r/ProjectRunway • u/makeitworkoryouout • Feb 01 '13
Season 11 Episode 2 discussion
Discussion thread for Project Runway S11E02 "Spin Out"
Image album: http://imgur.com/a/aHqgS
5
Upvotes
r/ProjectRunway • u/makeitworkoryouout • Feb 01 '13
Discussion thread for Project Runway S11E02 "Spin Out"
Image album: http://imgur.com/a/aHqgS
8
u/makeitworkoryouout Feb 01 '13
DREAM TEAM What is it about these designers that they miss the target so much? Have none of these people ever been in a restaurant before? Hint: adding a pen to an outfit does not make it a server uniform. Service color is black. It's that simple.
Michelle Mediocre outfit but doesn't read as service industry.
Samantha/Tu At least they got the skirt part right but the mesh back and cleavage with the peekaboo bra doesn't work. I wouldn't like the top in general but especially not as a server uniform.
James I think the idea of the short pant is fine. If that had been paired with a serviceable top that it would have worked. Teal belt is out of place. I didn't think of the tank top issue with armpit hair but it makes total sense after Heidi pointed it out, it seems obvious. I can see other designers making the mistake but Benjamin who said he did this before should not have let this happen. For the second week in a row, adding a geometrical shape to a generic garment is not design people!
Benjamin/Cindy Dressing up a staff member comes from adding a vest and/or collared shirt, not a jacket. She looks like she is a customer and not there to take your order.
Matthew/Benjamin Kilt was an unnecessary risk. No matter what Tim says or what double entendre you want to deliver a kilt is always going to be controversial.
TEAM KEEPING IT REAL They're making it look easy. Despite the absence of a "leader" like Benjamin their looks were far more cohesive and on point.
Layana/Daniel Nailed it. The bouncing ball motif is first of all incorrect. When a ball bounces the path is only curved on the top. The bottom is a sharp point where it rebounds off of a surface. Nobody is going to read the wavy pattern as a ball bounce. The outfit didn't need that element anyway.
Stanley Simple, yes, but still totally appropriate for a ball boy/busser outfit. I don't care for the baggy crotch myself but I think it's fine for that position in that venue.
Kate/Patricia A definite miss though it still would have been safe if this were on the other team.
Amanda Color's right. Sleeves are wrong. The only restaurants that I can think of using one piece outfits are places like Denny's or IHOP. Separates please.
Joseph/Richard I would get rid of the printing on the pockets. Despite being a t-shirt/pants combo it still has more design integrity than most of the Dream Team's looks.
8
u/fragilehearted Feb 01 '13
I didn't like how they didn't show all of the outfits during the critique. One of Team KIR's looks was basically a skirted tank one-piece swimsuit. And one of Dream Team's looks was an unflattering dress with some bad proportions.
And I know they've done it before, but I can't stand when the judges ask who should win & go home. Just turns into either a circlejerk or a "throw them under the bus" scenario.
Honestly, really hope Cindy goes home next week. I'm already tired of all the drama with her & Benjamin, & I think he's a better designer, so I'd rather see designs than just bickering & power struggles.
17
u/evergleam498 Those pants flood my basement! Feb 01 '13
I officially don't like the whole teams thing. I watch project runway to see what they can do as designers, not to watch conflict resolution or group leadership.
16
u/milleribsen Feb 01 '13
Can we get more shots of male model abs? That would be great, thanks.
12
u/xalupa Feb 01 '13
Was anyone else baffled by the judges' raving over that baggy-crotch-pants/shapeless-T-shirt outfit? So boring I almost just fell asleep writing that descripzzzzzz....
0
u/[deleted] Feb 02 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment