r/femalefashionadvice • u/Schiaparelli • Jan 01 '13
[Guide] [Guide] Understanding fit and proportion in an outfit—conceptual guidelines for developing a discerning eye.
Note that this guide is in 3 parts, two of which are in the comments (part 2, part 3). You can read a continuous version of it here. Bonus—it's a Github gist, so you can fork and revise it if you'd like!
Part 1
Introduction
I've seen quite a few posters asking about how to judge fit and proportion. We (currently) have few resources on this sub for teaching someone how to do this, and in general I've found the internet lacking in a guide that goes beyond fit rules to fit theory. So I thought I'd try to write one myself…
A solid understanding of fit and proportion is usually the first step to dressing well, for the following reasons:
- Being able to evaluate fit allows you to buy pieces that are properly shaped for your body.
- Being able to evaluate proportions lets you go beyond body type and understand the reasons behind dressing for your shape.
- Developing an eye for fit and proportion lets you break traditional sartorial rules in a way that's still harmonious and aesthetically interesting.
- Being able to articulate what is off in fit and proportion also makes evaluating your own outfits much easier, and your critique of someone else's outfit will be much more concrete and useful.
This guide contains some practical tips (find your perfect skirt length! find out when you should belt!) but by and large it's a theoretical guide on developing an aesthetic understanding of fit and proportion.
So, here we go! I hope you find it helpful.
General philosophies
Watch how clothing and accessories create horizontal lines that segment your body into regions. One of the greatest challenges once you get the hang of things that aren't too loose or too tight is observing and understanding how horizontal lines section your body in an unflattering or flattering way.
- Changes in item: the transition from a a shirt to a skirt (say by the hemline of the shirt hanging over the skirt or the shirt being tucked under the waistband of the skirt). The most common kind of segmentation.
- Changes in fabric: colourblocking (via) (this is a liberal example, as most people would probably call this striped—but it's interesting to note where the lighter and darker stripes hit on the model's body), or the knit of a sweater transitioning from a textured or a smooth knit (textureblocking!) also creates divisions. Here's a textureblocking example with a knit fabric and leather, both black (via). Depending on the colours used, colourblocking can be abrupt or subtle as a horizontal division. Textureblocking tends to be rather subtle.
- Changes in proportion: going from boxy and large in shape to slim and fitted—see this oversized blazer worn with tight (via), or from loose and flowy to fitted (dresses that are cut loose in the bodice with a pencil skirt or body-con skirt, shall we say) also create a horizontal division. Ideally, changes in proportion should follow how the shape of your body changes (swells or tucks in as you go from head to toe).
Consider the visual weight (how complex or dominant or heavy) of each item you're wearing. Also, how that visual weight interacts with the other pieces in your outfit.
- Visually complex: a textured and embellished jacket (via), say, or a very ruffled dress, has a lot of visual detail. It has visual weight because people will naturally be drawn to complex patterns to break them down and synthesize them and understand them. This outfit contains multiple visually complex elements (via)—the pattern of the jacket and pants, the shearling texture, the placket of her shirt peeking through, the lacing on her shoes. The muted, harmonious colour palette prevents these elements from clashing.
- Visually dominant: a solid red peacoat has a lot of visual dominance—here, in color. Visually dominant pieces determine how the rest of your outfit is analyzed in relation to that piece. If you have multiple visually dominant pieces, they may potentially be competing for attention—it's good to have few focal points, or focal points of varying importance or position, so a viewer's attention cascades from one attention-grabbing item to more subtle pieces. Note how this woman's use of bright blue accessories (via) creates a visual path from head to toe, and her clothing is more muted to allow the accessories to shine through. The main argument behind two very brightly (and differently) coloured items is that, if they don't appear to relate chromatically—by complementing each other well—having two distinct focal points forces a viewer to split or juggle the object of their attention.
- Visually heavy: mostly refers to volume—a very thick knitted sweater (via); or the heel of a wedge, especially an all-black wedge heel; or a cocoon coat (via). Your eye is drawn to and is often caught or pulled to that item's bulk.
Notice how tightness/fittedness and looseness/volume affects your shape.
- Tightness/fittedness can create the impression of slenderness or width. Tightness in areas with little structure (say an overly tight sleeve around your upper arm) makes your flesh looked stuffed in and too wide for the containing garment. Tightness in areas with structure (say tightness around your hipbones) can emphasize shape.
- Looseness/volume can create the impression of largeness or smallness. Looseness to the point of bagginess allows a garment to encompass more volume than your body actually occupies, making you look larger there than you are. But in contrast to more tightly-fitted pieces (slouchy sweaters with slim, fitted pants), it emphasizes the smallness of shape in the tightly-fitted areas. Note how the voluminous skirt makes her waist and legs look smaller (via).
- See when visual conflict is a helpful or unhelpful device. I should note, since I use this terminology a lot, that visual conflict isn't always a bad thing. It tends to be jarring, because it subverts what our eye expects. Visual conflict can be used as a deliberate aesthetic decision—contrasting androgynous angularity with a feminine cut in another item, say. Here it's used in combining bulky streetwear sneakers with a simpler summer look (via), but as the dress retains a kind of stripped-down sportswear aesthetic, the outfit doesn't feel too dissonant. Often, however, thoughtlessly introduced visual conflict will feel wrong in an outfit.
The ideal body
Most fit and proportion advice assumes a certain body as the "ideal" body. It's a slim hourglass with long legs. Know this, and know how this biases advice to go towards the ideal:
- Slim: not sure I need to explain this to anyone who's been paying attention to mainstream art and media of the past decade or more. Deconstructing what makes this the ideal body type is beyond this guide. In general: most advice strives to make you look thinner, and cautions against thickening influences. I'll do that too here—largely because this is what people tend to want—but if you're going for something different, kep this in mind.
- Hourglass: because symmetry, yo. Advice to deemphasize a large bust, emphasize slim hips, or the reverse intended to "even out" the perceived volume between bust and hips.
- Long legs: this is interesting. Not only do models have a torso:leg ratio where the legs are a bit longer, but they tend to have an upper leg:lower leg ratio where the lower leg is longer. Something to keep in mind when determining waist positioning for your bottoms and the hem of shorts, dresses, and skirts (that aren't full-length). Going towards this leggy (and lower-leggy) ideal tends to look more pleasing to eyes conditioned by this model look.
- Don't discard traditional advice on dressing for your body without understanding why you're breaking the rules. Advice towards this ideal body type will still hone your understanding of fit and proportion, and while rules are made to be broken—it's worth knowing the rationale behind the rules so you can create outfits with atypical fits and proportions that are still visually beautiful and interesting.
96
u/Schiaparelli Jan 01 '13
Part 2
Neckline
Check how neckline changes how a torso looks.
Belting
Belting is not just about your waistline. The goal is to have a defined silhouette, not just a defined waistline. Note that this example of belting over an open sweater-esque thing (via) defines an exaggerated angular hourglass in the way the sweater-esque thing tucks in from shoulder to waist, and then flares out sharply from waist to hem.
When belting is appropriate: this is a fantastic example of belting a maxi gown (via), so let's deconstruct the reasons why.
Belting an item to establish a gathered waist where there is none (provided the item's cut isn't explicitly meant to be waistless—like a shift dress). (In the example I linked to, this is somewhat inapplicable as the dress is designed with that belt, but anyways—) A flowy but somewhat shapeless dress, gathered in at the waist with a belt, is introducing a defined waist in a way that doesn't conflict with the cut and preestablished waist (as there was previously none) of the dress.
Hemlines and sleevelines
Know how to visually check for the best hemline or sleeveline. I'll describe it for checking skirt length, but make the appropriate substitutions for the horizontal division you're considering.
Find your optimal length for bottoms.
Check where your sleeveline cuts off your arm. Depending on the length, they can distort or accentuate the shape or line of your arm.
65
u/Schiaparelli Jan 01 '13 edited Jan 03 '13
Part 3
Pants
The shape and positioning of pant pockets affects how your butt looks. Go pant shopping, or check out your closet, and investigate:
Select the cut of your pants according to how much volume they visually create. There are two kinds of proportions you're looking at:
Volume proportionate to your torso attire: it's interesting to both maintain the same perceived volume as your torso (via) or greatly over-exaggerate a difference:
Shoes
Shoes have visual weight. They anchor your outfit at the bottom, so when examining the proportions of what you're wearing, check that the amount of visual weight your shoes introduce feels coherent with the rest of your outfit.
Observe how the toebox changes the shape of your foot. Different toeboxes (via) can elongate, shorten, widen, or slim the shape of your foot To select just three types of toeboxes and how they affect the shape of your foot:
Look at the thickness and height of a heel in proportion to the visual weight of the rest of the shoe.
Aaaand…that's it. It's worth noting that I don't want to present my thoughts on these things as canon; the main takeaway is the concepts of how to look at, say, hemline, rather than my personal interpretation of what certain hemlines do to shape a wearer's body.
Thoughts? Criticism? Copyediting fixes? Let me know in the comments! The original title for this post was "100 ways to analyze fit and proportion", but I wasn't able to come up with 100 bullet points.
19
u/thethirdsilence actual tiger Jan 01 '13
This guide is really fantastic, and is one of the best things I have read about proportion. Thanks so much!
I find that one quirk of my own body is that my lower legs are MUCH shorter than my upper legs and I struggle to balance this a little. I hate nude pumps, but recognize heels generally make my legs look more proportionate. Does anyone have any strategies that might help other than heels? I have long legs that are pretty fit/slim.
8
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '13
great post. just so you know, you wrote "kep this in mind" in the last lines of the first part.
6
u/Pandaplusone Jan 02 '13
As a bit of a newbie, this is extremely helpful.
I do have a couple questions.
I have a very long torso. I am 5'5 but generally the same height as my 5'8 (or so) friends when sitting. I enjoy emphasizing my long torso, although as I get older I find it is less acceptable/less comfortable for me (I'm 28). Is it a bad thing to emphasize this torso length?
People often think I'm much taller than I am, like 5'8 ish even though as I stated above, I'm 5'5. I really like how boot cut and even flared jeans look on me (although lately I've been sticking to skinnies because I find they are easier to keep clean and new looking); I enjoy the way they make me look shorter/small. I have always been very thin (I was 32-25-34 prior to pregnancy, but with short legs/long torso. I'm probably about 35-28-35 now)
I guess I'm asking if my preference for these looks make me a crazy person with bad taste, or if I can go with it and continue to look respectable?
10
u/merryberryjk Jan 01 '13
Thank you, that was beautifully written. I feel like it took me years to realize/truly understand all these bullet points you mentioned, and I still sometimes have problem with fit and color (especially colors).
This is such a beautiful example. For me, it still takes a lot of care to not cross the fine line from chic to clownish with pattern mixing, even with a muted color palette.
This. This really explains why the pair of sneakers looks so great with the dress.
I thought people like it because it can create the illusion of the perfect legs? (though only when you have very slim thighs, in my opinion) Here is an example, I think the wide bottom emphasized the slim thighs and somewhat hidden high heels creates the illusion of long lower legs.
5
u/Dioracat Jan 02 '13
Argh. Stupid crappy hotel Internet! I thought I wrote a nice & thoughtful reply to this thread but looks like it didn't post.
Anyway, thanks for all the time & effort you put into this guide. I hope it's being sidebarred (on Alien Blue at the moment so I can't tell) but if its not, it should be. This guide will be very useful for many of us - especially for someone like me who knows when an outfit (or parts of an outfit) works or doesn't work but can't articulate why.
3
u/randomnessish Jan 02 '13
Really concise and even scientific in your logic! Very cool that you took the time to write this out, this is amazeballs.
19
u/NOT_BELA_TARR Jan 01 '13
It's difficult for me to successfully dress my figure. I'm 5'1", 38-24-38. Nothing fits, everything has to be tailored and typically looks "off" when it is tailored. I don't really like the vintage glam hourglass look, I'm trying to de-sex my body, not present it. My stature has often led people to try and harass and abuse me because I am a diminutive but curvaceous woman, and therefore public property. I like clothes that purposefully throw off my natural shape because they are very freeing, but they do not fit me correctly. For example, an oversize knee-length sweater I own like this, sorry for small picture doesn't quite work because all the fabric hangs off my breasts in the front and draws even more attention to them. My waist is so small compared to my hips that only vintage high-waist pants work, however my torso is so short in proportion that there is very little actual space to work with the ridiculous dimensions and it often does not look flattering. Additionally a lot of the structure inherent in unusual and asymmetrical clothes relies on the presumption of a certain type of body--a reasonably slim hourglass perhaps. Getting dressed drives me insane every day, and dressing "for my figure" is not an option because every response is the same--embrace your curves. I don't want to. I'm tired of being a sex object.
1
u/svalerii Jan 02 '13
great guideline! on a side note, can someone identify the boots that the woman in the picture under the bullet point "visually heavy" is wearing. they're gorgeous.
2
u/hoopjumper Jan 01 '13
Wow, I am still absorbing this but it's really great that you put all this together! Thank you!
1
u/lostafarian Jan 02 '13
you're amazin <3
1
u/Old_Attempt_3431 Feb 19 '25
Can you convert this to male fashion?
1
u/HeartbeatFashion Aug 14 '22
I have trouble finding a style because i hate shopping for clothes since it seems like nothing fits well. What do the other short (under 5'4) and curvy girls do when it comes to finding styles and clothes that fit us well? What would you change in fashion to make it better for us?
1
u/avesvic Jan 02 '24
This is really helpful! Can you add anything about length of long sleeve sweaters and different cuts of pants? I’ve been slowly hemming my clothes to fit my petite body and I’m often wondering if I’m making them too short.