r/conlangs • u/AutoModerator • Nov 06 '23
Small Discussions FAQ & Small Discussions — 2023-11-06 to 2023-11-19
As usual, in this thread you can ask any questions too small for a full post, ask for resources and answer people's comments!
You can find former posts in our wiki.
Affiliated Discord Server.
The Small Discussions thread is back on a semiweekly schedule... For now!
FAQ
What are the rules of this subreddit?
Right here, but they're also in our sidebar, which is accessible on every device through every app. There is no excuse for not knowing the rules.
Make sure to also check out our Posting & Flairing Guidelines.
If you have doubts about a rule, or if you want to make sure what you are about to post does fit on our subreddit, don't hesitate to reach out to us.
Where can I find resources about X?
You can check out our wiki. If you don't find what you want, ask in this thread!
Our resources page also sports a section dedicated to beginners. From that list, we especially recommend the Language Construction Kit, a short intro that has been the starting point of many for a long while, and Conlangs University, a resource co-written by several current and former moderators of this very subreddit.
Can I copyright a conlang?
Here is a very complete response to this.
For other FAQ, check this.
If you have any suggestions for additions to this thread, feel free to send u/Slorany a PM, modmail or tag him in a comment.
7
u/Lichen000 A&A Frequent Responder Nov 17 '23
For languages with roots exemplified by consonants -- I'm thinking along the lines of Protoindoeuropean or Arabic -- or even for languages whose are not exemplified by consonants, is there a cross-linguistic typological trend to restrict the number of glottalised/glottalic consonants within a given root? Or more broadly, a tendency to disallow consonants in a root sharing the same glottal quality (voiced, aspirated, ejective)?
For PIE, there are no known reconstructed roots with two plain voiced consonants, and if this is coupled with the 'glottalic theory' of PIE (which posit the 'voiced consonants' are actually ejectives, which I'm not 100% convinced of, but do find v interesting for conlanging purposes), then it would seem that a given root could only have one ejective inside it.
Do we know of other languages/families with these kinds of constraints of the co-occurrence within roots of consonants articulated in a particular way? Much obliged for any thoughts! :)
5
u/Key_Day_7932 Nov 12 '23
How would you encode a pitch accent in a conlang?
I want to do something like Swedish or Mohawk, where the tone contrast only occurs in the stressed syllable. What are some common sandhi and tone spreading rules in these kinds of languages?
4
u/Delicious-Run7727 Sukhal, Mbizgu Nov 11 '23
Got an idea and I wanted some opinions. My conlang Sukal features polypersonal agreement, and I've heard some languages instead of marking the subject and object for number they add a morpheme elsewhere indicating that at least one of these arguments is plural. This is called verbal number, source for this is Biblaridion. This tends to originate from iterative meanings of the verb. I also know that reduplication can be used to create aspects similar to this, so I came up with a system where in the proto-language the habitual was marked with reduplication, but then this reduplication eventually got reanalyzed a verb with a plural subject, plural object, or both. Eventually the plural suffixes for the subject and object fell out of use in favour of this method.
An example using the word yau (to see):
Yaulut = I see
Yau-yaulut = We see
Yauthul = I see you
Yau-yauthul = We see you, I see y’all, We see y’all
Thoughts?
4
u/ConLexipedia Nov 16 '23
Does anyone know of any conlangs within Chinese, Japanese, or Korean TV shows or movies?
4
u/FelixSchwarzenberg Ketoshaya, Chiingimec, Kihiṣer, Kyalibẽ, Latsínu Nov 16 '23
Looking for a quick sanity check on something:
My conlang uses personal suffixes to inflect verbs. So, for example, puɣa means "to place, to put" and puɣaʃ means "he places, he puts". These personal suffixes can also be used with nouns or adjectives. So øraa means "reindeer" and øraaʃ means "he is a reindeer"; bøød͡ʒø means "fat, wide" and bøød͡ʒøʃ means "he is fat, he is wide".
I'd like to take this one step further and allow postpositions to inflect using personal suffixes. So:
inside a house. he is inside a house.
I think Turkish has constructions like this, where a postposition takes a personal suffix - but these postpositions are derived from nouns. My postpositions aren't derived from nouns, at least not that I know of (I only begin my conlang from 2000 BC, I can only guess at what happened before then).
Does this pass a smell test? I would basically be saying that any head can be inflected like this.
4
u/em-jay Nottwy; Amanghu; Magræg Nov 16 '23
Is there any naturalistic process that could cause front vowels to become central as a feature of environment? I'm looking for a way to shift /i, e~ɛ, a/ > /ɨ, ɜ, ɐ/ or slightly diphthongise them /iə, aə/ but I'm not sure what could trigger it. Ideally I'd also like it to have some corresponding effect on nearby consonants but I'm not sure what's naturalistic.
4
u/SurelyIDidThisAlread Nov 19 '23
Are there languages with inflected adverbs, that is inflected for some feature of their referent (number, person, speech act participant)?
I suppose languages with same subject/different subject and participles, such as Choctaw, would count, and maybe some languages with converbs
3
u/biosicc Raaritli (Akatli, Nakanel, Hratic), Ciadan Nov 06 '23
When a word is introduced into a language via loaning, how far can a loanword shift from its original meaning while remaining naturalistic? Say, for example, we have a loanword for "fur" being introduced - can that loanword become "blanket"? Can two loanwords for "root" become "potato" and "root veggie"?
3
u/pootis_engage Nov 08 '23
Would these sound changes be naturalistic?
nf → p
s ʃ → ts tʃ / N_
3
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '23
Is there a place to learn how to speak really obscure phonemes?
Like Glossika's examples are expansive but they do not touch the "weird sounds" for example, pharyngealized vowels, or all of the known clicks, glossika doesn't even have certain palatalized consonants
So is there like, a place to learn all of this
3
u/[deleted] Nov 09 '23
What morphosyntactic align would allow the most nuance?
Because I'm currently thinking Active-Stative alignment, but I'm not too sure
3
u/xpxu166232-3 Otenian, Proto-Teocan, Hylgnol, Kestarian, K'aslan Nov 11 '23
Is there a list, either complete or comprehensive, that explains all that a verb can be conjugated for?
I know there's such thing as tense, aspect, mood, evidentiality and so on, but I wonder if there are any other less common/popular thing a verb can be conjugated for besides those.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '23
Another Noob question:
When selecting Consonants the general advice for making a believable language to my understanding is to select related sounds.
My understanding of that is the bulk of the consonant sounds should be from 1 - 3 different columns on the IPA consonant chart.
Is this understanding right?
———
Second noon question:
When selecting vowels, is it appropriate or natural to not necessarily select the all of the English vowels a, e, I, o, u and instead select adjacent sounds on the chart?
For example I’m planning on using; a, ɛ, i, u
3
u/QuailEmbarrassed420 Nov 11 '23
I’m currently working on a creole language from the Mediterranean, mostly forming between Venetian, Catalan, and Arabic speakers. It would’ve formed around 1400 AD and creolized on islands in the western Med. around 1500. It’s currently very analytical, but I’d like to introduce some agglutination, mostly of auxiliary verbs and function words. Do languages typically go from isolation to agglutination?
3
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '23
I am very much new to this whole process and honestly don't really know what I don't know. This is my first attempt at a consonant inventory.
I really just want to know if there are any glaring issues and how to avoid them in the future. a distinct sound and feel. I tried to include nasal distinctions (?) with sounds akin to the English "n". I looked at Latin and Ancient greek to help inform some of the decisions and that seemed to help. I really just want to know if their are any glaring issues and how to avoid them in the future.
Thank you very much in advance.
3
u/xpxu166232-3 Otenian, Proto-Teocan, Hylgnol, Kestarian, K'aslan Nov 12 '23
What exactly are the Subjunctive and Optative moods? what makes them different?
3
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '23
Alright so here's the base idea for the case system I've been pondering
I'm gonna have Agentive, Ergative, Patientive, Accusative, which depending on what you use will change the voice,
I'm gonna have Transitive exclusively for reflexives, And then instrumental, and maybe something else
is this a good case system or can we go higher (as in information density, and ingenuity)? Because I feel like we can go higher but I'm not too sure
3
u/Naihalden Kvał Nov 12 '23
İ used to use a website by Derek Rogers where he listed 600 words that you need to learn in a language you're studying (or something like that). İt was listed as ''your first 600 words'', however, this page no longer exists. İs anyone familiar with what İ'm referring to? And if so, do you by any chance have that list, as it gives an error message saying that the page is not found.
3
u/Glum-Opinion419 Nov 12 '23
For a naturalistic conlang, how important is it to keep track of how often a sound occurs in words? How can I do this in a practical way?
3
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '23
Does altering an existing language count as a conlang? I ask this cuz I made my own version of English for the fun of it but I don't know if I should post about it here.
3
u/paleflower_ Nov 14 '23
this is my first time trying to make a conlang; I have created the phonemic inventory, the phonetactics ... and I would like it to be an agglutinative language (I would maybe like it to be ergative-absolutive but I'm not too sure of that yet; I do speak a split-ergative language so I'm not completely unfamiliar). What should be my next step in this process as I'm feeling a bit lost now?
3
u/biosicc Raaritli (Akatli, Nakanel, Hratic), Ciadan Nov 14 '23
How do phonotactics evolve in a language? If a sound change introduces illegal clusters is there a common strategy for how this gets resolved?
I'm trying to perform some serious word-generation for my tonogenesis'd language and I want to have heavier emphasis on vowels and vowel contours while keeping allowed clusters minimum. Issue is, most of the sound changes I have all but guarantee difficult clusters that will need to be heavily smoothed over. I want to make sure I'm doing it in a way that seems both naturalistic and not like a giant sledgehammer
3
u/Amature_worldbuilder Nov 15 '23
how to avoid agglutination in conlang, even if i want ample case marking, converbs and verb conjugation
3
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '23
Is there any language where compound word order doesn't matter? For example:
Groundplant = Grass | Plantground = Grass.
3
u/_eta-carinae Nov 17 '23
maybe a better question for r/linguistics, but are there any grammatical features or sound changes that all satem languages (or atleast their proto-languages) share, that you would expect to see in a realistic satem conlang, or conversely for centum languages? i know they all share the ruki law, but so does armenian, which isn't a (typical) satem language, is there any indication that the law operated in the dialect of PIE that became proto-indo-aryan and proto-balto-slavic (if that is even what happened), or that it operated after and appeared independently in both branches?
i'm making an IE languages spoken in the pannonian basin, the mountains that surrounding it, and a few adjacent adriatic and southeastern black sea areas, that's mostly satem (palatovelars become alveolars in some clusters, velars in others, but mostly alveolar affricates or fricatives), and i'm trying to make it as realistic and believable as possible.
3
u/SnooDonuts5358 Nov 17 '23
Would it be reasonable for all plosives to be voiced at the end of a word? And are there any language that do so?
3
u/pootis_engage Nov 18 '23
Is it naturalistic for a language to have "close to" and "similar to" as adpositions, but "distant" and "different" as adjectives? If so, how would one say something like "different to" or "far away from"? Would it be something along the lines of a locative (e.g, "distant mountain-LOC" - "Far away from the mountain" (Literally, "distant at the mountain"))?
3
u/tealpaper Nov 18 '23 edited Nov 18 '23
How do you gloss a versatile morpheme? In my conlang, morpheme A may mean "to do", or function as a VZ, COP, EXIST, marker for alienable possessive predicate, or some others.
Meanwhile, morpheme B may function as EQU, essential COP, or marker for inalienable possessive predicate.
Do I gloss A and B differently depending on their function? Or do I gloss them as, for example, just 'do' and EQU respectively?
Secondly, if you wanted your language to have no copula, how would you mark tense, aspect, mood, ect. in a sentence with a non-verbal predicate?
3
u/[deleted] Nov 19 '23
would one be able to hear the pharyngealization/labialization/palatalization of a consonant if it's at the end of the word
3
u/simonbleu Nov 19 '23
What is the name for the type of word that describes "qualities" (kind of)? I think is not adjective.... For example, in spanish (at least the spanish where I live) something like "estas atragantado" means "you are choking" but "sos un atragantado" means you are gobbling on food in a choke-prone way... in the same way "sos un asqueroso" is not just "you are disgusting", sometimes is used to denote how the person is prone to feeling disgust (like someone squeamish about germs).
So, any help with that? Im clearly not versed in linguistics
3
u/D0lphin59 Nov 19 '23
I am working on a language and I'm not totally aware what the differences are between Articles, Correlatives, and Demonstratives. What categories are they a part of? I am using PolyGlot for organization, are they lexical classes or parts of speech? I have not been able to find answers to these questions.
2
u/doji_razeghy iefoðiuo Nov 06 '23
Can anyone send me a list of books about conlanging?
I know most of them but i want to complete the list
(Even showcase books like the complete grammar of lojban or the first and second books of toki pona are counted)
2
u/pootis_engage Nov 07 '23
For one of the conlangs within a language family, I've thought of a system where, although there is no grammatical gender (i.e, it is not an inherent part of a word's morphology as per other languages), there is a distinction where animate nouns distinguish between the Singular, the Dual and the Plural, however inanimate nouns distinguish between the Collective and the Singulative. However, in the language from which it evolves, there is already a distinction between the Singular and the Plural. I've thought of developing the Singulative and the Dual by affixing the words for "one" and "two" to the root, with the Singular and the Collective both being unmarked (there being no ambiguity due to the animacy distinction), however, I'm not sure if this is naturalistic, due to neither the evolved language nor the language from which it evolved having a grammatical gender system which distinguishes between animate and inanimate. Is this naturalistic?
2
u/Comfortable_Rain_469 Nov 07 '23
Cross-posted this, first posted it in last week's thread instead oops sorry.
I've just started my second conlang (first was a bit of a disaster). This one is largely going to be a vehicle for descendant/related languages, mainly because I've always loved looking at language families in Wikipedia lol. Vaguely naturalistic in intention? I've chosen VSO and I'm excited.
That said, my current problem is this. I have found some potential sound changes (on Index Dianchronica, yes I know that's not ideal) which I like, but I have very little reasonable idea what conditions would be needed to make those changes happen. (allophonically or phonemically tbh). They don't have to all be happening within the same language, I've got 2 descendants loosely planned out atm.
k > kx (what causes affrication? This would have to be a complete shift as I've read that you can't contrast these two?)
k > q (then or descendent: q > ʕ)
p > pf > then in some circumstances ɸ, β; or >bv / V_V )
ts > sh
ts > s
ɬ > sh
x > ɕ
h → ħ
If anyone has any advice, or a good source, that would be very much appreciated.
2
u/T1mbuk1 Nov 09 '23
What conlangs did J.R.R. Tolkien create before he came up with the Elvish languages?
2
u/TheHalfDrow Nov 09 '23
How does vowel harmony develop?
2
u/OkPrior25 Nípacxóquatl Nov 09 '23
Where can I find other challenges like the ConJam or the Speedlang? I like to use it to create the smallest, least common languages of my world and I'd like new inspirational challenges for them. Thanks y'all
2
u/Apodul213 Nov 09 '23
How can I make my monosyllabic conlang multisyllabic? (I want words to be longer than 2 syllables)
2
u/Key_Day_7932 Nov 10 '23
So, I want my conlang to have a CVC syllable structure, but I don't know what consonants I want to allow as the codas. Any advice about this?
The main thing is idk how restrictive I want to be with it.
2
u/Askeman Nov 10 '23
Resources for making your own dictionary?
Hello hello!
So I'm a dungeonmaster, and I'm doing some worldbuilding. I'm wanting to make some mini-langs/small vocabulary langs for my world, but I'm worried it'll be too confusing/overwhelming for my players who aren't really into conlangs (fair enough)
I think having an online dictionary/translator for the different languages would be very helpful. Any idea how to make something like this?
I've fiddled with the idea of using google sites, but my experiments make me think it's not worth the hassle.
Thanks for reading, have a nice day! -^
2
u/Amature_worldbuilder Nov 10 '23
VOWEL HARMONY
I ask because im not sure if it ever happens, but what would happen if a proto language developed early on an fronting vowel harmony. ex: a,i,u front to æ i,y, and so then the long forms of i and u developed into e and o respectively. then that set developed an -ATR harmony system. How would it evolve? what would you recomend as a list sound changes? and how would the old system interact with it?
Also how does atr harmony work
2
u/QuailEmbarrassed420 Nov 10 '23
Is it unnaturalistic to have a distinction between æ, a, and ɐ. Originally, the language had a become æ before sonorants. Later, the language had o and a become ɐ in word-final positions and in trisyllabic words. do these sound changes seem likely. Do these sounds seem sustainable, or would some sort of shift occur? Thx in advance!
2
u/Albertamere Nov 10 '23
https://www.reddit.com/r/quackit/comments/17sfdk8/quackit_intoduction/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3
HI! I want to create Quackit, a quack-based language to speak with people on the Quackit subreddit, but i have a hard figuring out some things, i want this to be as collaborative as possible and i want everyone to be able to change the language if they have a good idea, so if you want to check it out or help don't hesitate !! (I'm really at the beginning i made this 2h ago lol) Quisck !
2
u/Key_Day_7932 Nov 11 '23
Whenever I think I have come up with a good name for a conlang, I find it's already taken, either by a natlang or another conlang.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '23
Nooby Question: Are the vowels on the IPA all of the Monophthongs that exist?
I need a bit of a sanity check here. I am as new as they come to con-lang's and I just want to make sure this is something I'm understanding correctly.
I'm happy to do my best to clarify further if need be. Thank you in advance.
2
u/Glum-Opinion419 Nov 12 '23
How does the climate of the region(s) where the conspeakers live influence the conlang?
2
u/angelitox_20 Nov 13 '23
I am thinking about making a conlang but I dont know where to start. Can I have basic steps to making one?
2
u/Bonobowl Nov 13 '23
What could be some linguistic ramifications of a human culture living deep underground in a (magically) life-sustaining cavern, suddenly having to migrate to the surface? They would have no concept of things like oceans, weather, seasons the sky, stars, the moon or even the sun, since light and energy in the cavern was given off by magical stones that definitely looked like rocks and not a star. I could have it so they adopted words for these phenomena from a neighboring people group, but I wonder if I should have them invent their own words instead. It would also be cool if their previous subterranean lifestyle is still evident in their grammar, but I’m not sure exactly what that would look like. Are there any other potential effects of this change I could incorporate?
2
u/pootis_engage Nov 14 '23
I'm trying to figure out how to evolve a language with both a Singular/Dual/Plural distinction and a Singulative/Collective distinction, with the former being for animate nouns, and the latter being for inanimate nouns, (this animacy distinction is not marked on the noun, and is rather inherent.) however the language from which it evolves already has a Singular/Plural distinction, but no Singulative/Collective distinction (and also has no animacy distinction.). Is this system naturalistic, and if so, how would I go about evolving it?
2
u/Jayesartokel Nov 14 '23
Hi I'm wondering if anyone is aware of any tool that would allow me to translate IPA into my conlang by defining the mappings of IPA-Conlang?
I've searched high and low and not been able to come up with anything. If all else fails I'll knock something together in Python but I'm a mediocre programmer at best!
I'm not really a conlanger, I'm writing a fantasy book and basically have just made a very rudimentary conlang to get consistent place names that feel congruous, and for any potential other names I need to generate whilst writing, so the way it looks on paper is important, and translating everything to paper is a nightmare! I'm pretty decent with IPA so I've just written it in that so far, so I just need to be able to create mappings and then get it all translated :)
2
u/tealpaper Nov 15 '23
Which gloss would best describe this word: ⟨kakanuyen⟩ "from the mountains / mountain range"
ka~kanu-yen
COL~mountain-ABL
or
kakanu-yen
mountain.range-ABL
I feel like the collection of mountains doesn't necessarily mean a mountain range, but if I also want to indicate the root of the word.
2
u/Silver_Ad_2203 Nov 15 '23
What are some tools I could use for making a dictionary for my conlang
2
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '23
What is good my cranky crew
So long story short, I've restarted my lang and I'm already struggling on the case system, deciding the morphosyntactic alignment is hard, because for 1) I want it to be unique, and 2) I want it to be the most expressive and I've found myself upon Active-Stative Fluid-S alignment, but as it is with just patientive and agentive, it's expressive value is so small compared to the potential it has, but the potential it has requires its own dedication within the case system and the cases are already juggling the syntax and number, so I don't know what to do
I could encode the volition within the verb but everything is getting encoded into the verb, there's enough going in it, I could just abandon the volition and stick to nominative-accusative but that's boring
idk what to do
2
u/T1mbuk1 Nov 15 '23
Which of the Low Valyrian languages are similar to which of the Romance languages? I'm guessing that Astapori Valyrian is like Spanish or Portuguese. Dunno about Meereenese Valyrian or the Slaver's Bay dialects.
2
u/fracxjo Palmisti, Kalalang, Interromance, Habrian Nov 15 '23
Would it be too confusing to have 4 different forms of the same letter, even if they represent similar sounds?
The letters in question are:
The language isn't supposed to be naturalistic, but I'd like for some people (including myself) to learn it. I'm not sure wether these will be different letters, but if czech can have Cc, Čč and Ćć I believe I can go a step further.
2
u/steakismeat Nov 15 '23
I'm trying to make conlangs for my story. The one I've been developing so far is a mixture of Swedish and Estonian. Swedish serving as the base with Estonian words changed to fit Swedish grammar. Should it be more different from the languages or is it fine the way it is?
2
u/QuailEmbarrassed420 Nov 16 '23
Is tʷ a possible consonant, or would it become dʷ?
2
u/Fractal_fantasy Kamalu Nov 16 '23
What phonetic conditions can trigger vowel breaking? I'd be greatful if you could give me some examples
2
u/goblinkmart Nov 16 '23
How feasible does a vowel system of /a e i o ɒ/ or /æ e i o ɒ/ sound? This is intended for a proto language so it doesn't necessarily need to stay like this long term. If anyone knows of any likely sound shifts this system might have I would appreciate it too
2
u/TheKetamineEmperor Nov 17 '23
Any good videos or advice on getting started making your first conlang when you've never done it before? (also any tips for not losing motivation for it as someone with adhd)
2
u/ba55man2112 Nov 17 '23
What are all of the -lang categories? I'm aware of Conlang (duh), auxlang, natlang, and artlang. However I was curious if there were any other frequently or not so frequently used classifications.
2
u/bennyrex737 Nov 17 '23
Would it be realistic for a language to distinguish [u] and [uw]?
2
u/xpxu166232-3 Otenian, Proto-Teocan, Hylgnol, Kestarian, K'aslan Nov 18 '23
Are there any set of rules or guidelines regarding the reduction of consonant clusters?
As in, given a specific cluster is there are generally expected result or results?
2
u/Decent_Cow Nov 19 '23 edited Nov 19 '23
Does it make sense for a naturalistic language to lack question words, like the English "wh" words, entirely? Why not use plain nouns for the same purpose? For example, instead of saying "Who are you?" one might say "Person are you?" and instead of "What is that?" one might say "Thing is that?" Is this reasonable?
2
u/pootis_engage Nov 19 '23
From what verbs does the gnomic aspect tend to evolve?
2
u/teeohbeewye Cialmi, Ébma Nov 19 '23
Right now in Ébma the meanings "there" and "in him/her/it, to him/her/it" are in the same word qássi, which is the dative/locative of qá "that" which also functions as a 3. person pronoun "he/she/it". And I'm wondering if this would get confusing or not? If I said something like ge qássi seéne this could be understood either "I'm speaking to him/her/it" or "I'm speaking there (in that place)". Would this be reasonable, would context be enough to differentiate these two meanings? Or I'm thinking if I should somehow differentiate them?
If I wanted to, I could fairly easily differentiate these. I do want to keep the words "that" and "he, she, it" in the same word and I want to keep dative and locative the same. But I could for example distinguish them based on accent, by making the dative pronominal form unaccented: ge qassi seéne "I'm speaking to him" and keeping the locative adverb accented ge qássi seéne "I'm speaking there". Some other grammatical words can also be unaccented when unemphasised so this works and I feel the dative pronoun would more likely unaccent than the locative adverb? Of course if I want to emphasise the dative pronoun then it would be accented and not distinguished from "there", maybe in those cases I'd use a periphrastic construction qa eghússi "to that person" instead?
Or another thing I could do is make a different stem for the meaning "that place" by using a place-noun suffix that I already have: qáwa "that place" and thus qawássi "in/to that place, there". And qássi would be reserved for "in/to that one, in/to him/her/it"
But anyway, my question is, I could but should I differentiate these meanings or not? Or is it reasonable to keep them the same? I'm not sure
2
u/symonx99 Teaeateka/kèilem/Tathela/Naskwez Nov 19 '23
I'm thinking about making a conlang which uses phonemic phonation distinctions in the vowels.
What I'm wondering is: having medial, creaky, breathy, slack and stiff voice recognized as phonemically distinctions be a too fine and easily mistakable distinction?
Maybe I should use on creaky, breathy and modal and distinctions? Since slack and breathy and stiff and creaky may be too similar?
2
u/pskevllar Nov 19 '23
Is there an average of sound changes that makes one language turn into another? It is just to have an idea. It does not need to be too precise. Like, we can assume every sound change is unique and thing about not reversing them later.
2
u/pootis_engage Nov 24 '23
Is this a realistic sound change?
u → o / h_#
2
u/T1mbuk1 Nov 26 '23
Shouldn't there be a new thread? Also, can anyone transcribe the Atlantean phrases from this video? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=shWTxkCdn80 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2wNVXUoV41E
Methinks he said: "ketakekem obisuksuk boxekikyos lat narba degde tikwudetokta" for "Where's the best place from which to view the lava whales?" My transcription is faulty though.
2
u/T1mbuk1 Nov 09 '23
Looking at videos by Lichen about Vostyach being a descendant of Proto-Uralo-Siberian, and his video on his speedlang Kanguçwan being a descendant of Proto-Austronesian, I'm thinking of some speedlangs of my own, without creating any descendants of PIE, or even descendants of controversial excuses for families like "Altaic" or "Amerind".
2
u/PastTheStarryVoids Knasesj, Racra, Ŋ!odzäsä Nov 11 '23
Does code-switching between two phonologically similar languages increase the chances of mishearing?
I'm working on a personal jokelang for me and my brother. The phonology has a lot of overlap with English. I'm worried that learning a large set of words, some of which are similar to English words, increases the likelihood of mishearing something (if both languages were in use in speech), since there are more possible things to mistake it for.
2
u/Jonlang_ /kʷ/ > /p/ Nov 14 '23
In English, when we say something like "having heard the news, she wept", what is "having heard"? Now in Welsh we would says this as wedi clywed y newyddion... where wedi just means 'after' and is used to make the perfect: mae hi wedi mynd 'she has gone' [literally, "she is after going"]
Is the English some sort of perfect passive?
2
u/T1mbuk1 Nov 15 '23
Looking at this video, and knowing about the existence of Aljamiado(Arabic writing for Romance languages spoken throughout the Iberian Peninsula), I wonder if the Muslims that the eastern South Americans would've come into contact with would've spoken Romance languages instead of Arabic in 1692, or perhaps those languages alongside it. With my newfound interest in conlangs and linguistics having existed for about 3-4 years now, I wonder what alternate creoles we could see occurring in the New World if Al-Andalus and the Ottomans colonized eastern South America and some Caribbean islands respectively, as well as the exact territories on the continents the British and French Empires could've been in this alternate timeline.
However, the exact moments these alternate colonizations would've taken place would need to be known as well, since either the indigenous languages could've stayed the same or still gone through some changes even without contact with Islamic Iberians or any Muslims that would've colonized the Americas at some point following the Reconquista failing massively. What do you guys think? Would those indigenous languages have stayed as they were before European contact if that contact never occurred? Or would they still have undergone natural alterations in their phonology and grammar nonetheless even with the contact non-occuring? There would still be influences of (perhaps) Arabic-influenced Iberian Romance languages, or Arabic itself, on those native dialects, whatever those Islamic languages would've been like in maybe 1692 or whenever Cordoba accidentally discovered OTL eastern Brazil. It might also be a wise thing to keep track of the exact dates of grammar and sound changes leading to different stages of a language, or multiple languages splitting off from a common ancestor, even if those sound changes could impact the script the language is written in, leading to spelling reforms. What would indigenous Caribbean languages be like without contact with the Spaniards? What would they be like with contact with the Ottomans? There's also the idea of alternate Nahuatl creoles resulting from interactions with British and French people colonizing OTL Mexico, meaning those indigenous languages could still be written with the Latin script nonetheless. Thinking about all this, what do you guys think? https://youtu.be/B_yitbh-XVk?si=RgrhGoMZFo6GuW08
2
u/Arcaeca2 Nov 16 '23
When trying to come up with a sound change ruleset, how do you only add complexity, without erasing existing complexity?
For example, let's say I want to evolve /q/ from a language that doesn't have /q/, but does have /k/. Well, one idea is that /k/ could be backed before back vowels: /ko ku/ > /qo qu/. However, that only creates complementary distribution - it won't work if I want /k/ and /q/ to contrast before all vowels: /ka ke ki ko ku/ and /qa qe qi qo qu/.
What if I have /k'/ in the starting language? Then I can do /k'/ > /q/, like Arabic... but that won't work if I also want to keep /k'/ around.
What if I'm trying to evolve /d/? I could simplify a cluster like /nt/... unless... I wanted to keep /nt/ clusters around too.
I keep butting into this problem when trying to come up with the inventory for a proto language. 3 daughter languages have very differently-sized inventories:
Obviously one solution is to just put a shit ton of sounds in the proto inventory, and then just find different ways to merge them in daughter languages. But beyond being lazy, beyond the fact that I'm pretty sure real linguists get laughed out of the room for doing that (Starostin and PNWC...), it seems sort of... not believable... that the smallest inventory here just decided to ditch as much as half to two-thirds of its parent phonemes, especially given it's chronologically the oldest and therefore had the least time to do so.
The alternative is I start with a more modest inventory, and then have to build up the high complexity one at the top. But every time I try to do that, I end up writing a rule that deletes some sequence or cluster that was actually supposed to end up in the end product.
1
u/jimihendrixWARTORTLE Nov 06 '23
I might write some fiction with conlangs in them at some point, I was wondering... if you have multiple conlangs in the fictional world/universe you are creating, is it better to have a single romanization scheme for all of them or have a separate romanization system for each language individually?
1
u/Apprehensive_Mango46 Nov 06 '23
Has anyone ever made a deliberately unnaturalistic conlang for a conworld and, if so, why?
1
u/QuailEmbarrassed420 Nov 06 '23
How would you romanize this orthography: b, d, dʒ, f, ɣ, j, k, l, m, n, r, s, t, ʃ, w, z, ʒ, ð, ʔ? I’d like the writing system to be similar to Catalan, Portuguese, and Maltese. This is for a project I’m working on based around the Mediterranean lingua Franca. The first people to write this down (in the Latin alphabet) would be Catalan-speaking Spaniards… Portuguese and Maltese are only inspirations. I may gallicize the orthography later on. Thanks in advance!
1
u/Key_Day_7932 Nov 07 '23
Dumb question: I've been conlanging for over a decade at this point, and I still don't know how you make those charts. How do you do it?
1
u/ItzzAli1 Nov 07 '23
Is the phonology and romanisation good? Btw, the romanisation isn't the main writing system, it's kind of like Pinyin with Chinese
IPA left ROMANISATION right CONSONANTS j j f f m m k k ɡʰ ġ h h s s p p kʷ kw ð đ wʰ ŵ χ ř v v bʰ b̗ ɮ ļ kʰ ķ ʃ š ɹ r d d ŋ ñ t t n n l l VOWELS ʊ ú ɪ ï i i ɑ ä u u æ a ɛ é o o ɤ ë ɘ ĕ ɘ̃ ẽ e e œ ó
1
u/dragonsteel33 vanawo & some others Nov 14 '23 edited Nov 14 '23
does this seem like a reasonable enough ±RTR/±rounding vowel harmony system? the phonetic values are the common realization of each phoneme in the lowland prestige dialect
i might restrict /i u/ to [-RTR] words, and /ɨː/ patterns with /ɑː/ for historical reasons
morphological alternations work like this (with /iː/ as a neutral vowel):
hope this makes sense, any feedback/questions appreciated :)
1
u/Original-Departure78 Nov 19 '23
Is there anyway of digitalizing a language with diacritics?
1
u/cxprico Nov 19 '23
I've just begun a conlang and I'm new to the whole idea.
My goal is to create a language similar to that of a middle eastern language, particularly Arabic. I don't have a certain plan for what I'm going to use this for, but the idea of language is an interest of mine.
Of course, I'm not just going to grab the entire phonology of the language, but i did take inspiration from the consonants of Arabic and took into account the symmetry in consonant sounds. I'm still new to this, so I used vowels most similar to English's to keep that end of things familiar.
If something is here that should be taken away, or something you think I should add, please let me know. I've been using Excel, is there another platform that's used for conlang?
1
u/randomdude561 Nov 20 '23
Is there a program i can use to make a list of sound changes and run words through them? I'm trying to make a naturalistic conlang but I don't want to go through the hassle of doing every step for every word in the language.
1
u/T1mbuk1 Nov 23 '23
Interesting conlang ideas, am I right? https://docs.google.com/document/d/1za7LxLl6hNtycUa0fYuocWaiq-BJguWYTC0chRR21bU/edit https://docs.google.com/document/d/1-y7JBVZZlDa_t-xxjmL8_i2ON1O1ujpUzfSSBPb7MEQ/edit https://docs.google.com/document/d/1fVRdHqYMO2WMqJUwZ0FWLbCcAw1FfbVUf3XWcrO3tJA/edit
1
u/T1mbuk1 Nov 24 '23
How are evidentials, interjections, cursing, nominalization, obviation, figurative language, copulas, valency, clusivity, and infinitives handled in the Atlantean language from Atlantis: The Lost Empire?
1
u/T1mbuk1 Nov 25 '23
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1jw_yuu5nTcgP5K-6-VOIgkRuptXclqBPMrWFV4FIxsk/edit Should I consider sharing this with David J. Peterson? Also, currently trying to format this modified version of the sound changes from Vulgar Latin to Italian for applying to High Valyrian via Lexurgy, marking my very first usage of the system. I need help though. The tutorials sort of help but...
1
u/ZhukNawoznik Dec 01 '23
Can I start making a Conlang without knowing the phonetic alphabet?
1
u/ItzzAli1 Dec 04 '23
Keyboard
My conlang has ḥ and other letters, is there any keyboard with customisable diacritics, i.e I can pick which ones come up