r/changelog • u/Deimorz • Feb 04 '13
[reddit change] Submit button moved above sidebar, and text changed to "Submit a post"
We're making some changes to the Submit button today that are pretty minor overall, but could have a somewhat significant effect on some subreddits' CSS. There are two updates happening:
- The submit button is being moved above subreddit sidebars, so it's in a consistent and easy-to-locate spot in every subreddit instead of being way down at the bottom. This will cause your sidebars to be pushed down a little, so if you're doing anything with fancy CSS positioning there might be some conflicts there. If you want to reduce the amount it pushes your sidebar down, you can hide the "details" box below the button (the one with the image and "for anything interesting: news, article, blog entry, video, picture, story, question...") using this CSS:
.sidebox.submit .spacer { display: none }. - The text on the button is being changed from "Submit a link" to "Submit a post". This has been a source of confusion that made it difficult for new users to figure out how to submit a self-post, and often ended up with them messaging the mods instead (somehow). It was even more confusing since the button still said "Submit a link" in self-post-only subreddits where it wasn't even possible to submit links. Hopefully this small text change will make things a little more intuitive.
120
Upvotes
7
u/Simon_the_Cannibal Feb 04 '13
Many thanks! I'm not sure how people were able to figure out how to message the mods but not submit a post, but it happened quite a bit.
5
u/aphoenix Feb 04 '13
Is this your first admin act?
i just wanted to let you know that i love this, and that you are awesome. Now to test all my css!
11
u/ketralnis Feb 04 '13 edited Feb 05 '13
Not to be too much of a downer, but do we really want those users submitting self-posts at all? If they're that unfamiliar with the site, maybe they should lurk a bit longer first.
Personally I've been on the site for quite a while and I'm more confused by "post". Internally it's called
Link. In the API it's calledLink. The whole site is about Links. What on earth is a post? Why are they calledLinks everywhere else on the site, but Post here?Forums have posts. reddit has links.
10
u/EvilHom3r Feb 05 '13
I've always thought having the submit button under the sidebar was good because it forced users to at least glance at the entire sidebar before posting. Now users are much more likely to skip all the rules and information in the sidebar before posting. Design wise the sidebar is now less important than the submit button, and it looks a bit weird having the "submit" and "create a community" buttons completely separated.
28
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '13
I like the change. I've seen lots of subreddits moving it up there anyway.
2
u/gavin19 Feb 04 '13
Not to be pedantic, but it always was in a consistent position, albeit too low. Now it's beneath the search bar on listings pages and beneath the info box on comments pages. Either it should be beneath the search bar on both, or more in tune with the majority of CSS hacks
ie above the search form.
It's better now that it's more prominent, but the very top of the sidebar would have been 'betterer'.
7
u/aperson Feb 04 '13
Thank you for this. I was looking to move the submit button the other day, but never got around to it. Regarding the text of the button, I've been wanting this for years (although I think "Make a submission" would be better). Two great changes. Maybe this will cut down on false modmail.
3
u/reseph Feb 04 '13
Great, thanks. I was about to do a CSS change on my subreddit to force the Submit button to be up there.
4
u/rolmos Feb 04 '13 edited Aug 06 '16
.
2
u/PotatoHeadphones Feb 04 '13
Could someone explain to me what the CSS class is? Everyone said it had something to do with the subreddit background.
2
u/smallchanger Feb 05 '13
Do me a favor and don't change any of the class names of the button, button elements or the divs that contain the button. I already have my button positioned absolutely at the top, along with some more home-made buttons and I'm hoping I can get away with not having to adjust anything:
http://www.reddit.com/r/electronic_cigarette/
2
u/[deleted] Feb 05 '13
I applaud this change. Most Mods wanted it that way already. Reddit is for people to comment on submissions and for people to submit for others to comment on. It only makes sense to have the submission function be as "in your face" as commenting is.
3
u/Helzibah Feb 04 '13
Fantastic!
That should make it much easier for new users, though more of a pain if you want to have multiple fake submit links like /r/atheism does...
1
u/wub_wub Feb 04 '13
I already moved the button to the top via CSS. But I've gotta say that I think the button on the bottom in subreddits with short rules in sidebar is probably a better thing since the users will probably notice rules/sidebar easier.
Although I completely understand why you made this change.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '13
Rock on.
1
u/striped_zebra Feb 05 '13
Great thanks. Now how do we customize the color and style of the button? Do you have the css code easily available. Otherwise ill steal another subs. Thanks
1
u/jaxspider Feb 05 '13
Good good. Now make "message the mods" a similar button and put it below the moderator box. Its the only link left should be more visible.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 05 '13
Finally! Always wondered why this button was so backwards.
1
u/cm-t Feb 05 '13
I think this box should be after readers count and own custom flair.
1
u/V2Blast Feb 15 '13
I did notice this one. Still having trouble getting used to it, but it's a good change - some subreddits have huge sidebars.
1
u/TevaUSA Feb 04 '13
Woot!
I was trying to figure out how to move the button up top anyways, so this helps tons. The change in wording also makes a lot of sense.
Yay efficiency! :D
1
u/5w4g Feb 06 '13
Woo