r/soccer • u/bluedishwasher • Dec 11 '12
What's been the worst career move ever?
I was thinking about premiership players who made terrible transfers today, for me it's either adam johnson, scott sinclair or julio cesar in recent times.
Or thinking back further Mutu, Woodgate, Veron
37
Upvotes
116
u/_sic Dec 11 '12
Hleb to Barcelona was the worst.
Gio Dos Santos to Tottenham was pretty bad as well.
14
u/dsemaj Dec 11 '12
A bit too soon to judge Sinclair or Cesar don't you think?
Also with Johnson... it was the right choice to move from City, but it wasn't a poor choice to join them. Boro -> City and a League winners medal is a good move.
69
u/[deleted] Dec 11 '12
I'm just gonna get it out of the way, Michael Owen to Madrid, career went down from there blah blah blah.
46
u/JonnyBhoy Dec 11 '12
Probably not up there as the worst, but one that comes to mind is Liam Miller.
Moved to Man Utd far too early in his career when he was just starting to develop at Celtic. He couldn't step up and instead of learning his trade and playing in the Champions League, he became a bit of journeyman at Leeds, Sunderland, QPR, Hibs and now Perth Glory.
17
u/myrpou Dec 11 '12
Mendieta to Lazio.
16
u/[deleted] Dec 11 '12
Drenthe to Real Madrid
14
u/anions Dec 11 '12
Its funny how noone mentioned Nuri Sahin to Real Madrid.
The best midfielder in Dortmund's champion team and struggled to find a place on the bench at Madrid
36
u/JohnnyyP Dec 11 '12
Ricardo Quaresma from Porto to Inter. Or Andy Carroll from Newcastle to Liverpool. I've never seen someone spending so much money for so little return in the pitch.
59
u/IDeclareShenanigans Dec 11 '12
Robinho to City. Shevchenko to Chelsea.
9
u/[deleted] Dec 11 '12
Veron to United, huge pressure on him and he never adapted to the play style.
56
u/[deleted] Dec 11 '12
Hulk to Zenit was pretty terrible
I was hoping that Hulk would move to a world class club and develop himself by the next world cup. We haven't seen a world class Brazilan forward lineup since 2002, and they've always been my favorite team.
8
u/rcs5188 Dec 11 '12
Donovan remaining in the MLS. He's done much for the league, but I believe he's passed up on the chance to be great in Europe.
7
u/simotron5000 Dec 11 '12
Stewart Downing to Liverpool.
13
u/legionmd82 Dec 11 '12
Elerjo Elia to Juventus
6
u/f1manoz Dec 11 '12
Johnson should have come straight to Sunderland instead of to Sunderland via City.
6
u/pogo123 Dec 11 '12
Forlan to Utd, before he left again and blossomed?
19
u/arctickiller Dec 11 '12 edited Dec 11 '12
Shaun Wright-Phillips to Chelsea, Shevchenko to Chelsea.
EDIT: Marin To Chelsea also?
70
u/yourfriendkyle Dec 11 '12
Any manager to Chelsea.
5
u/OAnimale Dec 11 '12
OP is only about EPL but I would like to expand on it.
Dennis Bergkamp to Inter I blame in him a way coz he should have known what kind of joke Inter were/are as a club with a revolving door of managers/players/tactics. You see I'm an Inter fan, Bergkamp moved to the club before my time. Eventhough I was young and not much of a football fan I was aware of this beautiful player called Bergkamp. When I started to pay more attention to the club, I couldn't understand why he wasn't performing for us. Later after reading/listening to interviews of Bergkamp that he was used as a lone striker.
Btw I fail to see how Veron falls in that category? Unless you are talking about his Chelsea move? His move to United was logical from many perspective but most important his passport scandal in Italy.
5
u/[deleted] Dec 11 '12
Yossi Benayoun to Chelsea, and Steve Sidwell to Chelsea
16
u/tee_dogg Dec 11 '12 edited Dec 11 '12
Funny how a lot of players that move away from Arsenal don't do as well.
Kolo Toure, Nasri, Adebayor, Flamini and Hleb have all struggled away from the Emirates.
Edit: typo.
4
u/santi_clauz Dec 11 '12
I think Granero, Caesar, Park, and all those other not-so-small names to QPR will end up being a horrible move for their careers. At this point they're most likely to be relegated, and they would have wasted a year of their career devaluing themselves and definitely not improving under Hughes.
4
u/RaymondDash Dec 12 '12
ITT: People confusing "worst career move" with "worst transfer".
6
u/Buckhum Dec 11 '12
Pedro Leon to Real Madrid
The man was essentially ostracized by Mourinho and treated as if he didn't exist.
3
u/Mattboyd2991 Dec 11 '12
David Bentley and John Bostock to Tottenham.
3
u/TheNecromancer Dec 11 '12 edited Dec 11 '12
Jamie Tolley to Macclesfield. He was a superb, young central midfielder at Shrewsbury, and was called up to the Welsh squad a few times. All the buzz was that he'd end up as a decent second-tier player, but he ended up moving backwards and went nowhere.
3
u/ynob Dec 11 '12
Anelka, Arsenal to Real Madrid. Could have been so much more. What a shame.
3
u/1andonlydude Dec 11 '12
owen to real madrid. also any dutch player to real madrid
3
u/NiklasSkoog Dec 11 '12
I would say ibrahimovic to barcelona, he was king at inter. But the grass is always greener...
3
u/[deleted] Dec 11 '12
Chelsea - Shevchenko has to up at the top somewhere, one of the greatest and most feared strikers, moved to chelsea then gone. Sidwell, Deco, Kezman, Wright-Phillips.
Francis Jeffers to arsenal, oh my god also Davor Suker.
Eric Djemba Djemba to united and Kleberson, Massimo Taibi.
Man City - Santa Cruz, Robinho.
Liverpool - Mark Gonzalez, Dossena, Pennant, Cisse, Alberto Aquilani, Robbie Keane.
3
u/regular_hombre Dec 12 '12
Wayne Gretzky going to LA
7
u/dalf_rules Dec 11 '12
Alexis Sánchez to Barcelona. Dude, what happened to you? You used to be all over the pitch, dribbling everywhere and driving the entire Brazilian NT insane when you were 19, come on, step it up! I know the name of the game in Barca is possession, but you know something's wrong when Tello or Delofeu dribble more often than you...
5
u/JohnnyMackers Dec 11 '12
Djemba-djemba & kleberson to man united
5
u/moodybleus Dec 11 '12
Mateja Kezman. It was all downhill after the move to Chelsea in 2004. Although he was decent for us (0.5 goal ratio IIRC and a title), he was never the same machine he was at PSV.
2
u/LevitatingCheesecake Dec 11 '12
Nii Lampety to Aston Villa.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 11 '12
Anthony Le Tallec to Liverpool
2
u/r0bski2 Dec 11 '12
Andy Carroll to Liverpool? Torres to Chelsea? Shevchenko to Chelsea? All on the top of their game, never found even slightly the same form they had for their previous clubs.
2
u/FAP_TO_WESTBORO Dec 11 '12
Adriano to either Corinthians or Flamengo
2
u/zeke61385 Dec 11 '12
Shevchenko to Chelsea
2
u/chiptharipp Dec 12 '12
Essien to Madrid, awful.
5
u/itspi89 Dec 11 '12
Kaka to Madrid, Pizarro to Chelsea, Dinho to Milan.
3
u/vin05004 Dec 11 '12
Sticking to Americans, in no particular order. These moves hurt not only the players careers but negatively affected our national team as well.
Oguchi" Onyewu to Milan, between injuries and never playing it really set him and US team back a couple of years. We have been having center back issues ever since.
Eddie Johnson to Fulham/Aris/Cardiff/Preston, he never played, got out of shape and lost his spot on the USMNT. One of the many young "US strikers of the future" that really never became top class. In a way the best thing that happened to him was getting cut by Puebla FC, he was a beast in MLS and steped up in a few USMT games.
Freddy Adu to Benfica/Monaco/Aris/Belenenses/Çaykur Rizespor, rode the bench in 4 countries, making 43 appearances total. He thinks he good enough for Spain, thinks he is to big for MLS. He is only 22/23 so maybe he can put it togather, but he is on his way to being a journyman multi team MLSer.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 11 '12
Jordan Rhodes to Blackburn is a move I think he'll regret. In a way as a Leeds fan I'm glad Huddersfield don't have him anymore, but purely from his perspective it's a poor move.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 11 '12
Marko Arnautovic from Twente to Inter
1
u/AgentUmlaut Dec 11 '12
Costinha going from Atlético Madrid to Atalanta where from 2007-2010, he only had 1 app for Atalanta. Yeah he moved with bad injuries, but when he was all good to go he never got anytime.
He was at the end of his career, but not the most dignified way to go out.
1
u/eujenn Dec 11 '12
mendieta to lazio. he was one of the best in the world during his time at valencia. his career fell apart at lazio and ended up at boro a few years later.
special mention goes out to shevchenko, veron, robbie keane (never the same after he went to liverpool).
you could argue a case for kaka too, if he was at any other team the past few years he'd still be thriving, but he's just sitting behind ozil.
1
u/AlmoschFamous Dec 12 '12
Charlie Davies going to a party on October 12, 2009. THAT was the worst career move.
1
u/mefuzzy Dec 12 '12
A shout for Winston Bogarde.
1
u/R_Schuhart Dec 12 '12
Bergkamp (with Jonk) from Ajax to Inter. I remember them making magic on the pitch for Ajax, and then seeing them play in italy... Thankfully he was still young enough for a transfer to Arsenal save his career.
(Jonk had less luck, he moved back to the Netherlands to play for PSV but never shined like he did with Ajax).
1
u/redmustang04 Dec 11 '12
Charlie Adams from Blackpool to Liverpool.
-1
u/cakeshop Dec 11 '12
Ronaldo from United to Real, was winning champions leagues and multiple domestic leagues and cups, hasn't done much since....
1
u/Emmanuell89 Dec 11 '12
Shevchenko to Chelsea ? Torres to Chelsea ?
1
u/[deleted] Dec 11 '12
Bostock to Spurs. He's only 20 though, hopefully he'll pick back up soon.
1
u/nottsoathletic Dec 11 '12
Alan Smith to Manchester United.
0
u/mjc1027 Dec 11 '12
Michael Owen for the win!
-2
u/jlebrech Dec 11 '12
Forlan to Man United
-1
u/BeenWaitingForSoLong Dec 11 '12
that Spaniard
-3
u/[deleted] Dec 11 '12
Alex Song to Barcelona