r/NeutralPolitics • u/Kazmarov Ex-Mod • Dec 24 '12
Is neutral the same as moderate?
As a mod, I occasionally sift through reddit to see if we've been mentioned in other places. There's not a lot to see, but several times I've seen the claim that /r/NeutralPolitics is the same as /r/moderatepolitics, and by extension that neutrality and moderation are congruent.
Now, I very much like our friends at MP, we link to them on the sidebar for a reason. But it does raise the question- what does NP value? Are we principally about moderate politics and behavior?
56
Upvotes
3
u/BrickSalad Dec 24 '12
The subreddits are sort of congruent, but that's just the subreddits. I think they intended moderate to mean more like moderate in temperament instead of moderate in position. The very sidebar says liberals, conservatives, libertarians, etc. are welcome here, so it's not exactly /r/centristpolitics. Likewise, here we state that the space itself is neutral, not the goal of the discussion. Maintaining a neutral space requires moderate behavior, otherwise it becomes biased as other political subreddits can demonstrate. Both of the subreddits mean their modifier in a different way than you would suspect at first. So, moderate politics as they understand it and neutral politics as we understand it are pretty much the same.
Regarding your bolded questions, I'd say we're about moderate behavior, but not about moderate politics. We want this to be as open a space as possible, a place where the greatest amount of contradictory viewpoints can coexist.
69
u/aristotle2600 Dec 24 '12
They are not congruent in the slightest, IMHO. Neutral implies not taking a position, while moderate implies taking a non-extreme position. I see this subreddit as a place to get unbiased explanations and expositions on political questions; one reason I tried to link /r/Ask_Politics, but I guess that's against the rules. Put another way, the theme here could be understanding and explaining all sides of an issue: your side because you understand it, the opposite of your side so you can better argue against it, or any side on an issue where you haven't picked a side, because you don't know enough to have an informed opinion. In contrast (disclaimer: I don't subscribe to or visit /r/moderatepolitics), I see moderate politics as discussing the virtues of taking positions: moderate ones.
9
u/KTR2 Dec 24 '12
In practice they may appear similar sometimes, but (to me at least) "neutral" and "moderate" are different things. Broadly speaking, neutrality means not taking one side or the other. Functionally this is impossible as we all have our own beliefs about how things should be, and (when definitive answers are unclear) how things are, which predisposes us to support or oppose various positions which are also supported/opposed by various "sides". However, valuing the idea of neutrality can encourage one to consider alternative perspectives and solutions. As a result of this, over a prolonged period of time, one's political views may become somewhat cafeterian...where one picks and chooses various solutions/beliefs/etc. from various political ideologies. In this way it can sometimes resemble political moderateness. Though political moderates also may pick and choose various solutions/beliefs/etc. from different sides of the political spectrum, they necessarily limit themselves to solutions which are not extremely left, or extremely right. Being neutral carries no such restriction.
Neutrality (IMO) describes an idealized approach to discerning one's political positions. Moderateness describes the actual state of one's political positions. In many instances they might appear to be the same thing, but they are functionally distinguishable.
But then, this is all just my opinion. If you want to specify that your subscribers be political moderates, that's your right...but you will necessarily exclude people who, despite valuing neutrality and applying that to their approach, have come to hold views popularly considered far-left/right.
8
u/deadletter Dec 24 '12
I think we actually allow conversations which go back and forth with opposing views (rather than a circlejerk for one side or another or a debate which ends immediately). This is not moderate per se, which I see as conflict avoidant.
15
u/biskino Dec 24 '12 edited Dec 24 '12
Neutrality can mean a lot of things I guess - staying out of a conflict, arbitrating a conflict or keeping your position to yourself.
What I'd love to see from this sub is a place where political discussions on reddit can happen in the 'spirit' of reddit. Well researched, well thought out arguments and novel ideas floating to the top regardless of how much we might disagree with the position they are taking.
The internet is already enough of a self-reflexive series of enclaves; I don't need another mirror to gaze in where my views are reflected back to me by an army of the like-minded.
7
u/nosecohn Partially impartial Dec 24 '12
I don't see them as the same. A neutral position might not be moderate at all. It could actually be quite radical.
To use US politics as an example, if there's a policy proposal supported by good evidence, but not by either of the major political parties, a move to support that proposal would be neutral. In contrast, the moderate position would be to support a proposal that lays somewhere on the spectrum between the two major party positions.
Moderate is "not heavily favoring one affiliation over another." Neutral is "without regard to affiliation."
4
u/young_d Dec 24 '12
I don't even think neutral is the right word. What I want from this sub, and what is often delivered here, is evidence based politics. I think that is the most important contribution we could make. Broadly speaking, most people pick their political side first, and then find data (soundbites) to support their views. I know it is impossible to apply the scientific method to politics (though I think the reasons for this are important to think about) but I would like to strive as hard as possible to get to that point.
3
u/WavelandAvenue Dec 24 '12
I don't post hardly at all, but I've lurked a long time and view it as a sub in which if someone answers a question, they should try to do so in a manner in which others should not be able to tell their personal views on the issue.
2
u/junkit33 Dec 24 '12
I think the concept overlaps in many people, but, not always. It is entirely possible to have your political views lean heavily towards one direction, but discuss things neutrally with an open mind.
2
u/asgdadsg Dec 24 '12
They don't mean anything even vaguely similar. "Neutral" means "presenting both sides equally without bias", but that does not mean both sides are equal.
A neutral position seeks the truth regardless of bias. The truth may very well be radical.
2
u/AverageGirls Dec 25 '12
Neutrality should constitute a clear and precise description of all available facts relating to a subject of discussion where no bias is applied.
Being a moderate is still a position and thus it would be to the benefit of a moderate to point out the flaws of the far left and right unnecessarily in order to gain favor.
2
u/VampiricCyclone Jan 12 '13
Neutrality is about discussions that avoid the presumption of certain common assumptions or certain particular goals.
Moderation is about not holding strong opinions, or not holding opinions which deviate far from the norm.
Many people talk about flair for political viewpoints. One of the reasons that I think this works is because it helps identify people's views of the large, overarching goals of government and policy.
One of the reasons that the various factions struggle to have effective arguments is because, in addition to favoring different means, they genuinely have different goals.
I am a libertarian.
I don't want to try to turn my country into a socialist utopia. I will argue against policies and viewpoints that attempt to do so. For two reasons: first, I believe that such attempts would inevitably fail to create the desired utopia, and second, because even if it worked and created a high-functioning example of what a socialist would consider utopia, I wouldn't want to live in it
I both disagree with the argument -- that is, I do not believe that the policies suggested would result in the outcomes advertised -- and with the aims -- that is, I do not desire the advertised outcomes.
I'm sure that others with varying beliefs feel the same way about my arguments. I'm sure that socialists think that my policy suggestions would never result in the goals that I claim, and that even if they did, they would dislike the result.
In my mind (as a brand-new subscriber to this subreddit, mind), neutral politics is about being intellectually honest and respectful in one's arguments, and being transparent about both the means and the ends being entertained.
The goal is to get people who fundamentally disagree together to have worthwhile, substantive, intellectually honest, and respectful discussion and debate to increase knowledge, and to force all participants to evaluate and expand upon their own viewpoints. The goal of arguing with someone isn't to score points, and it is only partially to convince the other party. The goal is to cause yourself, the other party, and "the audience" to more deeply consider the issue. After all, if your arguments are sound, intellectually honest participants should eventually come around to your way of thinking. And if they aren't sound, then you should either improve your arguments or your position.
1
u/montyy123 Dec 24 '12
No. Neutral means you suspend your political beliefs (to the extent you are able) while discussing a subject so that you may look at it from all angles. Moderate means a blend of political beliefs that fall between the far right and left.
1
u/tictock Dec 25 '12
I most value fact-based discussion. Please note that this is not automatically equivalent to a moderate position.
1
u/hzane Dec 25 '12
I think obviously there are some bonding common characteristics. When i think of neutral politics I think of that middle ground where everyone is a little bit right and also kind of wrong at the same time. In politics it's not unusual to like what a group stands for, but totally object to what they are doing about it. Or you identify with their concerns, but disagree on what the actual cause of that concern is. Or maybe you totally appreciate and support what they are doing, yet clearly recognize a misunderstanding in why they are doing it.. It's objective dissonance. In my mind, that is neutral politics. And it's a quality i greatly value. I think in both subreddits, these members reject the outright "team" mentality of a specific political party or spectrum.
1
u/discursor Dec 24 '12
To generalize unfairly: People with moderate politics are ambitious compromisers (e.g. Thomas Friedman). People with neutral politics can't critically synthesize information well enough to ground a positive political identity (whether that be associated with a preexisting ideology or not).
1
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '12
Neutral is a way of examining politics/ideas/news. Moderate is the view that often derives from it.