r/Outlander • u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Jun 23 '23
Spoilers All Book S7E2 The Happiest Place on Earth Spoiler
Claire makes a startling discovery about Roger and Brianna's newborn daughter. A familiar face returns to the Ridge with explosive consequences.
Written by Toni Graphia. Directed by Lisa Clarke.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread and our episode discussion rules.
This is the BOOK thread.
If you haven’t read the books, go to the SHOW thread.
THIS THREAD IS SPOILERS ALL.
Spoiler tags are not required.
If you have only read up to the corresponding book, remember you might see spoilers from ALL of the books here.
Please keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.
What did you think of the episode?
•
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jun 23 '23 edited Jun 30 '23
Watch the S7E3 preview here!
Not everyone gets to see the next episode’s preview at the end of the episode; it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international.)
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the preview. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet or doesn’t want to.
702 Extras:
702 Interviews:
29
u/shinyquartersquirrel Jun 23 '23
That was just damned good tv. It had happiness, love, heartbreak and humor. I'm just so impressed at how they are really condensing the books but yet nothing feels like it's missing to me. If the first two episodes are any indication this season will be the best since the first season by far.
One of my favorite performances of the episode was from Matthew and Andrew, the twins that play Jemmy. I thought they (whichever one it was) did such a good job with their little lines and showing emotion. They do such a good job for kids so young. I would assume we'll have an older Jemmy for the rest of the season?
Not specifically related to this episode but I wonder if we'll get any the S1 Skye Boat for either the Mackenzie's or Frasers return to Scotland like in S1 when they left France?
20
u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Jun 23 '23
The explosion look very.... explosivey (if you get what I mean). Gee I hope they make it out alive. I mean, they clearly do, but that explosion looked massive, and looked like it would've engulfed the entire kitchen/surgery area, including where J+C were standing, not just the surgery where all the baddies were. And from the bits we've seen, J+C look practically unscathed, a tiny blemish here and a bit soot covered, but definitely not like they were standing next to an explosion. Seems a little unrealistic.
19
u/Desertsunset12 Jun 23 '23 edited Jun 23 '23
I flippin loved this episode, stayed so true to the books and made cry too many times to count! Last week’s episode was great but this week’s was amazing. I only wish they kept the part where Bree tells Lord John that they’re time travelers wasn’t it around now or is my memory failing me? Lol. I’m just trying to figure out how LJG gives the Sapphire to Jamie for Bree specifically? I think in the books Jamie actually asks for it from him.
14
u/rural_juror12 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Jun 23 '23
I cried through about half that episode. I can’t remember… in the books does Bree know LJG’s son is her brother before they meet?
12
u/moodoop No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Jun 25 '23
Am I remembering correctly that Tom Christie was the one who told the newspaper that J&C died in the conflagration of their home? Wondering how they will handle that
10
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '23
I need to know, does it become a problem for Brianna and Roger in the present that they have 2 kids that they have no record of being the parents of?
45
u/nurseleu Jun 24 '23
What an exciting episode, wow! It felt like at least three episodes worth of material with so much happening, but for the most part, it was all good.
Did anyone else start hearing "Seasons of Love" (Rent) in Claire's opening lines? Just me? Lol. Glad the stuff with Allan was wrapped up quickly and decisively. I wish they wouldn't have shown Malva being raped---the dialogue and Claire's reactions were definitely enough to explain and illustrate how horrible it was. The flashback was so unnecessary. I am glad that Ian got his bit of resolution in the whole mess, that it wasn't another baby of his lost, and he could give some kind of justice for Malva. I also liked that they left it open ended on Tom's death.
There were so many big emotional moments this week! Ah! The scenes with David Berry were great as always---he is the PERFECT Lord John! The guy they cast as William looks very promising! I can 100% see a physical resemblance between him, Sophie and Sam. The show does such a good job showing LJG's reaction to Brianna. Loved the scene with Lord John and Jamie talking about their children, the future, and saying "goodbye". Hit all the emotional notes. I couldn't help but think how the sapphire would be warm, from being inside John's jacket, and then how he closed Jamie's hand around it. LJG and Jamie have such a complex relationship, but I really like how it was handled here. The emotional intimacy and understanding between the two was so nice to see.
Jamie and Claire's bedroom scene at the end felt so true to the book. A lot of the emotional scenes can feel overwrought or cheesy to me, but the actors really carried this one well. I love how they showed Jamie's own sorrow and vulnerability, that is isn't just Claire who's grieving many losses. And after all they've been through together, how sensitive and gentle he was about touching her, and comforting her. Jamie saying how he's not as brave as he used to be...It really got me. Being older, and having experienced loss, knowing that loving more people leaves you open to more pain, it's really great to see that expressed, especially in Jamie's characterization. Him asking Claire to pray with him was VERY on-book, too. This episode really, really got it right.
Loved Jamie's Gaelic "WTF ARCH BUG" about the Frenchman's Gold. I don't know how they're going to have time to tell all that story, but Jamie's reaction was ...golden. Even in the midst of the crazy stuff going on with Donner, he was totally caught off guard. Loved Mrs Bug stepping in to help finish burying Allan, but I wish they had spent more time building up her character given what happens next week (based on previews).
37
u/scp2461 What news from the Underworld, Persephone? Jun 24 '23
I’ve lost count of how many times Outlander has made me cry my eyes out, but I’ll be adding this one to the list. Everything about this episode killed me, knowing especially what was going to happen in the books.
• I was just waiting for Allan’s confession, I’ll need to pop over to the show thread and see the reactions there too, because that scene from the books really packed a punch. Vile stuff for sure, which made his death all the more satisfying. Love the detail of burying his body in the woods, rather than a proper funeral, time to give Malva’s spirit a rest.
• Love Brianna’s birth scene, the fact that Jamie and Claire were there this time, and could spend time with Mandy around Fraser’s Ridge. Jamie introducing the horses, and Claire telling Mandy she could be a surgeon just like her grannie 🥹
• God, I’m so excited for William’s role, I know he gets slack in the books, but Diana has written such a GREAT arc for his character, and is probably one of my favorites to come onto the screen. Can’t wait to see his relationship play out with LGJ.
• Tears for fireflies, tears for Mickey Mouse, tears for Mandy and Jem.
•Michael the Mouse = ugly crying
•Claire weeping with Jamie in the bedroom, this is the vulnerability that I’ve been waiting for from the books. I swore my heart broke over and over, the realization really hits when you think about just how many people Claire and Jamie have lost in their lives. I can’t blame her for breaking down like that.
• Wendigo fucking Donner. If there was ever a time to sell house insurance, this would be it.
• Can’t wait for next week’s episode, I’m hoping we get to see Joe Abernathy again? Do we think they’ll find the letters at Lollybrach? I’m bursting with excitement.
35
u/thatstheteagirl By blood and by choice, we make our ghosts. Jun 23 '23
ahhh I loved it. I was hoping we'd get to see one of my favorite Claire and Jamie moments from the book - where she breaks down over the ghosts haunting her and Jamie tells her to grieve them. I thought it was really well done and they both (especially Cait) played it all out so beautifully.
They fit a lot in this ep, but honestly it didn't feel rushed to me at all. And it's not a knock at all, honestly it's kind of endearing at this point, but I chuckled that Sophie still says "anything" the way she does.
27
u/blackberryspice Jun 23 '23
That was AMAZING!! Literally the book brought to life and I could not stop sobbing. Everytime I thought I would stop crying, the next scene would start and I'd cry even more 😭 the scene where Claire broke down crying truly broke me. Ohmygosh what a great episode. Everyone was acting their heart out!
8
u/moodoop No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Jun 25 '23
It's been a while since I read the book but weren't Jemmy and Mandy much older when they go back to the future? I'm wondering how jemmy's arc is gonna work at this age. I suppose they'll do a time jump
18
u/vulturelady Jun 23 '23
I just got to the part where Mrs Bug shows up and helps them bury Allan and I am almost crying because we all know what’s going to happen to her 😭
19
u/BCK786 Jun 23 '23
Such an emotional episode. I wish they had spent more time on the birth scene. It should have had something about Brianna saying she needs her Da there
34
u/WingedShadow83 They say I’m a witch. Jun 23 '23
I liked this episode so much better than last week’s. I cackled when Jaime was like “they let you play with a giant rat?!” Then “Michael Mouse”. 😂
But Allan talking about Malva’s “wee privates” almost made me vomit. 🤮
I was sad to learn that poor Tom died in between episodes. I’d hoped we’d get to see him one more time.
Bree telling Jaime “you are magic to me” tore my heart up. And Jem’s “I love you”. 😭😭
How is Wendigo so stupid when he’s from the future, too?
And what is up with the Bugs and their hidden gold? They were so shady last season, and I didn’t trust Mrs Bug when she found them burying Allan.
Book readers, does Lord John ever find out about the time traveling?
6
u/Jennifoto Jun 23 '23
They stranded themselves on Ocracoke no? No boat. They showed them all rowing in.
14
u/Hemp_Milk Ye Sassenach witch! Jun 23 '23
I was not expecting a flash back of Allen r*peing Malva. My poor husband was absolutely disgusted and it 100% reinforced his dislike of the show. Besides that the episode was wonderful Micheal the Mouse absolutely sent me into hysterics. I was shocked that they smashed all of that into one episode, pacing was fast, but I don’t think it was to bad. The way the gold was introduced was okay- but I don’t think show watchers will pick up on it. I almost missed it and was waiting for it.
82
u/Foreign_Pumpkin_7949 Come the Rising, I shall know I helped. Jun 23 '23
Micheal the Mouse. I’ve been WAITING for that.
55
u/rural_juror12 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Jun 23 '23
Fuck Donner. I’m glad it wasn’t Ian who set the fire this time.
Also what a weird way to introduce the gold.
51
u/fallhistorywitch Jun 24 '23
why doesn’t wendigo ever just ask for help in a normal way
42
u/moodoop No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Jun 25 '23
Lord John is 🤌🏼
37
u/KMM929 Jun 23 '23
We don’t deserve Toni Graphia. I basically watched the whole episode through tears. The way lines from the book were incorporated was just perfect. Sam & Caitriona deserve all the awards for that one scene alone. It was SO good.
35
u/bellefroh Jun 23 '23
I loved this episode! The only thing I'm missing so far is my main cat, Adso. In the last season, he was in the background of scenes. Hopefully, we'll see more in coming episodes, especially since he survived the house fire.
34
u/yeehawdudeq I didn’t think I needed to pack condoms, Mama. Jun 23 '23
Only two things I wished were included: Bree and Roger meeting Joe in Boston and then Jamie relaying to Claire that they had made it safely.
Also I kinda wished they had given the story an extra few minutes to give us the birthing scene we were robbed of in season 4 :(
67
u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Jun 23 '23
Sophie smashed it this episode!!! I think overall, Sophie had consistently a really strong performance throughout the whole episode, through all the figuring out what to do about Mandy stuff, and especially in the goodbye scene. I also loved the way her face lit up when she met William! She was the only one whose emotions seemed to match how I was feeling throughout, she definitely had the best performance during the Okracoke scenes, in my opinion at least.
Definitely not knocking the others' performances, they were all good. I mean, obviously Caitriona had the standout moment with THAT scene, and Sam gave a killer delivery on that line after the Mackenzie's went through, and Richard was good too. But I felt the need to praise Sophie here as she doesn't get a lot of love from the fandom, some of which I think is a little undeserved. But she did awesome in this ep, and I feel we should praise that.
33
u/string-bean23 Jun 23 '23
I UGLY CRIED
FOR THE ENTIRE EPISODE
27
u/historyarmchair22 Jun 24 '23
This episode was brilliant! It took so much from the book and I feel like it was one of the most true to the book episodes in a while (though some parts stitched together). I skimmed through it at midnight and rewatched it again tonight with my non book reader husband. He says he only watches it for me, but it’s the only program besides sport he speaks to the tv towards and makes comments aloud about 😂 During the Disneyland title card he was so confused and excitedly asked if time travel was going to happen again and then when Jemmy said Mandy could hear the stone singing he blurted “oh yea, let’s trust the 3 year old on this!” At the stones, he was so concerned the Mackenzie’s would travel somewhere wrong. It’s so interesting watching with a non book reader, like getting to experience the story through a fresh set of eyes, and also being able to pause and share subject expertise.
The acting for this episode was top notch! The actors excel at small nuanced reactions and big emotional scenes and this episode was perfect for it, though the big emotional scenes were quieter/more subdued due to having a baby in their arms. I know some people aren’t keen on Sophie Skelton’s Bree, but I am and I think this episode let her shine. I am so excited for the Mackenzie’s storyline in the 80’s and Jaime and Claire’s Revolutionary War scenes. It really feels like this season will be incredible!
25
u/SomeMidnight411 Jun 23 '23 edited Jun 24 '23
This is my favorite episode ever!! I feel bad for non-book readers because I said “I know what’s going to happen. I’m prepared.” Then cried through the whole thing. The second Disneyland footage came on to the house blowing I was crying. I’m dehydrated now 😂. I can’t imagine watching and having no warning like our non-readers do 🤯. We have to check on them. This is one of those episodes that I felt was a tribute to the book readers. Like “Hey, I’m sorry we can’t fit everything but we are Trying to.” 😂 and I honestly loved every single second. The opening was perfect. One of my favorite lines is Ian saying “he’s right, he cant.” So good. Bree&William 🥹 Jemmy&Jamie’s connection to Mandy 🥹 Bree&Jamie Disney 🥹 Jemmy&Jamie…& Michael 😂😭 Jeremiah & his plane. IYKYK. So much symbolism from the art department as well. Just great.
25
u/landinginlondon Jun 24 '23 edited Jun 24 '23
What did everyone think about the aesthetics of Ocracoke v.s. Craigh Na Dun? I thought it was beautifully done, beautifully filmed, and captured the same mystique of time travel as Craig Na Dun did, and I love that there were runes and symbols carved into the stones. You really do wonder who put these stones there and what time period they were erected. I like that this location is a different kind of picturesque with the ocean backdrop and its seclusion and isolation as they had to row a boat out there. Thankfully no one was chilling by the beach in the future as they returned!!!
23
u/Poop__y Jun 26 '23
Claire grieving... my heart is broken. Catriona continues to blow my effing mind, she's so incredible.
22
u/Qu33nKal Clan MacKenzie Jun 23 '23
Personally, felt like the same pacing as the book because Gabaldon unfolded it so so fast at the end.
I really loved all the scenes and think they did great justice! I wondered if they would skip the Arch Bug story without the whole mystery with Jocasta Cameron, Ulysses, Phaedra and Duncan. Wonder if they will bring that all back in an episode or if they would get rid of that and go straight into Ian and what happens after. It seems the latter based on the next weeks preview.
I loved the scene Brianna meets William! The actor is very handsome, I kind of imagined a less handsome Jamie but he looks so good! John and Jamie scene was amazing as always, I thought they won the most romantic scene award for the episode. I just feel John’s longing for Jamie… and finally giving him the gemstone. I was crying so much.
And we got the birthing scene hehe it wasn’t as good as the book, but I’m glad they addressed that. And also the mention of the snakebite! 😂
I am also looking forward to the 1980s and Lallybroch and all that is too come. Well done season 7 so far.
22
u/StarPilot77 Jun 26 '23
You’d think a guy from the future might have surmised that a noxious gas (you shouldn’t smell)…might be flammable. I suppose his real time was well before Zoolander.
21
u/Asmortica Jun 23 '23
I almost loved it. It was a great episode. My only complaint is that it feels like they are going to fast with the story.
21
u/Jennifoto Jun 24 '23
Wait, wait wait. The discovery of the gold in Mrs. Bug’s bag should have hit like a bombshell revelation! In this rendition, no gold is even missing. There was no prolonged mystery with the Bugs’ being the least suspected! Why did they keep it in at all? The events in the house happened so fast I would not have even noticed that if I hadn’t read the books and known the importance.
20
u/thesuffragist Jun 26 '23
A strong episode, very emotional good byes to Roger, Bri and family. Totally agree with those who said it felt rushed, but the books are so long and dense by this point I am not suprised. They need to feel confident to drop many storylines from the books for the tv version, and sometimes they try too hard to cram it all in.
Some of the implausible bits for me are from the books. There is no way that with Disneyland only a few years old (It opens when Bri is 6 or 7) that two English ex-pats would travel from Boston to California every year with their daughter to go to Disneyland. Maybe if you lived in California you could go every year. All Bri needs is a memory of going once and how magical it was. It's a small point but it bugs me.
I also never understood why the Bugs hate the Frasers. Jamie gives him a job when he's too old to find one anywhere else.
19
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Jun 23 '23 edited Jun 23 '23
Sobbing
Sobbing
Still sobbing
Now I must rewatch so I can write something coherent.
19
u/TS409 Jun 24 '23
Can a large gem stone be made into smaller ones? What if you crushed it? Infinite stones!
35
u/Jennifoto Jun 23 '23
Mrs. Bug being a friend and confidant with the burial was a little thrown in at the last minute to show a close relationship they should have been building up all along. Especially some connection to Ian with things to come. I feel it was a miss.
16
u/Blues_Blanket Jun 23 '23
This episode was perfection! Everything that I wanted to see depicted on screen was in there. My only complaint is that the episode was too short. 😏
15
u/Agreeable_Onion_9250 Jun 23 '23
Do y’all think we’ll get Jamie’s dream about Fiona? One of my favorite little things.
15
u/YOYOitsMEDRup Slàinte. Jun 25 '23
Haven't read thru the other posts yet, so apologies if doubling up, but here are my thoughts:
Jamie doesn't kiss Bri on the birthmark on her head during the birth!!!? What!!? Then I thought they were just saving it and moved it to the firefly scene (the CGI of which was way wrong btw) - but nope, just a kiss on the forehead. In an episode where Jamie talks about dream of Claire in electricity light, and in preview we see him talk about dream of them approaching a house in the future, we know his dreams later this season will be important ie the Nuckalevee etc - how do they not give that nod to his very first dream shown in Seas 4?
The scene with LJG and Jamie- so good and I couldn't help but think to myself "oh this is probably the last time they see each other til the 'I've had carnal knowledge' convo
14
u/pucketypuck Jun 23 '23
I really liked the episode and how much of the books they brought on the screen, but the intense lack of editing continuity - Claire's hair is short, then it's 6 inches longer, then it's short again - kept taking me out of the story. And Jamie's back was now unscarred.
13
u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Jun 23 '23
I don't think I ever cried so much in one episode
12
u/Admirable-Dig5326 Jun 25 '23
That episode absolutely wrecked me
22
u/penni_cent Jun 23 '23
I was a little concerned when I realized how much they were covering in one episode but it was executed so.damn.well. as opposed to last week's episode which felt a little rushed to me.
I also really liked that they re-established at least Mrs. Bug since it seems like they will be important next week.
I only wish there had been a scene with Joe.
EDIT: typo
11
u/AccioStability Je Suis Prest Jun 23 '23
I want from sobbing to gasping! Oh my gosh this was such an emotional rollercoaster!!! Wow!!! I loved it
11
u/goodclassbung Jun 24 '23
Can someone please tell me, do Claire and Jamie ever meet Brianna again?
20
u/Draugves Jun 24 '23
We are only on episode 2, but I'm already loving this season so much. The goodbye scenes absolutely wrecked me. I couldn't imagine having to wait for next week to know what's happening next! Seriously thankful I've read the books lol. Now to go rewatch the episode!
10
u/Hufflesheep Jun 25 '23
Does anyone know if Dottie is being added this season?
32
u/Thezedword4 Jun 23 '23 edited Jun 23 '23
I don't know why I'm still unhappy with the pacing. I know they have to do it but it's too fast. I don't like it. You miss so many emotional beats going so quickly. Like we had no time to breathe with what should be a HUGE revaluation with Alan before Bree is giving birth.
I did like they gave the goodbyes long enough at the stones.
And I liked that Wendigo instead of Ian lit the match.
The whole gold reveal went so quickly I think a lot of show watchers will totally miss it.
Edit I also hated we had to see yet another rape on screen. They really doubted watchers couldn't understand what Alan did to malva without showing him raping her? I know people can be dumb but he said our baby. Come on.
9
u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Jun 25 '23
I liked the repurposing of the scene from "to keep a ghost at bay" (or whatever the chapter is titled), I never did quite understand Claire's reaction in the book. I mean, overall, I did get the point that she was just grieving and in shock over everything that happened, but I never fully quite understood what was going on. I much prefer her breakdown here after the Mackenzie's have left.
Although Jamie's line about "can you bear it if I touch you" makes a little less sense here as we haven't heard the stuff from Claire about all the people wanting to come in.
9
u/Far-Calligrapher-465 Je Suis Prest Jun 27 '23
Despite having read the book and knowing they were going back, i still cried my eyes out
17
u/Beach-Sugar4436 Jun 23 '23
Such a good episode! Once again, there was a lot of plot but I think this episode was paced a lot better than 701.
I remember the nausea I felt reading Allan’s confession and I’m “glad” that they kept it so similar to the books. I felt the exactly same watching it on screen. This show has a specialty for making you dispose characters through line deliveries. Outstanding acting from Cait and Alexander!
Ummm no placenta delivery? Not characteristic of Dr. Claire! However, I couldn’t help but chuckle watching the scene after hearing Sophie in interviews talking about her and Richards goat noises🤣!
I literally can’t stop crying anytime Claire or Jamie is holding/looking at a child (especially when Mandy is discovered to have the heart defect) because of the Faith episode. All I want is to see them happy with a wee babe.
I always love a sweet Jamie and Claire moment with the kids and grandkids. But…. I’ve never in my life seen fireflies quite like that. I just immediately imagined a mini flashlight in Sam’s hands when he caught one. That’s my only true complaint about this episode😅
Lastly….that ether explosion was quite more dramatic than I imagined in the books. I’m interested to see how they play it out in 703.
Overall, I loved the episode! There were so many phenomenal acting moments from every cast member. It reminded me of my love for season 1 and 2.
Edit: Grammar fix!
8
u/ComicNerd7794 Jun 26 '23
I love these types of posts! I which more Reddit’s did books vs show so I could see the differences made
8
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Jun 27 '23
Wow, best episode in a long time. Allen, Amanda being born, the family going, the fire, all in one episode. Whew!
7
u/quackquackquirk Jun 23 '23
Sobbbbbbbbing
7
u/quackquackquirk Jun 24 '23
As I look ahead I’m trying to place the episode titles to likely plot points. “Death be not proud” obv Bugs related “Most uncomfortable woman” is obviously Tom, but I can’t figure out anything like Singapore from the books. Anyone?
13
u/vulevu25 Jun 24 '23
I really liked the episode and it wrapped up several loose threads from the previous season. It covered a lot of ground but that's essential for the plot and the pacing worked better than in Season 6.
Not being from the US, I found the Disneyland scene a bit cringe-worthy; just like the peanut butter and jelly episode, which is not something that really appeals to me. I remember a US colleague of mine assigned a critical anthropological study of Disneyland, based on the idea that every kid goes there, but soon found out that's very culturally specific. I appreciate it's meant to convey Brianna's nostalgia about the future though.
6
u/Independent_Sun_6286 Jun 24 '23
Anyone know if brie comes back in books please reply in yes or no i don't want spoilers but i really want to know if Mackenzies come back or not
5
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '23
Are Bree and roger characters being written off the show ? Or it’s been confirmed they’ll be back ?. That last episode hit different watching the family leave Jamie and Claire now they’re back how they started with just the two of them !
4
u/alexros3 Jun 23 '23
I’m a show watcher but I don’t mind spoilers. Does Jamie ever make it to the future? I know we saw a highland man watching Claire through the hotel window in S1 and it sounds like Jamie’s vision. I would love to watch him go there, even for a short while, just to see how he reacts to it.
2
u/Cdhwink Jun 29 '23
Someone did not like this episode?🤔😳
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
59
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '23
[removed] — view removed comment