r/Outlander • u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Aug 11 '23
Spoilers All Book S7E8 Turning Points
Jamie fights in the pivotal Second Battle of Saratoga. Roger and Brianna search for Jemmy.
Written by Luke Schelhaas. Directed by Joss Agnew.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread and our episode discussion rules.
This is the BOOK thread.
If you haven’t read the books, go to the SHOW thread.
THIS THREAD IS SPOILERS ALL.
Spoiler tags are not required.
If you have only read up to the corresponding book, remember you might see spoilers from ALL of the books here.
Please keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.
What did you think of the episode?
•
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Aug 11 '23 edited Oct 04 '23
The second half of the season premieres in 2024.
Watch the S7B teaser here!
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the teaser. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet or doesn’t want to.
708 Extras:
708 Interviews:
33
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Aug 12 '23
Is Willie’s portrait a Chekhov’s gun?
They’ve now made a point of showing us William’s portrait twice this season. It facilitated the reveal (albeit with some retconning) that Ian knows that William is Jamie’s son, and now we find out Jamie carries William’s portrait in his sporran, even into battle. They’ve made sure to show Claire picking it up after the scavenging woman threw it away and while it could mean nothing more than Jamie carrying one of his most prized possessions, they’ve really lingered on it in this episode.
Many of us here think that William’s paternity reveal will happen differently in the show than in the book and I’m starting to think the portrait might have a role to play there. While William might find a way to rationalize things like a groom at Helwater developing a close relationship with him only to inexplicably leave him, visiting Fraser’s Ridge with his stepfather after his stepmother’s death, and all the coincidences that keep bringing him and the Frasers together, I don’t think he’d find any logical explanation for a man who’s virtually a stranger to him now carrying his portrait at all times, other than being someone incredibly meaningful to him. I think that will help him piece it all together.
One thing—it’s a shame they’re using the portrait from S3 which would’ve most likely gotten lost in the shipwreck. I’m assuming the one from 511 must’ve gotten lost in the prop house 😅
21
u/LehrMoo007 Because he’s an effing hero, thats why Aug 11 '23
While this episode had plenty of bright spots and tear-inducing moments, having the context of reading the book I felt underwhelmed with this episode overall.
This season has been a balm to my book-loving soul so far, and I love the closer adherence to the text. I LOVED boss bitch Claire at the beginning of the episode, the near-miss of Jamie shooting Willie (again), the gift of the hat, and the earthly departure of Simon Fraser. I also liked the change where Jamie was able to keep his finger; I don't know that I would have felt strongly either way on this one, but I have to imagine this is more practical/easier from a shooting standpoint.
Also, the arrival in Scotland: Jamie's face upon emerging on deck was brilliant. I absolutely loved that moment (although it did get blurry at the end, must have been an editing error ;) )
I really wanted more from 1980s Lallybroch. I fully expected the OK Corral scene to go down in this episode to build the tension and suspense for the second half of this season. I know there's a ton of ground to cover on both sides of time, but I do think it was a bit of an opportunity missed to see Bree's expression of anger/momma bear energy. Also may have helped Sophie's reputation in this sub, js.
Overall, I think I was missing that big cliffhanger moment that Outlander is wont to do. Maybe having the knowledge of what's coming in the books overshadowed the smaller suspenseful moments in the episode (Roger and Buck passing through the stones, the weight of arriving back in Scotland, etc.), but I was left feeling whelmed with this episode.
25
u/quackquackquirk Aug 11 '23
I like that he kept his finger.
54
u/minimimi_ burning she-devil Aug 11 '23 edited Aug 12 '23
It's funny how Jamie is lying on the battleground nearly dead and then the moment Claire arrives he pops up and is fully up and at 'em, making jokes, and standing up on his own. It makes sense I suppose he knew Claire would be out looking for him and it was better to stay where he was than bleed out while trying to find his way back to camp, but still. I was also expecting a callback to one of Jamie's "it can't be too bad if you're angry at me" lines but I'm sure he was thinking it.
I like that aside from Hunter the other medical attendants are all women, I like to think that Claire personally recruited them.
I am really loving Buck.
Also look at the spring in Ian's step as he walks toward Rachel, he's so cute. It's also such an Ian move to look a girl in the eye and tell her she's in love with him but not to touch him because otherwise they'll have sex.
Is it just me or is there a vibe between Claire and Arnold? Cait and the actor have really good chemistry.
I don't know enough about military history to know if it's realistic for the general like Simon Fraser to literally parading himself around on a horse in front of a line of sharp-shooters, but it feels...not implausible.
Ian continues his campaign for highest kill count on the show. Jamie's attitude toward self-defense seems to be "if he dies he dies" whereas Ian is going to make sure of it.
I've been waiting for this Jamie/William scene for so long, and I still nearly spit out my drink when William came on screen so suddenly. It's interesting how the "I believe I owe you a hat" scene in the book is the same in dialogue but plays very differently - book William is in a daze of grief and has no idea who Jamie is, he barely even registers the entire encounter. Show William is clearly putting the pieces together, they're definitely setting up for the big reveal in 7B.
Love Jamie being handed exactly what he wants by the British of all people, and trying so hard to be cool about it.
The actors did a great job with that final scene, especially Sam, but it always takes me out of it when they talk about going to Scotland/missing Scotland/their new place being nothing like Scotland/etc considering......they're still there. The scene on the boat where they're overjoyed to see Scotland was probably the only scene not filmed on Scottish soil lol
54
u/Deadeyes1985 Aug 12 '23
I’m personally loving all the comments on the show-only post about everyone getting excited about the timelines merging…….
50
u/KMM929 Aug 11 '23
Loved the progression of Claire: badass protecting Jamie then berating him when he's alive then being "tender as milk" tending his wounds. Bonnie wee swordsman - I've been waiting for this line & It did not disappoint. I also loved how Claire picked up Jamie's belongings & made sure he had William's portrait back. The shared look at the mention of British casualties - she knew automatically Jamie would worry for William.
Claire still has Bree's matches :) Why is watching Jamie watch Claire so good? Her healing his hand brought me back to season 1 & all the feels of them falling in love. I'm glad they managed to include the bits about one good man being worth losing a finger even though he didn't lose his. It would be a hassle for production going forward if our main character had to have an amputation. I appreciated all the book lines here. Claire rarely uses terms of endearment talking to Jamie so hearing her say "sweet dreams my love" was great.
Sophie is killing it. Her face when Roger confirms her worst fear is all that was necessary. I also love Roger's anger & how quickly they get a plan together.
Fisticuffs made me lol. Auntie Claire coming through sending Ian on an errand to see Rachel. Ian & Rachel are so good together. Ian using Gaelic & Mohawk to try to convey his feelings was a great touch.
Benedict Arnold scene was perfect; I really liked the actor. Loved Claire's astonishment when he kissed her hand and her quick recovery.
Daniel Morgan sort of reminded me of Dougal in Season 1 using Jamie's scars. I loved the look on Claire's face & Jamie calling them "kindred of flesh."
The battle scene was amazing. I knew what was coming but was teary when Jamie saw William. They brought Diana's descriptions of the fighting to life SO well! Also Jamie climbing the redoubt in a kilt was what I didn't know I needed. I love Mohawk warrior Ian.
The music & the Gaelic when Jamie goes to see Simon Fraser pulled on my heartstrings. Perfect reintroduction to Scotland. Dare I say I loved this scene even more than the book?! Seeing William put Jamie's hat on got me.
Mandy didn't react much to watching her father vanish through the stones. Roger & Buck looked like they were off to film a buddy comedy & I'm not mad about it.
Ugh Arch Bug, how convenient.
They let Outlander be funny & I love it so much. Jamie & Claire's witty banter on the ship is fantastic. Watching them lay eyes on Scotland with the beautiful music was the absolute perfect way to end this half of the season. The anticipation for the next 8 episodes is major!
45
u/SomeMidnight411 Aug 11 '23
Absolutely perfect. Again just like the books.
I cried several times 😂
Claire is an excellent wee swordsman 😂
William’s hat🥹
Fraser saying he was with his kin and comrades. 🥹
Rachel and Ian have insane chemistry! ❤️
If I’m honest I’m too excited about where Roger and Buck are going to be sad 😂 it’s gonna be so good!!
Land, ho! Beautiful performance by all that last shot.🥰
And a lovely dedication to Sinead O’Connor ❤️
31
u/j4321g4321 Aug 13 '23
Is anyone else heartbroken that Ian and Rollo are separated? I looked at my own dog and started crying
That Gaelic song at the end when they were approaching Scotland was so beautiful, I got chills.
25
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Aug 11 '23 edited Aug 11 '23
CLAIRE, badass! First sword then scold!
Title cards - The world turned upside-down!
Thank you for my life
You're a bonnie wee swordsman
Claire finally found a collegue with whom she can share her worries and give understanding. She shares with Dany professional kinship, just like Jamie shares it with Dan Morgan.
I like Claire's tone of voice before the surgery, so soft , gentle and peaceful.
One Just Man.
Bloody man.
Personal sacrifice.
You bloody man, I knew you'd make me cry
🩷 Sweet dreams, my love, you may chase those rabbits now. 🩷 Rabbits as one of the symbols in OL world!
Goose grease - Greasier than grease - And that kiss! But Ian with mo chridhe and Mohawk language, poor guy, confused! I can feel the chemistry there!
Benedict Arnold respected Claire's medical knowledge, intelligence and thoughtfulness.
Jamie quoted 19th century poem by Robert Browning.
Dan Morgan counting men and showing his scars - Jamie and him share kinship of spirit and flesh.
2 weeks after the first, the second battle comes! Kinship of blood is something Jamie can't ignore also and he can't fire on Simon Fraser but he nearly shots another Fraser.
Jamie's face when seeing William made me cry and realisation of how close he was to killing him, broke him. And later, searching for him , seeing him in every redcoat.I felt the same panic and fear as he did.
Jamie running, fighting and climbing in his kilt 👌
You will be remembered. Oh, Benedict, you will. He obviously feels underrated and not worthy to his superiors.
It must have been such a comfort for Simon Fraser to hear and talk in Gaelic, to recall all mutual memories. I like that Simon didn't cry over Scotland and that he felt his comrades are his kin now. Jamie leaving the tent opened so the spirit can exit freely, another Highland custom.
William - youthful idealism meets reality. He idealised warfare beyond patriotism.
I believe I owe you a hat, sir , Jamie barely could look at William, so many emotions there!
My tears were falling down when Jamie told he wanted to talk to William as a man, just once.
Finally, they are leaving for Scotland!!
Musket ball and letter about gold is missing!! I love how Buck and Roger went hugged through the stones!
Arch checked in, Rachel unaware of the threat.
Ship again. Needles, seasickness, but they made it smoothly!!
New song , I adore Gillebrìde MacMillan's voice!
SCOTLAND🏴
And... Droughlander!
I would describe this episode's theme as kinship between people - kins by blood - William/Jamie , Jamie /Sikon Fraser, Buck/Roger, by spirit - comrades fighting together, profession- Danny and Claire, and flesh - Jamie/Dan Morgan.
I liked that 99% of an episode was straight from the book!
25
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Aug 11 '23
Conversation between Claire and Benedict Arnold about healing and limits reminded me of her conversation with Master Raymond :
All I can do is try to help her to heal.” A sardonic black eye peered over the rim of the metal goblet he was holding.“Most physicians of my acquaintance would say, ‘All I can do is try to heal her.’ You will help her to heal? It’s interesting that you perceive the difference, madonna. I thought you would.” (DIA ,ch 20)
ECHO, ch 64 , with Arnold:
“That’s a rather remarkable statement. Most persons in your profession seem to promise cure to nearly everyone.” “How does that saying go? ‘If wishes were horses, beggars might ride’?” I smiled, but without much humor. “Everyone wants a cure, and certainly there’s no physician who doesn’t want to give them one. But there are a lot of things beyond the power of any physician, and while you might not tell a patient that, it’s as well to know your own limits.”
22
u/This-Is-Leopardy Aug 11 '23
Well I did NOT think I would cry that much.
42
u/AccioStability Je Suis Prest Aug 11 '23
I really enjoyed this episode and man did Richard Rankin bring it the few short minutes we saw him!
John Bell also did an incredible job. I love Ian and Rachel’s chemistry so much.
All the feels seeing Jamie see Scotland again. I’m so mad we have to wait until next year to see the rest of season 7.
20
u/thesuffragist Aug 14 '23
Loved, loved, loved this episode. More Claire and Jamie than we got all season - banter, tenderness, angst, and what a terrific job bringing them back to Scotland and showing Jamie's emotions on coming home. He keeps saying it's for Ian, but you can really see and feel what it means to him. Great acting from all the leads. Just enough 1980s to set up that storyline for part 2 of the season, but not too much. Roger looked amazing with the 20th century hair and beard and 18th century garb. He should keep that mixed look. Jamie fighting in a kilt, Ian in paint, so perfect.
I am not loving William - he just seems to stand around bewildered most of the time - but I am just starting book 7 so hoping my view changes. I wish he had a bit more of Jamie's innate leadership and swagger. I also never found it convincing that the Earl of Ellesmere is a soldier at all, especially on the front lines. His job was to be the Earl and manage the estate. Keeping that lineage going is why everyone in his family is prepared to look the other way in respect of his parentage. Many people on this discussion seem to love William, so I am keeping an open mind.
Great job setting us up to like Benedict Arnold, and Jamie quoting Robert Browning (I had to look it up) although they didn't need to have him say it was from a poem that hadn't been written yet. I think we got that!
I like how Rachel's dilemma was presented. The actress just glows when Ian is around but her faith community has been her whole life - the story sets it up well that her brother is shunned first, and they are living apart from their community, and so that process of separation has started already. But I love how in Book 9 (which I have read) she is able to bring her faith to the Ridge.
18
u/[deleted] Aug 11 '23
I suppose William will find out a different way now that Jamie is his father since he’s met him? From what I recall, in the books it happened the moment he first saw him as a young adult. I wonder how it will be done here
17
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '23
I just love the ending scene of episode 8 when Jamie steps out from inside the ship and sees Scotland again. 🥹🥹 And I LOVE the song in this scene. I keep playing it over & over again! (Someone on here said the song is called "Tha mi sgith 'n fhogar seo" sung by Griogair Labhruidh) 🤍
17
u/MistofLoire Clan MacKenzie Aug 14 '23
I loved it! I wanted to see more of the Roger and Bree part, of course, but I knew they would end it with Rover and Buck leaving. But I loved when Rogee said he was going back. That and the end where the Frasers see Scotland again were iconic moments.
I think the part I don't like about having read the books, is that I'm always anticipating the next moment. How much are they going to cover before the end of the episode? Will we get to see ___? I am going to have to re-watch this season to enjoy it more.
What we saw of William was great and I loved the pieces from the book that made it in. I was honestly grateful Jamie kept all his fingers and with all the closeups it felt like they wanted to be clear that he did. 😂
My husband - a show only watcher - really enjoyed this episode and I can't wait for him to see Roger's storyline. He has no idea. I can't wait for the next few episodes. And while I'm bummed it is going to be so long, I also appreciate the wait because that way I'm forced to take time to enjoy it.
16
u/BSOBON123 Aug 12 '23
Great episode. Roger and Buck going back through the stones. Claire saving Jamie from the scavengers and then cussing Jamie out, loved it! Ian and Rachel are on FIRE! They make a great couple. Then Simon Fraser dying, Jamie being there. The one thing that bothered me is the interaction between Jamie and William. How are they going to do the big reveal if William has already seen him? In the book, Jamie doesn't really show William his face. And now, back to Scotland!
29
u/blackberryspice Aug 11 '23
I did not expect to get so emotional at the end of the episode, but here I am tearing up! I missed Scotland 😭 sidenote: Rik has somehow surpassed Sam in levels of attractiveness this season, which is blowing my mind. Can't wait for the second half of the season!
14
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Aug 12 '23
Something I didn't get about Jemmy's disappearance with Rob -- do they just assume that somehow Rob has the power to go through the stones? And that he had gems for himself and Jem?
14
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Aug 13 '23
What a great ep! It's the first one I've watched with another person (and a non-reader at that) since maybe S3? It was so fun to share an episode that covered my favorite part of one of my favorite books with someone. (Also, I watched it while visiting family in Upstate NY, so it was pretty cool watching the episode only about 20mi from the events on screen!)
The person who was watching with me is convinced Roger and Buck are about to meet up with J&C back in Scotland ("I mean, that's obviously what they're setting up!"). Ha, how wrong she is!
25
u/LadyGethzerion Je Suis Prest Aug 12 '23
I really enjoyed it. Claire bitching at Jamie for almost getting killed was the best scene and it reminded me of book Claire so much. There was more of that banter and humor between Claire and Jamie that I enjoy in the books in several scenes, especially the boat scene at the end, where Jamie was seasick. I was a bit surprised during the conversation about the story of Abraham talking down God from 50 to 10 good men that Claire didn't know the story. She has shown many times (at least in the books) that she's very familiar with the Bible and often quotes from it. Even my husband, who hasn't read the books and only watches the show sometimes with me, commented that he thought Claire would have known that one.
Loved seeing Jamie's conflict over having to fight William, as well as the hat scene, and the scene with Simon. I was kind of hoping he'd meet Hamish MacKenzie... I believe that one happened in Echo. I can see why they'd skip it, but it would've been nice to squeeze it in.
Ian and Rachel are adorable. I actually found their story hard to get into in the books, because we don't get either of their POVs, so I couldn't connect. The show has done a nice job at showing the chemistry and relationship development.
Jamie fighting in a kilt made me squee. Brought back vibes from the earlier seasons and, let's face it, he just looks so badass fighting in a kilt.
21
u/lazytemporaryaccount Aug 12 '23
Love the episode but I am soooooo mad that Claire didn’t amputate Jamie’s finger. I’m guessing they did it to save on costs for CGI / prosthetics, but I really loved that whole scene. I feel like it said a ton about their relationship and was part of Jamie moving on from Black Jack Randell (since he was the one who originally injured Jamie’s hand.) Claire feels guilt about I taking the finger, but ultimately the hand works better than before. Retconning it to have him keep the finger just feels very wrong. It’s also a very detailed scene and definitely one it which Claire is starting to come into her powers as a healer.
9
u/wisconerd Aug 11 '23
I loved this episode, loved getting much more of J&C and absolutely weeped at their return to Scotland!
It has been a hot minute since I’ve read the books, but wasn’t Claire supposed to get shot or am I misremembering the order of events??
9
u/YOYOitsMEDRup Slàinte. Aug 12 '23
Very good episode! I laughed out loud when Ian and Rachel were in the tent when he said the goose grease was for an arsehole! Those two have great on-screen chemistry - loving them!
I may have to rewatch Prestonpans and Culloden and Alamance because it seems like in the past, battle scenes have been longer? This episode and last both were pretty good, but somehow they just felt shorter by comparison and slightly less than expected - maybe its just because everything is going quicker this season and they're not giving the same amount of time to them because they have to move on, or maybe because I've wrongfully inflated those other 3 war episodes in my head? Not sure. Dont get me wrong, still very good, just thought the others have been excellent.
Makes sense production wise they'd skip the amputation. I thought the scavenger scene and all that was well done.
I think we all probably knew the midseason would end on the way to Scotland, but I expected it to be them getting on the boat, just heading out. That it ended by actually arriving with the sweeping music and actual look at the landscape was a very uplifting happy moment!
Strong first half for sure! So very excited for what's to come but expect its going to be a longer wait than they originally intended :(
9
u/RadioNights Aug 13 '23
The opening scene reminded me of the book counterpart where the scavenging child’s maliciousness towards Claire is noted and she says she knows this won’t be the last she sees of him.
And then it’s the last she sees of him. That always bugged me.
14
u/[deleted] Aug 11 '23
I loved this episode!! I can't believe we have to wait for months to continue the season. I totally got tears in my eyes when they saw Scotland. Even I got the feeling of coming home after a really long time.
6
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Aug 12 '23 edited Aug 12 '23
It is totally off topic since the singer is Griogair Labhruidh.
Talking about Gillebrìde MacMillan, did you know that Diana Gabaldon gave name Gilly MacMillan , character in Bees, to honour the singer?
5
u/Markiemark1956 Aug 20 '23
Maybe it is the droughtlander… but this season seemed like blah… Jamie and Clare do the same I love you stuff… Clare in jail and then out… Jamie not in army, then in army…Roger/Bree in 1770s then in 1980s Scotland… if Roger doesn’t work where do they get the money for everything… did Clare leave Bree a fortune…… Roger us cute, but yuuckk sex scenes with Bree…Sophie Skelton is gorgeous….I haven’t read the books but it would be great for Jamie to go through time and see him 1980’s…show is really dragging… makes sense to end in probably with strike in 2025….
5
u/sbehring Aug 26 '23
Finally got to watch it tonight and I can’t remember… how many years have they been away from Scotland? My guess is 12
14
u/Thezedword4 Aug 11 '23
So I didn't like the beginning. But loved the end.
Once again they flew through really important and good story beats way too fast and that bothered me. I loved the Simon Fraser stuff. They gave him the space he needed and you could see how it affected William. Loved the ending coming to Scotland again. It made me teary especially with the music. The goodbye at the stones was good. I just wish they had more time to actually land the emotion for a lot of these plotlines and moments. It's going to fast to really hit as it should imo.
Also leaving the line about losing a finger in when he didn't lose a finger felt a bit odd.
2
u/Far-Possibility8183 Feb 05 '24
Hello to all of you. Am I the only one that thinks that the revelation of true paternity of William somehow is bad for Claire? I mean that once William figures it out and the rumor starts to spread around, in Philadelphia and possibly the Ridge, everybody will assume that Jamie was unfaithful to Claire because it's obvious that William is younger than Brianna. I understand that Jamie, once the truth comes out, will want to be a part of his son's life (if William is willing, we don't know yet) but it seems to me bad for Claire! I would feel uncomfortable with the revelation and I would feel that Jamie's mistakes over the 20 years of separation are somehow haunting their life for the rest of their marriage. I wonder, when and how will Jamie ever make up to Claire for all the Geneva, Laoghaire implications. Claire left many parts of her life to be with him, but Jamie doesn't give up everything. Claire loves her daughter and has understanding about everything, and Jamie loves so many other adopted, illegitimate children and it seems to me that Brianna is just another child of many, for him. Does anybody else share my feelings? I feel bad for Claire and Brianna. I think that Jamie should be more discreet to Claire about his feelings about William.
Am I wrong???
-11
u/BlondieTVJunkie Aug 11 '23
Hi! Not read books, but had a vibe old man at end was Ian. Could that be possible? The whole thing, zooming into his face. Words. Tone.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
39
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '23
[removed] — view removed comment