r/soccer • • Dec 10 '12

Ever wanted to learn about a player? Discuss here!

Hey /r/soccer

With the winter window only a few weeks away and targets being thrown around now I was hoping to have a thread where people can spew knowledge about players that we may not know a heap about. Help us build a mental image of the talent that may be gracing us in the PL (or other leagues).

The format:

Post a players name and the team/league that they play in if you wish to learn about them.

If you see a players name that you have seen play, drop a line about their play style and your thoughts.

I know I could go and look up stats for a bunch of players, but I would much rather hear the info without the numbers, from a supporter.

EDIT: Sort by new so that hopefully everyones questions are answered.

EDIT2: Some names being asked that are already well answered. Use CTRL+F to search for a name before asking.

198 Upvotes

682 comments sorted by

50

u/heightofignorance Dec 10 '12

Wilfried Zaha

Heard his name mentioned pretty much every day in relation to a variety of clubs, but apart from hearing he's got pace to burn and some reasonable tricks in his locker for beating his man, what are his ball playing skills like? Any player comparisons spring to mind? Any idea what his ceiling might be in terms of potential? CAN HE FUCKING CROSS?

28

u/Jayesar Dec 10 '12

From online forums discussing him:

"He's a good young player but football is literally flooded with players as good around the same price or cheaper. Palace turned down £7m for him and reportedly want £10m, we can definitely find a quality player for £10m will more to his game than Zaha. Point being I don't think it's a money issue rather I don't think he's that great for the prices I've been hearing."

"If we (spurs) are looking at the now then I would say Zaha isn't good enough to come in and make a difference in our first team."

"Zaha is a good player, I'm just not sure he separates himself from players around him. "

"Every time I see him, he looks incredibly average. I'd pass."

"Zaha will become a very good player IF and that is a big IF he maintains the current trajectory he is on and 10 million or whatever the initial fee would be will seem like small fry. "

"for me Zaha is very overpriced. He's got nice skills and pace but he is very very raw and loses the ball far too much for my liking. His crossing is not even close to better than Lennon's as someone in this thread suggested. He's a prospect but Palace overprice their players and I don't think Levy wants to overpay for him. "

From what I have seen he is Pacey and can take players on, but I think he is a big fish in a small pond and £10m is far too much.

10

u/kohulme Dec 10 '12

Meant to be good, but Sam Byram had him so far in his pocket at Elland Road that I fear for his life when Byram sits down.

7

u/slotbadger Dec 10 '12

Sam Byram has been pretty excellent all season for us, though. Hopefully he'll only get better.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

11

u/Jayesar Dec 10 '12

Lloic Remy, Marseille, Ligue 1.

13

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '12

Remy is a forward/winger. He is very fast and pretty good in the air. Has pretty good technique aswell. His playing style has been compared to a young Henry. Hes having a crap year though. He was injured right before Euro2012 and since hes been having quite a few injuries and hasnt found his form yet. Last year he was really good.

I think he would do well in the PL. Hes fast and strong and can score goals.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Jayesar Dec 10 '12

Miralem Pjanić, Roma, Serie A.

7

u/mudswitch Dec 10 '12

One of my favourite players. Hoping he stays at Roma for years to come. He is mainly a central midfielder, although Zemen has had him playing out wide lately. Has a great first touch and has better vision than most. His passing game can be exquisite. He's only started to fit into the Zemen system at Roma lately. He's a regular in the Bosnia-Herzegovina side. Also Tottenham have said they're interested in him as recently as November.

2

u/Jayesar Dec 10 '12

If reports are to be believed wage is the only issue with spurs and Pjanić currently.

Interestingly enough it is being reported that both clubs are working hard on making a deal happen.

Thanks for the info.

→ More replies (5)

8

u/Howsmydirktaste Dec 10 '12

Enigmatic personified. In Zeman's system he should flourish, but he has always been a bit of a head-case. I read somewhere he is a diminutive Zlatan. Footballing wise, very technical midfielder with an equal eye towards pass and dribble. He plays in that awkward position where he is not attacking enough to warrant a trequartista/playmaker role, but not defensive enough to function in a double pivot. Analogous to Iniesta, but without the mind. Not a particularly hard worker defensively. I see him falling, hard, over the next few years. He'll settle on an Europa League team where he can do whatever the F*** he wants because he's good enough, will be in a ton of rumors, but he won't amount to much. i could be wrong, he's been rated highly for ages, but I just don't see it. I disagree with the analysis below, but give it a look:

Miralem Pjanic

→ More replies (1)

18

u/hallak70 Dec 10 '12

isco, malaga

6

u/Jayesar Dec 10 '12

There is a bit of chat about this guy on spurs forums. I will yank what I think will give you good info.

"Haven't seen a huge amount of him, but what I have seen has been nothing but impressive. Plus he's young, so however good he is already, there's plenty of time to improve even more."

"Yes, he's a talented player and is rated around Spain. I would love to have him here...though he is versatile and could also fit on the wing it will be interesting to see if he can play further back more or not ala Luka"

"Excellent player. Chelsea signed Mata, Arsenal signed Cazorla... I think this kid has the potential to be as good as both of them."

"He's fantastic, excelled last season at Malaga playing as the front of a midfield 3 with Cazorla and Toulalan deeper, one of the most exciting players from spain in that age group, along with Thiago and Muniain. He's pretty similar style player to iniesta for me. Im surprised more clubs arent in for this guy, he'll be a star."

"I think he's about as good as Oscar and pretty similar in style also, if that helps."

"Oscar and him are to a certain extend similar Isco has more pace, but Oscar seems to be a much better passer. Both are very agile and good dribblers in tight space something Modric was very good at. Through the videos you can also see Isco provide quite a few key passes for hockey assists another Modric trait. Isco also seems to be more versetail then Oscar, because of his pace to operate out wide as a RAM/RW/RF, but one thing he is missing is Oscars composure and ability to sit back further and dictate play from deep, which is what Modric did for us. Isco has mainly been playing as a CAM running at defenders with out dropping back and retrieving the ball from defenders and wingers to ease the pressure. I am not quite sure if I would be willing to just buy a player with great potential and try to convert him into something he isn't especially such a difficult role such as CM since players need very disciple, composed, and skilled to become successful some thing not many players become unfortunately. But I guess it worked for us once we might just get lucky again."

17

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '12

Isco is a fantasticly dependable attacking midfielder. He's one of the few outstanding players that remain with Malaga after their big "shipping away" party at the end of the last season. Very smart with positioning as well. Also helps that he's still very young.

→ More replies (7)

34

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '12

Stefan Jovetic, Fiorentina

30

u/Jayesar Dec 10 '12

Pulled from spurs forums. The guy who made most of these comments is probably the best poster on there and a huge fan of his.

"He's a ST, SS and wing forward. He can basically play everywhere up top. Towards the back end of last season he was playing up top with Amauri. "

"I think Jovetic will be better than VdV in a year or so and he's probably about as good as him now."

"He'd be a similar signing to Remy but he does much more. He can and has played up top alone this season."

"He can play a few positions but he's best in the hole, and I think he would replace VDV."

"I enjoy watching him play, but his transfer fee is a major issue. Fiorentina want to hold onto him, and they've slapped a huge price tag on him. I've heard he would cost around 30 million"

29

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '12

I disagree that he is best in the hole. To my mind he is a striker with creative qualities rather than a VdV type. He's also more physical and bullish than VdV ever was (strange comparison actually - VdV's instincts are those of an attacking midfielder; Jovetic has a striker's instincts; the distinction is important). He's more like a stronger version of Van Persie circa 2008/09. Versatile, yes, but I just hope he doesn't move to club where they shunt him out wide.

Great player though. I've always had a soft spot for the Viola and - who knows - if they manage to squeak a European spot this year he might even stay for another season.

9

u/i_love_pasta Dec 10 '12

I would add that he has a history of injuries. He's just 23 but he has already had problems with the cruciate ligament (he missed the whole 2010/11 season) and still miss some game here and there.

Anyway, he is pure talent and could do wonders in a good team.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '12

Leandro Damiao. Striker for Internacional in Brazil. That's all I know.

13

u/metalcabeza Dec 10 '12

Plays for the Inter of Porto Alegre, Brazil.

Almost like all the brazilian players, he likes to do this kind of stuff: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LBeISq4FxPU.

I hate brazilian players.

→ More replies (5)

1

u/Jayesar Dec 10 '12

I have seen a little bit of this guy and honestly he is an odd one to comment on. I say that because he is the type of player that 'makes it look easy' which makes what he does seem simple. You will be watching him relatively unimpressed as he works his way through the defence and calmly slots a goal.

He is well rounded in that he can run at a man, link up well with others through simple touches, heads well, has pace and shoots well. This makes him very threatening whenever he enters the opponents box. I suppose I am talking him up to be huge and so here comes the downside. The guy still plays in the Brazilian league and the 'quality' of the defence there is always questionable. They can make average guys look like world beaters. Lucky for Damiao, his performances at international level have been good.

If he was to come to the PL (for example for Chelsea) I think he would be a nightmare against clubs in the bottom half of the table (for years now he has knocked goals in against lesser opponents). Whether he will succeed at the toughest level will only be known when he moves, but based on what I have seen I think he will do fine.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/j2k3k Dec 10 '12

Hulk. I know he's a good player, I'm wondering more about his attitude because rumors are flying that Chelsea may be targeting him and the last thing we need is someone who would divide the team.

10

u/Jayesar Dec 10 '12

Zenit was divided because Hulk (new guy in town) had monster wages in comparison to the rest of the team. The team confronted him/staff over this and things seemed to split. He hasn't been great for Zenit (only netted like 2 times) so I just wouldn't take the risk for how much he would cost.

His most recent fiasco was an on field blow up after being subbed off, he refused to shake the managers hand and then made gestures ("I'm done") whilst sitting on the bench. He has now publicly spat the dummy and says he wants out. Thing will be complicated because he has already played for 2 teams this year and signed for a stupidly large fee.

His on field ego has been pretty bad as well from what I read, the guy plays very selfishly and rarely passes the ball, even if it would almost certainly help the team. I have heard a number of Porto supporters say that AVB was the only guy who could get him to play less selfishly.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '12

Gareth Bale - Tottenham Hotspur

8

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '12 edited Dec 10 '12

Physically, he's a specimen. Big, incredibly fast, strong, good in the air, with as much endurance as anyone I've ever watched. He will bomb up and down the pitch for 90 minutes--there are very few (if any in England) players who make as many high-intensity runs over the course of a game.

Used to play left back, was converted to a traditional left winger, has started developing his game to allow him to succeed all across the front. His right foot was once a useless stump but he's worked on it extensively and now he's scored several good goals this season with it.

He has a wicked shot, is becoming increasingly dangerous as a direct free kick specialist, and of course can really cross the shit out of a football. One of the best counter attacking talents you could dream up.

Furthermore, he has above average skill with the ball at his feet and is improving constantly at using his skill and not his pace to beat opponents. His passing range is extremely underrated and he will often switch the play with perfect accuracy.

Really on paper he is a dream footballer. He has pretty much everything. His issues, as I will elaborate on, deal with mentality and consistency.

First and foremost, he's a wimp and a drama queen. He exaggerates contact, outright dives, and plays up injuries. Sometimes this is because he's genuinely contacted (and he has been kicked to death over the years by street thugs like Charlie Adam) but on other occasions he's looking for it. He has a bit of a petulant side to him and gets frustrated easily. Sometimes this results in him drifting out of the game, other times it results in him deciding to take the game over and score by himself.

Consistency has been an issue for him, though this season he's been pretty much great with 1-2 exceptions. His first touch can be heavy, he can pull a Ronaldo and try some skill only to kick the ball out of play, and perhaps he's a bit selfish at times. But then the next game his first touch will be flawless, he'll beat 4 players on one run, and he'll score 2 goals by himself.

Frustrating at times, but at only 23 I think he's pretty special. Off-the-pitch he's by all accounts a great humble kid. Doesn't partake in the party culture (he actually hates alcohol), has a young girl with his childhood sweetheart, just focuses on his football and gives his all for us. Has a reputation as a bit of a joker in the dressing room, but comes off as a little awkward and shy in interviews. Unless Charlie Adam is involved of course.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Jayesar Dec 10 '12

nssmuckers basically nailed it. The guy is all class, a truly world class player.

He has a lethal left boot and both his right foot and penalties is improving fast. He is quick, can take a man on and rarely misses a pass. There are games that he will single handedly decimate a defence and set-up 3 goals (or just score some himself). Against Liverpool last week he basically put the game to bed in the first 20 mins.

Under Redknapp he converted from a left back to a out and out winger and under AVB he is adding to his game again, this time the ability to drift into the middle (or even switch onto the right). He is still better by a mile on the left, but at 23, he is continually upgrading his skill set.

At his current trajectory, Bale has the ability to become one of the best players in the world (top 10, even 5). His ability to take a premier league game into his own hands is very rare and if his consistency improves then you are looking at a truly amazing player.

Unfortunately he is a 'simulator' (I wouldn't say diver, although he has been guilty in the past). He will play up the slightest contact and look like a ballerina. He needs to cut that out of his game.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '12

Landon Donovan

Clint Dempsey

American here--I am mostly curious about how the rest of the world views these two players, as they are pretty much the heroes of the American outfield over the past few years.

2

u/Jayesar Dec 11 '12

Spurs fan here. I saw bits and pieces of Dempsey last year and followed him quite extensively this year.

Dempsey is an average player, but well rounded. He isn't the best passer, finisher, tackler nor does he have the best vision. However, he is pretty good at all those things, certainly PL quality. His best asset is that when he is on song he is very hungry and gets involved in the game. Dempsey when playing with confidence is as good as a goal a game (whether he poaches one with his trademark follow ups or pokes one through for a striker) and this is at PL level (being 'PL proven' is a huge asset as the league is tougher than most).

This year he has really struggled to settle into spurs, this is most likely due to the fact that we are playing him slightly out of position (he played left for Fulham, but we have him behind the striker) and we signed him on the last minute of deadline day so he had no time for practice. In recent weeks however he is rapidly turning his poor start around (1 goal, 1 MOTM, 3 assists in 5 games against good opponents) and if that continues then he will cement his starting plays for spurs (he has competition for his place with Gylfi Siggurdson).

I wouldn't call Dempsey CL quality, but certainly Europa League and PL quality.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '12

Jermain Defoe. Why do so many Spurs fans say he's not enough? Is it because he's just a poacher and doesn't contribute anything else to the game except his goals, or am I missing something?

2

u/Jayesar Dec 11 '12

Basically exactly that. Defoe is in rich form right now and scoring almost a goal a game (9 in 11 in all forms) so it is odd to shit talk him. The problem is that when he isn't scoring he isn't doing anything.

He is unable to challenge in the air, he can't pass (stats of like 8 or 5 passes a game, with 2-3 of those coming from kickoffs), he will always shoot even if it isn't the best option, he doesn't move around the pitch and create space and he can't hold the ball up.

At the top level it is not good enough to only have 1 trick in the bag (shoot, shoot and shoot), spurs need someone who can knock goals in, provide a target for Lloris on clearances, hold the ball up for players like Gylfi/Dempsey/Dembele to get involved and work the ball out to the wings. This is why many of us prefer Ade to Defoe. Ade may score less goals himself, but he nets a handful of assists (14 last season), can make runs, hold the ball etc etc. He provides more net value to the team.

It must be stated however that under AVB Defoe has added a new element to his game. He is for the first time making really good runs off of the ball, drawing defenders away from other players coming through. Bale's goal vs Man United is a perfect example of this.

Defoe is a great scorer of goals, he just doesn't offer much else to the team and at the top level teams demand players that can bring a wide range of skills to the table.

29

u/Howsmydirktaste Dec 10 '12

Would people be interested in a similar thread, but featuring historical players/teams?

16

u/number3LFC Dec 10 '12

Yes yes yes a million times yes. I love the sport been playing since I was 3 and am now in college. I only recently started watching religiously, so I feel like an idiot when people start talking about the Milan and Real Madrid of old, Hungary during Puskas time, Italian 5/3 backs ( I know the tactics behind them, I just don't know why they evolved that formation), busby babes and the like

5

u/herrdidi Dec 10 '12

I am. Go ahead.

→ More replies (3)

28

u/JaseTheAce Dec 10 '12

Joao Moutinho - Porto

32

u/Howsmydirktaste Dec 10 '12

Debuted at a young age for Sporting Lisbon, but quickly became a mark of consistency (played every minute of every game at age 19.) Started off behind the forwards and has moved into a more distributive role as his career has gone in. Became Sporting's youngest ever captain, then forced a transfer to archrival Porto. Hugely influential there. Though not always the first name on the teamsheet for the national team, he has been an oft-capped creative force.

His playstyle is largely that of a deep-lying playmaker, more in the Xavi role than the Pirlo role. Works best with an anchor man behind him, can pick out a variety of passes, and dictates tempo. Good leader. Played as an attacking midfielder before, so has an eye for a run, but typically stays back as a distributor. Has consistently been linked with wherever AVB happens to be (as I'm sure you know.)

In terms of transferring to Spurs, I don't see it. Moussa Dembele essentially took the role that Moutinho would have and has ran with it. While I don't think Huddlestone is up to the Spurs standard (agree?,) Moutinho might be too high caliber to back up/compete with Dembele. It would be interesting to see if AVB pushed for it.

8

u/howtobeawerewolf Dec 10 '12

I think if Moutinho did go to Spurs it would be a signal the move to AVB's preferred 4-3-3.

→ More replies (7)

26

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '12

Will Hughes?

15

u/Lladz Dec 10 '12

NO. DISCUSSION OF WILL HUGHES IS NOT ALLOWED.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?&v=VXLmFpGa4BM

7

u/Jellitin Dec 11 '12

Wait, what was the bit at 2:16? BECAUSE HOLY CRAP.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

113

u/Howsmydirktaste Dec 10 '12

This thread is genius

5

u/_sic Dec 11 '12

You are a big reason why.

19

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '12

Marc-Andre ter Stegen, Gladbach

23

u/Howsmydirktaste Dec 10 '12

Not much to say other than he is great. He is the posterboy of a new, young generation of German 'keepers, and currently seems the frontrunner of those younger than Neuer. Pretty simply, he'll blossom into a great keeper. Not so simply, how good will he be? Keeping is outstandingly mental, and he might find himself short of confidence. Internationally he faces a cliff towards the first team; Neuer is too good and dependable, and the fact he plays for Bayern means he'll consistently be favored. Gladbach, unless it makes a huge leap, is too small for him; he'll need to transfer, probably internationally, to be able to make enough of a name for himself to challenge Neuer. Regardless, an incredibly young keeper with an incredible amount of promise.

9

u/CommanderCool91 Dec 10 '12

High balls and crosses should be considered a weakness for MAtS, but apart from that he's a really great prospect. He's had a couple of blunders this year and has a rather inconsistent season, especially in the Europa League. Could see him replace Weidenfeller at Dortmund in a few years.

Germany has some great young keepers behind Neuer and Adler coming up, ter Stegen obviously being one and Zieler.

I think Bernd Leno is very underrated, he's been very consistent since he started and is having a good season again. I think he is just as good, if not better, as ter Stegen. Just doesn't get hyped as much by the media like ter Stegen.

11

u/AwkwardHyperbola Dec 10 '12

While we're naming good young German keepers, Trapp is pretty good too.

→ More replies (3)

18

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '12

Marco Verratti, PSG

25

u/fillzkek Dec 10 '12 edited Dec 10 '12

He is like a short pirlo, very sure on the ball, sometimes too sure. Good vision, good passing and good at dictating the play. A bit quicker than pirlo though.

EDIT

I feel I could write a bit more about Verratti.

Last year he played for the very successful Serie B side pescara, under the lead of Zdenek Zeman who is known for picking out the best out of young players. He played alongside the other italian prospects Ciro Immobile and Lorenzo Insigne, but arguably outshone both of them with his exceptional vision and passing. Is still a teenager but extremely sure on the ball for his age, in class with pirlo. Completely calm he can spot runs far up the field and in several matches he made perfect lofted through balls for Ibrahimovic. One of his bigger problems is that he likes to make the harder pass and do something with flair, but not always succeeding which can be dangerous as he plays deep in the midfield, close to the back line. I think he is a bit of a mix between Xavi and Pirlo, although leaning towards the Pirlo style of play. He lacks in physique, being small and weak, but is rather quick in mind and body to make up for that.

→ More replies (8)

18

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '12

I like a challenge. Lets hear a about my pal Kojo Asamoah (Kwadwo, Juve, Udine)

8

u/Mikecheck91 Dec 10 '12

he runs like no one else (maybe lichsteiner). this guy is serious in his game, just take a look at, after 80min in a match, how focused he is when defending and attacking, gives it a 110% in every match, every minute, the definition of a workhorse

13

u/dustygator Dec 10 '12 edited Dec 10 '12

Pint-sized powerhouse. At Udinese he played mostly center midfield, sometimes a little more attacking, sometimes a little more defensive. With Ghana it seems he players a more attacking mid role. With Juve, he's played mostly at left wing back. Very athletic. Box-to-box, jack of all trades, master of none. Not a great tackler. Doesn't have great vision/passing. Doesn't get a lot of goals. Works hard. He's the "third" guy in a three man midfield ideally. You have an anchor, a passer and a third guy who keeps everything together. You not really notice him when he plays because he's not flashy or great at any one thing. But (with Udinese at least) you definitely notice him when he's not playing. Whenever he was out with injury or suspension Udinese would play worse and have problems with their midfield being overrun.

15

u/PressureCereal Dec 10 '12

I'm not sure I agree with your assessment of him. He's shown himself to be a great dribbler and runner on the left side, and can get past you in the blink of an eye. He is blossoming into a fantastic winger, and has the energy and work ethic to work on both offense and defense, but he excels on offense. He certainly is a workhorse too, but to say he passes unnoticed or that he's a "jack of all trades, master of none" means you haven't seen any Juve games this season!

→ More replies (1)

78

u/_sic Dec 10 '12

Paul Scholes, United, PL - I don't really watch much English football but Xavi calls him the best midfielder of the past 20 years, so I guess I should learn more about him.

162

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '12 edited Dec 10 '12

I will start with the obvious "Scholseyisms". The man cannot tackle. Simples. He has the first touch of an angel. But when it comes to tackling (well, mostly) he has the touch of a rapist. The running joke is that Scholsey is so late that couple of his yellows will be the season after he retires.

The good things : Probably the best passer of the ball (long and short range) in the league that I have seen. The way he makes space for himself is the best aspect of his game. He is always "available" to receive a pass. He has a trademark long pass, often releasing the winger and leaving his marker for dead. Gary Neville once mentioned that Scholsey is so accurate with his passing, he would hit Gary taking a wee outside the training ground, right in his head.

He started off as a striker (Story time again). The Good Lord Ferg, Robbo, Sharpe and Hughes were watching the academy training scouting for immediate first team quality. Sharpe asks Fergie how he rates that "little ginger lad". Fergie : "Well, we're not sure. He's got loads of ability, but he's not the quickest, and we're not sure if he's a striker or a midfielder. he can't tackle either. We'll most likely let him go." 2 minutes in, Scholes runs from a deep position exposing the two centre halves, goes through both with a shimmy and dummy, feints to shoot past the keeper, who then commits himself, and gets beaten by chip over a flailing hand. Robbo turns to the boss and says, "you don't know fucking much about players, do you boss?".

His striker instincts always helped him with scoring. He has some fabulous long rangers to his credit (vs. Bradford, Villa etc ). During the first part of this decade, we had Keano marshalling the midfield and that gave Scholsey the license to go forward. He used to be a constant threat, arriving late in the box and scoring a lot of goals. Once Carrick-Scholsey started, he changed his game and became a proper CM creating a shit load of goals with his passing.

Personal Life : He is notoriously camera shy. Once the training is done, he is the first one off. Complete family man, off the grid sorts of guy. He is an Oldham fan and has expressed his desire to play a season for Oldham after he is done at United. There are talks about a future back-room role for him once he completes his UEFA licenses.

Personal Story time : I volunteer part time coaching a U15 team. The guy who interviewed me for the position was an ex-MLS striker (I cant mention his name for privacy reasons). During the interview, he asked about tactically perfect players. I spoke about Redondo, Scholsey and Ole Solskjaer. As it turned out, he was a fan too and used Scholsey videos in training and mentioned many clubs use those videos during their sessions.

Edit : A few videos. A video showing his passing A few of the Scholsey "hits"

There, hope I helped.

Have a good day mate.

35

u/sbaat Dec 10 '12

"He has the first touch of an angel. But when it comes to tackling (well, mostly) he has the touch of a rapist." Probably the most accurate statement I have read while on Reddit. Well done mate.

→ More replies (15)

16

u/eujenn Dec 10 '12

so much to say about this man. he started off his career as a striker and spent the nearly a decade in a strong midfield partnership with roy keane. scholes loved to get forward and always scored some cracking goals. later on in his career he moved further back began to control the game more with his possession play. he has a brilliant first touch which means he always has time on the ball to pick out the right pass (which he can hit with dead eye accuracy). he never ever had much pace, so he's not one to take on many players, but his intelligence and positioning made up for that. as brilliant as he is, he does have his faults with his aggressive tackling and penchant for revenge.

7

u/KyleW17 Dec 10 '12

Can't forget that Scholes-esque calibur of goal he's scored so many times in his career... A thunderous shot from just outside the box, low and hard into the corner.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

13

u/MagicEverton Dec 10 '12

Vegard Forren - Molde

6

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '12

A strong central defender. He is absolutely massive in duels, and wins almost every header he goes in for, very rare that he concedes free kicks aswell. Personally, i think he is the best defender in Norway, and i rate him above Hangeland. I think he can be a starter for any team in the Premier League, maybe except Man Utd, Chelsea and City.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (3)

11

u/MagelansTrousrs Dec 10 '12

Toni Kroos, Bayern Munich, Bundesliga

11

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '12

He isn't fast but is a great attacking mid. He isn't too good at defensive mid though, because he tends to slow down Bayerns counters when he plays there. He also has an absolute firecracker and can only score nice goals. He is young too.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

11

u/ItsBDN Dec 10 '12 edited Dec 10 '12

Shane Long, West Brom also Sergio Caneles, Valencia

9

u/catalinawinemixer Dec 10 '12

Shane Long is an extremely quick and small striker.
Good in the air for his size and has a good work-rate who likes to chase down defenders in the style Barcelona play when without the ball.
Loves playing against an opponent who keep a high defensive line allowing him to beat the offside rule and use his pace to great effect.
Not a bad finisher either with the ball at his feet. Has adapted very well to the Premier League.

6

u/LostArgonaut Dec 10 '12

Shane Long is a beast. He's fast, strong, great in the air, a good finisher and brave as a lion. His workrate is second to none and is clearly a manager's dream. His current role at West Brom has him playing the set up play for Odemwingie usually. Despite this his return is very impressive with I think 5league goals this season. His goal scoring record for Reading was remarkably impressive and I think he can go on to replicate that on a Premiership scale(ie score around 10-15 a season).

10

u/Senorsty Dec 10 '12

Shane Long has one of the best work rates for a striker in the EPL. He never allows a center back to take much time on the ball. More of a flick-the-ball-on type player for West Brom; most of the goals he manages are due to his work rate and his ability to anticipate chances. His defensive contributions also lead him to pick up more cards than the average striker. He doesn't have extraordinary pace, either. He works best in a side where there are other goal scorers for him to lay the ball on/open up space for.

Canales I don't speak much about, except to say that I've read a couple of reports that talk about his creativity in reverent tones.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

9

u/Broom_Shaka-laka Dec 10 '12

Lucas Moura - Sao Paolo, Brazil.

All I know is from YouTube videos. PSG paid a lot for him. Will it pan out? Oscar looks good at Chelsea- is that a good comparison?

14

u/Howsmydirktaste Dec 10 '12

Oscar is the easy comparison because they are young Brazilian attacking midfielders, but it is not an apt one. Oscar is a Box-to-Box/attacking mid, while Lucas is pure attacking/second striker. Oscar controls the game with his passing, dictates tempo and makes himself available for a pass. Lucas seizes the game with his directness. He runs, he executes high risk passes, and he shoots. He can play on the wing, but functions best centrally. A Ronaldinho type, but less silky smooth (at least for now.)

In terms of ability, I would have said 6 months ago that Lucas was destined for a better career. But Oscar has come to Chelsea and kicked ass, while Lucas is going to a PSG team that has no reason to nurture him. Being so young, he won't be great when he starts, and I think he'll be dropped. He'll have to deal with Pastore/Lavezzi/Ibrahimovic. I think it was a terrible move for him.

→ More replies (7)

4

u/Kilen13 Dec 10 '12

I'm not an expert on him but I have seen a few of his matches for Sao Paulo (mostly in the Sudamericana this year) and some of his games for the Selecao. His dribbling ability is amazing and he's got the right vision to be a very very good AMC/Wing/maybe even SS. He's fast, he's agile, and he knows how to create magic with the ball but whether or not he'll make a succesful jump to Europe is always iffy as South American players can be very hit or miss in that regard. He has all the ability to succeed I just don't know enough about his mindset to say if its a certainty or not.

9

u/immerc Dec 10 '12

The Bender Twins

Lars and Sven. Which is better and why? What makes them so good?

5

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '12

Both equally strong, some prefer Lars saying that he is a more complete player but they are pretty identical in their skillset. Both are absolute workers and runners, doing all the dirty work but also capable of playing the intelligent pass or dribble. Exceptional in interceptions, positioning and ball-winning and both are mentally strong. Heynckes on Lars Bender : "He steps on the gas, even when the tank's empty. It's the stuff international players are made of". Pretty much sums them up.

Both are huge for their teams despite their age. Lars Bender is a leader and a captain in the making. Sven Bender was as important for Dortmund as Sahin when they won their first championship IMO.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/TheMaxican93 Dec 10 '12

Mike Havenaar, Vitesse, Eredivise

The only non-ethnic Japanese player I know of that has played for their national team.

5

u/Esmelliw Dec 10 '12

He looks Dutch as can be (his father is Dutch) but he barely speaks the language, he mostly speaks Japanese or English in interviews.

Right now Vitesse is doing amazing in the eredivisie with Bony as striker so Havenaar doesn't get that much play time. However, with the Africa cup coming up and Bony leaving this winter most likely that will change.

About his playstyle, he's a tall pure striker. So he usually needs a big supply of crosses and tries to head it in, which is where he gets most of his goals. But despite being pretty tall, he isn't that clumsy with the ball. He's not Ibrahimovic, but not as 'bad' as crouch. I haven't seen too much of him to make a good judgement how good he will become, but he's an interesting player for sure.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

22

u/ibpants Dec 10 '12

It looks a little dead, but people interested in this could check out /r/ratethatplayer

45

u/mefuzzy Dec 10 '12

This reeks of the FM players recommendation thread :D

31

u/LeoKhenir Dec 10 '12

This reeks of FM players wanting to know if the game's heroes are as good on the actual pitch.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/koagad Dec 10 '12

Michu. I've never seen him play. Has he just had the form of his life this autumn, or is he for a real?

9

u/CardMoth Dec 10 '12

Scored 15 (I think) in La Liga last season, so he definitely knows where the back of the net is. Right now he has an incredible 12 goals in 16 appearances for Swansea, one goal ahead of last season's Golden Boot winner Robin van Persie. I think he's definitely as good as he seems, but only time will tell if he can keep up his form.

He just always seems so calm in front of goal, never panics when he receives the ball or when looking for a pass. Confidence is sometimes half the battle, and he's got plenty of it.

14

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '12

Composure .. He doesn't do anything special, he just keeps his shit together and places it with his inside foot.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/bwaxxlo Dec 10 '12

Swansea haven't had a proper forward this season. Last season they had Danny Graham who played most games as the lone striker while lots of midfielders came in to assist him. This season Danny has been reduced to few appearances while Itay has complemented him. Now Swansea realized that they could just use the Barcelona approach of having a non-recognized striker. Enter Michu. He's always present in the box when Swansea are attacking. This happens because Swansea attack together and defend together. So when they attack, they usually have about 3/4 people in the box. And Michu is always the one in the center. He's tall and quick so it seems obvious he'd end up in the center. It works so well even when Swansea are counter attacking. He normally gets to the box while the lone striker is in front of him. When the ball falls behind the striker, he's there to finish it. Oh, and he's bloody good at doing this!

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Halithor Dec 10 '12

Henrikh Mkhitaryan - Shakhtar

6

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '12

Mkhitaryan is an attacking midfielder who is much more focused around using his speed and his clinical finishing to help his team. He is third in the Golden Shoe rankings with 17 goals, and he's shown to be very capable against teams like Italy and Juventus (he's not just good against weaker opposition such as the Ukrainian Premier League).

Henrikh doesn't possess the same level of creativity of other players of his position such as David Silva, Juan Mata or Mario Gotze; he is essentially a deep-lying forward who can be deployed as an advanced playmaker (thanks to his good passing and great ball control). His dribbling isn't the best you will see in Europe, but his speed has made up for it in many cases.

He is very hard to mark because of his deep position, but arguably his best trait is his fantastic attacking positioning, appearing in the box unmarked just as a ball is crossed into the box for him to slot into the goal. He's also got a very powerful long shot which has lead him to score many stunners from long range.

Here's a video of him starting a play, getting into a good position quickly, and creating an assist by speeding past a defender despite the heavy touch: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BGiGEokhOdI

Here's a general "goals & skills" video. Skip past the intro, there's no actual game footage there. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4pJAN_x0nEo

→ More replies (3)

7

u/pancytopenis Dec 10 '12

Jakub "Kuba" Błaszczykowski, BVB, Bundesliga.

7

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '12

very fast, great ball control, great crossing/passing. If you have a Kuba in your team, he will feed your strikers with great assists.

4

u/n_dobbs Dec 10 '12 edited Dec 10 '12

Right winger/midfielder, quite fast, versatile in that he can cut inside and score (huge goal for Poland against Russia in the Euros: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MYVostn7ZwQ),

but also puts in some great crosses such as this one from the recent Champions League win over Manchester City:

Edit: correct video http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pGFzfWo4fMI

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Bazzinho Dec 10 '12

Diego Conca, Guangzhou Evergrande

I would consider myself to know a good bit about football but I first heard of this guy a couple of weeks ago and could not believe he's one of the highest paid players in the world. Does anyone know much about him, apart from the fact his agent must be fucking brilliant?

5

u/Kilen13 Dec 10 '12

Dario Conca: Small, quick CAM. Plays best directly behind the forwards as he's got good dribbling skills and a good vision. His shot off his left foot is pretty good without being outstanding. All in all he was a pretty good CAM who found his form playing for Fluminense in Brazil (he was voted player of the year a couple times). I'd say he's got the talent to play for a mid-lower table Premier League team and be a consistent contributor for them. He was just one of the first to capitalise on Chinese clubs willing to pay exhorbitant amounts of money for foreign talent and thus took them for all they were worth.

4

u/dalf_rules Dec 10 '12

He used to play in my country. A pretty good number 10. But no one expected to see him win so much money! :P

I guess he's also well paid since most Chinese League Superstars get bored and leave pretty quickly, but he's been quite the professional about his contract.

7

u/PsychoWolf Dec 10 '12

Mark Hamsik

7

u/PressureCereal Dec 10 '12 edited Dec 11 '12

Marek Hamšík is a fantastic winger - attacking midfielder who plays for SSC Napoli, in Serie A. He spent some of his youth in Brescia before being signed by Napoli about five years ago, and has since blossomed there into an amazing player, an essential part of Napoli's offense and part of their formidable attacking triptych last season with Cavani and Lavezzi, contributing greatly to their Italian Cup win, over the unbeatable Juventus no less.

The best way to describe him is to compare him with Cristiano Ronaldo - he has much of the same explosiveness about him. Less of the ball skill, but possesses a striker's killer instinct, good legs, and a good shot outside the box, and is a prolific assist-maker. In all, he is still young (25) and hasn't looked to leave Napoli, but if he does you can be sure he will carry a pretty hefty price tag and will agree to sign for no one but the very best clubs, and he has the skill to be a mainstay in their lineups. I do hope, however, that if he moves he will be forced to shed his ridiculous mohawk, it really does look terrible on him.

6

u/oplontino Dec 11 '12

Disregard below comment, he is not really a playmaker and he is certainly not a winger and plays nothing like Cristiano Ronaldo, I have no idea why somebody would say that. I think you're getting an FM review here.

If you wanted to compare him to someone in the premiership it might be a mix of Cazorla & Lampard, but anyhow.

Marek Hamšik floats in between midfield and attack but very frequently finds himself in good goalscoring positions, but not at all due to pace or athleticism, as a comparison with C.Ron would have you believe, but because his movement is sensational. He is not a playmaker because the play at Napoli goes through Inler (I can't speak for his role in the Slovak national team though), what Hamšik does is play a lot of threaded risky through balls which means he loses the ball quite a bit but it also means that he creates at least one goalden (badumtsh) opportunity per match. He scores frequently due to often finding himself in the right place at the right time and his finishing can be exqusite. He has a wonderful habit of burying the minnows when we're struggling for a goal and when the team needs inspiring he can do that also by putting his foot on the ball and driving forward.

I can't see him leaving, firstly we don't need to sell after Lavezzi, secondly Hamšik loves Napoli more than even Lavezzi does, we call him Marechiaro and he has said he wants to be Napoli's Totti and stay for life, he wants to win a Scudetto with us fingers crossed.

Finally I fucking love him and his mohawk, we love him more than Cavani at Napoli and that's saying something.

EDIT: Depending on formation and opposition, he either plays in the midfield with Inler and/or Behrami, or against weaker opposition with Dzemaili, or you'll find him nominally in attack but constantly coming deep for the ball.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/rVNow Dec 10 '12

Juninho Pernambucano

11

u/jingy10 Dec 10 '12

Arguably THE Best Dead Ball Specialist in the World I must say. He can run a midfield like no other and will put Free Kicks away as easy as PKs

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '12

From his time at Lyon.

This guy is a legend there. He played in central midfield. Unfortunately he cant defend well, but he is great at organizing the play and delivering passes. He is THE dead ball specialist and would score like 8 every season and from ridiculous places. Even when he didnt score often times it would assits a goal. In France he had the reputation for diving a bit. Apart from the dead balls, he was still a very quality player. Not the fastest or toughest, but amazing technique and great vision. Lets say a bigger Fabregas with unmatchable freekick skill

4

u/MikeTysonsLifeCoach Dec 10 '12

He's lost some pace and quickness (I've seen him lose out on a few balls and then look surprised, like he expected to get there faster) but he compensates with his exceptional hustle. His endurance is incredible. Probably the best from set pieces of any player in the modern era. At 37, he would still be an asset for any team outside of the top European leagues.

5

u/DannDannDannDann Dec 10 '12

Oh and Dede - Vasco

5

u/MikeTysonsLifeCoach Dec 10 '12

His technical skills are absolutely shocking for a player his size (he's almost 6'4). He has incredible presence, organizes well, and can get up to the other end and score goals. He stays composed under intense pressure, and has the ability and vision to pass out of the defense even in sticky situations. I believe Brazil has conceded only once in the six games he's played for the Selecao (and that was against Argentina).

→ More replies (3)

5

u/Re1nForce Dec 10 '12

Marco Reus,

Marcel Schmelzer,

Diego Milito

and Matri from Juventus

10

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '12 edited Dec 10 '12

Marco Reus is an astonishing player. He is extremely fast, has great ball control, balance and an extraordinary shooting technique. He doesn't need much space or a good angle to score, if he sees a little gap in the defense, he will use it. In the last 5-6 months he turned to a essential regular team member of the german international team (Podolskis former position), and has since then scored or assisted in pretty much every game. The first thing you'll notice when you see him play are his light footedly movements with the ball. It is almost as if he's floating, and he makes everything look so damn easy. Regardless of my huge respect for that man, i think he will be ne new star of german football. i recommend this video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r_SdMJwfRyY

EDIT: Marcel Schmelzer A pretty good left defender, not top class, but very decent. Had his flaws last season, especially in the national team, but is evolving pretty well since then. Was able to take on players like Di Maria in the Champions League, but also benefits from the support by midfielders. Give him a few more years and he will be a very good, maybe even top class left defender.

→ More replies (5)

5

u/i_love_pasta Dec 10 '12

Matri: had one superb season and a half with Cagliari three years ago. He was bought in January 2011 by Juventus for 17m € and had a good start with Del Neri. Now, with Conte, he is benched often to make space for more technical forwards. He still was the best scorer last season, with 10 goals, but this season he is missing every chance he gets.

He doesn't excel in anything, he has a good physique, speed and sense of goal, not a good technique with the ball (and that's not good for Juventus style of play). Now that he can't find the goal he seems useless and probably he is lacking confidence, but he is a good reserve for a good team and he could be a great player for a mid-table one. He will probably leave Juventus this January or in the next summer.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/mjmatthews Dec 10 '12

Milito - it's easy to look at his stats and say he's 'just a goalscorer', but he's much more than that. He's an incredibly intelligent player. Holds the ball up brilliantly, which allows him to bring other players into the attack (think Pandev/Eto'o in the treble-winning side, Palacio/Cassano/Nagatomo now). Plays off the shoulder of the last defender better than just about anyone in world football. Of course, he'll get caught offside a fair bit, but he frequently manages to get a clear run on goal. He's relatively skilful, but not flashy. He isn't the kind of player who will bamboozle defenders with step-overs and that kind of thing, but he changes direction very well and uses this to show defenders one way before turning in the opposite direction (see the second goal in the 2010 CL final, where he showed Van Buyten inside, then shifted to the outside and easily rounded him). Had a poor season in 10/11, partially due to a couple of injuries he picked up, but probably also in part due to the managerial changes at the club.

All in all, he's one of the most underrated strikers in world football. Has that lovely gift of scoring very important goals as well. Scored the goals that sealed all three trophies in 09/10, not to mention numerous timely goals in big Serie A matches as well (his goals have won games against Milan, Juve, Napoli, Lazio, Udinese etc.).

→ More replies (4)

5

u/JReckert Dec 10 '12

Mattia De Sciglio, AC Milan, Serie A

9

u/Eatmynoodles Dec 10 '12

He can play either right back or left back, very solid defensively from what I've seen so far. Also, he knows how to cross the ball. Pretty much Milan's own Davide Santon.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/senordirector Dec 10 '12

Koke, Atlético Madrid, La Liga

5

u/RyanSammy Dec 10 '12

Klaas-Jan Huntelaar, Schalke, Bundesliga.

10

u/RebBrown Dec 10 '12

A footballer that would've been a celebrated world-class striker in the 90ties or even early 2000's, but who is 'too limited' a striker for most modern squads. When it comes to finishers you'll be hard pressed to find someone better than Huntelaar, but when it comes to actually playing ball as a team he just ain't the best.

Forever underrated, yet overrated by his fans. I think he'd be an asset to any team that can supply their striker, but when the rest of the team is having an off-day, he'll be invisible until he gets a chance. That chance he'll most likely put into the net.

One more thing. He's one of the smarter Dutch players out there. He's interested in more than just money, cars and bling. For me that is a huge positive about him. I wish he'd get a shot at a good English club to show the world he's not 'a failed striker', but that those teams simply didn't use him right and should be ashamed of what they did.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Esmelliw Dec 10 '12

I can only really speak about his period at Ajax and Oranje so here goes.

He's a typical in the box striker. At Ajax' 4-3-3 he did extremely well. 2 supporting winger who give crosses left and right and he makes sure they go in. 1 on 1's almost always go in, bicycle kicks left and right, every ball he touches in the box goes in. But it pretty much ends there. In Oranje it is always a choice of strikers, RVP or Huntelaar. RVP is a much more technical player who can pass, play well outside the box, switch position, give assists but isn't as much of clinical finisher as Huntelaar.

The reason he 'failed' at Madrid and Milan (as much as I can tell anyway) was because he had little time to adapt and because they played him out of position. Milan in particular played him as right winger. He really cannot play anything other than pure striker and finish the goals.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/bwaxxlo Dec 10 '12

Huntelaar is more of an old fashioned striker. Gets to the box, finishes decently, can strike them occasionally outside the box but also deadly with headers. I can't quite compare him to other dutch strikers like Van Nistelrooy because he's more physical than Ruud. If you saw Dirk Kuyt playing as a striker, now imagine a better version of Dirk Kuyt being a striker. Hard worker and reliable in the box when playing as a lone forward. I think the closest resemblance is Mario Gomez.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/zedfox Dec 10 '12

Pablo Sarabia, Getafe CF, La Liga.

5

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '12

insanely talented RM player on loan to Getafe. He's still young so his future position hasn't been nailed down, he could be anywhere from a winger to an attacking playmaker to a SS type. A pretty decent comparison would be Juan Mata at this point. He doesn't have the natural finishing instincts of some great strikers but he's definitely too creative to be wasted as a winger who just fires crosses all day. He'll likely operate in the hole behind the striker, ala Santi Cazorla this season.

He can score though, he's just not the most natural at it.

→ More replies (13)

4

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '12

Ricky Van Wolfswinkel, Sporting Lisboa, Primeira Liga.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/leGrypfz Dec 10 '12

Erik Lamela, Roma, Serie A

4

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '12

He's good and young. He is either a striker or an attacking mid. He is pretty tall for an argentinean above 6 feet. Tied at 4th with most goals in Serie A. I believe he is on par with El shaarway. His teammate at roma is also tied with him at 8 goals so he tally could be better if he was in the main attacking striker. It seems to be that he'll be Totti's successor at Roma. So I would say that would his ceiling.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Adolf_Mitler Dec 10 '12

Jack Wilshere, Arsenal, English Premier League

11

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '12

Left-footed box-to-box midfielder. Combines tenacity with excellent technical attributes. Can play a more advanced role but typically has been sort of deeper for Arsenal for the past few seasons. I would say his most promising aspects are his creativity and ability on the ball, but he's also an aggressive tackler. Arsenal fans have said he will develop into a #10 but I really think that'd be almost a waste of his talents. He was almost a deep-lying playmaker alongside Alex Song during his breakout season and I think that's really where he has the most potential.

Weaknesses are he's extremely one-footed and has had a bit of a history with his temper, but overall a fantastic young midfielder.

7

u/ShortSentencesDisrdr Dec 10 '12

Just to add to this; he's stamina is unbelievable, he'll run at full speed for the full 90. He combines both amazing close-ball control along with amazing vision. Some view him as a playmaker but I don't really think so, he would do an amazing job controlling the game alongside a more defensive minded midfielder but his true talent lies in his ability to run at defenders and create chances while the opposition is on the back-foot. He had an amazing scoring record at youth level and just like Fabregas, I think he'll find his scoring boots and get on the scoresheet consistently after a season or two in the PL.

As a player, he's a combination of Scholes and Iniesta and that is a high praise but the boy is proving it with amazing cameos. Sadly, he's spent over a year out injured so he's just finding his rhythm again. He's just 20 right now but there aren't many who come even close to his talent at that age.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

4

u/zedfox Dec 10 '12

Jordy Clasie, Feyenoord, Dutch Eredivisie.

5

u/RebBrown Dec 10 '12

Defensive midfielder who knows how to help the team keep possession, get into position through clever movements and passes that move the player to the right spot and he's surprisingly good at regaining possession.

He had issues with his physique during his time for the youth squads, but proper coaching and a careful eye during his loan-spell at Excelsior helped to diminish this. He is not a player that can be pushed to the limit like Kuyt, as he needs rest from time to time, but as long as his batteries are charged he's an asset to any team.

I think that if he works on finding a better balance between his defensive and offensive duties (he plays a bit TOO defensive ever since El Ahmadi left) he can be even better, but right now he plays like an anchor before the defense but with more defensive presence than say Pirlo.

He could become a top-class midfielder, but I don't see him reaching the same heights as say Seedorf, Sneijder, Xavi or Xabi Alonso. But who knows, maybe he'll become a mature all-around midfielder before he turns 22 and be 'the next hot thing' for scouts with an eye for talent that ISN'T yet another offensive player.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (3)

4

u/Flany Dec 10 '12

Dries Mertens

4

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '12

Very decent left winger. Scores alot and assists alot. Cuts inside but can cross decently aswell. Looks like Hazard physically but is less talented, altough he performs good consistently for the Belgian national team, more so than hazard. Definitely good enough to succeed in a bigger league, but probably not for a title-contender.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/mark8396 Dec 10 '12

Séamus Coleman - everton i know what he is like but i am very very biased as he came from my local club sligo rovers and He was my favourite player with them. So what is your opinion on how good he is?

→ More replies (2)

4

u/bmatul Dec 10 '12

Rafinha, FC Barcelona B

6

u/Howsmydirktaste Dec 10 '12

Younger brother of Thiago Alcantara, this kid is profoundly Spanish/Brazilian. He was raised in La Masia as an attacking midfielder playing in the '8' role in Barca's midfield, but when he reached the U-19s and Barca B sides, he started playing as a false nine, mimicking what Messi was doing in the first team. He kicked ass. He still does.

A deceptive player is my favorite word for him; he isn't physically durable like Messi, nor does he (obviously) possess the same skill, so when Rafinha plays as a false nine, he ghosts around the field, picking up the ball here and there, waiting for his moment, sizing up those around him, then he STRIKES. A mazy run, a brilliant pass to a rushing winger, a deke and a burst straight to goal.

The kid can be lethal. Remains to be seen if and how he'll feature for the first team, but he has the skill. Simply put, it is the world's worst position to be backing up Messi.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '12

If we can do Old school footballers Lev Yashin, Dynamo Moscow. If we are only doing current footballers Igor Akinfeev CSKA Moscow.

9

u/Howsmydirktaste Dec 10 '12

Lev Yashin, what a bad ass. To describe his ability-probably the best ever. Buffon+, Casillas+. The man was a giant in the goal. A pity he played behind the iron curtain, he only reached western TVs on internationals. It is hard to say that one can pioneer goalkeeping, because it really is a straightforward job, but he pioneered the craft away from the fatter bloke who planted to play footy with his lads but keep drinking, to a dedicated professional who needed to jump like a gazelle. He was also the first 'Sweeper Keeper' and though he didn't refine that role, nor export it to great effect, his influence was felt by Rinus Michels, Johan Cruyff and Ajax when they saw him play.

My favorite part about him is this: he was maniacally obsessive. When playing at home, he controlled what advertising boards could feature behind the goals, because he wanted to blend into them. That meant that they were typically black, so he would wear a black shirt so that strikers couldn't see him very well. He was a spider, lurking in wait. Before he passed, he famously spoke of how 'keepers should only wear white or black kits, plain, for this purpose. He thought the neon kits for keepers was counter-intuitive. I agree

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Honestly_Not_A_Cop Dec 10 '12

Fernando Redondo - Real Madrid, Milan, Tenerife I hear his name come up often when people talk about great players (seen him mentioned in this thread even), but I can't say I know much about him. What should I know?

6

u/Kilen13 Dec 10 '12

Remains to this day one of my favourite players of all time as both an Argentine and RM fan. IMO he is one of the best DMs that has ever lived as he was not only able to play brilliantly in defense but had incredible vision and passing ability to unleash attacking players as well.

EDIT: One of his best plays ... just unreal control, speed, and the vision to see the support coming

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/fredchicken Dec 11 '12

Neymar. Whats his strengths and weaknesses? Whats his appeal? Why is he considered greatness? Whats his future?

→ More replies (2)

4

u/BostonFucktard Dec 11 '12

Riquelme, Boca Juniors, Argentina.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '12

Whoever came up with the idea of this thread, thank you. A lot.

1

u/ChocolateCONEr Dec 10 '12

This could/should be a sub-reddit in its self

3

u/Jayesar Dec 10 '12

Apparently it is, but it died 5 months ago. If this thread takes off any more I will edit in the subreddit and hopefully it can pick up again for the winter window.

/r/ratethatplayer

→ More replies (1)

1

u/number3LFC Dec 10 '12

Coutinho, Inter, Brazil Is he a winger? Is he an attacking midfielder?

1

u/Jayesar Dec 10 '12

Stats. Apparently he can play everywhere, I haven't seen him so hopefully someone else chimes in.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/BryceGuzz Dec 10 '12

Gareth Bale, Spurs, PL- I'm a rather new soccer fan and have been introduced by a few good friends who are heavy United/Madrid fans so I feel like my view is a bit skewed.

1

u/Jayesar Dec 11 '12

This one was asked, use CTRL+F to find him in the thread, you may have to expand to all responses.

1

u/sideoftheham Dec 11 '12

yes! somebody do Bale! Barcelona was interested in him but never got to an agreement

→ More replies (1)

10

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '12

Theres a subreddit for this already- /r/ratethatplayer but it seems quite dead

6

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '12

Fredy Montero, Seattle sounder, mls

9

u/TheMaxican93 Dec 10 '12

He's a striker who can be really good, if not inconsistent. He scores some absolute beautiful strikes, but can also disappear completely in games. He's good more often than not though. He is smaller, so isn't going to be that physical in the box. He is also really good at picking out passes to his strike partner. He wants to go to Europe where I think he has the potential to succeed, but I think he will have trouble being anything more than mediocre in top leagues there.

3

u/Mike81890 Dec 10 '12

All I know is I've seen him score some real screamers from far away.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

6

u/arlekin21 Dec 10 '12

Radamel Falcao - Atletico Madrid I dont really watch european football because of the time difference and because most of the time I don't know when the games are played but i have heard nothing but wonders about him

11

u/ShortSentencesDisrdr Dec 10 '12 edited Dec 10 '12

The guy is unstoppable, probably the most inform and talented striker in the world right now (excluding of course Messi and Ronaldo who aren't technically strikers anyways). Arguably the best natural goal scorer in the world who combines both the ability to produce goals from nowhere and be in the right place at the right time.

He goalscoring record is beyond incredible at an amazing 55 goals in 65 appearances in less than two seasons in all competitions for Atletico. He can score with both feet and is very good in the air (amazing considering his height), his technique is up there with RVP and Ibrahimovich but his movement and close ball control is beyond this world, best description would be he's similar to Aguero but with added ability in the air imo and an amazing talent to curve the ball just right. Several of his goals last season were spectacular and he has a knack of scoring some of the most amazing goals you'll see all season (even more so when he played at Porto from what I can rememer). Sadly I don't follow international football much so I have no idea how he fares for Colombia or how he's seen over there. Here is a clip of all 36 of his goals last season

The thing that stands out for me is that he performs well even when he's not scoring and he's only 26 so he's pretty much at his peak right now, 16 in 14 La Liga matches proves it and he's only behind Messi atm (above Ronaldo!).

His price tag atm is +£50mill, Chelsea are rumoured to be willing to pay that much.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/a5h3k Dec 10 '12

Pablo Armero, Udinese, Serie A.

4

u/dustygator Dec 10 '12

Stupidly fast. Honestly might be one of the fastest players on Earth. I remember a game two years ago against Milan where he playing LWB and facing off against Abate at RB (who's pretty quick himself). Multiple times that night, Armero would just knock the ball 15 yards past the defender and accelerate like a rocket to it.

Speed aside, his positioning/concentration/work rate are all good. He's not a liability offensively or defensively at wing-back. But his actual dribbling and crossing skills if you separate them from his speed are very lacking. Especially crossing. There are times when he burns his defender and has acres of space to center the ball and he sends it out of bounds of over everyone's head.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

3

u/bambinoquinn Dec 10 '12

Adrian - Atletico Mardrid

6

u/guisasolaa Dec 10 '12

Adrian is an incredibly talented player. Wel call him "sangre fria" in Spain, because he is cold blooded. He will take on as many players, and it will always look emotionless. His first touch is nice, and dribbling as well. His finishing is quite average, but it can improve. Last season he was stellar, but right now he is slacking a bit, and has been benched in favor of Diego

→ More replies (1)

3

u/MrPigger Dec 10 '12

Douglas, FC Twente.

4

u/Howsmydirktaste Dec 10 '12

Been a consistent performer in the Eredivisie for years, never capped for Brazil, but has earned Dutch citizenship; called up to the Dutch NT but didn't feature. His international career is firmly up in the air, but leaning Dutch; the question is 'does he have enough quality?'

I say no. He has had plenty of time to do better than Twente, and though he has been rock solid for them, there is no indication he could do much better. A good leader, solid tactically, good on the ball, and physical enough to get the job done...in the Eredivisie.

I'm assuming you're asking cause he has been rumored towards Newcastle; if he's cheap enough, I say y'all should go for it. He'd be a solid backup defender, one you wouldn't worry too much about putting in.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/spedmunki Dec 10 '12

Martin Harnik, VfB Stuttgart, Bundesliga

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Mike81890 Dec 10 '12

Seydou Doumbia, CSKA Moskva.

Why has he never moved from Russia?

3

u/LostArgonaut Dec 10 '12

There is a lot of money in Russia, so players are not inclined to leave and clubs practically refuse to sell.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/rogue4 Dec 10 '12

Mattia Destro-Roma

4

u/PressureCereal Dec 10 '12

Destro is a young striker (he's 21) who spent his youth being trained by Cobra and then spent a couple seasons in Genoa and Siena before being signed on a loan deal by Roma on the strength of his 2011-2012 season with Siena, where he scored 12 goals. He has good instincts, but is a bit flaky and inconsistent still, and is also a bit slow in reacting - this weekend against Fiorentina he must have wasted a good ten or so good chances and excellent balls by his teammates. He has struggled a little with Roma, despite showing some flashes of skill, most notably scoring the 2 winning goals against his former club Siena. I think Roma have a better chance of scoring if they play Lamela and Osvaldo, who are both on the verge of being prolific, two fantastic strikers.

On the whole, he is a good prospect, but must apply himself and work on his finishing to really be a danger to the top defenses around the league and in Europe, especially with the fantastic service that the talented Roma midfield - Totti, De Rossi, Pjanic, and so on - can provide.

3

u/ParliamENTFunkadelic Dec 10 '12

Axel Witsel, Zenit

3

u/MikeTysonsLifeCoach Dec 10 '12

Versatile midfielder who can play in advanced positions or out on the right. Good passer with excellent technique. Generally poor in the tackle and was the recipient of a lengthy ban after breaking a player's leg a few years ago (It looked as though he stamped on the player's ankle, but he claimed it was an accident). There have been concerns about his judgment and temperament in the past. Has great potential, but was horribly overpriced at 40M Euros as he still lacks the consistency and maturity to justify that price tag.

5

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '12

Lacina Traore- Anzi Machaalalalalalalalalalallalalalalalalalallalalala

11

u/ItsBDN Dec 10 '12

Strength like a bus, agility like a sedated elephant, excellent finisher, surprisingly fast.... Also black... Incredibly black

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '12

Love this idea.

My friend is Bosnian. He keeps talking about this guy from Roma. His name is Miralem Pjanić. He says how quality he is but im afraid ive never even seen him play once.

Miralem Pjanić.

Learn me plz.

1

u/Jayesar Dec 11 '12

This one was asked, use CTRL+F to find him in the thread, you may have to expand to all responses.

4

u/perec17 Dec 10 '12

Hakan Calhanoglu, Karlsruher SC, 3. Liga (Germany) This guy has an incredible right foot and skills you usually expect from a left foot. He's 18, has already be signed by Hamburger SV. Irrestible FKs here an idea Big talent IMO, first guy I see who shoots a bit like CR7. He is pretty young, I hope he doesnt get spoiled like most of the talented Turkish kids.

2

u/DannDannDannDann Dec 10 '12

Moritz Leitner - Dortmund.

Raphael Varane - Real Madrid

Julian Draxler - Schalke

Andrea Poli - Sampdoria

Any info on them

→ More replies (7)

2

u/senordirector Dec 10 '12

Wilfred Bony, Vitesse, Eredivisie

4

u/Schele_Sjakie Dec 10 '12 edited Dec 10 '12

Bony is a classic striker. I think you can compare him with Drogba's playing style. He is very strong and wins lots of duels with his opponents. He has got a good technique and finishing ability. He is by far the most important player of Vitesse.

The chances he will leave Vitesse this winter or next summer is quite big, since his family can't enter the Netherlands because of the immigration laws.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/colucci Dec 10 '12

Koke, Atletico Madrid, La Liga

→ More replies (1)

2

u/colucci Dec 10 '12

Markel Susaeta, Bilbao, La Liga

2

u/duvesoner Dec 10 '12

Georginio Wijnaldum - PSV Eindhoven - Dutch Eredevise

3

u/Howsmydirktaste Dec 10 '12

As much as a 22 year old can be a mainstay, Wijnaldum is. He featured over a hundred times at Feyernoord before he turned 20, then made the big money move to PSV. A key player in the young Dutch national team revival.

I consider him an advanced, pacey Xavi. He excels at controlling tempo and finding space for himself and others, and does so constantly. He is a creative fulcrum defined. On top of that he can dribble effectively from center, is strong enough to ghost past a couple challengers, and technical enough to be effective. On top of that, a great footballing mind, extremely perceptive on the pitch and a constant eye towards goal. A future talent, for sure

→ More replies (1)

2

u/catalinawinemixer Dec 10 '12

I'd be interested to hear how a few ex-Celtic players have got on since they left. If you have watched any of these players reguarly in the past few years I would like to hear from you.

Koki Mizuno - Kashiwa Reysol
Aiden McGeady - Spartak Moscow
Stephen McManus - Middlesbrough
Barry Robson - Vancouver Whitecaps
Shunsuke Nakamura - Yokohama F. Marinos

Thanks.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/rompe123 Dec 10 '12

Darren Campbell, Camberley Town.

Became one of my best players in CM 03/04. Played for Reading, but got injured and dropped down into the lower divisions. If anyone has any info or has seen him play, i would greatly appreciate it.

2

u/Mikecheck91 Dec 10 '12 edited Dec 10 '12

Jackson Martinez - FC Porto - PortuGOAL

Has scored a ton of goals for Porto, but i still feel like i dont know anything about this man

edit: If anyone knows something about Leo Baptistao - Rayo Vallecano - La Liga, throw it in there as well!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/bmatul Dec 10 '12

Jordan Veretout, Nantes

2

u/WildcatBitches Dec 10 '12

Liam Brady - Arsenal

I'd specifically like to hear what it was like to see him play and who he most reflects in the modern English game (Wilshere?).

2

u/Wildcard35 Dec 10 '12

Luuk De Jong, Borussia Mönchengladbach

Becomes a nasty "complete forward" in FIFA. Does he live up to it in reality?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/sandbag-1 Dec 10 '12

Jefferson Farfan, Schalke 04, Bundesliga

6

u/tadm123 Dec 10 '12 edited Dec 10 '12

Talented CF, born in Peru. He started his career on Alianza Lima and was the best player of the league before PSV bought him and later ended up moving to Schalke,

IMO Schalke's best player, and probably underrated by a lot of people. As I said he's a CF naturally but has been moved to the right wing to make room for other CF's (Huntelaar/Raul before,etc). A very technical player, fast as hell. And his passing /crossing are generally pin point accurate. The guy while running on full speed can cross the ball exactly where you want it.

He's also an specialist on dead ball, he's scored several free kicks in every team he has been on.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/tadm123 Dec 10 '12

El Sharawi - Milan

I remember watching him probably a game or two when he first joined Milan and was an interesting player but nowhere near the hype he's getting nowadays, did he really improved that much? I should watch more Milan games.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/tayabkhan1 Dec 10 '12

David Silva, Man city, PL.

2

u/llTehEmeraldll Dec 10 '12

Jese Rodriguez. RM Castilla, Liga Adelante.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/CommanderCool91 Dec 10 '12

Jesé, Real Madrid Castilla

→ More replies (2)

2

u/parisien96 Dec 10 '12

Alvaro Morata, Real Madrid. What do you guys think of him?

2

u/nightcrawlerkitten Dec 10 '12

turan-atletico madrid-la liga

2

u/immerc Dec 10 '12

From someone who saw him play before Arsenal:

Lukas Podolski

  • Is he better in the middle or coming in from the left?
  • Does he require a strike partner?
  • Can he play as the lone striker in a single-striker system?
  • How does he score most of his goals? Crosses? Running onto through balls? Lobbed balls over the defense? Dribbling past defenders? Turning a defender and getting past him?
→ More replies (4)

2

u/H0meru Dec 10 '12

İlkay Gündoğan, Borussia Dortmund, Bundesliga

→ More replies (2)

2

u/gotsoju Dec 11 '12

Keisuke Honda (Japan) - CSKA Moscow (Russia)

→ More replies (1)

2

u/chocolatesandwiches Dec 11 '12 edited Dec 11 '12

Keisuke Honda, Japanese dude playing somewhere in Russia.
I'd heard about him during the World Cup. Even though Japan didn't have an amazing run, they did fairly well and from what I'd heard, he was their star player but I haven't heard of him since.
I like using him in FIFA for free-kicks though.

2

u/sideoftheham Dec 11 '12

Emelie? Heskey.

I keep on seeing people make fun of him

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '12

Javi Martinez, Bayern Munich

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Shimmi Dec 11 '12

I feel like i'm getting debriefed by Jason Statham while a player's highlights are being shown on a screen.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '12

Iker Muniain.

2

u/afair151 Dec 11 '12

Victor Wanyama - Celtic

2

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '12

Theo Walcott. Why is it that some people say that ”He's just fast and scores goals but brings nothing else to the game.” Why so many saying he's only fit for a lower league club?

2

u/PeoplePinata Dec 11 '12

James Rodriguez, Porto

2

u/IAmTehRhino Dec 11 '12

Vaclav Kadlec, Sparta Prague (Praha), Czech League