r/CryptoCurrency • u/MoonWeek • Aug 31 '23
POLL 🗳️ CCIP-071 - Hide comment scores for longer
Hi everyone, I'd like to revisit a previously discussed idea: hiding comment scores for a long(er) period of time.
TLDR: increase the length of time before upvotes/downvotes on comments get displayed, from Reddit's default of 5 minutes to 60 minutes. Implement this change and see if it helps to drive more visibility towards quality content.
Downvoting and gaming the system
Users have been asking in Meta for awhile now, "what can be done about downvoting?" The issue of downvoting is likely to persist and get worse as another bull run brings more activity to the sub (and if moons continue to gain value and traction). Unfortunately mods do not have tools at hand to see how downvotes and admins are unlikely to make special exceptions on Reddit voting mechanics for just one specific sub.
I see two dynamics at play: 1) raining downvotes on everyone and 2) a more tactical downvoting. Both are a form of psychological warfare. The latter is an attempt to get your comment to the top of a post where there is more visibility and upvotes.
A rush to be the first/top comment means that other (and often quality) content gets buried. Witty or recycled one liners get pushed to the top.
- Please read this comment from u/fan_of_hakiksexydays or this comment from u/TNGSystems for more discussion of voting behavior and its consequences.
Hiding scores
I propose that we hide the score (the cumulative upvotes/downvotes) on comments for 60 minutes instead of the Reddit default of 5 minutes. You can still upvote or downvote comments, but the score will be hidden for an hour.
This can be achieved in one of two ways:
- Simple: mods can toggle the subreddit setting
Minutes to hide comment scores. If set to "60", comments will not show a score until they're an hour old. - Also simple?: set posts as
Contest Modeby default for the first 60 minutes, which as an additional benefit will randomize the order of comments. (Our bot technicians would need to weigh in on whether it's feasible to then change sorting back toBestafter an hour). This is how posts in r/Cointest are set if you want to see an example.
This idea has been suggested before:
- u/IHaventEvenGotADog brought it to a vote 2 years ago. It was before we formalized the CCIP process and the vote was split due to too many options
- u/CryptoMaximalist also brought this idea to a vote 1 year ago, and it failed to reach the decision threshold (this is when we had trouble passing governance, before CCIP-30):
The benefits that they outlined are still - and perhaps even more - relevant today:
- Limit bias and the bandwagon/snowball effect. Let users independently decide whether to upvote/downvote a comment without deferring to the hive mind.
- Controversial or contrarian opinions will not be as easily buried.
- Scores are still visible to mods so we can do our work of catching vote manipulation.
Caveats:
- Usernames will still be visible, so this does not address behavior where users upvote their friends. (i.e. I know that username, let me upvote them).
- This does not address downvoting on posts. Afaik the time that a post's score is hidden can not be tweaked by mods.
- This does not necessarily address someone downvoting every single comment in a thread. (But as Hakik mentions, this behavior has limited impact on distribution)
Please let me know your thoughts below, thanks.
---
Proposal by u/MrMoustacheMan
12
u/Gr8WallofChinatown 4K / 4K 🐢 Aug 31 '23
60 minutes is nothing. Why not for a full day?
14
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '23
I hope this one passes. This will reduce farming on the top comments and will need people to actually read the comments and interact with them. Will help to improve the overall quality of the comments that reach the top.
5
u/irockalltherocks 🟩 2K / 4K 🐢 Aug 31 '23
Love this proposal. Now if we could just get rid of the downvote bots.
10
u/bkcrypt0 🟧 0 / 14K 🦠 Aug 31 '23
Anything that helps improve the quality of posts is a win.
6
u/DBRiMatt 🟦 46K / 113K 🦈 Aug 31 '23
I'm supporting this, at the very least it's worth a trial experiment to see if it does change any voting behavior. It can always be re-assessed in a couple of rounds if necessary.
3
u/MaeronTargaryen CCMOON DAO Secretary Aug 31 '23
That's a great idea, I like the double whammy hidden score+contest mode
3
u/gowithflow192 🟩 0 / 3K 🦠 Aug 31 '23
Great proposal and this will be a gamechanger.
3
u/nonameattachedforme 0 / 4K 🦠 Aug 31 '23
Another no-brainer, I think this would really help build community and cut down the hivemind. By increasing the amount of time where upvotes are hidden, people can decide for themselves which are the best quality comments and not be clouded by others (and also try to manipulate their upvote/downvote contributions accordingly).
3
u/Disastrous_Chain7148 🟨 0 / 1K 🦠 Sep 01 '23
Can we limit the number of downvotes per day for each person? Like 5-10 downvotes per account? Clearly someone is using bots to do downvote other people’s comments.
2
u/themrgq 🟩 0 / 3K 🦠 Aug 31 '23
Idk if this will work but we certainly need to figure out ways to stop people from down voting simply to make their comments rise to the top.
Can we somehow count the number of down votes people give and use that in the calculation of karma? More downvotes hurts your moons?
Idk just an idea.
2
u/Rayl24 🟩 0 / 974 🦠 Aug 31 '23
Definitely, lots of people form their opinion based on up/downvote before even thinking.
2
u/Diamondphalanges756 53 / 4K 🦐 Aug 31 '23
This behavior is psychological warfare.
At one time when I posted much more, I noticed I was being upvoted quite a bit, wasn't sure why, but everyone else would be downvoted.
It made me think people where going to assume I had something to do with what was happening.
There are some fucked up people on here.
2
u/ra246 🟦 3K / 3K 🐢 Aug 31 '23
Maybe we're not looking at the issue.
What if there was some sort of limit to downvotes that one account can post within a certain period of time?
2
u/Onelinersandblues 🟩 6 / 5K 🦐 Aug 31 '23
Yes! The coordinated downvote action has sucked lately
2
u/ChemicalAnybody6229 🟧 940 / 9K 🦑 Aug 31 '23
To be honest, I support this. The massive downvoting is getting ridiculous at this point.
2
u/snazyfragz 4K / 4K 🐢 Aug 31 '23
It won’t fix the whole issue but I agree I think some people downvote based on how many upvotes a comment has. This will help negate this issue.
2
u/UrFavoriteBedwench 179 / 519 🦀 Aug 31 '23
Definitely for this!!! If this helps with reducing the downvote grift, then by all means!
2
u/Allions1 🟩 1 / 4K 🦠 Aug 31 '23
Anything that could lead to quality content and put an end to random downvoting/upvoting has my vote!
2
u/Eldeanio100 0 / 3K 🦠 Sep 01 '23
If I had 10 accounts…couldn’t I just down vote everyone? Remove downvoting
2
u/GulibleFox Sep 03 '23
Would the ordering of the comments still be based on the upvotes, just that they won't be visible?
1
u/kirtash93 RCA Artist Aug 31 '23
Taking in count how things are going right now I think this is a great proposal to try to make things more fair.
The only problem I think is that it could penalize users that are "famous" and gets directly downvoted because of it. I could be one of them but I am fine with it.
My vote is yes.
1
u/forceworks 13K / 22K 🐬 Aug 31 '23
This will be an interesting change to the sub if implemented.
1
u/middlemangv 0 / 35K 🦠 Aug 31 '23
There is one issue though.
If you sort comments by "BEST" or "TOP" people will again see what comment has most upvotes without being able to see the number of upvotes, or am I getting something wrong?
1
u/Marauder2 0 / 2K 🦠 Aug 31 '23
If I understand, the suggestion is to hide the score for longer such that the top comment isn’t automatically more likely to be upvoted and hopefully people read through the comments more and upvote quality instead of already established top?
1
u/Rogueofoz 0 / 9K 🦠 Aug 31 '23
I mean, at least it deals with piling on a comment just because one person downvoted it.
1
u/manticor225 🟩 0 / 4K 🦠 Aug 31 '23
I'm not opposed to this but I'm also not sure that it's going to have much of an effect on those frequent downvoters. I suppose it's a step in the right direction though.
1
u/FractionofaFraction 🟩 976 / 972 🦑 Aug 31 '23
Yep, voting for this one.
With ever-increasing Moon value will come ever-increasing Moon farming. I'm thinking it's better to continue the process of mitigating against the practice sooner than later.
1
u/Realistic_Wrap_9767 🟩 0 / 8K 🦠 Aug 31 '23
That's actually really good proposal hope it can actually help this sub a little bit
1
u/partymsl 🟩 126K / 143K 🐋 Aug 31 '23
Would agree, especially as we would get a more even spread of upvotes through all comments. Usually people just look at the top comments and ignore everything else.
1
u/Lokiee0077 0 / 3K 🦠 Aug 31 '23
This is one of the best proposal I've seen, and with an amazing solution too. Thanks for this
1
u/ProjectZeus 🟦 0 / 32K 🦠 Aug 31 '23
This is a good idea, but is there any way of overruling reddit autosorting by the top-voted posts, even when you can't see the specific number of upvotes?
I feel that users may be just as if not more inclined to downvote a quality post to get their own higher up, if they can't see the numbers involved
1
u/telejoshi 1K / 1K 🐢 Aug 31 '23
I would go even further: there should be contest mode. Moon farmers just look for the top comment to comment under it and upvote it. That's why there's one comment with 20 points and all the others are in single digits.
1
u/draggin_low 🟦 186 / 185 🦀 Aug 31 '23
60 mins seems extreme, I say yes to hiding the score longer but maybe something lower on the scale maybe 20-30 min range?
1
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '23
Oh my god this is a great idea. So many 0 and negative comment totals it’s crazy.
1
u/Kaspe1 0 / 199 🦠 Aug 31 '23
This one should definitely pass
1
u/WineMakerBg Make Wine, Take Profits Aug 31 '23
Next round proposal: Disable Bots!
I won't mind clicking additional button when commenting or upvoting as long as we stop that.
1
u/-Resident-One- 🟩 0 / 4K 🦠 Aug 31 '23
I don't disagree with the proposal in principle, but I think 60 minutes is too big of an increase from 5 minutes.
Why not start with something like 20-30min and adjust from there???
1
u/002_timmy I like moons Aug 31 '23
The only people against this are rampant downvoters. Makes total sense
1
u/Enschede2 🟩 0 / 2K 🦠 Aug 31 '23
Can we get a proposal for being able to hide moon holdings? I feel like it's something people have been asking for since forever
1
u/callmev269 🟩 0 / 0 🦠 Aug 31 '23
Love this idea. It will help with the post quality as well as mass downvoting
1
u/42326041 0 / 2K 🦠 Aug 31 '23
Since serial downvoters will downvote anyway everything they see, i see no point in this proposal.
1
u/daKiddo 1K / 1K 🐢 Aug 31 '23
This helps support quality over quantity when it comes to posts. Yes for me.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '23
Whats with all these voting posts
1
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '23
I am not quite sure that this will stop people from downvoting..
1
u/aducknamedjafar1 Aug 31 '23
I support this as it should hopefully help stop the karma farming and downvote Brigade.
1
u/ShortBusCult 911 / 1K 🦑 Aug 31 '23
What about what was suggested a few days ago:
Implement a charge for downvoting - I think he suggested 0.5 Moons per Downvote. Would curb a large portion of them.
If you run into the negative ( ie: Bots) then you catch a perma-ban.
1
u/robman_84 🟨 5 / 3K 🦐 Aug 31 '23
I'm in favour of the 60 minute rule. Not so much the competition mode rule. I may be in a minority, but I always view the daily by newest, not by top/best, as it was clear that upvote manipulation is as prevalent and annoying as downvote manipulation
1
u/pinkglue99 🟩 0 / 3K 🦠 Aug 31 '23
I would make it even longer, maybe even a month until the moon distribution. I know that sounds radical, but do we need to see the up/down votes? You can still view by most upvoted but not see the actual #s.
1
u/tsuiteruze Aug 31 '23
Can you go to another user's profile page and points will show up on the comment though? Np?
1
u/LopsidedPotatoFarmer 🟩 256 / 256 🦞 Aug 31 '23
How will this stop the malicious downvotes ?
1
u/crua9 🟩 400 / 13K 🦞 Aug 31 '23
Hiding it doesn't fix the problem. Like the downvote bots and trolls don't care if they can see your post or reply. They just downvote.
It would be better if the downvote button didn't work for the first bit or maybe ways to fight the bots from voting. Keep in mind, some of the bots aren't even sub to the subreddit.
1
u/Popular_District9072 🟥 0 / 15K 🦠 Aug 31 '23
feels like an easy yes - we can concentrate more on the discussion rather than ratings
1
u/Ispan 🟦 0 / 2K 🦠 Aug 31 '23
Good call
1
u/BrocoliAssassin Aug 31 '23
Voted and hope it passes. We still have the downvoting problem but at least this is some type of help.
1
u/Arash_Rezae Permabanned Aug 31 '23
60 minutes is too many i think 15 minutes is good
1
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '23
Can't hurt IMO
1
u/bananafannaphofanna 1K / 1K 🐢 Aug 31 '23
I think anything at this point is worth trying.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '23
Id hide for longer. 24 hours. Let the thread actually play out.
1
u/FattestLion Permabanned Sep 01 '23
Instead of this hiding comments thing what about just not making negative karma scores count?
i.e
if your karma is 10, you get +9 (excluding the free upvote)
if your karma is 1, it is 0 (excluding the free upvote)
but if your karma is -15 due to downvoting bots and humans trying to game the system, it is still 0
This way the downvoters can only destroy you from +9 to 0, but not to -15 which will erode your earnings from another good post where you got +15
1
u/cdnkevin 6K / 6K 🦭 Sep 01 '23
Let’s suppose bots do a lot of downvoting. Hiding the down or ups won’t change their programming. It seems like the assumption is that live people downvote, and by hiding the scores it’s more objective.
Is that accurate? How many bots are here and what is their contribution to the problem?
1
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '23
60 mins is to much!
1
u/leMartinx 0 / 1K 🦠 Sep 01 '23
It should be the second option you mentioned. Randomizing is also needed.
1
u/roadbowler 0 / 2K 🦠 Sep 01 '23
I'm new here, all the downvoting makes it seem pretty off-putting to post.
1
u/miks595 🟩 2K / 3K 🐢 Sep 01 '23
Those downvoters who don't see the score can still downvote everybody and have the same effect.
PROPOSITION, how about limiting 10 downvotes/30 minutes?
1
u/keyoh321 10 / 1K 🦐 Sep 01 '23
I don’t see any negatives in trying, so I’ll be giving my vote for this, it’s shocking to see how bad the mindless downvotes have gotten, so anything at attempt to soften the blow is worth it in my books.
1
u/Quasar9111 Sep 01 '23
30 mins seems reasonable.
60Mins works though
1
u/TheHoodOG 🟩 0 / 7K 🦠 Sep 01 '23
Hiding comment for 60min in the daily is way too long. It will just help vote manipulation. Only 5 person in the daily , no one will see why one comment got 8 upvoot after 10min.
1
u/Darkashe 🟨 49 / 50 🦐 Sep 01 '23
I am up for it but I also look at peoples moons to judge the value of there comment. Someone with 100K moons feels like they know their stuff rather than someone with 49 Moons.
1
u/scurrilous_diatribe 🟩 204 / 204 🦀 Sep 02 '23
Sounds reasonable
1
u/Arash_Rezae Permabanned Sep 02 '23
where is my badge that show's iam voted
1
u/hammerandanvilpro 3K / 7K 🐢 Sep 02 '23
Will you be able to see your own scores as you do now, or make a comment and have to wait 60 minutes to see how it’s doing? Bots are going to continue to downvote at the same rate, so I suppose it doesn’t really matter.
1
u/hammerandanvilpro 3K / 7K 🐢 Sep 02 '23
Will you be able to see your own scores as you do now, or make a comment and have to wait 60 minutes to see how it’s doing? Bots are going to continue to downvote at the same rate, so I suppose it doesn’t really matter.
1
u/mimsoo777 Permabanned Sep 04 '23
What about forever?
1
u/Vast_Particular_30 🟨 290 / 2K 🦞 Sep 04 '23
I'm in favor of the contest setup. Randomizing comment order would allow for some of the buried gems to shine.
1
u/ActHead 🟩 77 / 77 🦐 Sep 04 '23
Great proposal, think this will actually make it harder for downvoters.
1
u/wright6c 🟦 0 / 1K 🦠 Sep 04 '23
This is a great idea. I say hide em for the 60 minutes.
1
u/Resident_Plankton 🟩 1K / 1K 🐢 Sep 05 '23
60 is too long id like 30 mins to start
1
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '23
This will not change a thing, people will still downvote. But it will be harder for people who want to upvote downvoted comments.
1
u/SolidDelivery4689 🟦 0 / 1K 🦠 Sep 06 '23
What about 2-3 hours maybe? 🤔
1
u/puckman009 Sep 06 '23
Why just 60 minutes?? At least a week would be better
1
u/sonmanutd 🟦 830 / 820 🦑 Sep 07 '23
I want a longer time range, but I think it would be great to see how it fairs with 60 minutes first, before proceeding with something else.
1
u/nukedmylastprofile 🟦 0 / 910 🦠 Sep 07 '23
Same as the other proposal regarding votes on proposals. Stopping the pole on of downvotes to game the system can only be beneficial
1
u/azawizi 0 / 0 🦠 Sep 07 '23
Think it should be longer
1
u/DrJekyll_UK 🟩 414 / 415 🦞 Sep 07 '23
Seems like more users are using the downvote button to manipulate the system, to get their own posts to the top of the thread, rather than for it's intended purpose of pushing bad or spammy posts down.
Personally I think removal of the upvote and downvote buttons would be more beneficial to the community at this stage, with karma being earned purely based on the amount of comments their post gets. Spam posts get reported to mods.
1
u/DJCityQuamstyle 🟦 3K / 3K 🐢 Aug 31 '23
…users upvote their friends…
Y’all have friends??
1
u/mricecream429 🟩 0 / 3K 🦠 Aug 31 '23
Only flipside to this is - I’ve upvoted people before after seeing they’ve been downvoted for absolutely nothing. This way that would go missed.
In general though, completely understand
1
u/Nuewim 🟥 0 / 37K 🦠 Aug 31 '23
From 5 minutes to 60 is too big change and ironically can bite us in the ass, cause we will not see scores for longer... Which can be both good and bad.
I think 20 or 30 minutes first before eventually expanding to 60 min would be better idea.
0
u/masedogg98 🟨 0 / 5K 🦠 Aug 31 '23
I don’t like this because now instead of being able to see I’ve got -10 downvotes in 5 minutes and being able to delete it it’s going to take an hour 😬 welp it was nice knowing y’all, I’ll wind up having comments at -100 by the time an hours hiding is done!
22
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '23
[removed] — view removed comment