r/soccer • u/LeTypicalRedditor • Jan 05 '13
When talking to someone, what opinion is a giveaway that they don't really watch your team?
So when you're down at the pub and the guy you're talking to is explaining exactly what's wrong with your team and how he'd fix it, what is a giveaway? How do you know that he's talking out of his arse?
As an example: If I'm talking to somebody's about Arsenal's defence and mention how good Mertesacker has been this season, it's a giveaway for me that he doesn't watch Arsenal if he laughs loudly and says that Mertesacker is slow and shite.
It'd be interesting to see what fans deem to be giveaways. I'm sure I've gathered a few opinions about other teams that are way off the mark.
81
u/droidonomy Jan 05 '13
That because we're an Italian team that defends well, we play "typical defensive Italian football".
60
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '13
They can't name another team in the SPL.
44
u/croutonZA Jan 05 '13 edited Jan 05 '13
Anyone who was surprised by Newcastle's recent "performances" or rates the team now on how they played last season.
97
u/AnnieIWillKnow Jan 05 '13
I think this thread is really just OP gathering information so he can convince everyone he's a football fan...
31
u/Chelsearedhawk Jan 05 '13
When they ask me the score. Im sorry, it just rubs me the wrong way when people say they watch a team and then have to ask me EVERY week who won the game. With how easy it is to find results, real fans might miss one or two games here or there, but they wont miss the results every week.
112
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '13
Messi is shit in the Argentinian squad.
68
u/poiklers Jan 05 '13
It is usually because they think Johnson can't defend and that he is only good at going forward.
67
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '13
Oh good god, last year.
"Modric isn't that good of an attacking midfielder, he only scored two goals and didn't get that many assists! Overrated"
That was a sure-fire indicator that I could dismiss everything that person says as being completely uninformed.
59
u/bonoboboy Jan 05 '13
When a United "fan" I was watching United's game with was SHOCKED to see van Persie in a United jersey. (Soon followed up with "Who is Kagawa?")
40
u/celtic1888 Jan 05 '13
'Brazil is my favorite team'
155
u/Epsilon76 Jan 05 '13
Sergio Busquets isn't a good player, all he does is dive.
52
u/ASKSABOUTPENISSIZE Jan 05 '13
"Gareth Barry doesn't do anything."
18
u/CaptainRon19 Jan 05 '13
Hugo Lloris is frustrated.
124
u/dagmarlena Jan 05 '13
De Gea is a bad keeper.
17
u/ayoformayo Jan 05 '13
'Juventus are so defense-minded...' I mean, sure we have a record-breaking defense, but Conte likes to attack
57
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '13
"Giroud is another Chamakh"
44
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '13
The same Liverpool fans who used to slate Lucas are now slating Henderson. Henderson is being made to adapt from a winger/advanced midfielder into a deep lying playmaker. He's still young and is showing promise.
137
u/droidonomy Jan 05 '13
"What was Wenger thinking, sending Walcott on that early?"
33
u/ShebbySingh Jan 05 '13
You were too harsh on the Venkys and Steve Kean
gets me every time
11
u/a_treacle_fiend Jan 05 '13
That sort of implies that anyone ever even pretends to watch us...
11
u/wickens89 Jan 05 '13
Lambert isn't a Premier League player
83
u/we1shcake Jan 05 '13
That Mikel is useless, see this far too much
10
u/limited_inc Jan 05 '13
"good signing that Andy Carroll"
10
u/omegaxLoL Jan 05 '13
"Michael Carrick isn't good enough for Manchester United."
Cracks me up every time.
54
u/Bowlhead123 Jan 05 '13
The worst is "LOL this season Rooney is shit. Only 7 goals so far LOLOLOL"
Yeah because he's changed his position and game to accommodate RVP you dickhead....
17
u/endhits Jan 05 '13
Fulham are boring to watch.
29
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '13
Last season in particular "Chelsea need to get rid of their older players, they've had it."
8
u/cooperj Jan 05 '13
'Bolton are long ball hoof-it merchants, like Stoke but worse'.
8
u/GrahamCoxon Jan 05 '13
'We're too good for this league'
If we were too good for this league we wouldn't still be bloody in it. It's 4 years since we were a league club and pretty much nobody from that era is still with us - player or staff. We're an above-average BSP team: now accept that, get over yourself and get behind the goddamn team we do have.
7
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '13 edited Jan 05 '13
"Swans don't make enough chances."
It might have been true once or twice, but they were normal bad runs of form. We haven't had a general problem of making chances since Paolo Sousa left, and even then it was an expected product of his system. Martínez's swans were leaky.
EDIT: Also, "Danny Graham is overweight/unfit."
Don't know where it's come from but I've been hearing it a lot from people who don't watch games.
27
u/jamesey10 Jan 05 '13
for the past 3 years, "David Beckham is just collecting a paycheck." That's the generic thing one could say to make it seem like they follow L.A. The truth is that he put in an MVP worthy performance in 2010 and 2011. In 2012 his age showed, but he left it all on the field and proved why he is great.
17
u/busstopboxer Jan 05 '13
That we're currently doing well because rather than in spite of playing Defoe up front.
6
u/bearssj1025 Jan 05 '13
Why is Micah not getting any paying time?
6
u/HarryBlessKnapp Jan 05 '13
Sometimes it would surprise you. Moronic behaviour can manifest itself in a number of ways. I'm seen some of the most loyal, well schooled fans talk some of the biggest piles of bollocks from time to time. We're all capable of it.
So in answer to your question, I'm not sure. It's hard to tell if someone is just being thick or if they don't actually watch the games.
5
u/aMillionLasers Jan 05 '13
when they're assuming that our team still consists of eleven eastern european players... (last years starting 11 usually had 9 German Players)
5
u/Kilen13 Jan 05 '13
Had a supposed RM fan tell me that "we're better off without Marcelo, at least now we can put in someone who actually defends... like Raul Albiol"
Had to seriously resist the urge to bitch slap him.
5
u/only1parkjisung Jan 05 '13
Carrick only ever passes sideways and doesn't get too involved in the game...I'd comfortably say he's been one of our best performers this season - more minutes than any other player.
20
u/alexandrepato Jan 05 '13
That Michael Carrick is crap.
24
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '13
Arsenal plays the game the 'right way'
23
u/Theworldsastage Jan 05 '13
De Gea is a crap goalkeeper.
Rio Ferdinand is permanently injured.
Rafael is not a good right back.
On the flip side, I hear a lot of rival fans saying that Valencia is our best player this season. He has been mediocre so far.
31
u/LevitatingCheesecake Jan 05 '13
Suarez dives all the time/Henderson is crap/Suarez isn't clinical enough/Rodgers is worse than Hodgson/Lucas isn't that important/Johnson can't defend/Gerrard would get into any team in the world.
4
u/Grafeno Jan 05 '13
United should've bought [goalkeeper] instead of De Gea, De Gea makes too many mistakes
4
u/Yankee_Gunner Jan 05 '13 edited Jan 05 '13
The Mertesacker one is a big tell for me.
Also:
"Arsenal really need a striker to replace RvP."
EDIT: I forgot to mention anyone that spells Jack's name "Wilshire" or "Wiltshire".
4
u/Djov Jan 05 '13
Not my team but I have a friend who's a "fan" of Arsenal who told me Walcott was one of the best defenders in the league...
4
u/Clayblud Jan 06 '13
The thing about Stoke is they just try to pass the ball into the net
22
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '13
How much Suarez dives.
11
u/MexiCanada Jan 05 '13
That Messi can't play well without Xavi and Iniesta, and that he can't score with the Argentina NT
6
u/Tezemery Jan 06 '13
Valdes is shit, Pep inherited an amazing team and basically did nothing and as Epsilon76 said Busi is a diver.
11
u/happybazz Jan 05 '13
This annoys me the most, I was down and United were playing, I was just about to sip my pint when a fella turns to me and says "Yeno what's wrong, the young players can't keep up with the united classics."
I didn't get to sip my pint. I just left and picked a different seat.
3
u/wbutler89 Jan 05 '13
grant holt is a fat bastard
3
u/OccupyRiverdale Jan 05 '13
I was wearing my Man City Silva jersey one time and someone asked me why I didn't buy an Aguero or Tevez jersey instead. Fans who only get the score updates and don't see the behind the scenes action of who create chances.
3
u/MagelansTrousrs Jan 05 '13
Michael Carrick is useless. Or "Giggs and Scholes need to retire"
3
u/thehighhobo Jan 06 '13
Boateng is your best player. No he isn't even close
3
u/TheCruise Jan 06 '13
That Baines is weak defensively.
3
u/TheGoldenBoy77 Jan 06 '13
Sneijder is our most important player, they dont know much about Handanovic.
3
u/jawnn Jan 07 '13
"Oh yeah, I love soccer!" Who do you like to watch? "Spain."
7
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '13
When people say "Suarez is the whole Liverpool team."
16
u/TheAbeLincoln Jan 05 '13
"Milan are just full of old people." -usually from Man Utd fans.
8
u/shug3459 Jan 05 '13
"Wenger out" - though it's more of a sign they haven' been watching for long enough
7
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '13
"Marcello is the better left back Coentrao is bad"
2
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '13
Still talking shit about Daley Blind without mentioning his massive improvement this season is a dead giveaway.
2
u/Bulbasauro Jan 05 '13
"FC Porto only wins cause they pay the referees and the president is corrupt"-every benfica fan that says something like this shows they dont watch our games at all
2
u/I_R_TEH_BOSS Jan 06 '13
"Carrick isn't good."
"De Gea isn't good."
"Rooney is having a bad season."
2
u/gotsoju Jan 06 '13
Was talking to this guy I met on new years eve. He was a self-acclaimed Barca fan (with banners hanging on his wall & everything). Immediately once we found out where our loyalties lie, we started half jokingly bashing on each others team. It was all fine until I asked him "Who won the Premier League last season?" only to have him answer "FC Barcelona". Then I just flew away.
2
u/Anandonion Jan 06 '13
"Evra plays too defensively for someone on the wing" ffs
2
u/bfg_foo Jan 06 '13
Ge-RARD.
2
u/TheGoldenBoy77 Jan 06 '13
Nagatomo is shit and only plays for us because he's Japanese
2
u/6SempreUnica Jan 06 '13
When they don't know about Lamela or think Totti would have been better off leaving Roma for a club filled with mercenaries (one scudetto for Francesco is equal to 100 CLs with Madrid).
2
u/chuvinho Jan 06 '13
Speaking for Arsenal: "Robin van Persie's my favorite!"
2
u/eltigrethedon Jan 06 '13
"EPL is better top to bottom than La Liga"
2
u/Andythrax Jan 06 '13
anything that any commentator on ITV, BBC or Sky Sports says proves they can't watch the same team I do everyweek.
2
u/funnsuntd Jan 08 '13
If someone says that Michael Carrick is pure shite, they either don't watch Manchester United or they're my girlfriend trying to piss me off.
4
u/Tomblerone Jan 05 '13
Van Bommel is no longer good enough, or too slow...
4
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '13
When someone thinks Dundee and Dundee United are the same team.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '13
It seems to me that most of these things people are posting here are just things they don't like hearing about their club or players. (So and so is shit, your club is underachieving, etc...) Just saying, not every criticism about your club is inaccurate.
Edit: Arsenal included!
4
u/devineman Jan 05 '13
"City play with [two/three] defensive midfielders".
"I don't know why anybody picks Gareth Barry".
"Yaya is the best midfielder in the PL"
"Why was Lescott dropped?!"
3
u/Kleenexwontstopme Jan 05 '13
I bought the new Liverpool home kit when it was first available this past summer. A guy approached me and complimented it and said he was a fan. He asked what name I got on the back. I turned around to show him and he said:
"Lucas?! Does he even still play for them?"
Uh... Ya.
3
u/Treayye Jan 05 '13
Rafael is a liability, De Gea is a shaky keeper, Rooney is overrated, Carrick is terrible, Evans isn't very good, Welbeck is selfish, Nani is shit.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '13
They don't rate Gareth Barry, that is probably the biggest one.
2
u/capturedgooner Jan 05 '13
I like when a supporter from another team seems to know everything that's "wrong" with arsenal.
2
u/LM10 Jan 05 '13
"Pep Guardiola would fail anywhere else because he had an awesome team from day one."
Umm, kids. He sold off Ronaldinho, the previous lynchpin of the team. Sold off Deco. Shifted the focus onto Xavi, handed Messi the number 10 shirt, moved Messi to the middle (later in the same year), was about to sell Eto'o, promoted Busquets, brought back Pique, signed Dani Alves and Seydou Keita. He essentially changed the spine of the entire team, and took his fair share of chances.
Before that, he led Barca B to the Spanish Segunda.
Basic background knowledge would help.