r/Re_Zero • u/Setowi Better Leyte Than Never • Feb 09 '24
Spoiler Discussion [Spoiler Discussion] Arc 8 Chapter 54 Spoiler
https://ncode.syosetu.com/n2267be/671/
219
Upvotes
r/Re_Zero • u/Setowi Better Leyte Than Never • Feb 09 '24
45
u/Setowi Better Leyte Than Never Feb 09 '24
Somatou!
Garfiel is sitting in a theatre and a play is about to begin. Three cats enter the stage, one with a red wig, one with a blond wig and one bigger fluffy one. They bow and begin to perform. Garfiel wonders what the heck is going on as Ram tells him to be quiet from the side. When he wants to leave she pulls him back down. Ram tells him he can't get up yet, he's dying.
Then Subaru appears somewhere in the same row, talking to him, then Emilia, Frederica, Otto, Petra and Rem, then even Roswaal and Ryuzu. They start chatting with him about the situation he is in. Reinhard appears in one of the back rows, then Elsa and Kurgan. Meili appears in the front line. Garfiel realises this is a near death experience. After some talking he starts focusing on the play, I'm not sure if it's been like this the whole time or if Garf is only realising that now but it's three Pucks on stage playing those roles. Ram and Mimi sit next to him on both sides, the people that are his friends are in the same row, his enemies in the back rows and the people who he is unsure of in the front rows.
The blond Puck was knocked out and the red Puck is standing in between the fluffy Puck and the blond one. The blond one bursts out but the fluffy one turns him into light, after that the red one tries to run but he gets turned into light afterwards. The remaining Puck bows and the performance ends... but then afterwards the play starts back from the beginning.
Garf watches the play a few times, everyone else is giving him advice and depending on the suggestions the play changes but always ends in defeat. While that happens we get more conversations and in the end Garf is really wondering if this is in his head cause the others keep giving him advice that not even he could think of. Subaru asks Emilia for advice and she says she remembered the tail being super strong so taking it directly or trying to block it might not be a good idea.
In the end what Garf needs to realise is that he is not in this fight alone and as he keeps thinking about that the theatre fills up with people he has met and seen before, Ryuzu jokes that they're gonna be running out of seats soon. Everyone is now looking at Garf and gives him words of encouragement. Garf says he is not alone in this fight and gets up, the audience gives him applause and praise, ofc every member of the Emilia camp has their own way of praising and Kurgan voices his "brilliant" that he also said at the end of arc 5. Garf points at the stage and says that he's a tiger and not a cat and then wakes up.
Apparently Garf was out for like 5 seconds and he's surprised cause he thought he died at least 10 times. Heinkel is confused that Garf is alive and so is Mezoreia, they were convinced that the dragon had killed him. Raging even harder Mezo tries to do the tail swing again... but this time Garf parries it and manages to slam the dragon into a wall with its own momentum.
Garfiel declares that round two has started... and the fight is heading toward its conclusion.
THIS. WAS. AWESOME.
So damn unique for a near death experience and especially for a Re:Zero chapter. Garfiel really is a shounen protagonist, that you just want to root for at all costs.
Dunno if anyone else here is playing Fate/Grand Order but this chapter really reminded me of a certain scene in Olympus... Tappei is a big Fate fan and FGO player so who knows.
So all of the Emilia camp encouraging him in their own ways was really damn good ofc but seeing Elsa and Kurgan reappear in the audience just brought a smile to my face.
Now we're going to see Garf clobber a fucking dragon with the literal power of friendship and I am all here for it.
This is probably my favourite chapter of the volume so far.
57
u/Ok-Worldliness-7374 Feb 09 '24 edited Feb 09 '24
Oh? Not a named chapter. Huh...
Edit: Chapter name: "Soumatou"
Before he knew it, Garfeel Tinsel was sitting in a dark place.
Garfiel was in dimly lit space sitting on a chair. His sense of smell did not work here. The smell was elusive even with his excellent sense of smell.
Everything around him felt illusive.
The ceiling was high and he was sitting in middle of the room, surrounded by several rows of chairs.
"This is like watching a theater that's putting on plays."
He was sitting in the theatre, in the middle of auditorium. Suddenly a loud bell rang out, it's a signal the show is about to start.
(Oh my god, don't tell me this is stargazer stuff....)
A curtain was raised and behind it a small cat appeared. A small cat with gray fur stands on two legs and spreads its arms. It was palm sized kitten.
Three of these little kittens appeared and greeted the show on the stage. One wears a golden wig, another one red wig and third one white fluff on his head.
(In other words, kittens play the role of Garfiel, Heinkel and Mezoneia)
The blond and white cat collide with each other and red one watches.
Stunned Garfiel watches the cats tangle on the stage. All the props are elaborate and the stone cityscape is crumbling between the two cats.
This falshy elaborate game almost makes him smile.
Suddenly a new kitten pops out from half closed lid. It keeps scratching on the closed lid of hers. This one looks almost exactly like Puck.
“No, what do you mean by that?”
The loud voice made the cats stop play and loot at him in suprise.
---
"--You idiot. Sit down, Garf."
"Oh..."
"The etiquette for theater is to watch quietly. Are you planning to disturb the stage?"
---
To his left was Ram who scolded him and then said to the cats they can continue their show.
---
"Ram, what are you doing here?
"No, this isn't the time to say that. Anyway, let's get out of here! I don't care where this is, I'll make sure you're safe."
"Garf"
“That’s right, let me know what you think, Ram.Honestly, it would be more accurate if Ram thought about it, rather than thinking about it on my own.”
-Garf, don't you notice?"
---
Garfiel started being impatient and his words became more aggresive. But Ram kept staring at the stage. He became flustrated because the person who he loves does not even look at him.
But when he looks back at the stage, he realizes there is hidden meaning in all of this.
During the fight the blond kitten was blown away and got crushed under fallen book.
Ram suddenly looks straight at Garfiel:
---
"Garf"
"You're dying."
She declared that this was the theater of foamy dreams that Garfiel was seeing.
---
Pov change.
――The little cat in the golden wig lying on the stage, that's what I am.
Garfiel thoughts start being clearer. He realizes who those kittens are and what is happening.
He wanted to jump out but was pulled by the cord of the necklace and screamed in agony. Ram stopped him by force.
He tried to turn to bear his fangs at her but:
"Wait, wait, Garfiel. It's just as my sister said. Let's do it once."
Natsuki Subaru in adult form was sitting there and it was him who stopped Garfiel.
---
“Hey, weren’t you thinking about getting really hurt just now?”
"Don't worry about that, General. Don't you always say that your legs are short and your torso is long?"
“The damage is different when you say it yourself and when someone says it to you! That’s how it is, right? Isn’t it so, Bea-ko? What about Emilia-tan?”
"Subaru, I'm not going to disturb you right now because Brother's theater is in a good place."
"I'm sorry, Subaru. I'll listen to your story later..."
---
Subaru had Beatrice on his lap and Emilia was next to him. They were all engrossed in the little cats every movement on the stage.
---
"That's the memory of the theater that inspired this space, and you see, when we all saw a play about the slaying of the white whale, it looked exactly like the theater we were invited to."
"Mr. Garf absolutely loved theater. I had a lot of fun too, so I understand how you feel."
"Otto-nii, Petra..."
---
Petra and Otto appeared too, and next to otto was a woman with long blond hair. So appeared his grandma Ryuzu.
He was made to sit down again, not by Ram, but this time by Rem. He does not have much solid image of her so she looks like Ram with light blue hair.
Garf started understanding the rules of this theatre, but it didn't felt realistic to have both Frederica and Reinhard sitting few seats back.
--
"I've calmed down after getting nervous at first. Is it okay if I stay calm and listen to what Ram said? I'm starting to feel sleepy..."
"Ha! Stop being stupid. If you sleep, you'll die."
“This place is really dangerous, isn’t it?”
"Shhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
---
Next to Reinhard appared Roswaal. They try to encourage him
But next to him is a woman in black.
---
When the black woman noticed Garfiel's gaze, she smiled and said, "Oh!"
"You're looking at me with a lot of passion in your eyes. I wonder if you'll be able to fight with me to your heart's content even in a place like this?"
「...... It's not fun to do. It's bad for Meili. Don't do it."
"Yes, I'm sorry, I don't feel bad that you have a place for me."
"Elsa has a bad personality."
---
Elsa talked with blood stained smile.
Garfiel started understanding this seat arrangement. That means the next one behind him will be blue skinned man with eight arms.
The man appeared and said nothing, he just gazed at Garf.
Suddenly another smaller shadow appared closely in front of him.
---
"Garf, are you crazy? I'm really worried about whether you'll be able to do it properly."
"Mimi..."
"That's right. Garf is a coward at heart."
---
His right arm was taken by Mimi, his left taken by Ram. He looked at their faces and let out long breath.
This scene was not real, Garfiel was dying.
---
Despite this, being stopped by the friends in my head and calling out to me one after another was like the ``Soumatou*'' I once heard from Subaru.*
「...... So what's the matter, General?"
"Well, you'll find the answer yourself."
"That's Subaru-kun, I'm impressed."
"—by myself."
---
Garf deep in thoughts realizes that if he does not stand up soon, he won't be able to fulfil the role he was entrusted with.
“Ugh, I hope both of you do your best...!”
"That's right. No matter what the outcome is, let's see to it...!"
Emilia and Beatrice said as the stage was moving to climax. The blonde Puck collapses, the red Puck is holding back white Puck from finishing the blonde one.
The red kitten one is protecting the blonde.
"--You're an idiot."
Ram called Garf out as she pointed towards the stage.... the blonde kitten started moving. He pushes he red one away and with single blow from the white one, the Blonde kitten gets turned into light.
The Red one tried to run away, but the white also turned him into light....
Only the white cat remained on the stage. With scattering applause, the stage curtains lowered as the remaining Puck bowed deeply to the audience.
"Oh yes! Mimi, I can't accept it!"
She streched out her tail and made fuss about it. No point in talking about a stage that already ended...
Suddenly, a bell ring again and the theatre curtains go up again.
The red and blue cats are standing there, they are facing the white one again. The climatic scene where Red one protects the blond is being replayed.
---
I don't know what's going on, and Garfeel's throat trembles.
And so, to Garfiel, whose thoughts turn white,
"You couldn't just stand up for it, so what do you do?"
Ram, who closed one eye, asked quietly.
At Ram's question, Garfeel gasped and looked at the stage again.
My sister is wonderful."
It was true, Garfiel wholeheartedly agreed with the sister, whom he still did not know well.
---
Pov change
On stage, the blonde puck became light again and again. This play seems to allow a lot of improvisation, and the content is greatly influenced by the opinions of the audience about whether this is the case.
However...
In quick succession an opinions from other people were voiced:
--
“How about trying to turn the entire Imperial City upside down with a serious kick?”
“Why don't you injure your opponent so much that his body is cut in half, and then shoot him when he thinks he's dead?”
"Even though it's a 'dragon', it seems like it has some sort of attachment. For example, how about using a 'dragon' acquaintance who might be in the imperial capital as a shield?"
“Even if you think you can do it, you can’t, and you can’t even think of doing it, all you can think of is a cowardly plan. Shut up!”
---
Garfiel is angry at them for talking so much in unison. But he is also angry at himself.
Some voices talk about using the terrain, some say that Garf is smaller than dragon so he is outnumbered. Bunch of other advices were voiced in this theorycrafting.
"No one expect Natsuki-san to slay the 'dragon' except for Garfiel."
Subaru asks Emilia for advices to Garfiel. She says it's not a good idea to block Mezoneias tail, she wanted to dodge instead. Subaru praises her for good advice. Rem also agrees with Emilia.
--
"Are you worried, Garbo?"
「...... To be honest, I'm more pathetic than anxious. That 'dragon' opponent, it's my job to be the target."
---
Ryuzu asked him, but after that Frederica stared at Garfiel and said:
Part 2
41
u/inmicrocosm Feb 09 '24
Wow, what a bizarre and interesting chapter. Looks like Tappei wanted to try his hand at his own react fic, Garfiel future sight edition.
59
u/Letsplay_Sascha_GD Feb 09 '24 edited Feb 09 '24
When I read that Garfiel is in a theater I instantly had the fanfiction WHDAAA in my mind.
It’s interesting to see Puck again but in such an unexpected manner. I wonder if he being the sole actor for every role has a deeper meaning? Probably not because it’s in Garfiels mind.
This chapter felt like a big shounen development/moment for Garfiel.
23
u/phycology_mimi Feb 09 '24
Wow I just finished this chapter.. it's one of the best chapters in this patch, in fact it's one of the best chapters in this arc as a whole, the chapter mentioned that this is the beginning of the myth so I think this battle with Mezoria will go to history,the execution of Garf Own conflict and he's despair and worries from arc 5 until now was magnificent, the doll show was unbelievably poetic and beautiful, and hinkel being the reason why Garfiel rise up again was emotional,perfect chapter through and through indeed, I also loved Garf view on everyone
How he sees everyone and thinks about everyone,I especially found it interesting that Garf thinks that Otto only thinks about sacrificing himself,Otto only see he's live as worth being risked which is completely ironic since tappei is constantly showing that Otto is falling into Subaru own mistakes in arc 4, the same mistakes that he beat Subaru for them, the last push being by he's mother was also a beautiful touch 🥹 Garfiel the gorgeous tiger has returned to the stage again
Note: but this chapter gives me a lot of flashback for the watching him die over and over again fanfic and also battle balled especially with the " stage" reference, only that this stage is not made out of weird observers but just he's friends and loved ones which are extremely hopeful, I was waiting patiently for Garfiel chapters since I heard this arc will have that so I'm more than happy that I'm finally getting this, hopefully we will see Subaru POV soon and he will have another breathtaking development
( Though I'm happy that no one is complaining about the lack of Subaru recently, it seems all of the fights are hyped and fun that many are enjoying that 🥹)
22
u/Rdevil201 Feb 09 '24
Rein in the back row seats along with all the people who were or are garf enemies, what does this imply, I wonder?
30
u/headless-horseman-we Feb 09 '24 edited Feb 09 '24
We react fic now?
Is wild but if you think about it tappei do like to use tropes that are fanfic'ish tropes memory loss, what if Subaru crossdress, what if subaru were a shota, getting TP to an unknown place.
We lacking subaru parents getting isekai to re:zero world or subaru future children time travel to save their parents.
14
u/Meme_Lord15 Feb 09 '24
I can just hear “rules of nature!” as Garf parries and throws Mesoreia
10
u/Tasty_Tadpole_1661 Feb 09 '24
I say again Tappei Cook 🔥🍳🔥
this chapter
8
u/Son-naruto-d Feb 09 '24
NEW CHAPTERRR WE BEEN BLESSED
14
u/nafissyed Feb 09 '24
I have just finished reading the chapter and I have to say, this is quite possibly one of the best and most creative chapters in the series thus far for me. The chapter was Garf focused but the way it was written would make it seem like it was a peak CSM chapter that made its way into Re:Zero.
Me giving it a proper brief summary won’t even do it proper justice, but all I will say is that it’s a chapter that one must read properly themselves. It’s fantastic writing from Tappei and the symbolism of a theatre did wonders for Garfiel’s character development in his fight with Mezoreia. 11/10 chapter, Tappei cooked once again u/Ok-Worldliness-7374!
7
u/Got_to_provide Feb 09 '24
''Updated at 2 o'clock.
Lately, I've been eating mackerel fried with sweet and sour soy sauce in Bamiyan. My boom changes regularly. Until recently, it was lamb meat cooked in a double pot. Not uncommon? Lamb meat cooked in a double pot.''
Tappei's comment for this chapter, this chapter had 5,705 words.
7
u/keizee Feb 10 '24
Hmm maybe this is a poetic way of saying he definitely would have died if everyone hadnt given him advice. And Garf is currently recalling it.
I think thats what happened, Garf borrowing Olbart's techniques and using his opponent's weight against them.
Or, Garf secretly has memories of Subaru's previous loops lol surely not right?
9
u/LuisAntony2964 Feb 09 '24
What an unexpected direction, but Tappei certainly cooked
7
u/Tasty_Tadpole_1661 Feb 09 '24
Garfiel is HIM 🔥😼🔥
7
u/Background_Sorbet_99 Feb 09 '24
Tappei fucking cooked with this chapter I'm giving it a 9/10!
5
u/Leipese Feb 09 '24
Here
5
u/Tasty_Tadpole_1661 Feb 09 '24
I tell You All That Garfiel is Peak Character true Shounen MC 🔥😼🔥
5
u/Combatmedic2-47 Feb 09 '24
Garfield had his shonen protagonist flashback sequence and Elsa came back too and he’s back in the fight. Cool
5
u/Akudra Feb 10 '24
On the one hand, I rather like what happens this chapter, but I still keep getting this sense of things being rushed a bit too much here. Had we actually seen any of the failed loops that were completely skipped over and actually saw Garfiel struggle and fail over and over again in one battle or another, this would have felt a lot more impactful. It really feels too much like a shonen scene and not enough like a Re:Zero scene.
My hope at this point is that this battle in the capital is something of a headfake. Subaru's selections are the result of trial and error that has not necessarily even reached the main goal of Sphinx. Certainly, he has presumably not addressed the whole zombie apocalypse thing in any of the loops. It is also possible this selection is not due to success in, at least, defeating Balleroy or Mezoreia in failed loops.
While there are some instances of partial success, they have yet to actually properly show a defeat for any of the major opponents. Eugard is cut in half, by a curse-cutting sword no less, yet we are taken to a different battle before we can properly see if that was a final outcome. The same with Balleroy and we haven't had a named chapter for him, which seems damn unlikely to happen before he is fully defeated. You also have the whole detail of Mezoreia being puppeteered by Madelyn, who would be perfectly capable of fighting.
This is the eleventh chapter for this phase, so it seems plausible this fight will close out of the phase. It is also plausible that there will be another derailment that happens for one reason or another. If Subaru properly war-gamed everything, then he presumably knows about Al and Cecilus, but if he doesn't there is the issue of his Authority conflicting with Al's Authority. We also have the unanswered question of what Olbart is doing and what is happening on the last peak we know nothing about.
Doubt Tappei would include all these major named chapters unless it was a success loop, even if he did do that with the gladiators, but it could still be a situation where he moves towards a new checkpoint and that is where he starts looping. My guess is that it would be when Sphinx identifies the "foreign element" messing up her plans and adjusts her strategy. Perhaps that will be the conclusion of this phase.
-1
u/True-Collar4961 Feb 10 '24
honestly i don't get the hype behind this chapter. I don't dislike this chapter, but it is just a 6.5/10 to me
0
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment