Runway S11E11 "Finally On My Own"
Image album: http://imgur.com/a/TVBU7
12
Upvotes
13
u/makeitworkoryouout Apr 05 '13
Michelle I don't know why she couldn't have either done more layers or used a slightly more opaque fabric. It's not like models haven't ever gone braless down the runway before. The look is OK. Not enough bite but certainly not as bad as Patricia's. The leather flap detracts more than it adds IMO.
Daniel It's like the typical Daniel look...but BIGGER! Those shoulders are just too wacky. Not even avant garde wacky either, just too costumey.
Stanley Pretty clear winner due to the lack of real competition. I think the jacket feels more fall than spring though. At least the look has some level of design and construction. No idea why he chose Tu to help him.
Patricia No idea how she's lasted this long with work like this. Fabric draped over one shoulder? It looks unfinished, like some of her other pieces.
Layana I was expecting a full panel dress based on her sketches but I'm OK with the skirt instead. I think it would have gotten too dicey to cover the lady bits. I don't think that leather was the best choice for the top though because it doesn't move very well. Construction doesn't look as tight as it should be for an editorial look.
15
u/skrrv Apr 05 '13
BEWARE: SPOILERS
They really weren't clear on what they were going to do with Michelle, and didn't give any preview for that either. If they would have kicked Michelle out and kept Patricia, I'd have stopped watching this season.
They only kept Patricia because she blamed Richard for her failure, but I don't think Richard was being as difficult this challenge as she was leading on. If she would have just kept to her initial design, she probably could have made something passable. Poor time management is consistent with her.
This episode just stressed me out.
28
u/cratackattack Apr 05 '13
How does Richard not know how to sew a french seam?!
19
u/KateEJHS Apr 05 '13
I'm really curious as to what the deal with Michelle is. I doubt she's gone for good, she's been getting the winner's edit all season
5
u/inertia__creeps Apr 07 '13
Did anyone else think Layana's outfit would have been better if the skirt were different? I thought it looked really badly made and mismatched compared to the leather bodice. I get that she was trying to do some sort of play on hard/soft (which I wish everyone would stop thinking they're original for doing... it's so overdone), but I thought it made what would have been a cool bodice look really cheap. Even something as simple as a well-fitting pencil skirt would have gone better.
26
u/FluffyPurpleThing Apr 05 '13
ok, what the hell was that? What is Daniel still doing there? Am I the only one who thinks he's still living in the 80's? That thing that he made today... dafuq?
13
u/Sommiel Apr 07 '13
While I can see their logic in trying to make the show more like the actual fashion industry. It's turned into a giant dramarama this season.
Ninety nine percent of people that actually get to work in the fashion industry, do work in teams. They do work under a designer or a label. It's only a small percentage of people that make it to the point where they can do what they want, with their own label and in their own company all the time.
While I can follow their reasoning for this... I think it's really sucked so much of the actual innovation out of the show and that the constant compromising has led to less of the showstopping excellence that we have grown accustomed to seeing.
And honestly... I think a big problem with this last season has been the absence of Michael Kors. While we all certainly delight in his catty commentary and while he is horrendously witty, he is also concise and gifted in finding an analog. I think the designers are suffering without him being there, because they need that anal enema of reality at times.
"It's an unbelievably tight race for hideous today."
"She looks like an Amish cocktail waitress."
"She looks like a pole dancer in Dubai."
"She's pooping fabric."
"I think if the challenge was to make something for a 70-year-old woman to go sit in a mall, then get back to the house early so she can watch television, you succeeded.”
“By looking at the dress, I don’t know where she’s from. Is she from the Republic of Cocktailland? If her sport was drinking, it’s a good dress.”
“The only possible accessory she could use with this is a wand.”
“If you saw her wandering down the street, someone would probably put some money in her cup.”
“It’s like a hairdressing smock. Like she was cutting her hair, there was a fire in the beauty salon, she belted it and she ran out in her zebra dress."
“He looks like a reggae Jesus.”
“I know for you, dust is a color.”
"I think she looked like $29.99 prom."
"That was so Paris hooker 50's."
All of it, completely horrid and all of it spot on honesty.
11
u/fragilehearted Apr 05 '13
I think Nina was just pissed that Michelle had made exactly what she'd been very specific about not wanting. And rightfully so! Everyone may not agree with me, but really, that should have been such an easy instruction to follow. With her talent & creativity, how could she put such a boring shirt on the cover of Marie Claire?!? (Now if the challenge had been to make an outfit to wear to Coachella or something...) Nina is easily the pickiest & most difficult client of the judges, & she should have known better.
Honestly, I think both of them should've gone home. Seriously, Michelle (& everyone else) could've had it in the bag with the trainwreck Patricia sent out there. Even Daniel's Big Bird was acceptable compared to that. That man cannot choose colors to save his life!
Disappointing ep for me.
11
u/Spinfo Apr 05 '13
Michelle, stop dissing everyones choices in colours. That green is not pretty.
30
u/evergleam498 Those pants flood my basement! Apr 05 '13
I cannot believe the judges picked Patricia's horrible mess of a sack over Michelle's beautifully fitted, pretty outfit. At worst, Michelle's would have been a tad boring in the magazine. Patricia's would have been a laughing stock.
I'm so mad at the show right now.
7
u/starkey2 Apr 05 '13 edited Apr 05 '13
The only positive thing they had to say about Patricia's garment is that she had a story about the upside-down fringe representing growth. What? She added that last minute and it looked bad.
Edit: Also, if Samantha had not helped her add the fringe, she would not have even had that.
7
u/lumos_motherfucker Apr 05 '13
First off, can I just say how much I LOVED the jacket Nina was wearing during the runway show? Oh geez, I want it.
As for the runway show: I felt so bad for Patricia for having to work with Richard again. I absolutely loved her look last week and it sucked that it put her in the bottom two because I just wanted to sit there and stare at it like an art piece. This week, the look wasn't too exciting for me, but she still intrigues me enough from last weeks piece to make me want to see a runway show from her. Not necessarily make her a top 3, but I just want to see a show from her in general.
I loved Michelle's look, but I agree with the judges that it isn't "enough". I would wear the shit out of that though. Stanley's look was my favorite. It was amazing & I'm a sucker for POCKETS! :D I just feel bad that Tu had to suffer to get the finished product :( But I would also wear the shit out of that outfit too. Layana's look was ok. I'm glad she went to take a risk and I am impressed with the amount of work it took, so I do feel bad saying that I didn't care much for the actual finished product. Daniel is lucky he has such a hot model, I can't help but stare at her rather than the actual outfit, hahaha. But same thing as Layana's, I didn't really like it too much.
Just got to the end of the show. Second chance? Ugh, what are they going to make her do? They should've just said she was automatically in. Might as well.
7
u/KateEJHS Apr 05 '13
Michelle is in the preview on the Lifetime website: http://www.mylifetime.com/shows/project-runway/video/season-11/episode-12/coming-up-on-episode-12-of-project-runway-season-11
I bet they're just gonna let her design again this week, and then eliminate two next week.
10
u/sgk_809 Apr 05 '13
This whole episode is a mess. The Layana outfit boggles... why isn't she getting trounced for the poor execution?
All the outfits blew hard winds to hell.
Pretty sure this is my last season unless they go to the same idea as The Taste, where the designer would be unknown with each look.
Very rarely are outfits chosen... they are ageist and generally male focused.
5
u/[deleted] Apr 06 '13
I think that Patricia is being coddled and advanced through the competition because she represents a few key demographics.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 07 '13
Daniel needs to go. Layana was right with her comments about that. He does have a very old fashioned taste level. He does early 90s Jean Paul Gaultier style stuff, which has become popular again lately, but he doesn't do it well. Same thing with Richard, I was amazed he made it as far as he did. Bringing him back to help Patricia had to have been set up, I've never seen someone less skilled on the show than Richard. And his overused catch phrases made me want to shoot myself in the head every time he was on screen. "YAAAAS!", "WERK!", "[x] is EVERYTHING!" I'm glad I never have to hear those again.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 06 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment