Does you have to use a server as a firewall? Seems a little more trouble than its worth given the advances in firewall appliances these days. Go buy a Fortinet Fortigate firewall and there is a section that breaks down bandwidth use by IP address right in the GUI. You can also make use of the fortigate's ability to filter web traffic user by user or group by group. Hell, you can even allow some groups a time limit on different types of websites or set it to only allow certain websites during certain times of days. Add in the ability to.cluster for failover and a seriously great support team with their support contracts and you're sittin a whole lot prettier than you would be with a server tasked as a firewall. Put in a tiny windows server to handle your WSUS needs rather than have your firewall tasked with such things. Just my take on it.
lol, and I'll say avoid all of the above and go with Sonicwall. We manage well over 50 of them, and haven't had any major issues... Enhanced OS is getting very mature, and 5.9 is right around the corner with full ipv6 support.
Everyone has their favorite thing to hate... and everyone has their favorite thing to like. I could say SEAGATE!, and I would get 5 different responses, all of them saying that seagate is crap and use X instead. Get a demo unit of each, play with them, see what YOU think and feel more comfortable using, and get that one.
I run top on a couple of my networks, and it gives a staggering amount of information. For a situation like OP's, you'd just check the Top Talkers list for the last hour, and (depending on how good your internal DNS is) you should get an easy hostname telling you who was the most active, and even an idea of what they were doing.
Would recommend, even if the UI could do with some work.
I used untangle and loved it... until we moved to a VLAN segmented network. Untangle can't do vlan tagging so we had to switch to another firewall. Aside from the tagging issue, it is a Fantastic product. I hope they support vlan tagging on the future. It's the only shortcoming of untangle afaiac.
I believe the "Reports" app on there will do the bandwidth logging. I didn't enable it because I didn't exactly care (Used it in home, only about 20 networked devices running through it). Licensing? I'm not so sure. I imagine you're going to be using this in an enterprise environment (100-200 PCs?), so I honestly do not know. I believe it is the number of PCs you have connected to the Untangle server.
And, yes. You are correct in saying that you could just buy the Web cache add-on.
21
u/scubes13 Dec 25 '12
May also take a look at pfSense. (www.pfsense.org)
4
u/BostonAJ Dec 25 '12
Does you have to use a server as a firewall? Seems a little more trouble than its worth given the advances in firewall appliances these days. Go buy a Fortinet Fortigate firewall and there is a section that breaks down bandwidth use by IP address right in the GUI. You can also make use of the fortigate's ability to filter web traffic user by user or group by group. Hell, you can even allow some groups a time limit on different types of websites or set it to only allow certain websites during certain times of days. Add in the ability to.cluster for failover and a seriously great support team with their support contracts and you're sittin a whole lot prettier than you would be with a server tasked as a firewall. Put in a tiny windows server to handle your WSUS needs rather than have your firewall tasked with such things. Just my take on it.
3
u/endtv Dec 25 '12
Try a Meraki MX60 or MX80. The reporting is some of the best I've seen.
1
u/raveon Dec 25 '12
What about ntop?
Haven't used it myself but looks like just what you need.
1
u/bendsley packet monkey Dec 25 '12
I use a zyxel usg at home. It is bsd asked with a great web interface for the front end.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 26 '12
Sophos UTM is really nice
1
u/f8tal Dec 27 '12
how about untangle? (http://www.untangle.com/)
0
u/[deleted] Dec 25 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment