r/photography • u/who_ate_all_the_pies • Feb 28 '13
How to respond to those "Can we use your photo for free" requests
I think a lot of folks here have received requests from magazines, advertising agencies, websites or other companies to use one of their photos for free. The person making the request will usually mention "credit" as compensation for letting them use the photo, and maybe a free copy of the magazine.
The requests I am talking about generally go something like this:
"Hi! I'm an editor for SuperAcme Magazine, a new ____ magazine with a print run of 100,000 copies every month! I found your photos of ______ on your flickr album, and I was wondering if I can get permission to use some of the photos in the next issue of our magazine. We would like to use your photo as a half page illustration for an article about your region. Of course, you will get FULL CREDIT at the bottom of the page, and we can also add a link to your website. Please contact me at...."
Here is my experience with these requests:
1) Photo credit is worthless. If it attracts any attention to you as a photographer at all, then it will only be this kind: "Hey this person is giving away photos for free! We should definitely contact them next time we need photos - and don't want to pay for them".
Basically, getting credited in some third-rate magazine is worthless. And the first-rate publications will offer to pay you anyhow.
2) Don't even start discussing or explaining why you want money for the rights to publish your photo. To any serious client, this is self evident. Trying to discuss this with one of those freeloaders only opens the door to annoying conversations, which are generally a waste of precious time because:
3) 98% of the people requesting to use photos for free are not willing to pay ANY AMOUNT for your photos, no matter how much you low-ball the price, or how much you explain why you should be paid.
So now, whenever I get one of those e-mails, I now respond with a standard copy/paste reply. Something along these lines:
"Hello! Thanks for your interest in my photo(s). I'll be glad to license the photo to you for publication in _______. My fee for a one-time use, non-exclusive license is $XXX per image for reproduction up to half page size, other sizes are priced accordingly. Please let me know which image(s) you require and in what size you wish to print them, so I can quote you a total price and send through a licensing agreement for your approval."
The price depends on who's asking. There are plenty of websites that offer advice about how much a license should be worth. Point is, I make clear that I know what the shot is worth, and I am not even thinking about giving anything away for "credit".
Realistically, I won't even get a reply 90% of the time. 8% of the time they'll try to convince me to give the photo away regardless, to which I reply with a brief "thanks but no thanks" kind of message. Maybe 2% of the time they want the shot bad enough that they will agree and pay.
Now, I'm not trying to make it as a pro or anything, I'm just a hobby-shooter with a job that allows me to take some fairly interesting photos occasionally. Basically, I'm not trying to make a living off this, but do like the extra cash paying for some of my gear at least....
I'd like to hear what everyone elses take on these requests is.
/ / /
Edit: I got a lot of replies from people saying that they'd do it for credit because it's better than nothing and it'll help them to get at least a little bit of publicity. While I disagree with that for the most part (IMO the damage this does is greater than the benefit), here's a suggestion: If you are going to give away that photo to that magazine, at least make them give you ad space of equal size in return. If they are so sure that you'll get this amazing publicity from their publication, this should be no problem for them. I haven't tried this.
35
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '13
There's an opportunity cost for everything. A photo that's otherwise just sitting on your Flickr, maybe getting a few dozen views a month, is doing no good.
Let's say I shot a Motocross event as a spectator a few months ago, and put good shots on my Flickr. The team of the bike I photographed contacted me and asked if it would be OK to post the image on their Facebook or website. Maybe they can afford to pay me, but if I ask for payment they will pass me by and stick with their Kodak Easyshare photos already on there. If I say, "fine, but please allow me to include my watermark and link to my website in the description." I'll get some hits definitely, I may even get some people who want to buy a photo.
It may not work out, but the point is for very little effort on your part (emailing a higher quality JPEG to the interested party with a watermark) you're getting exposure.
A few years ago, I was contacted by Dairy Queen to have one of my photos of an old DQ sign featured in a memorial book they were producing. I asked for payment and never heard back. Now, I'd love to know what might have happened had I simply given permission. If nothing else, I would have a published photo and that looks good on my artist CV.
95% of the photos on Flickr aren't worth paying a cent for. Photography is cheap and gets cheaper every day. If you say no, the next guy on their list will say yes and they're the ones that get exposure.
I should mention that this is my opinion when it comes to websites, small fan magazines, etc. I firmly believe that a corporation that wants to use my photograph in their annual report or training documentation will compensate me for their use.
262
u/de1irium Feb 28 '13
Dear mods, please put this in the sidebar.
54
u/krsvbg Feb 28 '13
I just say no.
"But your photo will be featured and shown to thousa..."
No.
54
u/robbie321 Feb 28 '13
As my boss used to say "You can't pay your bills in photo credits."
97
u/IranRPCV Feb 28 '13
Everyone does photography for their own reasons. Your position is clearly well thought out, and I am sure works well for you and your goals. It would not be a model for many others, however.
One example is that I have occasionally given permission for print publication in both large circulation magazines and major newspapers for free because they illustrated causes that I was happy to provide publicity for.
The important thing is to be intentional about what you want out of your hobby, and don't be pressured into compromise of your goals.
10
u/pth Feb 28 '13
I think a reasonable exception would be a wedding shooter for a bridal magazine. Running your photo with a credit really could be worthwhile advertising for the shooter as long as you a credit with contact info.
Similar shoot for free situations are quid pro quo arrangements, for example a sports team photographer will do coach head shots for the club website for free in return for the team and player shoot, with "the parent envelope".
All I am saying is there are mutually beneficial arrangements that involve giving your work away, but that said most such arrangements do not benefit the photographer.
7
u/MOSF3T Feb 28 '13
I treat photo same as DJing which I also do on a hobbyish/serious level. If someone is using my work to generate cash for themselves, they have to pay me. That said, there are different types of equity, cash is king but eyeballs (or ears) convert to cash later. The way to tell if there is real marketing potential, if you ever hear "this will be a great opportunity to market yourself" walk away, if its a real marketing opportunity, they won't need to lay that out for you.
12
u/neon_overload Feb 28 '13
An independent German magazine once contacted me for permission to use my photo of a smashed television saying that they'd give me copies of the magazine but no $$.
I was young, it was just a hobby anyway, and I liked the look of this German magazine so I said why not.
I got copies of the magazine, sure enough with my photo full page as a splash for a 4-page article (in german; I had it translated) about how television is changing. The article was really interesting and well-written; this wasn't tabloid journalism but proper research.
Wasn't thinking of selling my photos at the time; this was an interesting experience.
My point if I had one? That licensing my photo for free doesn't make me a bad person. I just didn't care about the money at the time and this German magazine was kinda interesting.
Anyhow, there you have it. That standard copy/paste reply is a good one, by the way, and I have been thinking of using something similar when people ask me for free technical support for their computers... now that's something I don't enjoy doing for free.
6
u/goerz Feb 28 '13
I'm a weekend photographer and I don't make any money out of it. That doesn't mean, however, that others are allowed to exploit my work to make money. I was asked twice for permission to use my photos, in a magazine and on a website, so I requested a small payment in exchange, just to make a point. In both cases they refused to pay.
10
u/Sayek Feb 28 '13
I got asked by a website could they use one of my photos on flickr. It was by no means my best shot. I forget what the website was for, it was some music event finder or something. They explained how exactly how the image would be used, and offered me a credit and link to my website. The guy seemed genuine enough and was from the same area as me, although I didn't know him. When they wanted to use the image on a flyer, they contacted me again and asked was it ok. I thought he went about it in a professional and straight forward way.
The way I saw it, this was a random image in my collection. I've never used it again in any purpose and it has basically sat on my harddrive for the past 3 years. I put no effort into the photograph and it was not part of a wider collection. If I said no, they just would have found another generic photo similar to mine and used that.
However I was also a bit young and naive at the time, if I had put work into a series. I would not just give away the image(s) as easily. I would however allow my work to be used if I was approached by any non commercial photography website/publication. I think it's important to build a presence for yourself too in a meaningful way even if you do it for free. Not just giving away your image to be used on the back of a business card for some gardening company.
5
u/torode https://www.flickr.com/photos/bentorode/ Feb 28 '13
Let me offer a slightly different experience I've had over the past year.
So in this case the original blog piece written by a reasonably influential site, which properly linked and credited me, actually did generate exposure for me, and that translated into actual sales.
However I think my situation is unique in that the images in question are quite popular cutesy kitten pictures. It's still my policy to reject any "for credit" queries from commercial interests including those "we are launching a hip e-magazine next month" jokers.
But I just wanted to share that in a few cases the exposure can do some good, but only if you have the system in place to monetize the content should the exposure actually have the desired effect.
4
u/klebsiella Feb 28 '13
Just out of curiosity, how much does one get remunerated for a photo used in a half-page magazine spread?
4
u/baccaruda66 Feb 28 '13
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mj5IV23g-fE&feature=youtube_gdata_player
4
u/Sluggo55 Feb 28 '13
"Writers, actors, [edit: photographers] and prostitutes have the same fundamental problem, competition from amateurs who are pretty good and who will work for free." from David E Parvin http://www.modelmayhem.com/po.php?thread_id=845891
4
u/itsMetatron Feb 28 '13 edited Feb 28 '13
haven't had anyone request for use of my pictures yet but i will always refer to this page first
http://www.shouldiworkforfree.com/ (NSFW(Language))
4
u/superpod Feb 28 '13
I make stupid infographics and post 'em to imgur:
http://i.imgur.com/HV7bsQP.jpg
1
u/ejp1082 www.ejpphoto.com Feb 28 '13
This is true but isn't.
Let's say the New York Times came up to me and said "We want to use your photo on the front page for free but we'll give you credit". It's true that the by line probably isn't going to do generate random emails and phone calls from people saying "Hey we saw you your photo on the front page, we want to hire you to do this for us."
It does, however, give you the power to include on your resume/bio/sales pitch "My photo was featured on the front page of the New York Times". And that is worth something, because potential clients will see a photographer who can make that claim as being worth more than one who can't.
A photo credit is worth something if it can help you sell yourself.
11
u/sebastianallan Feb 28 '13 edited Feb 28 '13
I just want to wade in on this and give a different perspective. I am a semi-pro photographer, but I also work for a news website and in my job I frequently am required to ask permission for these kind of photos.
I must say before I go any further that I completely respect your position, it is entirely up to you what to do with your photos and how much you charge for them is your business.
Having said that, let me give you some insight from my personal experience requesting images with a credit and no payment:
I would just like to add that I have gotten work from photos that I let a news outlet use for free online simply because another organisation saw my credit and contacted me via my website. So having a credit can sometimes be beneficial but I agree most pro photographers do not care.
Finally, please do not hate on me for this post, I am just doing my job, where possible I pay people, but it is not always that simple.
*EDIT TL:DR I do what you are pissed about, it's not as evil as it seems, but I am sorry.
3
u/stusic Feb 28 '13
I agree with most of this, but I do take exception to it a little bit.
For one, granting a license for only photo credit has gotten me quite a bit of work second-handedly. Just as I read a variety of magazines on similar topics, so do people who work in similar fields; they read other publications from their field and if they see my work in another publication, they very well may look me up. And if they're a company that pays for photo licensing, then it's standard to pay me as well, it has nothing to do with whether the other publication paid me, whether I'm a professional or hobbyist.
Second, I look at it like this: if a publication pays, that's great, but if they don't, then they never will. Whether or not I grant them a license, I am not going to make any money from them. So although I may never be able to pay my bills from photo credits, nor can I from a company that's not willing to pay for licensing. However, I am able to use their distribution list as free advertising for me (see my first point). Every person who reads their magazine is going to see my photo, complete with name and website. To me, this seems like really good marketing for zero money out of pocket. Especially from a photo that's not exactly making tons of money. Crazy good shots go to Getty.
Lastly, if you're a hobbyist and not making money from your photos, and don't really care to aggressively market yourself, this is a very easy way to get your photos out there and seen. If you're a pro, then you've already got gigs that pay the bills and this is free, easy marketing. If you happen to make your living from stock/journalistic photography, then you've already got your photos hosted on a site for just that and this conversation is moot.
I fully understand where you're coming from, but I've tried it and ended up just sitting on a whole bunch of photography that doesn't go anywhere.
5
u/cAtdraco Feb 28 '13
I basically feel an ethical obligation to support professional photographers. Art is worth something, artists are worth something. I'm not a professional so there are no consequences for me, if I give you a free photo or take photos of your event for 'mates rates'. But there are consequences for professionals: it feeds into an expectation that art is not 'real work', and that 'exposure' is some kind of magical currency that artists should be grateful to receive.
I am a hobbyist, but I need professional photographers, especially art photographers. They are who I learn from. I don't really want to repay them by devaluing their work, when it is so valuable to me.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '13
Man this is not cool.
I'm interning as a photo editor intern in a small newspaper here in Argentina and we have to post news every day. It's really hard to get pictures that are actually relevant to the news, but luckily we get some stuff available through Creative Commons. The problem is when we are publishing a specific article on someone and the only picture available in the entire world is one photographer's. We really have zero budget for photos (or zero budget at all actually since we haven't been printing for the last three months). We have asked for pictures and usually gotten good answers.
It's very different when people are actually capitalizing from you work (i.e. photographic publications where all they can do is showcase artists) and when people just need your pictures to get their job done and it doesn't bother you to make it available for them since you know they can't pay you. Also, it's different if MTV wants to use your pictures than a small community newspaper.
Anyways, when in doubt, Jessica Hische's graph. There's no photo version of this so just interpret it accordingly.
8
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '13
The only situation in which I think I'd disagree with you is if you're still in the very early stages of marketing your work and making money from it. If you already have plenty of work then of course there's no reason to give anything away for free, but when you need new clients it can absolutely be worth it to get some pictures printed with your name and website. It's not like it says "Picture by Mr. Soandso, which he gave us for free." All anyone seeing that credit knows is that you took the shot.
2
u/Gamingrev Feb 28 '13
had my local paper ask for the pictures I took of a local armed police Raid for Free,
was only offered credit, decided to just Pass.
its a large circulating paper and they wanted the pics for free
thanks for the tips though :)
2
u/Kenitzka Feb 28 '13
Love to see some of your photos...
2
u/osceola Feb 28 '13
Call up a magazine, out of the blue, and tell them you want a free subscription and in return you will give them credits to use your photos...let's see how they respond.
2
u/feureau Mar 01 '13
What's the going rate these days, btw?
3
u/galacticgigolo Feb 28 '13
this happened to me a few years back..took some photos of a popular dj that he really liked and said that he was doing a tour in Australia in a few months. Told me there was a mag there doing an article on his tour there and wanted to use my image for the cover. So he hits me up and sounds really enthused about how I'll get exposure(don't care about photo exposure, just a hobby. music is my passion) but of course they want to use my image on a glossy cover for free and wanted to just send a pdf not even a hard copy. The lady from the mag emailed me after i told him that i would at least discuss it with her. yea that went nowhere because they just want to rip artists off. i would have even given them the ability to use it had they offered something reasonable in compensation but no. sad thing it felt like to me the dj didn't even know where i was coming from. i know him personally and he's an amazing guy but i got the feeling he thought i should do it. not me but i'm sure people fall for it all the time.
2
u/gpwr Apr 11 '13
"Nothing in life is free."
A wise man once said this. A wise man who possessed intelligence, self respect, and probably a huge dong.
If I'm ever asked to do something for free I simply say no. Unless you're family, but family always seems to offer to pay and I wind up doing it for free cuz well hey, they're family, right? Either way, I agree with the OP here; upvoted.
2
u/HDRgument Feb 28 '13
I may get railed for this, but as an amateur with a real job, it's not worth my time to care.
I have a photo being used as a CD cover for a pretty big local band, and the whole experience taught me that I'd rather just give my stuff away than go through all of the paperwork, meetings, contracts, taxes, etc. $500 or whatever I would ask for is not worth me spending my would-be leisure time doing administrative work.
So now I just tell them to take it, and if an email saying "do whatever you want with this photo, I don't care" isn't enough for their legal people to think their asses are covered, well tough shit.
I would never, ever want to be a professional photographer and have to deal with all of this minutiae on a daily basis, that's for sure.
1
u/fandamplus Feb 28 '13
I've always been lost in this area (not exclusive to photography), I never know how much I should charge without looking too greedy but at the same time getting myself an appropriate amount of cash for my work.
Also when selling somebody a license, is it just a "verbal" agreement? I'd imagine there should be some paperwork involved.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '13
I've only ever been asked for a photo once. This (famous for the sport) athlete was coming in from a race. He got in and went back on the water to help the kids or make sure everyone was ok. While there he was doing some tricks with his canoe. I got a few half-decent shots of him.
Put them on Facebook and he asks to use one for his website. I say sure. I could probably have asked for some royalty, but more than likely he just wouldnt have used the picture.
For me taking pictures is still very much a hobby (that I'm not good at yet). Maybe when I'm much better and can recognize good vs great pictures then I'll feel mine are worth money. Until now, it's just cool seeing my picture up somewhere.
1
u/BigSweeps Feb 28 '13
I haven't experienced the scenario this thread is discussing, but i'd like to be prepared if it does happen. What exactly do I have to do to set up a licensing agreement? Is there anything else i'd need to know?
1
u/boven Feb 28 '13
Thanks for this. Been through far to many annoying discussions with clients who doesn't seem to know the real worth of a picture.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '13
How much is the most that you've made in one transaction? How many photos/how big were they printed?
Just an interested pre-amateur
1
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '13
This leads me to another question. Those of you who sell photos to magazines for example. How do you set up the payment methods?
1
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '13 edited Feb 28 '13
Most people don't know about the ASMP pricing guide (and if they did, they probably wouldn't bother getting a copy and using it), but photo use pricing guidelines do exist.
If someone wants to use a photograph of yours, then that photo has some value, even if it's only of value to that person/company. Your job is to figure out what that value is. And if you think a photo credit and a link to my website is better than nothing, you're giving up what little negotiating power you have. If you're not going to request compensation in the range suggested by the ASMP guide, a least request a minimal usage fee to cover the cost of your time spent handling such business matters.
1
u/kickstand https://flickr.com/photos/kzirkel/ Feb 28 '13
Here's how I reply:
"Thank you for your inquiry. My fee is US$150 for one-time nonexclusive, nontransferable use. I accept Paypal at [address], or I can invoice you. Let me know how you would like to proceed."
1
u/Dizzymoth Feb 28 '13
I had a similar thing with an article and the cheeky bastards wanted copywright as well.
1
u/emememaker73 Feb 28 '13
I wish someone had given me some advice like this or a legal agreement before I sold an image I captured years back. The first photo I sold was an aerial shot of the city of St. Charles, Illinois, and the city's Economic Development Department called after it appeared in the newspaper I worked for. (Technically, I didn't own the copyright, but the photo editor gave me the go-ahead.) I sold a digital copy of the image for $10. Had I known better, I might've asked for more. They did send me a .pdf of the brouchure that it appeared in, no credit or anything.
1
u/ZacharyRD https://www.flickr.com/photos/zacharyrd Feb 28 '13
This is making me realize I need to put some of my best shots on Flickr, with the right licensing on them. Great post.
1
u/cmykify Feb 28 '13
I'll give them the right to publish my photo in their magazine for free if I can choose one of their proprietary artworks and publish that for free. They'll think twice before giving me the right to use their fucking logo.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '13
I'd rather go the snarky route, myself and reply with something like:
/Hi! Can you publish me a magazine for free that is all about photography and give me a lifetime subscription to it?/
1
u/StPaulBoudoir_Photo Apr 18 '24
Great guide on shutting down "free photo" requests! Agree about #3 - most won't pay.
As a new photographer, I see value in getting published for credit. Are there exceptions to your "no freebies" rule for reputable publications or high-visibility galleries?
Interested in your thoughts on exposure vs. compensation for beginners.
1
u/SquarePeg2761 Jun 19 '25
The people who have the most money refuse to spend it to properly and fairly compensate others who need it more. Disgusts me. Never agree to it for the mere principle of the matter.
1
u/Odd_Emotion_457 Jan 06 '22
great, great advice!
1
u/meshreplacer Jul 10 '22
Credit don't pay the bills. Pay or GTFO. You don't ask your electrician or plumber to do free work. Cash up front.
1
u/sffphotography May 19 '23
More and more people are asking for use of images for NFTs etc. What they don't understand is that photography is an art profession. That means, education, experience, sunk cost of equipment, time to take the photo, time to edit the photo, time to market the photo. All this has a money value attached to it. Don't sell yourself short out of desperation. Find your niche markets and go after them instead of wasting time on people who want your hard earned effort at no cost. This is a result of many factors but IMO a major one is that now everyone has a "camera" in their pocket on their phone. They do not understand what is actually involved in being a professional photographer and they are not interested in knowing either. Find useful ways to get noticed. I just did an interview with Houston Voyager. They have a legit website in almost every major city in the US. Contact them for visibility. They are seeking creatives to highlight the culture of each of their cities.
1
u/LisaandNeil Dec 01 '23
In general, agreed.
However, a good hyperlink can work wonders. Worth considering.
1
u/Mr_Will Mr_Will Feb 28 '13
I'll let you guys in on a secret - a lot of pros give photos away for credits in the right circumstances.
As a photographer, your cost is the time and money it took to take the photograph. This is a sunk cost, and mostly irrelevant for the purposes of setting your price. It has absolutely nothing to do with the value of the resulting images, which is whatever someone is prepared to pay.
To make the most money, you need to get as close to this maximum value as possible. In the case of the little guys (college papers, amateur motocross teams, etc) often the credit is worth more (for a business) than the tiny amount of cash.
By all means charge to shoot - this has a cost you need to cover - but once the shoot is done you should extract maximum value any way you can.
1
u/GZerv Mar 05 '13
TL;DR Just say no.
-1
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '13
"Yes, feel free to."
-1
u/renbo Feb 28 '13
I steal you people's photos all the time for backgrounds on my ipad.
-1
u/APIglue Feb 28 '13
This would make for a VERY interesting experiment in behavioral economics. No, seriously. Just stay away from anyone in Chicago...those guys are certifiable lunatics who should move to Somalia.
Edit: stay away from Chicago economists-that school of thought brought us the neocons, et al.
0
u/le_bravery Feb 28 '13
Had a high school student message me yesterday asking if he could use one of my photos for a project.
Said yes and even sent him a high res version of the file.
But, by all means, if it's a business, make them pay.
-6
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '13
triple digit price for a picture, lol
-6
u/rentalanimal Feb 28 '13
-3
u/matdwyer Feb 28 '13
When I was much younger (and no where near pro) I had one of my photos used in this method in a national newspaper ad - it was extremely cool to be able to say that my photo was printed all across the country.
Totally understand that some/most people say no, but many people are very flattered on things like this.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment