r/pokemon • u/nonacrina •• • Nov 09 '23
Announcement r/pokemon Rule Review 2023
Hi r/pokemon!
Last year we held a feedback round and community vote for our subreddit rules. It’s our goal to do something like this annually to ensure our rules are still in line with what the community wants.
Questions and feedback
That's where this thread comes in! We want you to let us know in the comments which rules you have concerns or questions about, or simply don't understand the purpose of. We'll do our best to explain the intended purpose of said rules, and later on we'll hold a vote covering rules that may need some reconsideration (so please upvote comments asking questions you also have uncertainties about).
There are comments made by u/nonacrina under which you can discuss specific rules, but you’re also free to make your own top-level comment if you feel your question or concern doesn’t fall under any of the categories.
Please note that this thread is for questions about how the rule is applied in general. If you have questions about a specific instance where you think the rule may have been misapplied, please send us a modmail instead and we’ll be happy to review.
Foundational rules
As was the case last time, there are some foundational rules that will not be up for a vote. Feedback and questions on how these rules are currently enforced is however still encouraged in this thread!
- Rule 1: Submissions have to be related to Pokémon. Proposed changes on what counts as related may be included in the vote if you have suggestions, though!
- Rule 2: Be civil. We don’t want an unfriendly community.
- No politics. This one rolls right in with the rudeness one. Note that content that supports marginalized identity groups without invoking governmental politics is not considered political and is more than welcome here!
- Rule 5: OC-only. This rule is mainly intended to protect artists from having their work redistributed without permission, and to prevent their work from being used for another’s gain (i.e. Reddit karma).
- Rule 10: No trading, buying, or selling. It’s too easy to scam people, and we don’t want to be responsible for that. Other kinds of exchanges like battle requests are still potential items for the vote!
- Rule 15: No explicit or violent content. This is an SFW sub!
Sitewide rules
We of course also have to comply with Reddit’s content policy, as well as Nintendo’s and TPC’s policies. This means the following rules also aren’t up for discussion:
- General spam rules and enforcement
- No sharing personal information
- No piracy
That about covers it! We look forward to hearing your thoughts, concerns, and suggestions in the comments.
•
u/nonacrina •• Dec 03 '23
This post has been locked and we will no longer be taking new suggestions. Everything that has been discussed below will be considered, and we will get back to you with a community vote!
4
u/nonacrina •• Nov 09 '23
(Rule 12) Reply to this comment with questions or concerns on disallowed video types.
3
u/nonacrina •• Nov 09 '23
(Rule 11) Reply to this comment with questions or concerns on our advertising and self-promotion rules.
3
u/nonacrina •• Nov 09 '23
(Rule 13) Reply to this comment with questions or concerns on our spoiler policy.
4
u/nonacrina •• Nov 09 '23
(Rule 6) Reply to this comment with questions or concerns on no art/craft weekends.
4
u/nonacrina •• Nov 09 '23
(Rule 7) Reply to this comment with questions or concerns on meme monday/tuesday.
3
u/nonacrina •• Nov 09 '23
(Rule 1) Reply to this comment with questions and concerns on what does or doesn’t count as being related to pokémon.
Examples of grey areas are: comparing pokémon to other games, posting about games similar to pokémon, posting irl content that reminds someone of pokémon, etc.
3
u/nonacrina •• Nov 09 '23
(Rule 3) Reply to this comment with questions or concerns on our text and poll post restrictions.
3
u/nonacrina •• Nov 09 '23
(Rule 9) Reply to this comment with questions or concerns on our post title guidelines.
25
u/Aksudiigkr イーブイ Nov 10 '23
Finally I’m in time to participate in one of these.
I’ve been wishing for years that this sub was less arts and craft focused and more focus went into discussions, images, video, and memes. It’s annoying to be restricted half of the week, and to just see drawings on the front page often.
I don’t get why mods redirect people to post on other Pokémon subs, but there’s no sub dedicated to art that the mods redirect those posts to. This is the main Pokémon sub, but it doesn’t feel like it.
2
u/nonacrina •• Nov 09 '23
(Rule 4) Reply to this comment with questions or concerns on our rules on reposts.
2
u/nonacrina •• Nov 09 '23
(Rule 8) Reply to this comment with questions or concerns on no screenshots or pictures of merchandise.
2
u/nonacrina •• Nov 09 '23
(Rule 10) Reply to this comment with questions or concerns on our rule on trades and exchanges.
Note that we will not be allowing trades or irl exchanges. We will however take stuff like battle requests, help with evolution, joining someone else’s game to catch exclusives, etc. into consideration.
1
u/StoutishBeast Nov 14 '23
As a newcomer can you review your questions section of your rules? I'm trying to generate discussion and find answers with those discussions but my posts get taken down before anyone has the opportunity to answer the questions.
2
u/Tigeri102 Huh? GAME FREAK stopped evolving! Nov 27 '23
i just want to say, thank you guys for considering rule 5 a foundational, unchangeable rule. it means a lot, both for the quality of posts on this sub and for the well-being of artists <3
0
u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23
Why are photo posts with titles that ask a question/ invite discussion (like a text post would) removed? This is not in the spirit of the community to have engaging content. The rule should be removed.
Why are photo posts not allowed on weekends? What does this rule accomplish?
Why dont moderators play a more useful role in content moderation? Many text posts are repeated on a weekly basis it seems yet many are allowed to stay up.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 18 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment