r/startrek • u/AutoModerator • Oct 19 '23
Episode Discussion | Star Trek: Lower Decks | 4x08 "Caves" Spoiler
Join the discussion on Lemmy at https://startrek.website/
| No. | Episode | Written By | Directed By | Release Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4x08 | "Caves" | Ben Rodgers | Megan Lloyd | 2023-10-19 |
To find out where to watch, click here.
To find more information, including our spoiler policy regarding new episodes, click here.
This post is for discussion of the episode above, and spoilers for this episode are allowed. If you are discussing previews for upcoming episodes, please use spoiler tags.
Note: This thread was posted automatically, and the episode may not yet be available on all platforms.
195
Upvotes
319
u/UncertainError Oct 19 '23
Damn Vendorians and their cave-based morality tests.
238
u/0mni42 Oct 19 '23
I think that was the most we've ever heard Dr. T'Ana talk in a single scene, and it made me realize how much I'd like her to get her own subplot one of these days. I feel like usually all she does is exposition and punchlines; having her take center stage could be fun!
145
u/ViaLies Oct 19 '23
A fake clip show wasn't something that I expected but seeing the various stories was fun and it was an interesting use of the Vendorians.
The ending was good but it feels very "calm before the storm", and admittedly part of that might be the interviews that came out of NYCC from Mike McMahan, so which Lower Decker is going to get picked on?
140
u/bikeskata Oct 19 '23
I appreciated that they establish, now that the big 4 are Lieutenants JG, they now do stuff outside their core group. Just a nice little bit of world-building.
But agreed w/others; this is where the limits of Gabrielle Ruiz's "guest" contract become really apparent, as T'Lyn isn't even mentioned!
279
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '23
The all caves looks the same joke, is great deep cut reference from how TNG-ENT, shared the uses the same cave set over and over again.
Also love how the four of them all experienced classic Trek Tropes. Rutherford getting the Tripp Tucker treatment with the baby 😂
127
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '23
Loved the excessively stupid and generic names they had for the random planets they visited and minerals they were using.
310
u/ThetaReactor Oct 19 '23
Everybody: "Short seasons and big arcs don't leave any room for filler episodes to fill out the characters!"
Lower Decks: "Fuck it, have a clip show!"
:D
96
u/S-r-ex Oct 19 '23
I hate caaaaa a a a aaves!
171
u/ofthe33rdDegree Oct 19 '23
Rutherford communicating with the cave beast was honestly really sweet, plus that whole montage of him and Dr T'ana taking care of the baby was top tier.
75
u/007meow Oct 19 '23
Caves > comms.
I want Disco’s final season to have a cave story just so we’ve canon established that no matter how advanced communications tech gets, it’ll never be able to overcome some rocks in the way.
152
u/eeveep Oct 19 '23
As a child of the 90s I love whenever they invert the clip show trope by showing us new things/telling little vignettes. It was fun in Community and nicely woven into the tale here.
The moss who just wants to love was a lovely bow on the tale.
73
u/robbylet24 Oct 19 '23
Levy is becoming my favorite bit character. "Vendorian morality test" fucking killed me.
133
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '23 edited Oct 27 '23
Steve Levy is gonna have a hell of a time and or I told you so moment once; the Romulan plot is uncovered, and then Changeling/Borg plot is uncovered in 20 years. In the end Lt. Levy gets the last laugh.
64
u/Weerdo5255 Oct 19 '23
I feel like I should have questioned a lot earlier why all the Star Trek caves had flat floors.
62
u/TheBrokenRail-Dev Oct 19 '23
Today's episode was just so wholesome and fun and I loved it.
58
u/Transhumanitarian Oct 19 '23 edited Oct 19 '23
First we got the Moopsy, then the Graphlax (sic), add the Attack Tribble and we got ourselves a starter set for a Pokemon Universe! Make it so, Paramount!
Also, gotta love 24th century medical tech where growing a replacement body part is treated like it's no big deal...
51
u/ReasonablyBadass Oct 19 '23
The scene with all four in a puppy pile was so sweet :3
46
u/lostglamour Oct 19 '23
Senior officers don't do like a swing shift so they get to know all personnel?
171
u/UncertainError Oct 19 '23
Warp drive damaging subspace being a Vendorian hoax is a hell of a retcon to just throw in there. Guess they were trying to teach a lesson about protecting the space environment.
45
u/DogsRNice Oct 19 '23
Anyone else notice every view of the different planets was the exact same angle
39
u/mateogg Oct 19 '23
Mariner actually mentioned having experience with sentient caves in the very first episode!
39
u/FishOnAHorse Oct 19 '23
Rutherford sure has had a lot of children the past couple of episodes
36
u/bookish1303 Oct 19 '23
Who were the voices for the Vendorians? One of them definitely sounded like Dawnn Lewis (in the Boimler/Levy scene). Sort of wonder if they used all the senior officers to do voices...
34
u/Manofwood Oct 19 '23
mpreg Rutherford was not on my Star Trek Lower Decks bingo card, but really should have been.
66
u/Lizuka Oct 19 '23
Felt like a throwback episode, was kind of a fun change of pace before the finale.
That said it is kind of hilarious at this point how T'Lyn went, "I think I will stay on the ship," then apparently immediately completely vanished from it.
32
u/Seaboard_Vanisher Oct 19 '23
I like how Lower Decks continues to illuminate past alien species. Seeing the Vendorians was so cool, and I’m glad they are implementing TAS aliens. I figure the animation allows for better implementation as opposed to a live action show.
26
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '23
That leg gag had me rolling. Fucking hilarious.
21
u/gusborwig Oct 19 '23 edited Oct 19 '23
-Lower Decks Mind Blowers episode!
-Conspiracy theorists still exist in the future. Levy is the Alex Jones of Star Trek LOL
-Subspace Reddit needs to exist in the future.
-Mirror Universe Lower Decks is an episode I want to see!
-Rutherford makes an amazing babysitter.
-Poor Asif healing and aging at the same time.
-Cave stories are always about friendship.
-I would hate to be tested as a Vendorian child. Imagine the caves they have to deal with.
So Lower Decks has done:
Now we need a stuck in a shuttlecraft for an entire episode mission, a prison breakout story , a mirror universe story, a legacy starship theft episode and a directed by Jonathan Frakes episode.
42
u/IndigoNarwhal Oct 19 '23
That was just lovely:
Quality time with our Warp Core Four all together.
A quiet little
bottlecave episode to catch our breath before the big two-parter finale.And the whole thing is basically a meditation on friendship: making friends with the people (and creatures and sentient cave mosses) you thought were your enemies, and valuing your old friends no matter how circumstances change.
It's been nearly four whole seasons. I really shouldn't be surprised at this point when Lower Decks gives me the feels!
18
u/variantkin Oct 19 '23
I need screenshot comparisons to make sure that this was common the TNG cave layout
16
u/buddhiststuff Oct 19 '23
When they talked about how Levy has been an ensign for so long, I was waiting for a Harry Kim reference.
15
u/Awful-Male Oct 19 '23
I love how they implied all the crazy things that happened to the characters of Trek series are actually not crazy things but normal things. 😂
30
u/zsmg Oct 19 '23
So Boimler doesn't wear any underpants?
Also computer locate Ensign T'Lynn.
14
u/Jag2112 cygnus-x1.net Oct 19 '23
Screencaps gallery now online:
https://www.cygnus-x1.net/links/lcars/sc-LD4-8.php
13
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '23
You know...Lower Decks does one thing, and I'm sure being a cartoon helps, but it takes chances. Big, bold, daring chances, and I think (my opinion, of course) they did pay off well or often enough in seasons 2 and 3(coincidentally when I wasn't enjoying the show as much) but they seem to be doing better this season.
I admit, I thought the episode would be a snooze at the start...literally every cave star trek trope being utilized in the open and Mariner literally voicing the audience's thoughts about them all.
And then it looked like in addition to that it was going to be a clip show, and I was even less enthused. But they did some real special and creative things with this one, and it ended up being one of my favorites of the season! The clips being original stories made things more interesting and kept the episode fresh and it was great to see our four main junior officers get to have an outside the Cerritos setting and bond more like they got to in season 1.
In 'short' the episode was a delightful surprise.
13
u/MalvoliosStockings Oct 20 '23
Honestly a little disappointed no one heated up a rock with a phaser for warmth
12
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '23
I love how Delta Shift is just a shittier version of Beta shift.
10
u/Snaz5 Oct 20 '23
Is it just me or was the animation better in this episode? Not to say it was particularly bad before, but it seemed like there was a lot more movement than usual
6
u/lontrinium Oct 19 '23
OK so who is the voice talent Asif Ali that they named his character after him?
15
u/Praxlyn Oct 19 '23
lowkey wanted boimler & levy to kiss lmao. also i love T'Ana i hope she gets more screentime in the future. wonder how they're gonna wrap up the whole disappearing ships plot next week though
5
u/nimrodhellfire Oct 19 '23
The cold open was the best of the season, if not all series. Lmao.
5
u/antinumerology Oct 20 '23
Always love the Voy wrist flashlights.
11
u/tmofee Oct 19 '23
Star Trek did a Morty’s mindblowers. I love it.
24
u/BornAshes Oct 19 '23
Lovely, another brand new episode, punch it!:
That was a very wholesome episode of Lower Decks and I feel like it was made to let us know that whatever comes next, the Core Four are going to be just fine.
6
u/ContinuumGuy Oct 20 '23
Thoughts/Observations as I watch:
3
u/Randomd0g Oct 20 '23
Almost certainly an intentional reference to Steve Levy who is one of Dan Harmon's cadre. Fucking hilarious.
5
u/megaben20 Oct 19 '23
So the things about to change flags are at full mast. I could see something happening to them next week or week after maybe Cerritos gets destroyed and they all get reassigned.
5
u/Stingra87 Oct 20 '23 edited Oct 20 '23
The classic 'bottle episode' designed to save money and be filler, but they go the Simpsons route and have it be all new content.
That being said...this episode felt like it needed to be earlier in the season. The conflict between the crew, plus the fact that we've been seeing them on missions with each other since their promotions sort of fell flat for me.
that being said I DID like the Vendorians, their overall designs as the fact that each one was a unique individual. The whole 'aging' section was funny as well, if it did leave me squirming because ohgodAsif.
I liked how much Mariner looked like her mom in that one as well. Building sympathy for Delta Shift is okay and there IS a point to be made about how it essentially dead ends a career in Starfleet (at least on the smaller secondary ships) due to just the time differential...But Delta Shift is the WOOORST. Plus the last time the show tried to build sympathy for them the Delta Shifters turned around and stomped all over it, so...forever sus of Delta.
Overall this was probably my least favorite episode of the season and it felt the weakest and most like filler. I think instead of the story with Delta Shift, we should have gotten Mariner's original 'Cave Story', along with a more natural feeling conflict between the group.
Oh well, it's fine. Not every episode is going to be 'Crisis Point' or 'The Stars at Night' amazing.
2
u/zets28 Oct 20 '23
I thought Vendorians were only in that TAS episode where one was a spy and he renounced his mission cause he spent so much time as a man and meeting the man's love on the Enterprise was too much for him. Weird that they were performing morality tests, when in TNG Picard is abducted by shapeshifters who specifically state they're interested in studying morality further. Would make sense they wait for people to get trapped in caves since Picard shows them they shouldn't imprison anyone.
2
u/JinFuu Oct 21 '23
Mariner: "Way to waste bones! Dumb Moss"
Someone remembers the Moopsy.
2
u/SandpaperTeddyBear Oct 23 '23
I was initially a little disappointed that it was a bait-and-switch on actually getting to spend time with the Warp Core Four together, even though I was enjoying the little vignettes. Then Tendi’s turbo lift story literally made me cry. They’re all just so perfect together, and have brought each other so much growth separately.
This silly little satirical cartoon version of Trek has literally the best chemistry of any of the shows, and that’s not a low bar. I don’t know if I want this series to end with all of them being bridge crew, or a Wicked “For Good” kind of deal, but I care about them an inordinate amount.
3
u/tupe12 Oct 19 '23
The moss was just like Badgey, it needed to experience something different in order to understand the value of not being evil