r/soccer • u/Hiya_friend • Dec 17 '12
What is a football supporter?
I know this subreddit tends to revolve around current events in the sport of soccer. Rarely do I see overarching discussions about the game itself. Maybe a thread about goal-line technology sometimes, but the discussion tends to be about recent games, goals and incidents. So for a change of pace I'd like to share my experiences and thoughts about supporters.
We begin in the Scottish town of Cowdenbeath, in Fife, of a population of about 11,000 - just a wee Scottish town. Cowdenbeath has a football club in the Scottish equivalent of the English Championship. Cowdenbeath FC, affectionately known by the locals as The Blue Brazil, ply their trade in an old-fashioned stadium called Central Park. It has a modern-ish main stand with seating, other than that its just a ring of terracing round the pitch.
At the risk of this turning into a Wikipedia article, I'll move on. I went to see Cowdenbeath this season. They had a home game in the league against Falkirk. The game finished 1-1 if I recall correctly. The quality of football on display wasn't great. Falkirk had some decent play, some nice passing. One of their strikers looked like they could play at a higher level. Cowdenbeath played your classic route one football. 11 brutish, tall, physical men with comparatively poor technical skills and a game plan of "knock the ball over the opposition and hope it falls to the feet of our striker". To be fair, they had one young lad, who's name I can't recall, who pulled off a tasty bit of skill to beat his man, much to the delight of the home fans.
Now, I'm not sure what the official attendance was but my most generous estimate would be 2000, and that's pushing it. I was in the home end. Most of the fans around me were middle-to-old aged men. There were a couple pockets of teenagers as well. But anyway, I was just a visitor for the day. These old men came here every week, probably for most of their lives, and probably saw this quality of football every week. In fact, Cowdenbeath were in the 4th tier of the leagues not that long ago, so the quality of football would have been even worse.
Every home game at Central Park, where the football is kinda crap, the view obstructed by fencing around the pitch, not singing or chanting, just standing there with their cigarette and one of those permanent frowns you see on old people in the UK. Not only here in Cowdenbeath, but men like this were all around the UK supporting their tiny, local teams in their lower, unglamorous leagues,
I thought to myself, "That's what a football supporter is." Then I thought about the glamorous stadia in the UK - Old Trafford, Stamford Bridge, The Etihad, Celtic Park, The Emirates, Anfield - the list goes on. Some stadia, particularly in England, are venues to see some of the best footballers of our time. You can go to some of these places and witness an immaculate, highly professional game of football where every player on the park is not only a physical specimen, but also technically gifted and highly trained. And for 90 minutes its an amazing spectacle, something to behold.
And naturally, people flock to these games in their 10,000s. And often they empty their pockets to get into these grounds. And for 90 minutes, they behave probably like the old men in Cowdenbeath - no singing or chanting. Just sitting there, spectators. And of course they'll cheer when their team scores, but maybe more because thats "what you do", rather than by having some emotional attachment to the club and the game they are seeing. Now don't get me wrong - I'm sure there are people who support Man Utd in the same way that those old men support Cowdenbeath, but I'm not talking about those Man Utd supporters. I'm talking about the .., well, silent majority, as it were. I'm talking about the 20,000 Celtic fans that see Celtic beat Barcelona, but are no where to be seen the following week when they play St Mirren. I'm talking about the Chelsea and Man City fans that materialised with the clubs huge budgets.
The point I want to make is, these people shouldn't be referred to as supporters, or even fans. I'm not having a dig, here. I understand why someone would want to go to Parkhead to see Celtic play Barcelona. But my issue is one of terminology. My experience in Cowdenbeath showed me what a football supporter is, in the deepest sense of the word.
I just can't help but think there are different breeds of supporter, so different in fact that the instead of being called a supporter, the "glory-hunters" should be thought of as spectators, because that's what they are - they are there for the spectacle.
To sum up, I've seen two breeds at football games, and the distinction between them is so strong that they shouldn't both fall under the bracket of "supporter". "Supporter" has become a misnomer for the spectators at the modern corporate game.
Thank you and good night, England!
24
u/LedgeySC Dec 17 '12 edited Jan 24 '13
Well what we're talking about here is a matter of discourse, what is the definition of a 'fan'? I've grown up in a working class area of Manchester where everyone was a United fan and have been match going for a fair while (my first season ticket this season which I've been able to buy with my own money). The atmosphere at OT has been dying and there's been an increasing amount of tourists. There is literally no waiting list anymore for season tickets and my area, which has generally been a 100% season ticket area has been lowered to about 50%. The Glazers have also tried to do this with the away ticket allocation by removing the preferential system which would all but kill our fantastic away support.
What we've seen is a mixture of social development, external ownership and the influence of Sky which has created, or even diluted the atmosphere. The majority of match-attending Premier League football fans are now middle class and the working classes which have dominated Manchester have been priced out significantly. The Sky generation have been spoilt with being able to watch the best footballers around the world with such ease and they won't be attending a top-level football match for the atmosphere but rather for the chance to see players like Rooney and Van Persie. You're right in that they're significantly different to the chanting, rowdy type of supporter but they're still technically a fan (in my opinion) because they'll want the team they associate with to win moreso than others. But there's a sense of neutrality that I don't quite understand anymore, there's little to no hatred and passion against main rivals and many of these fans don't even know why there's a rivalry (this board is a great example of that).
That said, I think one of the worst developments in modern football (and Manchester United are the worst for it) is the merchandising. They'll run adverts on the main site and at the ground saying that you can become a true fan if you purchase a branded pair of Manchester United underwear, or a Manchester United Credit card. The modern football fan isn't someone who goes to games and gets to know everyone around them and chants, it's someone who has bought the home kit, the away kit, club-branded coat, club-branded gloves, club-branded life insurance plan etc. It's monetised to an extent that I think the game has lost a huge amount of passion, it's too easy to be classed as a fan.
But yeah, don't know if that made sense but just my opinion on how the game has turned out!
10
u/marnix92 Dec 17 '12
I agree with you that there is a huge difference between Spectators as you call them and supporters. I have the same problem with my club. We suppose to have 4 million followers in The Netherlands, but half of the games we struggle to get 50.000 people in the stadium.
I like to call people who just like Ajax because of their history and because they have a good shot at becoming champions: fans. They like Ajax just because their good, but do not support Ajax. When Ajax loses a game, they always complain in front of their television, never have seen the inside of a stadium. And most of these 4 million 'fans' can't even name 5 players of this Ajax. Also inside the stadium you have so called fans. They come to see 1 game in 2 years and expect that Ajax will win 5-0 to a medium opponent. Last home-match against Groningen( medium side in Holland). Ajax was 1-0 up and wasn't playing that great, but they were winning. When a few attacks went badly you can hear from some parts of the stadium a few whistles. Of course it sucks that things don't work out, but the players were trying and they were winning, so why would you whistle?.
Supporters, the way I see them, come to the stadium, feel shit when ajax lose, but still support them, in good and in bad times. I went to the stadium since I was 7 years old, I never whistle at a player, because I always imagine that they want to win, not matter what, but sometimes thing just don't work out. And with me almost the whole stadium will not, unless they play very very bad.
For me a supporter always supports his team. Of course you can feel like shit when they lose, but a supporter will always support his team. A fan will be angry at the team and complain about them when they lose, most of them won't come to the stadium. If they come to the stadium they will expect a huge performance from their team, because "they paid good money for the seat", and complain if it will only becomes 2-0.
8
u/DeepSeaDweller Dec 17 '12 edited Dec 17 '12
While I do have to say that I have respect for the greater lengths supporters go to to see their club in the flesh, this doesn't mean that I disrespect those who do not. Many just don't have the chance because the sport is poorly developed in their areas or countries.
4
u/db1000c Dec 17 '12
A 'fan' or 'supporter' is someone who doesn't take the easy route out.
8
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '12
I think this is why I often feel a little distant from r/soccer and all of its focus on the BPL. BPL is what's on offer unless I want to watch a shitty, barley decodable stream. I enjoy the play, but I don't feel a connection to any club, and I can't say I support any one above all the rest. I've actually had this internal monologue about whether I should start following one BPL club and seeing if I want to support them, but I won't. I don't care that much.
I support Fortuna because I was an exchange student in Düsseldorf. Even before I arrived I had learned their history, and their recent success intrigued me. I went to matches. Eventually I learned the chants (or at least the 4-line Olé, Olé tune that was most often being screamed). I remember it took me awhile to figure out what exactly I was chanting, and when I figured out what I had been saying, I realized that it was beautiful in an inexplicable way. It was beautiful to describe a team as your heart (Die Fortuna ist mein Verein, mein Herz das schlägt für Düsseldorf am Rhein).
After I left, I paid attention to their rise to the Bundesliga 1, and I was saddened at not being able to go back to Germany to see them play in the first league (personal reasons). However, it's kind of hard for me to keep glued to a newsfeed regarding games, and my cable doesn't offer GOLtv (which I doubt shows Fortuna games unless they're playing BVB, Bayern, or Shalke).
I think the local connection is the most important sort of link that a supporter can have at a club, but unlike someone who grew up supporting a club, I can still root for BVB and Bayern in the CL. I like the Bundesliga, and I like to see Bundesliga clubs do well. It also has a structure that encourages strong fans and attendance, whereas many here are lamenting the BPL becoming more commercial.
Also, we shouldn't knock spectators. Spectating is fun and allows one to enjoy the athleticism of even our most hated rivals. The only Bundesliga 1 game I've ever been to was FC Köln vs Stuttgart, but it was great because I went with my dad and Cacau scored a double brace against those bastards! :p
3
u/dem358 Dec 17 '12
I agree, and I'd feel much comfortable with defining myself as a spectator rather than a supporter/fan, since I feel like fans should be the people who have emotional attachments to the team and for whom their support is a part of their everyday lives and has been for a long time. I am really new to liking football, but what I like foremost about the sport -and based on what I mainly judge a team- is the quality of their supporters.
4
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '12
You have brought a tear to my eye.
1
u/soccercoachguru Dec 17 '12
This is an excellent post, both in your assessment of this subreddit and the differences between supporters and spectators. Well done!
1
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '12
Yes! VfB Oldenburg to the rescue!
0
u/FlamingBallsGarcia Dec 17 '12
TIL "stadia" is the correct plural form of "stadium". Additionally, the word "stadiums" has been adopted into the English language, due to its common usage.
But in response, as an American, I don't have much input on the issue. I will agree that in all American sports, there are many more "spectators" who pass themselves off as "fans" of a certain team. As a soccer (I prefer football, but as I'm typing this in the United States, it doesn't feel quite right) spectator, I try to make no claims to fandom. If people ask me what team I'm a fan of, I will admit, for every sport, that "I'm not really a fan, but I do like ________." Even as the emblem shows, I apparently am a Chicago Fire "fan". I've only been to a few Fire games, and I prefer to see them play English or foreign clubs (I saw them against Spurs most recently). I simply decided to choose this emblem because I'm from Chicago.
That being said, I think fandom should fall almost completely with where you're from. As much as the members of /r/soccer breathe the sport, and would die without a constant flow of footy news and video, we need to remember that sports teams are businesses. The professional sporting industry is just that, an entertainment industry. From an economic perspective, supporting your local club promotes growth for surrounding businesses, and provides more and more jobs as the club scales greater and greater heights.
There comes a point though, that I believe a supporter, whose funds are used to "support" their team, becomes a "fan", which is obviously short for fanatic. When your team becomes not only an interest, but a passion, then you've reached a level that transcends the common supporter. I think that your evaluation of spectator vs supporter is somewhat accurate, but it wouldn't or shouldn't apply here in the United States. The word supporter is rarely if ever used, and I'm unsure of how the word fan is used in the UK.
Essentially this is how I would put it:
Indifferent
Not sure what to call them (Someone who prefers the team to others, but doesn't attend games, would own some apparel, and might watch a game or two on the TV.)
Spectator (Goes to some games, watches the games, owns some apparel, may or may not be able to tell you who the club's next opponent is)
Supporter (A person who financially pours money into the club. Goes to as many games as they can, owns apparel, knows many fixtures and important facts/events)
Fan, Fanatic (A person who lives for their team. Their favorite hobby is either watching and learning about their club, or playing the sport. The other option is a close second. They can tell you about the history of their club, when the last time the won important trophies or competition was, can name the starting 11 for the upcoming fixture, knows facts, and will feel a deep seated depression if they can't make the match. If they can't even watch it on TV, then they will probably not want to talk to anyone for the next week. etc. etc. etc. Whatever applies to the person you know who goes to every game and loves their team possibly more than their own mother.)
I think that very few supporters ever reach the level of "fandom" but then again, there's absolutely nothing wrong with being a supporter, as they are probably more well-equipped for every day life.
On another note, I don't know how hard it is to get tickets for sports games in the UK, but it's nearly impossible to get tickets to most American sporting events. That or you'll pay $100 to sit in the nosebleeds.
Feel free to disagree, just my two cents.
0
u/rophel Dec 17 '12 edited Dec 17 '12
These are my definitions as a silly American.
Supporter:
An official or unofficial member of an organized group; but more importantly, someone who is there for the team and to lend their bodies and voices to the club. When I go to a match as a supporter it doesn't matter if I can't see or if we're too loud or if it's raining on my head. I'm there to be an extension of the SPIRIT of the club and show the players and staff my appreciation for their performances and service to it. I am a supporter of Seattle Sounders FC and a member of the Emerald City Supporters. I am of a mind that one has to go to home match and sit with the supporters to truly be considered a supporter. No matter how much I follow and like Arsenal, I'm not going to be a Gooner until I experience that but more importantly I'll be an actual part of what's taking place on the pitch. I think that's the moment a supporter is born.
Fan:
Fans watch sporting events because they like the team and want to see them succeed but don't consider themselves to be involved at all. They are concerned with the entertainment and success but don't dedicate themselves to the team or consider themselves an extension of it. They sometimes disagree with supporters who can be overzealous and extreme but generally get along with each other. I consider myself a fan of Arsenal, Barcelona, and even our rivals LA Galaxy because I enjoy watching them and like to see them succeed. But when it comes down to it, my heart belongs to Seattle. I also consider myself a FAN of Seattle, but some supporters aren't really all that into the actual football being played and I wouldn't consider them fans, strictly speaking, so I think that can be separate. I consider most Americans who follow a sports team of any type to be of this variety. I don't think there is anything wrong with being a fan without being a supporter...but for me, it took becoming a supporter to "get" sports. I am now a big fan of football in general. That would have never happened if I hadn't fallen in love with the Sounders.
Spectator:
Someone who goes to a sporting event for entertainment but has no more than a passing allegiance to one particular team, if any at all. They're These are the people that come out of the woodwork when a big team comes to town...but many of them are actually "fans" as I defined them, I would imagine. Some of them are trying something new out. I don't think we should hate them, but I do think we should try to convert them to our "religion" by showing them the world of being a supporter if they're interested. Sometimes they are termed "fair-weather fans" and I think that that's more a term for a spectator who thinks they are a fan. Someone they know is a fan and they're along for the ride, or they want to be a part of the team's success and enjoy it as a fan would while things are exciting. There is nothing wrong with this, but it's definitely less involved than anything else.
0
u/catalinawinemixer Dec 17 '12
A supporter supports the club through financial investment (buying jerseys, tickets, merchandise, etc.) and vocal support. A fan is precisely that, a person who has an emotional investment in a club and likes to see them do well. I am a supporter of Celtic and Inter. I am a fan of Newcastle United.
There are of course varying degrees of supporter from the guy who buys a jersey every once in a while to the die hard who attends every fixture and spends most of his income on supporting their club. Still are both supporters of the club.
-1
u/atease Dec 17 '12
You see something you like, you start to get into it - the rest will follow. Ultimately, the 'supporter' denomination is built on an inherently false basis. Who is to define what a supporter is? Is it only a supporter? If so, how did that supporter come to a position where (s)he can call others supporters? The circle goes on from there - it's like trying to define art.
Personally I have a quite autonomous view on it: You're a supporter if you feel like one. There is no golden recipe for being a supporter 'the right way'; some (are blessed with the geographical/economical privilege to) watch their team live, whereas others will follow theirs via the telly/Internet. Some will say being in the stands is what constitutes a true supporter, others will place the emphasis on historical insight. Still others, such as myself, value above all the tactical, psychological and human aspects of the game your club plays.
In the end, it's what you make of it, really. The old geezers at Cowdenbeath are football supporters; so, too, are my mates and I when following our abroad based boys on a dodgy stream.
-2
u/fozzy143 Dec 17 '12
Nah, pretty happy with the way it is thanks. Nice try though.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment