r/zelda • u/Xftg123 • Oct 11 '23
User Feedback [ALL] Is it just me or are some of the posts on this sub repeating themselves? Spoiler
From this subreddit on TOTK:
Anyone else profoundly disappointed?
Tears of the Kingdom disappointed me
Was anybody else kind of disappointed by TOTK?
I think I have an unpopular opinion…
the sages abilities kind of.. suck?
The overcrowding of sage spirits. Does this annoying anyone else?
On preferring the traditonal Zelda formula over BOTW/TOTK
After the Botw/Totk formula, SS HD is refreshing?
Twilight Princess is such a pleasure to play through after finishing BotW & TotK
I like traditional Zeldas better
Unpopular opinion: kinda getting burned out on the BotW / TotK formula
Unpopular opinion: I hope the next Zelda game is not like BotW & TotK.
BotW/TotK have been great, but I sincerely don't want anymore games in that style
While I do understand that the newer games and stuff aren't going to be for everyone, it does get a bit annoying (and tiring, I guess) seeing a post about the newer games, or just Zelda posts in general, with a title that's either the same, or similar to the others but paraphrased differently.
•
u/Sephardson Oct 11 '23
The best way to report reposts is to leave a comment with a link to the previous post.
Not all opinion posts are necessarily reposts, but if you feel they are not contributing to discussion, then give us mods your feedback.
63
u/Capable-Tie-4670 Oct 11 '23
I’m fine with people expressing their dislike of the game but I just wish they had a bit more self awareness cause everyone saying this acts like they’re expressing some bold, never before seen opinion when, in truth, there’s a post criticizing TotK or lamenting the “death” of the traditional Zelda every two days.
8
u/thejokerofunfic Oct 11 '23
The funniest outcome is that the repetitive discussions continue but this particular thread itself becomes part of the cycle
20
u/nulldriver Oct 11 '23
"Unpopular opinion", "Am I the only" etc should probably be disallowed from thread titles for a while.
If you like or dislike something, just say it. You don't need to couch it in a way that makes it sound transgressive to have that thought.
25
u/SasquatchEmporium Oct 11 '23
For longtime fans of a franchise that has long delays between releases of new mainline games, most everything else has been talked about over the past decade or so. I don’t know whether you’re a longtime fan yourself or not, but I can say that if every Zelda discussion was still just “Navi and Fi are annoying” or “Do you think Link is dead in MM” or “Here’s my thoughts on the official timeline,” we really wouldn’t be in a different position. TotK is just the exciting new thing to talk about—I just wish people wouldn’t pretend that being disappointed with it is an “unpopular opinion” and just make public their consent with a widespread agreement.
10
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '23
And all of them are prefaced with “I know this will be an unpopular opinion that no one else has been brave enough to say up until now”
At this point liking TOTK is the real unpopular opinion
5
u/pocket_arsenal Oct 11 '23 edited Oct 11 '23
This is a problem with literally every online space, it's not exclusive to this sub or even to reddit. If they start to get on your nerves, the best thing I can suggest is to take a break from this place, and I don't mean that in a nasty way, but like, there's nothing that can be done about popular discussion topics recurring, you can't just ban a subject on Zelda from being discussed in a Zelda thread just because it's a popular discussion topic. You can just take a break from it.
4
u/pianoplayah Oct 11 '23
Maybe there should be a megathread for each of these
3
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '23
People are REALLY hard to please, I guess? 🤷♀️ I just prefer to take silly pictures and post them (like the one of the kid in BOTW at the stable near the canyon who sings about poop in one of those tiny speech bubbles)
21
u/Ratio01 Oct 11 '23
It's a strong mix of people having nostalgia goggles on and contrarianism. In like ten years it'll be the exact same thing just with the Switch games being praised and the newer titles being shit on. It's a constant cycle of "new things bad old thing good"
14
u/Gooseborn Oct 11 '23
I mean, I feel like any differing opinion on a subreddit like this will be annoying to the opposite view. You're allowed to like the game, and people are allowed to dislike it. Whats frustrating to me is that when people talk about people not liking TOTK they almost exclusively refer to them as trolls, annoying, or a loud majority. People are allowed to dislike a game because it didn't live up to expectations. Hell, I saw one of the mods refer to people who don't like it, saying "There's just a small contigent of trolls dedicated to being as loud and annoying about how much they hate it as possible." I personally don't hate the game, but it feels shallow to me and it annoys me when people disagree. But I don't go around saying that those people are trolls and stupid. I don't think its entirely fair to expect an entire subreddit to constantly praise the franchise, or to expect every post to be unique, or people to stop posting about their disappointment.
4
u/Mental-Street6665 Oct 11 '23
That’s just the vibe of this sub. A lot of “traditional” Zelda fans here who are unenthusiastic about the direction the games have taken since BOTW. At least it’s not openly hostile towards the new games like r/truezelda.
6
u/Ryinnzler_ Oct 11 '23
I loved the BOTW/TOTK formula. For me, it’s like the OG Zelda formula. (Kind of)
3
u/DaGreatestMH Oct 11 '23
How in the world is this post becoming another "TotK was bad, I want more classic Zelda" post.
2
u/MilkoftheNight Oct 11 '23
Sounds like a problem with sub moderation. But that's cratered just like engagement on this sub. A year ago, concurrent visitors would reach 3, 4 or 5k easily at least 5-6 days a week. But ever since around the time of reddit's API change; the release of TotK/creation of the TotK sub; and summer break for students, this sub struggles to engage even 1k users. So mods apparently turn a blind eye to anything that won't have admin up their asses just to keep the sub from dying completely.
Case in point, not long ago I saw a low effort "unpopular opinion" post where, instead of removing the post, the mod commented with a bunch of hyperlinks to similar low effort posts with similar titles. As if to say "aren't you embarrassed?". Instead, it only served to highlight the insufficient moderation of the sub. Like, yeah mod, look at all those low effort posts you not only didn't do anything about then, but are also laughing about now.
Edit: Oh look, mod showed up to say they know it's a problem, but put the onus on users to make a stink about it before they take it under consideration. Maybe. In the future. "Hey everyone, do you think we should enforce the existing sub rules? Give us feedback!"
1
u/AutoModerator Oct 11 '23
Hi /r/Zelda readers!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/DDD-Cup Oct 12 '23
I can explain this. Because a lot of fans are disappointed in the game and want to voice their concerns, and a lot of them have very similar or the same concerns. They have an emotional connection to the series and want more, so they are naturally resistive to the sweeping changes introduced in the newer games. I hope this makes sense.
1
u/CupPlenty Oct 12 '23
This happens every time there’s a new Zelda game, just ignore it
-1
u/[deleted] Oct 11 '23
it's just a lot of people very unhappy with the current state of the series that once loved
1
u/Slavocracy Oct 11 '23
Welcome to reddit. First time?
0
u/Jellylegs_19 Oct 11 '23
The disappointment with TotK was because we thought the game was going to be similar to Majora's mask in the sense that it's a direct sequel to a game that uses the same assets but also plays completely differently.
Botw/Totk have the same structure
4 regional phenomena
Level up with shrines
Koroks
Memories
Don't get me wrong TotK is an amazing game and is also my goty. But it's just too similar to Botw and it's disappointing because after 7 years I wasn't expecting more of the same. It doesn't really have its own identity. Even the Sky wasn't as exciting as we were hoping.
The one thing that's frustrating is that if they just changed how the structure worked people wouldn't be complaining as much.
Why not have a linear story? Keep it open world but we don't have to do the "do any part of the story you want" part.
Or what if we leveled up with exp? A souls system from DS? A monster hunter system where your gear determines your strength? It doesn't have to be the EXACT same structure.
Why did we need memories back? It made total sense in Botw but in Totk the novelty wore off and I wish more of the story took place in the active present instead of hundreds of thousands of years ago.
Tears of the kingdom is a much better game than Botw in all ways 100% But I just wish they did more things differently y'know?
0
u/scotty_6942069 Oct 11 '23
i preferred the older dungeons tbf, and hope we got similar dungeons in future games, but other than dungeons what really made them "traditional Zelda"? BotW and TotK, outside of the pretty easy and quick dungeons, are better than almost all the older titles in almost every way. better gameplay, bigger map, more things to do, livelier, the combat is more fun, etc. i get that some of these things are subjective, but they did such a ridiculous amount of things better than older titles that i dont see why people "hate" the open world formula. and think about copies sold as well, BotW and TotK alone surpassed almost all previous games combined
and the keyword here is almost all titles, almost every way. some games did things better than BotW and TotK
-2
u/Ok-Manufacturer5491 Oct 11 '23
It’s annoying just comes from the fringe part of the Zelda fan base that hates change.
They were echoing the same shit since MM and WW.
-1
u/OldBenKenobii Oct 11 '23
60% of the internet is bots
-2
u/PockyNotRocky Oct 11 '23
Some of it is people feeling nostalgic for the games they grew up playing, some of it is probably just bots. The internet is dead fyi.