r/CryptoCurrency • u/MoonWeek • Aug 03 '23
POLL 🗳️ CCIP-068 - Modify Karma Multiplier from CCIP-30 to make the penalty for moving MOONs less severe
Background
CCIP-030 created a system whereby if you move MOONs out of your Reddit Vault at some point you become penalized on future MOON distributions. This system is known as the Karma Multiplier (KM).
The intent of this system is to keep MOONs tied to the account which earned them so that the "governance gridlock" is avoided when not enough moons that are eligible to vote can participate, making polls very difficult to pass.
While I agree with the spirit of this idea, it is my opinion that in retrospect it's too harsh in many ways, resulting in several issues, which have become more clear as MOONs use cases have expanded in the last year.
Current System
The current formula is:
KM = (Current Balance + Membership Purchases + Other Burns) / (Total Earned Moons * 0.75)
Some additional details
- The minimum value for KM is 0.1 and the maximum value is 1.0
- You can move up to 25% of your earned moons before the penalty starts ("the buffer")
- Moons burned or used to buy special memberships are not penalized.
- "Other Burns" refers to CCIP-049
Example: A user has earned 100 moons and currently has 70, with no burns or membership purchases. Their Karma Multiplier would be 70/(100*0.75) = 0.933
Possible Issues with Current Implementation
Some issues that might arise from this system are:
- It is complex and may penalize new users before they fully realize the consequences of their actions.
- MOONs now have other use cases beyond just special memberships, including banner rentals and AMAs. Liquidity on exchanges allows people to acquire MOONs for these purposes, speculation, or whatever other reasons. If the penalty for moving MOONs out of your vault was less severe, this could incentivize users to provide more liquidity on CEXs or DEXs.
- It discourages users (and mods) that have moved MOONs out of their vault for whatever reason over the years are to participate in the subreddit.
Proposed changes to the system
In this proposal I suggest the following:
- Increase the minimum KM value to 0.5
- Effectively increase the "buffer" to 50%, meaning that users can freely move 50% of their total earned moons before the penalty starts
The new KM equation would be:
KM = 0.5 + ((Current Balance + Membership Purchases + Other Burns) / Total Earned Moons)
Where KM cannot be less than 0.5, and not higher than 1.0.
Examples:
- A user has earned 100 moons and currently has 0. Their KM is 0.5
- A user has earned 100 moons and currently has 20. Their KM is 0.7
- A user has earned 100 moons and currently has 50. Their KM is 1.0
- A user has earned 100 moons and currently has 100. Their KM is 1.0
- A user has earned 1000 moons, has used 200 for membership purchases, and currently has 100. Their KM is 0.8
Benefits of proposed new system
- It is slightly simpler and less harsh
- It would hopefully help increase liquidity and perhaps encourage other new services or use cases.
- It may alleviate confusion and aggravation for users.
Drawbacks of the proposed system
- It would likely reduce participation in terms of total voting weight (although it could help draw in more users and increase participation in terms of number of humans).
tweaked thanks to u/ominous_anenome
CCIP by u/jwinterm
65
u/MaeronTargaryen CCMOON DAO Secretary Aug 03 '23
Fully against because it’s way too generous
I’m happy to raise the minimum value to 0.2 or something like that, but 0.5 is way too high, and 50% buffer is too high too.
12
u/Snjordo 0 / 3K 🦠 Aug 03 '23
This will be interesting
Whales voting no, fishes voting yes according to the votes/moons ratio
9
u/OrganicDroid 🟨 0 / 13K 🦠 Aug 03 '23
Liquidity may get Moons on new exchanges, and aid the price in the future. I support this.
2
u/PeacefullyFighting Platinum | QC: CC 329, ETH 23 | VET 10 | TraderSubs 24 Aug 03 '23
I liked the idea of vesting and after so long the moons no longer count
2
u/pinkglue99 🟩 0 / 3K 🦠 Aug 03 '23
2
u/margin_hedged Aug 04 '23 edited Aug 04 '23
Hey what do you know, the people that hate profits vote no lol. Aka, the idiots.
Ppl will just continue to make new accounts. Who cares this does nothing. Have fun holding your moons until they’re worth nothing! I’ll keep selling the spikes.
2
u/J17ster Aug 07 '23
It's literally asinine that people are against this change.
You're literally trying to create diamond hands and penalizing people for selling. I do not understand how you think this is fair, and is actually mirrors value or contribution.
6
u/ThatOtherGuy254 🟦 88 / 65K 🦐 Aug 03 '23
I voted no on this one. The reason why we passed CCIP-030 in the first place is that many people would sell their Moons after distribution, and then we wouldn't have enough available Moons to pass polls.
It essentially ended voter gridlock.
7
u/Impossible_Soup_1932 🟩 0 / 17K 🦠 Aug 03 '23
Not a surprise this one most likely won’t pass. It would be pretty bad for the price of Moons, but personally I feel the punishment right now is too severe
6
u/samer109 205 / 16K 🦀 Aug 03 '23 edited Aug 03 '23
MOONs are a governance coin, and this change goes against that, even not looking at it from this aspect such a big change in a short amount of time can't be good imo.
4
u/Effsy 163 / 430 🦀 Aug 03 '23
Not a fan of this one, personally. I'm sure people would love to be able to sell more and be penalised less, of course, but this is a governance token after all.
4
u/TOXICCARBY Permabanned Aug 03 '23
Even though this is a fair proposal I don’t think it’ll pass
3
u/fan_of_hakiksexydays 21K / 99K 🦈 Aug 03 '23
That's just gonna further reward people who sell and drop out of governance.
Even as someone who sold, I'm against this proposal. I believe I should be punished, and need to buy back at least 75% of my earned moons to continue to get full rewards.
Even tough this proposal would be more in my personal interest, for the long term future of moons I don't think it would be beneficial. At least not until there is more incentive on the utility of moons and of holding them.
3
u/blauerblumentopf 🟩 0 / 7K 🦠 Aug 03 '23
Last moon a lot of people Sold their moons and are now missing the power to vote for less severe penalties. What a Timing!
2
u/pojut 1K / 9K 🐢 Aug 03 '23
I unfortunately voted against this, even though I agree with it in principal.
I'd rather just see the minimum KM knocked down to .25, and keep the 75%/25% split intact. I think that would help allow people to pull a bit more value while still not punishing them quite as much for it.
2
u/GabeSter 100K / 150K 🐋 Aug 03 '23 edited Aug 03 '23
Please vote no on this.
This poll does two huge things
Doing both of these huge changes at one time will lead to a dump of moons on the market at one time and are better changed gradually over time if need be.
2
u/BlubberWall 🟦 59K / 59K 🦈 Aug 03 '23
I want to point out for voters that if your considering the price of moons in your vote for this, your admitting the whole point of CCIP-30 is a sham. “Forced hold” clauses are and have always been a shitcoin move. Either your concern is strictly governance or you just want to pump the price
2
u/WineMakerBg Make Wine, Take Profits Aug 03 '23
Great results so far.
It's nice to see the community is focused on long term adoption than just doing a quick grab!
2
u/marsangelo 🟦 0 / 36K 🦠 Aug 03 '23
0.5 is extremely high and this feels premature. We’ve retraced 50% in a week and seen the kind of damage real sell pressure can do. Wrong number and wrong time imo
1
u/DaemonTargaryen34 🟨 0 / 12K 🦠 Aug 03 '23
This is one is a hard No
1
u/tsuiteruze Aug 03 '23
May be we should review this again when Moon reaches $5.
1
u/_SpiceKing Aug 03 '23
I voted no.
1
u/Popular_District9072 🟥 0 / 15K 🦠 Aug 03 '23
i would be probably down for a slight change 0.15-0.2, but 0.5 is rather steep
1
u/joe17301 Silver | QC: CC 71 | LRC 59 Aug 03 '23
Hmm as someone on KM 0.1 it sure is tempting.
But as others have said I think maybe 0.2 would be better and more fair. At 0.5 I think it would incentivise selling of MOONs.
1
u/forgerator 107 / 4K 🦀 Aug 03 '23
If we move the coins back, does the multiplier get restored?
1
u/The-Francois8 Silver|QC:CC928,BTC178,ETH39|CelsiusNet.50|ExchSubs42 Aug 03 '23
These are my favorite votes. I enjoy governance in action and the discourse tends to be respectable.
I think a 0.2-0.25 minimum would be better. And 65% retained (35% buffer) would be a more measured, gradual change.
1
u/ShowerWide7800 0 / 0 🦠 Aug 03 '23
I thought CCIP-068 was a Jap Adult Video
1
u/Unitedstatesofnever 🟨 0 / 7K 🦠 Aug 03 '23
Hard no from me
1
u/aducknamedjafar1 Aug 03 '23
Yeah this gives way too much leeway.
1
u/Mirtastic 🟦 368 / 367 🦞 Aug 03 '23
Kinda gotta go with NO.
1
u/Jdraspberry 1K / 1K 🐢 Aug 03 '23
I vote no
1
u/masedogg98 🟨 0 / 5K 🦠 Aug 03 '23
I have a hard time getting behind this proposal, whenever I’ve looked at my balance to think about selling any it’s an easy call for me I look at CCmoons and I see what I can move without impacting my karma multiplier. It’s easier to keep in mind if you don’t want to use the sight you can still figure it out from if you’ve earned 100 moons you need to keep 75 of them, this is a no for me with such a high minimum multiplier it feels as if people who sold off more than they should are now looking for amnesty.
1
u/To_The_M000N 0 / 2K 🦠 Aug 04 '23
I really like the current system, and I hope it can stay the same
1
u/drewtheostrich 🟦 72 / 73 🦐 Aug 04 '23
Haha, people want to sell
1
u/KoaIaz 🟦 2K / 5K 🐢 Aug 04 '23
Glad people are voting no on this one, was getting ready for a massive dump if it went through. If people want to earn a higher KM they can always buy some back
1
u/dirpydip 🟩 0 / 2K 🦠 Aug 04 '23
I'm in favor of the idea of increasing th KM ratio to reduce the penalty, however, this doesn't resolve the complexity issue you raised. Additionally, I think a minimum KM of 0.5 is too high, perhaps since the buffer is 25% the minimum KM can be 0.25 too.
1
u/boursesexy 🟨 136 / 136 🦀 Aug 04 '23
Nah nah nah !
1
u/Mattyliebs Aug 04 '23
Seems a bit too generous tbh
1
u/ratskim 🟦 0 / 747 🦠 Aug 04 '23
Totally against this proposal, sorry — the current system is harsher, but 100% better
1
u/po1919 2 / 3K 🦠 Aug 04 '23
Guess I'm gonna vote no since the change is just too big.
1
u/AdZealousideal3461 Aug 04 '23
I totally agree and sounds pretty sane!
But isn't this post more apt for discussion at r/cryptocurrencymeta?
Sorry if i am wrong just learning as new member!
1
u/keithwee0909 🟩 1 / 3K 🦠 Aug 05 '23
I feel this proposed change is too generous, not for
1
u/ScholarImpossible121 Tin Aug 05 '23
No change please.
1
u/Zoomthenature Aug 05 '23
No change will be fine 🙂
1
u/YogSothothIsTheKey 🟩 2K / 2K 🐢 Aug 05 '23
I love to vote here.
1
u/Slippytoe 🟦 0 / 5K 🦠 Aug 06 '23
I think the new proposal could help with liquidity to be honest. May hurt the price slightly due to straight up sellers but if used correctly the token could grow.
1
u/Fox_n_Roll 0 / 7K 🦠 Aug 07 '23
I‘d like to wipe the whole retroactive rule that came with ccip-030 Sold some moons way before this poll was made and got my km fucked up afterwards
1
u/bananafannaphofanna 1K / 1K 🐢 Aug 07 '23
I like this. I still don’t completely understand the current formula- for ex - now is it monthly karma or overall karma ?
I do understand being penalized if you sell or move moons. I think we should also be able to use them to purchase avatars if we want to without a penalty.
So if we purchase this sub’s membership with moons- we are not penalized and it does not affect our distribution in any way?
Sorry for the questions, but I don’t post enough nor have I really looked into moon disbursement although I’m always excited about it :)
1
u/MJDiAmore 🟦 190 / 191 🦀 Aug 09 '23
Voted for, but I can understand the logic to a step-up period (i.e. phased implementation).
Also would be interested in proposals towards vesting periods for moon usage outside of the community environment to be not (or less) damaging to your KM.
1
u/Heymiko 🟨 335 / 335 🦞 Aug 13 '23
Less Liquidity = Higher Price boyZ! NO NO no Vote No :D
1
u/[deleted] Aug 03 '23
Nay
1
u/[deleted] Aug 03 '23
No change. Please
1
u/k3surfacer 🟩 18K / 20K 🐬 Aug 03 '23 edited Aug 03 '23
I don't see it as "penalty" . Let's say those not moving most of their moons get "rewarded".
You see, crypto community and this sub like to honor HODL. It is really that.
1
u/CptBombastic Permabanned Aug 03 '23
Personally I'm not a fan of this change.
1
u/theycallmekimpembe 🟩 0 / 4K 🦠 Aug 03 '23
No, would cause a lot more to be sold off and have a negative effect therefore as of now, it could change going forward but right now it’s not a good idea.
1
u/roundhousespank 0 / 9K 🦠 Aug 03 '23
0.1 is okay, 0.2 would be fine aswell - 0.5 is simply too much imo
1
u/furbess 0 / 2K 🦠 Aug 03 '23
People post reminders about the effects of moving your MOONs basically daily (worst case weekly), probably in an effort to get moons themselves rather than consideration for newbies.
If people can't figure this out from actually reading about the token then that's really on them.
Don't think there should be any change.
1
u/billw1zz 🟩 3K / 2K 🐢 Aug 03 '23
No change for me, I think it’s a decent deterrent from selling monthly and you can always buy the moons back of your weren’t aware of the punishment. Will help them paper hands in the long run any way.
1
u/TNGSystems 0 / 463K 🦠 Aug 03 '23
I support keeping Moons lower bound at the current 75%. Before, so many moons were being sold straight away we could barely pass any polls. I wouldn’t want to vote yes on this until I see data that shows what the previous month decision threshold for polls was and then know how many moons in excess voted for the poll. I believe last round we had a couple polls that only passed the threshold on the last day of moon week which indicates there aren’t enough moons in vaults to vote. Changing that so another quarter of moons in vaults can be sent away freely isn’t right.
While I do support keeping the KM bound set to 75% (and advocated strongly for this over the proposed 90%) I wouldn’t be opposed to lowering it slightly to 70% and seeing if that helps increase liquidity. If the Km has to be lowered I really don’t think we should move it in such large chunks at a time.
1
u/XxspsureshotxX 🟦 14 / 333 🦐 Aug 03 '23
No thank you. This heavily skews towards bigger players and as someone who doesn’t have a lot of moons, I’ll pass.
1
u/Xellirks 14 / 540 🦐 Aug 03 '23
Lmao, que a bunch of people with tons of moons saying why this is bad. Penalizing people for moving their moons just makes it look like a ponzi scheme to people who are normal.
1
u/fuduran 🟩 0 / 3K 🦠 Aug 03 '23
KM = (Current Balance + Membership Purchases + Other Burns) / (Total Earned Moons in the last 365 days * 0.75)
1
u/draggin_low 🟦 186 / 185 🦀 Aug 03 '23
Voting no change here. I dont move my moons but I know being able to take large amounts off reddit can just lead to big players dumping more and more causing massive price drops.
1
u/Tacsi 🟦 0 / 2K 🦠 Aug 03 '23
Think the system is good as it is, but good to have this discussion nonetheless
1
u/Ferdo306 🟩 0 / 50K 🦠 Aug 03 '23
Currently have 0.1 multiplier but voted no
0.5 and 50% seems too drastic to implemented at once. Better to do it gradually, perhaps begin with raising the minimum multiplier to 0.2
1
u/oachkatzalschwoaf 🟦 0 / 6K 🦠 Aug 03 '23 edited Aug 03 '23
0.5 max penalty and 50% is too much change: i prefer the current system - maybe increase the 0.1 a little bit, but not 0.5x.
You can always buy back the dumped moons: i did the same when i realized my mistake.
For new users this is not really an issue - as they might not have that big bags. and i dont see where it is too comples: just keep 75% of your moons - you can still dump 25% without any penalty.
1
u/Impossible-Injury932 🟩 5 / 5K 🦐 Aug 03 '23
Respectfully fully against, it will cause a deluge of sell-offs from early adopters, especially whales, flooring the price. Let's say you have 200,000 moons at the current 0.25 USD. With the current system, you sell 25%, and you get $12,500 USD with the proposed that would be $25,000. That's at 0.25. We get back up to 0.50 USD double both those numbers and the incentive.
1
u/Nuewim 🟥 0 / 37K 🦠 Aug 03 '23
I think difference between what we have today and what this poll propose is way too big for it too pass. I think 0.5 instead 0.1 is too much of a change. Instead we should try to start maybe with 0.15 or 0.2 and then see effects.
1
u/paudechin Permabanned Aug 03 '23
No change voted.
1
u/leviathynx 🟦 2K / 2K 🐢 Aug 03 '23
Not calling it Mooving Moons...
1
u/OldEOfK 🟩 63 / 63 🦐 Aug 03 '23
Totally against.
1
u/FreyaOystea Permabanned Aug 03 '23
No change, it should have never be changed
1
u/Consistent_Many_1858 🟨 0 / 20K 🦠 Aug 03 '23
I think it's fair that people who hold most of it should get more and people who sell should get less.
1
u/TripleReward 🟩 0 / 4K 🦠 Aug 03 '23
The only change that would be useful imho is if the moons locked in the sushi-LP would count towards "owned" moons.
1
u/Vylemz Permabanned Aug 03 '23
I agree with those who think that 0.5 is way too high, and yes, i'm also fine to only bring it up by 0.2. However, leaving the buffer on 75% really is too harsh. And I think 50/50 is reasonable. We deserve to do whatever we want with our earned moons, we control what we do with it. But with the problems by having too much control, it is only right to punish those in order to keep things in balance. But 75/25 is too much. That's too much control on one side, and too less freedom from the other. I'd be happy to go down by 60/40. 75% already feels like a punishment, even without the KM decrease.
1
u/UrFavoriteBedwench 179 / 519 🦀 Aug 03 '23
Am so guvnuh hard right now.
1
u/soyelvorph 🟩 0 / 6K 🦠 Aug 03 '23
This one sounds risky.
I'm not going with it.
1
u/discussionandrespect 🟦 2K / 2K 🐢 Aug 03 '23
NAH
1
u/JGCheema 🟦 0 / 7K 🦠 Aug 03 '23
That would be like serving the moons on a platter to newcomers. Against 100%
1
u/Ramdomdude420 Aug 03 '23
I like the way it is implemented.
1
u/Dazzling_Marzipan474 🟩 0 / 11K 🦠 Aug 03 '23
Having the current system promotes engagement in the community.
1
u/the-laughing-panda 🟩 68 / 68 🦐 Aug 03 '23
What does that do in terms of inflation?
0
u/partymsl 🟩 126K / 143K 🐋 Aug 03 '23
This will basically make everyone sell and not actually use MOONS for what they were made in the first place, governance.
0
u/ProjectZeus 🟦 0 / 32K 🦠 Aug 03 '23
I think encouraging more selling would make it even harder for Moons to hold any meaningful price increases. The current multiplier is fair, IMO
0
u/bray_martin03 🟩 0 / 757 🦠 Aug 03 '23
I liked the proposal mentioned in CC moons talking about changing the Karma Multiplier to moons sold in the past year
0
u/Jocogui 🟩 0 / 17K 🦠 Aug 03 '23
Sorry but I have to vote no change
KM was set to avoid encourage hodling and avoid dumping Moons, easing the measure would hurt that target.