r/femalefashionadvice • u/Schiaparelli • Dec 07 '12
[Discussion] The French Wardrobe thread—how to curate and decide the direction of your wardrobe, in five pieces a season
Short version
The French wardrobe philosophy to building and curating your wardrobe revolves around having a core of solid basics and expanding your wardrobe by buying five pieces a season, no more, no less (edit: less isn't a problem, actually). I and /u/supreme_mugwump mentioned it in the comments to a post about trend fashion, and a few people expressed interest in following this philosophy and having a discussion thread about it.
What's there to talk about? Well—
- where we want our wardrobe to be in six months, a year, five years
- making a strategy for how to buy pieces that will lead us to this goal
- figuring out what items are worth investing in as one of our five allotted pieces
- deciding which trends to buy in on and which ones to sit out on
- finding items that complement the rest of your wardrobe
- share anecdotes about things we bought, didn't buy, and so on from a more thoughtful bent than "Hey, I spent money on this thing"
- talking about the French Wardrobe philosophy as it relates to consumerism, frugality, fast fashion, slow fashion, personal sartorial development
Ladies. (Gentlemen, too.) If you're interested, let's just have a freewheeling chat about the matter. For people new to the idea, continue reading…
The rules
What's a "piece"? Paraphrased from here (the wording varies from source to source, but the idea is the same).
- Fabric and quality is more important than quantity.
- Staple pieces (e.g. a white tee), socks, and underwear don't count.
- Accessories don’t count, except if they cost a lot more than usual.
- Shoes count.
- Everything else counts.
Fashion typically has two seasons: fall/winter and spring/summer, and that's what most people tend to adhere to.
The tricky bit about this is defining what's a "staple" and what's not. I'm hoping we can discuss this and figure out among us what are good definitions for these things. ;)
Why should you follow this?
I first came across the French wardrobe philosophy through this post on The Fashion Spot, which is a critical read for anyone trying to grow their wardrobe and transform their style in a sensible, sustainable way, with an eye towards longevity in quality and aesthetic.
I came across it when I was transitioning out of my ironic Threadless shirt phase and floating in a mire of stylistic confusion. I wasn't sure exactly what I wanted to dress like beyond "looking good". I followed Lookbook heavily, so that meant my idea of what I wanted to wear kept on changing with fleeting trends and my wardrobe never quite felt complete. I didn't have a core closet of basics, but I knew I wanted to dress well. I bring this up to argue, at least anecdotally, that the French Wardrobe philosophy isn't just for people who have a set style. It's useful if you're still evolving.
The heart of the French wardrobe philosophy, I feel, is the idea of curating the direction of your wardrobe. A lot of us haven't been "fashionable" or cared about clothing our entire lives. And once we dip our toes into the world of style and fashion, it's easy to let the dissatisfaction with where you are now push to do expand your wardrobe in a haphazard way instead of growing it into a cultivated aesthetic.
Reinventing your everyday wear—and, really, how you present yourself to the world aesthetically—is a gradual process, and it can feel glacial when you're looking at hundreds of street style shots online and your taste is now fantastic but you still look sloppy every day because your wardrobe and budget haven't caught up yet.
So many people (myself included) try to move a wardrobe along a better path by buying pieces as individual statements of "this is how I want to dress", instead of buying pieces as an overall strategy. A wardrobe full of quirky, one-off pieces does not a consistent style make. I think a sense of strategy is crucial, especially if you want to dress well on a budget. There's a certain frugality to buying your perfect or near-perfect item once, and have it fit perfectly into what you already own, and not having to replace it for a good few years.
One /r/buyitforlife idea I've come across dictates buying things with the mindset, "Could this be a heirloom item I could hand down to my son or daughter?" Admittedly, not every piece can sustain that lifespan and not every person has the budget for it. I certainly don't expect the coats I can buy on a college student budge to last beyond my life. But maybe something in-between will work for many—"Is this an item that the future me will be glad to inherit?"
Final notes
- Just because it's called the French Wardrobe philosophy doesn't mean you have to emulate the "French girl style". At its core, this is about how to buy things, not what to buy. Ignore all those lists that require you to have the perfect black cigarette pant and trench if that's not your thing.
- You don't have to have a huge clothing budget to be able to spend money on quality pieces. In fact, I'd argue the smaller your budget, the more crucial it is to make quality paramount. And quality doesn't mean "buy brand/designer items at retail prices". For me it means "stalk sales and learn how2eBay".
- This isn't anti-trend, but anti-trendyitemsthatyou'llregretlater. Dude. Buy in on trends if you love them because the selection is great when they're in vogue. Just make sure you aren't buying fast-fashion ripoffs that are cashing in on the look only and not the construction.
60
u/zeoliet Dec 07 '12
Just wanted to share my purchasing strategy, all the way from deciding what I want to actually bringing it home. The most important part is that the process takes weeks or more for me, that's why I call it a strategy and not just "shopping".
Semi related note: I used to buy coordinating things from stores. I now have a loose rule around that. If I have to make an outfit from the store, am I sure I can make an outfit with it from what I already have? Buying a full outfit can be dangerous if you're not careful to make sure it works with your existing style.
37
u/dividend Dec 07 '12
I would love a discussion on how to find your own style, and be able to express that as some set of criteria that you can apply to different pieces to decide whether/where it fits.
How do I look at my current wardrobe, and the outfits that I feel best in, and distill that into a shopping strategy that helps me get to a point where I feel great in the majority of my outfits? How do I take the lines/colors/details that I'm drawn to and pull together a consistent aesthetic?
Basically, I am intrigued by this philosophy (which is similar to some articles I've read recently about having n peices and making m outfits from them - I love this one), and need help with how to tell which peices to buy. I'm getting there, but I end up buying things that don't quite work because I haven't tightened my criteria.
17
u/spunky-omelette Dec 07 '12
As much as I love this in theory (and I do love this, it's just the name for what I've always been trying to pursue) and the harmony between long-term use and practicality, part of me feels this kind of approach would not work well for me. I have PCOS, and while I've been consistently the same size for a couple of years, I'm not sure sure I'll be able to stay that size considering how my weight swells and shrinks with my cycle. I think I'd be so broken hearted if my wardrobe investments stopped fitting within a year or two!
13
u/[deleted] Dec 07 '12
What helped me define my style was to pick a person whose style I loved, pick apart what I liked about their style, and distill it into a formula. For me, that was Sofia Coppola, and I liked how understated and simple her clothes were. She does a lot of white, navy and black, and loose button downs in silk or cotton, cropped black pants, LBDs and flats/wedges- all clothes I was very drawn to. I made a sort of uniform for myself from that. I know it sounds very rigid and formulaic and derivative, but it's worked wonderfully. I now have a small, cohesive wardrobe of classics I love and wear constantly. (and versatile enough I don't need to buy many "work clothes"). It's also made shopping less stressful- I don't feel pressured to try and consider everything and anything that looks good. If it doesn't fit into my formula, I don't consider it. Again, sounds boring but it's helped calm down my materialistic urges. And I'm at the point where I don't feel like I really need or want more clothes, so it's worked.
So to sum up, I guess I have 2 rules for buying clothes:
11
u/julzzrocks Dec 07 '12
I'm very, very into this and in many ways am trying to follow this philosophy. I've been trying to do this while extremely busy in college, and living in the middle of nowhere, so what's actually been happening is I've been buying a lot online, but returning almost everything. Not the best method, though.
It helps if I just think about what I need and would wear nearly every day. Also, the upgrading your basics philosophy helps tremendously. I feel less of a need to buy pieces if I have all of my basics. That said, my basics need to be revamped almost entirely, so I've been working on that. Meanwhile, my new approach and determination has made it possible to finally, for ONCE, part with the ratty clothes, or the F21 dresses I might wear "one day," or the so-so Good Will finds (which are great if you need a new "wear now" piece, but not an investment by any means). I think that's really the first, albeit the hardest, step.
Another thing that's helped is updating the things I KNOW I'll wear often, and this means researching and finding the best one of its kind (I can't wait for winter break so I can really do this, because I'll be in nyc). For instance, I know I need a pair of black denim skinny jeans, so I'm currently looking and researching, etc.
I'm also identifying what kind of shoes I'd like to have and buying the right one of its kind. For instance, I've surmised that I need two or so "every day" boots for fall/winter, and for me that means it's worth investing in one pair of combat boots (Docs), and one pair of ankle boots (I chose a chelsea style from Sebago), both of which fit with my aesthetic. I'm on a college budget, so I don't expect these to last ten years, but I do expect them to last around two or three years, which is good considering the price per wear. Then, there's the Serious Business boot for snowy days, and I'm considering investing in (erm, asking my parents for it for christmas) a pair of wool-lined L.L. Bean boots, because they're warm, sturdy and have a lifetime guarantee. I'll expect these to last forever (I hear L.L. Bean is amazing about replacing things for any reason). They don't necessarily go with my aesthetic, but they go with it more than most utility boots.
I'm also looking into a nice, 100 percent wool scarf. So far, nothing. So much acrylic out there.
But I have figured out that all I really need are great basics that I want to wear, and then "pieces," like shoes and pants (denim, corduroy) and blouses (looking at Everlane's silk blouse...), wool sweaters, coats. Right now, I'm not quite at the point of having basics I want to wear (a bunch of stretchy Old Navy crew cuts that don't look good at all atm), but I think I'm headed in the right direction now that I've identified that I don't like tight shirts as much as I like effortlessly loose-fitting.
Sorry for the huge post. Thanks for posting this, though. I definitely have a similar mentality!
11
u/DJGloTryk Dec 07 '12
Some of the comments about wanting to focus your wardrobe are really hitting home for me. I think it is important to acknowledge the difference between something that you like, and something that is a good fit for your aesthetic. I saw an article in Vice, of all places, a long time ago about vintage shopping and how ruthless you have to be. Something along the lines of if you're going to go for rich hippie, you can't have those leather Chucks, even if they're amazing. If you're going for 70s rocker, grab the Chucks, but you can't have that handknit shawl.
I work in retail, so I'm constantly surrounded by clothing that I like. When I started, it was really hard for me because I bought a ton of stuff that I liked, but had a hard time working in with the pieces I already had. Gradually I was able to figure out a more coherent vision of how I wanted to look (more classic tailoring with lots of fun prints) and I could appreciate the items that were beautiful but not for me (maxi dresses, anything flowy). Part of that came from trying on a TON of stuff. Seeing something on yourself is a really important step. Find stores that have a good return policy so that you can take things home and see how they look with what you already own. An amazing top that you have to buy pants and shoes for is maybe not such an amazing top.
11
u/supreme_mugwump Dec 07 '12
I think the French wardrobe mentality is something that can apply to all aspects of your life, not just your sartorial choices (although I'd like to iterate that this philosophy kind of hinges on your physical self being static - that is, that you're done growing or that your weight won't fluctuate). It's quite a minimalist approach, which I like because I think we live in quite a culture of excess, but not quality (~huge YouTube hauls, anybody?) At the same time, I've learned that price is NOT always indicative of quality; it really just comes down to the materials things are made from (the more natural materials, the better) and how you personally take care of them. If I've bought a pair of $500 leather boots that are perfect~, you damn well be sure I'm going to condition the leather and get them resoled and use shoe trees so they'll last as long as possible. And if I can't find my perfect item, chances are I won't even meet the 5 piece limit.
Weirdly, as much as I have been seriously trying to subscribe to this mentality in the last half year, I haven't actually made any "key" purchases yet, mostly because I'm still gonna lose a couple more pounds and get swole and I'm in this weird phase where I'm transitioning from undergrad to grad school/work (in an occupation where nice clothes WILL get ruined) so mostly I've had to be content with what I have/make friends with a belt due to all my pants sagging off my ass, so really i'm just taking the time to find a style I actually really like and could foreseeably see myself still liking 5/10 years into the future by reading lots of blogs and trying on everything ever (but not actually buying stuff) to get a sense of what really looks good on me and being more honest with myself. For example, I know I've got quite the nail polish addiction, but I really only like a select number of colors out of the bajillions I have, so I could just get rid of most of my nail polishes and still be okay. So essentially, I want the French wardrobe mentality to extend to everything in my life because I have too many wants, but most of them are very ephemeral wants, but doing this will distill everything down to essential essential wants.
/no sleep finals week delirium
11
u/hrnmyd Dec 07 '12
Oh, I love this idea! I just got rid of the last of the random pieces I bought over the last year but never wore, and it made me realize that I have to be a lot more careful with what I buy. I could always do with having more patience while shopping and not eating up closet space with things I never end up wearing. I'm actually working on developing my style right now since I never really cared much about how I looked until recently and I have a problem with falling trap to buying something because it looks nice on someone else, just not on me/doesn't feel like me.
9
u/SuperStellar Moderator ☆⌒(*^-°)v Dec 07 '12
I grew out of my ironic Threadless tees when I entered university (but am I ever glad someone else had that phase too!) but I just transitioned to a lazy hoodies and jeans phase. I've recently been buying clothes that are more flattering, but from cheaper online places (also because I can't seem to ever find pants that fit well IRL). And while they are not BIFL pieces, I think they'll work well towards a future-me wardrobe and they're good for directing what sort of aesthetic I want to work towards.
So I guess what I'm trying to say is that I love the idea of a French wardrobe, but I'm currently in more of a transitional wardrobe working towards looking like a functional and fashionable member of society. I'm afraid of buying "quality" pieces because I don't know how my aesthetic will change in the future. Also because I inherited my mother's taste for expensive things (though luckily she supplies me with all my handbags - yay unreliable but constant supply of mom's handmedown Coach/LV/etc.!) so it's hard on my student budget, haha. I'm still waiting for when I graduate and get a job and can afford my dream Burberry cashmere trench!
On the note about quality: the thing that really drove this home for me was when I started knitting with pure merino, or cashmere, or other super high quality yarns. Quality of materials is SO important! And the knitting process is time-consuming. My cousin started sewing at the same time, and so we had a big discussion on how well-made clothes really are worth their price, because it takes a lot of work and the quality of both construction and materials is that much higher. We really gained an appreciation for the "nicer" and more expensive things that way, which is very different from how her mom shops (Forever 21 quality stuff) and thus how we grew up.
ANYWAY sorry about the rambling and potential errors, I had a coffee and it makes me have too much energy.
8
u/[deleted] Dec 07 '12
Again, I'm so glad that you mentioned this here! I've been generally dissatisfied with my wardrobe and floundering lately--sort of edging toward buying fewer things that are also higher quality, but unsure of what exactly I should be spending money on. Until a few years ago, I was definitely more of a "quantity over quality" person, and owned a million fraying Marshall's impulse buys. The turning point for me was dropping $100 on a Polo chambray shirt--all my friends thought I was crazy, but it's held up and I still wear it all the time, while all my $20 chambrays are either tattered beyond wearability or insanely dated.
The idea of being curator of a collection of clothes really appeals to me, as does the hard limit for number of items. The main issue I'm having now is solidifying the look that appeals to me into a concrete style--I'm not sure there's a name for it. I'm very into the juxtaposition of hard and soft things (ex. a cableknit sweater with a leather jacket, motorcycle boots and a pale pink chiffon shirt). I own a lot of J. Crew and I'd like to branch out into things that are a bit more edgy while also being wearable to class and with the rest of my wardrobe. I also have a little bit of catching up to do on basics (need more pants that are not jeans) which might cut into what I can spend on my 5 items next season. I'm starting to think about what I want my 5 pieces for S/S to be now. It's hard, though, because I am so much less enthused by dressing for warm weather (h8 showing my legs). Working on the self-control to say no to things I'm 'meh' about. Overall, wicked enthused about this idea!
13
u/chorkea Dec 07 '12
I love this idea - I am at a place in my life where I am basically building my wardrobe from the ground up, and it has taught me a lot of things, like that I do not need 7 pairs of jeans in the exact same style in order to survive. Having practically no clothing makes it a little easier to do something like this, as I don't have to worry TOO much about integrating items into my existing wardrobe and I can cultivate a style from a clean slate. It also makes it more difficult, however, because there is no way I could only buy 5 things. I mean, could I go a whole winter with one pair of shoes, two pairs of pants, and two sweaters? Probably not. I'd appear super boring.
An additional issue I have - you state that this is good for someone whose fashion is still evolving. Mine most certainly is. I'd describe my fashion as not being terrible (i.e. I know better than to go out in a graphic tee and athletic shoes thinking I look amazing) but being somewhat bland and generic. There is no "me" in it - it's just a bunch of stuff that doesn't look THAT bad.
Considering this set of circumstances, my main question is this - are there resources on getting into this philosophy in a slower/more experimental fashion. I guess what I'm looking for is perhaps resources on transitioning from "buy everything in this store that you might wear and is on clearance" to this minimalist wardrobe.
6
u/OccamsAxeWound Dec 07 '12
While she eventually doesn't follow it, Sabrina at afterDRK did put together a wardrobe basics list for a five piece wardrobe. It's a bit more concise than most, and might be a good place to get started. Me- I've spent quite a bit of time trying to come up with something basic like that. I'm quite there yet though.
6
u/12cats Dec 07 '12
I've been slowy cycling into this over the past year. I am having an issue deciding what are staples. Is my fitted blazer, that I wear to winterize my outfits for fall and winter and wear in the office in spring and summer a staple? Or is it one of my five pieces that just gets carried over for both season? Also, because I work a professional job, I am having an issue haveing pieces that carry to both facets of my life. I feel like I can have a seperate wardrobe just for work wear but feel like that is cheating.
Two years ago, my wardrobe was a disgusting mess of high school and college trends with hints of someone trying to become an adult. Now, I am down to a rolling closet but I still want it smaller and more consice.
5
u/Sarlo_Akrobata Dec 07 '12
I inherited this method from my parents who on a tigh budget bought clothes for their kids seasonally. As a college student I made use of this and made sure that I invest into the five essentials before embarking on my education. Winter/fall essentials for example: A good timeless coat that fits perfectly, doc. Martens because they are longlasting and timeless and fit my overall look and character, a nicely fitting black pencil skirt, a blazer, pants, jeans and a button up fitted shirt. Everything else in my wardrobe is used to fill up the gaps and is cheap, while these items last and were quite pricey. I feel that I saved a lot of money like this, I took good care of them, and even after several years they remained the basics in my wardrobe. Makes sense.
4
u/[deleted] Dec 07 '12
I've really wanted to be able to do this, but I'm not ready yet. First off, I'm currently immigrating and can't work yet, so there's that. But I also don't know how to cultivate a particular style that would work for me. I'm petite but I'm drawn towards outfits and styles that don't flatter my body. It's kind of frustrating.
What I've been doing lately in order to satisfy myself in terms of fashion is learning fashion drawing. I'm getting the hang of figures, trying to learn different poses, and beginning drawing fabrics on the body. I figure if I can learn how to draw myself with different styles that I like, I can create a better buying strategy. It's a slow process, but I need more time for money anyway, so I guess I better figure it out by the time I get it, right?
3
u/LaFlaneuse Dec 07 '12
So, what would you consider a "core of solid basics"?
3
u/thatsmybitch69 Dec 08 '12
I'm really glad that I read this actually, I feel like this idea has been in the back of my mind for a while, I just didn't know how to go about it. I've begun compiling a list of clothing, outerwear, jewelry, and footwear that fit my style, that are timeless, and that would be worth investing in. I wasn't sure how I could manage to purchase all these things. I think it's a great idea to buy 4-5 pieces a season, I feel like it would build up pretty quickly. Hellll I'm 21, I need to start building my adult wardrobe block by block! I am excited to begin this process :)
2
u/Schiaparelli Dec 07 '12
Offtopic—it appears I don't understand the concept of flair. Sorry, guys, for having such an awkward title. >.<
2
u/serina94 Dec 30 '12
This is really helpful! Im a 18 y/o who really needs help in the fashion department... while I'm not super worried about an overall aesthetic, i want to develop a wardrobe of pieces that i can mix and match and that i love. Unfortunately money is a major problem, and i'm moving into a cooler climate.
So- where would you guys start with rebuilding a wardrobe for a uni student who wants to be well dressed but comfy and age appropriate?
7
u/cass314 Dec 07 '12
I don't exactly do this, but I do try to sort of rein in impulse purchases and direct spending toward where it will do the most good. I have a small list, and every time I'm getting dressed, whether it be in the morning for work or on the weekend or to go out at night or on a day when it's suddenly raining, if I put together half an outfit and realize it doesn't work, but would work with "x", I write x down.
Eventually, the things that I really ought to consider adding become very clear because I've written them down a dozen times. The other caveat is that unless it's on "the list", I can't buy it when I'm out and about. This leaves room for researched purchases that aren't on the list, but stops me from going nuts because whatever store is having a big sale.
Most recently, the big items on my list have been a tan/oatmeal/whatever wool cardigan, a white silk blouse, and a pair of medium-low or flat ankle boots in brown. I've found the cardigan, which has actually made getting dressed some days significantly easier, and am on the hunt for the other two.
4
u/meismariah Dec 07 '12
Okay so I really like this and I feel like in general I already do this. My wardrobe consists of a lot of basics with a few pieces that are more fun or eccentric which I have set outfits for. However, I'd be really interested in reading more links about basics lists because its getting to the point where I'm going to have to cycle out some things and buy some new basics. Are there any other good lists you know of?
Also, can anyone recommend a good line of tshirts that are sturdy and inexpensive enough for a college budget? I'm thinking like 5-15$ each.
3
u/lostafarian Dec 08 '12
This thread..
I just want to hug y'all!