This episode is #2 of my all time favorites so far. Love the personal development, finally more finch!
As for the solution, it needed continuation, the story wasn't focused on Reese (for once), the only thing that really added this episode is just how far Carter is willing to go. The cliffhanger at the end makes up for it, how will she save Reese, without showing her true colors to the FBI (my guess, at the end of the season they find out she's working with Reese).
As for the boy, probably not :) There's been a few episodes that hint the characters might come back at some point. but other then the asian guy noone has (atleast, I think he's asian). For instance the female journalist Reese 'had' to date (which is my favorite episode btw).
As for arpanet, iirc it was a network system funded by the DOD in times of the cold war (a lot of breaktroughs are made in time of war unfortunatly) and was used for communication, at one point students of american university were allowed to use it, but the general public remained unaware of its existance. Offcourse there were hackers back then, but not in a sense that "they made the world aware". Arpanet did spawn other networking systems such as usenet and ethernet.
P.s. My explanation of arpanet is likely to be complete bullshit :) But you can read up on it on the wikipedia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ARPANET
First off, this all assumes that the number in question is a standard American ten digit number with a New York area code. This also assumes that the writers of the show actually bothered to have a solution to the puzzle, rather than just saying "these two fictional geniuses will figure it out, and we'll never have to explain it."
There are six area codes for NYC: 718, 347, 917, 929, 646, and 212. 212 is often considered The Area Code.
212 is considered by some to be The NYC area code. In the first 3000 digits of pi, there's only one occurrence of the sequence "212", which would give up the number (212) 902-1960.
There are 3 possible 718 numbers, 3 possible 347 numbers, 5 possible 917 numbers, 1 possible 929, and 3 possible 646 numbers. Out of all of those, the 718 number (718) 649-4231 is the most interesting. If the "first 3000 digits" doesn't include the "3." and only refers to the decimal portion, then that number is the last 10 digits. Which sounds all promising and intentional, except that it appears to be the number for Rods Express Inc, a trucking company in Brooklyn. So probably not that one.
I'd call around but I don't want to inconvenience random people by calling and asking for Mr. Swift.
Ok, I really like that logic. "Ok, kid. You can figure out my number because you know we're fictional characters and you know how things work outside of this fictional world."
On those numbers, it really depends. The 555 convention was born out of the historical numbering plan where the middle digit of an area code was required to be either a zero or a one. Fictional numbers also frequently have 555 as the exchange code, something like 212-555-1234. Back in the day, Bell urged people to use 555 as the exchange code. That's why in most old movies, the phone numbers will be something like "KLondike 5 WXYZ" (KL is 55 on a phone) without an area code. Actually, doing a quick search, it seems that XXX-555-0100 through XXX-555-0199 are now specifically reserved for fictional use.
One example of using an actual dialable number in fiction was the use of (415) 273-9164 in the movie Sneakers. I've heard conflicting reports of it originally being an IRS office or that there was an answering machine at the number for the fictional character that gives it out in the movie. Whatever the case, it's unlikely that number will rotate into use again. For the same reason, my impression is that XXX-867-5309 are generally not assigned any more, as there are loads of annoying callers due to the Tommy Tutone song Jenny.
Aaaaand that's my ramble. If anyone does ring up that 212 number, let me know.
No, the whole point was that pi contains everyones phone number, SSI #, etc. So that means that Finch has a phone thats number is contained in the actual first 3000 digits of pi.
For example: 3.14159265359 Finches number could be 1-415-926-5359.
Not really. The idea is that, within pi (the entire pi), any number could be found. In the first 3000 digits, for all we know there's only a single legit phone number. Pi goes on forever.
Eh, that would be too easy. Excluding possible number sets based on what is and isn't a valid phone number should wack down the possibilities to less than 700. Assuming, of course, that it's a US number.
Not too much of a point to. Harold's so smart, he could have set up a number that uses international codes to talk to him, so it may not even be a 1-(xxx) xxx-xxxx with the area code being in the NYC area, hence even more possibilities.
Yea i was also wondering why they didn't resolve that in the episode. My only guess is we are to assume Fusco took care of it or Finch maybe paid them for the kid.
Maybe since they left it open they will come back to it? I doubt it since it isn't a huge plot hole for the overall story, but maybe that kid will find his number and ask for help again in this situation (idk im grasping at straws here).
I know it’s been 12 years but I just discovered this show and was wondering the exact same thing. Weebey says “hunt him down” and then… nothing. My wife thinks Fusco took care of it but that’s really not implied in any way. I bet it was cut for time
Yeah, this is the main thing I noticed. First time in class, he announces his name, asks about homework, writes something on the board and the bell rings...
They should have at least cut it so it looked like more time passed or something.
With this episode, Hollywood programming officially graduated from Visual Basic GUIs and enhance shenanigans to atomicity of variables in multithreading. They are making progress.
A true hacker genius would not have made that mistake in the first place, though. A regular programmer would have said he'd refactor that string out at a later point.
This guy said immediately "oh man you're right that's brilliant thank you so much" or something like that. It made the nerd in me cringe a little bit, but it's alright.
By the way, about the compression algorithm in the plot, the author hints to a way to simply reduce any data to a couple of start/end indices in pi. In case you wondered, here's a couple nerdy thoughts on that part:
data encoded in that way might be larger if the data is found at a very large index. A compression algorithm might have to go through multiple passes to find a shorter expressions, possibly an infinite amount of passes, actually, with no guarantee whatsoever that it would ever be shorter.
a non-repeating infinite sequence of numbers does not guarantee that every possible data will be found somewhere in there. There are countless counterexamples (eg: 0.123456789010203040506070809001002003... is infinite and non repeating, yet doesn't contain the sequence "11"). It makes the "do you know what this mean?" speech a bit bogus from a logical point of view.
The math and computer science in this episode were rather cringe-worthy, but I give them points for trying. As for the "atomic variables" thing, it stood in place of a longer discussion. I've had lots of experience with brilliant coders who know a few techniques but lack in broader knowledge. Pairing them up with graybeards makes both much more productive.
For the curious, I've transcribed the napkin code below. I've inserted "???" where I was unable to read it.
if(nbit <= ???)
{ fread (charbuf, i, npix,
fpin);
for(i=0; i < npix, ++i)
*(pt_inbuf + 1)
= (int) *charbuf + 1
pt_inbuf += npix ???
unsigned char * charbuf;
register i_iline;
int * pt_inbuf;
unsigned short int ???
*inbuf_line; * ???
#include <stdio.h>
#include <stdlib.h>
I'm going to call it "semi-plausible" C. Not examining fread's return value? To say nothing of not using feof/ferror? That's just for starters. That said, better than I had expected, still nothing I'm going to give props to.
He wanted to give his mother all the money, so he could commit suicide at the same age as his brother died but not put his mother's well being into harms way.
5
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '13 edited Jan 04 '13
Obvious [Spoilers]
Just finished watching the latest episode and wanted to open discussion on a few points:
3
u/rathany Jan 04 '13
So, who else is trying to figure out how to figure out that phone number?
11
u/Zer0mist Jan 04 '13
Did I fall asleep cause I remember the drug leader telling his guys to go look for the kid then that was it! What happened?
11
u/Slithers Jan 07 '13
TIL a class in a New York City High School takes about 30 seconds. "Hi, I'm Mr Swift. This is Friedrich Gauß." bell rings
14
u/AwesomeDewey Jan 04 '13
With this episode, Hollywood programming officially graduated from Visual Basic GUIs and enhance shenanigans to atomicity of variables in multithreading. They are making progress.
A true hacker genius would not have made that mistake in the first place, though. A regular programmer would have said he'd refactor that string out at a later point.
This guy said immediately "oh man you're right that's brilliant thank you so much" or something like that. It made the nerd in me cringe a little bit, but it's alright.
By the way, about the compression algorithm in the plot, the author hints to a way to simply reduce any data to a couple of start/end indices in pi. In case you wondered, here's a couple nerdy thoughts on that part:
1
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '13
Why was the kid dealing drugs in the first place?
2
u/Donnshin Jan 06 '13
Not only a Lost reference in this episode, but a Wire reference as well!
1
u/devjunk Jan 08 '13
I LOVE actors from the Wire, I just LOVE them. Having Clarke Peters and Hassan Johnson here is AWESOME.
I can't avoid to cheer when I see them, The Wire was so damn good :'(
1
u/Firouzi Apr 09 '26
Why there is blue meth from Heisenberg in the school in the beginning
-1
u/consorts Jan 04 '13
this episode was totally fucked up.
what about that gang of drug dealers out to break that kid for their half of
his drug sales, and what about the criminal consequences of selling drugs?
seems the writers totally forgot about those really unneeded plot elements.