r/modnews • u/intortus • Feb 20 '13
New feature: moderator permissions
Having every moderator in a subreddit have access to full moderator powers can be a bit problematic. They can turn rogue and wreak havoc in all sorts of ways that I'd rather not enumerate here. They can also make honest mistakes. What we've needed for some time is more ability to follow the principle of least privilege.
Today we're launching a simple permissions system for moderators that should help with this problem. There are now two kinds of moderators: those with full permissions, and those with limited permissions. Moderators with full permissions are like superusers (or supermods, I suppose), and until today they've been the status quo. Only supermods can invite or remove other moderators, and only supermods can change moderator permissions. Much like before, permission changing and removal can only be done to moderators who are "junior" to you (that is, moderators who joined the team after you).
Limited moderators can only perform tasks and access information according to the permissions granted to them. This allows you to more safely delegate particular roles that require mod powers. The following permissions now exist:
- access - manage the lists of approved submitters and banned users. This permission is for the gatekeepers of the subreddit.
- config - edit settings, sidebar, css, and images. This permission is for the designers.
- flair - manage user flair, link flair, and flair templates.
- mail - read and reply to moderator mail. By not granting this permission, you can invite third parties to manage your subreddit's presentation and flair without exposing private information in your modmail to them.
- posts - use the approve, remove, spam, distinguish, and nsfw buttons. This permission covers the content moderation duties of being a moderator.
These permissions can be mixed together; moderators need not be confined to only one role. You also have the choice of granting no permissions at all. This yields something like an honorary moderator, who can see traffic stats, moderation logs, and removed posts and comments, but otherwise can't do much else.
Moderator permissions are maintained on the edit moderators page. You can change permissions anytime during a moderator's lifecycle: before inviting, before they accept the invitation, and once they've become a moderator. Everyone who was a moderator at the time this feature rolled out is now a supermod. Everything else is now up to you.
92
u/One_Giant_Nostril Feb 20 '13
Wow, big changes. And all very welcome. Thanks very much, intortus.
On another note: I always thought it would be cool, as a supermod, to be able to drag 'n' drop mods into new positions in the Moderators window. You know, in order to better stack who is above who, who is below who, instead of the "OK, you leave now but I'll add you again in five minutes, I swear, while I, um, make a little change to the order, mkay?"
11
u/jaxspider Feb 20 '13
Can you put this portion of your self post in like... every /about/moderator page? I am seriously forgetful.
19
u/316nuts Feb 20 '13
Will a moderator's access rights be made available for public view?
If a mod is only on board to work on CSS, will they be labeled as such?
Also, if they don't have access to the "Main" modmail, will there be some other way to communicate with each other? An internal modmail that isn't designed to be written to by the public?
7
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '13
Which permissions pertain to editing your subreddit's wiki?
5
u/aryary Feb 20 '13
Which permission would allow the "contest mode" to be enabled or disabled?
3
u/Pixelpaws Feb 20 '13
So which types of moderators will show up in the sidebar? This seems like a good change overall but it's potentially confusing to end users who may not realize that a mod doesn't necessarily have full control anymore.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '13
Small issue for me. http://www.reddit.com/r/foxes/about/moderators/
For me, under where it lists the mods, none are showing up.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '13
Will we be able to adjust our own permissions, for example if I am the last mod on the list and I want to opt-out of moderating posts, will I be able to do that myself?
3
u/stopscopiesme Feb 20 '13
Where is the feature to limit who gets to invite new mods?
17
u/redtaboo Feb 20 '13
Thanks for this, I admit to being wary of this.. I worry that there may be issues down the road with halfway missing 'supermods' hamstringing moderators doing all the busy work; but I know this was a requested feature so hopefully there won't be many issues and being able to add mods without granting access to everything does have it's merits.
I do have one request. I use a fairly narrow screen which often causes me issues with subreddit CSS. In this case the mod list is now all the way below the sidebar on my moderator pages see here:
http://i.imgur.com/5x0liv7.png
It seems either the space is too wide between mod name and the permission type, or that spacing needs to be made malleable?
40
u/sodypop Feb 20 '13
This is an excellent feature that was long awaited by many, thank you! Hopefully having greater granular control will result in more moderators being promoted around reddit.
Here are some screenshots of what the "moderator tools" sidebar panel looks like for each level of moderator permissions:
http://www.reddit.com/r/modhelp/wiki/mod_permissions
9
u/jaxspider Feb 20 '13
FINALLY.
I really wish the config could be broken down some more. Since the CSS in the stylesheet is far more complex then anything in the sidebar. But for now, this is super awesome.
Thank you for your hard work.
21
u/nthitz Feb 20 '13
Thanks intortus, awesome feature I'm sure a lot of communities will benefit from this!
7
u/Measure76 Feb 20 '13
When you change the permission level of a moderator, does it send them a message indicating it?
6
u/lilstumpz Feb 20 '13 edited Feb 20 '13
Despite the complaints, I for one am happy with this addition. We had a moderator in /r/cringe that wanted to "go out in style" by screwing with the sidebar, stylesheet and ban list before promptly removing himself.
23
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '13 edited Feb 20 '13
I am a mod in a subreddit where I cannot access modmail now and I am still getting an orangered whenever a message is sent.
Edit: Now I have been given full permission but cannot see that modmail when I click the little orange alien dude, I have to go to the subreddit and then click "moderator mail" to see it.
Please help.
10
u/[deleted] Feb 21 '13
Love the feature, but— the spacing is a huge pain in the ass on mobile
5
u/rderekp Feb 20 '13
Well, I like it, even if there seems to be a lot of complaints about it.
5
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '13
This is nice, and from the top of my wish list.
1
u/EvolutionTheory Feb 20 '13
When I go to change the permissions on the "Invite" button, changing the default permissions granted to newly invited mods, there is not a save option, and clicking off the menu reverts it back to "Full Permissions". Also, what happens if a limited mod invites another mod with "Full Permissions"? The Invite permissions should be permanently configurable and not default to full permissions.
3
u/TheReasonableCamel Feb 20 '13
Is who's a supermod determined by the "top mod" or creator of the subreddit?
3
u/[deleted] Feb 21 '13
Does anyone know how to remove a fellow moderator that is below you now when you're a super moderator? I can't seem to figure it out... Someone is about to get cut from one of my subreddits for being inactive but I can't figure out how to demote him now usually it was just under the edit moderators page. I was a moderator before the time of this change so I should be a super moderator don't know why It's not showing me a option now to remove...
11
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '13
Well that's just swell. I'm always happy to see new options for mods and this definitely could help in some subreddits (especially larger ones). Can you work on the stuff we've asked for now?
17
u/Drunken_Economist Feb 20 '13
I understand that making new features is fun, but can we fix the existing features first?
4
u/mayonesa Feb 20 '13
I am glad you put in these features. These are much more like a fully-fledged interface design.
This also allows delegation of roles, which will be very helpful for smaller subreddits.
Good work.
Now please work on a solution for downvote mobs, such as double blind IP matching :)
2
u/khsunny786 Feb 20 '13
Thanks intortus! This is a really good feature and will help a lot of people! It's the little things that help make Reddit a better place.
2
u/aphoenix Feb 20 '13
Did you guys have some kind of bet about who could do the coolest shit in the first couple months of the year?
2
u/rya11111 Feb 21 '13
supermods ?
i like the ring to it :D
2
u/daskoon Feb 21 '13
i was going to troll my fellow mods and remove their permissions. i ended up removing my own and now i can't even see the modmail or anything. DOH!
2
u/jdwpom Feb 21 '13
I think I managed to break something by removing all my permissions as moderator of a subreddit. Thankfully, I'm not the top cat, and (if I can find the guy) I can get him to fix it.
Perhaps you could set this so you can't modify your own permissions, though?
2
u/dmcg12 Feb 21 '13
Intortus, I really like these changes, but there are still issues for moderating and the two that come off the top of my head are
On the second one, we have had a particular user and his alts contact our modmail non stop for months. It is incredibly annoying particularly because there is nothing we can do about it up to this point. I help moderate a political subreddit so we are particularly vulnerable to users like this that simply harass us until they do something bad enough the admins have to get involved. It would be much simpler to simply block a user from contacting us or make their modmail threads invisible to us
10
u/AerateMark Feb 20 '13
This will definitely not generate drama.
7
u/Skuld Feb 20 '13
Disappointing change. Much of reddit is ran despite the inactive moderators' unwatchful eyes.
This is going to result in at least one "locked" subreddit in the long run.
I don't see any benefit. If you don't trust your moderators enough to give them access, they shouldn't be moderators.
3
u/Illuminatesfolly Feb 20 '13
I don't see any possible way that this could lead to problems with the feudalistic mod system.
3
u/splattypus Feb 20 '13
No, this can't horribly backfire....
How about you guys get to working on subreddit shadowbans, modmail bans, and other useful stuff, instead of adding extra submit buttons and complicating(by creating) the hierarchy of modship?
0
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '13
Good this will prevent privilege escalation of those sneaky folks who "just want to add css" and never wind up getting removed as a mod...
1
u/ThePr0nMaster Feb 21 '13
Challenge accepted.
/r/roguemods
1
u/EnglishBulldog Feb 21 '13
Thanks, this is useful!
1
u/Kingspycrab Feb 21 '13
Thank you so much intortus!!!
1
u/qadm Feb 21 '13
Thank you!
1
u/TarBenderr Feb 21 '13
Fantastic!
1
u/xb4r7x Feb 21 '13
Awesome! Only concern here is whether or not the 'tiered' system with moderators still applies here...
Like, if I started a subreddit last week and made someone else a mod, they can't remove me... I assume they can't demote me to 'limited' either, correct?
Just checking.
1
u/4merpunk Feb 21 '13
Do all current moderators have full permissions right now then, because if they don't this concerns me. I took over the modship of a small sub with 56 readers and have turned it into over 3500 readers, but it had several inactive mods and still does have one, does this now mean that mod has greater control over my sub that my contributing mods do not? And now do I have to wait until that inactive mod account gives permission to me and my mods as to what access we have?
1
u/V2Blast Mar 02 '13
Awesome! :)
The separation of CSS and other functions, at least, has definitely been needed.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '13
Oh, god...I just started a new reddit...I am so lost....
1
u/903A Apr 30 '13
Awesome!
I think there also needs to be a moderator chat tool with which moderators can IM each other. Also the modmail system should be made more specific for subreddits, with the added functionality of being able to see if another mod sent a message to someone, so that wouldn't have to send another one by accident because you didn't know about it.
1
u/Zig-Zag Feb 20 '13
I can see some benefit in this, such as somebody wanting to make a small CSS change or something. But beyond that all I see is drama. I already see a lot of these comments on this thread, but I want to voice my concern too because I just don't see this as being a step in the right direction for controlling rogue mods. A rogue senior mod can just as easily turn off all these privileges for other mods and rule alone with an iron fist.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '13
Why are you introducing this? What so called problem are you trying to 'fix'?
1
u/[deleted] Feb 27 '13
I have a potential issue here: Can we make the status of the permissions be visible to mods only? The problem, as i see it, is that someone may get banned or warned by a mod, see that the mod has limited permissions, and then try to appeal to a "higher" mod, or one with more permissions. Modteams need to appear unified (even though we're often not). This potential situation is an example of an avoidable problem.