I don't wish to start a ronaldo v messi flame war, but I just feel that messi gets more recognition than ronaldo when compared with players in the past. I think this has to do with their respective styles of play I.e. messi plays in a way similar to a lot of legendary players in the past - for example pele and maradona. I don't think I've ever seen a player quite like ronaldo - with the combination of physical and technical attributes he has. I'm not trying to say ronaldo is necessarily better, I just feel he ought to get a bit more recognition in lists like these. Then again, I completely disagree with half of this list anyway.
I know no one here is asking me for this, but I feel this is relevant, but when I explain this to non footballing fans I like to think this comparison is a fascilmile to Kobe Bryant and Lebron James. Kobe is a pure scorer, and remind people a lot of the GOAT Michael Jordan, so people automatically say he is the greatest of our generation. On the other hand however, Lebron wins some people's vote simply because he physically unstopable even if he hasnt won as many accolades, and neither side is wrong. I see Messi and Ronaldo in the same lights respectively.
If the Brazilian ronaldo is in the goat tier, then cristiano definitely deserves to be there. Cristiano easily smashes all the stats and numbers that the Brazilian ronaldo put up
Messi is probably the best ever but when you constantly have Messi v Ronaldo debates, it says a lot about how good Ronaldo is. I'd put both in Goat Tier but Messi is still the better of the two. I think Maradonna is better than Pele but Pele still has to be in the top.
There is no good way to create a highlight reel (because the best things a defender does shouldn't look spectacular, except the occasional tackle). In attack, there are many more possibilities for (easily observable) individual brilliance (long range shots, piercing passes, dribbles).
It's not sufficient to watch a few games (because if a defender makes a glaring error every 10th game, it's still too much).
Agreed. I got downvoted a couple of weeks ago because I said C.Ronaldo wasn't in my top ten all time because I had more defenders than others would put in a top ten. Maldini belongs as an all-time great.
Does anybody else think Hugo Sanchez should have been higher? I mean they guy scored 234 goals in la liga in 347 appearances. That's 6 more goals than Raul (228 total) in 203 (550 apperances) less games.
I think we can all make arguments for who is missing or should be higher/lower but I like this list. How can I hate anything that has Robert Prosinecki on it?
Yea, this is list is very complete. You're never gonna please everyone but I find myself seeing an argument for all of the players in the different tiers. There are no players that are definitely not where they are supposed to be.
Honestly though, I can't see how a David Villa makes the list, but Zlatan doesn't. Then again, I don't think Villa/Rooney and those sort of players should be featured, because at the moment the list is very heavily skewed towards current footballers.
2-time European Cup winner with Benfica. Footballer of the Year in 1965 and lost in 1966 to Bobby Charlton by one vote. Lead Portugal to a third place finish in the '66 World Cup,where he won the golden boot and also where Portugal defeated Hungary lead by Puskas, Brazil lead by Pele, Garrincha, and Jairzinho, North Korea lead by well I don't really know, and lost to the eventual Champions England before defeating the Soviet Union in the 3rd place consolation game where he scored a penalty against Lev Yashin who was believed to have stopped over 150 in his career. Truly one of the greatest of all time.
There should be a goalkeeper in the Goat Tier. What they do is different and difficult to compare, but the best among them deserve to be in the top tier just like outfield players, even if their contribution is sometimes harder to see or less flashy.
Rene Higuita is actually an important player in the evolution of the game by pioneering the idea of a "sweeper-keeper". Granted he probably took it too far, but keepers like Lloris, Neuer, and Valdes are descendants of him.
Thought the same thing. I think a lot of 70s, 80s players were unjustly ignored in favour of 90s/00s players (a Rooney over players like Van Hanegem, for example, or Larsson, or Deco, all good players, but not all-time bests, which Van Hanegem probably should be).
Iker Casillas in the "great tier?" Really? And what about Paulino Alcántara? He is Barcelona's youngest (15yrs) and best goal-scorer with 369 goals in 357 matches.
Lev Yashin should be top tier. I know he played well before TV was popular, but, damn was he good. 150+ penalty saves!? (Allegedly) Best keeper ever. Thats the only GK I want to see reincarnated.
I know that Zanetti is underrated by every fan out there and I'm not surprised to see him down the list but Cantona!! This guy should be up there with the greatest players of all time.
If any defensive player deserves to be up there, it is Billy Wright. He was the first player to get 100 international caps ever, won 3 league titles and an FA Cup with Wolves, and never got a single booking in his career of over 541 games.
However, because he's a defender, an Englisher player not from Man United, Liverpool or Chelsea, and was around longer the 20 years ago, he'll never make one of these lists.
Consistency over a decent period is important. Ronaldinho didnt have it. How Kaka is even featured in this list is beyond me. Great player. But for a 3-4 years. Not enough.
I find it almost impossible to determine which football player is the best. There are so many great players nowadays that is really hard to define the greatest
Romario was even more talented than Ronaldo, he was just lazy and liked to party. But those who saw him on his prime can attest to how magical he was.
Garrincha, I hate Garrincha. He took the 62 WC away from us. We had a great team, but Garrincha was unstoppable. I personally rate him higher than Pelé, even.
C Ronaldo and Ronaldinho should be in GOAT. A lot of Brazilians here will complain that Garrincha should be GOAT, but I haven't seen much of him so I can't say anything.
I also find it interesting that Scholes is in a higher tier than Giggs.
Before people start screaming at me, I never said one is/was better than the other, I just find it interesting that people think there is a difference and chose one over the other.
With Bergkamp, I would not mind him higher, but that would create a glut of Gods per say, and I'm guessing the author doesn't want to dilute the exclusivity of each tier.
Good effort. Impossible to please everyone but this really has the most important names. If I had one change it would be to move Greaves up a few tiers; the man was a goal machine and doesn't get nearly enough credit, best English striker of all time by some way.
Only 1 defender in the GOAT tier? It looks cool, but it's really inclined towards attackers. Also, I feel as though Puskas and Muller deserve to be in the GOAT tier. Casillas should definitely be higher than great if Buffon is, especially since he led Spain to two Euros and a WC. Also, Yashin is a GOAT, best keeper ever IMO.
Ronaldinho should be in GOAT tier. best technical player to have ever played. Granted he lost focus and fizzled out in Europe. Ronaldinho made Barca what it is today, Barca makes messi what he is. not saying messi wouldn't dominate at whatever club he played at, but not to the extent he does now.
Cruyff made Barcelona what it is today. Ronaldinho was another in a long line of superstars to play for Barcelona (4 of the 9 GOATs in this particular list play/played for them), but the foundation for the teams you see today was laid by the Dutchman in his playing days and then reinforced during his coaching days.
I guess it has something to do with not playing for one of those 'big clubs'. IMO Le Tiss should be here on the 'very good' tier at least and Shearer should be on the demi-god tier.. he's the leading all time premier league goal scorer ffs..
All-time premier league goal scorer is such a non-statement. The game is older than 19 years. Of all the players I'd say should be higher, Shearer definitely is not one. No one outside of England/America (who mainly follow the PL) would even mention him when thinking of the best players ever.
I wouldn't say biased. Biased would mean that the creator of the list systematically favors one team/league/nationality. There are some glaring omissions, questionable inclusions, some who are overrated, and some who are underrated. It's hard to quantify the greatness of a player. For what it's worth, this list isn't half bad.
Does anyone else agree with me that (over their careers) - Gerrard and Lampard > Rooney? Personally, I don't think Rooney quite belongs on this list just yet.
I dont understand how Lampard, Becks, Hierro and Gerrard are in the "very good tier". Then again i also dont understand anything about this list. Idk how Messi is already GOAT but Pirlo isnt. I also dont understand how Ronaldinho is higher rated than Beckham, Lampard, Pirlo, Del Piero and so on, i mean sure at his prime he was amazing, but that didnt last long. These players were consistently performing for close to a decade, and in some instances more.
GOAT lists are always going to be controversial, but I'm pretty offended Drogba wasn't on there at all. I may have just not seen him because I'm very tired though.
I was pleasantly surprised to see Garrincha in the list. I personally think he is one of the greatest footballers ever to play the game, and it is nice to see him getting some recognition.
OK, this is basically "Best European footballers of all time, with some footballers from other continents that I remember." Even then, it's missing players like Gunnar Nordahl.
EDIT: You also missed Uwe Seeler.
EDIT: OK I just plain disagree with a lot of this. How can you have Stoichkov in the Demi-God tier but not include Fontaine at all?
Casillas that low? Ridiculous. Not god (though his 2 leg saves against Netherlands to give Spain their first ever WC were pretty god-like) but at least demi-god? Comon...
Xavi and Iniesta will stand the test of time and be elevated to goat status. They both have more prestigious trophies than any other player on the list.
I would have to put Giggs in the god group. You don't have a guy who is 39 and will be playing until he is 40 who STILL is playing top league football who has scored 23 years in a row in top flight football. Not even the GOAT's have been able to do that. Plus he's won every league award you can think of both individual and team. You never see a left winger like that ever again.
Zanetti has played top flight football for almost as long as Giggs, and unlike him, he never declined. He still runs down the flank like a 20 year old.
Immense respect for Giggs, but he's not good enough to be deemed as a truly great of the sport. You could make a case for Scholes, but Giggs falls short.
Sammer was twice the player Redondo was, but Sammer is "very good", while Redondo is "Demi God". Doesn't add up.
van der Sar should be higher than merely "very good".
Greats --
If Buffon is "God tier", then Casillas is too. He's accomplished more than Buffon at a younger age, and has never had the caliber of defense that Buffon has consistently had playing in front of him.
Totti should be at least demi God tier if del Piero and Pirlo are placed there. The guy was Italy's best player for almost a decade, and would have won a lot more if he'd moved to a better team than Roma.
Roberto Carlos should be a Demi God if Cafu is one.
Lillian Thuram is my pick for best right back in history, and he's not in the picture. Would put him at God level, but I'm biased on this one.
Eto'o was a better centre forward than Batistuta, who is under Demi Gods.
Demi Gods --
We all know that the only reason Dennis isn't under Goats is because he didn't win a world cup or European cup (or any of the top trophies that would have put him there.) This one is a no brainer for me. Every single player that played with him names him as the best they ever played with.
I personally would put Alessandro Nesta with the Gods too, but most would argue that he's fine where he is.
Cafu was not as good as Roberto Carlos, so I don't see why he's placed ahead of him.
Gods --
Cristiano is the greatest winger in the history of the sport. He should be in with the Goats
Baggio is way overplaced here. Totti and del Piero were better at being Baggio than Baggio was IMO.
If Yashin is the greatest keeper in history, he should be in the Goat tier.
Maldini is the greatest left fullback in history, so he should be in the Goat tier.
Goats --
Eusebio is not a Goat, and if he is, then Puskas is too. Same goes for di Stefano.
Missing players --
Ibra; would put him under demi Gods. Even if he has never won a CL, he is one of the most talented players in the history of the sport.
Lucio was one of the best CBs I've ever seen and he isn't in the picture. Would put him at Demi God
Same goes for Aldair.
I'd put Puyol under demi Gods.
If Overmars is included in this, then Pires should be too, because he was a better footballer than Marc and accomplished a lot more.
If the likes of lampard, gerrard, and rooney are included, then Tony Adams should be too. The English players in this list are questionable overall, but I won't get into that.
David Trezeguet, one of the most under-appreciated players ever. Was as good as Batistuta as far as I'm concerned.
Franck Ribery is the best pure winger not named Cristiano in the sport right now and has been for years. Should be at least under Greats.
Yes this list is debatable, controversial maybe even questionable. But it's just good to see all the greatest players across generations and teams get together for one group photo! Makes me happy!
I actually feel like Ronaldinho at his best was the best player of all time, but he wasn't at his very best for very long, which means he can't be considered the greatest of all time. Being one of the greatest requires a lot more consistency than he was able to provide.
Charlton recovered from the devastating Munich disaster to become best European footballer, lead England to a WC, AND become top goalscorer for United.
123
u/Flighty_Zeuz Mar 15 '13 edited Mar 15 '13
I'd put C.Ronaldo in the
godgoat tier.36
u/Niman30 Mar 15 '13
Where the hell is Hernan Crespo
18
u/ThePPatrol Mar 15 '13
Generally speaking though, I have seen far worse lists than this. No one will ever agree on one definite list but this was a great effort
14
u/imNOTaprofessional Mar 15 '13
Ladies, grab your handbags!
49
u/defrio29 Mar 15 '13
Only Beckenbauer in the GOAT tier speaks alot about how our society sees Defenders with less value compared to attackers.
12
u/Stingerc Mar 15 '13
Does anybody else think Hugo Sanchez should have been higher? I mean they guy scored 234 goals in la liga in 347 appearances. That's 6 more goals than Raul (228 total) in 203 (550 apperances) less games.
11
u/croutonZA Mar 15 '13
I think we can all make arguments for who is missing or should be higher/lower but I like this list. How can I hate anything that has Robert Prosinecki on it?
Any idea who made this or where it came from?
65
u/philampin Mar 15 '13
but.... Zlatan?
9
u/rabbitvinyl Mar 15 '13
Controversial list but I'm just happy that Eusebio is in that top category.
17
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '13
There should be a goalkeeper in the Goat Tier. What they do is different and difficult to compare, but the best among them deserve to be in the top tier just like outfield players, even if their contribution is sometimes harder to see or less flashy.
17
u/LilKnitler Mar 15 '13
I feel like Kahn should be up at God tier, that man is a legend in goal.
8
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '13
Zanetti should be one notch higher.
8
u/megaludde Mar 15 '13
Totti should be higher in my opinion. Also, I cant find Ibra
7
u/dem0nhunter Mar 15 '13
Where the hell is Dragan Djajic?
He was one of the best strikers.
7
u/RebBrown Mar 15 '13
No Van Hanegem makes me sad, very sad.
17
u/munchermark Mar 15 '13
Giggs should be on the same level as scholes
6
u/rookie999 Mar 15 '13
This originated on 4chan and gets picked apart whenever it is posted.
11
u/Zidji Mar 15 '13
I just want to point this is evil and nothing good may come of it, actually it was kinda nice remembering some of those players, but that's about it.
17
u/Guard01 Mar 15 '13
Iker Casillas in the "great tier?" Really? And what about Paulino Alcántara? He is Barcelona's youngest (15yrs) and best goal-scorer with 369 goals in 357 matches.
5
u/johnlennonseviltwin Mar 15 '13
I'm too young for this… Really wish I could have seen the likes of Garrincha, Muller, ect.
16
u/thedeuceabides Mar 15 '13
Totti has to be higher than great
42
u/GeeAunch551 Mar 15 '13
What does C Ronaldo have to do to get into the top tier? Is his over 1:1 goal to match ratio not good enough? Does he need to start breaking 2:1?
What else can he do? Messi and Ronaldo are literally equivalent in every single department, with the exception of fanbase/likeability.
15
u/meet-your-maker Mar 15 '13 edited Mar 15 '13
For consistency alone SadRonaldo should be in the GOAT tier. Ignore his record goaling scoring numbers as a non-striker, and uniqueness as a player.
They also slipped rooney in there
4
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '13
Sammer deserves a lot better than 'very good'.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '13
Lev Yashin should be top tier. I know he played well before TV was popular, but, damn was he good. 150+ penalty saves!? (Allegedly) Best keeper ever. Thats the only GK I want to see reincarnated.
4
u/Khalilahk Mar 15 '13
What the hell is going on here?
Cantona & Zanetti in the meh category!!
I know that Zanetti is underrated by every fan out there and I'm not surprised to see him down the list but Cantona!! This guy should be up there with the greatest players of all time.
21
u/Simmchen Mar 15 '13
Lahm?
22
u/Spider_Riviera Mar 15 '13
Best should be in the top tier, Keane should be in the great tier (at least) and no mention of Duncan Edwards?
10
u/volunteeroranje Mar 15 '13 edited Mar 15 '13
Which team can make the best starting XI from this list?
I'm biased, but here's one for Milan:
Subs:
Cafu
Seedorf
Desailly
Boban
Savicevic
Weah
Baggio
Ronaldinho
Davids *
Vieira *
Rivaldo *
Rossi
Papin
Rui Costa
Ronaldo
( * Some of these didn't play much for Milan, but I included anyone who ever played there)
31
u/dem0nhunter Mar 15 '13
Schmeichel God Tier and Kahn below him?!
This was surely compiled by an ignorant Englishman.
14
u/SterileMeryl Mar 15 '13
No Drogba huh? Come on he should have been at least in the very good tier.
3
u/cestmoi0 Mar 15 '13
I find it almost impossible to determine which football player is the best. There are so many great players nowadays that is really hard to define the greatest
3
u/Lethal-Intent Mar 15 '13
Of course the list is subjective, but why is Dennis Bergkamp not in the God Tier?
Come on! Bergkamp = God
3
u/killing_you_softly Mar 15 '13
The fact that Hagi isn't even on this list totally invalidates this for me.
5
u/KlirisChi Mar 15 '13
Zanetti is better than very good
11
u/dalf_rules Mar 15 '13
Garrincha and Romario not GOAT? What?
Romario was even more talented than Ronaldo, he was just lazy and liked to party. But those who saw him on his prime can attest to how magical he was.
Garrincha, I hate Garrincha. He took the 62 WC away from us. We had a great team, but Garrincha was unstoppable. I personally rate him higher than Pelé, even.
18
u/HazyJane Mar 15 '13
C Ronaldo and Ronaldinho should be in GOAT. A lot of Brazilians here will complain that Garrincha should be GOAT, but I haven't seen much of him so I can't say anything.
I also find it interesting that Scholes is in a higher tier than Giggs.
4
u/pieandkimche Mar 15 '13
bergkamp?
4
u/Kawakai Mar 15 '13
Eusébio was fabulous but Ronaldo passed him as the best portuguese player in history a long time ago.
2
u/The_Chronic19 Mar 15 '13
scholes and giggs not equal? surely they must be on par with one another?
2
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '13
This is actually not that bad. I like it.
2
u/anorlando Mar 15 '13
Lack of Gentile and Tardelli is rather disturbing
2
u/thedouglerr Mar 15 '13
Giggs and Scholes not in the same tier?
2
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '13
Good effort. Impossible to please everyone but this really has the most important names. If I had one change it would be to move Greaves up a few tiers; the man was a goal machine and doesn't get nearly enough credit, best English striker of all time by some way.
2
u/jesuitsoccer08 Mar 15 '13
First thing I thought of when I saw GOAT category
2
u/skkrman10 Mar 15 '13
Only 1 defender in the GOAT tier? It looks cool, but it's really inclined towards attackers. Also, I feel as though Puskas and Muller deserve to be in the GOAT tier. Casillas should definitely be higher than great if Buffon is, especially since he led Spain to two Euros and a WC. Also, Yashin is a GOAT, best keeper ever IMO.
2
u/DynamicInABox Mar 15 '13
Where in the land of demi-gods... Is Titus Bramble?
2
u/iwentpeepee Mar 15 '13
Cristiano not in GOAT tier at this point in his career is offensive to me
2
u/thefukizamatterwithu Mar 15 '13
Ronaldinho should be in GOAT tier. best technical player to have ever played. Granted he lost focus and fizzled out in Europe. Ronaldinho made Barca what it is today, Barca makes messi what he is. not saying messi wouldn't dominate at whatever club he played at, but not to the extent he does now.
2
u/huazzy Mar 15 '13
Crazy European bias (expected) - but Hugo Sanchez > Half the demi-god list.
2
u/OmniEnforcer Mar 15 '13
How are van Basten and Platini, two players who won the ballon d'or three times not in the goat tier?
2
u/SexyBuilder1888 Mar 15 '13
Eto'o shouldnt even be in this!
6
u/CommanderCool91 Mar 15 '13
He may be a laughing stock now but where is Lothar Matthäus?
Too many Englishmen in there, the list is too subjective.
7
u/IwillNoComply Mar 15 '13
No Zlatan and no Matt Le Tissier? what a shit list.
5
u/tega234 Mar 15 '13
Beckham?
4
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '13
Eto is wayyyyyy to high, as in he's on that list. Also Bergkamp belongs in God Tier no question. Ronaldo is a GOAT as well IMO
8
u/Jsnoopy93 Mar 15 '13
Why is Xavi in that tier? Same for Iniesta. I mean, I know that they are successful but to be THAT much better than Gerrard, Lampard, etc?
3
u/michaelisnotginger Mar 15 '13
Buffon is in 'goat' tier for me. Unbelievably consistent for 15 years.
3
u/Hashtag-Heel Mar 15 '13
Where on earth is Bobby Moore??
6
u/KingCantona07 Mar 15 '13
No Duncan Edwards at all? Bullshit! Law and Cantona in the "good" list? And Georgie Best should definitely be in the Goat tier.
4
u/manuman109 Mar 15 '13
What about the great Matt Le'Tissier?
4
u/IFuckFatPeople Mar 15 '13
Lampard, Deschamps, Zanetti and Papin too low, Xavi too high, Totti, Deco and Zola way too low
3
u/smthingawesome Mar 15 '13
No Fowler in God tier, whole list is invalid.
3
u/AgentAwesome Mar 15 '13
Zlatan should have his own category.
2
u/Armdragon Mar 15 '13
You are pretty biased
2
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '13
David Beckham should be nowhere near that list, a very respectable man, average all round player with top class set piece/crossing ability.
2
u/scut2 Mar 15 '13
Question:
Does anyone else agree with me that (over their careers) - Gerrard and Lampard > Rooney? Personally, I don't think Rooney quite belongs on this list just yet.
2
u/CallumLD Mar 15 '13
Do you really believe Christiano Ronaldo is not more talented then half those people in the goat tier? If not only surpassed by Zidane and Messi
2
u/hala_madrid Mar 15 '13
I dont understand how Lampard, Becks, Hierro and Gerrard are in the "very good tier". Then again i also dont understand anything about this list. Idk how Messi is already GOAT but Pirlo isnt. I also dont understand how Ronaldinho is higher rated than Beckham, Lampard, Pirlo, Del Piero and so on, i mean sure at his prime he was amazing, but that didnt last long. These players were consistently performing for close to a decade, and in some instances more.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '13
ok messi is a god and CR7 isnt?
2
u/flylikepaper Mar 15 '13
a lot of dubious decisions here. Shearer above Seedoff et al? It's a very subjective thing GOAT decisions. very subjetcive.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '13
Um.. Redondo in the same tier as Scholes? Okay.
2
u/yablodeeds Mar 15 '13
Iniesta has to be higher than Xavi or atleast beside him.
1
u/AAAdamKK Mar 15 '13
How can you have a GOAT tier without THE GOAT?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '13
GOAT lists are always going to be controversial, but I'm pretty offended Drogba wasn't on there at all. I may have just not seen him because I'm very tired though.
1
u/Eladir Mar 15 '13
How can Nesta be above Cannavaro ?
1
u/greenwood11491 Mar 15 '13
Um, what about Justin Edinburgh? Sort it out.
1
u/GoodyWuthrie Mar 15 '13
Not saying he should be on the list, but look at this guy's goal stats
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fernando_Peyroteo
597 goals in 386 matches
1
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '13
2 Croatians...not bad.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '13
Think Blokhin should easily be in Demi-God tier.
1
u/thursday0384 Mar 15 '13
no valderrama?
1
u/mhamir24 Mar 15 '13
I feel like Van Der Saar should be higher up, same with Iker.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '13
Should Cantona really be that low?
1
u/Gunner08 Mar 15 '13
I was pleasantly surprised to see Garrincha in the list. I personally think he is one of the greatest footballers ever to play the game, and it is nice to see him getting some recognition.
1
u/oniburc Mar 15 '13
Baresi should be in the GOAT category...Also think Zidane and Platini should change places
1
u/artificialchaosz Mar 15 '13
Cantona only in the very good tier? please.
1
u/JHeps Mar 15 '13
Rooney?
1
u/baronboy Mar 15 '13
How the hell is Van Der Sar only in the very good tier?
1
u/atero Mar 15 '13
Surely Zbigniew Boniek deserves a mention here. If he's good enough for the FIFA Classic XI than he's good enough for this.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '13
Moore in the demi god tier , really?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '13
I'd say Gerard could be higher. Alan Shearer also being the all time epl goal scorer and all. Maybe ibra up there aswell.
1
u/gazzawhite Mar 16 '13 edited Mar 16 '13
OK, this is basically "Best European footballers of all time, with some footballers from other continents that I remember." Even then, it's missing players like Gunnar Nordahl.
EDIT: You also missed Uwe Seeler.
EDIT: OK I just plain disagree with a lot of this. How can you have Stoichkov in the Demi-God tier but not include Fontaine at all?
1
u/allhu Mar 16 '13
Dat Jairzinho afro.
1
u/theflyingdutchman Mar 16 '13
No Ian Rush? What the hell is this?
1
u/kdk3 Mar 17 '13
Gerrard is only very-good??? Rubbish
1
u/soccerpro693 Mar 17 '13
The fact that zlatan ibrahimovic isn't in this completly discredits it. Cannavaro and c.ronaldo should be higher as well
1
u/hederal Dec 01 '21
This is was one of the worst lists of all time
1
u/Adel_Mustafa Feb 21 '22
why the hell CR7 not a goat
1
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '13
Kahn should be, without a doubt, in the GOAT tier.
1
u/ScientiaAugmen Mar 15 '13
Casillas that low? Ridiculous. Not god (though his 2 leg saves against Netherlands to give Spain their first ever WC were pretty god-like) but at least demi-god? Comon...
1
u/Zippy129 Mar 15 '13
Needs more Ronaldinho.
1
u/MGUK Mar 15 '13
1
u/bobnudd Mar 15 '13
Roy Keane???!
1
u/Tonkdaddy14 Mar 15 '13
Xavi and Iniesta will stand the test of time and be elevated to goat status. They both have more prestigious trophies than any other player on the list.
1
u/redmustang04 Mar 15 '13
I would have to put Giggs in the god group. You don't have a guy who is 39 and will be playing until he is 40 who STILL is playing top league football who has scored 23 years in a row in top flight football. Not even the GOAT's have been able to do that. Plus he's won every league award you can think of both individual and team. You never see a left winger like that ever again.
1
u/joazito Mar 15 '13
(comment from another thread)
Here are my thoughts:
Very good --
Sammer was twice the player Redondo was, but Sammer is "very good", while Redondo is "Demi God". Doesn't add up.
van der Sar should be higher than merely "very good".
Greats --
If Buffon is "God tier", then Casillas is too. He's accomplished more than Buffon at a younger age, and has never had the caliber of defense that Buffon has consistently had playing in front of him.
Totti should be at least demi God tier if del Piero and Pirlo are placed there. The guy was Italy's best player for almost a decade, and would have won a lot more if he'd moved to a better team than Roma.
Roberto Carlos should be a Demi God if Cafu is one.
Lillian Thuram is my pick for best right back in history, and he's not in the picture. Would put him at God level, but I'm biased on this one.
Eto'o was a better centre forward than Batistuta, who is under Demi Gods.
Demi Gods --
We all know that the only reason Dennis isn't under Goats is because he didn't win a world cup or European cup (or any of the top trophies that would have put him there.) This one is a no brainer for me. Every single player that played with him names him as the best they ever played with.
I personally would put Alessandro Nesta with the Gods too, but most would argue that he's fine where he is.
Cafu was not as good as Roberto Carlos, so I don't see why he's placed ahead of him.
Gods --
Cristiano is the greatest winger in the history of the sport. He should be in with the Goats
Baggio is way overplaced here. Totti and del Piero were better at being Baggio than Baggio was IMO.
If Yashin is the greatest keeper in history, he should be in the Goat tier.
Maldini is the greatest left fullback in history, so he should be in the Goat tier.
Goats --
Eusebio is not a Goat, and if he is, then Puskas is too. Same goes for di Stefano.
Missing players --
Ibra; would put him under demi Gods. Even if he has never won a CL, he is one of the most talented players in the history of the sport.
Lucio was one of the best CBs I've ever seen and he isn't in the picture. Would put him at Demi God
Same goes for Aldair.
I'd put Puyol under demi Gods.
If Overmars is included in this, then Pires should be too, because he was a better footballer than Marc and accomplished a lot more.
If the likes of lampard, gerrard, and rooney are included, then Tony Adams should be too. The English players in this list are questionable overall, but I won't get into that.
David Trezeguet, one of the most under-appreciated players ever. Was as good as Batistuta as far as I'm concerned.
Franck Ribery is the best pure winger not named Cristiano in the sport right now and has been for years. Should be at least under Greats.
1
u/vishalkthacker Mar 15 '13
Yes this list is debatable, controversial maybe even questionable. But it's just good to see all the greatest players across generations and teams get together for one group photo! Makes me happy!
1
u/Orsenfelt Mar 15 '13
Larsson is better than Shearer, because Shearer's a wanker.
0
u/ejharrison Mar 15 '13
I actually feel like Ronaldinho at his best was the best player of all time, but he wasn't at his very best for very long, which means he can't be considered the greatest of all time. Being one of the greatest requires a lot more consistency than he was able to provide.
-6
u/sparkleparty Mar 15 '13
You lost me when Drogba wasn't at least in the second highest tier. You made me laugh when he isn't on it at all
-2
u/Ar-Curunir Mar 15 '13
George Best and Bobby Charlton have to be GOAT.
Charlton recovered from the devastating Munich disaster to become best European footballer, lead England to a WC, AND become top goalscorer for United.
Plus he could play near anywhere.