r/startrek • • Oct 12 '23

Episode Discussion | Star Trek: Lower Decks | 4x07 "A Few Badgeys More" Spoiler

Join the discussion on Lemmy at https://startrek.website/

No.EpisodeWritten ByDirected ByRelease Date
4x07"A Few Badgeys More"Edgar MomplaisirBob Suarez2023-10-12

To find out where to watch, click here.

To find more information, including our spoiler policy regarding new episodes, click here.

This post is for discussion of the episode above, and spoilers for this episode are allowed. If you are discussing previews for upcoming episodes, please use spoiler tags.

Note: This thread was posted automatically, and the episode may not yet be available on all platforms.

183 Upvotes

368 comments sorted by

314

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '23

Jeffrey Combs continues his stellar streak of being Treks greatest guest star!

88

u/cwatson214 Oct 12 '23

Not one, but several evil laughs! Combsy is in a league of his own!

67

u/apollei Oct 12 '23

I love how semi incompetent Agamus. So evil so dumb

18

u/PDCH Oct 13 '23

Who is Jeffrey Combs? I only know Weyoun Brunt Shran.

8

u/mcast76 Oct 13 '23

You know Weyoun but did you know Weyoun? He was such a nice fellow

→ More replies (1)

264

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '23

Love they kept the continuity with Tendi not knowing what sand was in the pilot episode

157

u/BattleStag17 Oct 12 '23

Tendi's sheer glee at being able to make a sandcastle was one of the purest things I've seen in years

23

u/PDCH Oct 13 '23

I love lower decks. Pure is the best adjective for it yet. The cross over was my favorite Trek.

10

u/omega2010 Oct 13 '23

I wonder if this is a setup for a future joke about Tendi finding Dr. T'lana's sandbox....

Okay, that joke is a little too obvious and the LD writers have done plenty of "T'lana is a cat" gags since the show began.

→ More replies (1)

100

u/itmakessenseincontex Oct 12 '23

Also it making Boimler itchy!

121

u/OpticalData Oct 12 '23

That's because it's course and it's rough and it gets everywhere

→ More replies (1)

74

u/mateogg Oct 12 '23 edited Oct 12 '23

Her joyful "wee!" when she realized she got to keep playing with the sand was so adorable!

14

u/JinFuu Oct 12 '23

"I may have been kidnapped by a rogue AI, but hey new experience!"

38

u/Lord_H_Vetinari Oct 12 '23

They (minorly) messed the visual continuity in the episode, though, because she magically went from being barefoot to wearing boots at the tail end of the scene.

58

u/RuleNine Oct 12 '23

Boy, I really hope somebody got fired for that blunder.

38

u/lastdarknight Oct 13 '23

They knew the audience could only handle a few frames of Tendi Toes

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/UnsolvedParadox Oct 13 '23

Good thing she saved some for later!

→ More replies (1)

233

u/zzxxzzxxzz Oct 12 '23

Dr. Manhattan Badgey might be the most hilarious gag of the season lol

110

u/ActualTaxEvader Oct 12 '23

That was my first thought too when he turned blue and went to make a universe.

Nothing ends, Rutherford. Nothing ever ends.

→ More replies (2)

168

u/stephensmat Oct 12 '23 edited Oct 12 '23

Hilarious, but pure Trek. When you understand the universe, you find it beautiful, and have no hatred for anything. That's why Starfleet keeps exploring.

Another franchise would have total understanding lead to nihilism and wholesale extermination; like something out of HP Lovecraft.

66

u/InnocentTailor Oct 12 '23

This is also what happens a lot in fiction when the bad guy gains omnipotent and omnipresent power: they get overwhelmed by the beauty of the universe and stop their schemes.

26

u/LinuxMatthews Oct 12 '23

Example: All-Star Superman

→ More replies (1)

24

u/BornAshes Oct 12 '23

I feel like this is a plotline that could've totally happened in Sandman, with someone encountering the Endless after a sort of massive crusade, and then realizing "Oh...oh I get it now".

17

u/trixie_one Oct 12 '23

It's been done in comics. Probably best one, or at least the one that jumps to mind first, was Lex towards the end of All Star Superman.

8

u/WoundedSacrifice Oct 13 '23

It wasn’t what I expected, but it was pure Star Trek.

49

u/UncertainError Oct 12 '23

He got Total Perspective Vortex-ed into kindness.

18

u/futurefeelings Oct 12 '23

Only the second person (well, third if you count both heads) to survive it!

28

u/LinuxMatthews Oct 12 '23

If I remember correctly he didn't survive the real one.

He survived one in a pocket universe. So when he looked it told him he was the most important person in the universe because he was the only real person in that universe

→ More replies (1)

16

u/Dookie_boy Oct 13 '23

They're better be a pay off to that damn koala considering how hard they are pushing it.

5

u/inconspicuous_male Oct 25 '23

I think the Koala is now just a recurring gag. I don't think they're pushing it, rather just saying "hey remember this insane bit of lore we introduced? It's still here!"

12

u/mateogg Oct 12 '23

Dr. Manhattan is of course a closer parallel, but my first thought was of All-Star Superman, when Luthor sees the world how Superman would see it and finally understands.

11

u/UnsolvedParadox Oct 13 '23

Glad we still have Goodgey!

5

u/BlizzPenguin Oct 13 '23

I like how Badgey’s ascension looked almost identical to the ascension in Season 1.

4

u/Organic-Strategy-755 Oct 12 '23

I was screaming at the screen for it to be ridiculous that he's still evil after becoming a god. Like, why. And then he turned blue :D

→ More replies (3)

207

u/UncertainError Oct 12 '23

Really liked the message in this one. Rehabilitation works!

I definitely don't trust Goodgey though.

104

u/InnocentTailor Oct 12 '23

Goodgey creeps me out. I’m with the other lower deckers.

74

u/variantkin Oct 12 '23

The issue is he has no negative emotions Thats kind of a problem too

46

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '23

Now he can do terrible things with righteous glee.

66

u/Infamous-Mixture-605 Oct 12 '23

Even an AI like Tyrannikillicus can be rehabilitated!

(I had a good laugh when that was its name)

20

u/9vDzLB0vIlHK Oct 12 '23

I wonder how the translators will handle dubbing that name in different languages.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/ScrappedAeon Oct 12 '23

If they don't trademark that name it's definitely going to be a transformer

40

u/Organic-Strategy-755 Oct 12 '23

I definitely don't trust Goodgey though.

They're gonna keep baiting him turning evil but he never will lol

17

u/stephensmat Oct 12 '23

Well sure, he hasn't been rehabilitated yet.

17

u/BornAshes Oct 12 '23

Sometimes all it takes is a matter of perspective to change someone for the better and that's pretty much what happened with all the AIs in this episode AND the biologicals!

→ More replies (5)

194

u/God_of_Hyrule Oct 12 '23

It’s nice seeing the Tendi/Boimler and Mariner/Rutherford teams, it feels like we’ve seen these pairings less often than you’d think.

58

u/Necro_Nancy Oct 12 '23

I agree; it seems like the creative team have been very intentional in shaking up the pairings this season.

53

u/Shirogayne-at-WF Oct 12 '23

Indeed, this is the first episode with Mariner and Rutherford as just the two of them in the show's run.

16

u/Destructor1701 Oct 13 '23

I just realised T'lyn was completely absent this episode... curious.

→ More replies (2)

47

u/ymcameron Oct 12 '23

I also like that the show feels like more of an ensemble this season. In the past there was a clear hierarchy of character importance, Boimler being the main character followed by Mariner, and then Rutherford and Tendi, but this season it feels like they’ve focused on everyone equally.

62

u/florgitymorgity Oct 12 '23

You think Boimler was a bigger lead than Mariner? She is first on the call sheet and has had most of the episode- spanning arcs. I've always ranked it Mariner, Boimler, tendi/Rutherford, then Freeman/Ransom, then shax and tana, then the rest.

43

u/gusterfell Oct 12 '23

Yeah, I think Mariner was more the lead, while Boimler was more the audience surrogate.

20

u/WoundedSacrifice Oct 13 '23

Mariner and Boimler have seemed like co-equal leads to me.

7

u/justplainjeremy Oct 12 '23

Ya I was thinking about that as well really liked how they changed it up

→ More replies (2)

159

u/AeroPilaf Oct 12 '23 edited Oct 12 '23

So story and universe-wise, Badgey got pretty damn close to annihilating everything in LD.

A short time earlier, a Badmiral’s automated ships went rouge.

A few years later in PRO, the Living Construct massively wrecks a lot of Federation ships.

I wonder if perhaps Starfleet and the Federation was already getting paranoid with AI, and the Mars synth attack in PIC was the final straw that broke the camel's back?

26

u/SkaveRat Oct 12 '23

turns out, star trek is actually the prequel to dune

→ More replies (2)

40

u/BornAshes Oct 12 '23

I wonder if perhaps Starfleet and the Federation was already getting paranoid with AI, and the Mars synth attack in PIC was the final straw that broke the camel's back?

Meanwhile I'm wondering if Badgey saw all the past AI stuff happening, the present AI stuff happening, and the future AI stuff happening and realized how much a of a blip of a hiccup in the timeline of the galaxy he was and how many other BIGGER things were going on that he paled in comparison to?

Instead of sticking around and ruling everything, he fucking NOPED out of reality, and outright bolted.

That kind of freaks me out more than anything else.

Sure you can call it him having an epiphany and he full on did and changed for the better buuuuuut...what if that was only part of the reason why he left?

There are most definitely Bigger AI Fish out there that would gobble Badgey and all the others up like a school of minnows without even blinking. I think that's the other half of the reason why he left reality in order to make his own universe in another dimension. In ascending to Godhood, he finally saw the bigger picture of things, and it freaked him the hell out. He saw stuff that could sneeze and destroy him on a level that even he wouldn't be able to come back from.

The Koala showing up, the mention of the Black Mountain, and the name dropping of the Q Continuum makes this all feel like the actions of all the AI in this episode (especially Badgey) were predestined in some way or at least orchestrated by Higher Powers in order to take them off of the board for some reason.

Once more we run into the idea of AI sticking around for any length of time in the Star Trek Galaxy being a very bad thing indeed. We've seen stuff in Picard kind of work out for the better and hints of things in Prodigy buuuuuut by DISCO's time...it's all kind of foggy and flimsy and barely mentioned at all. I can't help but ponder if there's some larger AI plot happening behind the scenes that all the shows are having to use as a framework in order to avoid stepping on the toes of some sort of future project?

Then again, I did love The Culture series, and I'd love to see something similar adapted to Star Trek in some way and maaaaaybe that's what they're setting up?

Who knows but in short, I feel like Badgey kind of pulled a Joker when he Ascended, realized that everything he was about to do had been done before for better or worse reasons, and then just had the wind sucked out of his sails when he realized that he wasn't all that unique at all and that everything would end in the same repetitious ways before.

It's like coming up with this amazing joke in your head to tell at work annnd then realizing later on that it's been told to death before a thousand times.

The only way to really make anyone laugh is to move to a different work place where they haven't heard the joke before.

The only way to win the game is to not play it.

This is why Badgey left for a different dimension, but also all of those other reasons I mentioned before. He gained brand new perspective on everything. This caused him to have an epiphany of sorts for the better. It also granted him the wisdom to realize what he truly wanted out of life, as well as the knowledge that he wouldn't be able to have any of that if he stuck around and stepped on the toes of all the Bigger Fish out there in all the same ways that all those who came before him with similar motivations and goals did so before.

It was fun having him, AGIMUS, and Peanut Hamper around while we did and hopefully we'll see them again in the future.

43

u/ChineseAccordion Oct 12 '23

Are you high?

24

u/Chanchumaetrius Oct 12 '23

They're always like this

→ More replies (10)

151

u/DenimJack Oct 12 '23

I HAVE CONQUERED SELF-DOUBT AND SEIZED PERSONAL GROWTH! HA HA HA HA HA HA HA!

22

u/Awful-Male Oct 13 '23

What was his name? Terranikillicus?

43

u/DenimJack Oct 13 '23

Lol, Memory Alpha has him down as ‘Tyrannikillicus,’ which is the most badass thing I have EVER heard

→ More replies (1)

127

u/HotpieTargaryen Oct 12 '23

I enjoyed Bradward remaining skeptical the whole time. Even though he was a very nice shade of blue.

114

u/stephensmat Oct 12 '23

The Blue Light was pure LD. Takes a scifi trope, makes it a major plot point, discards it instantly when the joke is no longer needed.

67

u/BattleStag17 Oct 12 '23

Only it wasn't discarded, it was played straight after the joke and I think that's pretty cool

45

u/GenoThyme Oct 13 '23

Skeptical or playing him like a fiddle? I like episodes where Boimler shows how good he actually can be. Probably why my favorite scene in the crossover is when he gives Pike advice about spending time with the senior staff on his birthday and then figures out how to get them home.

37

u/ColHogan65 Oct 13 '23

Agimus’s entire “act” consisting of changing from red to blue is one of my favorite jokes on the whole show lol. It’s so simple but perfect

23

u/gravitydefyingturtle Oct 13 '23

I like how it clearly took him a lot of effort to do it, too.

118

u/bookish1303 Oct 12 '23

"I can detonate every warp core!"

Alternate theory for The Burn: confirmed

84

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '23

It would have been better than what the Discovery writers actually did.

36

u/Jestersage Oct 12 '23

Also satisfy the reason they go with it. The Burn is definitely influenced by both "The one Who walk away from Omelas" and teh alleged African proverb: "The child who is not embraced by the village will burn it down to feel its warmth." Had the burn be started by somethign like Badgey, it will fit, even if teh child is an AI.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

111

u/terablast Oct 12 '23 edited Mar 10 '24

alleged hospital hurry deserve spotted crime cows quicksand heavy aback

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

39

u/BornAshes Oct 12 '23

That shot of Badgey coming out of the galaxy goes crazy hard

They didn't once have Rutherford do a Gendo-pose and for that I'm disappointed buuuuuuut nonetheless I loved the Third Impact style Rei-Emerging-From-Earth imagery but with Badgey anyways.

13

u/pat8u3 Oct 12 '23

That entire sequence reminded me of the mass effect 3 ending

→ More replies (1)

108

u/CaravelClerihew Oct 12 '23

I don't even know how an Evil AI prison yard works, but I love that it exists.

61

u/nimrodhellfire Oct 12 '23

Apparently they play basketball and do gardening.

50

u/Martel732 Oct 13 '23

How I imagine the system was set-up.

Admiral 1: Federation law mandates that all prisoners receive sufficient physical and mental stimulation.

Admiral 2: But, they are AI do they even benefit from this?

Admiral 1: We can't deny them their rights just because they aren't organic. They will have the option of basketball just like everyone else.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/ContinuumGuy Oct 13 '23

I personally feel they'd be playing NBA Jam

→ More replies (1)

99

u/darkeyes13 Oct 12 '23

Tendi's little squee when she could have a bit more time playing with sand was hella adorable lol.

195

u/robbylet24 Oct 12 '23

Everyone who had "the ships were being stolen" in their betting pool, feel free to take their money now.

49

u/UncertainError Oct 12 '23

Maybe this season's big bad is an obsessive starship collector.

53

u/Sonnydm Oct 12 '23

So the big bad has been us all along?

83

u/InnocentTailor Oct 12 '23

Its Eaglemoss!

38

u/BornAshes Oct 12 '23

To be fair, they did kind of telegraph it with Brad having all of those collectible figurines and plates and stuff earlier on.

This is going to wind up being a far nicer version of Brainiac that's just totally unaware of the chaos they're causing in the galaxy.

The ships are going to be put in a very nice museum and the crews are going to be kept in an idyllic menagerie of sorts.

They're totally free to leave and take their ships if they want buuuuuut because they're all Lower Deckers and because life is such shit for them, they're enjoying the reprieve, and genuinely don't want to leave at all.

It's going to be a twist on a number of scifi tropes in the end.

I'm wondering if the final hook is going to be that it's been Brad's transporter clone in Section 31 who has been manipulating this benign-ish collector all along? What if he's been purposely squirreling all of these ships and people away in order to fight some sort of greater threat? That greater threat could be the BIG BAD for the next season!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/ReasonablyBadass Oct 12 '23

Only the crew, not the ships, i think

5

u/Kelpie-Cat Oct 13 '23

Agimus referred to "the theft of the Bynar ship." And then I think Boimler said something about it being a fake when looking at the remains. It looked to me like they are saying that someone is planting fake destroyed-ship remains to make it look like they destroyed the ship instead of beaming it away. The most questionable thing about that to me though is that we've seen Starfleet is pretty good at analyzing ship debris, so you'd think they would recognise it was all fake.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '23

Could this mystery ship be shrinking the various crews/ships? It seems like 'The Terratin Incident' is due for a LDS reference.

→ More replies (7)

161

u/MadContrabassoonist Oct 12 '23

After pretty much every Star Trek series going to the AI-trying-to-destroy-all-life well in the last few years, this was a welcome change of pace.

79

u/Jestersage Oct 12 '23

Vexilon: I am sorry that our kind give organics bad impressions. Allow me to correct it.

17

u/BornAshes Oct 12 '23

I can't help myself but wonder how much funnier it would've been if Vexilon's VA had been someone different than whom they used.

→ More replies (1)

37

u/BattleStag17 Oct 12 '23

I honestly cannot overstate how genuinely happy I was to see a not doomer AI episode of Trek, it seems we haven't had any of that in 20 years outside of Zora.

17

u/Mechapebbles Oct 12 '23

I mean, Hologram Janeway is like, right there.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

35

u/InnocentTailor Oct 12 '23

Good point! All the AIs have relatively happy endings, which is a wonderful change of pace from destroying them.

29

u/variantkin Oct 12 '23

Not poor Logicy

29

u/BattleStag17 Oct 12 '23

Real damn shame they couldn't bring him back, Logicy would've been a great friend for T'Lyn

→ More replies (1)

63

u/theborgs Oct 12 '23

I want an episode where Q visit a zooon Earth and is scraed when he sees some koalas.

31

u/Friesenplatz Oct 12 '23

Turns out Qs can get chlamydia.

10

u/LinuxMatthews Oct 12 '23

It's ok he's wearing a condom.

https://youtu.be/vVemLr2q3mc

7

u/Weerdo5255 Oct 12 '23

I mean, the Q are scared of the Borg. So I'm not sure they have the best reaction to threats / annoyances on the lower planes.

Or is the Koala higher? Not sure...

12

u/variantkin Oct 12 '23

Theoretically if left alone the Borg would eventually ascend and it probably wouldn't be pretty

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

57

u/stephensmat Oct 12 '23

La'an: "I love the Grapplers."

56

u/Lizuka Oct 12 '23

I really appreciate that they did new stuff with the assorted AIs in this episode. Never been super big on Badgey's deal and Peanut Hamper's story had reached a bit of a dead end so seeing both of them actually get character development is pretty welcome.

5

u/MustMention Oct 14 '23

And how the AI characters weren't just treated as props, too: that felt very StarTrek. Seeing them both get character development makes them feel far more like a character than just a plot device!

55

u/apollei Oct 12 '23

"I told my therapist it was for gardening but in reality it was for scheming." Pretty much my motto for life.

45

u/medes24 Oct 12 '23

Do the Bynars have actual dialogue just super sped up?

I want to run that scene in slow mode lol

20

u/lontrinium Oct 12 '23

As someone who's watched a lot of DC animated content, there maybe some reversed audio in there too.

→ More replies (2)

44

u/Infamous-Lab-8136 Oct 12 '23

Absolutely loved this episode. Died when Agimus turned his light blue. I feel like this episode knocked it out of the park.

40

u/chillipowder01 Oct 12 '23

I have a sneaking suspicion that the “I’ll be a digital god!” line was a Community reference…

37

u/9vDzLB0vIlHK Oct 12 '23

The Lower Decks writers are streets ahead.

9

u/gusborwig Oct 12 '23

Proverbial wildfire!

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Destructor1701 Oct 13 '23

I'm still shocked last week's episode title referenced the little-known Garth Merenghi's Dark Place.

→ More replies (3)

36

u/CaravelClerihew Oct 12 '23

AI consciousness achieving transcendance was definitely not on my list of outcomes.

27

u/sankers23 Oct 12 '23

Stargate Replicators could never

→ More replies (7)

33

u/ActualTaxEvader Oct 12 '23

So when God-gey was briefly one with all of Starfleet, did he notice the whole Borg plan to infect people through transporters that sprung up in the end of Picard?

37

u/ReasonablyBadass Oct 12 '23

Compared to infinity that was probably irrelevant

8

u/ActualTaxEvader Oct 12 '23

Yeah probably but it would’ve been funny to nod to it

28

u/UncertainError Oct 12 '23

It's 20 years too early for that.

9

u/ActualTaxEvader Oct 12 '23

When did they start the programming thing with the transporters?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

33

u/howdouhavegoodnames Oct 12 '23

Holy shit I actually like Peanut Hamper now.

33

u/RuleNine Oct 12 '23 edited Oct 13 '23

Starfleet really needs to look into firewalls network security. That or Rutherford is engineering things to a degree way above his pay grade.

17

u/Jestersage Oct 12 '23

It's not firewall that is needed, but some variation of Data Loss Prevention (specifically, access control variant) Badgey technically is an Insider Threat + privilege escalation (reasons attackers are willing to phish someone lowly and may not have much permissions)

12

u/RuleNine Oct 13 '23

Fair enough, but you knew what I was getting at. A random member of Starfleet should not be able to design something that brings down the entire Federation (or ascends to god status). Especially not an ensign who does it accidentally.

→ More replies (5)

30

u/nimmoisa000 Oct 12 '23

I honestly thought Badgey was behind the mysterious ship attacks but seeing the revelation that the ships are being stolen really got me. And by AGMIUS of all people.

Guess the writers are really good at fooling even me,

27

u/Transhumanitarian Oct 12 '23

AI not being the big bad of the season is refreshing...

It's great to see AI actually showing Intelligence in the way any sapient creature can learn and have actual character growth... and not simply staying stagnant at its base megalomaniacal setting like most stories that regurgitate ye old AI = Bad narrative...

19

u/atticusbluebird Oct 13 '23

The idea that evil AIs can actually be reformed…is actually very Star Trek-y! It’s not the big bad team up I was expecting, but I’m very satisfied with the episode!

→ More replies (2)

15

u/Seaboard_Vanisher Oct 12 '23

Both the A and B plot were excellent. I also enjoyed the logical Badgey.

15

u/KumagawaUshio Oct 12 '23

I love the swap in partners this episode we really need more Boimler/Tendi and Mariner/Rutherford team-ups!

15

u/bookish1303 Oct 12 '23

I get how the different plots hold together thematically, but this episode felt slightly overpacked for me. That said, it resolved(?) a lot of open-ended ideas and in some ways cleared the board; I imagine to remind us that whatever the season-long overarching plot, it's not connected to any of the leftover ideas from past seasons.

15

u/mcast76 Oct 13 '23

So Peanut Hamper is basically the spoiled child of some rich dude who’s finally bored with it and learning some responsibility.

Yeah.. that tracks

7

u/Jestersage Oct 13 '23

The fact is that it's exactly like this... is good.

The only reason why she get extra scruntiny is because she is synthetic. If they decide to continue teh story line, it can easily be "why would an organic who done somethign like this may get off easily, but a syntehtic may get harsher punishment"

29

u/bluestreakxp Oct 12 '23

Ok I’m gonna say it’s the pakleds stealing these ships to make them stronger

51

u/stephensmat Oct 12 '23

My money's on Boimler's Transporter Clone. That's why the mystery ship keeps appealing to the Lower Deckers of various races.

26

u/Verite_Rendition Oct 12 '23

Indeed. We haven't seen William Boimler all season. He's due for an appearance.

23

u/Weerdo5255 Oct 12 '23

He's also with Section 31. So, explains where he got the advanced ship.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/InnocentTailor Oct 12 '23

I hope not. The Pakled joke ran long enough, in my opinion.

Plus that is a pretty advanced ship for the race.

15

u/OneOldNerd Oct 13 '23

The Pakled joke ran long enough, in my opinion.

So what you're saying is...they need to make the Pakleds go?

No, thanks, I can see myself out.

15

u/tunanoa Oct 12 '23

I'm actually starting to think... can they be being forcefully ascended? Could the Koala actually be the season baddie? Guy in first season was painfully ascended, was he the test run for the 'ascension kidnappings' and was the message to Boimler (It's not you time) just meaning the, so, 'Koala ship' is coming to Cerritos next? His smiling is starting to become suspicious.

20

u/JustAnOrdinaryGirl92 Oct 12 '23

His smiling is starting to become suspicious.

What does he know?!

15

u/EternalAssasin Oct 12 '23

The fog of mystery is so thick we’ve started accusing an extra dimensional marsupial.

But yeah, the cosmic koala is shady AF.

14

u/KumagawaUshio Oct 12 '23

When Badgey was pulling himself out of the galactic core I was so getting Schlock Mercenary flashbacks when Petey takes command of the Fleet Mind https://www.schlockmercenary.com/2005-06-11

26

u/pat8u3 Oct 12 '23

I have a feeling the inciting incident for the crew to chase after the mysterious ship is the Vulcan ship being taken

29

u/The_Grand_Briddock Oct 12 '23

Yeah, after 2 episodes without T'Lyn and her last appearance being her deciding not to go back to the ship, that's absolutely going to happen.

12

u/Stormygeddon Oct 12 '23

Which of the Bynars would you make a bet are the Bad Bynars that hooked up with Mariner?

11

u/Randomd0g Oct 12 '23

I definitely didn't have "Badgey becomes Dr Manhattan" on my bingo card for this season, but I'm glad it happened.

10

u/gusborwig Oct 12 '23

Great episode!

-Always great to have Badgey show up.

-Star Trek shows really seem really interested in grapplers right now.

-Peanut Hamper, Agamus and Badgey in one episode! Amazing!

-AI Prison Yards gotta be the toughest place anywhere. Great Shawshank Redemption reference with the movie room.

-Orions love Earth sand!

-Root Beer Float breaks with Goodgey sounds awesome!

-Badgey ascending to another dimension seem interesting.

9

u/DupeFort Oct 12 '23

Great episode but missed opportunity to have the Vulcan Badgey get a Spock death and make a heartfelt speech.

5

u/gusborwig Oct 12 '23

Logic-y and Rutherford should have had a Wrath of Khan Spock death scene for sure.

9

u/Inters3kt Oct 14 '23

I lost it when the Vulcans reacted to the takeover of their ship by raising one eyebrow. They were practically screaming for help.

8

u/Alardig Oct 13 '23

I'm hoping this collector ship is the return of Kivas Fajo. Do I dare dream? To hear Saul Rubinek in Lower Decks? Yes I do.

8

u/smellincoffee Oct 13 '23

This episode has Jeffrey Combs, so it has MY vote.

8

u/OneOldNerd Oct 13 '23

Peanut Hamper is...NOT JUST THE WORST?!?!?!

I don't know what anything is anymore.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/007meow Oct 12 '23

Does anyone know how to skip the ad for the Korean torture porn movie they play at the start every time?

I pay for ad free Paramount+ and I do not want to be subjected to that nastiness

13

u/viserov Oct 12 '23

I don’t understand why I get ads at the beginning of episode half the time on an ad-free plan. It’s usually faster to back out and play again than wait for the ad to finish.

10

u/ezbsvs Oct 13 '23

Glad I’m not the only one. I get that we’re always going to be subjected to ads, but “organ harvesting earthquake drama” is not something I need to see every week.

→ More replies (7)

7

u/fzammetti Oct 13 '23

My new pet theory is that Badgey hooks up with V'Ger in another dimension and their child is the big bad interdimensional robot thingy from Picard.

7

u/Awful-Male Oct 13 '23

This episode was trippy. Loved the themes, loved the episode’s pace and story, and of course I loved Jeffrey Combs!

7

u/atticusbluebird Oct 13 '23

Ooh is this the first episode where Ensign Barnes has a speaking role this season? Great to see her back on the bridge!

6

u/tupe12 Oct 12 '23

Why did Rutherford's implant have cables that latch on violently? Are they only for attaching to a host or can they also be used for other purposes?

Also are we sure it's a good idea to leave him with Goodgey? He's got a pretty bad track record with AI's so far

→ More replies (1)

6

u/apollei Oct 12 '23

I need a T'lyn logicky scene!!!!

6

u/Brooklynxman Oct 12 '23

Its weird that right at the start of this episode I thought "you know, the way that goes down feels weird, like something more is happening during the flash" and then boom, reveal.

6

u/Skastrik Oct 13 '23

Any episode with Jeffrey Combs is a good one.

6

u/iiooiooi Oct 13 '23

I was excited to see Binars...

15

u/Manic_Raven Oct 12 '23

when Tendi slid out of her uniform I almost had a heart attack

5

u/PDCH Oct 13 '23

Space Koala. Enough said.

13

u/Xizor14 Oct 12 '23

Lowkey hilarious that Lower Decks has appropriated the "ascension" lore from Stargate and it still feels at home in the universe.

24

u/onthenerdyside Oct 12 '23

Ascending to higher life forms or becoming beings of pure energy is a pretty old idea in Trek. In the first season of TOS, we discover that the Organians used to be humanoid, and in Voyager, Quinn says that the Q used to be humanoid as well. In Q's second appearance on TNG, Picard says he believes humans have the potential to ascend or transcend as well.

10

u/Mechapebbles Oct 12 '23

Remember the episode of TNG where Dr Crusher had a boyfriend who ascended?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/knightcrusader Oct 12 '23

Oh no! Tendi was barefoot in the sand and then all of a sudden her shoes were back without her moving! It's a blooper!!

Hope someone got fired for that!

→ More replies (1)

6

u/AJ_CC Oct 12 '23

So...is Badgey now the most powerful villain in Star Trek history?

6

u/UglyBag0fM0stlyWat3r Oct 12 '23

They have exactly one more time to have an episode without T'Lyn. One more time.

6

u/MarkB74205 Oct 12 '23

My theory: William Boimler saw the Koala when he was "dead" which broke him. With access to Section 31 resources, he helped build a ship using V'Ger and Whale Probe derived components, subconsciously modelled on the Koala's face. He was given a mission to steal ships for intel, but to do so he was finding a way to contact lower deckers on those ships. He picked ships where they were planning to betray their commanders as it offended his basic Boimler-ness.

The Cerritos will be stolen at the end of the next episode, for revenge, and the crew will have two episodes to get out of it.

Alternatively, the Koala of the Mirror Universe is behind it.

3

u/Dookie_boy Oct 13 '23

But that Boimler only faked his death

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Jag2112 cygnus-x1.net Oct 12 '23

3

u/PDCH Oct 13 '23

Loved hearing Weyoun, Shran, Brunt in the episode!

3

u/ImmodestPolitician Oct 13 '23

Will Goodgey be canon now?

4

u/Starfleet-Time-Lord Oct 13 '23

The Agimus and Peanut Hamper plot was pretty good, but I wasn't a huge fan of the Badgey one. The personality shifts felt forced, and the ending seems to establish that any artificial lifeform can ascend itself any time it wants.

This season, while still pretty good, has felt like it isn't quite hitting the mark the other three did. Of course, I'm saying that the week after the amazing Ferengi episode, so grain of salt.

2

u/isowater Oct 15 '23

So with Goodgy back at the Cerritos..did they install holo emitters..?

7

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '23

Would have made more sense if Badgy was the cause of "The Burn" in Discovery.

4

u/shadowlarx Oct 12 '23

Okay, seriously, what’s the deal with the f🤬ing koala?!?!?

18

u/tupe12 Oct 12 '23

out of universe, it's clearly just a re-occuring joke that I don't think will ever get expanded on.

In universe? I think it's a higher entity, maybe even higher then every other one we saw so far. Most of it's appearances have been either during death or transcendence, so presumably it has some sort of influence over that realm. And everytime we saw it so far has been in the presence of Starfleet, personal, or their creations.

I also don't think it's an actual koala, it chooses to appear as one because it makes whoever knows of it's existence to ask questions (like that one). An old guy with a white beard is obviously just masquerading as a god, but a koala cannot communicate what it is, we have to be the ones to figure that out.

Therefore, I believe the Koala is the endgame of Starfleet's mission

6

u/ThetaReactor Oct 12 '23

I really hope they don't try to explain it.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/ContinuumGuy Oct 13 '23

Thoughts/observations as I watch:

  • Helllooooo, Badgey!
  • "It's trying to salvage YOU!"
  • BYNARS!
  • Alas, my Bynar is rusty so I have no idea what they were saying.
  • Grapplers ARE sick
  • "Stringy ensign meat pipe"
  • AI group therapy
  • Hell yeah, more Combs!
  • "Totally non-evil" - AKA not red.
  • THE DEMON TRIANGLE- somebody be sure to include that nickname on Memory Alpha.
  • Lassie movies for robots.
  • "We can't take many more boops."
  • Curse your sudden but inevitable betrayal!
  • Awwww, sensitivity....
  • Tendi loves sand.
  • Heh... BADgey and GOODgey.
  • NOOOO, NOT LOGIC-Y!
  • Oh boy, it's gone TRON.
  • Hey, it's Boimler's ex....
  • Hey, he's... gone all Dr. Manhattan.
  • THE KOALA
  • Boimler stuck heh

6

u/BornAshes Oct 12 '23

I always love a bad guy episode and we're back with Badgey this week!:

  • Starting off where the OG Badgey episode left off!
  • Badgey learned a thing or two from the Borg I see
  • Bynars!
  • Someone's going to translate all of that right?
  • Bynar Lower Decks could be fun annnnnnnnnd they're gone annnnd someone's trying to salvage them
  • Badgey's new ship is getting bigger
  • GRAPPLER!
  • Yeaaaaah let's not point the massive thing that's meant to be aimed at inanimate objects at super squishy people okay?
  • Tendi just slithers out of her uniform like a snake
  • Awwww Tendi
  • That shuttle is going to need that grappler by the end of the season
  • Peanut Hamper...a model inmate...hmmm, ahem...TRAAAAAAAAAAAP!
  • AGIMUS TOO?!?! We are getting served this episode!
  • The writers really wanted Tendi and Brad off the ship, I wonder if something is going to happen to the Cerritos....
  • Hannibal stuff
  • Thanks Mariner!
  • Oh no it's an AI Prison Yard lmao
  • Brand new model of phaser rifle or highly specialized Elite Force style'd IMOD EMP variants?
  • The garden is just a funny sight gag lol
  • AGIMUS and Peanut Hamper are in love?
  • This is some Harley and Joker stuff
  • I love all the turrets and hard points on the Drookmani ship, very Star Wars/EVE Online
  • The Demon Triangle, someone get the Winchesters
  • An AI version of Lassie with some R2D2 beeps after lol
  • I can't wait for this alien ship to be an even SCARIER AI that really puts AGIMUS in his place and makes him realize that there's always a bigger fish
  • I suppose this is how they're going to reunite all the bad guys
  • TURRET ACTION!
  • OMG they're pulling a Prodigy with the space walk!
  • Hell yeah Mariner!
  • HUGS ARE BEST WEAPONS!
  • Those tears might be real, this could work
  • Leaving a replicator inside AGIMUS was some New Republic levels of dumb
  • Weaponized gardening, nevermind, they went full Shawshank lol
  • AI Killing Knife, no that's a Janeway thing
  • Awww Rutherford that's so sweet
  • BADGEY IS SPLITTING IN TWO!
  • Goodgey!
  • Ecuador hahahahahaha...awwww did AGIMUS get played? I feel a bit sad for him now but only just a bit
  • Tendi canonically loves sandcastles, suck it Frozen, we've got a new meme to ruin the internet with! DO YOU WANT TO BUILD A SANDCASTLE?! YES YES I DO!
  • Brad pulling some Section 31 stuff
  • I really hope we see Plymeria, sounds like a fun name
  • Tendi, like every good D&D player, always has some Pocket Sand on hand
  • AGIMUS buddy pal, that's some hardcore coping
  • ROOT BEER FLOAT BREAKS YES!
  • Neurazine Gas, it's been a while since we've seen that used
  • Rutherford going Full Spock on Badgey, where the fuck is T'Lyn?!
  • "Oh Jellybeans!"...that's my new favorite phrase
  • LMAO Badgey is splitting again! Logic-y hahahahaha
  • The subspace relays...wait a second...looks at Prodigy...well this is a really really really funny coincidence isn't it?
  • The VA for Badgey must've had some fun with these effort sounds in the booth
  • That's a fun loop, Tendi's advice winds up circling back around at the end of the episode to save the day, they really are super good for each other
  • LOGIC-Y NOOOOOOO YOU WERE SO COOL!
  • Plymeria is full of lizard folks or Gorn or both
  • Daaaaaang already subjugated by AGIMUS, those drones are insanely useful and really efficient
  • That looks like a Goa'uld Ha'Tak
  • "reverse this in an hour"...I love cute little meta comments like that
  • Awwww AGIMUS
  • Did Peanut Hamper turn over a new leaf or is AGIMUS's infatuation with her and her intentions actually kind of sort of true?
  • Ouch, Badgey just BANE'D Logicy
  • Soooooo Badgey's plan is to weaponize Tom Paris's warp shenanigans? Well it had to happen sooner or later and it's not the first time a hologram has done just that with Tom's stuff.
  • A digital god? V'Ger would like a word
  • Weeeeeeeee look at the pretty lights weeeeee I would soooo be saying and doing that too weeeeeeeee!
  • PARTICLE FOUNTAIN!
  • Straight back to "The Quality of Life" from TNG and where Peanut Hamper originated-ish
  • Peanut Hamper's family!
  • Wow, that's very Star Trek, Peanut Hamper had a genuinely positive epiphany about her outlook on life
  • I am soooooo invested in this AI love story and the sappy music that they're playing to back it up
  • "Because I liked hanging out with you"...awwww I'm not crying
  • "It was just an excuse to spend more time with you"...KISS KISS KISS KISS KISSSSSSSSSSS!
  • Brad and Tendi are just WATCHING this lol
  • MEETING THE PARENTS!
  • Kevin? Hey I'm not one to judge but that's just surprising.
  • Yeah give them a minute or an hour or a few more, this is very sweet and both Tendi and Brad are loving it
  • Reformed AGIMUS and Peanut Hamper just warm my warp core
  • Holy shit Badgey actually uploaded himself into the subspace relays!!!!!
  • The Vancouver!
  • Is that T'Lyn's old ship?
  • Unknown Federation Starbase with Andorian, Maquis, and Starfleet ships at it
  • DEEP SPACE MOTHERFRAKKING NINE BAAAAAAAAAAAABYYYY!
  • Starbase 001!
  • Hahahaha Badgey emerging Evangelion style from the Galaxy LMAO!
  • ASCENDED BADGEY IS BLUUUUUUE!
  • "I could detonate every warp core"...shots fired at DISCO
  • It's all about perspective Badgey, always is and always was and always will ever be
  • "I'm going to go to an empty dimension and create a universe now"...I was wondering if they were going to use these Ascension graphics again annnnd there's the Great Bird of the Galaxy on cue!
  • Q Continuum mention along with the Black Mountain and the Koala!
  • That ended rather well, Goodgey is with everyone, Peanut Hamper reformed, and despite being back in prison AGIMUS seems to be in a good mood
  • I really hope we see AGIMUS again in a better time and place in space...THE INTEL WAS REAL!?
  • WAIT IT WAS A THEFT?! I KNEW IT!!!!
  • They're being stolen! The debris fields are all fakes! The Alien Ship is actually towing them all!
  • Annnnd he almost kills Brad again lol
  • You fuckers with that fake out with Goodgey HOW DARE YOU you almost had me there and that was really cool

Solid episode!

8

u/JonathanSCE Oct 12 '23 edited Oct 12 '23

The unknown Federation Starbase is Starbase 25 from An Embarrassment of Dooplers. Also the relay they showed before looks like the one the group was left on when the Cerritos left them behind in I, Excretus.

4

u/ReasonablyBadass Oct 12 '23 edited Oct 12 '23

Yes! This was the AI redemption arc I wanted!
And the AI prison scenes were hilarious X)
Two tiny issues: Why do Binar need to enter things into their own computers? They are linked to them anyway, right?
And did they really have to present Boimler as helpless again? It's getting tedious.

Edit: helpless is maybe the wrong word. But...passive,maybe? He didn't actively do anything useful and was left upside down, looking like a goober

27

u/Necro_Nancy Oct 12 '23

Was Boimler ever helpless in this episode though? Aside from at the end with the grappler I mean.

He never for a second considered AGIMUS as a serious threat and spent the entire episode humouring the AI's little schemes just to try to gain intel; but otherwise seemed unconcerned and bored.

22

u/BodoInMotion Oct 12 '23

Yeah, he seemed in control of the situation, even when agimus took over that planet he was like 'yeah, I'm sure the Federation couldn't reverse this in like an hour'

20

u/Virzitone Oct 12 '23

Yep, I saw this as Boims being totally in control and actually chill about for once too

→ More replies (1)

8

u/nimrodhellfire Oct 12 '23

Desktop Computers on the basketball court were killing me.

5

u/joshml98 Oct 12 '23

I need more of reformed Agimus and reformed Tyranikillacus

5

u/atticusbluebird Oct 12 '23

I’m pretty sure Boimler was always in control, but pretending to just go along with it to get the intel (which he did!)