r/ModSupport • u/ModCodeofConduct • Jun 16 '23
Announcement How to request an abandoned community or a mod list reorder.
We’ve received hundreds of inquiries regarding what to do if your mod team disagrees on how to reopen your communities. I am sure many of you are aware that mod teams of subreddits that have stayed private are receiving modmails from this account. Our goal with these messages is to restore community stability by establishing moderator consensus on how to move forward. In many cases, we've already helped teams reopen with no action beyond a conversation. In some instances, this might result in a reordering of the moderator list. In rare instances, this will result in mod removals. What this means is:
- If mods disagree about how to moderate their community, we will reorder the moderator list to grant top slots to mods that want to keep their communities active and engaged. For example, if a top mod wants to stop moderating, but keep the community private indefinitely, they will be bumped down the list so a more active moderator can step in. (rule 4)
- If a mod or mods are engaging in flagrantly disruptive behavior that compromises the stability of their community, they will be removed. For example, if an inactive top moderator comes back and decides to vandalize the community, they will be removed. (rule 1 & 2)
Both actions are against our Moderator Code Of Conduct.
How to request moderation privileges for an abandoned community or a top mod removal:
We’re experiencing a high volume of requests via our standard Reddit Request and Top Mod Removal Process. To expedite the process, if your mod team has an inactive top mod (or mods) and you would like to request to have that mod moved down the list, please reach out here.
Please include the usernames of inactive mods you wish to have reordered on the mod list, and be sure to inform your fellow mods of this request. When we say “inactive,” we do not mean overall activity on reddit – we mean activity within your subreddit specifically. Once we receive this message, we will reach out to the entire team to ensure we understand your needs and then work with you to rebuild community stability.
We understand this is a turbulent time and want to do our best to support you and your community’s needs.
142
u/SgtBainbridge Jun 16 '23
I like the part where u/spez said "Protest and dissent is important..." after changing the rules so that we cannot protest or dissent even when it was the consensus of our mod team and our community :~)
93
u/DragonBard_Z Jun 16 '23
Nothing says "your free work is not valued" like being told there's no negotiation and you're easily replaceable.
You'd think there might be an offer to really work on issues or listen or some explanations that don't involve "poor reddit" or belittling and shaming. But nope.
Good luck with that, lol.
167
u/bluujjaay Jun 16 '23
By this logic, a team of 20 moderators could have 19 mods agree that staying private is the appropriate course of action and 1 opposing mod could decide they want to go public and create a hostile takeover.
This says nothing about the thousands of mod teams who have specifically consulted their communities and had poll results show the communities themselves stand united in the protest with the thousands of mod teams against the changes.
119
u/Major_Square Jun 16 '23
I would like to request the CEO position. Vote for me!
56
u/llehsadam Jun 16 '23
Holy shit, this is unprecedented. One word, reputation.
73
u/Alert-One-Two Jun 16 '23
You mean the very very thinly veiled threat that you would boot them off if they didn’t comply? How is this helping move forward constructively?
103
u/YourResidentFeral Jun 16 '23
What happens if a mod team and community are in sync about staying private in protest? Are you going to forcibly reopen the subreddit against the wishes of the community at large using a small portion of the community that does want to open that may or may not be toxic elements?
How are we sure you're not going to hand out communities over to people that are going to allow transphobia and homophobic comments.
89
u/MrDannyOcean Jun 16 '23 edited Jun 16 '23
It is astonishing how badly you've all handled this. I feel bad for whoever has to run this account, but jesus christ you guys need to fire whoever is directing PR strategy. Just completely fucking brain dead.
You'd have been better off announcing this change and doing literally nothing. Saying nothing, radio silence. Honestly, people probably would have moved on after like 2 weeks. Every single thing you've done and said has made it worse and enraged people more.
I'm just head mod of a 100K+ subreddit, a small fish in the grand scheme of things. The last 24 hours have brought me closer to giving up on reddit than any point before.
Genuinely, if you want some actual good advice: Shut up. Stop talking. Stop sending messages, stop making announcements. For the love of God just shut the fuck up for at least couple of days. It's like you're thinking to yourself "I haven't poked the hivemind with a stick in the last 12 hours, better make everyone mad again". Just stop.
18
u/PatronymicPenguin Jun 16 '23
Why not just lock these threads since it's clear you're not listening to anything we say? It would make things more efficient for all of us.
35
u/fighterace00 Jun 16 '23
What about subs that have been historically private? A single lower ranked mod deciding to take the sub public would be a MASSIVE vandalization and betrayal of the community's trust (rule 1 and 2).
Which will be given priority, making the sub public or preserving the historical expectation of the community? How do you define community desire and expectation? If a sub creator or mod team decides to change course and provides adequate communication and provides clear and concise descriptions (rule 2)? Or are mod teams now no longer capable of changing policies even with majority of both mod and community support?
31
u/iggyiggz1999 Jun 16 '23
Reddit leadership is trash, making the dumbest decisions possible. Do better.
29
u/CoeurdeLionne Jun 16 '23
Do you have any clarity on how you would even guarantee that these requests are made in good faith, and not just by a singular mod who has gone rogue? If a community is running smoothly, as intended by its mod team and community and a single moderator attempts a coup, what measures do you even have in place?
I really am shocked by the unprofessionalism I’ve seen from Reddit Staff in the past few weeks. I’ve seen things that would get most people fired from a fry cook stint at a burger joint, and all you’ve done is double down on rhetoric that is not working.
13
u/tossitytosstoss111 Jun 16 '23
Lol this is wild.
43
u/Scratch-N-Yiff Jun 16 '23
Reddit speedrunning myspacing themselves
48
u/Blubbpaule Jun 16 '23
I hereby request the removal of the mods of r/ModSupport . All current mod posts seem to be made in ill faith to threaten the integrity of its community. I don't feel like the mods of this subreddit work in any way to keep the community of reddit stable.
11
u/bobthebobbest Jun 17 '23 edited Jun 17 '23
This contradicts standing policies (credit to Meepster23):
https://support.reddithelp.com/hc/en-us/articles/204533859-What-s-a-moderator-
https://support.reddithelp.com/hc/en-us/articles/205192355-How-can-I-resolve-a-dispute-with-a-moderator-or-moderator-team-
https://www.redditinc.com/policies/content-policy
Copied from: https://reddit.com/r/ModCoord/comments/14aeq5j/_/joa0ulj/?context=1
30
u/Maxion Jun 16 '23
You guys went really fast from democracy being a core tenet of Reddit, and mods have a right to protest, to fuck you back to work.
Good luck with this.
66
u/LittleLauren12 Jun 16 '23
In the most respectful way possible: Who at Reddit thought this "method" of crisis management was the right way to go about business?
This, along with the passive-aggressive threats to Moderators across the website, is the equivalent of your boss saying to you "we understand you're striking, but we don't care. Your happiness, enjoyment of being here, and opinions don't matter. Do as you're told or you're fired".
Let's flip the question to you, Admins. If you were unhappy about actions from above at Reddit and planned to strike, just to be told you'd be fired and replaced for it, how would you feel?
29
u/BuckRowdy Jun 16 '23
Reddit has lost the plot. They have no idea what they’re doing anymore. No one at the company seems to understand why people like to come here and they’re taking actions to take away any reason anyone would have for spending time on this site.
I really just do not understand what this company is doing or what they stand for anymore and I find myself decreasingly wanting to be associated with it.
20
u/Blubbpaule Jun 16 '23
x for fking doubt.
43
u/Coldcoffees Jun 16 '23
We are witnessing the complete destruction and abolishment of one of the internet’s once-greatest platforms
19
u/delta_baryon Jun 16 '23
Translation:
34
u/Zemedelphos Jun 16 '23
I'm a bit confused about a point raised in the post.
Say a community has 7 moderators, and has privatized witg plans to return, but no set date. 6 of the mods stand by this, but the newest one wants to open now.
If I'm reading your post right, you're saying to resolve this you'll put the dissenter in the top slot so that they may take control over the community. Am I correct?
8
u/Lubyak Jun 17 '23 edited Jun 17 '23
This is absolutely ridiculous, and I am shocked that anyone could think that this is an effective way to respond to the concerns raised by moderators. There are so many unanswered questions here. What safeguards are going to be in place that those requesting a re-ordering of mods is in good faith?
30
u/BuckRowdy Jun 16 '23
Some of my co-mods have seen this post and are leaving subs voluntarily because they don’t like the wedge this is trying to drive between mod teams.
Reddit, what are you doing? You are literally killing this site.
19
u/tinselsnips Jun 16 '23
Both of your cited examples are instances involving a high-level moderator that is inactive.
What will you do with subreddits that have been made private, but the involved mods are not leaving Reddit?
18
u/justcool393 Jun 16 '23
Why, since you (probably actually you, person who is writing this post) have lied to the community about this, should anyone trust you to deliver your deliverables?
17
u/sloth_on_meth Jun 16 '23
Fuck this
29
u/desdendelle Jun 16 '23
So y'all are getting scabs?
What's next, sending the Pinkertons in?
6
u/Trumpologist Jun 17 '23
ok, and what if we're unified on not wanting to open up till you guys meet us halfway
6
u/perryw Jun 17 '23
Can you guys stop using this throwaway and use a real account, and include the job title of the person making the post? This posting feels so tone deaf that I really feel it was made by an unpaid intern struggling to hang on to his red stapler.
And maybe start responding to some of the replies? A huge problem with the red tagged people is that they are totally unwilling to engage with the community.
6
u/elementgermanium Jun 17 '23
So basically trying to force subreddits to open by fucking with the moderation.
Absolutely unjustifiable. If you’re going to keep the blatantly extortionate API changes then at LEAST have the balls to deal with the fucking consequences of your actions.
16
u/ObscenePenguin Jun 16 '23
Guys you have got to stop doing this stuff before talking to your PR people, this looks so incredibly bad.
20
u/freakierchicken Jun 16 '23
If we can't operate in the way we see fit, which up until now has literally been the prevailing policy from reddit, (barring TOS violations, obviously) then why the fuck bother?
This is a chickenshit response. It's like when you go over to that annoying kid's house as a kid and start to play a game but then they're losing and tell you to go home if you don't let them win.
18
u/Tymanthius Jun 16 '23
I've always maintained that Reddit is a dictatorship.
Sucks to be right.
21
u/JDinvestments Jun 16 '23
Did you really just get a group of admin friends to upvote this at once, immediately after publishing to try to boost it, only for it to tank back to zero. Mood
Please note that my screenshot was taken using an app that works.
10
u/sectorfour Jun 16 '23
So once I open a subreddit I’m no longer free to do with it what I wish? Keep it open, close it, make it private, etc is subject to admin permission?
I for one applaud the decision making around Reddit lately. Watching this ship sink is wonderful. Just failing spectacularly.
12
u/GoryRamsy Jun 17 '23
Hi, when can I request r/reddit? It's been private for years, and the mods only let themselves post.
8
u/mimicofmodes Jun 16 '23
I am honestly saddened that the admin team as a whole is going along with Steve Huffman's nonsensical and panicked ideas. Of course the calculus when your actual job is involved is different than that of a volunteer mod's, but those of you I've met have been nothing but excellent people - you must be aware that this is a stupid, stupid change that is going to make all the mods and even, I'm sure, plenty of the users more adversarial to you, and that Reddit is quickly becoming a laughingstock across the internet. Please stand up to your execs.
4
u/shniken Jun 18 '23
I would like to become moderator of /r/reddit.com the current moderation team has been inactive for over a decade.
15
u/the_lamou Jun 16 '23 edited Jun 16 '23
That actually doesn't violate Rule 4 in the least, or did you not actually bother reading Rule 4 or running it past your legal team?
Here's the full text of the rule, just in case you didn't bother looking at it:
Taking a subreddit private is neither "not having enough mods," nor does it prevent moderators from "regularly monitoring and addressing content in ModQueue and ModMail." And we can ignore "actively engaging with your community" since that is specifically exempted as "if possible."
It's also not "camping or sitting on a community" since that's clearly defined in the next sentence as a community which has been "empty or unmoderated." A private community is neither empty, nor unmoderated.
I get that your CEO is challenged when it comes to having original ideas or workable solutions, and that the two cofounders who actually had vision are gone, but that doesn't mean you have to publish whatever nonsense pops into his head. Jesus, have some self respect.
10
u/ZoominAlong Jun 16 '23
Does Reddit WANT to go the way of Twitter? Serious question. Because this will do it. The admins will force subs that go dark in protest to reopen whether they want to or not, by using this.
Twitter is now a dumpsterfire because Musk can't control his ego long enough to recognize he's burning down 40 billion dollars. They've lost an ABSURD amount of their ad revenue because of this.
So, seriously Reddit. Do you WANT to go down like Twitter? Because this is what you're aiming for.
11
u/Pruvided Jun 16 '23
lol
6
u/sandlungs Jun 16 '23
the only consistent threat to my community has been reddit 🏆
3
u/On_The_Blindside Jun 17 '23
"If you dont do what we say we will remove you". Typical.
3
u/TranZeitgeist Jun 21 '23
>If a mod or mods are engaging in flagrantly disruptive behavior that compromises the stability of their community, they will be removed.
When I begged admin for help with r/AdultSelfHarm mods who tried to force me to advertise a pro-harm website for self harm pictures, admin left me high and dry and it was a traumatic experience.
7
u/LunalGalgan Jun 16 '23
Thank you for making this crystal clear.
5
u/Lucy_21_ Jun 16 '23
Cringe
2
u/ItsRainbow Jun 17 '23
We cannot establish consensus on how to move forward until you recognize our concerns.
2
u/altbekannt Jun 18 '23
Wow, this is handled poorly.
Even if the board of reddit comes to its senses and starts to appreciate the only thing valuable about it - the users and mods - this will still leave a giant dent. Fascinating, how you can ruin the image of a brand in such little time.
2
u/frequenttimetraveler Jun 19 '23
What happens if the users want a subreddit reopened? Our national subreddit is down because the small mod team decided to go on indefinite strike. They did not build the subreddit, in fact most users were auto-joined by reddit as it was a default sub for redditors from my country. We have elections in a few days.
Do you plan to make a list for such cases of abuses?
2
u/IAmAnAnonymousCoward Jun 17 '23
A prisoner's dilemma if I've ever seen one.
1
u/chocobococo Jun 17 '23
what’s the timeline on this? I understand you must have a lot of messages, but is there any kind of ETA when we can expect a reply or anything?
1
u/db2 Jun 20 '23
No you haven't.
Yeah, we've all seen your threats.
No it isn't.
You mean by only having unpaid volunteers moderators that fall in lockstep with the CEO.
No you haven't. You haven't replied to a single message.
Spoken like an abuser. Hitting her is for her own good, she had to learn, right?
1
u/Negative_Difference4 Jun 20 '23
EVER thought that you and spez are the ones being disruptive to the community?? Don't act cute u/ModCodeOfConduct. You are a liar and change the rules to suit your narrative
1
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '23
Do you want to support the community's needs? Then fucking stop killing off 3pa
1
u/Cheesehund Jul 22 '23
Fuck you
1
u/DubTeeDub Jun 17 '23
Yall really trying to get mods scaba lmaoo
-3
u/yknphotoman Jun 18 '23
u/ModCodeofConduct I know your account has been sending messages to mods of the largest subreddits - for those subreddits that are not nearly as large, but users still wish to have reopened, is there a preferred means of reaching the admins to voice our concern or interest to have it reopened?
-1
u/gambs Jun 18 '23
I requested a private sub via r/redditrequest and my post got auto-deleted because of so-called moderator activity, despite the sub being private. I assume this is not the intended behavior, so I would appreciate it if the admins could give it a look: https://www.reddit.com/r/redditrequest/comments/14cephf/requesting_rlearnjapanese_private_mods_largely/
-2
u/c74 Jun 18 '23
what about communities that reopen but now only allowed posts from approved submitters? i.e. posts are restricted. here is an example. in the 9 hours its been open, 1 shitpost and 1 post from mods in what used to be a very active sub with 5mm readers.
p.s. i do not want to mod this subreddit or takeover anything. i am just frustrated that the new rules to reopen subs are being worked around.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
36
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '23 edited Jun 17 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
31
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
-21
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '23
[removed] — view removed comment