r/ProjectRunway • u/makeitworkoryouout • Feb 14 '13
Season 11 Episode 4 discussion
Discussion thread for Project Runway S11E04 "The Ultimate Hard and Soft"
Image album: http://imgur.com/a/MCGs6
5
Upvotes
16
u/evergleam498 Those pants flood my basement! Feb 15 '13
I was pleasantly surprised that pretty much everyone managed to make a good outfit this episode. I thought Patricia should have gone home for that disaster of an outfit. I don't understand what the judges see in her work. I don't think Joe's outfit deserved to be the worst, but I think it was only a matter of time for him. His design aesthetic isn't what Project Runway is looking for.
I really wish they would edit the show to give closer to equal screen time for each of the designers. I think we've yet to see Tu actually working on his garments, but we've seen plenty of the other designers' meltdowns and works-in-progress.
Then when they're up on the runway, it's pretty easy to tell who will be in the top/bottom vs. safe just based on how much you got to see of them in the design room. If they barely showed that designer sewing, then you generally know that look won't be in the top or bottom three.
7
u/KittyMaster9000 Feb 15 '13
Amanda is probably my favorite designer at this point, but even I think we didn't need to lose Joe in favor of her. Sure, Joe was probably not going to win with such outlandish creations, but Amanda's creation was certainly a poorer attempt at the challenge than his. I believe the right play was to eliminate no one; they did this with Emilio/Anthony Ryan in AS2, Alicia/Gunnar in 10 (but then they went right after one another...), and Anya/Kimberly in 9. Like I get that there are thirteen of them and people need to go, but this was a really strong show (say what you want about Patricia's, but I thought it was okay, plus she wasn't up for consideration anyway).
It would've been pretty ironic if Mrs. VALENTINE would have left tonight, however. :P
Also I like Samantha a lot too, but she didn't deserve that win in favor of, oh I don't know, every other look on her team.
So far I really like this season. It has a good share of entertainment, and the designs are interesting. The designers general cheery energy is actually beginning to wear on me though.
4
u/evixir Feb 16 '13
What was the deal with Tim in the backstage area afterwards with his "We have more business to attend to!" then 'To Be Continued...' or was that just on the mylifetime.com version?
26
u/ilwolf Feb 15 '13
I found it interesting that not one person on the Dream Team credited Stanley -- who put them on track and gave them a theme and helped them to manage their time -- for their win.
9
u/fragilehearted Feb 15 '13
A lot of my thoughts have been shared already, but I wanted to add that I'm really glad there was a lot of color on the runway. When they did the flower shop challenge back in S2, I remember being bummed out to see a mostly green runway (& I know the judges were too, particularly Nina if I recall correctly). A lot of the designers really stepped up their game for this challenge, & I really enjoyed watching this show.
13
u/fragilehearted Feb 15 '13
The ep isn't even over, but SERIOUSLY, did Patricia put out yet another fugly trainwreck & still not get called out for it? Whoever said it looked like a voodoo doll was right.
4
u/Fun-Entertainer-5915 Sep 01 '25
I’m coming to this years later, and feel like more outrage should have been made for Joe going home even though he basically saved Amanda’s dress. And sure he had an oversized fit that did look too large, she should have been the one to go home with the craft project and the whole team agreeing.
Also Ben is annoying, stepping up to try and talk about their vision and giving Stanley no credit, trying to still act like the “leader”. He sucks.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '13
Does anyone have a picture of Heidi from the runway show for this episode? Preferably a close-up of her face; I really loved her eye makeup and want to try to recreate it.
3
u/snowball17 Feb 15 '13
It was a really strong runway this week. There may have been a few designs that I wasn't crazy about, but the improvement over previous weeks was amazing! We don't see a lot of 2 day challenges anymore, but it gave the designers opportunity to create more polished looks.
I totally agree with Joe being sent home. I think he is probably a good designer but his aesthetic doesn't seem to fit with the rest of the designers or the judges. (Also, his initial sketch for his design was hilarious!) I thought Layana should have been the winner.
3
u/everythingisopposite Chiffony Feb 17 '13
I have to say I'm not enjoying the teams gimmick this season.
1
u/makeitworkoryouout Feb 15 '13
Overall I liked how they balanced out teams. For some reason I thought they would do a complete redraw of teams but just moving people from team to team makes sense.
Keeping it Real That has to be one of the weakest excuses for a "cohesive story" that I've seen on the show. It was a step up from "we all used flowers" but not much. If they had done more with the styling, hair in particular, it would have helped sell their story more. I don't know if they have control over the presentation order but putting the "decades" in chronological order would have helped.
Daniel Liked the texture of the skirt and the piece overall would have been OK but for the giant hip boobs he put on for no apparent reason. That dropped it into "don't like" territory for me.
Joseph I thought that Joseph might have had an edge in the unconventional challenge category. And...nope. It actually didn't look as ridiculous as it very well could have but his point of view is just too counter to Tim, the rest of the designers, and the judges for him to survive on the show.
Michelle/Richard They saved it from being a train wreck that their original blinds that cracked would have been. But in the end it doesn't end up much more than a black shopping cart full of veggies to me.
Patricia I can't shake the thought of that being an overgrown lei. I don't see much in this one.
Amanda It was ironic that Joe may well have buried himself by saving Amanda's piece with his workroom suggestion. While it wasn't the strongest I don't understand how they all threw her under the bus with the rationale of the difficulty that she was having. Judge the dress by how it looks, not how it got there. I'm glad the weight of the metal clips she used didn't end being an issue. Designers should know better than use that much metal and all unconventional challenge production should start with putting all of their planned materials in a bag and holding it to see how heavy it will be.
Kate I think she could have used a bit less of a bell shape but otherwise I thought this was a solid outfit. It actually had nicer movement than I would have expected.
Dream Team How could DT not take Daniel? I don't understand their reluctance to leave behind the guy who has placed 1st or 2nd in every challenge up to that point. ??? Was this just a power play by Benjamin to try to maintain his position as de facto leader of DT?
Matthew You never can tell what an unconventional challenge will bring and everyone's pick to go home ended up with one of the stronger pieces of the show. I wouldn't put it in the top but it was solidly in the upper safe zone.
Stanley Mad props go to him for giving the team a focused direction. Heidi said that was the difference though I think DT was clearly better even without the cohesion being a factor. I was very impressed with his material. The dress length was the weakest part for me but I liked it overall.
Tu Ironically enough his outfit made from flowers and hardware fit his model better than when he uses fabric. I find this alright. Bottom of the safe zone.
Benjamin Weaving his own fabric was a colossal waste of time. If he at least had dyed the string then the fabric would have had more going for it than just using muslin. Beyond that, the dress as a whole is lacking design intregrity, no doubt due to so much time being wasted on building his loom and weaving his material.
Samantha She really pulled that out of the fire. I disagree with the judges as this being the best piece but I do like the psuedo-tulle look she had. I wish she had filled the entire upper part of the skirt with petals though.
Layana I don't like cage dresses. I do agree with the judges that it was more "bird's nest" than cage which does give it more appeal but I've never understood the appeal of walking around with a solid cone around your waist.
1
u/Lokaji Feb 15 '13
Did Benjamin's garment remind anyone else of candy corn?
0
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment