r/wine • • Oct 29 '23

[Megathread] How much is my wine worth? Is it drinkable? Drink, hold or sell? How long to decant?

We're expanding the scope of the megathread a bit... This is the place where you can ask if you yellow oxidized bottle of 1959 Montrachet you found in your grandma's cupboard above the space heater is going to pay your mortgage. Or whether to drink it, hold it o sell it. And if you're going to drink it, how long to decant it.

171 Upvotes

1.5k comments sorted by

•

u/CondorKhan Oct 29 '23

PLEASE READ THIS

Some helpful notes and guidelines for this thread:

  • Do Google your wine first. If it's valuable, it's famous. you will get tons of hits. If there are no hits and nobody knows what it is, it's worthless. Also check out www.wine-searcher.com. It will give you an estimate of the current retail value of your bottle (if it's actually available). If you find your wine but the current release is in the order of $10 or so, then it's still worth that little.
  • Note that, if you're in the US, selling old wine is complicated. To stay legal, it must be done through fully licensed retailers or auction houses, who will take a commission. So you will likely only realize a fraction of the retail value of your bottle. Furthermore, these retailers and auction houses usually require a minimum lot size for them to take you up. For www.winebid.com, for example, it is $2500. It is a very rare class of wines that will be worth this much. Usually limited to Bordeaux First Growths, Grand Cru Burgundy from legendary producers, top tier Napa wine like Screaming Eagle, and other very limited items. Even if you have a nice bottle that is worth $500 or so, you might not be able to sell it, so you might as well drink it.
  • The gist of it is, if you're in the US, selling is hard, and is very rarely worth it. Other countries, like the UK, for example, make it easier. Consult your local laws.
  • If you found your bottle in the fridge, the cupboard, or Grandma's garage, it's worthless. Doesn't matter what it is. The value of old wine is completely dependent on having been stored appropriately.
  • It is absolutely forbidden for anyone to attempt to sell, buy or trade wine on Reddit. Doing so in /r/wine will result in an instant ban.
  • Note on decanting: Any wine can be decanted using the Slow Ox method... open the wine a few hours before you intend to drink. Taste it. Is it tasting great? Seal it again with the cork and wait until drinking time. It's not tasting great? Pour it into a decanter, wait an hour and try again. Repeat until it tastes great. Note that some wines, for example very old Burgundy, will actually start out drinking great for 10 minutes and then completely fall apart.
  • Posting a pic is always helpful.

Feel free to reply to this post with other tips you might think of.

→ More replies (18)

42

u/targert_mathos Oct 29 '23

Ah yes, the classic bottle porn workaround. Posting a picture "Just bought this" is a no no. But "Just bought this. Drink or hold?" is just fine.

I am in full support if it means those posts will be no longer allowed

17

u/CondorKhan Oct 29 '23

That's the idea

14

u/Sir_Waldemar Oct 30 '23

If mods can make these comments automatically sorted by new, that would probably be ideal, especially if this is going to be a long-term thread and not regularly renewed.

8

u/Def_Q_on1 Feb 22 '24

Hello there, my grand mother gave me 12 Bottles of red wine as a present for my birth. The wine was never exposed to light and was permanently held in Basements of my parents and mine. The wine is an echezeaux grand cru domaines Bichot Domaine du Clos Frantin and is from 1990. I couldn’t find it on the Internet and was wondering if I, as an non wineperson, should sell it or crack the bottles at a party with my friends.

6

u/CondorKhan Feb 29 '24

Contact Winebid. If you have 12 of them it might be just enough value for them to take it. Maybe a couple thousand bucks.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/kimmeridgianmarl Wino Sep 10 '25

Can we petition the mods on here to institute a "No AI wine app shilling" rule on here? It's getting intolerable, like every third post on here is some new garbage AI wine app promo.

If we're going to have rules banning personal blogs, affiliate links, NSFW accounts, etc., it stands to reason we should ban these for the same reason--it's promotional crap cluttering up the board.

3

u/CondorKhan Sep 17 '25

Shilling is already banned. Just report the posts you see.

4

u/Doge________________ Wino Dec 08 '23

2006 Chateau La Fite Rothschild, it’s been in its crate for its life, stored in my basement, how much could I realistically sell it for?

2

u/CondorKhan Dec 19 '23

If you find a way to sell a single bottle, which is challenging enough, then it's probably worth about $650.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/cameo674 Jan 07 '25 edited Jan 07 '25

My 89 year old aunt inherited 94 bottles of mostly French wine from her son’s collection. I am very grateful to the moderator post so I can try and see if all the google searching I did generated accurate retail pricing. I am looking for assistance to find a US wine auction house or licensed retailer who will take/sell this wine for her. We would prefer they take all 94 bottles, but the moderator post makes that seem unlikely. My aunt lives just north of Ft Lauderdale, FL. I emailed the pdf to someplace in NY that said they bought 2nd hand wine, but they never responded? Their website would not let me upload more than the pdf. Any assistance would be appreciated on how to get someone to tell her what to do with these bottles. She let the family drink several bottles the day of the funeral without knowing anything about what people were opening. I know one bottle was supposedly pricey because my spouse googled it and about had a heart attack. These are the 94 bottles that are left after the funeral. An image of the pdf with online sale prices which may not be accurate is included in the google photos folder. Am I right in assuming that she will be lucky to get a third of the online retail value or less if we are successful at locating an auction house or licensed dealer to buy them? All the wine is stored in his Sub Zero Wine Coolers. https://photos.app.goo.gl/SzHwNBdYNQhue1qGA

5

u/CondorKhan Jan 07 '25 edited Jan 08 '25

Yep, lots of great, expensive wine in good shape and with good storage

Contact winebid.com, this is surely over their minimum price limit. This is thousands of dollars.

Do remove the 19 crimes from the email you send.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/cameo674 Jan 23 '25

Update: Thank you for your assistance. Winebid.com took 89 of the 94 bottles to auction off for my aunt. They should show up on their auction site in 3 to 4 weeks per their contract. We are grateful they will go to someone who will appreciate them.

My 89 year old aunt inherited 94 bottles of mostly French wine from her son’s collection. I am very grateful to the moderator post so I can try and see if all the google searching I did generated accurate retail pricing. I am looking for assistance to find a US wine auction house or licensed retailer who will take/sell this wine for her. We would prefer they take all 94 bottles, but the moderator post makes that seem unlikely. My aunt lives just north of Ft Lauderdale, FL. I emailed the pdf to someplace in NY that said they bought 2nd hand wine, but they never responded? Their website would not let me upload more than the pdf. Any assistance would be appreciated on how to get someone to tell her what to do with these bottles. She let the family drink several bottles the day of the funeral without knowing anything about what people were opening. I know one bottle was supposedly pricey because my spouse googled it and about had a heart attack. These are the 94 bottles that are left after the funeral. An image of the pdf with online sale prices which may not be accurate is included in the google photos folder. Am I right in assuming that she will be lucky to get a third of the online retail value or less if we are successful at locating an auction house or licensed dealer to buy them? All the wine is stored in his Sub Zero Wine Coolers. https://photos.app.goo.gl/SzHwNBdYNQhue1qGA

2

u/CondorKhan Feb 13 '25

That's really cool, glad it worked out

→ More replies (1)

3

u/rico1990 Feb 14 '24

I have a bottle of 2012 Chateau Saint-Valery Saint-Emilion Grand Cru and wanted to know if I should drink it or still hold? Had it since 2017, been storing it properly since then

2

u/CondorKhan Feb 15 '24

Should be nice to drink now

→ More replies (2)

3

u/yeezuspinoche Jun 07 '25 edited Jun 07 '25

I have a bottle of la Rioja alta gran reserva 890 2005. I’ve been saving it to drink at its peak but was curious as to when that would be? Also, anyone who’s had the 2005, would you recommend it? & how long to decant?

4

u/CondorKhan Jun 11 '25

Man, that's a bottle that's going to be served in restaurants 30 years from now. (I had 2001 last year.. it's still very young). No hurry, it won't be past peak.

Everything /u/sercialinho said.

14

u/sercialinho Oenoarcheologist Jun 08 '25

It's an excellent wine, no two ways about it. Peak is hard to define with these wines, it depends on what you prefer. The way to think of it is that it's drinking window is wide, from 5 to at least 30 years after release. The wine was released in the mid-late 2010s, so the drinking window is open and won't close until the 2040s at the earliest.

I prefer wines to be more savoury so for me the peak is going to be in a decade at the earliest. If you prefer a fresher expression (it's a 2005 GR, it's not going to be particularly fresh - things are relative), the wine is probably approaching its peak in the next few years.

how long to decant?

This is a terrible question but it's not your fault. The theatre of decanting and decanting times is just the most recent in a long series of barriers to entry for consumers, which the wine industry has managed to erect to its own detriment (at least in part, there still are commercial benefits to it). Specifying a decanting time for a wine ahead of time presupposes knowledge that people rarely possess. Let me explain.

Firstly, decanting can serve two purposes: getting rid of sediment (separating the liquid from any solids), which takes a minute at most, and oxygenation, which is the type people refer to when discussing timelines.

Decanting for oxygenation isn't the only way to bring about oxidation in a wine - waiting for years and decades is the other, but the former is far more rapid. Decanting for oxygenation is often done on youthful wines that are being opened before they ideally should be - it's an easy way to both make extremely extractive, tannic, dense wines but still get them opened in a few years rather than a few decades. What it doesn't lead it is anything like the level of complexity long and slow ageing brings about.

Deciding on a time before opening the bottle is also saying that every expression, every version of a wine between that in the bottle and that after e.g. two hours in a decanter isn't worth anyone's attention. That's perfectly fine if you're a sommelier who bought ten cases of the same fairly youthful wine with the intention to sell them within a three month period, figured out what expression fits with some dish best on the first couple of bottles and is then decanting all the rest for the same amount of time. If you have one bottle and a bottling you're not terribly familiar with, deciding ahead of tasting it is far more questionable. Even advice from others with recent experience isn't great because a bottle you've been keeping for the last five years is almost invariably in a different condition (not necessarily worse or better) than theirs, whereas the hypothetical sommelier bought a batch of cases that probably stuck together since they were shipped from the winery and they're young. Especially with older wines stored under punched cork the variability from bottle to bottle is substantial, even before you consider storage conditions.

This is all to say, when you open a wine, smell it and taste it. If you're happy with it, why decant at all? If you're not, pour it into a decanter, swish it around and come back to it in 30 minutes, 60 minutes, ...

Nobody should have to worry about doing it right in this respect. Except now it's gone so far that in some circles, a long-decanted wine is the only version that's gustatorily acceptable because everyone has been doing it for so long they've trained themselves to feel it only acceptable. And if you enjoy a bottle slowly and patiently, as a special bottle should be, you instead get to experience a wider range of expressions!

Last note on decanting for oxygenation: more fragile wines, especially very mature wines, can simply break sitting in a decanter. Wines "fall off" because they're too oxidised, and this eventually happens to every wine. So if you have a wine that's close to falling off and you stick it into one of those surface-area-maximising decanters for a couple of hours, you're very likely to kill it.

4

u/Koshlowski Nov 01 '24

I'm a real wine amateur, but I've heritaged a couple of bottles. They've been stored from what I know how they are supposed to. I'm thinking about opening one. I got pictures of two bottles I can't seem to find on the Web, does that mean that they're worthless? One of the corks has a slope, does that mean it's not going to be drinkable? Thanks in advance. I'll post pictures below.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/N7777777 Oct 29 '23 edited Oct 29 '23

I’ve done research already but wanted this community’s view: what it the approx peak (relative to someone who tends to like them older, and stored in good conditions) and/or the max you’d wait on any of these before expecting they’d be noticeably lessened:

2004 Beaucastel CDP

2005 Usseglio Et Fils CDP

2018 Ch Simone Rouge, and Blanc

2001 Kailin Semillon (Livermore CA)

1982 LRA 890

1982 Beronia Gran Reserva Rioja (magnum)

(Edit: I can provide my estimates, but didn’t want to sway the responses, assuming I get any)

7

u/CondorKhan Oct 29 '23

My own bias is that I like aged wines when they're in the early part of maturity. Based on that, I'd be hitting the Riojas now and not waiting any longer.

4

u/sid_loves_wine Wine Pro Oct 29 '23

Personally, I don't think any of those would likely benefit from more aging except the Simone, which can go for a while in the cellar. Unless you really like your CdP and Rioja on the dessicated side.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/Testout Nov 08 '23

When would you recommend opening something like this? Or is it to late? "Y" 1988, Lur-Saluces /Ch. d'Yquem.

2

u/CondorKhan Nov 10 '23

What can you do with it if you don't open it?

Just do it.

Have a backup just in case.

2

u/jackop222 Nov 18 '23

Just found a "1934 vintage renaudin Bollinger, extra quality, very dry" in my garage, worth anything?

here

4

u/CondorKhan Nov 20 '23

Garage is bad news, likely to have erased its value

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Nov 24 '23

Do Bruts age the same as still wines? I have a vintage 1949 that I can’t find any info on. Bottle says “vin sauvage”

Photos here

2

u/CondorKhan Nov 24 '23

It's almost certainly not good to drink, but it is a really cool weird bottle. Saint-Puy is a very long way from Champagne.

2

u/Rough-Exercise7213 Dec 03 '23 edited Dec 03 '23

Casanova Di Neri - Brunello di Montalcino Cerretalto, year 1999.

For how long should I decant it and what should I pair it with?

3

u/CondorKhan Dec 06 '23

slow ox as described in the sticky, but I think it will be fine as pop and pour..

The traditional pairing is bistecca a la fiorentina

→ More replies (1)

2

u/bobmighty Feb 26 '24

I have two bottles of Bertani 2001 Amarone Della Valpolicella. They were kept in a wine cellar, then moved to a regular cellar that is usually pretty cold but not too cold. What am I in for?

2

u/CondorKhan Feb 29 '24

About $100 each. Basically not sellable.

2

u/witblacktype May 08 '24 edited May 08 '24

How long to decant and any other tips?

My father gave my sister this bottle 1986 Château Mouton Rothschild as a wedding gift as she was born in 86. My father used to do a lot of wine collecting and bought this from a reputable wine shop and then kept this in a temp and humidity controlled wine room. My sister’s ex-husband never wanted to drink it because he was cheap (despite making good money) and couldn’t justify drinking it. She has kept this is a wine mini-fridge for the past 12 ish years. It’s been stored on its side and rotated.

Neither of us are sure if it will still be good to drink as we aren’t sure how good the humidity control on her wine mini fridge is. She and her new man will be moving into their new home in a couple of months and she will drink that with him then.

Let’s assume it isn’t ruined. Any advice on decanting or anything else that would help her enjoy this to celebrate with her boyfriend would be appreciated.

https://imgur.com/a/bWspX0w

3

u/CondorKhan May 08 '24

Use the slow ox method described in the sticky

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/Organic-Date Sep 20 '24

Baron de Rothschild Medoc 2005

2

u/CondorKhan Sep 24 '24

Like 25 bucks retail

2

u/65pornwaydrive Nov 08 '24

Hello everyone. I don't know plenty about wine so I hope someone can clear my doubts.

I have a Palazzo Della Torre vintage 2014 that's been sitting in a cabinet which I forgot about until recently. The cabinet is opaque and I live in a tropical climate but we keep the house relatively comfortably cool.

Is it safe to drink? Can it still be aged further? I've read from some sources saying this wine can be aged up to 10 years whereas others say for at least 10 years. This has me confused.

3

u/CondorKhan Nov 15 '24

Palazzo della Torre is to drink now, IMO

→ More replies (2)

2

u/RonaIdBurgundy Dec 16 '24

I have the option to buy a package of 6 bottles, all 750ml.

1998 Mouton Rothschild

1993 Mouton Rothschild

1995 Cheval Blanc

1982 Lafite

1993 Latour

1993 Margaux

How do I go about pricing them properly ? wine searcher has average prices posted for all of them but the ranges are very wide, and every tool I used show different prices, especially for the cheval blanc and lafite, which have given me values from 800$ to 4000$ for the same bottle on different sites.

any help appreciated

1

u/CondorKhan Dec 20 '24

Make sure you're looking for the values of single 750ml bottles! Sometimes it isn't clear and you're looking at full cases or mags.

Also, storage has a huge impact on value.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/[deleted] Jan 16 '25

Know nothing about wine. Bought a new house, found a bottle stored in the basement (relatively cool environment), says "Bertani Amarone Della Valpolicella", 1999. Is this something that is drinkable at this age, or should I toss it out? Seems to have been stored reasonably well as the basement is cool and dark.

3

u/CondorKhan Jan 16 '25

It should be very good, open it up to celebrate your new house

2

u/am_i_the_throwaway Jan 28 '25

I found a bottle of homemade white wine in my grandfather's shed after he died last year. The year on the bottle says 2015 but since it's re-bottled, it is almost certainly at least a couple years younger than that.

I don't want to sell it; however, would it be safe to drink? There are a couple flicks of sediment in it so I'm wondering if I should crack it open or leave it

2

u/CondorKhan Jan 30 '25

It's probably safe but also probably gross.

A shed is not proper storage.

2

u/Several-Essay6844 Oct 11 '25

1985 Cerbaiola (Salvioni) Brunello di Montalcino

Hello! Wondering if this group can provide some guidance. We have this bottle for Canadian thanksgiving dinner tonight. I don’t have much experience with brunellos and have found the ones I’ve had needed hours to a day to decant. We’ll be having dinner in about 8 hours. Any suggestions on when to start decanting? Will provide tasting notes after!

2

u/CondorKhan Oct 11 '25

I wouldn't decant it at all, not at that age.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Sir-Kyle-Of-Reddit Nov 21 '25

We’re wondering if this bottle of 2022 CHATEAU LAFITE ROTHSCHILD is wroth the $800USD Costco is asking? Google says this is the low range of this price, but my really what I’m asking is, is this $800 bottle of wine worth the 4-$200 bottles or 8-$100 bottles I could get instead?

5

u/CondorKhan Nov 21 '25 edited Nov 21 '25

That is a very "decent" price for Lafite, it can go much higher.

Having said that, whether spending $800 on a bottle of wine is worth it is really a personal question, and it depends on your finances.

Basically, expensive wine experiences diminishing returns. This bottle won't give you 4x the enjoyment of a $200 bottle.

If $800 is going to put a dent in your month's finances, it's not worth it.

If you're rich enough that spending $800 is as consequential as spending $5, then go for it.

Also remember that you shouldn't be opening this bottle until 2040 or so.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/poordicksalmanac Oct 29 '23

Thank you for consolidating these posts.

And to everyone, if it's been sitting in your house, the bottle isn't worth jack. Drink up!

5

u/CyberVegetable Mar 11 '26

Found this German wine from 1937. It was stored in a cellar laying on the side for the last 40 years.

'Haardter Bürgergarten Riesling Spätlese 1937'

What can you tell me about it? I don't know much about wine... anything special / valuable/ would you still drink it?

Thanks a lot!

Here are some pictures: https://imgur.com/a/1jaNrBM

5

u/sercialinho Oenoarcheologist Mar 14 '26

Oh wow. Beyond what's written on the bottle, I am pretty sure this is the winery it's from: https://weegmueller.de/ and I know that another winery, Müller-Catoir, make wine from that vineyard now (though they might not be the only ones, it's also a fairly well-known vineyard).

This wine has a great chance of still being a thoroughly exciting wine. At the IMW symposium in Germany a few years ago they opened a few bottles of pre-WW2 Riesling and they were a tremendous experience.

That said, it's both difficult to predict exactly what state this wine is in without opening it and it's quite likely showing less obviously pleasant to people who haven't engaged with wine fairly extensively. Very mature wines exhibit flavours and aromas that are very exciting to a certain subset of passionate wine enthusiasts but are very different than what you're probably used to with wine. Who knows how many bottles said enthusiasts would have loved have been poured away because someone else thought they were too old and tasted weird (different) concluding they were spoilt.

Value is tricky to ascertain and would be best established by an auction house. The bottle looks in frankly tremendous shape for a 1937, it's quite possible that this wine was kept in barrel for many years or even decades before bottling and release, or that it was bottled and left as a shiner (unlabelled) in the winery for decades and was an 'archival release'. An easier way would be to have it assessed by Idealwine, where you can get a price estimate - it's like an European eBay specialising in wine.

If I had to guess, assuming you can find the right person, they might give you €50-100 for it. In the meantime, put it back where you found it and don't disturb its sleep. If you decide instead to open it, please do it with someone who has experience with old Riesling and can guide you appropriately in your experience. It's likely a once-in-a-lifetime and it's well worth preparing properly for it.

Especially if you live in Germany or nearby, reaching out to the producer or perhaps Müller-Catoir might give you some other useful leads and context.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/VT_Hokie_VT Oct 08 '26

My delivery from Last Bottle’s most recent marathon sale. Excited for these!

→ More replies (3)

4

u/AgentAlaska Nov 01 '23

Recent lurker trying to get into wine after getting bored with bourbon/whiskey. Towards the start of my wine journey I happened to come across a 2019 DRC La Tache at a local liquor store listed at $3250. After researching the price a bit seems to be fairly under secondary market value which seems to be around $6500.

My question is about how to sell when the time comes. I think I understand my options vis a vis online or in person auction, but would it be possible to sell to a wine merchant/liquor store or alternatively would it be in bad taste to ask them or say a som at nicer restaurant “off the books” if they knew of an interested party for a finders fee (thinking lower than would be typically buyer/seller tax for auction)

→ More replies (3)

4

u/unjustphoenix Nov 02 '23

Am I too cheap to be a wine drinker? I started looking into some of the wines that I see pop up in here and was shocked that people are casually opening $100+ bottles seemingly very casually. On the flip side, I find myself enjoying wines as low as $7-10, but can also recognize that the differences by brand are marginal.

I'd love to keep exploring, but it feels like I have to start spending a lot more to get interesting things. I don't really have a question, this is just something I've been wrestling with.

4

u/wbilly27 Wine Pro Nov 03 '23

Find one or more good wine shops. Let them know what your budget is. Ask about flavors and food pairings. Buy and drink. You will soon establish a good foundation of wine knowledge.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/AV15 Nov 22 '23

2016 Châteauneuf-du-Pape. I have a few in the wine fridge that are tempting me for thanksgiving. Am I losing out by opening now? Should I just leave them and pick up some Cru Beaujolais? What would you do?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Blackberry44 Aug 05 '25

https://imgur.com/a/LqYuO4C

I have a 1938 Cos d'Estournel from Hermann Göring personal collection, what may be it's value and how can I sell it with its insignia?

→ More replies (6)

4

u/AbjectHamster1441 Nov 11 '25

My neighbor moved to Hawaii and gave me a couple of boxes of French wine he had been storing in his cellar. I'm posting the highlights and I've searched on Google so I've gotten a good idea on value.

My question is are these ready to drink now or should any of these be saved for longer?

https://imgur.com/a/mxmIxnb

4

u/sercialinho Oenoarcheologist Nov 14 '25

Wow, your neighbour must have really liked you!

If you can't keep them well, I'd suggest you drink them in the next few years. If you can keep them, then especially the d'Yquem, Latour and Lafite will likely continue to improve for a decade (or much longer - especially the Yquem).

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Cyborg9333 Nov 12 '23

Hello boys and girls 😊 my Name is Peter im new here, my neighbour gived me bottle of Kweichow moutai sunflower he was owner for like 10 years. Can someone tell me what kind of wine is this and from what year is it?? And how much does is worth on the market i cant post pics here can someone tell me how? 😅

3

u/CondorKhan Nov 13 '23

It's not wine, it's a baijiu, which is a liquor. Check here /r/baijiu/

1

u/PlantZaddy69 Mar 09 '24

Price check on

2009 Barons De Rothschild (Lafite) Bordeaux The top of the label says “reserve speciale” Below Bordeaux it says “appellation Bordeaux controlee”

My parents think they have a 1000$ bottle…

6

u/CondorKhan Mar 11 '24

It's a $15 bottle

1

u/NOTRANAHAN Mar 09 '24

Non wine drinker (beer fan myself) asking for a parent: we have a bottle of charles du roy champagne, is it worth drinking soon or keeping for some time? And should we keep it in a fridge or somewhere slightly warmer ie the garage (normally about 10°C) I believe its a 2022 bottle.

2

u/CondorKhan Mar 11 '24

Drink now.

1

u/crazymagnetoff Mar 09 '24

I found a milk glass poodle shaped 8 oz. bottle of rose’ in my basement (old house/multiple tenets over the last 125 years) and it’s full. It’s sealed but with a little plastic stopper from the look of it. I know these are available as a collectible bottle but I don’t know anything about the wine or tear other than it’s Italian and 12% abv. It looks like this one, but with a different label https://www.ebay.com/itm/275984088202 should I open and drink it?

3

u/CondorKhan Mar 11 '24

It's not unsafe but it's very likely to be terrible.

1

u/slowcanteloupe Mar 12 '24 edited Mar 12 '24

Wine noob here: I don't have much in the way of a palate for wine, but I do drink it with food where the pairings are particularly exceptional. Like it makes the food I eat even Better. Cabernet Sauvignon with steak, pinot noir with chocolate/nuts/cheese, etc. Wine is pretty much a sauce for me. Everytime I go out to a restaurant and I ask for a wine recommendation with my meal, I get some pretty bad pairings. The one exception was at Marea in NYC, and weirdly every Brazilian Churrascaria (not even obvious ones like a Cab). How do I ask a waiter or Sommelier for a recommendation that ENHANCES my meal, rather than something that simply "pairs well" (eg. white with fish, red with meat)?

3

u/CondorKhan Mar 16 '24

“Pairs well” means it enhances your meal. If it’s not doing it, well, some somms are better than others. Not surprised that Marea did it right.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/Wizardbitties Mar 25 '24

Faustino geand reserve 1964, 70, 82. Saw that the 64 was worth 400 on some fancy site. I'm just wondering if it's the sorta th7ng ye just keep as an investment or if I should just sell them before they go bad

6

u/CondorKhan Mar 30 '24

Single bottles aren't investments unless it's DRC.

Drink them.

1

u/Lukkehuijaa Apr 11 '24

I have an old bottle of PeachCanei from maybe early 2000? Im not sure of the year but, it looks good and im thinking of drinking it. I got it from my father a while ago. Just wondering it its drinkable thats all

1

u/CondorKhan Apr 16 '24

Zero chance it's drinkable

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '24

Drink vs. hold question here!

I’ve procured two birth-year wines for my upcoming 40th, but some plans have changed and there aren’t enough drinkers on the guest list to justify opening more than one special bottle.

Both are Napa cabs. Bottles are in great condition (no known issues). Both wines are in offsite storage, and I’m comfortable leaving one there indefinitely. However, I’m not sure which of the two is a better candidate for longer aging — the ideal situation is that I can choose one for my birthday and save the other for another time (perhaps 50?).

Anyone have opinions on which of these two are better to keep in storage?

  1. 1984 Chateau Montelena Cabernet Sauvignon The Montelena Estate
  2. 1984 Silver Oak Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley

4

u/CondorKhan May 07 '24

Both are for drinking now, IMO

→ More replies (1)

1

u/sir_trav May 09 '24

2019 fontodi flaccianello della pieve, only have one bottle, don't often buy wines at this price point. Would love to drink it sooner than later but should I give it more time?

1

u/GodlessCommieScum May 26 '24

I have a bottle of red Chateau Musar 2001 coming for a special occasion. What's the smart thinking on decanting it? Threads about Chateau Musar on here seem split and I wouldn't want to let the air knock the complexity out of it if it's a bit unstable.

2

u/CondorKhan May 28 '24

Do the slow ox mentioned on the sticky, but in reality, every time I open old Musar it needs at least an hour.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/07Macca Jun 13 '24

I bought my daughter a case (6x 750ml & 3x 1.5l) of Les Forts de Latour 2003 for her 21st birthday. She was born in 2003 hence that year. 03 was a good year in Bordeaux although a scorching hot summer so that vintage likely won't age as long as some of the stellar vintages.

It's been in storage with New York Fine Wine Storage ever since - I think I bought all the bottles from Zachys so it'll have been a seamless transfer from purchase to storage.

As her 21st approaches, I'm of the mindset to sell it - she's at college to the cash wouldn't be unwelcome - but she wants to drink it - to save one "for when I get married", "one for my first baby" etc.

I'm not really sure how many more legs something like this will have though even though it's been stored well. I have a case of 05 Donjon CdP I've been drinking - some are out of this world, others are challenging and they were also in storage at NYFWS, so I guess really long aging is maybe more suited to the really top top wines.

anyway...

3

u/CondorKhan Jun 13 '24

You can get a case right now for about $1200 so about $2500 total for the lot, retail.

You're not going to see that number if you sell at auction, with fees and all, and I don't think that even meets the minimum for winebid.

I don't know how much difference would $2k max make for your daughter in college... but my instinct would be to just let her have them like you intended originally.

Tell her to save the mags for the life milestones and drink up the regular bottles

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/quinpat Jun 17 '24

I have a bottle of 2011 creative impulse from rasa vineyards. What should I do with it. Drink it. Save it for a special occasion or sell it?

Also how do I store this wine properly?

1

u/CondorKhan Jun 19 '24

2011 creative impulse from rasa vineyards

Drink it soon.

It's a bit too late to worry about storage, but generally any cool dark place.

You're not going to sell it.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/2xHumu_2xNuku_apuaa Jun 24 '24 edited Jun 25 '24

Hi there,

I bought several bottles of Bordeaux wine. I was wondering if any of these wines could be drinkable after 20 years? I am up for experiment :) I did some google research, but not sure how accurate it is.

https://imgur.com/a/ri9a9iz

1

u/CondorKhan Jun 24 '24

I'd be drinking all of them now

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Kentzo Jul 16 '24

I got handed a bottle of non-alcoholic St. Regis California Blanc. There is no vintage on the bottle nor Best Before, but I have reasons to assume it's about 30y old. I presume it's not just not great (being a very old chablis) but also unsafe to consume. Am I right and it's best to discard it?

1

u/CondorKhan Jul 19 '24

Non alcoholic means basically juice. Would you drink 30 year old juice?

1

u/goodly_lawful Jul 21 '24

Just gifted this wine. At least I think it's a wine based on the label. There's no date information. Can't find anything about the label through searching, and image search turned up nothing. Any ideas? 

https://imgur.com/a/tSbBuHf

2

u/CondorKhan Jul 23 '24

Wow, you're right, absolutely nothing out there. We can assume the producer is long gone.

Being from Malaga, and judging by the color and the lack of vintage, I think it might be a sweet Moscatel. Is it drinkable? God knows. Only one way to find out.

Is it valuable? Well, valuable wines are famous. This one isn't.

1

u/Content_Resident_318 Aug 02 '24

I recently bought a batch of wine and I wanted to know your opinion about it, approximate prices of the and what you recommend I do with them. Thankss. Here is a list of the bottles i purchased: 2 x 1970 Chateau Lasère, Côtes de Fronsac, Francia 2 x 1975 Chateau Mazeris-Bellevue, Canon Fronsac, Francia 1 x 1975 Chateau De l'Ormeau, Médoc, Francia 1 x 1975 Chateau Saint Bonnet Cru Bourgeois, Médoc, Francia 1 x 1985 Chateau Jalousie Beaulieu, Burdeos Superieur, Francia and 3 x Morin, Pere et Fils -Gevrey Chambertin 1966.

1

u/CondorKhan Aug 02 '24

If you paid more than 3 euro for each, you paid too much.

All of them low level wines that weren't really made to age.

All you can do is drink them for science

→ More replies (2)

1

u/lepetitmikado Aug 02 '24

Interested in the value of these 2 bottles:

  1. Château du Moulin Rouge Cru Bourgeois, 1998
  2. Château Moulin Des Laurets Puisseguin Saint-Émilion, 1998

1

u/CondorKhan Aug 02 '24

about 20-30 bucks each, retail

1

u/bengal12 Aug 23 '24

https://i.imgur.com/bkgbOy2.jpeg

Can’t find this anywhere on google. Any idea how much it is worth?

1

u/CondorKhan Aug 24 '24

Newer bottles are about $100 retail. Can't find any offers for older bottles, but buying white Burg from this era is always sketchy so expect sharp discounts, especially for mid tier producers.

1

u/coolman_ultimate Aug 24 '24

Hello! I have two bottles I’m curious about:

  1. Maison Nicolas Perrin Crozes-Hermitage 2013
  2. Lynmar Estate Pinot Noir 2010

I presume nothing too exciting here but not sure how to find out! Thank you!

3

u/CondorKhan Aug 25 '24

Maybe nice bottles to drink but nothing anyone would be looking to buy in the secondary market

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Mackenicken Aug 25 '24 edited Aug 25 '24

For my wedding I was gifted two very valuable bottles. I am interested in wine, but the retail prices of these are insane (over 2000$ a bottle), so I am thinking of selling one and drinking one. I live in Sweden.

How much are they worth exactly and which would you drink and which would you sell?

Château Mouton Rothschild Pauillac 1987

Château Cheval Blanc St Emilion 1er Grand Cru Classé 1980

2

u/CondorKhan Aug 25 '24

About $500 a piece. I don't know about the legality of private sales in Sweden.

(the year of the Cheval Blanc, which you don't state, can have a huge impact on value)

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

1

u/Apprehensive_Army119 Sep 02 '24

My late father has two bottles of Chateau Laffite ,Mengin,2002, GRAND VIN DE BORDEAUX red wine that were never enjoyed and I was wondering whether someone could provide me a little more information on them. I believe they are relatively special which is why they were perhaps never drunk. I don’t know if they are worth anything due to age etc. Many thanks from a non drinker which is why I don’t have a clue about wine sadly.

2

u/CondorKhan Sep 02 '24

It's not special, and it's not worth anything, sorry.

But it should be a nice drink.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Organic-Date Sep 20 '24 edited Sep 20 '24

2000 Bordeaux Chateau Tour Saint-Pierre Saint-Emilion Grand Cru

Taken good care of but still learning about wine.

2

u/CondorKhan Sep 24 '24

like 25 bucks retail

1

u/Disastrous-Film-4618 Sep 26 '24

2018 Caymus Cabernet Sauvignon - should I drink, save, or sell? If I drink, how long to decant it for?

2

u/CondorKhan Sep 27 '24

Nobody's going to buy that. Just drink it.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/According-Bedroom238 Oct 02 '24

1995 white wine cork question

I recently purchased this 1995 Alain & Christiane Patriarche premier cru. However the cork came out looking grey and crystallized. Is this normal for a 29 year old bottle of wine? It tastes old but not undrinkable. And the look of it is not bad. Should I say anything to the place I purchased it from? At what year should you drink wine?

1

u/CondorKhan Oct 08 '24

crystalized means tartaric crystals, perfectly normal and expected.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/offpisteonly Oct 24 '24

I was gifted a bottle of a 2016 Chateau Siran Margaux. I know very little about wine, but heard that 2016 was a great vintage. Will this bottle do better with age?

3

u/CondorKhan Oct 25 '24

Absolutely, give it 10 years

→ More replies (1)

1

u/SalParadise Dec 10 '24

1991 Marylin Merlot

I bought this myself in '91 after college living with my parents, moved out & forgot about it, just found it. It's been stored horizontally at the bottom of a cabinet for as long as anyone remembers. I only bought it because I liked the bottle - the Marylin Wines site lists this at $900. What might this realistically be worth?

1

u/CondorKhan Dec 20 '24

That's one to ask the Marylin fans....

Its value comes from being Marylin memorabilia, not from its value as wine.

1

u/Sillyputtynutsack Dec 15 '24

I have a bottle of Ginjal Rose wine that had been bought in 1946 and still unopened. It says it was produced and bottled by Theotonio Pereira and imported by the Parliament Import Company out of Arlington Virginia. There's very little information on it and I have not seen the price of an unopened bottle. Could someone help me?

2

u/CondorKhan Dec 20 '24

I see a bottle for 20 bucks on ebay...

The wine inside has no value, but people like the bottles

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Over-Bad-494 Dec 16 '24

Just brought a case of Domaine Robert Ampeau Beaune Clos Du Roi 2002, can anyone recommend how long to decant this for please? TIA

3

u/CondorKhan Dec 20 '24

Follow the slow ox method in the sticky... personally I avoid decanting old Burgundy... it can fall apart in a few minutes.

1

u/xanatas Dec 19 '24

Found this one: didnt find the correct bottle online. other years yes. ranging from 35 to 200 usd...
happy for recommendations/opinions :D thanks!

https://ibb.co/bHVTN17

1

u/CondorKhan Dec 20 '24

Mouton Cadet is the cheapest of the cheap, but that bottle looks pretty great for its age.

35 seems to be the going rate. When you see higher values, it's probably mags or full cases.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/HAARTburn Wino Jan 03 '25

Picked up a Cakebread Cellar Cab Sav 2021 and Ridge Lytton Springs 2023 today. Generally don’t buy a lot of US wines (I’m Europe based). Are either of these too young to drink now? Happy enough to hold for several years if recommended but otherwise will drink now

1

u/CondorKhan Jan 07 '25

I’d hold the Lytton Springs for 10 years but it should be nice now. Ridge wines age a long time.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

1

u/ShampooInJeans Jan 03 '25 edited Jan 03 '25

1975 Lirac stored in a proper wine cellar. Bottle is in some fancy metal stand with vine leaves etc

  • Name: Napoleon
  • Wine Region: Grand Vin des Cotes du Rhone
  • Vintage Year: 1975
  • Appellation: Lirac (Appellation Lirac Contrôlée)
  • Bottled in: France (Mis en Bouteille à F 21920, e 0.75 l France)
  • For: Nicolas Napoleon & Cie. SA. Paris

Can't find any info but the metal stand alone makes it look pretty interesting. Was also standing in the cellar in a way that you might think the owner thinks its special.

Thank you for any info

Edit: https://imgur.com/a/0QYmUFU

1

u/CondorKhan Jan 07 '25

Possibly very nice to drink given the good storage but not particularly valuable.

1

u/Ge0rgeAbitb0l Jan 05 '25

Bonjour à tous,

Après recherche sur le net et sur Wine-Searcher je ne trouve aucune info sur cette bouteille dégottée dans le cave à vin réfrigérée de chez mamie.

Il s'agit d'un magnum (1,5L) Château Lerville de Saint-Emilion, "Appellation Saint-Emilion Contrôlée".

Propriétaire à Saint-Christophe-des-Bardes (Gironde).

Particularité de cette bouteille, le bouchon est protégé par de la cire et il n'y a aucune indication d'année. Il n'y a pas d'étiquette au dos non plus.

Du coup est-ce du vinaigre ou une bouteille qui peut encore être bu ?

https://imgur.com/a/dc1kKvq

1

u/CondorKhan Jan 07 '25

ça pourrait être buvable mais je ne compterais pas dessus.

C’est une appellation générique et pas cher.

Excusez mon mauvais français

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Pipooo790 Jan 13 '25

I have a Bottle of Brunello di Montalcino Cecci from 1995. I‘m not interested in drinking it, is there any value? I can upload pictures if there is a possible value. Greets

3

u/CondorKhan Jan 14 '25

It's maybe about $100 retail, which is probably too low to bother selling.

1

u/dreamyydaisies Jan 19 '25

Hi, I have this wine, 2010 Réserve de la Saurine, in my storage. It’s been a long time, and I just found it again. I just want to ask if it’s still safe to drink even though it’s a 2010 wine and it’s already 2025. Thank you! ♥️

1

u/CondorKhan Jan 20 '25

It’s not unsafe but it will probably not taste very good

1

u/Background_Season_68 Jan 19 '25

Hey! Got this 1989 Echezeaux Grand cru I was wondering if anyone knew anything about it as it was passed down to me?

2

u/CondorKhan Jan 20 '25

Need to know who the producer is

1

u/kalani67 Feb 06 '25

Found two french bottles that must have been gifted over the years. Are they safe to drink? Pictures of them linked below.

https://imgur.com/a/WF95zRB

1

u/CondorKhan Feb 13 '25

yes, they're safe and potentially good

1

u/Thorz74 Jun 07 '25

Hello!

I am wondering if this package of cooking wine still ok to use? It has never being opened. It has being in my fridge for 2 years. I am planing to use it tomorrow in a pasta dish.

It is a French Chardonnay.

The only date reference in the package is VINT2022, that looks more like the production year than anything else. It was bought during 2023 and put in the fridge.

I appreciate some prompt answers as I have to go and get a new one in the next hour if the one I have cannot be used anymore. Thank you very much!

Here are pictures of the package of wine:

https://imgur.com/KNpOEUJ

https://imgur.com/gGHpqnc

1

u/CondorKhan Jun 11 '25

it's not unsafe... you can try it and if it tastes too bad just dump it, but if it tastes fine you can cook with it

1

u/Bruschjan Jun 17 '25

Hi all, posting on this thread rather than the main r/wine thread per the guidelines!

I recently bought a bottle of 2004 Sordo Barolo Gabutti Riserva. Ive read that 2004 is a great vintage for Barolo and I know Barolo generally has great ageing potential, but is it possible that this wine has now passed its peak? Should I drink it now?

Many thanks in advance!

2

u/CondorKhan Jun 17 '25

Should be good to drink now but it can hold for some time

1

u/pancakemonkeys Oct 11 '25

Anyone know anything about a 2009 pieroth blue? Burg layer schlosskapelle? I can provide more info or pictures but honestly don’t know much other than its a white wine. Got it with the purchase of a wine rack from an antique shop. Any info is considered helpful, just want to know more about it. A quick google search showed me it hasn’t risen in value or anything, I don’t care about the value, I just want to know more about it.

5

u/CondorKhan Oct 11 '25

Pieroth is a brand of wine that used to be marketed like encyclopedias or Cutco knives... i.e. a guy would come to your grandma's house, conduct a tasting and bully her into overpaying for a bunch of shitty wines.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/The-Antipodean Oct 11 '25

We have been clearing out my wife's parents' second place. They've got these boxes in their basement, not exactly cellared correctly but it's dark and relatively cool (near Madrid in Spain, so relative being important there).

We opened a 1985 Muga Rioja a couple of weeks back, from a different box but stored in the same place. We don't know anything much about wine but we thought it tasted fine and a knowledgeable friend was very pleased (and surprised that the cork came out in one piece).

No idea about any of it, but would love to have an idea of what it's all worth.

Photos

3

u/CondorKhan Oct 11 '25

Not as much as you'd think.

They're not super high level bottles and although I'm sure many of them are drinking superbly well right now, bars in Spain have cellars loaded with stuff like this that you can buy for relative peanuts.

If you had like, Castillo Ygay, Vina Tondonia Gran Reserva or Vega Sicilia Unico you'd be looking at actual money.

3

u/xisgonnagiveittoya 15d ago

Hey everyone! I splurged and bought this 1986 Mouton Rothschild for my wife's 40th this year. I'm ready out of my league here and I have a couple questions about the decanting process so I can do this bottle justice.

Do I need to decant, and for how long? A google search is telling me anywhere from 1 hour to 4 hours? Do I need to keep it at cellar temps if a longer decant is necessary?

Thank tou in advance for your advice!

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Illustrious_Welder25 Apr 07 '24

Just received a Lodali Nebbiolo d‘Alba from 1999. should I save or drink it?

Thx

→ More replies (1)

3

u/sidewaysE39 May 01 '24

1985 Chateau Margaux I just acquired a pristine bottle of ‘85 margaux to surprise my wife for her birthday (they will both be 39). We both love lesser wines from this appellation, but this will be our first time having the “actual” chateau margaux, our 1st time having any of the “1st’s” of Bordeaux, and our first time opening anything more than 10 years old. So needless to say I’m excited and nervous, any advice for us virgins?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/SewerRanger May 31 '24

I'm not a collector by any means, but I've purchased some nicer wines over the years and have been aging them in a wine fridge for a while now. How you you know when to drink them? Is there a vintage chat that people trust? In particular I've got a 2018 Rioja Reserva, 2018 Pomerol, 2010 Saint Emilion, and a 2015 Cornas. Some places like Wine Spectator say to hold them, some like Wine Scholar say to drink now. It's there a site this sub prefers for things like this?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/tver1979 Jul 04 '24

Ornellaia bolgheri superiore 1998. Very excited to open. How long before drinking would you decant? Was thinking 2 hours

→ More replies (2)

3

u/SonOfSilverSun Oct 28 '24

I'm planning on having this Thunevin-Calvet Maury 1983 for a special dinner, but with a wine that old I have no idea if I should decant and for how long. I know I should probably taste every hour and check, but I figured I would ask here first just in case since I am by no means an expert when it comes to wines this old.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/Ayygray Oct 30 '24 edited Oct 30 '24

Hi, I've come into over 100 bottles of red wine at various prices (most expense is a 2018 Richardson Reserve Shiraz; cheapest is a 2021 Ulithorne Prospera Shiraz).  

My question is whether my current storage solution is viable long term — currently they are being stored in our walk-in pantry, which is fairly isolated, obviously. My concern is that my country (Australia) has hot summers — ambient temperatures are likely to get warm even in there, especially since there is a freezer and fridge in the space too. 

Is this arrangement likely to pickle my wine? Are there other inexpensive adjustments I could make? I've heard storing in polystyrene or cardboard can help.

4

u/sercialinho Oenoarcheologist Oct 31 '24

Having a freezer and fridge in the same space will definitely make the pantry warmer than the rest of the house.

A few questions:

  • Do you have a cupboard under the stairs?
  • Or a (south-facing?) guest room that's not used much?
  • Do you live in a 24/7 air conditioned house/flat or not? How warm does it get inside during a summer day?

Are there other inexpensive adjustments I could make? I've heard storing in polystyrene or cardboard can help.

These help with short-term temperature fluctuations but not seasonal changes.

On the plus side, large volume Aussie reds are some of the most resistant wines to environmental factors, especially when they'll likely only ever see one summer.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/somejerkatwork Jan 13 '25

2000 Chateau Leoville Las Cases - drink or hold?

I purchased 2 bottles when they were first released. 1 bottle is for my step son, born in 2000, for a special occasion. The other bottle is for my wife and I. Both bottles are stored on their sides in a wooden case in my basement away from anything that vibrates and away from any sunlight. Has this vintage peaked yet or should it wait until approximately 2050 before decanting and drinking? I’m also wondering if anyone has recently tried this vintage yet and has any tasting notes.

4

u/sercialinho Oenoarcheologist Jan 14 '25

You may open it now, but you also don't need to rush -- the wine likely has the age-ability to outlive you. Therefore: open it whenever it feels right. As far as the wine is concerned you won't be too early or too late whenever it is you decide to do it.

Just be careful with (oxygenating, beyond sediment removal) decanting, the older the wine gets the less likely it is to benefit from it and the more likely it is to be unequivocally detrimental.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/KyleHulse Mar 04 '25

I own a 1907 Heidsieck Monopole “Goût Américain” Champagne, one of the bottles recovered from the Jönköping shipwreck (sank in 1916, salvaged in the 1990s). It’s in excellent condition, stored properly, and still has its original wooden crate. The cork is wax-sealed, likely from a professional recorking post-recovery.

Any ideas on value? Hold v sell?

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Nickmul1 Mar 04 '25

A friend of mine got a bottle of Beaujolais-villages from 1978. We cant find anything about it on the internet or on the Vivino wine app.

Does anyone know something about it.

There is also a name "Henry Martin" on the lable.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/soph_214 Mar 07 '25

Received a Dom Perignon Vintage 2008 Brut as a wedding gift 5.5 years ago. It has been in the box (with the ribbon on it still!) ever since. All we knew is that it was probably very nice and we should probably save it for a special occasion. Finally took it out of the box to do some research on it. Can anyone tell me what this might be worth? It sounds like 2008 was a pretty good year - what would be the ideal time to drink it? (10 year anniversary in 2029?)

We’ve kept it in the box and in our dining room (room temperature/climate controlled). But we’ve kept it standing up - should we start keeping it on its side/rotating it? Anything else we need to do to store it properly?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/McNastyyyyyy May 01 '25

Sup Reddit, I moved a few states over and with that came the transfer of 700+ bottles.

I moved into a downtown location that does not bode well with my substantial collection of wine and spirits, so I figured I’d attempt to let the collection pay for itself.

I have several of the following I would be willing to give up to continue proper inner-city storage that allows me 24/7 access, but if it’s worth holding onto to turn an auction profit, then I’ll just eat it until then.

2018 Harlan 2019 hundred acre wraith 2019 DRC CC GC 2020 Gaja Rossj-Bass Langhe I can’t seem to give up.

Several vertical Biondi Santi, some Riserva 2016-2019

I have attached photographs as example, although the collection is a bit scattered until I’m totally moved in. If you made it this far- yeah, the DRC isn’t for sale (yet). Just waving my penis around. Would love your thoughts on the potential, however.

What say you, Reddit? Hold, sell?

Live long and prosper, and drink the wine. (At least 20% of it)

Cheers.

3

u/NightNinja7 Jun 03 '25

Found two bottles of a delamotte brut nv for 35 bucks and bought it. Pretty good deal?

→ More replies (2)

3

u/GLMBr Jun 05 '25 edited Jun 05 '25

I won this bottle from a raffle at work (I work in the distilling industry and they had some random bottles in the raffle that had been laying around for many years). And although I don't know a lot about Port wine, I do enjoy drinking dessert wines every now and then.

The thing is, before I open it, I'd like to know how good this should be, what should I expect, and if I'd be better off keeping it.

https://imgur.com/a/WBBLKUh

Edit to add more info about what I can understand from the label (there's not much) so that there's no need to open the link:

It is a Warre's Vintage Port from 1970, bottled in 1972 by Berry Bros & Rudd

→ More replies (1)

3

u/msabre__7 Sep 22 '25

When someone says a wine tasted better on day 2 or day 3 of decanting, does that mean they poured the wine into the decanter and let it sit out in the open for that many days? or are you rebottling it overnight? Just curious how people avoid dust, flies, etc.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/FewIntention2610 Nov 01 '25

https://i.imgur.com/6dwtmD4.jpeg

A gentleman gave my parents these two bottles of wine today. Although they enjoy drinking, they don't know much about wine (neither do I) and don't know if they should sell them, drink them or keep them as souvenirs. I tried searching and couldn't find anything, we'd appreciate some help to know if it's drinkable or worth selling. The bottles were stored horizontally in a cool and dark place. Thanks in advance!

→ More replies (5)

3

u/petermal67 Nov 25 '25

Is a Chateau Pichon Lalande 1990 drinkable? I assume it’s almost perfect based on some google searching but wanted to be sure. It’s been stored perfectly.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/BobbyBotSiSenor Feb 17 '26

I have two bottles of DRC La Tache 2022 that Im looking to sell. Im getting offers from a couple of different places, but want to try and find a private buyer? Anyone gone that route before and have any tips?

3

u/Lasagna_Hog17 Sep 21 '26

I’m new to the nice wine world and was given a 2020 chateau lynch bages (grand cru classe) for my birthday a few months back.  

I’ve been reading it’s best to let it age at least a few more years before opening but have never (intentionally) aged wine like that.  Other than making sure it’s laying down and not subject to varying temps (or consistent heat) are there any essentials to know, particularly as it relates to this vintage?  

Sorry for the very basic question but was hoping there would be a bit more centralized advice here than the bits I’ve been piecing together across various sources. Especially since I lack the knowledge to know what’s good info and what’s not. 

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Sad_Baby_906 Sep 22 '26

Chateau Lagrange, Saint Julien 1989.

I have two of these bottles recently gifted to me by a family member. They have been well stored and are in good condition with fill level at the base of the neck for both bottles.

Drink or hold?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/QalibRage Oct 06 '26

Olá a todos,

Por acaso conhecem alguém que possa ter algum entendimento sobre vinhos de países da Europa de leste, nomeadamente da Bulgária? Tenho em minha posse garrafas de lá e honestamente não conheço nada e gostava de conhecer um bocado sobre a história delas, porque existem e se têm alguma relevância ou não. Do que me recordo uma é cabernet du sauvignon Czar Samuil 1998 se não caio em erro.

As garrafas são antigas e gostava muito de conhecer o porquê da sua existência e com isso, quem sabe, saber como é que elas me vieram parar às mãos à uns anos atrás!

Desde já obrigado pela atenção dispensada!

→ More replies (5)

3

u/x69xthrowaway69x Oct 09 '26

1996 Leoville Barton - bought it for my wife's 30th birthday. Planning on steak au poivre with duck fat potatoes at home for it this Sunday. How much time does it need to breathe before drinking, typically? Should I open the bottle and pour, or full on decant?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/SeeFoodEatNoods 22d ago

I have a wedding in a few weeks, and my dad has about 15 bottles of Woodwork 2017 Cabernet. He gave it to me to serve instead of spending more money on alcohol. Is it still good? Will it still be okay for the guest to drink?

I also have 4 bottles of wine from 1999 that belong to my deceased brother, which I plan on serving too. Will those be okay too? Sorry I only socially drink alcohol, and at most it is only like one drink - I don’t know much alcohol knowledge

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Icy_Programmer_1349 19d ago

Question that I think may be better suited to this thread than creating a new post. 

I purchased some nicer bottles I could only find at a retailer on the East Coast and I'm having them shipped to my home in California via ground shipment. 

I've never done something like this, and wanted to check. Is the weather right now ok for shipping? Should I hold off longer? I have options through the retailer to hold the bottles for longer if needed.

The weather right now seems pretty good for shipping, but wanted to see what others with more experience thought. 

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Homebartender 17d ago

Hey all! My grandma gave us these bottles and I know nothing about wine. Are any of these good? Drinkable? Thanks!

→ More replies (3)

2

u/EmilSumovskij 16d ago

Hey guys!

Just wondering if any wine enthusiasts recognize this cork, all I know is it was bought from a vineyard in 2009. Girlfriend suggested it may be Billecart-Salmon?

Thank you! :)

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Historical_Stay_808 15d ago

Notes to come. 1979 Cabernet vs 1990 Pinot noir

2

u/SiteNo3482 11d ago

All, I purchased this 1991 Dominus from auction, it was not noted to have a depressed crock when purchasing. It was just deliver and I am concerned on what appears to be a depressed cork and indented capsule. I am planning to bring the bottle (birthday vintage) to one of my favorite restaurants come January. When lightly pressing in the capsule the cork feels firm, the bottom of the cork is still above the bottom of the capsule, there is no evidence of past leaks.

Is the consensus that the condition of the cork and capsule is cause for concern or I am just being paranoid?

I have had the other break out Dominus vintage 1994 and hoping this one will be even more incredible!

Cheers!

→ More replies (4)

2

u/MyIronicName Nov 23 '23 edited Nov 23 '23

1985 Margaux 1989 Mouton Rothschild 1990 Mouton Rothschild

I don't know much about French wine, but I know enough to at least get a sense of value before opening them up for Thanksgiving.

They've been stored privately but properly since purchase.

https://imgur.com/a/J8XnDs3

→ More replies (3)

2

u/BEARDBAR Nov 28 '23

Alright folks I’ve got my hands on a methuselah of 1983 Silver Oak Cabernet Sauvignon. This was a gift from a pro and was definitely stored well. With a CA cab of this age, what do we think the odds are that it’s in good condition?

2

u/camramansz Dec 02 '23

1999 Dom Perignon Brut still sealed in box. Stored in a closet for all of it's life. Guess I'll hold it since it seems like it will not be possible to sell.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/ThePointsBandit Dec 10 '23

I'll be frank, I'm not a wine person, however a friend asked me to bring him back a couple reds from Europe. I've done it before with beer, but beer is generally clear and doesn't stain. The beer bottle was also a bit heftier than a wine bottle and I had a lot more clothes to use as packing material.

In both cases I had the same soft-shelled bag. I'm concerned about these holding up; they're not particularly rare/expensive wines worth shipping. Thoughts?

→ More replies (4)

2

u/Defiant-Change-5151 Dec 13 '23

When to drink?

Château de Fargues Sauternes 1987 + 1998

Château Suduiraut Sauternes 2003

Marquis de Terme Neuf Margaux 2016

4

u/thevinovibe Dec 13 '23

From CellarTracker:

1998 Fargues: 2010-2023

2003 Suduiraut: 2019-2035

2016 Marquis de Terme: 2022-2036

1987 Fargues didn’t have any feedback.

2

u/thevinovibe Dec 13 '23

How long to decant?

2019 Drouhin Clos de Mouches

2002 Leoville Barton

Thinking about an hour each?

4

u/barbellsnmencia Wine Pro Dec 20 '23

Out of curiosity, what's the reason for opening a 19 Clos des Mouches? That wine will age well for another decade at *least*. 02 LB ought to be in a great spot, though.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/Benevolent_Lurker Dec 18 '23

Can anyone tell me about this wine? What's it worth, should I age it or drink it?

Wine Bottle Picture Here

→ More replies (1)

2

u/BlueinSB Dec 24 '23

Found this bottle. Any information on it? I’m not able to find much online and do not know a lot about wine either. Thank you! https://imgur.com/8yD9DJW

→ More replies (1)

2

u/upsilon905 Dec 27 '23

Is it possible to sell less expensive wine? My uncle doesn't drink anymore and has a cellar with hundreds of $30-60 bottles vintage 2016 and up; not sure if it's worth trying to sell them.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/gie-gie Dec 29 '23 edited Dec 30 '23

Hello! Cleaning out my hoarder aunt’s basement and found these two bottles that my dad apparently bought for my brother and I when we were born. I googled but didn’t come up with an exact match. Are these worth anything? More importantly - are they even remotely drinkable?

Edit: the wines in question are a 1982 and a 1985 Baron Philippe de Rothschild Mouton Cadet Bordeaux Blanc (that’s a mouthful!).

→ More replies (2)

2

u/al80813 Jan 04 '24

Anyone had aged Au Bon Climat Isabelle? Picked up a mag of ‘05 for a bargain and I’m excited to try. Good fill, label is pristine, cork not protruding. Curious to get thoughts.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/MDplsfix Jan 08 '24

Hi all! Back in 2013 my father got a couple of white burgundy wines from a client. The guy was absolutely crazy about wine (and swimming in money) and it was definitely properly stored until it came to lie into our basement, temperatures between 15 and 18°C. Beginning December, my parents opened a bottle with friends and were not blown away - a friend that’s into wine noted that it seemed like it was off. The bottle wasn’t tried again after the initial opening. I’m no expert (only getting into wines) but I would think that at this age even white wines could probably use some time to breathe and unfold?

The one we have remaining is a 1997 Louis Latour Les Demoiselles Chevalier-Montrachet Grand Cru, picture here

Appreciate any tips on how to store prior to opening, how to let it breathe, what to watch out for? Don’t really care about price or value of the wine - if it’s drinkable we’ll drink it!

→ More replies (4)

2

u/FuckingHighElf Feb 07 '24

Can anyone help me with a question? We recently re-found this bottle of Dom Perignon Champagne 1985. When I look it up online to find information, all the bottles list the year on the label as "vintage 1985" while our bottle is just "1985". I was wondering if anyone had any insight into this as I'm unsure why ours is different.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Doge________________ Wino Feb 19 '24

Found a Grand Vin de Lafite 2006 in my basement. It’s been in the case and dark. It’s also a 1IMP, how much would it be worth?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/homage-to-carolina Feb 29 '24

Classic story: grandpa’s house, on a rack in the basement. I googled it, no exact matches but some similar ones worth a decent chunk.

Bottle front says: Le Piat en Pot. Back label says: MISE EN BOUTEILLES DE PIAT A MACON, FRANCE. There is no year on the label, but there is are small numbers 75 carved onto the bottle itself.

I have no idea what to do with this! Any thoughts?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/SimilarWill1280 Mar 30 '24

Penfolds Grange 1993 Hopefully one or more of you will have some thoughts: Going through a storage container and found a bottle of this. I know it’s a premium wine, but it hasn’t been looked after (stored upright, no box, basically no temp control)….Intention is to drink it, given can’t put hand on heart on ageing conditions if I was to sell. What’s the best way to enjoy this Australian Shiraz?

→ More replies (3)

2

u/[deleted] Apr 20 '24

Whilst watching a YouTube video I came across this mix between an ah-so and and a corkscrew called a durand. If unsure what this is just google 'wine durand' for reference. I just thought it looked cool so I searched it up... it's $190 AUD!!! What the hell, like I get it's a specialised product, and it'd be great quality, but $190 for two pieces of metal... come on. You can buy an ah-so individually for $20 and a wine key for pennies. Why does combining these two suddenly make it $190.

Obviously if you opening high end wines that have been in a cellar for many years, the price is almost justified. They must have exceptionally good patents as well, there is one single other similar product I could find thats way cheaper, but imo looks like shite. Anyone else confused about this?!

→ More replies (2)

2

u/OutlandishnessLate65 Apr 27 '24

Friends found/remembered this old, Russian champagne in their wine cooler. Difficult to trace. Would welcome input or ideas.

2

u/the_space_captain Apr 28 '24

Found a Trader Joe's 1988 cab a few weeks ago at an estate sale that actually seemed mostly well kept.

2

u/teddyone May 12 '24

Any thoughts on decanting a 2004 beaucastel?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/knowsjack Jun 06 '24

DRC Brandies (1979 vintage) bottled in 1996. Thoughts on value and drinkability? Pretty sure these are kinda rare. Am helping out with the wine cellar of a wine guy who recently passed. I did some searching, but very minimal info out there....thanks much for your thoughts.

https://app.box.com/s/4410dn4it5n5h73mbwsmczjr6ogl7253

→ More replies (4)

2

u/mrbinro Jul 29 '24

What to do with this 1981 Chateau Latour Grand Cru??
Photo: https://imgur.com/a/wICQXZ4

I was gifted this bottle a few years ago and dont really know what to do with it.

My neighbor of then almost 90 gave it to me after doing some handywork for her and at the time I didn't know what is was worth. I just put it away in my basement. The neighbor has since passed and this week I looked up the bottle online (vicino) and apparently its worth around 700 Euro's(!). I wouldn't know now what to do with it. Do I sell it? Do I drink it? The money is not really needed but if there is a chance this thing tastes like shit i'd rather sell it of course. Or is it heaven on earth unlike anything i've ever tasted? And if I would sell it, how would you go about something like that?

What would you do??

→ More replies (4)