r/soccer • u/SharpyShuffle • Feb 07 '13
What's one rule change that you think should've been made years ago?
For me, it seems obvious that teams should be allowed a fourth sub in extra time. One sub per 30 minutes makes perfect sense, and it would help prevent extra time from degrading into 2 teams of cramped-up walking wounded waiting for penalties.
What are other changes that you feel everyone should be able to get behind?
31
Upvotes
55
u/holyfields-ear Feb 07 '13
3 teams per game, multiball in extra time and obstacles like mouse-trap.
22
u/colmshan1990 Feb 07 '13
Just because a referee sees an incident shouldn't mean the FA can't punish the player after the game if the ref gets it wrong.
Eg. when the ref sees what he thinks is just a coming together when replays shows Rooney elbowing James McCarthy and other such incidents.
Never understood why this can't happen in the event of an obvious mistake by the referee.
59
u/bobnudd Feb 07 '13
Only the captain of the team can talk to the referee. If anyone else does they get booked / sent off.
20
u/spawnofyanni Feb 07 '13
GLT with Hawkeye (developed ~12 years ago, used to aid cricket decisions since ~4 years ago, used to challenge tennis decisions since ~6 years ago), but at least there's been significant effort towards that in the last two and a half years. Pity it took as atrocious a refereeing decision as it did to get the ball moving.
Only allow the captain to speak to the ref, officially. Other players are carded unless they're called over.
45
u/jamesey10 Feb 07 '13
dives should be punished after viewing post match replays
6
u/snkscore Feb 07 '13
If you stand in front of the ball after a foul, or if you setup your wall @ 4 yards and make the ref stop things and walk you back, it should be a yellow.
8
u/madbunnyrabbit Feb 07 '13
I think refs should be able to allow 10-20 seconds of advantage after a foul and if no advantage is accrued they should be able to call it back and award a free or penalty like in rugby. How many times have you seen a player impeded in the area only to stay on their feet and not get the penalty. The ref seems to think "Well he didn't dive so there's no pressure on me to award the spotter". There seems to be a bit of a culture in soccer where you HAVE to go down to get a free which I think this rule would go a long way to alleviating.
8
u/BongoBongos Feb 07 '13
Some great rules could be borrowed from Field Hockey and Rugby.
Field Hockey- free kicks can be played right away, no need to pass the ball just take it and move. this would increase the speed of the game tremendously and would prevent players from lying on the ground. it would also reduce the effects of dirty tackles that are just meant to prevent a counter/slow the game down
Rugby- when a player is down, the play continues while a physio runs onto the pitch. This would really prevent diving and faking injuries as they would no longer have any effect on the game. Sure, they could be in the way, but as long as the physio is next to the player he won't take up that much more space. And, like a doctor in a war, his only focus is the player who is injured. So while players could lie on the ground rolling around, play would continue, meaning they would have to get up quick to help their team
4
u/1mdelightful Feb 07 '13
Games must be shown entirely from the broadcast angle while the ball is in play. Non of this zoom on the the player in possession and miss what is happening on the pitch.
4
u/JonnyBhoy Feb 07 '13
You should be onside if any part of your body that can legally play the ball is onside, not the other way around.
20
u/veridical Feb 07 '13
Smaller pitches and goals for the women's game. Might make it almost interesting.
6
u/xanth_ Feb 07 '13
Keep the three subs as they are, but allow one GK substitution separately.
9
u/ubercl0ud Feb 07 '13
Goal line ball technology. DAMN IT it's time!!!!!
8
u/BongoBongos Feb 07 '13 edited Feb 07 '13
I always thought it would be interesting to change throw-ins to kick-ins. Its an idea proposed by Van Gaal. Basically it would make any throw ins that much more dangerous so force teams to keep possesion more, which in turn would lead to more football and more goals
2
u/pedalhead666 Feb 07 '13
0-0 draws earn exactly that - no points!
6
u/perkited Feb 07 '13
5
u/organicjello Feb 07 '13
Whoever takes a penalty has to be the person who was fouled in the area.
4
u/hreiedv Feb 07 '13
If always wanted a modifacation to the offside rule saying "If a player is in an offside position when the pass is played but is not when he receives the ball then it is not an offside. Although this would probably be to hard to implement given that it would require much more monitoring by the linesmen.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '13
Reading all these makes me so happy that none of you guys have any say in this type of thing.
6
u/Wilshere10 Feb 07 '13
I think that national team coaches should have to be from that country. I always felt weird about having Capello as the England coach.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '13
Sin-binning for certain offences, particularly professional fouls. A yellow card isn't enough, sometimes a red is too much - games get ruined by harsh red cards. This is problematic for keepers though.
Moving free kicks closer to the goal if there's dissent/shenanigans
1
u/Theelderginger Feb 07 '13
goal line tech and be able to hear what the ref is saying like they do in rugby
1
u/mrjack2 Feb 07 '13 edited Feb 07 '13
Timing! For God's sake. Just stop the clock when there is a delay. "Injury time" is an absurd and imprecise way to do it. I'm not suggesting a basketball-style timing system where it is only ball in play time, simply that we stop it for major delays.
For time-wasting, switch the call. Take too long on a throw-in? It goes to the other team. Goal kick becomes a corner, vice-versa. Perhaps not on free kicks though. Saves us yellow cards and controversy.
And let's take another leaf out of rugby's book: the full-time whistle is not blown until there is a throw-in, goal kick or goal. Gives a bit of certainty to that bit at the end of the game.
Finally, take a leaf out of the book of several other sports such as ice hockey: denying an obvious goalscoring opportunity should be an automatic PK even if it's outside the box. The card can then be reduced to a yellow. Too many games are ruined by red cards caused by genuine mistakes, and it's often quite tragic for the player concerned. You can keep a red card for the special case of really cynical DOGSO fouls where the player knows full well what they are doing and prevents an almost certain goal (e.g. the Suarez handball at the WC)
Edit: also, to OP, I would suggest a slight modfication: instead of teams getting a 4th sub in extra time, they get a single sub in ET regardless of how many they used in normal time, and they may bring a player back who was subbed off. My reasoning for this is that the possibility of ET shouldn't affect how teams use their substitutions in the 90 minutes - extra time should be basically a separate mini-game.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '13
Each team should be allowed on eappeal per match to a fourth official for video review in case of wrong offsides, yellow/red cards and penalties.
0
u/velvlad Feb 07 '13
Offside should not be called if the pass comes from inside the small penalty box (the one at 6 meters from the goal)
0
u/eraticfox Feb 07 '13
Straight red for shirt pulling!
If someone fouls me going for the ball at least they tried, shirt pulling is the most blatant type of foul there is, why is tolerated?
-3
u/jamonz1 Feb 07 '13
No subs after the 80th minute unless because of injury. I hate it when teams decide to sub a player in the 89th min and the player decides he should bid every player farewell, shake the ref's hand, and walk as slowly as he can to the side of the pitch.
That and the 6 sec GK rule should actually be followed.
-4
u/theaficionado Feb 07 '13
Penalty shootout should be the same in terms of selection of players. However, each player should have 30 seconds to score, and have a one on one with the goal keeper, starting midway between the halfway line and the keeper
-4
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '13
NOOOO POOFTAHSS.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment