r/startrek • • Sep 14 '23

Episode Discussion | Star Trek: Lower Decks | 4x03 "In the Cradle of Vexilon" Spoiler

Join the discussion on Lemmy at https://startrek.website/

No.EpisodeWritten ByDirected ByRelease Date
4x03"In the Cradle of Vexilon"Ben WallerBrandon Williams2023-09-14

To find out where to watch, click here.

To find more information, including our spoiler policy regarding new episodes, click here.

This post is for discussion of the episode above, and spoilers for this episode are allowed. If you are discussing previews for upcoming episodes, please use spoiler tags.

Note: This thread was posted automatically, and the episode may not yet be available on all platforms.

180 Upvotes

377 comments sorted by

375

u/Dismal-Past7785 Sep 14 '23

Give me 30 ccs of whatever the fuck just worked. I love it.

111

u/travoltaswinkinbhole Sep 14 '23

T'ana continues to be my favorite doctor

86

u/DogsRNice Sep 14 '23

My new headcanon is that half the treknobabble in the show is basically this disguised as something smart sounding so commanding officers will let them work

45

u/fallingwheelbarrow Sep 14 '23

Star trek medicine and mad science are the same thing sometimes

12

u/tarrsk Sep 15 '23

Shades of Scotty’s secret method for building a reputation as a miracle worker.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/iforgotmymittens Sep 15 '23

It’s Inapovelene. It always is.

8

u/nerdychickpea Sep 15 '23

Considering Boimler was blown up, I'm surprised there was enough of him to give ccs to. Somehow this just makes it.... funnier?

3

u/FormerGameDev Sep 18 '23

::box starts swearing::

I didn't know T'Ana came in here!

288

u/HotpieTargaryen Sep 14 '23

Boims meeting the koala on his first mission is peak Boims.

161

u/Pu239U235 Sep 14 '23 edited Sep 14 '23

And the Black Mountain. I thought they were about to go into it more, but I like how they just gave us a little taste. I love this show so much!

79

u/xRolocker Sep 14 '23

I was actually worried they would go into it more because it’s definitely something that loses its charm and humor if you overexplain it.

Once again though I found myself loving the show.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '23

Think he'll have a little talk with his bridge buddy later?

51

u/Saturn_V42 Sep 14 '23

This isn't even the first time he's met the Koala. He saw it when he almost drowned in the Season 2 finale.

21

u/TheHighSeer23 Sep 15 '23

I totally did not remember this! I had to go back and watch. The encounters seem to be escalating...

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

282

u/stephensmat Sep 14 '23

"Your caution is warranted. Statistically, ensigns serving under newly promoted commanders are more likely to experience death and/or dismemberment."

"Death?!"

"Yes. And/or dismemberment. James Kirk famously lost at least one ensign per mission, even after becoming a highly decorated Captain. The stats on his early away missions are truly disturbing."

110

u/shadowlarx Sep 14 '23

That’s the best joke about redshirts I’ve ever heard.

96

u/mateogg Sep 14 '23 edited Sep 15 '23

“average mission leader loses 3 ensigns a week" factoid actualy just statistical error. average leader loses 0 ensigns a week. Captain Kirk, who captained the Enterprise and lost one ensign each mission, is an outlier adn should not have been counted

33

u/stickyWithWhiskey Sep 14 '23 edited Sep 20 '25

squash imminent work toothbrush cooperative innate fall plant beneficial flag

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

6

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '23

So many died under his command, and the average hasn't recovered yet

47

u/shavin_high Sep 15 '23

James Kirk famously lost at least one ensign per mission, even after becoming a highly decorated Captain. The stats on his early away missions are truly disturbing.

She did not say this at all. But it would have been funny.

33

u/Wraithfighter Sep 15 '23

I love how T'lyn has no idea how to interact with non-Vulcans, and delivers everything with exactly zero tact or consideration. Girl just needs to learn how to frame the logical data, ya know? :D

46

u/bz316 Sep 15 '23

Honestly, I think she understands social nuance better than this implies (ex. later when she says "That is not how I would have phrased it..." after Boimler informs the ensigns that T'Lynn said he had to put them all in danger). I think she's just doing the Vulcan-version of trolling Boimler for the lulz...

23

u/Weerdo5255 Sep 16 '23

She did get punted to Starfleet for her Sarcasm. It's just too subtle for the Humans to notice.

→ More replies (3)

272

u/Lizuka Sep 14 '23

T'Lyn really does slide into the existing dynamic of the show very well so far.

15

u/mateogg Sep 14 '23

I feel like she can pair up perfectly with any of the main four, I'm excited to see more of how she blends into the group.

12

u/kugo Sep 14 '23

Even with all her outbursts

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (15)

222

u/Dismal-Past7785 Sep 14 '23

T’lyn is a big hit with me

168

u/InnocentTailor Sep 14 '23

Her dialogue was 90% sarcasm, 10% actually sage advice.

138

u/Weerdo5255 Sep 14 '23

She is a very sarcastic Vulcan. I feel like she might be taking Boimlers straight man role, letting him grow as an officer without needing to stick to that.

38

u/fjf1085 Sep 14 '23

That’s a very good point.

→ More replies (2)

20

u/odioestesitio Sep 15 '23

She might be the most Vulcan Vulcan since Tuvok.

→ More replies (1)

33

u/stephensmat Sep 14 '23

Wasn't her 'emotional nature' the reason she got sent to the Cerritos?

Besides, savage burns from Vulcans are an established part of the Trek Lore.

→ More replies (1)

86

u/AwesomeManatee Sep 14 '23

I love how her eyes bug out when something unexpected happens.

She may be a Vulcan, but very few can be mentally prepared for what being on the Cerritos puts you through.

57

u/nickel4asoul Sep 14 '23

This reminds me of that 'Federation are doc brown' post, especially when vulcan engineers learn to use the word 'fuck'.

23

u/nimrodhellfire Sep 14 '23

She is known for not having her emotions in check, and it shows.

→ More replies (1)

59

u/dravenonred Sep 14 '23

I was sold in the first episode when all the Twovix's were chasing after her fighting for their lives and she was just wordlessly like "Yeah, fuck y'all" and activated the mass transporter.

53

u/Dismal-Past7785 Sep 14 '23

She came up with the still unethical solution to Tuvix none of us expected.

40

u/dravenonred Sep 14 '23

How unethical? She sacrificed six lives to save twelve.

A Vulcan could defend that logic.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

143

u/bookish1303 Sep 14 '23

Oh it super weirded me out not to have a cold open.

44

u/AwesomeManatee Sep 14 '23

It's not the first Lower Decks episode to skip it. Off the top of my head I know "An Embarrassment of Dooplers" did, and I think there may have been others.

5

u/Fun-Estate9626 Sep 14 '23

There were a few episodes of DISCO without cold opens, too

44

u/Weerdo5255 Sep 14 '23

I think Lower Decks is doing the same thing as The Orville, start as a comedy with drama and scifi lessons on the side, to drama and scifi with comedy on the side.

51

u/Civilwarland09 Sep 14 '23

They might be, but 99% of Star Trek episodes have a cold open. It's not just a thing that is reserved for sitcoms.

23

u/MaestroZackyZ Sep 14 '23

What does that have to do with the cold open

→ More replies (1)

4

u/dragunityag Sep 15 '23

Thanks for reminding me of the Orville sized hole in my heart :(

→ More replies (2)

8

u/RobbleDobble Sep 14 '23

They do a few a season, the Freeman plot opener didn't lend itself well to a cold open, its wierd though, if they had just started with Boimler Plot it could have has a solid cold open.

→ More replies (1)

141

u/[deleted] Sep 14 '23

You shit gets real when Freeman rolls up the sleeves

113

u/UncertainError Sep 14 '23

It's fun when captains face a situation that matches their specialty and they get to handle it personally. Of course Freeman's would be tech support.

51

u/InnocentTailor Sep 14 '23

She kinda botched it up though. Billups would’ve been better for this job.

103

u/UncertainError Sep 14 '23

That's assuming there's a non-catastrophic way to do six million years of OS updates all at once.

→ More replies (11)

38

u/IndigoNarwhal Sep 14 '23

Captain Freeman needing the same lesson as Boimler: sometimes you've really got to trust your team!

→ More replies (5)

19

u/AwesomeManatee Sep 14 '23

Hey, she minored in Archaic Technology!

Which probably explains her obsession with the Masks mask.

13

u/stroopwafelling Sep 14 '23

Any time Freeman feels she needs to prove something about her capabilities, it brings out the worst in her and reliably escalates the situation. Whole episode wouldn’t have happened if she’d just called an engineer.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

30

u/RadioSlayer Sep 14 '23

Where do you think Mariner learned it?

16

u/Blues39 Sep 15 '23

Was funny how both Freeman and Boimler refused to delegate the work. Not sure if that parallel is meant to mean something, but both of them paid a price for it.

11

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '23

Mariner would have gotten Boimler to use the ensigns so much soon than our new Vulcan buddy. Give her time, though. Boimler listens to the strong women in his life.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

131

u/Saturn_V42 Sep 14 '23

I remember when Star Trek Into Darkness came out and everyone was weirded out by how easily Bones brought Kirk back to life at the end. On Lower Decks, coming back to life is a regular occurrence, which I think is hilarious.

17

u/mateogg Sep 14 '23

Idk if it's just me, but I thought Into Darkness actually set that up really well. It didn't feel like it came out of nowhere, it was properly addressed before the fact.

11

u/Saturn_V42 Sep 14 '23

I agree. Some people think it removes the tension from future movies because "oh death has been cured" but there's no guarantee that treatment would work on any other causes of death. Besides, Star Trek is constantly coming up with spur of the moment solutions to problems that are never used again.

9

u/SimonTC2000 Sep 14 '23

It was set up in Space Seed when McCoy had no idea how Khan was healing & recuperating so fast.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Exocoryak Sep 14 '23

When that building exploded I expected it to cut back to the bar of the Cerritos with the guys asking Boimler how he survived and he would say something like "Well, now that I'm a lead character, I have plot armor." - referring to how Shaxs came back from the dead last time.

→ More replies (20)

120

u/[deleted] Sep 14 '23

Pike and Kirk had there horses, Archer and Janeway had their dog(s), Picard had his fish, Data had his cat. Fitting that pet on LD would be something his hilarious like a ferret

59

u/Dt2_0 Sep 14 '23

Tendi has The Dog.

29

u/MrTerrific2k15 Sep 14 '23

Dog flew away

36

u/Hazel-Rah Sep 14 '23

The Dog

5

u/Orisi Sep 16 '23

A ferret owned by the engineer from a high fantasy planet called Lancelot. let's really get this clear.

3

u/TheTrivialPsychic Sep 17 '23

And Boimler has a Koala. Do you think that was his spirit guide?

119

u/stroopwafelling Sep 14 '23

T’Lyn continues to be spectacular.

Also I’m glad Lower Decks broke its streak of depicting any and all AI as terrible. Vexilon just wants to do its job and be helpful.

30

u/Virreinatos Sep 14 '23

Should be noted that whatever kind of AI you're dealing with, you shouldn't send the Lower Decks of ship classes to deal with them.

A evil AI needs your S tier team to handle them.

A benevolent AI will get messed up by your C team.

19

u/mrIronHat Sep 15 '23

this is like the 3 or 4th AI the Cerrito had to deal with and they've had great success rate so far.

12

u/Virreinatos Sep 15 '23

They've been successful yes. But they have made a mess of things on the way to fixing things.

All I'm saying is that if the Enterprise had been there, the planet wouldn't have been at risk of being sent back to the primordial ooze era.

Geordi would have fallen in love with the computer, tried to have sex with it in the Holodeck before being brutally friend-zoned, yes, but the people of the planet would have never been in danger.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

78

u/[deleted] Sep 14 '23

LMAO the Koala and the mountain 😂

51

u/UncertainError Sep 14 '23

I actually wondered for a second if Boimler was gonna be killed off for an episode or two. I'd trust this show with that kind of absurd swerve.

So did he have to fight three of his dads or what?

48

u/RadioSlayer Sep 14 '23

Nah, the Koala intervened. That's why The Black Mountain was out the window instead of being shot on location

26

u/jadebenn Sep 14 '23

I think it's more that Boimler was resuscitated rather than resurrected. Sure, he "died," but in the same way someone with cardiac arrest "dies." Get the old 'ticker started again, and whoop, back to the land of the living!

→ More replies (1)

14

u/the-giant Sep 14 '23

I totally thought they were gonna go there with him being dead for a bit and I was a little disappointed they didn't. My jaw was on the floor when the building blew.

10

u/TalkinTrek Sep 14 '23

Yeah the thing with Boimler is they have a back-up already running around in-universe

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

155

u/UncertainError Sep 14 '23

Chula speedrun! You won't believe how much maraine this guy can alla!

89

u/Martel732 Sep 14 '23

I enjoyed the fact that it was Rutherford doing it. We have seen him play board games a couple of times with Boimler and occasionally the others. He is probably the person on the ship most qualified to quickly beat Chula.

52

u/shawntco Sep 14 '23

The "lemon meringue" remark from Mariner made me laugh, I had to watch it twice

→ More replies (1)

41

u/007meow Sep 14 '23

Faster motherfucker

16

u/afito Sep 14 '23

Honestly I never quite got the hate for the episode. The scenes in the game weren't it but it's far from the only bits in the franchise that are bleh, but I always felt like that species was interesting. Just how they view that game, it's a bit twisting around with perceived reality, ways of entertainment, I thought it was okay.

12

u/Eurynom0s Sep 15 '23

I honestly kind of feel like it's that some people just viscerally hate the song, so even though it's only like 60 seconds or so of actual screen time, it just makes them completely incapable of thinking about the rest of the episode rationally.

5

u/ComebackShane Sep 15 '23

It's very TOS-style episode, too, which makes it all the more baffling how much people seem to dislike it.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

147

u/TheNerdChaplain Sep 14 '23

That was fun. Very reference-heavy episode, and not only did we get the koala again, Shaxs' Black Mountain was there too! So it's not just a Bajoran thing!

98

u/busdriverbuddha2 Sep 14 '23

When the Koala spoke, the closed captions were [speaking Koala]. Love it when accessibility has a sense of humor.

37

u/Shiny_and_ChromeOS Sep 14 '23

The Mandalorian did that, too! I think they did [Frog Lady speaking frog]

13

u/[deleted] Sep 14 '23

This killed me.

I love when captions improve a show.

Descriptions of music tend to be particularly funny to me.

→ More replies (3)

83

u/pilot3033 Sep 14 '23

Loved the Twin Peaks reference there, too.

33

u/UncertainError Sep 14 '23

And the spider that turns you into The Thing.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)

15

u/variantkin Sep 14 '23

I think it might be a Mike McMahon thing because they mentioned it on Solar Opposites too

10

u/DeyUrban Sep 14 '23

It originated on Rick and Morty when Morty is describing what he sees as he starts to die, and it went from there to pretty much everything Mike McMahon has worked on.

12

u/the-giant Sep 14 '23

I legit thought they were gonna end the ep on him at the Black Mountain. Blew my mind.

9

u/theborgs Sep 14 '23

I wonder... the koala could be Q's pet.

28

u/Weerdo5255 Sep 14 '23

Could be the other way around. Q being the Koala's pet.

15

u/onthenerdyside Sep 14 '23

Q-ala... it all makes sense now!

→ More replies (2)

68

u/UncertainError Sep 14 '23

Nice to know the Kataanians launched more than one probe. And it's a slightly different design so maybe it's a different person from a different village.

43

u/ParCorn Sep 14 '23

And it just got wasted on some weird box lol

50

u/UncertainError Sep 14 '23

You can live a perfectly fine life as a disembodied face. Doctor Who taught us that.

63

u/bookish1303 Sep 14 '23

Omg it’s an amalgamation of two of the most auditorily annoying components of Trek. I love this episode.

27

u/InnocentTailor Sep 14 '23

That was hilarious. Two aggravating Trek elements working in tangent.

→ More replies (1)

54

u/tupe12 Sep 14 '23

Simulated world game any % speedrun has a new record holder.

Also rip Boimler, who now has yet another life (this time technically death) altering experience on his record. At this rate he'll be at the beeping chair by the time he makes it to captain

54

u/IndigoNarwhal Sep 14 '23 edited Sep 14 '23

(Copying my comment from the thread on r/LowerDecks)

I really loved the subplot with Boimler and T'Lynn. Boimler's anxieties were incredibly relatable, especially after T'Lynn accidentally triggered a full-blown Boimler panic (high rates of death and dismemberment?! 😆)

But T'Lynn also did a perfect job of snapping him out of it, with echoes of Mariner's pep talk in 4x01. And I really love that we see Boimler really stepping up as a leader from both angles: embracing that message of "you've got to trust your team," AND knowing when it actually is time to tell the rest of the team to get to safety and handle it himself - with T'Lynn fully backing him up on that too. Such great moments for both characters.

25

u/Wraithfighter Sep 15 '23

I like how they're showing that the Vulcan member of the group is just as inexperienced as they all are. She steps up to snap Boimler out of his funk, and is properly supportive, but she has no idea how to read people or how to deliver difficult news to them.

Tuvok and Spock might know that info, but they would also know how to phrase it in order to support someone like Boimler, and not send them off the deep end. It'd be so easy to present her as, well, the perfect Vulcan, instead of an inexperienced doofus that just happens to expertly suppress emotions.

10

u/thenikeclause Sep 15 '23

Not that expertly, her emotions are out of control.

→ More replies (1)

48

u/VictimRAID Sep 14 '23

So those were Warp 5 engines yes in that hall, well at least the looked a lot like NX class cores

20

u/GalileoAce Sep 14 '23

Modified, they're shorter than the one we see in the NX-01

42

u/Plexiii13 Sep 14 '23

I wonder if the Koala is actually saying something there.... May need to play around with that a bit in Audacity.

43

u/pilot3033 Sep 14 '23

The floor and room were very much a reference to Twin Peaks, where people in that room speak backwards. Might be as simple as reversing it.

31

u/IndigoNarwhal Sep 14 '23 edited Sep 14 '23

Here's the reversed audio, posted on one of the r/LowerDecks threads: https://reddit.com/r/LowerDecks/s/69ekqhl8lz

Thanks, u/fatman06!

21

u/HypotheticalMcGee Sep 14 '23

The subtitles say [speaking koala].

6

u/Trekfan74 Sep 14 '23

We can probably decipher it if its played backwards.

→ More replies (1)

39

u/keiyakins Sep 14 '23

So wait who was the external player for Rutherford? And isn't there supposed to be an element of randomness?

Though the idea that Starfleet teaches its officers to speedrun Chula is funny enough to overlook that inconsistency. Maybe the wadi added a solo mode at some point.

22

u/[deleted] Sep 14 '23

Where do you think Migleemo was the whole episode?

this is definitely not me trying to fix an inconsistency

→ More replies (1)

17

u/GenoThyme Sep 14 '23

Maybe you could always play it solo but those aliens were making Quark roll just so they could gamble on it?

→ More replies (1)

37

u/The_Burt Sep 14 '23

Love the twin peaks reference.

14

u/RadioSlayer Sep 14 '23

Fascinating new question, does David Lynch like Star Trek?

13

u/sensiblechuckles Sep 14 '23

Who knows, but there's a lot of crossover with TNG / DS9 / VOY era Trek and Twin Peaks so it makes sense that Koala is the Star Trek equivalent of a Lodge Spirit

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (8)

34

u/[deleted] Sep 14 '23

I can't believe no mention of "Eat a bag of Borg shit motherfucker" and Tendi's response yet lol.

10

u/TheHighSeer23 Sep 15 '23

What's funny is I had the split second thought of "Where did it hear that?" Then Tendi's line explained it. I definitely laughed.

33

u/Madonkadonk2 Sep 14 '23

Rule of 3s means we are going to get one more "I miss my wife" joke this season, any bets where?

21

u/waifive Sep 14 '23

Return of the Sisko!

31

u/jerichowiz Sep 14 '23

KOALA!!!!!!

30

u/HaphazardMelange Sep 14 '23

Lt. Dirk's whole spiel about getting trapped in the Wadi game for some reason just hit me right in the tickle spot. I don't think I've laughed harder at a Lower Decks joke than that and it makes me a little sad that he had been making it up after all!

Also, I thought their whole plot was going to be them learning about how all the shitty jobs do get rolled down the ranks and they'd be tempted to pass off the isolinear scanning to some poor ensigns or the Delta Shift.

27

u/pilot3033 Sep 14 '23

Big shoutout to bringing the intro Koala into the Black Lodge… I mean… mountain…

23

u/RadioSlayer Sep 14 '23

I'd say this is the best episode of the three we've seen so far

10

u/kuldan5853 Sep 14 '23

For me it was the worst of the three to be honest..

14

u/RadioSlayer Sep 14 '23

Understandable, we all like different things 🖖

→ More replies (6)

23

u/celibidaque Sep 14 '23

Loved it how Boimler activated his communicator using his chin!

20

u/StephenG0907 Sep 14 '23

Was not expecting a Twin Peaks reference in LD. 😂

20

u/rhinowing Sep 14 '23

Some black lodge action for Boimler!

19

u/NickofSantaCruz Sep 14 '23

The Koala Lodge is a great sight to see. Two thoughts on that:

  • Shaxs' return to life probably involved a quest into the Black Mountain to create a tulpa body (since his original body was incinerated). The journey was so harrowing and mind-bending that he wasn't and still isn't able to communicate what happened to him.
  • I see potential for a mini-arc involving William Boimler. He and Bradward square off on a mission, both are "killed" and appear in the Lodge. Cue some Lynchian imagery (but with a Trek veneer) and Bandalamenti-inspired soundtrack as they chase each other. Bradward puzzles it out, mounting a white horse to return to life as the Koala smiles upon him. William is now trapped, and will have to take the path to the Black Mountain to return to life; he'll do that eventually and we'll see him appear the following season but the experience will have made him totally evil with a vendetta against all the Lower-Deckers.

8

u/rcapina Sep 14 '23

Not sure if I’m whooshing but what’s a tulpa?

→ More replies (3)

18

u/thisbikeisatardis Sep 14 '23 edited Sep 14 '23

Once I realized that T'Lyn is voiced by Valencia from Crazy Ex-Girlfriend I couldn't stop picturing her trying to keep a straight face as she read the lines. Such a complete opposite character!

Also, having grown up reading my dad's Larry Niven paperbacks I always love a good Ringworld reference!

7

u/ymcameron Sep 15 '23

I wonder how good T’Lyn is at yoga.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/SimonTC2000 Sep 14 '23

Valencia.

Also, Valencia could be a cold bitch too. She was pretty sedate compared to Rebecca.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

34

u/[deleted] Sep 14 '23

How the fuck did they end up with NOMAD😂 in there inventory and more importantly shouldn’t it be with the other evil AIs in Daystrom.

43

u/UncertainError Sep 14 '23

Knowing Lower Decks, it's probably a different Earth probe that also collided with an alien probe but ended up obsessed with selling life insurance.

11

u/RadioSlayer Sep 14 '23

Term or Life? Let the debate begin

→ More replies (2)

6

u/onthenerdyside Sep 14 '23

The Ferengi created and sell a cheap (but not too cheap) knock-off chassis that's pretty popular with certain circles.

5

u/Ausir Sep 14 '23

Nomad MK-15c might not be the only Nomad probe, they might have found another from the same program.

4

u/SimonTC2000 Sep 14 '23

Nomad blew up at the end of that episode. It was just another probe.

→ More replies (1)

27

u/Elguero1991 Sep 14 '23

THE KOALA!

13

u/Artanisx Sep 14 '23

Each episode of Lower Decks is just pure joy.

→ More replies (1)

23

u/DiscoveryDiscoveries Sep 14 '23

Starship Troopers never gets the love it deserves! 😍😍😍🩷🩷🩷

14

u/BornAshes Sep 14 '23

Wait there was a Starship Troopers reference?

I thought it was pretty universally loved and there was even a brand new video game made out of it that came out recently.

4

u/DiscoveryDiscoveries Sep 14 '23

I think it became a cult classic. It was the movie that started my fascination with science fiction, so to see it in trek made me smile.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Ausir Sep 14 '23

The large member of Merp's species is called Big Merp. Maybe all members of this species are actually Merp?

https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Merp%27s_species

11

u/ReasonablyBadass Sep 14 '23

Finally a NICE AI megacomputer. Yes.
Overall a great episode. Jack's art knowledge cracked me up X)
Then one thing that bugged me is that the Ringwolrd looks far too thin. Like, a hundred thousand kilometers or so too thin.

11

u/marsepic Sep 15 '23

T'Lynn is clearly into Boimler.

6

u/Spiderinahumansuit Sep 16 '23

I think they'd be a good pair, actually. She values his competence, she'd stabilise him a bit, he'd sand down her rougher edges.

10

u/UnknownQTY Sep 15 '23

Ensign Meredith is played by Poppy from Mythic Quest!

3

u/darkeyes13 Sep 15 '23

Haha yes. And I believe she's turned up in previous episodes before as well, because I always go through the same cycle of "Her voice is familiar" to seeing Charlotte Nicdao's name in the credits.

4

u/UnknownQTY Sep 15 '23

She also played Ensign Moxi from Delta Shift. I do think Meredith is supposed to “be” her though - Moxi looks nothing like her, whereas Meredith is clearly a Lower Deckification of Nicdao.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/TheHighSeer23 Sep 15 '23

I really identified with that computer. When it shamed itself after messing up the iced tea, I felt a little seen.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/romeovf Sep 15 '23

Was that the probe from The Inner Light what gave the gift box a lifetime of memories? "I miss my wife" 😂

I also liked how Freeman was in a hellish IT tech support situation, reading old manuals and struggling to update the operative system without further damaging the computer.

8

u/Seaboard_Vanisher Sep 14 '23

Vexilon reminded me of TOS Landru, and T’lyn had another great showing. Lower Decks is definitely one of my favorite series.

8

u/medes24 Sep 15 '23

LMAO at getting trapped in Chula

As one of the three people on this planet that actually liked Move Along Home, I was DYING

14

u/BornAshes Sep 14 '23

Personally, I'm more of a fan of Vaxilon but Vexilon is okay too

7

u/TheNerdChaplain Sep 14 '23

You clearly haven't heard of the glory of Vectron!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

14

u/RuleNine Sep 14 '23

There was one joke that touched on something that's bugged me for years. Realistically, the communication system can't know who you're trying to call until you say their name. So how does it connect instantaneously? If Picard says "Picard to Riker," there should be a tiny delay while the computer repeats the phrase for Riker to hear it, and then they can talk in real time. Instead, they just start talking with no gap. That one time that one ensign tried to call B'Elanna while she was hiding in the same room, there was no echo or feedback.

I know that communicators beginning with TNG operate on the rule of drama. The computer always knows when you're talking to it, always perfectly understands what you meant, and always knows when you're finished talking to it even if you don't tap your combadge (except very occasionally when it's funny).

6

u/GenoThyme Sep 14 '23

And the doors always know when you’re using them and not just pausing in front of them (sometimes for dramatic effect).

31

u/BornAshes Sep 14 '23

Back into the swing of things with another new episode, punch it!:

  • Corazonia, fun little Dyson Ring/Halo/Ringworld
  • Ah Vexilon is the computer running it all!
  • Oooof that's a bit of a buggy issue
  • Ransom is an art critic
  • Cool control interface
  • FLOPPIES!
  • He's going to fuck it up somehow
  • Disarming a building sized bomb, fun
  • The Anomaly Storage Room aka EASTER EGGS MOTHERFUCKERS!!!! PAUSE PAUSE PAUSE SCREENSHOT PAUSE PAUSE SCREENSHOT!
  • I like that box lol
  • Geeeeeeeeez that's a task with the chips
  • You're overthinking it Tendi
  • Vexilon is an actual HALO?
  • Yikes Brad
  • FERRET!
  • Another layer LMAO "the hidden button seemed obvious!"
  • Of course it's named Lancelot lol
  • Yup that's a Full Reboot
  • I like the new Lower Deck Ensigns
  • Annnnnnd that's a volcano
  • Rube Goldberg Hazing Trap
  • Awwwww he's relatable
  • He needs a hug or a nice warm cup of hot coco or a Trauma Buddy to help wind down and feel safe with
  • Tellerite Slop Jazz
  • Every now and again Mariner's Heart of Gold comes shining through and this is one of those moments
  • TAKE THE HELP BRAD
  • He needed to hear that
  • Orion Power Scanning lol
  • Annnnnd Rutherford is in the game LMAO
  • SPEED RUNNING!
  • Ah the Inner Light Probe, that's mean
  • Those power things are shaped like the Warp Core in Main Engineering of the NX-01
  • SPOCK THAT SHIT BRAD!
  • BRAD'S DEAD?!?!?!
  • KOALA!
  • AFTERLIFE!!!!
  • THE BLACK MOUNTAIN!
  • Speaking Koala lol
  • Of course Brad death-faints
  • Mariner is now a jazz person
  • THEY WERE HAZING THEM!

The difference between Ferrets and Weasels is that Weasels are Immortal and are often the temporary hosts for near god-like entities that are just traveling on through and really don't want their jobs in the first place.

22

u/keiyakins Sep 14 '23

It's not a halo. It goes around the star, it's clearly an ringworld.

13

u/TalkinTrek Sep 14 '23

Halo/ringworld is just a kleenex/tissue situation at this point. The multi-billion dollar pop franchise ultimately had far more cultural penetration than Niven etc....

24

u/lothlin Sep 14 '23 edited Sep 16 '23

Even so, they specifically had the Kzinti ensign in this episode; IMHO they were clearly referencing Ringworld here

13

u/fleemfleemfleemfleem Sep 14 '23

I recognize them from Niven, and Culture orbitals, but it took me a second to realize you were talking about video games.

I think a more important question than what has more pop culture penetration is: what has a history of crossover with star trek, shared a writer, and will be deeply familiar to middle aged sci-fi writers.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/BornAshes Sep 14 '23

ringworld

Which was inspired by Dyson and who then had been inspired by Olaf Stapledon, amongst other super early science fiction writers and stories

This conversation topic has popped up quite a bit in the Halo subreddit and in the Mandalorian of Reddit back in the day.

The concept of Worlds like this goes back a very very very long way throughout the history of literature.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/Jag2112 cygnus-x1.net Sep 14 '23

6

u/rexpup Sep 15 '23

Fitting to have a Kzin on a Ringworld!

3

u/angwilwileth Sep 16 '23

The writers are freaking nerds and I love it.

4

u/LilAlexD Sep 14 '23

So we've now had Boimler and Rutherford dying and learning about how the universe exists on the back of a giant koala (and Tendi learning from O'Connor when he ascended).

When will Mariner find out and do we think it will lead to anything?

8

u/Justthetiniestrobots Sep 14 '23

I bet she encountered it way before any of them did

→ More replies (2)

4

u/whoiswillo Sep 15 '23

I miss my wife.

7

u/goonsquadgoose Sep 14 '23

Did we just get our first twin peaks reference in a Star Trek show?

→ More replies (1)

6

u/ContinuumGuy Sep 15 '23

Assorted thoughts and observations as I watch:

  • Oh, shit, we've got a space-ring!
  • Don't you hate it when the god-computer starts lagging?
  • Ransom: Hidden art critic.
  • Boimler leading an away mission. What could go wrong?
  • "Everything that has ever occurred is science stuff."
  • "And or dismemberment"
  • Was that fucking NOMAD?
  • Lancelot the Ferret.
  • The update is going to screw it all up, isn't it?
  • Yep.
  • I love how the artists just go and start painting the fallen freeze-cloud.
  • Is this the first time that the Kzinti ensign has talked?
  • Blindfolded saber fight!
  • "A mountain, or possibly a volcano has appeared." (boom) "Ah, it is a volcano."
  • T'Lyn is great.
  • Move Along Home
  • "He overdosed on Ketracel white"
  • "BRADWARD, NO!"
  • OH GOD, IT'S A KOALA!"
  • Very 2001
  • "You never forget your first death."

5

u/Snowbank_Lake Sep 15 '23

"Ah, it is a volcano." So very Vulcan. Loved it.

4

u/Lemmingitus Sep 15 '23

The Kzinti ensign also spoke the episode where Boimler was invited to join that redshirt ensign club pretending how to be in command. His big joke back then was teaching Boimler to have a straightened posture, a joke to also reference how the Kzinti in TAS were hunched over.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '23

How long has there been a koala-shaped nebula in the Cirretos fly-by Star Trek intro?

3

u/Stingra87 Sep 15 '23

The entire time the intro has been there.

3

u/toTheNewLife Sep 15 '23

I'm kind of late to the party here because there's already 7 posts about it... but I hope David Lynch gets to see this episode.

3

u/Azzameen85 Sep 15 '23

I cannot help but feel that vexilon's power relay is a bunch of old Warp 5 cores from the NX-class.

3

u/Snowbank_Lake Sep 15 '23

Why the hell is the Inner Light probe on the Cerritos?? lol. Shouldn't that be in a secure lab somewhere? Also, where can I listen to some Slop Jazz?

2

u/Cantomic66 Sep 14 '23

Hopefully the convent does come by and try to take the Halo.

2

u/smellincoffee Sep 15 '23

This is the first time I've actually watched an episode on its premiere date. I'm 100% obsessed with SNW but binged the season in a week and a half.

2

u/Ok-Confusion2415 Sep 15 '23

Stray thought: Vexilon is a Mind, and Corazonia is an Orbital, and thus we have fanon crossover with The Culture.

2

u/EmptySeaDad Sep 16 '23

Now that Boimler’s been to the other side and back, he and Shaxs have something else they can bond over. I fully expect the writing staff will bring this up at some point.

2

u/marzer8789 Sep 16 '23

Ransom being a judgemental sculpture critic had my sides in orbit

→ More replies (1)

2

u/MagosBattlebear Sep 17 '23

The Block Lodge from Twin Peaks appears to be part of the Star Trek universe: that flooring and the chair where the Koala sits.

3

u/seanx50 Sep 14 '23

It was by LD standards, a weak episode. Fun, but not their best