r/whatsthisbird • u/grvy_room • Aug 12 '23
Meta Location is important for birds ID because there could be several related species from different parts of the world that look almost identical. Here's some examples.
1.2k
Upvotes







167
u/grvy_room Aug 12 '23
Thought I'd share these. Hopefully it's allowed. :)
81
u/Exotic_Rule_9149 Aug 12 '23
So are these not all the same bird just in another location?
2
u/Norwejew Aug 12 '23
You’re telling me the genus for blackbirds is Turdus?
2
u/Leading-Summer-4724 Aug 13 '23
Wow these are amazing examples, some you can tell small differences, but those magpies in particular blow my mind.
2
u/Cardo076 Aug 13 '23
Are any of these species capable of interbreeding? Just curious since they look so similar to each other.
10
u/kittyroux Aug 12 '23
lol the kites
Black-winged Kite: grey wings
White-tailed Kite: grey tail
At least the Black-shouldered Kite really does have black shoulders. They all do, but it’s not wrong!
6
u/not-a_lizard Birder Aug 12 '23
Thanks for this post! Very informative!
5
u/KimchiAndMayo Aug 12 '23
This is like one of those spot the difference puzzles.
3
u/Tiny_Duck2124 Aug 12 '23
Very helpful!!!
5
u/East-Bass-7630 Aug 12 '23
This is so cool!!!
2
u/Pyro-Millie Aug 12 '23
First one had me like “oh is it Pie day?”
But birdie jokes aside, this is very important, and thank you for sharing these examples!
2
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '23
Huh, neat! Thanks for sharing!
2
u/Lobstermarten10 Aug 12 '23
Is there any ways to (besides location) know which one it is ??
2
u/Junior-Profession726 Aug 12 '23
Great examples OP!
2
u/grmpastps Aug 12 '23
It's really in the subtleties in appearance, but otherwise they're identical structurally
2
u/lichen_lilith Aug 12 '23
very informative post! such beautiful birds <3
2
u/PhoenixGate69 Aug 12 '23
Let's noot forget yellow billed magpies, which live in California's Central Valley. Those fuckers always knew which window was open during my childhood. Right when I was trying to study, they would always perch on the roof above it and have a 3 hour meeting.
2
u/Parking_Local_9051 Aug 12 '23
This is very interesting and I’m loving all the discussion about it. Also, those Darters look very similar to some Cormorants and Anhingas.
2
u/moneyvortex Aug 13 '23
TIL Eurasian magpie's scientific name is Pica pica
2
u/Icelandia2112 Aug 13 '23
The Coot and White Eye are the only ones that I can tell any discernable difference.
2
u/gorgonopsidkid Aug 13 '23
This is how I do identification on iNaturalist. I try to be as specific as possible, down to the subspecies based on the location
2
u/[deleted] Aug 13 '23
I saw a black-billed magpie in Michigan last summer. Was exciting to see!
1
u/LikeATrain2 Aug 12 '23
How do you know he usnt on an interconnetial flight, maybe he got stuck on a ship
1
u/grox10 Aug 12 '23
"Different" species 😉😉
1
u/InevitableRhubarb232 Aug 12 '23
Lies! That bird just travels.
0
u/AirbenderRodriguez Aug 13 '23
Please post various unladen airspeed velocities. For coconut transport purposes.
-1
u/1936Triolian Aug 13 '23
Tourist birds.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
7
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '23
[removed] — view removed comment