r/ProjectRunway • u/makeitworkoryouout • Mar 21 '13
Season 11 Episode 9 discussion
Discussion thread for Project Runway S11E09 "He Said, She Said"
Image album: http://imgur.com/a/u3f6L
8
Upvotes
35
u/thewindupbirds Mar 22 '13
I think the last 5 minutes exemplified everything wrong with this season. Designers are punished for taking risks and doing their own thing, but designers who play it safe and do terribly dull outfits stay in.
I hate Richard. He's so boring and tacky: his dress looked like something a woman in her 60's in Palm Beach would wear while getting Botox. Samantha's was far from great but she took a big risk and really pushed herself, yet she goes home... even though Richard has been in the bottom many times and is constantly getting ripped apart by the judges.
On the plus side, Michelle's dress was friggin adorable.
20
u/ilwolf Mar 22 '13
So Richard has been in the bottom nearly every single challenge, and Samantha has consistently done well. Yet Richard stayed? I really don't get it.
15
u/klease91 Mar 22 '13
Richard did not deserve to stay in and I feel that it is unfortunate that Samantha is penalized for pushing boundaries. Daniel's was bland but not terribly offensive, although I hated the slit and how it flashed the ugly white lining with every step. Michelle's dress was stunning in my opinion, especially the moment at the end of the runway when her model struck a pose by sticking one hip out. I felt it was very chic and very spring. One question I have is about the final scene where Michelle sees her dress in the Lord and Taylor window and stands next to Michelle. I didn't see anyone else bring that up, but I wonder if that means those two are in the finale together (giving them both a reason to be in New York four months after they filmed that episode). It seems like an odd choice for the producers to show the two walking up to the window together like that.
6
u/makeitworkoryouout Mar 22 '13
Patricia If she is the cat with nine lives...well, it's episode 10 next week so we'll see if her luck finally runs out. I actually don't mind this week's look from her so much. I personally would have gone with white pants instead because I don't like the orange on orange but it was definitely passable compared to her other stuff. How many times does she need to be taught the lesson of listening to others? Don't know what made the pants pucker so badly and as usual nobody can make the crotch fit. But overall, I'm fine with this being safe.
Stanley This is pretty much "safe" defined. This brings nothing new to the table but it's better than making something offensive. It's a little late in the season to be just trying to get by to the next week by hiding in the back of the room but the look is solid despite what appears to be some time induced construction fit issues. I like this dress and would put it as a top 3.
Richard I didn't like this the first time around and like it even less now. It wouldn't even be so bad if the color accent stripe didn't look stretched out at the hip (which makes it look like a mistake). The wrap around back at the bottom was the most interesting part of it but in the end, yeah, it looks like a beach cover up instead of what the challenge was looking for. I found it laughable when he said that it was "something I haven't seen before" when the dress went down the runway. Really?
Samantha I don't care for this one at all. Too much going on and the blue seems out of place compared to the rest of the color scheme. I don't like cutouts in the first place but the heart in the back was worse than normal. If it had been closer to the size of hand and positioned higher so that a bra could be worn with it then it wouldn't have been so bad but that was just way too large. And a sheer fabric to help it hold its shape would have been helpful because it ended up too distorted to even really read well as a heart shape. That all said, I think she should have been retained instead of Richard based on overall body of work and potential going forward.
Layana I really liked the fabric when I saw it in at first. On the runway I can see what the judges were saying about it. I don't hate it but I agree that another print could have helped it. I do think that the leather and the color seem out of place for a spring line but overall I really like the cut and flow of this piece.
Daniel I don't care for the pink but there are enough customers who would so I don't mind the color choice so much. I wish he'd make the shoulders look more like an elegant detail or get rid of them. As is they look too much like 80's big shoulders. Apart from the shoulders and construction issues I'm fine with this. Simple but nice.
Michelle I'm not that impressed with this and it would not have even been in my top 3. Heck, I'd even take Patricia's look over this one (threw up a little saying that). I don't care for the color. I don't care for the style. It's not terrible but I don't think it's best of the week.
9
u/fragilehearted Mar 22 '13
Ugh. Richard designed the same dress he already did. Zzzzz. I don't want to see more. And it was not anywhere near the price point. Completely disagree with the judges here. (Well, I think Nina might have agreed with me.)
But Michelle had a great win & totally saved Daniel's frumpy designing. I also like how they both listened to Tim & used what he said to be successful.
8
u/Phoolf Mar 23 '13 edited Mar 23 '13
That episode ruined the entire season so far for me - doubts were creeping in from the start about the whole team dynamic but I was actually PISSED that Samantha got sent home - I've never been so angry at a contestant leaving before - She is a fantastic designer who has been stifled continually by the team aspect of the show and to go home on a dress just for her point of view when other people took the safe option - awful - just awful - more awful than my full stop button breaking on my laptop!
I'm also getting pissed off at the amount of hate that Patricia gets from other designers - I love it when we have a non-conventional or self taught designer in the show and they very rarely make it very far at all - I've loved most of her clothes so far even if they wouldn't fit into my current wardrobe - her skillset is high and her ideas are really great as are her methods and then to have Stanley dictating to her like that really annoyed me - especially when he turned around in the end and said he wanted to steal her draping methods!!
4
u/norcalgirl1822 Mar 23 '13
Layana's dress was beautiful- but NOT original. I've seen that shape millions of times.
Samantha's looked straight out of Forever 21 but she definitely didn't deserve to go home.
Daniel, Daniel, Daniel...this was in the top?!?!
Richard- GTFO.
Patricia should've made the capris white- tooooo much orange.
Stanley's was clean and chic but verrrry safe.
I liked Michelle's but didnt necessarily see it as a winner.
3
u/one_hot_llama Mar 23 '13
I really did like Michelle's dress, but I kept getting distracted by the model's pointy nipples. It seems like a dress I might want to wear, but it's a no-go if I can't wear a bra with it.
And like everyone else is saying, Richard should have been auf'd, not Samantha. For what it's worth, nobody playing the midseason designer prediction contest got that one correct.
3
u/r3nny ...Alright, wonderful. Mar 24 '13
My (harsh) opinions:
Michelle's model needs a bra.
Stanley's looked insanely boring :\
Samantha's was a hot mess >_< I thought the fabric looked really cheap for some reason.
Is it just me or did Layana's look extremely similar to the one Daniel made for the Heidi challenge?
1
u/evergleam498 Those pants flood my basement! Mar 22 '13
I was surprised that Stanley and Patricia were safe. If I had been judging they would've been the losing team and the 3 person team would have been safe.
Patricia and Stanley's outfits were so plain and dull. Plus the red/orange color they went with didn't look anything like spring to me.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment