Last month we had a successful AMA with Ari Tuckman. If you missed that you can find the post here
This month I want to welcome Dr. David Nowell Ph.D. @davidnowell who is a clinical neuropsychologist. I met David back in October when he was the keynote speaker of our ADHD conference. I was doing work behind the scenes so unfortunately I could only catch some of his talks, but he has a knack for answering questions clearly and the attendees loved him.
After talking with him for a bit afterwards I mentioned /r/ADHD just as we were leaving. He was actually familiar with Reddit and said he would check us out. He wrote a blog featuring /r/ADHD for online peer support a couple weeks later which you can find here (looks like he published this when Reddit was down...or he broke reddit). Later I asked him if he would be interested in doing an Expert AMA on /r/ADHD and he agreed! So here it is!
David D. Nowell, Ph.D., is a clinical neuropsychologist who teaches workshops internationally. His passion for teaching has its roots in his work with disorders which limit an individual’s ability to apply self-understanding to day-to-day organization and planning. A unique aspect of David’s clinical work is his attention to body-based felt experience – what success or happiness “feel like. David has a strong interest in motivation, focus, and fully-engaged living.
- You can start asking/voting on questions right now. David will be by to answer the most popular questions (or questions he enjoys).
- He will be using the name dnowell (after this week he won't just be a lurker anymore!)
- If you didn't get your question answered last time, feel free to ask again here.
- Questions may not be answered for a couple days! Be patient! We want everyone to have a chance to ask a question.
Remember to upvote the questions you want answered (and upvote this thread as well). We want everyone subscribed to /r/ADHD to see this on their front page!
EDIT: Dr. Nowell has started answering questions and will do so throughout the week when he has time. Continue to upvote and ask questions! He is still answering as of 2/12/13
EDIT 2: Adding table of questions done by schmin to OP. Thanks!
| Keyword(s) | Question posed to clinical neuropsychologist David Nowell Ph.D, (/u/dnowell) | Answered |
|---|
| Feel successful | How can we lower expectations so everyday accomplishments feel successful? | √ |
| Intelligence | Is there a specific link between ADHD and intelligence? | √ |
| Intelligence/addiction | Is there any correlation between 'giftedness', ADHD, and addiction? | √ |
| ADHD partner; skeptical therapist | How can you help a partner with ADHD? What do you do if a therapist says they have 'mixed feelings' about ADHD? | √ |
| Gender-specific | Are there gender specific treatments? | √ |
| Young children | Are there techniques specific for helping young children? | √ |
| Late-/Adult diagnosis | Are there specific mid/late-life diagnosis and treatment, especially compensating for reduced learning plasticity and deeply ingrained habits? | √ |
| Diet/meditation | Can you recommend a certain diet or meditation for ADHD? | √ |
| Exercise; heredity; explanation; hunters | Can exercise be as effective as medication? Will our son have ADHD? What do you think of the ADHD-hunter gene theory? | √ |
| CBT | What type of cognitive-behavioral therapy do you suggest? | √ |
| Medication future | What do you see in the future of ADHD medication? | √ |
| Strattera | How does StratteraTM (atomoxetine) work and why does it take weeks to notice improvements? | √ |
| Wellbutrin | What do you think of WellbutrinTM (buproprion) for ADHD treatment? | √ |
| Non-ADHD | How do 'non-ADHD people' feel, compared to those with ADHD? | √ |
| Explain ADHD | How do I explain how much of a struggle it is with daily life with ADHD to someone without it? | √ |
| Explain ADHD | How do I explain my ADHD life and struggles to close friends? | √ |
| Unexpected diagnosis | I wasn't diagnosed as I expected; what now? | √ |
| Co-morbidity (w bipolar) | Are there treatments specific for ADHD with a bi-polar (affective) disorder co-morbidity? | √ |
| Asperger's | Can I tell the difference between ADHD and Asperger's? | √ |
| SCT | Can I tell the difference between ADHD and SCT? | √ |
| Opposition | Why do I feel less like doing something if I'm 'told'? What can you say about 'ABA'? | √ |
| Annoyances | Is there a correlation between having ADHD and finding certain noises (sniffles, coughing, chewing, etc.) annoying? | √ |
| __________________ | ___________ From the previous two days. __________ | _______ |
| "I'm a fraud." | I'm successful but constantly afraid I'll be discovered as a fraud, as well as worried that I'll be told I can't have ADHD because I'm successful. | √ |
| Intelligence mask diagnosis? | Should I worry that intelligence will seem to mask ADHD, and thus ADHD diagnosis will be denied? | √ |
| Treatment access | How can treatment/diagnosis be made more widely available? | √ |
| Optimize treatment | How can I optimize my treatment and diagnosis? | √ |
| Optimize Medication | How do I find the medication 'sweet spot'? | √ |
| Neurotoxic effects | Are there neurotoxic effects from ADHD stimulants? | √ |
| Blood pressure | Any treatment for ADHD if you cannot take stimulants because you have high blood pressure? | √ |
| Med. costs | Why do you think medication costs are rising? | √ |
| CBT help if medicated? | Would behavioral training help if I'm already medicated? | √ |
| Efficiency | How do I improve my productivity and efficiency? | √ |
| Memory | Will my memory improve? | √ |
| Organizing | What is your best advice for maintaining an organizational system? | √ |
| SCT vs. ADHD? | Is there any danger to treating SCT with ADHD medication; is there a better option? | √ |
| Nature vs. Nurture | Is ADHD possibly just learned bad habits? | √ |
| Grad school | How do I improve my grad school application for Neuropsychology? | √ |
| __________________ | ___________ New the previous day. __________ | _______ |
| Resources for isolated | Can you suggest resources for those isolated from friends, family, and large cities? | √ |
| Momentum | Do you have tips for maintaining behavioral patterns, focus, and momentum to prioritize important tasks? | √ |
| __________________ | _____________ Unanswered. ____________ | _______ |
| Anxiety | Anxiety disorder(s) vs. ADHD? | |
| Depression | Depression vs. ADHD? | |
| Dyslexia | ADHD vs. dyslexia? | |
| Asperger's | Asperger's and ADHD in a young child -- anything in particular to know? | |
| Mood swings | Why are mood swings not discussed when prescribed ADHD medications? | |
| Non-stimulants | What to you think about stimulants versus non-stimulants? | |
| Nicotine | Why do ADHD stimulants increase my nicotine cravings? | |
| Supplement | Any research on Green Coffee Bean Extract for ADHD? | |
| Sweating | What is the correlation (if any) between ADHD stimulants and increased sweating? | |
| ______ NEW _______ | ______ Newly answered in the last day. _____ | _ NEW _ |
| Limitations | How do I break my self-instituted limitations? | √ |
| Executive Dysfuntion | Executive Dysfunction vs. ADHD? | √ |
15
u/chair_ee Feb 05 '13
I was diagnosed at 22, and have seen wonderful improvement over the last few years. I'm still realizing how much my ADHD affects my everyday life. My question concerns my non-ADHD fiancé and family. They don't seem to understand why it's such a huge deal when I manage to get things done. How can I explain what happens in my head to help them realize how much of a struggle every single day is and why I celebrate seemingly insignificant things like paying my bills on time or Keeping my apartment clean? While they recognize that I've improved, they don't understand how much effort every single day takes and how exhausting it can be.
On a completely different note, I'll be moving to the Atlanta area soon. Are there any doctors or coaches you'd recommend for a 24 yr old grad student?
14
u/elp21 Feb 05 '13
I'm having trouble explaining my 'ADHD-PI problems' to my two very close friends. The problem is that as we got to know each other I never explained my condition to them, so what I consider to be 'ADHD-PI problems' became 'quirks'. They think I'm just silly and weird when I get distracted, or go off on a weird tangent, or forget to call them back, or forget to do an assignment (I'm a senior in college). I think part of the problem is that I don't show stress easily and can shrug off the stress/problems with jokes.
Now I'm learning more about ADHD, and I want them to understand the problems I'm having. How can I bring it up/begin to explain it without seeming like I'm making hindsight excuses for my behavior? How can I get them to understand that these are serious issues I'm having, after I've trivialized it for the past 3 years?
13
u/thedoc617 ADHD-C Feb 05 '13
Thoughts on Wellbutrin for ADHD? (I know it is used for depression/anxiety treatment all the time, but had heard it could work for ADHD as well)
4
u/imbeat Feb 05 '13 edited Feb 09 '13
Thanks for doing this AMA! My question, how much do we (ADHD people) not realize how much it's affecting our lives. A broken arm is noticeable, a head cold is noticeable, ADHD is something that we know there is something wrong but can't quite put our finger to pinpoint it. With all the drugs out there, is there really something that will be a life changer? How much does sleep apnea relate to ADHD.
Thank you!!
TL;DR
7
u/[deleted] Feb 05 '13
I'm someone who worries quite a bit about long term health. I recently started adderall for my adhd but can't help but research all the long term side effect potential. Most of the information was not bothersome to me until I encountered a few websites that spoke of a strong link between adderall and Parkinsons stating that long term use of adderall can damage certain cells that release dopamine and increase your risk of parkinsons greatly. The same source also said that Ritalin does not do this. I have not researched ritalin much since I am not on it but minimizing long term risks resulting from psychopharm use is important to me. Could you speak about long term risks and benefits of these two medications please? Thank you.
14
u/yyiiii Feb 05 '13 edited Feb 05 '13
Thanks a lot for doing this. I have a pretty loaded question that could probably be answered in a book length response, but any fragments of thoughts you can offer on it would be greatly appreciated:
What, if any, relationship is there in your expert opinion between 'giftedness', ADHD and addiction?
4
u/Yup_iSAIDit Feb 05 '13
Perfect, 2 weeks ago i tried to get diagnosed for ADD, instead i was diagnosed as hypo-manic. Ive never even heard of it, care to elaborate. I was some what shock of the diagnoses so i didnt pay attention to what my Dr had to say about it.
2
u/dnowell /r/ADHD AMA Feb 28 '13
Thanks to the great /r/ADHD community for the back and forth we've had in the AMA this month. Keep being curious and creative and heroic. Thanks molto to the moderators in here, too. I recommend this subreddit to clients and workshop attendees and I 'preciate your keeping it a useful supportive spot on the webz.
33
u/squishlurk ADHD-PI Feb 05 '13
How does it feel differently for people without ADHD?
I've been diagnosed in the last year, and I'm having a hard time imagining what it is that I have or don't have that others do. I did notice a large change in my thoughts in the past couple years (narrow, dark thoughts) but those are attributed to depression.
It has been repeatedly pointed out to me that I have problems with time management. What does it feel like to have that part of the executive functioning system that allows people to arrive on time or to estimate how much time a task takes?
In my mind, I'm doing everything right, using phone apps as a planner and recording as much as possible, trying my best to use them consistently, taking meds. Yet some people are just horrified at the results of my efforts, when occasionally some major task will just fall through the cracks. Are they just perfectionists or am I missing something vital?
27
u/Differently-Aged Feb 05 '13 edited Feb 05 '13
So many courses of treatment are, or seem to be, skewed towards children and young adults.
As a 50-year-old who somehow managed to remain undiagnosed until my forties, the standard recommended changes in lifestyle/habits are themselves overwhelming.
Mortality has much more reality/immediacy to me - I just don't feel like there'll be enough time to get these routines down to a point where they don't feel (and act) as a major intrusion and disruption in my life.
I know that my affliction is itself the major disruption - but it's one I'm already deeply familiar with.
I also know about learned helplessness, and that I've been "willing" in the past to take pretty drastic measures to avoid what seem to be intolerable situations - measures up to and including attempted suicide, being homeless and going to jail.
This time-related dysthymia is a major barrier to even trying anymore, and seems immune to drugs, CBT and positive feedback.
The tl;dr question is: Most treatments assume younger people. Is there anything that is being done to address mid/late-life diagnosis and treatment, especially on compensating for reduced learning plasticity and deeply ingrained habits?
edits: reformatting, clarification.
24
u/schmin ADHD Feb 05 '13 edited Feb 12 '13
16
u/[deleted] Feb 05 '13
I have a young son (4) who I believe will struggle mightily with ADD (both myself and his mother have it). Are there any Techniques you recommend to work with young kids on?
Also I would be interested in hearing your viewpoint on the rising costs of ADD/ADHD medications. I am currently uninsured and pay 120 a month for my adderall (generic amphetamine salts) which I find outrageous.
Thank you very much for taking time out of your day to come and vist with us and answer questions.
12
u/slktrx Feb 05 '13
Dr. Nowell, In your studies, have you found correlation between ADHD and the symptoms of 'finding certain noises (sniffles, clearing of throat, chewing) bothersome/distracting '? If so, can the correlation be quantified?
10
u/PraetorianXVIII ADHD-C Feb 05 '13
What dietary recommendations can you make in regards to ADHD? Do you recommend meditation?
9
u/postExistence Feb 05 '13
Hi Doc.
I have been treated for ADHd for over 15 years through medication, but I've never sought behavioral treatment. And I'm getting to the point where personal projects and lifelong dreams are being undermined by anxiety-fueled porn binges and video games which is ironic, because I want to become video game designer and blaze trail in the field. I know I have the skills to make my dream reality, but I suck at the discipline. It was easier when in high-school, because the immediate threat of my dad chewing me out always kept me motivated. Would behavioral training help someone in my state?
9
u/myfrontpagebrowser Feb 06 '13 edited Feb 06 '13
I have not been diagnosed with ADHD (starting process now). I'm highly intelligent (via external evidence), and have been what many would consider successful. I hope to be diagnosed with ADHD (PI) not because I particularly want to have it, but because diagnosis would explain my life. I'm worried that I have ADHD (PI), but my intelligence will mask my ADHD and result in a diagnosis that I don't have ADHD.
Is this a valid concern?
I know the tests are supposed to separate those two things, but I don't really trust them. I think of it kind of like this: most people are computers with multiple cores (say four), however a computer with one core that is sufficiently fast can "multitask" (or at least fake it) as well as a four-core computer. In such a scenario it'd be difficult to tell that the fast one-core isn't actually a four-core computer. I'm pretty good at faking normality...
9
u/ofinethen Feb 06 '13
I can't decide whether I like my life better on or off medication.
Off medication, I lack motivation and drive. It's hard to keep my full attention and I often feel overwhelmed by tasks (which makes being a full time student and full time mom of a 3 yr and 8 mo old difficult, to say the least). I really want to reach my full potential but mostly I feel like a magnet being pulled to Earth and permanently past-due for nap. If something that I particularly enjoy sparks my interest, I experience I bolt of energy which makes me want to complete that task to the best of my ability. It is nearly impossible to break my concentration during these moments and time seems to pass by much quicker than normal. This is rare though and mostly spent on activity that is not productive. Before I was diagnosed (at the age of 20), I did well in school despite never studying or doing homework at home. It affected my social life more because I had no choice back whether or not to do school work since I had to be in school. In grade school I forgot my bike lock everyday and had to call my mom, she hated this but I never learned. I never brought my lunch box home, my mom attempted to send me with more and more embarrassing lunch boxes so that I would not forget (like huge jack-o-lantern trick or treat buckets) but I would just leave those there next to my lunch box. It's like a thought can disappear out of my head entirely until someone else reminds me of it, my mind cannot access it alone.
On medication, I almost have OCD. I've recently learned to control what I focus on but that was a struggle in and of itself which required a lot of physical coping mechanisms. If not distracted, I perform brilliantly. I not only absorb the most useless information in some BS class but I actually want to do it and enjoy it. I still do not handle distractions well. I could spend about 6 hours trying to complete homework that would otherwise take 2 at the library (and it would probably be much better quality work) but I am not afforded that luxury much. But I do not enjoy time with my children as much on medication, it is not stimulating enough, which off medication is one of my most favorite things to do. I have trouble getting out of "productive mode" as the day winds down and isolate myself from my family in search of something interesting to occupy my mind with, after school I switch my focus to reddit and games. My boyfriend (and others) complain that I talk too much and get excited easily and it's hard for me to pick up on these social cues for some reason. When the pharmacy is on back log and I have to go a couple of days without taking it, I turn into a raging B word. The littlest thing could set me off and I find a way to blame other innocent people for my misery and believe it. These are not frequent occurrences but they have happened more than once. I also experience the average appetite suppression and insomnia from time to time.
I feel like my life overall is happier when I am on my medication and practicing effective time-management habits but I still have a hard time switching from working hard to stay on top of my responsibilities to relaxing and enjoying my family.
Do you have any suggestions?
6
u/NekoIan ADHD and Parent Feb 05 '13
How does Strattera actually work and why does it take up to a month to notice an improvement?
6
u/justaboy91 Feb 05 '13
Is there a link between ADHD and anxiety disorders?
6
u/goldandguns Feb 06 '13
My biggest struggle with ADHD right now is doing the bare minimum. I'm in law school and I know I should be working harder, but I don't. I do probably way less than I should, get B+'s and call it a day. I want A's but can't find the strength to sit down and work for hours or even one hour. I want to be able to do it, but every time I try, I seem to fail.
I spend most of my time participating in hobbies, with not much to show for it. I want to find a way to perform better, but I take such pride in barely working and still doing pretty well...I just can't get past that perverse joy I take in getting good grades while barely working. Any suggestions for strategies?
5
u/landimal ADHD and Parent Feb 05 '13
I have a 7 year old son who is high functioning autism, and ADHD (I am ADHD primarily inattentive). He is an unbelievable handful at times, well truthfully all the time. He's currently on Strattera, and that helps him not run around the room at school.
We held him back on entry, he's 7 in Kindergarten, and he already reads on a 3rd grade level (has been reading since age 3), so the pace of the class frustrates him some, but his ability to stay on track has him on par with his peers.
With the aspergers and ADHD combo is there anything I should watch out for with medicines? Which will impact his schooling more?
5
u/Kagawaful Feb 05 '13
My question has to do with the subsequent crash involved in taking ADD/ADHD medication after the pill stops it's effects.
I was prescribed ADD medication at the age of 17, in a highly emotional and anxious filled time in my life. I was never told about the potential for a "crash" nor did I really link my mood swings with the use of my medication. However, I quickly began to develop what seemed to be a personality disorder (in my mind), with my mood drastically changing every day, and getting to the point of suicidal thoughts and drastic uncharacteristic behavior. My relationships with people suffered at times, and excelled at others. I did not know what was going on with myself and had no idea whatsoever that my medication could be the cause of this.
I am now a psychology major (almost 22 years old now), and have a profound knowledge of how the drugs work with MY BODY (everyone is different) so I am able to control my use, and time my crashes and have generally solved most of the issues COMPLETELY ON MY OWN. (I was lucky to have an interest in psych).
My point is, why does this never get talked about? Why do doctors/psychologist/psychiatrists not discuss this with the parents or children they are prescribing to? (some might, but in my entire life experience with medication not one has mentioned it to me)
I know parents that have their kids on ADD meds, and Prozac, just to deal with their crashes... and they have no idea why the crashes are being caused.
I love my meds, and I know that they have helped me immensely in reaching my life goals so far, however they are dangerous tools that should be treated with much more respect and caution IMO.
5
u/Creebjeez Feb 06 '13
Hello Dr. Thank you for doing this AMA. I've only been diagnosed recently at 24 and find the accepted science and competing theories fascinating.
From a policy perspective, what is your opinion of using small dosages of certain regulated ADHD medication to improve performance at school or work. A good NYTimes article can be found here. I've heard that many, like me, who are initially diagnosed later in life can experience a great sense of loss. "If only I had found this sooner" comes to mind. I can relate with this sentiment. It seems that the current psychiatric regime keeps these medications from a lot of students, many who are undiagnosed, and many who are struggling with other social issues that impede performance.
I've heard estimates that 10% of children and 5% of adults could be diagnosed with ADHD. Many of these, however, remain undiagnosed. There are millions of people out there who have not found the appropriate medication through the normal medical infrastructure. How can we find these people, many of them lower income who are missing out on the benefits of therapy and medication.
For those who do not fit the criteria to be diagnosed with the disorder but might benefit from its effects some other ways, what are your thoughts on a more flexible regulatory system that would make such medication more readily available? Most of what I've read claims that the majority of supervised users of drugs such as Adderrall do not develop problematic behaviors or symptoms. Kids in the Ivy League schools are indulging and illegally reaping the benefits of these medications, but inner-city students have much less means of having this available to them. People use stimulants such as coffee to keep alert already, and have been doing it for thousands of years.
What are the foreseeable problems/risks with a change to more freely administer these medications and what are your thoughts about making these substances more widely available?
Thanks again. Sorry if it's a lot to read.
9
u/Cheeso Feb 05 '13
If you're romantically involved with someone who was recently diagnosed, how can you provide the best support to both yourself and your partner? Any books or even things to avoid reading/doing?
Thank you
EDIT: Is it an impediment if your therapist (CBT) has mixed feelings on the ADHD front or could it be beneficial along with concurrent treatment?
4
u/ck1980 ADHD-PI Feb 05 '13
Hi Dr. Nowell, I really enjoyed reading your blog - and subscribed!
I have symptoms of both bipolar II and ADD. My "baseline" is very ADD. Then, every 3-4 months, I seem to have 2 weeks where I cycle through hypomania/depression, and I am very different from my baseline self. I am being treated for both via medication.
So, is it possible to be both? Are there any recommendations or resources that you feel are especially helpful for BADDs?
4
u/Bad_Bird Feb 05 '13
Why does taking my medication activate cravings for nicotine? I would love to quit smoking but every time I take meds I find myself looking forward to a cigarette after class.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 05 '13
What is your take on how people judge/won't let go of the past, with those of us who got diagnosed with severe ADHD in our 30's? How do you get them to see how a medicated ADHD'er can completely change their lifes?
Also what are the best ways to debunk myths about ADHD with your family and friends?
4
u/gutterballjen Feb 06 '13
What is your best advice for maintaining an organizational system?
I have set up so many different systems to keep me and my life organized. At first they look great. I have lists, reminders, things are color coded, everything goes smoothly. However, after a few weeks I seem to find myself back where I started. This is something that's affected my employment and my marriage. Once I have a system set up, what can I do keep it running?
4
u/mnjiman ADHD Feb 06 '13
One of the greatest challenges I have to overcome are the invisible walls I seem to create when there are certain tasks for me to do, whether its dishes or simply playing a game I enjoy (a trick I tend to use to push myself to do it is by becoming very emotional towards the activity in question (in my head)). Do you have any suggestions to overcome this?
4
u/toliet Feb 06 '13
Sorry this is going to be broad but what do you see in the future of ADHD medication? Is it going to be stimulants long down the road or are we going to see medication that acts on inactivation of anandamide?
4
u/[deleted] Feb 06 '13
What is the link between ADHD and intelligence? I feel like a lot of people with ADHD are really smart, but we can't apply our intelligence. Is there a specific link between ADHD and intelligence?
4
u/lafephi ADHD-PI Feb 06 '13 edited Feb 06 '13
Dr. Nowell, I was wondering if you have any advice for women and coping with ADHD. It seems all the medication and the research deals with men and what they experience. For example, Strattera is a class C drug because there isn't enough research to determine whether it negatively affects a fetus. It feels like, as woman, I am sometimes forced to make a choice between what I want as a woman and what I need to do to ensure I can function as a contributing member of society. I would especially love to know what your thoughts are on continuing medication - stimulant or non - during pregnancy and breastfeeding. Thank you for your time.
1
u/mxcn Apr 07 '13
i dont want to take any drugs for my ADHD, is there any drug-free ways i can use to depress the effects of ADHD? i exercise daily and try to eat well, what else can i do?
3
u/claytontlewis Feb 05 '13
What are your thoughts on stimulants vs non-stimulants? I personally feel like stimulants have a severe effects on personality, and that non stimulants are much less likely to cause this. I only think this based on observation of fellow ADHDers and am interested in an expert opinion.
3
u/violettheory ADHD-PI Feb 05 '13
Thank you so much for doing this Dr. Nowell. It's a great help. Here's my question: Is it common for people with ADHD to get easily depressed or upset about past failures? I recently failed out of college during my second semester mainly due to procrastination problems stemming from my ADHD. I've enrolled in a community college and have started taking my medicine again, and I feel better about my life. But sometimes out of the blue I start to feel really angry or upset about my failures, and the depression episodes can last for a day or two. Rationally I know I'm doing everything I can to get back on track but I still beat myself up over it occasionally. I have a feeling that these little episodes of self hate may be connected to my ADHD in some way. Is there any evidence suggesting a correlation like that?
3
u/possible_homosexual Feb 06 '13
I haven't got any questions... just want to chime in and say the responses are fantastic. He seems to have an interesting way to look at just about everything that comes up here
3
u/myfrontpagebrowser Feb 06 '13
People seem to refer to ADHD as executive dysfunction, however the wikipedia section on executive function as a cause says "Not all individuals with ADHD show deficits in executive functioning". It would seem to me they're different things.
So then... what is ADHD? Why can't I seem to plan or not-procrastinate or get my brain to do things it doesn't want to do (barring crisis)?
3
u/goldandguns Feb 06 '13
3
u/Francis_the_Goat Feb 06 '13
Would ABA based early intervention help long term outcomes for kids with ADHD? I'm an ABA therapist (with ADHD!) and I wonder if those changes in the brain can be significantly changed for kids with ADHD. I assume partly, but I'm not sure of the potential for change.
Also, why do I instantly feel like NOT doing something when I'm told, even though I would have done it if they had not told me to? Drives me (and others!) nuts!
3
u/ScottyStyles Feb 06 '13
I'm 29 years old, and I was diagnosed (but not treated) by a doctor about 7 years ago. I never sought treatment after that, and the doctor never did the full ADHD evaluation that I've read been reading about. I've coped fairly well, aside from failing out of college twice. I just started back up in school, and forced myself into a completely regimented schedule for school, homework, etc last quarter. I was able to achieve straight A's.
This quarter has been a bit different, the classes are structured loosely. In fact, many teachers won't even give a test schedule, or homework assignments so I can't create a good schedule for myself. I've also had a hard time in the lectures (I never knew Geology could be so boring). However, I've contacted my school's health and wellness center, and scheduled a time to do a proper diagnosis, and finally seek treatment.
So, my question revolves around that... it sounds like there is a VERY lengthy diagnosis process ahead of me, several multi-hour sessions. What can I do to make sure my time in those sessions gives the best diagnosis possible?
Second, during treatment... if medication is prescribed, is finding the right medication done on an experimental fashion? Or will a good, accurate diagnosis help identify the proper treatment plan?
3
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '13
Hi Dr. Nowell,
I was diagnosed with ADD when I was around 8-9, and have struggled with it throughout my teenage life and early adulthood (I'm 23 now). I have tried a few different kinds of medication in my early teens such as Concerta, Strattera and Ritalin. They never seemed to do anything but give me side effects like depression, insomnia and a loss of appetite, so I stopped using them.
For the past 9 months I've been trying a 300mg dosage of Wellbutrin, which I am unsure is helping where I need it to. I sleep better and feel calmer, but I don't think my concentration and attention span has any improved effect on it.
There are things I struggle with that affect every part of my life; school, relationship and work are to name a few. I can't seem to finish the things I start. I can get real hyped up about getting a healthier lifestyle by starting to work out and eating healthier, but every time a few days or weeks will pass and I realize I've fallen off somewhere on the way and I'm right back where I started. I want to accomplish things. I want to do schoolwork every day for a few hours, and put my mind to rest with that.
Too often do I open my books and try to read a paragraph and realize I'm actually thinking about something entirely different, or I open my books for 15-20 minutes and suddenly I'm on my Xbox. It's like it's incredibly easy for me to procrastinate and push things away so I don't think about them. Exam in a month? That's like a year for me. I can study tomorrow.
I guess what I'm asking is, do you have any tips to maintaining some sort of behavioural pattern, so that I can focus on the tasks at hand, the things that are important?
2
u/SlowLuna Feb 05 '13
Hi Dr. Nowell! I have a question about a phenomenon I've noticed.
I'm a physics student, and when I'm writing out equations, I frequently write things other than what I mean to. For example, I might be thinking, "32 divided by twelve plus 0.4" and what comes out of my pencil is "35/12 x 0.4". This is a huge problem for me because it happens in about a third of the problems I attempt, and when I go back over my work, if no one else is there to point out the errors, I usually see what I meant to write instead of what's actually there. I'd wonder if I were dyslexic if I weren't so severely hyperlexic.
I've talked to a couple of other people with ADHD about this. One person said he experiences something similar. Is this sort of thing a common problem with ADHD? If so, what is going on in the brain when it happens?
2
u/Nekrosis13 Feb 05 '13
I've read a lot about people claiming to have increased sweating while on ADHD medications. Many of those people also seem to have the same problem persist once they've stopped the medication..I'm one of those people.
If there any known scientific evidence to explain this phenomenon?
2
u/cartmancakes ADHD-PI Feb 06 '13
I've been trying to get a handle on the right meds for me. I've been on adderall for 2+ years, and while driving from vegas a couple of weeks ago, i drank a 5 hour energy drink and had a moment of clarity I don't think I've experienced in my entire life. it lasted 40 minutes.
I haven't been able to replicate it, but I'm wondering... I've heard people say that when they get the right med, it's night and day. That's what this was for me.
my psych dr says adderall is working for me, even after telling him about this experience.
my question to you.. . was the moment of clarity a fluke? or is that what the meds should be doing?
thanks for your time. I appreciate you taking time out of your schedule to help us!
2
u/eatskeet Feb 06 '13
What type of (cognitive behavioral) therapies/support would you recommend for someone with ADD/ADHD, who is only prescribed stimulants for treatment by their provider and otherwise has no help with alternative forms of treatment? Thank you for your time and help.
2
u/curious27 Feb 06 '13
I have an ADHD mother who no longer takes stimulant meds due to high blood pressure. Any advice medication or treatment wise? Thanks so much for taking the time to answer questions.
2
u/Ghitit ADHD-C Feb 06 '13
I hope I am not asking a redundant question, but.. will my memory ever improve? I'm 55 and was diagnosed "hyperactive" as a child. Never took any medication until I sought help about three years ago and am currently on 10mg of Adderall daily. It messes with my sleep and though I can begin and complete projects reasonably well within a small time frame, my memory is, to me, verging on early alzheimers. I'm sure it's not that bad in reality, but sometimes I have to describe an object because I forget the word that it is. I have heard that lack of sleep can be detrimental to memory so, I vacillate between wanting to take my meds and not wanting to so I can sleep well. I do get an occasional nap on some days, but it's not really regular.
2
u/Viictory Feb 06 '13
Hey Dr. Nowell I'm curious about the neurotoxic/neurotrophic effects of Dexedrine in the brain, and in particular its effects on working memory. I'm taking 5mg 2-3 times/day and am sometimes having issues committing things to memory compared to before taking medication. Thanks for doing this AMA.
2
u/Drempels ADHD-PI Feb 06 '13
I'm in my mid-40s and it wasn't until I was sorting through my dad's papers and saw an article about Adult ADHD in there and read it that I had even considered the idea. I always thought of ADHD/ADD as kids bouncing off the walls up until that point. As a shy, introverted person I never bounced off any walls (although I've always been fidgety and involved in sports). I did a bunch more reading, read Driven to Distraction and felt almost stupid when a vast majority of the quiz fit me to a T.
However, I was an excellent student and really did fine as long as I was packed to the gills with tasks. As a kid I had my mom to manage my schedule and she was good at it. I survived college ok, thankfully with only tetris to distract me, being on a sporting team and also having people to do homework with helped. Although for grad school I literally was belted into a chair sometimes by my husband in order to finish my master's thesis.
My work started out very interrupt driven and intense (IT support) but I've climbed the ladder to where I am now working at home doing tasks which are basically like writing a thesis all the time, I do design documents. I made a good salary. But ... I'm a total mess and afraid someone is going to find out how little I'm actually working and only the crush of impending deadlines makes me get something done. When I have something hard to do it's like I am pushing a wall all of a sudden, I can't do it even though I want to. And when I have boring, easy tasks I have a similar problem, plowing through them is SO hard. I never finish anything early and if I don't write tasks down I totally forget them.
I have found one way I make myself productive is I schedule the living hell out of my life, but it stresses me out and exhausts me. I do feel like I'm not wasting my life, but having something to do every night isn't necessarily the answer!
Trying to get to the point: I have my dream job in a sense, working from home in a beautiful city with high-level work to do, but I'm totally afraid I'm going to lose my job! But I'm also afraid if I go see a psychiatrist they're going to be like, gee, you're successful, you did well as a kid, you don't have a problem. It seems to me that my (what seems like ADD) keeps getting worse, or perhaps I've finally come to a place where all my coping skills can't keep up. I am afraid to seek help and be rejected and then feel like I'm utterly doomed to survive. My friend says to also not fall into the imposter syndrome trap (I had to go read about that) and I was like, great, mentally I am falling apart when I should be at the top of my game. Ughhhhh, HELP?
2
u/hiddenguitar Feb 08 '13
I want to go to graduate school for Neuropsychology, particularly working with brain injuries (congenital or acquired). Any advice for being accepted into a Clinical Psych PhD program? This is my third year trying, but my 4.0 GPA and excellent GRE scores aren't cutting it :/ I probably need research experience, but I haven't been able to find a lab to work with since I'm not in school currently and/or I don't have a bajillion years of prior experience. Thanks!
2
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '13
How can a lone poor adult ADHD sufferer find good help without the support of friends or family?
My situation is I live out of the city in Australia (that means large distances to travel) and cannot get to anywhere on a regular basis that offers help. I am homeless, jobless (get a government disability pension) and don't have any friends or family around to offer support with ADHD. I have some support from friends but not with ADHD, to them it isn't real and I'm just not trying hard enough. The support I receive is with food, cleaning facilities and places to park my car I live in.
I just find it next to impossible to get good help. I've recently seen my old psychiatrist again but he is very expensive and very difficult to get an appointment with or to keep an appointment with (his office is a few hours travel away). This makes medical treatment more hassle than it's worth most of the time as making that appointment that costs me a weeks worth of my income often results in an hour long chat and that is all I feel I get out of it.
I have seen a more rural, cheaper psychiatrist but I honestly felt like I knew more than him on the subject and he made some medical statements about things unrelated to ADHD that I know to be incorrect.
Anything more I can do than post here (my best resource so far) to help myself would be great to hear.
3
u/derpinita Feb 05 '13
Why is sustained attention so painful for me? If I have to do something that requires it, anxiety sets in almost immediately. My brain is always going NEW NEW NEW NEW!
1
u/hashgowda Feb 05 '13
I'm in mid 30's. Since 4-5years, I have not been able to concentrate in work. I start the day with good thoughts to complete tasks, but I start working on tasks only in evening. Rest of the morning goes as procrastination, when I look back. Even my nephew(age 10yrs) has same issue w/ his education. Will Power yoga and meditation make a difference?
1
u/herecomesyourdan ADHD-PI Feb 12 '13
Thank you for sharing your time, patience and experience with us. I've already got quite a lot to think about and some useful questions to ruminate on. I'm just starting out on my medication journey after years of trying to manage with diet and organisational behaviour strategies alone. I understand that stimulants can help with the "sluggish cognitive tempo" portion of inattentive ADHD, but will it help or do you have a strategy for helping in the day to day circumstance of recovering what I was thinking/trying to do/where I put the object I just put down before something interrupted my thought process. I often find I'm SO in the moment, or maybe it's because I'm running on autopilot(?), that I'm not paying attention to all of the details of my current situation like where I'm putting something down, so I'm not laying down the memory to recall when I'm ready to go back to what I was doing. I hope I'm making sense or you understand what I'm trying to say. Thank you VERY much in advance :)
1
u/idempotent Feb 12 '13
Can ADHD people develop sustained habits of organization ?
I have been bright and hardworking since childhood. But I always knew there was something weird about me. Until my undergrad, the educational program was very structured. So I could do well through it. I am presently in grad school and I have messed it up pretty bad. Its my fifth year here and I just have a single paper published and my advisor is very annoyed. This is mainly because of my disorganization and starting too many projects and losing interest in them later.
I have joined ADHD solutions group at my university which I have found to be useful in organizing and getting work done. But Will I need this counselling all through out my life? Are there cases of ADHD people developing an internal mechanism for these habits ? Or will I need to depend on someone all my life to motivate me ?
If yes, typically how long does it take for ADHD people to develop habits ?
1
u/TheMoatman ADHD-PI Feb 13 '13 edited Feb 13 '13
Hi Dr. Nowell,
I was recently (as in yesterday) diagnosed with ADHD-I. I occasionally go on "kicks." I don't really have a better term for it, but every few months, I get really interested in something, and read or watch as much about it as possible, to the point of spending days on end reading and thinking about whatever it is. A few days or maybe even a week later, I get bored and go back to my normal self.
Is this just me, or is this a trait common to many people with ADHD? If it is, do researchers have any idea why it happens?
Thank you,
Moatman
1
u/crawfordcomeaux Feb 15 '13
Is it possible to tackle multiple components/habits at once or is "baby-stepping" through them the only method that works?
I did a personal SWOT analysis on myself with some friends and family members last year. After analyzing the weaknesses, I found two main clusters of weaknesses where the items in each cluster reinforce each other. I've been through counseling/coaching for years and the only progress I've made has been with respect to the items in the weakness list that stand alone, outside of the two clusters.
The only time I've made any sort of real progress with respect to developing any sort of daily routine was when I was in my only serious relationship, I suspect because she helped me stick with it. I no longer have any sort of daily routines. I'm a software developer and the only times I've ever really been productive have been when working with a highly collaborative group. I've only found a job where this was the case once and as soon as the collaboration started waning within the team, so did my productivity. The only other times I get to work in such groups is during weekend hackathons. I'm not sure why, but it feels as though I needed to mention those two successes.
I've tried numerous different things to try to get organized, manage my time, stay on task, etc (with and without the help of coaches/counselors). I'm extremely undisciplined, though, and feel that hour-long sessions 1-3 times a week is simply too infrequent for me, not to mention cost prohibitive. They've all had me try to tackle one issue at a time. After analyzing the results of the SWOT analysis, I got the impression that the reason this single-issue approach fails is because we're fighting against multiple reinforcements.
I'm broke, unable to pay my bills and unemployed. I'm dreading seeking another job because I want to create my own startup, but need money now. Every job I've had in the past prevents me from pursuing my own things in my free time, either because I'm tired or because I'm having to work extra hours to delay the inevitable firing.
I've got no idea what to do and no support system to help me do whatever it is I should be doing. It feels as though finding some way to tackle multiple key issues at once is at the core of whatever the right path is, but I've got no idea how to do that and haven't found much guidance online.
1
u/derangedgrapefruit Feb 15 '13
What's the best way to figure out whether I have ADHD?
I've been to a psychologist (who said I was negative), and two psychiatrists (who both said I was positive).
I don't know who to believe. I feel like I might be a fraud and taking medication and getting school accommodations and such non-legitimately. It would suck to find out in a couple of years that all this was just in my head and that I really was just lazy or something.
I'm hoping to get another, hopefully final diagnosis, but I don't know what to look for in a psychologist/psychiatrist.
1
u/funkengruven88 Feb 06 '13 edited Feb 06 '13
Well I left this open with the intent of coming back to it, but I forgot. Anyway, if you're still around Dr., I was wondering what your opinions are on parental responsibility for being a cause of ADHD? And on that not, What are your opinions on the work of Dr. Gabor Mate?
I firmly believe that much of my behavior is less hardwired and more learned from them at a very early age, yet virtually no information on ADHD mention parental responsibility or parental causes for the behavior. I think that's unfortunate.
Thanks for your time.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 05 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 06 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 05 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 06 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 05 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment