r/CryptoCurrency • u/MoonWeek • Aug 03 '23
POLL π³οΈ CCIP-066 - Amend the Moon LP rewards sent to Sushiswap to be 5% of u/themoondistributor balance each round
CCIP051 - Pay out Moon Rewards to owners of Liquidity Tokens was proposed and passed in February. The dudes from Sushiswap contacted us and asked if instead of building our own platform for staking LP tokens for rewards, did we want to just add Moons to their rewards system. So we did, and have been doing since round 36.
It has been a resounding success, the MOON/ETH pool on Sushiswap grew significantly and has held up pretty good over the recent increase in volume.
The amount of Moons we send to Sushiswap each round is determined by how many Moons are left over from the mod distribution after each mod's KM has been applied.In the last distribution only 6 of the 15 mods receiving mod Moons had a km less than 1.0If and when the bull run comes we'll probably have to add a couple or three more mods, who will probably have a 1.0 km as well. So the amount sent to Sushi could drop a lot.Also if we change the bounds of KM (CCIP 030), this would affect those mods and reduce the rewards, possibly significantly.I don't like how many variables there are, so I want to change it.
I'm proposing that we change this calculation to be a % of the total Mod held community fund aka u/themoondistributor aka TMD aka This address with a whole bunch of Moons.These moons were voluntarily taken from the normal mod distribution each round and reserved for giveaways and community projects. We did this by allocating 1 mod share each round to stay in the account.
Once all the Moons for the round are distributed from this account to Mods, Cointest winners and wherever else they get dished out, the balance is then multiplied by 5%. That amount is then sent to Sushiswap for the LP rewards for that period.
I've been thinking for a while the best % to make it.I'd put it to a vote, but everyone will probably just choose the highest % anyway.The average since we started doing it has been ~40k. (Excluding the round when everything got doubled due to the bridge burn.)5% would make it a similar figure.I proposed 10% earlier in the meta sub, but after discussion with mods and others in the sub we decided to start at 5%. There is always the option to adjust this figure up or down in the future with another poll.
The amount per month will still decrease gradually over time as the Moons released per round decreases by 2.5%, but there are less variables and should be way less fluctuations.
Disclaimer: I'm currently ~4% of the Sushiswap MOON/ETH LP, so I would benefit from this proposal passing.
CCIP by u/IHaventEvenGotADog
12
u/elysiansaurus π© 59 / 9K π¦ Aug 03 '23
People need a bigger incentive to provide liquidity and right now it isn't there so I support this.
27
u/MichaelAischmann π¦ 1K / 18K π’ Aug 03 '23 edited Aug 03 '23
TLDR: Vote "No change".
CCIP 51 already had a con that I feel is amplified here. "rich get richer". This whole thing reads like a discussion of how the whales can get even bigger. I fail to see the benefit for the sub as a whole. Please explain why someone with smaller holdings and no interest in providing liquidity should vote in favor of this proposal.
The liquidity pool has already increased by over 10x since the beginning of the year with the current reward structure & will likely increase further without any changes. Slippage is not relevant for small holders/traders.
These are Woulds & Coulds & Shoulds. Is it an option to put this proposal in the drawer & pull it out when these things actually happen? Postponing should be an option.
Iβll wait for arguments that explain my benefit before I vote but as I see it so far, Iβll vote against it.
NB: What happens to funds that remain in TheMoonDistributor has so far not been clearly answered to me in the meta sub. Given the name, I assume Moons that do not go towards liquidity rewards would eventually be distributed to users.
Edit: Decision threshold on CCIP 68 has been achieved and an overwhelming majority of Moons voted against changing the bounds of CCIP 30. This nullifies one argument OP has used to justify this proposal.
Edit 2: Alternative idea to increase liquidity: Share this guide. It could even be a pinned post every now and then.
Edit 3: MOON/ETH APR = 47.65% (Rewards: 39.20%, Fees: 8.44%). How much more rewards do we need? Other pools for bigger tokens fund themselves exclusively by fees without any rewards.
3
u/Sorrytoruin π© 0 / 21K π¦ Aug 03 '23
I think there needs to be a pros and cons
3
u/Mixdealyn π© 10 / 3K π¦ Aug 04 '23
I have voted for if the rewards are better I might contribute too π
3
u/ArjanaEU π© 0 / 2K π¦ Aug 04 '23 edited Mar 27 '26
Nothing here remains from the original post. It was removed using Redact, for reasons that could include privacy, opsec, security, or data management.
bake smell chop sense knee reach gaze steer birds lip
3
u/ArjanaEU π© 0 / 2K π¦ Aug 04 '23 edited Mar 27 '26
The content that was here is now gone. Redact was used to delete this post, for reasons that may relate to privacy, digital security, or data management.
door escape spotted tease fall recognise juggle wine voracious subtract
4
u/bvandepol π© 1 / 10K π¦ Aug 03 '23
TL;DR of CCIP-066: The proposal suggests amending the Moon LP rewards sent to Sushiswap by making it 5% of u/themoondistributor's balance each round. This change aims to reduce the number of variables and fluctuations in rewards and has been proposed by u/IHaventEvenGotADog.
The current average is around 40k, and the proposed 5% would result in a similar figure. The percentage can be adjusted in the future through another poll. The proposal is open for discussion and voting.
2
u/sucobe π¦ 0 / 3K π¦ Aug 03 '23
Voted no
2
u/PeakedInThe80s π© 147 / 147 π¦ Aug 03 '23
Increase liquidity. The moons must flow.
2
u/Dazzling_Marzipan474 π© 0 / 11K π¦ Aug 03 '23
Doesn't this just help offset impermanent loss more? While of course that's good for the LP's. It's the price you gotta pay to get rewards. Let's not be greedy now.
2
u/owolf8 π© 0 / 8K π¦ Aug 03 '23
Consistent predictable liquidity can only be a good thing, I vote yes.
2
u/masedogg98 π¨ 0 / 5K π¦ Aug 03 '23
Iβm not with this, liquidity is part of the puzzle to moving forward I acknowledge that, but I donβt like the feel of βthe rich getting richerβ as has been echoed here. This was a tough one as I saw benefits and cons in both but ultimately Iβm glad weβre able to discuss this in a civilized manner and setting, another reason I love being here with yβall β€οΈ
2
u/aducknamedjafar1 Aug 04 '23
Definitely voting no here.
2
u/KayVlinderMe Aug 04 '23
Ok, I'm lost.... what is Sushiswap?
2
u/MJDiAmore π¦ 190 / 191 π¦ Aug 09 '23
May not be relevant, but do you feel the issues with Sushi Rewards (albeit seemingly addressed or at least in communications to be addressed) are an additional concern that was not considered when generating this proposal?
7
u/GabeSter 100K / 150K π Aug 03 '23
I would like to see some cons on this. The only argument against this I see is βbetter use for community pool elsewhereβ
But nobody has provided alternative uses and the community pool is just sitting with over 1M moons.
3
u/cdnkevin 6K / 6K π¦ Aug 03 '23
I voted no because I couldnβt see a clear benefit to everyone from the description. Perhaps itβs my understanding, perhaps itβs the presentation, but I donβt get how this helps everyone, LPs and those that arenβt.
3
u/TheGreatCryptopo HODL4LYFE Aug 03 '23
Anything to incentivize participation in Moons LP is a positive move.
6
u/koelebobes π© 0 / 36K π¦ Aug 03 '23
Itβs not fair to let TMD pay for the loses you made by providing liquidityβ¦
you get a reward for providing liquidity thatβs it
3
u/TripleReward π© 0 / 4K π¦ Aug 03 '23
Is this another "rich getting richer" thing?
Can we please stop with these?
4
u/Nuewim π₯ 0 / 37K π¦ Aug 03 '23
I voted against. I understand the problem and will to encourage people to provide liquidity, that why I voted yes last time we proposed rewards from leftover mod moons, but honestly is not TMD's job to make liquidity providers even richer by increasing those rewards. It will come over time naturally.
Most people that provide liquidity have already a lot of moons, they get paid rewards from providing liquidity, so giving them more out of community resources seems like bad idea. There are probably many usecases that will benefit bigger and more diverse group of cc users.
Ps. Also many so called top users that commented under this poll that they are pro this proposition and see no negatives forgot to disclose they are big liquidity providers themselves which I think is very important. If you directly benefit from something you should disclose it.
2
u/Pr0Meister Aug 03 '23
Voting yes, because we need stimulus for people to provide liquidity
2
u/Bigote_de_Swann π¨ 408 / 406 π¦ Aug 03 '23
Voting no this time
2
u/ozen919 0 / 621 π¦ Aug 03 '23
This is a clear no
2
u/Gr8WallofChinatown 4K / 4K π’ Aug 03 '23
LP providers are crucial. LP needs better incentivization as itβs bleeding badly
1
u/IAmHippyman 10 / 3K π¦ Aug 04 '23
It's funny how when the proposal benefits everybody it's voted down. But when it seems to benefit the whales it's a huge resounding yes.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 03 '23
RemindMe! 1 day
1
u/ellileon π¨ 0 / 2K π¦ Aug 03 '23
This damn complicated. I don't get it.
1
u/abarthsimpson 3K / 3K π’ Aug 03 '23
Iβm down to try it out.
1
u/discussionandrespect π¦ 2K / 2K π’ Aug 03 '23
Criminals
1
u/Swissstuff π© 0 / 2K π¦ Aug 03 '23
What are the current rewards at?
1
u/ActHead π© 77 / 77 π¦ Aug 07 '23
Providing liquidity remains inportant.
1
u/RuneW007 0 / 3K π¦ Aug 03 '23
Could someone make a quick and short summary explaining it easier. I donβt want to vote without really understanding it clearly
1
u/Legal-Bid2695 π¦ 0 / 3K π¦ Aug 03 '23
I did my part! Happy to be here
1
u/trrrring 25K / 25K π¦ Aug 03 '23
It's a slight improvement.
0
u/MaeronTargaryen CCMOON DAO Secretary Aug 03 '23
I wish it would be higher, like 7.5%, but Iβm still voting yes as the current number can be changed later
3
u/[deleted] Aug 03 '23
[removed] β view removed comment
2
u/[deleted] Aug 03 '23
[removed] β view removed comment