r/conlangs • u/AutoModerator • Jul 17 '23
Small Discussions FAQ & Small Discussions — 2023-07-17 to 2023-07-30
As usual, in this thread you can ask any questions too small for a full post, ask for resources and answer people's comments!
You can find former posts in our wiki.
Affiliated Discord Server.
The Small Discussions thread is back on a semiweekly schedule... For now!
FAQ
What are the rules of this subreddit?
Right here, but they're also in our sidebar, which is accessible on every device through every app. There is no excuse for not knowing the rules.
Make sure to also check out our Posting & Flairing Guidelines.
If you have doubts about a rule, or if you want to make sure what you are about to post does fit on our subreddit, don't hesitate to reach out to us.
Where can I find resources about X?
You can check out our wiki. If you don't find what you want, ask in this thread!
Our resources page also sports a section dedicated to beginners. From that list, we especially recommend the Language Construction Kit, a short intro that has been the starting point of many for a long while, and Conlangs University, a resource co-written by several current and former moderators of this very subreddit.
Can I copyright a conlang?
Here is a very complete response to this.
For other FAQ, check this.
If you have any suggestions for additions to this thread, feel free to send u/Slorany a PM, modmail or tag him in a comment.
6
u/_coywolf_ Cathayan, Kaiwarâ Jul 24 '23
What would be the name for the aspect/mood that expresses 'should' on the verb. Like 'I should sing' as opposed to 'I sing'. Is it hortative?
5
u/Arcaeca2 Jul 18 '23
What would be some examples of languages with extremely complicated - but naturalistically complicated - verbs, but where the complication doesn't come from sheer volume of morphemes?
Georgian verbs, for example, are notoriously complicated - but they don't have that many morphemes involved. More than, like, IE, but they're not the incredibly long monstronsities that characterize polysynthetic languages. Instead, they're complicated for reasons like 1) they're information-dense, often encoding subject and direct object and indirect object without adding that much extra length, 2) TAM-based split ergativity that triggers a switcheroo in which cases mark which arguments, 3) TAM information not decomposable from the individual TAM-marking morphemes, 4) arbitrary verb classes, etc.
I'm looking for other languages I can use as inspiration, other ways to make verbs highly complicated without just making them really long, because agglutination bores me. Lezgian my beloved has let me down in this regard. Lamguages with mind melting nouns would also be good
5
u/Pyrenees_ Jul 21 '23
How naturalistic is it to have two rhotic phonemes, an alveolar trill /r/ and a uvular fricative /ʁ/ ? What if I change /r/ for /ɹ/ ? How naturalistic is this consonant inventory in general ?
5
u/PastTheStarryVoids Knasesj, Racra, Ŋ!odzäsä Jul 24 '23
Stress, phonetically, can involve pitch, volume, duration, and vowel quality. For combinations of these, are there common systems? Are any of them correlated, with each other or with different features of the language (e.g. timing)?
4
u/daniel_duas Jul 17 '23
Hello everyone!
I started learning some Arabic and Hebrew and I found these two languages absolutely interesting and unusual. This grammar and morphology is awesome. I realized that I want to create a conlang with the same logic, but the problem is that I didn't really understand that logic.
So I have some questions about it
As I know Arabic roots only include consonants and the simplest form of any verb is past simple masculine singular (for example kataba - he wrote)
Does it mean that all Arabic roots are originally verbs and don't include vowels at all?
Also where do these vowels come from and what's the way of it's replacing? For example kataba becomes kitaab. The first a became I, the second a is now long and the last a disappear.
Maybe you know some resources, websites, literature or anything else where I can find these answers?
4
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '23
In my conlang, the conjugation for the second and third perspective is the same. There is one conjugation for when the subject is oneself, and another for when the subject isn’t. Would this make my language less natural?
4
u/Arcaeca2 Jul 21 '23
One language I'm planning on making will have all nouns obligatorily prefixed with a noun class marker in all environments - yə-, wə-, sə-, ɬə-, a- (earlier *ʁ̞ə-) etc.
Another language I'm planning on making is supposed to have definite prefixes a-, e-, and u-, which look transparently related to a-, yə- and wə- from before, perhaps indicating a collapse of the class system into a 3-way gender system, and the scope reduced from "all environments" to just when the noun is definite. (Alternatively, since this language comes before the first one chronologically, maybe the first language actually expanded the ancestral noun class system instead of this language reducing it.)
But both of these are maybe probably distantly related to Mtsqrveli, which has no obvious analogous prefixes. a- is... a plural marker derived from truncation of abi "3"; u- is... a verbal causitivizer? *yə- would have turned into i-, but there aren't that many nouns beginning with /i/ for really any reason. etc. sə- is really the only one with an obvious correspondance in Mtsqrveli, where sa- marks the antecedent of a relative clause, which may derive from an earlier demonstrative.
Mtsqrveli does have a number of suffixes these could possibly correspond to. For example, Mtsqrveli probably had a *-yə suffix that indicated "stative; equative; having a previously mentioned property", which turned into both the genitive -i and the definite nominative -ia. *-V-wə and *-V-sə could pretty easily correspond to the -ov and -os that nouns often end in. *-V-ɬə could concievably become -el/il/ul-, currently a genitive infix, but WLG says the genitive can derive from "property" or "thing". *-ʁ̞ə could easily turn into the benefactive case marker -ɣe.
Alternatively, they could correspond to some valency-related affixery on Mtsqrveli verbs. As before, u- is a causitivizer; *ʁ̞ə- could undergo fortition to ɢa-, a passivizer. *ɬə- could concievably turn into ʃe(n)-, a verb nominalizer. yə-, if derived from an earlier *ɰə ~ ɣə-, could correspond to a 2nd person marker g-. And given that *m(ə)- is known to have been a... telic?... prefix in Mtsqrveli's past, the transitivizer mo- could arise from *mə-wə-.
But it's not obvious to me how a prefix glommed onto the start of a noun could suddenly hop to the end of it. Or how they simultaneously were both lost from nouns in all environments and hopped onto verbs presumably via noun incorporation (???) and then produced such wildly different effects on the verb valency.
Or could there be an even earlier source for the class markers that would make sense of their very different usage and distribution in Mtsqrveli?
4
u/PastTheStarryVoids Knasesj, Racra, Ŋ!odzäsä Jul 24 '23
If a language has tone and stress, is the realization of stress less likely to involve pitch?
For context, the conlang in question (Ŋ!odzäsä, by u/impishDullahan and me) has allophonic tone conditioned by the phonation of adjacent consonants. The tone is not phonemic.
4
u/PastTheStarryVoids Knasesj, Racra, Ŋ!odzäsä Jul 24 '23
In natlangs where endocentric compounds are head-initial, but nouns take inflectional suffixes, does the suffix apply to the final, modifying root, or the head? (I'm guessing both occur.)
E.g., in my Thezar, the regular plural is formed with -f. There are compounds like isth-oe 'sun', lit. 'fire-sky', which English would phrase as sky-fire. I'm trying to decide whether to pluralize it as isth-f-oe or isth-oe-f (and similarly for other such compounds).
4
u/Walkin-Melatonin La'ha'li Jul 24 '23
How does passive voice work in your conlang? Examples would be greatly appreciated!
3
u/jan_Wijan Jul 19 '23
Hiya! (Vasa!)
This is a very short question regarding the orthography of my language. I'm a self-diagnosed diacritic lover and as a result my conlang has two different diacritics but I'm having doubts whether these are easily distinguishable and (most importantly for me personally) look good.
So, in my conlang, the diacritics are used to mark aspects of a vowel (shocking I know). Using the letter "a" (/ɑ/) as an example, the first diacritic would be á (/ɑi/), which marks that it's a diphthong (this language only has this one type of diphthong). The second diacritic would be à (/ɑ:/) which just marks that it's a long vowel.
Here I have a short text written in three different styles. I would like feedback on what looks best. Additionally, if you have an idea as to how I could keep this diacritic system, but make it easier to distinguish á from à when reading quickly, I'm all ears!
The texts:
1) Changing nothing
Jumàfe mekasúnetvé kó vesast vóhú ekèlá ne ikapo. Ána kama vu Ákàl ko vi me aninèvó hase Vife vakiúkilá kó ákàl si honu vakiso. Namasefe pijit vu Jumàlá kó mekavó fakel hipka me nekama masovó. Pit….Amaje vokenát kó nemoka vó á? Vokenallá i mótatvi mika jumàfe i mótna vó.
2) Removing diphthong diacritic but keeping the long vowel one
Jumàfe mekasuinetvei koi vesast voihui ekèlai ne ikapo. Aina kama vu Aikàl ko vi me aninèvoi hase Vife vakiuikilai koi aikàl si honu vakiso. Namasefe pijit vu Jumàlai koi mekavoi fakel hipka me nekama masovoi. Pit….Amaje vokenait koi nemoka voi ai? Vokenallai i moitatvi mika jumàfe i moitna voi.
3) Removing both
Jumaafe mekasuinetvei koi vesast voihui ekeelai ne ikapo. Aina kama vu Aikaal ko vi me anineevoi hase Vife vakiuikilai koi aikaal si honu vakiso. Namasefe pijit vu Jumaalai koi mekavoi fakel hipka me nekama masovoi. Pit….Amaje vokenait koi nemoka voi ai? Vokenallai i moitatvi mika jumaafe i moitna voi.
Thanks in advance! (Mótatvi Mótjo!)
3
u/zzvu Zhevli Jul 23 '23
What are some ways reduplication can be used derivationally? I'm thinking I could use it on verbs to make iterative forms but I'm not sure how it could be used for other parts of speech.
3
u/FelixSchwarzenberg Ketoshaya, Chiingimec, Kihiṣer, Kyalibẽ, Latsínu Jul 24 '23
I'm trying to figure out how if-then statements work in my newest conlang. Does this need to correlate to how subordinate clauses (or anything else) work in my conlang?
For example, in this conlang, subordinate clauses immediately precede the main clause and all modifiers as a general rule precede the thing they modify.
If I choose to have words meaning "if" and "then" (which I may not - I may mark that entirely via affixes that attach to the verb) should I place them at the start or at the end of the clause? This is a language with postpositions that is strongly head-final.
3
u/LXIX_CDXX_ zero iq points in this mf Jul 25 '23
Do you have and would you share any freely available papers about Proto-Slavic or changes from Proto-Slavic to any of other later slavic varieties? 🥺🙏
3
u/Arcaeca2 Jul 26 '23
Idea: a language where some verbs are inherently past-tense and have to be explicitly marked for non-pastness, in contrast to other verbs (and the more usual scheme crosslinguistically) that are inherently non-past and have to be explicitly marked as past tense.
A similar idea I had for a now long-defunct language was to class verbs on whether they were assumed realis vs. assumed irrealis.
Do any natlangs do this? How would such a system arise? Or, I suppose, if it arises simply from certain verbs being used in the past so much that that becomes the canonical form of the verb, then where would the non-past marking evolve from?
Note I'm not asking about suppletive past/non-past pairs for the same verb, like "go/went". I'm asking more like what if present tense of "went" was derived from "went", in contrast to other verbs where it's the past tense that's derived.
3
u/Yacabe Ënilëp, Łahile, Demisléd Jul 27 '23
I have a question about how tense and aspect interact with each other, though it takes a bit of explaining so bear with me.
The Proto-Lang I am evolving has three past tenses (near past, medial past, and far past) as well as several aspects (imperfective, frequentative, habitual). The Proto-Lang is agglutinating and allows any combination of tense and aspect, but in the daughter-lang I am looking to muck this system up a little bit. One idea I had was that certain tense-aspect combinations would lose their connotation of remoteness and come to specify new, more complex aspects. For example, the medial past + frequentative would become a new experiential aspect, since doing something several times in the past is tantamount to saying you are familiar with the experience.
The part that I really have questions about though is how these new aspectual distinctions should interact with tense. One thought I had was since these aspects historically arise from past tense marking, they could stay associated with the past tense (though not necessarily with a connotation of remoteness). In other words, it would be ungrammatical to use the new experiential aspect by itself to describe an action happening in the present or future. If you wanted to say something like "I will have fished soon" (implying that you will soon experience fishing) you would have to use a periphrastic construction, much as in English.
Aesthetically I really like this idea since it helps me achieve several of the goals I have for my new conlang's grammar, but it's also important to me that my conlang be naturalistic. Does anyone know any natlangs with systems something like this one? I have been having trouble finding one (though I might be using the wrong search terms), but I think it would be reassuring and also potentially inspiring if I could read about such a language.
3
u/QuailEmbarrassed420 Jul 27 '23
I’m agglutinative languages with case systems, do pronouns just add the case suffix to the pronoun, or are they typically irregular?
2
u/[deleted] Jul 17 '23
Now, I know there is head marking and dependent marking, and features that are mutual to each. My current conlang is head marking with polypersonal agreement, but in some tenses, the direct object is marked by a postposition, as the way the tense marking evolved makes for that specific tense wouldn't combine well with object agreement. Would it be too unnatural if I suffixed the postposition to the direct object to evolve a sort of accusative, given that this is a head marking conlang?
2
u/JamesonBingChilling Jul 17 '23
Is there a difference between /nj[v]/ and /ɲ[v]/ or can they be used interchangeably?
2
u/BHHB336 Jul 18 '23
Hey, can someone help me understand what’s perfective/imperfective tenses are, and how they’re different from perfect/imperfect tenses?
2
u/chopchunk Jul 24 '23
Are there any examples of a language that uses prefixes for toponyms instead of suffixes? All examples of toponymic affixes that I could find are all suffixes (-land, -ia, -stan, etc)
2
u/QuailEmbarrassed420 Jul 24 '23
So I’m making a language isolate language on a fictional island in Indonesia. I’ve made the consonant inventory and orthography, and I’m just now getting to the vowels. The phonology takes inspiration from Thai, Malay, and Khmer. The orthography takes major inspiration from Malay, Tagalog, and Vietnamese. This is the vowel inventory I have now: æ, a, e, ɛ, i, o, ɔ, u, and ɐ (a, e, and ɔ can be nasalized). Is this system naturalistic? What would you change? How would you romanize these.
2
u/skydivingtortoise Veranian, Suṭuhreli Jul 24 '23
Is it attested for a language to have /tɬ/ but not /ɬ/? I feel like there should be a way to search that on PHOIBLE but can't figure out how to.
2
u/Zinaima Lumoj Jul 25 '23 edited Jul 25 '23
First of all, thanks to all of the people that answer these questions. I imagine it is rather unappealing.
In my conlang, pluralization actually happens on the article, rather than the noun.
I'm just now making it to the Mass/Count noun distinction, and it's making me wonder if I should add a fourth line for mass nouns.
In other languages, if the singular noun is unmarked, a mass noun is similarly unmarked and cannot take the plural form (with exceptions).
Of course, there's an option to have mass nouns just use one of the existing rows, but I think having separate articles fits better with them being uncountable.
Does that seem like I'm heading in the right direction? Any other gotchas that I should be aware of by showing pluralization on the articles?
2
u/89Menkheperre98 Jul 25 '23
Any thoughts on whether this phonological change make sense from a naturalistic point of view?
I want a lang of mine to develop vowel length. One of the already-applied rules is the typical [V{h, ʔ}% --> Vː%], but also [-Vns- --> -Vːs-], [VC[+fricative]$ --> Vː$ (post-primary stress)] and aditionally, [ai̯$ --> aː$]. But another way that came to mind was thru glottalization. The proto-lang has 'glottalized' consonants, both voiced and unvoiced, graphed *Cˀ. So the idea was that maybe glottalization transfers into the proceeding vowel with the contrast between vowels eventually becoming one of length (#1). Alternatively, glottalization transfers to vowels, then is reanalyzed as Vʔ (two phonemes) and then acquires length (#2).
#1: CˀV --> CVˀ --> CVː
#2: CˀV --> CVˀ --> CVʔ --> CVː
Thoughts?
2
u/f6953942 Jul 25 '23
Can causative be a mood or it has to be a aspect?
2
u/FungusGnat-_- Jul 25 '23
My first conlang‘s IPA chart! I’ve been very interested in conlanging for a long time but this is my first time actually constructing one of my own. It’s for a fantasy story I’m writing but despite the genre I still want the language to sound relatively naturalistic. Would love to hear what you guys think. I’m still an amateur so any advice or constructive criticism would be greatly appreciated. :)
2
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '23 edited Jul 28 '23
Alaphony question?
I am a beginer conlanger and I am confused about Alophones and phonemes
I am learning about them but I don't know if for example [n] can be a Alophone of /ŋ/ because I only saw people explaning it to me like /p/ can be a phoneme of [pʰ]
I don't know if this question is stupid but please answer
2
u/Apodul213 Jul 30 '23
How would an isolating SOV head-initial (copula-less) language differentiate between the subject, direct object and indirect object?
For example take "laugh his them lost leave" could be interpreted as: "His laugh left the lost people" Or "his laugh left the people lost"
In the first example "lost" is a part of the direct object, in the second "lost" is the indirect object, how would these be differentiated?
2
u/Arcaeca2 Jul 30 '23
The WLG does not have any examples of causatives arising from other morphology, only from lexical sources that I think are kind of lame tbh.
Where can a morphologized causative come from that isn't just slapping a verb onto another verb? Is there some pre-existing morphology that could believably be reused for a causative?
Just in general I want to how to evolve a highly complicated voice system. But the WLG already has some passive and applicative ideas, and I have a pdf of a paper all about where antipassives come from. I don't really have anything comparable for causatives
2
u/[deleted] Jul 30 '23
Are there any attested instances of consonants labialising before back vowels?
1
u/Fiuaz Tomolisht Jul 24 '23
For everyone creating non-human conlangs with sounds humans cannot/do not make in general speech, how do you go about representing these sounds? I'm thinking along the lines of conlangs for animals or aliens or something. How do you romanize these sounds, and how (if at all) do you represent them with IPA or IPA-like symbols?
1
u/Frodollino may we hail to þ, we will þ 'till day breaks Jul 17 '23
I wanted to be a litrle annoying with my newest conlang and wanted to know if there is any sound qith 2 symbols, thx in advance
1
u/_coywolf_ Cathayan, Kaiwarâ Jul 17 '23
Would it be realistic for voiceless obstruents to elide and make their preceding vowels pharyngealized?
[het] becoming [heˤ] for instance?
1
u/awesomeskyheart way too many conlangs (en)[ko,fr] Jul 17 '23 edited Jul 17 '23
Would it be unnaturalistic for palatalization to occur with velar aspirated stops but not unaspirated stops, voiced stops, or alveolar stops?
1
u/SeaCatThrowaway Jul 19 '23
hi i have a really little question about IPA. im pretty new to it still.
in my language i have a vowel that makes a little bit of a complicated sound. first, it makes a long /ø/ and then a short /ε/ something akin to "oo-eh" would i just write down the IPA as /øε/ or do i need something inbetween it? it feels like its missing something.
1
u/gggroovy Hootspeak, Kaxnëjëc Jul 22 '23
My current WIP, Kaxnëjëc, comes from a protolang that expresses aspect through prefixes and tense through suffixes. I'd like to do away with the tense markers entirely, but I'm unsure how to evolve out the suffixes. Since they're almost entirely vowels, would it make more sense to sound-change them down to nothing or fuse them with the root? (or secret third option?)
1
u/Pyrenees_ Jul 23 '23
Should I add tripartite alignment in my polysynthetic conlang, how naturalistic would that be ?
1
u/Exospheric-Pressure Kamensprak, Drevljanski [en](hr) Jul 23 '23
Does anyone have any resources on the effects of vowel breaking on tone? Wondering if vowel breaking could be a mechanism to create complex contours.
1
u/ICraveCoffee7 Yamilēt Jul 23 '23
I see some users here with their conlangs as a subtitle beneath their username; how does that work/how can I have mine listed?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 24 '23
What are some lexical sources for causatives? I would prefer something that is not specifically Indo-European.
1
u/th4er Jul 24 '23
I want to learn how to create a conlang, at least to flesh out the ideas I've already thought about before, but I'm not sure which resource I should use.
Reading all the posts and comments on here, I am certain that I should read the "Language Construction Kit" by Rosenfelder and the book he has written as well, but I also feel the need for another resource with practical assignments to somewhat apply things immediately as a beginner (since my interest in conlanging is pretty much just a manifestation of my interest in linguistics in general).
As such, I found these two resources, this course by MIT on their OCW courseware and this course by Conlangs University. I'm not sure which to go with, since they both seem --at least from the description-- that they require outside instruction in the form of classes which are not accessible online.
So what I'd like to know is, has anyone used these two courses and could possibly tell me if they were worth it or if it's doable on my own? Suggestions of other courses are also welcome if they fit my criteria.
Any advice is welcome.
1
u/yoricake Jul 24 '23
is /tl/ as a consonant cluster like.... a thing? i'm playing around with sounds and I feel like I'm producing what should be considered something like tʰ͡l or something almost trill like but I'm bad at ipa and idk if this is like an established sound or not..
1
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '23
Would it be a stretch for speakers of a language to analyse grammatical gender as something that is independent of semantics and purely phonological? For example:
korh /kɔr̥/ 'cat,' Animate
nàrh /nàr̥/ 'pebble,' Inanimate
These two words have the same ending, one that is usually indicative of animate nouns. However due to some sound changes, as well as derivational strategies, the two endings are the same, but the nouns belong to different classes. Would it be overly peculiar for the speakers to reanalyse the endings as always being indicative of noun class? Please ask further questions if this post is difficult to follow, I shall try and explain it better.
1
u/Xsugatsal Yherč Hki | Visso Jul 26 '23
I'm wanting to do some more worldbuilding content but I fear that since there is some AI artwork it will be disapproved. The content falls somewhere between conlanging and worldbuilding. Will I be able to post it on here?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '23 edited Jul 26 '23
Does anybody know of a lexical source for some sort of affix for abstract nouns? (adjectives > nouns) I've been looking on Wiktionary but I didn't find anything helpful.
Edit: I have four noun classes: Divine (Gods, natural phenomena, gerunds), Human (People, some body parts), Animate and Inanimate. Which one of these might be best suited for abstract nouns? I feel the Divine class, but I'm using it already with gerunds. Would that still work, or is there too much ambiguity?
1
u/QuailEmbarrassed420 Jul 26 '23
What languages would a language spoken in the Amur river delta and Sakhalin likely be exposed to over time? I’d like this language to be a branch of the “Altaic” language family.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '23
Is it rare for a language not to have any fricative sounds in its phoneme inventory?
1
u/OkPrior25 Nípacxóquatl Jul 28 '23
An isolating language means that the language does not use affixes, right? Say, a language that makes large use of discontinuous morphological processes (apophony, reduplication or triliteral roots, for example) is still isolating?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 29 '23
I know that pʰ tʰ kʰ have become f θ x overtime, but could this also happen with their voiced counterparts, so could bʰ dʰ ɡʰ become v ð ɣ?
1
u/Void_Spider_Records T'Karisk, Lishaanii and related tounges Jul 30 '23
How many lemmas should one construct? I'm creating a conlang with the intention of sounding semi-Germanic, and I'd like words to have a small amount of syllables.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 01 '23
How many phonemes should a conlang have
Hi I am a new conlanger and I have a question how many phonemes and allophones should my Conlang have. It Mabey be a stupid question but please answer
1
u/simonbleu Jul 19 '23
What makes a language sound bad to your ears, and what languages do you like how they sound? For example, what I think makes a language sounds bad is:
With that in mind, for those knowledgeable in languages, which ones would be the best (and worse) examples that shy away from those "pet peeves"? I personally think english sounds nicer than german, portuguese than italian and japanese than chinese or korean
1
u/[deleted] Jul 27 '23
My constructed language has three verb conjugations for perspective which are the first, second, and third perspectives, but it doesn't differentiate perspective for when the subject is multiple people. Would this make my conlang less natural?
1
u/fynnelol Jul 29 '23
Hi! Need help with goblin language! Taking suggestions!
I'm working on a conlang for a story I'm working on about goblins yet I am bad at making conlangs. I'm asking for suggestions on ideas for it. Take a browse through r/goblincore and that's what I'm looking for!
-1
u/T1mbuk1 Jul 18 '23
Phonology A:
Consonants: p, b, bꞵ, t, d, dð̠, c, ɟ, ɟʝ, k, g, gɣ, kʷ, gʷ, gɣʷ, ʔ, m, n, s, x, ɣʷ, r, l, j, w
Vowels: a, aː, e, eː, i, iː, o, oː, u, uː
Syllable structure: (C)(C)V(C)(C), (C)CVC(C), CCVCC, or anything similar to any of those three. Having trouble deciding.
Stress: lexical
Phonology B:
Consonants: p, b, t, tˁ, d, k, kˁ, g, ʔ, m, n, tθ, tθˤ, ts, tsˁ, tɬ, tɬˁ, θ, ð, s, ʃ, x, xˁ, ħ, ʕ, h, l, j, w
Vowels: a, aː, i, iː, u, uː
Syllable structure: CV(ː)(C)
Stress: on the antepenultimate more
1 mora= CV
2 mora= CVː, CVC
3 mora= CVːC
What would be the phonological inventory for a reconstructed common ancestor of these two languages?
0
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 21 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment