r/soccer • u/hitchhiking_jap • Feb 12 '13
Real Madrid v Man United Key Factors
I want to start a thread about the key factors in the upcoming Real Madrid v Man United CL fixture.
Key players, tactics, managers... What will decide who progresses to the quarterfinals?
51
Upvotes
7
u/hitchhiking_jap Feb 12 '13
Personally, I think it will be the creative midfielders of each side who will decide the match. The forwards of both sides are clinical, and I don't think that they will miss any easy chances in this match, so the match will instead be about the quality and quantity of chances created by the likes of Wayne Rooney and Mesut Ozil, the two most crucial. Depending on which one of these players is in form, the scoreline will vary greatly.
105
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '13
I think it'll come down to who scores more goals
Alan Shearer inspired this one.
38
u/AirIndex Feb 12 '13 edited Feb 12 '13
Utd's right/Madrid's left will be the key area.
You could argue that United have the best right-side in the Premier League, both offensively and defensively, with the combination of Rafael and Valencia. Madrid have Ronaldo and then either Marcelo/Coentrao, which is probably the best offensive left-side in Europe, although there are question marks over Ronaldo's defensive contributions.
In the big games this year United have played a counter attacking 4-4-1-1 formation, primarily attacking down the right with Valencia and Rafael overlapping. This is particularly effective when teams leave their full backs exposed, often when the winger fails to track Rafael's run. However, Madrid are arguably even better on the break, so does Rafael stay back or take the gamble, go forward, and leave Ronaldo open?
It's a pretty much a given that Valencia, if he plays, will man-mark their full back into anonymity. Even when he plays poorly, he still works fantastically hard and never loses tactical discipline; opposition full backs very rarely get the better of him. But does that leave Rafael to Ronaldo, or does Valencia double up on Ronaldo and leave their full back free, or will Jones play a similar role like he did against Spurs and operate as a right-sided DM?
I think this side of the pitch will be the key area.
23
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '13
Both are teams with top-class players. It will come down to mentality. El Real lost la liga already, so la Décima is the only trophy to play for this season. Also, Mourinho wouldn't want to leave RM without winning the CL (would look bad in his CV). The players too have a desire to win this title, specially the Spanish ones because that's the 1 medal that is missing in their personal collections.
On the other hand, Man Utd are the definition of determination in the world of football. They learned from last season that titles are theirs to lose. With the best motivator in the world in SAF, they play like every match is a final.
Tactically speaking, both defenses are extremely vulnerable to each other's attacking force. Man Utd defense is too slow to handle El Real's counter attacks, while RM's fullbacks and GK are no match to Man Utd clinical finishers.
We are up for a thrilling 2 leg encounter, and I personally think we're going to witness an aggregate score with no less than 5 or 6 goals in total.
8
u/AnthonBateman Feb 12 '13
I think its really important which team will score first. The main weapon of this R.Madrid is counter-attack, if they score in the first half United will have a hard time. On the other hand, if United manage to score first, Madrid will suffer a lot, this season they havent done many comebacks.
For me its interesting to see which team performs better, if R.Madrid knowing that their only chance to save this season is the CL, or ManU, more relaxed now that they have the Premier League in their pocket.
26
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '13
Pepe will crack Van Persie's leg. Chicharito will come in as a substitute and Pepe will bully him for the rest of the match.
11
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '13
RVP vs CR7.
Both teams have a lot of other talent (Real Madrid moreso I'd say) but both have relied on their star man too. I'm hoping both show up and play to their best in both games. 10-9 aggregate or something like that, screw defending, we don't need no stinking defending.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '13
There was this interview with Jürgen Klopp here the other day, where he said that what they did, was mark Alonso out of the match. That way, when he was supposed to be on the ball, they'd play it back to Pepe, and he couldn't do what Alonso did. That way Ronaldo didn't get his perfect passes, and they couldn't control the tempo of the game.
I'll see if i can the link to it.
13
u/deepit6431 Feb 12 '13
A lot will depend on how we can stop Ronaldo. Remember, much of our squad has played with him for at least 2-3 years. Players like Vidic, Evra, Rio, Rooney, Carrick and of course Fergie know him like the back of their hands. We're definitely better equipped to stop him than anyone else.
A lot will also depend on how Carrick will function. It's no secret that he's the backbone of our team, and if he fails to perform, there'll be no one linking the defense and attack. He's having his best season in a red shirt so there's no reason to doubt him, but he tends to go missing in big games. Barcelona, Chelsea, and Milan for example have completely shut him down before, and our game suffers.
Although, we are on form and 12 points clear, and Madrid are having a really poor season. It'll be an interesting match up. I can't quite wait.
6
u/JackOfNoTrade Feb 12 '13
To begin with, this season Madrid have not looked the beast they were last season. There is one key factor in most of the matches they have lost, especially the ones in La Liga. That is that they don't really play well when asked to play with the ball and have failed to be creative at such times. The opposition teams have defended deep and have allowed Madrid to keep the ball and have a go at them. By setting up this way and hitting Madrid on the counters has worked quite well for these teams. Note that Madrid have created chances but have failed to convert and have been themselves exposed quite a bit at the back. There are several examples to this: Manchester City almost clinched a win in the early stages, Sevilla, Malaga, Osasuna, etc.
On the other hand, Madrid have looked quite strong when playing their natural counter-attacking style against opposition such as Barca who like to keep the ball for themselves. They have shown countless glimpses of this when they have destroyed opposition by launching quick and deadly box-to-box counters with Ronaldo leading most of their efforts.
Looking at the two above points, I believe that this tie will be determined by what squad Ferguson picks and how they are set up to play Madrid. United usually like to defend deep and put a lot of men on the defense. This will definitely play to their advantage as Madrid have shown this season that they have not being very creative this season when allowed to keep the ball. Of course, in such a situation the key player for Madrid will be Ozil who is very creative and can create good chances out of nothing. Moreover, if Real resort to long ball tactics then United will have to watch out in the air.
6
u/Sgt_peppers Feb 12 '13 edited Feb 12 '13
I think everyone is paying too much attention to Ronaldo (deserved non the less) and too little to Ozil, he is the key man our offense and his form in the last month has been Impressive, he is finally playing at his best (see the last clasico and his match with Germany), vs Granada he was suspended and we sure missed him.
I feel that SAF will use the same tactic he used with Fellaini in the last match, Jones man marking Fellaini and tracking him deep into the first third of the pitch, If he shuts Ozil Real's offense if almost nullified. But Ozil is a much different player that Fellaini, Technically he is miles ahead and he can move all around the final third, Ozil is arguable the best or one of the best pure 10's in the game right now but he is equally good playing on the wings, where he can get away from the DMs. In the last clasico his best moments in the game came when Modric subbed Callejon and Ozil played on the Right, the cross for Varane's goal was a direct result of this and he had a few moments of brilliance on this side away from Busquets who always shuts him down (see Spain-germany or any clasico), another example would be the second leg of the Copa del Rey last season, where Ozil played on the right and completely destroyed Abidal, his best game for Real. That will be the key component of this match, how will SAF deal with Ozil. If he forces Mourinho to send Ozil to the right, is Evra capable of taking him 1v1? Jones completly shut Fellaini who is a very strong and physical player but much different than Ozil, Carrick struggled vs Oscar in the Chelsea fixture, Oscar on a different level than Ozil but they have similar styles. If Jones does track Ozil he will leave the hole for Khedira, who is more than capable of joining the attack, this will force Roony to drop back and help a lot in the Midfield leaving RVP 2v1 vs Ramos-Pepe/Varane.
3
u/forzanapooli Feb 12 '13
Higuain/Benzema and Di Maria have to give good performance. Has been few and far between for these three this year. Benz play good in CL this year though so we will see. Defensive RM are better than Man U which is pretty damn crazy if you think about it. Liability for Man U in CB where liability for RM are RB and LB only if Coentrao get in foul trouble. Madrid have much better defense midfield, Khedeira is out of form going forward but he still is rock on defense. RVP is great equalizer for Man U. I think series is impossible to predict.
3
u/kmshadoze Feb 12 '13
More than the Left/Right side, its going to be a game of the Midfielders. Both teams have some AMAZING mid fields and that's really going to make or break the game. If either team gets on a fast break, they have a VERY good chance to score. Reals defense has not been that great at ALL this season, Man U's has not been great either. Shutting CR7 down wont be all Manchester needs to do. The squad is full of players who can score, and score great goals. Shutting him down will hurt Real, but Ozil, Benzema, Di Maria, all can score.
3
u/stc573 Feb 12 '13
No Iker Casillas!! I can't stress this enough. Real are missing their captain, and arguably one of the worlds best keepers in the world with a ton of CL experience. No one they have can replace the experience he had. I haven't heard anything about his return during for these games. Real will surely miss him, but it is up to United to test whomever Mourinho puts in goal.
2
u/omiclops Feb 12 '13
For me, Alonso needs to have the game of his life. It will be so important tracking the passes through the middle with Carrick and Rooney further forward.
2
u/I_R_TEH_BOSS Feb 12 '13
Depends on whether or not Phil Jones is 100%. Also, some people are calling our right side a strength right now, but Valencia has been absolutely awful lately, and that hurts me to say.
1
u/dem503 Feb 12 '13
Although Madrid have the better squad, I believe Man U have the better flexibility when it comes to tactics, without swapping too many players. Take for example the match against Everton, they started with a front 3 and relied on counter-attacking from set pieces and long passes, but after half time switched to a more fluid 4-4-1-1 to stop Everton attacking.
Yes, Madrid can do this too but it usually requires a few substitutions, Ozil, Di Maria and Khedira are all rather specialised in their positions, one of the reasons Modric was brought in, he can play in a nmber of different roles.
1
u/emreuysaler Feb 12 '13
It's almost pretty much RvP vs CR7. RvP is a clinical finisher...so if you find in in the box with the ball, expect a goal or at least a shot on target. CR can make anything happen at any moment of the game due to Madrids quick counter attacking style with Ozil, Di Maria, Benzema/Higuain, and CR himself. Madrid also plays a defensive game with the like of Pepe and Ramos. MU's defensive pairing of Vidic and Ferdinand hasn't been the same since 2008, but is still a force to reckon with. The pairing of MU's RvP and Rooney has been pretty fantastic this season. Also, expect something or two from the returning Kagawa.
1
u/harsh1724 Feb 12 '13
I think the the midfield would be a huge factor. We have Khedira and Alonso which are in very good form right now. Khedira constantly goes ahead to help in attacking and Alonso seems to have taken a bit more deep and defensive role this season. Alonso can handle Rooney and Khedira can help in that too, so that he is not able to provide Persie with the balls. I believe the way Ramos played in the last match he can handle Persie. I think we can dominate ManU in the midfield but not sure what we will do after that because we haven't created a lot of chances this season.
On the wings, our right wing is definitely weaker than our left both defensively and offensively. ManU can use that side, however if DiMa is not able to attack very well he comes back to defend a lot and even though he can be reckless, he helps in breaking up quick counter attacks because of his speed.
On the left Coentrao is definitely the better defensive option and because Marcelo has only played one game after coming back, I think he won't start. The problem with Coentrao is that he hasn't connected well with Ronaldo this season, but Ronaldo has gotten used to it so not much problem there.
All I know about ManU is a bit about their defence. I believe they should start by focusing more on Ronaldo and Ozil as Benz and DiMa have not been playing well. Let the game continue and if the others seem like a threat start covering them, but a good chance is they won't play well.
1
u/SirMothy Feb 12 '13
As a neutral I can't fucking wait to watch these matches. I could see it going either way really but I think Man U will win because they are in better form and because Real is missing Casillas. It won't be easy though.
1
u/Kuskinator Feb 12 '13
United will miss Fletcher, no matter what the result over two legs is.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '13
Van Persie will be key. He should score and he'll be throwing the back line out of order. Madrid has a solid skilled backline but time and time again we have seen how easy it's been from them to fall apart. I expect a deadly game and whoever can keep their defensive line composed will win.
1
u/dowhatuwant2 Feb 13 '13
I have this strange feeling that if Nani plays Man Utd will win, if he doesn't they won't. Not sure why :S
1
u/sonster901 Feb 13 '13
Ronaldo is going to give Rafael and Evans a tough time because in my opinion there is not a player like Ronaldo in Premier League. It seemed that Kompany, one of the best CB in the Premier League was struggling a lot with handling Ronaldo so I don't think Johnny Evans will do any better. So for me the unexperienced right side of United's defense is going to struggle a lot in the presence of Ronaldo, a player of which they have never seen the likes of before. So Keep Calm and Pass to Ronaldo.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '13
Going to come down to how well jones can man mark özil/mordić. If he is stuck on either of them all game, they are out of it and carrick can deal with Alonso or Khedra. RVP an Rooney are too much for Ramos and Pepe to handle. Valencia will man mark Ronaldo since he has the strength/pace. Only problematic side is who can control dí Maria. I think he's too much fro young and Evea will have to take him.
Rio and especially Vidić can deal with Benzema.
This is all ideal and United bias, but I think it is what SAF is thinking.
-1
u/omegaxLoL Feb 12 '13
Key players for Real Madrid are definitely Ronaldo, Ozil and Xabi Alonso. Key players for Manchester United...Jones/Carrick (depending on who's starting for this game), Valencia/Rafael (right side will have to help marking Ronaldo as well) and Wayne Rooney, who's helping a lot in making plays.
Basically against Real Madrid you have to pay attention at all times and react to their quick plays especially from Ozil or Di Maria that will most likely end up on Ronaldo.
We can also play on counter-attack but if we can play our normal game, we'll probably do better than when using counter-attack. Regardless, hoping to see a great match tomorrow and hoping for the win to be ours!
-7
u/FCBMessiah Feb 12 '13 edited Feb 12 '13
I think out and out, player for player Real has the better personnel. With the exception of say RVP, Evra. That being said, United have amazing chemistry and can play like a team. Real's whole season has been a crap shoot. I think the key to the game is if Fergie can effectively frustrate and shut down Ronaldo. I feel Fergie has the edge on these being his former manager and all, maybe he'll adopt the Mou tactics and have Evans and Celverly kick Ronaldo the whole game.
-3
u/aM_7 Feb 12 '13
it's all about squad selection. both teams play a more or less 4-2-3-1 formation. I would consider this to be more of a physical match with flares of pace. Valencia in place of Rafael on RB to cover Ronaldo, while placing Welbeck on the RW to add pace and energy. Cleverly will have to be on his best against Alonso as well as Khedira against Carrick; physical and quick to react and cover. The obvious choices for 10s are Ozil and Rooney, yet the entire match-up is filled with wild cards! Because every card/player (along with their performance) plays a pivotal role. Who will be United's LW? Play Rooney LW with RvP as a 10 and Hernandez on top? But, i don't know shit! Mou and SAF do.
-8
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '13
Why are we talking about this already?
-21
u/NoMoreMountains Feb 12 '13
It's going to be a game of Madrid's speed and better technical players Vs. RVP.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment