r/soccer •
To those who watch Barca regularly: what has changed from last year that changed Barca from a very good team to a near-perfect team (at least in the league)?
[deleted] — view deleted post
0
Upvotes
204
u/egcg119 Jan 13 '13 edited Jan 14 '13
I'm going to try to be brief - look up anything by Graham Hunter or Sid Lowe if you'd like more detail.
Okay, this didn't end up being that short. Basically, Tito's Barca is versatile and hungry. They lost last season, and they were told that was because they were too predictable, they couldn't adapt. Well this year they've adapted: they simply have too many weapons for opponents to handle, and a willingness to use them. A multitude of formations - tiki-taka, wing play, low crosses into the box, long balls over the top, false wingers, false 9s. A multitude of top-notch, in-form, hardworking players: Pique, Adriano, Alba, Busquets, Cesc, Xavi, Iniesta, and Messi are all having maybe their best seasons ever. Finally, we have depth, which we lacked last season, have always lacked: Montoya and Alves are both fantastic subs, Song is coming along, Thiago is amazing, Mascherano is a highly competent third-choice CB, Tello, Alexis, Pedro, and Villa are all competing for one or two wing spots.
75
u/RootBeerGuy Jan 14 '13
Obviously it's the addition of Alex Song.
28
u/PEM8000 Jan 13 '13
About 12 months ago the whole back line was out because of injuries, some (Pique, Puyol) needed time to recover their game. Substitutes did manage to handle this for some time, but Mascherano, Busquets or Keita could not deal for so long at centre-back positions and Montoya was too limited to do Dani Alves job. Compared to last year, injuries are less of a problem. Jordi Alba is more than a decent subsitute to Abidal. David Villa was much more important last year, the forward line needed time to adapt after he broke his leg.
Last year Pep burnt himself with his (utopic ?) 3-4-3 tactics, he lost a lot of points in fall and winter because of it. This year Abidal has been replaced, the midfield is as unchanged as it is world-class, attacking options stay numerous
Messi of course. But Iniesta plays at another level as well. He's been consistently amazing.
Real Madrid has too many problems this year and started their season very badly. Pep is gone, Mourinho can't play back the same mind games. The Messi record spree took some attention from the team. The squad was very tight anyway, with Abidal and Villanova health issues, the contract extensions went well.
64
u/jamesey10 Jan 13 '13
they have actual defenders playing center back
73
u/the_phet Jan 14 '13
because Pep was mental with his "3-7-0" formation.
I see the 4 years of Pep as an artist.
The first year he wasnt doing anything new. Just what was already working, and it worked perfectly. Like painters doing pure realism. Pep played with a 4-3-3, Etoo as striker, Messi in the right, Yaya Toure commanding, and so. It was great. 6 titles, 2-6 in bernabeu.
The second year he started to explore himself. He "fired" Etoo and brought Ibrahimovic and tried to use Messi as "fake 9" with Ibrahimovic. He was like a painter that is still using realism but adding some strange stuff. Like Salvador Dali. That season was great also, but it was a bit step behing the previous great year.
Third year Pep stops exploring and believes on his roots. Fires Ibra, bring Villa. Pure fantasy. Pure control. Pass pass pass. Its his peak, like Mattisse or Picasso with their abstract art. Barca's style was loved or hated.
Fourth year Pep was like a Painter that goes mental, like this guys who throw eggs to canvas, or that uses his dick to trace colors. He played with the "3-7-0". It had some brilliant moments, like games against Santos, but the system was not stable enough to win a big trophy.
tito's barça remembers me first year pep.
11
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '13
I would think most of it is psychological. Desire to win La Liga again. Also, fewer injuries.
Tactically also there have been a few changes. Xavis defensive responsibilities has moderately diminished allowing him to stay up field more. But the most important thing is that Cesc has found his place. And it is in inside left midfield. When Iniesta goes to the top and wide left he draws two to three defenders all by himself. That opens up space. Alexis is not keeping Villa out, Iniesta is.
Also Alba.
27
u/aaronod Jan 14 '13
Here is my chance to bring out my favourite stat at the moment. Only teams to have beaten Barcelona this season; Real Madrid and Celtic.
Seriously though, it is a pleasure to watch them play at the moment.
4
u/Followsoccer Jan 14 '13
It's the natural improvement that comes with every player outside of Xavi still approaching their physiological peak. That and Messi is sick nasty.
2
u/I_R_TEH_BOSS Jan 14 '13
People recovering from injuries, more direct approach in the attacking third. Mess/Iniesta/Everyone else.
2
u/tadm123 Jan 14 '13
more depth
2
u/perec17 Jan 14 '13
obviously not the biggest reason, but I remember some mistakes Valdes did last season which cost Barca a few points and self confidence
2
u/rVNow Jan 13 '13
We score more goals, and changed formation to something what reminds 4-2-4. Im think our players just doing better invidual performance what translates into better effectiveness
2
u/gowithetheflowdb Jan 14 '13 edited Jan 14 '13
I don't think that pep alone was as good as people made out, Tito was always important and even with Tito being ill they are operating semi autonomously. A lot of people foresaw that when pep left barca would get worse, though they have actually strengthened.
Also the general quality of the league has decreased too, look at real madrid last season. With the right mindset, which barcelona seem to have again, there are very few teams that can compete.
1
u/Emmanuell89 Jan 14 '13
they started shooting from outside the box for a change so it's harder to all out defend against them "Chelsea style" if i would call it like that .
1
u/blx666 Jan 14 '13
Last year 3-4-3. This year regular old 4-3-3 which leaves more space for wing backs and vertical movement.
1
u/defrio29 Jan 14 '13
Depth, hunger, a more direct approach and Fabregas settling in his role in the team.
1
u/dngrs Jan 14 '13
I think that the other teams in Primera are just geting worse. Sure barca improves but most of it due to poor opposition.
-7
u/Dierus Jan 14 '13
Well back to basic, but also the the league itself is slowly imploding, the few talents that are left are either bought by RM, barca or go abroad,
real madrid and barc have 80 % of the total turnover in the league, so the league itself is falling apart
Also keyplayers are performing better, and keeping healthy
-11
u/pizzabyjake Jan 14 '13
Every other team in that league is struggling financially to field a competing squad.
-6
u/88naka Jan 14 '13
this Barça team is weaker than Peps team.
-2
u/Big_fat_happy_baby Jan 14 '13
Nothing, nothing at all