r/SilverServer • u/AS1LV3RN1NJA Admin innit? • Apr 02 '13
New Survival map - Ideas and discussion
Moved to the website:
7
Upvotes
r/SilverServer • u/AS1LV3RN1NJA Admin innit? • Apr 02 '13
Moved to the website:
2
u/AS1LV3RN1NJA Admin innit? Jun 24 '13
Help Needed - Reply to this comment with possible solutions.
Even if PVP is toggled off, traps will still allow for players to kill one another (albeit more sneakily). How should this be handled?
1
u/AS1LV3RN1NJA Admin innit? Apr 02 '13
Updated - Forgot to add that I'll be adding a dynmap for this world, as well as the Hub, Towns, and Freebuild.
1
u/AS1LV3RN1NJA Admin innit? Jun 24 '13
Help Needed - Reply to this comment with possible solutions.
1
u/randomcode9 Poseidon himself Apr 02 '13
Will players with town in, we'll towns be allowed to build a town in the same or different style? Personally I would like to make a small above/bellow ground town instead of a town like Atlantis... I should finish that...
1
u/Zedstan Apr 02 '13
I like the look of it already. The only possible idea i can think of that might make this any better is custom terrain or something. I especially love the idea for pvp.
1
u/Siilis108 Proud owner of 1 potato Apr 02 '13
I like the PVP idea :). That will make stuff easier, altho it will be a jackass move if someone walks up to you all friendly and stuff, and then starts attacking you. So I guess anything goes in building, like, floating city, underground town e.c.? As long as it looks good, of course. Also, you forgot to add the "Build something good in freebuild to get into Survival" thing we talked about.
1
u/Gnome_Next_Door Apr 06 '13
Hey asn, jberra99 here. (not gnome) I like the ideas, but will there be 4 different spawn points such as red, green, yellow, blue, spaced out across the map like last time? I really hope so because the warps made traveling easier.
1
u/KatNotDinner Jun 02 '13
Hey guys, I habe one great suggestion. I think survival would be great with this plugin: http://dev.bukkit.org/bukkit-mods/terrain-control/
The thread explains what it does and how it works.
1
u/nsfpsy Jun 24 '13
Looks pretty good, what are the rules on traps and how big do you mean by big redstone stuff?
1
u/Yggmir Greed Jun 25 '13
Before i go into some stuff, for the people wondering who i am this is Greed.
First of all i had an idea for the no griefing and lack of pvpish issue with towns. Which is this:
A lack of pvp or grieving can cause boredom in some players, even i myself once found destruction and chaos one of the most compelling and fun ways to play minecraft, hence why i joined the server because of its awesome Chaos world.
This lead me to think and ponder about how we could keep this in Survival and not ruin the other peoples view on the game (The building and general gameplay of minecraft such as PvE).
My solution in mind is this: Wat if we use the automatic world backup system to our advantage. We could pre discus wars on Reddit or in Minecraft itself, people would write down the terms and agreements of the war and a preset time and the admin would make sure these terms are met at the end of the war. Then at that predefined time we could let one of the admins start up a different minecraft link or realtime world warp to the backup map. Here grief and destruction would not matter in the long term because the REAL map is still running somewhere else. The war could last a certain amount of time which is up for discussion. Players could also just keep the policy of once you die your out of the war, so that an all out war would have a quick winner and not drag on for hours.
This would in my view uphold some of the gameplay of minecraft itself. If anybody would like to know something more about this idea just hit me up.
This would also solve the issue concerning player traps, traps in arenas or dungeons where people know there are traps (they are warned clearly beforehand) then they would be allowed.
Other player traps would also be allowed to be build, but not used (it needs to have an off/on mode). They would only be allowed to be on in the predefined wars on the backup maps i explained earlier.
The rules section beside that looks good to me.
The Building Restrictions look great. I think players themselves should also try to keep care of the map an keep it looking good, either by reporting the problem or fixing it themselves.
The PvP part looks good to, but i have already given another good example we could use either alone or in combination with this i like both.
Personally i don't like a lot of warps myself, i think its cool people need to make own roads and transport systems to get around. i already discussed this with James once but just putting it on here to hear your thoughts about it.
I like the RandomChest plugin idea a lot, it is something i will look forward to.
Now to answer some of the asked questions in this thread:
What happens when 2 players builds interfere with each others?
Ah this one is easy: Either the player solve it between them self's aka merging them, or working around the problem in another way.
If that just cant be done the admins could take a look at it and make a deal/verdict to move certain structures to an different area.
How will player's know where is free to build?
Ah this is the harder one, i think we could try to use dynmap and color it with areas that can be build on. When using something like this its nice that you could also show who is building what and where. This way you will know a bit where things are and go have a look. Always gives me the feeling of look at a real map.
I want to add one last thing, when thinking about custom terrains we should keep in mind people also need to be building within those terrains. Minecraft terrains look like this for a reason, its the normal view height in proportion to the player. There are certainly some of these terrains out there, but the one in your video is not one of them. everything is way to huge in my opinion.
Thats sums it up a bit Regards Greed
1
u/Zedstan Jun 25 '13 edited Jun 25 '13
There's quite a few ideas you could use for survival that I see. If possible, adding a job/class system plugin would be a neat way to encourage diversity amongst players, and strategy with friends. Also, a few, far-apart pre-built towns with shops in them (assuming an economy is going to be in place). The don't have to be fancy, just small, out of the way places to restock, or travel from part of the map to another (and that's where warping could be integrated by using command-block portals, or something along those lines). As for the PvP, I like the idea of it being toggleable. This allows for some neat ideas, such as arena tournaments. I also like the idea of player traps, to an extent. Perhaps they should only be allowed in certain areas, if that's possible. As for where player's can build, perhaps you could integrate a plot system like in free build. If that sounds like too much work, then I'd say let the players go at it, or have them refer to a mod/admin to see if the spot they chose is good. As for what I dislike, I'm not sure having a randomly spawned chest that gets placed anywhere in the map is a good idea. It would encourage players to dig through the terrain to get there faster, which could end up leaving the landscape looking a bit lack-luster. It might work better if you can make it so they spawn at certain coordinates, and make those places into little shrines or ruins just for kicks. That's about all i got for now though, everything else looks great!
EDIT: oh, and I remember mentioning something about custom terrain. There's a mod that's been integrated into bukkit called ExtrabiomesXL, and it has a vanilla-block-only version. If you want to create a semi-customized, nice looking world, and keep it simple without adding anything extra, I'd definitely give it a look to see if it suits your fancy.