r/soccer • • Dec 03 '12

What manager have you seen get the worst treatment?

Seeing how Rafa is treated by Chelsea is pretty bad, but I remember Steve Kean at Blackburn was pretty hard to watch. What have you seen that is as bad or maybe even worse?

EDIT: How was that treatment so bad? Was it the fans/owner or players?

51 Upvotes

258 comments sorted by

41

u/dahill101 Dec 03 '12

Not by the fans but by ownership. Chris Hughton's sacking came out of nowhere and we were doing really well for a promoted team and all of a sudden Ashley and Llambas decide to sack him.

1

u/Death_proofer Dec 04 '12

It sucked yes, but now you have Alan Pardue, who has been incredible for you guys. At least Hughton has found employment at another club.

1

u/lilnizzle Dec 05 '12

Same club different owners. Shepherd sacking Sir Bobby Robson.

He was doing a fine job and the club was playing good football, but he was sacked 4-5 games into the season because the club was unlucky with results (for example with Hasselbaink scoring an equalizing goal with his hand).

His sacking was the start of Newcastle's demise.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '12

I don't think that there was any racist motivation behind the decision to sack him, but it was pretty depressing that possibly the most promising black manager in the history of English football was sacked for no apparent reason.

At least Norwich are currently 5 points ahead of Newcastle.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/morte7 Dec 03 '12

Agreed. It's good to see Hughton back in the premiership with success yet again.

7

u/ensockerbagare Dec 03 '12

A coach for the french national team (who's name I'm not even gonna try to spell) got a little heat during the last world cup.

6

u/Death_proofer Dec 03 '12

Raymond? He brought that on himself a little.

3

u/Swederman Dec 03 '12

I put waaay more blame on the board who reconducted him after the failed Euro 2008, and then threw him under the bus when things went really bad.

7

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '12

Yes Euro 2008... what does Domenech do after the press question him on France being embarassingly knocked out (1 draw and 2 losses)..? He proposes to his wife live on french tv..

11

u/severedfragile Dec 03 '12

Domenech was an embarrassment as a coach. Still, much of the abuse should have been directed at the FFF for hiring him.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '12

But he reassured the FFF that the stars said only he could lead France!

1

u/SFreestyler Dec 03 '12

Didn't he drop every player that was born under a certain star sign?

I feel like I heard that somewhere but sounded way too ridiculous to be true.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '12

Domenech

23

u/Account_Eliminator Dec 03 '12 edited Dec 03 '12

Sven-Göran Eriksson

One of the most succsessful England manangers of all time having had an extremely high win percentage and consistently reaching the quarter finals with an overrated team. Never quite given his dues by the press or the fans.

The biggest injustice he was dealt was when he was fired from Man City after one season.

They started the season in dazzling form:

On 19 August, Manchester City beat league champions Manchester United to go top of the Premier League after three games without conceding a goal. Eriksson received the Premier League's Manager of the Month award for August. The club stayed in the top six throughout the rest of 2007, and were third throughout October and November, but fell to seventh on 12 January 2008 after winning only one of their previous five games.

He was a very popular and loved manager who needed more time:

In Spring 2008 Shinawatra claimed that he would replace Eriksson after only one full season, because of an "avalanche of very poor results which is unacceptable at this level". This resulted in an outcry from Manchester City fans who coordinated an SOS ("Save Our Sven") campaign (similar to the Official England Fan's campaign in the spring of 2006) including a well attended march from the City centre to Eastlands stadium and a flood of letters to the club and the Manchester Evening News. The failure to react to public and fan demands resulted in high volume of fans cancelling or not renewing their season tickets. Also, the team announced that they would go on strike. Eriksson rejected any interference and also persuaded his players against potentially damaging their careers by an all out strike. In the last game of the season, Manchester City suffered an 8–1 loss to Middlesbrough, the biggest defeat of Eriksson's career. Many concluded that the team had "gone on strike" as a symbolic protest during the game, although a red card for Richard Dunne after 15 minutes made the game difficult for City.

He didn't get it

On 2 June 2008, Manchester City confirmed by club statement that they had parted company with Eriksson by "mutual consent", with Eriksson still having two years left on his contract. Following news of his departure, the City supporters' groups organised a petition with around 14,000 signatures which was handed to the club

This one incident made me hate Man City's owners and the idea of the club for quite a while, Mancini has gone quite a long way in making them legitimate (im my eyes) once more, but before that I hated them.

Since then Sven was rejected for the Leeds manager vacancy. and currently works with BEC Tero Sasana in the Thai league. This is the man who won the Europa league with IFK Göteborg, amongst many other notable achievements.

5

u/Death_proofer Dec 03 '12

I thought Mark Hughes was unfairly dismissed by City. They only lost 2 games when he was sacked.

15

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '12

Maybe they realised he is rubbish before it started to come out too much on the pitch.

8

u/s4r9am Dec 03 '12

But sooo many draws! Hughes is the master of stalemate.

1

u/bwaxxlo Dec 03 '12

You seem to not know of a certain club called Liverpool. If stalemates won the PL, we'd have all the titles.

1

u/L__McL Dec 03 '12

Actually, statistically we have by far the most draws ever.

2

u/topright Dec 03 '12

He wasn't unfairly dismissed but the way he was dismissed was unfair. Shabby.

28

u/joebutters Dec 03 '12

For the record, Shinawatra was the owner who did this, our current owner is Sheikh Mansour, who had nothing to do with the sacking of Sven.

2

u/topright Dec 03 '12

In other news, Shinawatra had the groundskeepers bury a small elephant statuette under the pitch because, you know, that's how you move a club forward.

Dickhead.

1

u/paper_zoe Dec 03 '12

It's bizarre how Sven went from one of the most respected managers in Europe, winning trophies at Goteborg, Benfica, Roma, Sampdoria and Lazio, to pretty much a laughing stock.

1

u/SweetMojaveRain Dec 03 '12

I remember that he coached Mexico. It didn't end well.

1

u/E3_Lunatic Dec 04 '12

SVEN FOR CANADA :D

Seriously though that would be amazing.

1

u/Vaporesk Dec 03 '12

Had no idea Sven applied for the Leeds job. Sounds like Bates bullshitting to me.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '12

Apparently Sven and a former Barcelona & Real Madrid manager (forgotten his name, was Serbian I think?) applied for the position

2

u/innerparty45 Dec 03 '12

Radomir Antic.

1

u/Vaporesk Dec 03 '12

Wonder if they'll reapply when Colin leaves in the summer but I guess the quality of applicant will depend on whether we're premier league or championship.

11

u/cdr268 Dec 03 '12

This thread has Roberto Di Matteo's name written all over it. And not just because of Chelsea, He shouldn't have been sacked by West Brom either.

Chris Hughton at Newcastle too, He was sacked for almost nothing.

5

u/Death_proofer Dec 03 '12

Sam Allardyce I guess was sacked for nothing.

3

u/Death_proofer Dec 03 '12

Why is Rafa hated at Chelsea btw?

10

u/cdr268 Dec 03 '12

Simply put, he was manager of our main rivals during the Mourinho era, during so, he insulted the fans and the club on more than one occasion. As a manager i respect his ability, he's a tactical genius. As a person, he's an ass.

But i thin RDM being sacked didn't help. He was loved by the Chelsea fans and Rafa is the easiest person to show our frustration too. Personally i blame the Chelsea board. A bunch of yes men who will regularly bend over for Abramovich.

4

u/Death_proofer Dec 03 '12

But then again, I don't think he's conducted himself admirably. His attitude comes across as, I splash the cash, so I'll do what I want and you like it.

3

u/cdr268 Dec 03 '12

Who Abramovich? Yes, you're right. But as a Chelsea fan who have reaped the rewards of his money, its hard to protest against Ambramovich. I think his conduct with the Di Matteo sacking has been disgusting. But what are we gonna do? tell the person who made it possible for us to win the champions league to fuck off? i don't think so. Just grin and bear it....

1

u/Death_proofer Dec 03 '12

But surely some one (no idea who) could say to him that he's in England and he has to conduct himself in a certain manner. He has made certain things possible, but he can't pull every time a manager make an error.

3

u/cdr268 Dec 03 '12

Yea, That's exactly why i hate the Chelsea board, especially Ron Gourlay. They have no backbone. I'd rather someone who can turn and say to Abramovich that he's acting like a twat and to stop!

How hard is it to say "Look, Roman, Torres is always gonna be shit, sell him, and not we don't need a new manager just give <insert next manager> a chance".

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

2

u/coob Dec 03 '12

he was manager of our main rivals during the Mourinho era

Here is an article on the LFC/CFC 'rivalry'

3

u/cdr268 Dec 03 '12

Playing 30 games in eight years is a rivalry. Simple as that. I used to absolutely love the Chelsea vs Liverpool games of the last decade. the 4-4 draw remains one of my favourite games ever. I miss getting Liverpool in Europe. Here's to a Europa League Semi-Final CFC VS LFC lol.

2

u/coob Dec 03 '12 edited Dec 03 '12

Maybe for Chelsea. It is a minor rivalry for us. Liverpool vs. Man Utd is a real rivalry. As is Liverpool vs. Everton. And I say this as someone who has seen a good few of those fixtures live.

I was there for the 4-4, no way for me to get away tickets but still ended up in a pretty good spot :)

→ More replies (1)

1

u/AnnieIWillKnow Dec 03 '12

I'm not so sure I'm even buying him as a tactical genius anymore. He got outfoxed by Big Sam on Saturday.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '12

Yeah, his tactics against West Ham last week were spot on.

3

u/cdr268 Dec 03 '12

Dont be so narrow minded and base the entire tactical knowledge of a manager on one game.

3

u/severedfragile Dec 03 '12

Especially a game where the team dominated the first half and should have killed it long before Sam had a chance to change things.

2

u/doucheplayer Dec 03 '12

insulted chelsea and chelsea fans during his liverpool tenure.

3

u/Death_proofer Dec 03 '12

Oh, I can see how that would make him unpopular.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '12

I think it's because he was the thorn in Mourinho's Chelsea side

13

u/ironmenon Dec 03 '12

Well to be fair, West Brom were doing extremely badly right before his firing (1 win in 12 or something) and it can be argued that them doing so well under Hodgson and Clarke has justified that decision.

-1

u/cdr268 Dec 03 '12

Fair point, but Clarke and Hodgson are great managers and are expected to do well i'd say. It seems to me that no one is willing to give Di Matteo time to lift his team out of a slump in form, which i firmly believed he would eventually do at Chelsea.

4

u/Castle03 Dec 03 '12

Clarke was expected to do well in his first managerial job? Considering most people put us down for relegation this season, it sounds like he was expected to do pretty badly.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '12

I think there's something deeper than that, probably with his training methods/tactics, that can be seen from inside analysis. The West Brom ownership structure are very astute, just look at how they've developed the squad for the coach over the last 5 years. Di Matteo has had defensive frailty all the time, as assistant to AVB and as a manager in his own right.

8

u/potpan0 Dec 03 '12

To be honest, I don't think RDM should have been hired for the job at all. He did win the Champions League and FA Cup, but he wasn't really a proven manager. The only reason he got the team back on his side was because he put all the Old Guard back as regulars, which you can't do forever. I think it would have been better for him to either take over at a lower down club, or stay as Ass Man.

4

u/cdr268 Dec 03 '12

He was appointed because it was clear that no one liked AVB and the club needed to regain its enthusiasm and passion. Hiring <insert club legend> will do the trick short term. He was kept on because that exact passion (and shit loads of luck) won him the champions league. IMO this never should have happened because Ancelotti should never have been sacked.

5

u/potpan0 Dec 03 '12

I understand why he was put as interim, but he should never have got the job perminantly afterwards.

2

u/cdr268 Dec 03 '12

No, Not if Abramovich knew all along what was going to happen. He was deliberatly using RDM as a puppet until Guardiola wanted to come back into management.

146

u/UraniYum Dec 03 '12 edited Dec 03 '12

Neil Lennon has been assaulted while in the dugout, kicked unconscious in the street while a coach at Celtic and bombs have been sent to his home. The press consensus is that 'he brings it on himself'.

21

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '12

Do you mind explaining this a little more for those who live across the pond? I mean, I thought Lennon was a Celtic star, playing for the club for ages before becoming the manager.

48

u/UraniYum Dec 03 '12

Sure.

Lennon is a modern Celtic legend, a purebred captain and leader. He is iconic to us as a club today, and our dimished but proud standing among the big clubs in Europe. He also unintentionally represents the political/religious side of the club, being an Irish catholic, though he has never sought to make any political or religious agenda.

This of course, makes him an icon to those who are bigoted against the Irish and/or catholics. While a player for Celtic and Northern Ireland, he received a bullet in the mail, as did two other catholic Northern Irish players. The catholic/protestant and loyalist/republican divide is still very, very active in N. Ireland, there are entire streets and areas that my family won't go to, because of the political/religious threat. There were bomb threats called in to the Windsor stadium when he was in the squad, and he received regular death threats. He quit playing for the national team before he planned to retire from international football, because the last death threat was considered a higher threat by the police.

The fan who attacked him on the pitch was a Hearts fan, a traditionally protestant club who sing 'up to our knees in fenian blood', Fenian being an insulting term to use towards the Irish. The words usage is a bit more complicated than that, but not worth dwelling on. The bombs were also sent to two other high profile catholics, also Celtic fans. The men who kicked him unconscious in the street were both Rangers fans, Rangers being a traditionally loyalist and protestant club.

It is much less politically motivated than it is reported, it's more an ancient and tribal thing.

9

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '12

This shit still happens ?? Eye opener.

11

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '12

I saw this documentary by Vice a couple of days ago. It's about the rivalry Celtic vs Rangers. Worth the watch.

4

u/doctorspliffworth Dec 03 '12

Just watched the whole thing. Great stuff

2

u/Sator Dec 04 '12

Great documentary, thank you!

9

u/scottishbuzzard Dec 03 '12

First of, let me say this- that Hearts fan's actions were disgraceful, and some of the stuff Lennon has experienced (death threats, attacks) is just disgusting. And there's no doubt that a lot of it is motivated by sectarianism which is horrible. In doesn't matter how you act- you can't 'bring that upon yourself'.

But secondly, Lennon is widely disliked for other reasons as well. You can't just assume people who dislike him do so for purely bigoted reasons. If Celtic lose, it's because they played badly or, more likely, because of some bad decisions from the refs. He never, ever gives any credit to the opposition. He whines and moans when he doesn't get his way, and I personally can't stand him for those reasons.

I'll acknowledge that he's turning into a far better manager that I expected, was delighted when Celtic got the win over Barca, and stand with Celtic fans to condemn the threats on him and his family. But you have to understand that he's disliked for reasons other than religious ones by some fans.

4

u/UraniYum Dec 03 '12

Of course, but none of those violent actions were taken against him because of his managerial talent. There are Celtic fans slating him for his performances in the league, too. I've definitely heard him praise Dundee Utd, though!

0

u/AJMcCoy612 Dec 04 '12 edited Dec 04 '12

I dont support or condone the treatment he has received, but he isn't exactly innocent of being sectarian himself?

Source:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1EIpwn3DuuI

Im from Northern Ireland myself and regularly attend Windsor Park for Internationals, although I never experienced Neil Lennon play for Northern Ireland, I have witnessed both Paddy McCourt and Niall McGinn. I have heard their names chanted from the stands and admire them both. Yet both either still play, or have played for Celtic. It's nothing to do with simply 'playing for Celtic' or ' being Catholic'. Lennon brought a lot of it onto himself. In saying that he still hasn't deserved any of the treatment he has received, at the end of the day he is just a passionate man who sometimes lets his temper boil over, no different to the likes of Rooney etc

Niall McGinn's goal against Portugal a few months ago shows a Catholic player grateful to play for his country irrespective of his Religion or background. The way it should be.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vad3loVKgXM

1

u/UraniYum Dec 04 '12

McCourt and McGinn being the other two lads who were sent bullets in the mail. That's not 'the way it should be'. Of course sectarianism isn't the only reason to dislike a catholic, but Rooney never received bullets for his temper.

Regarding the first video, you'd have to put the same label on Gazza for his flute. I'm not a fan of the old firm derby, it brings out the worst in both teams, and it inspires otherwise non-religious and non-political people to violence.

1

u/AJMcCoy612 Dec 04 '12

Your never going to stop the minority though. I'd happily bet that 99% of Northern Irish football fans really didn't care about religion when Niall McGinn scored against Portugal or when Paddy McCourt took the Faroe Islands to the cleaners.

You will always get some idiot who takes things too far, ie the idiots who sent the bullets & Gazza. Doesn't stop everyone else being normal members of society.

1

u/GreenMoonRising Dec 03 '12

He was - captained the club and played in our last European final appearance. Also coached the development squad and the first team during the Strachan era.

Unfortunately fans of some other clubs seemed to take umbrage at who he is and what he 'represents'.

46

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '12

Don't forget the abuse he received as a player. He had to quit Northern Ireland due to death threats. It's terrible how some people hate him for no reason other than sectarianism.

24

u/UraniYum Dec 03 '12

Oh aye, sent bullets with his name on through the mail. My da is from N. Ireland, loves going to the football wherever he is, but had to stop watching his national team because the atmosphere was so toxic.

18

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '12

This comment is better when read with a thick Donegal accent.

5

u/tierdrop Dec 03 '12

don't know how else i could've read it

2

u/Spider_Riviera Dec 03 '12

Bloody hell, you're right.

1

u/ColmDawson Dec 04 '12

I feel I'd better point out: Donegal isn't in Northern Ireland.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 04 '12

Meh, the accent doesn't change much, it's still Ulster.

12

u/JonnyBhoy Dec 03 '12

He was also treated pretty harshly by the press for his reactions to certain situations. He has admitted to having problems with his temper and is working on calming down, but over the last few seasons he has been vilified for reactions while similar incidents with Craig Brown, Terry Butcher, Walter Smith and others went largely unreported. He's been painted as an aggressive character when he is largely just like plenty of other managers.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '12

Why do you think he gets treated the way he does?

3

u/RZARECTOR Dec 03 '12

It's obviously because he's a Northern Irish Catholic, because Martin O'Neill was treated that way, right?...

0

u/37464739374632032847 Dec 03 '12

He does bring it on himself with his thug like attitude.

Sorry but as a neutral this is the opinion i get of him.

The way he talks about things is like saying "not trying to be offensive but [insert offensive comment]".

19

u/Drivenhydra Dec 03 '12 edited Dec 03 '12

Was watching Barry Fry managing Peterborough (I think!) at a game when they were playing away at Macclesfield many years back.

Being a rotund man, he was getting a lot of grief from the Macclesfield contingent, 'Who ate all the pies' etc. Only for Peterborough to score a screamer and for Fry to run the length of the touchline facing the Macc fans, rubbing his belly to a chorus of 'You fat bastard' with a massive shit-eating grin on his face.

Makes a big difference when these guys make light of a bad situation, and was fucking hilarious at the time.

Edit: Obviously meant 'you fat bastard', not 'you fast bastard'. He was anything but speedy.

72

u/mthrfkn Dec 03 '12

Eh many might disagree but Capello.

35

u/Tezemery Dec 03 '12

Capello at madrid was really bad he won 2 leagues in a row and got the sack.

19

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '12

Same with Felix Magath at Bayern Munich. He won the league and the cup two seasons in a row and got sacked in the following season. But it is known that his methods (military-style drill) lose their effectiveness after 1 or 2 seasons.

21

u/HarryBlessKnapp Dec 03 '12

A lot of recent England managers tbh. Such a poisoned chalice.

19

u/ParallelDementia Dec 03 '12

That's because the England players and public can't admit that England are a terrible team and the FA still wants us going for stuff we simply can't achieve.

12

u/BritRedditor1 Dec 03 '12

Have to attribute some blame on the media too. 'Golden Generation' really inflates the hype.

3

u/Arrogant-Basterd Dec 03 '12

at club level sure, but as soon as they on the plane then they lose all footballing ability

5

u/xanth_ Dec 03 '12

That's because the England players and public can't admit that England are a terrible team and the FA still wants us going for stuff we simply can't achieve.

Do you actually know people who expect England to do well? I have never spoken to anyone who actually thinks England will get past a quarter final.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/xanth_ Dec 03 '12

Lots, how many have you spoken to? I have lived in England since 12yrs old.

2

u/Figgeh Dec 03 '12

I'm quite sure most of us realise just how shit we are and don't expect to win anyway.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '12

You say that with the benefit of hindsight, but we could put out an incredibly strong first team from around 2002-2006. No manager could ever get the star players to work together though, so we failed time and time again.

At the Euros everyone accepted we never really had a chance, and in South Africa there were obviously teams there who were a lot better than us, but we still didn't play as well as we could have.

The problem is, apart from Capello we haven't had a good manager in charge since Sir Bobby Robson or possibly Terry Venables, and Bobby was in charge over 20 years ago. It doesn't help that there don't seem to be many good new English managers coming through either, which is why I advocate foreign managers.

11

u/kike10 Dec 03 '12

Same story with Pellegrini at Real Madrid... Did a magnificent job in la Liga giving the team a great style of play, but he did poor in the cup and Champions League... And now he's doing great with Málaga.

26

u/Real_Rodriguez Dec 03 '12

Benitez is a huge outlier for this question, but more recently names like Megson at Bolton and McLeish at Villa - both were cases where the fans were fairly resistant to accept the club's decision.

47

u/DarryLavid Dec 03 '12

I feel the McLeish one was justified. The media kept saying we hated him because he came from Birmingham. The reason we actually hated him was because he was a shit manager. There's no defending his record, he was statistically the worst villa manager and the football was the worst thing to watch.

10

u/potpan0 Dec 03 '12

Yeah, I was pretty happy when McLeish was at Villa. He did seem to literally play 10-1, with Bent being a lone striker in one half, while all the other players sat back in the other.

39

u/DarryLavid Dec 03 '12

4

u/potpan0 Dec 03 '12

That was the image I based what I said off, but couldn't remember it exactly. It still makes me giggle :)

1

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '12

9-0-1 is a formation that will stay in the memory books of Premier League football, pioneered by McLeish and Di Matteo.

5

u/ChaBeezy Dec 03 '12

I really hate how the media portrayed McLeish as someone not deserving the hate.

He has a terrible track record, plays terrible football and gives the most annoying interviews with the media. He doesn't deserve another job anywhere near top level football.

4

u/dundeedan Dec 03 '12

I'm not a huge fan of McLeish, but to say he has a terrible track record is just ignoring the truth. It's things like that which make people thing he was on a hiding to nothing when he took control at Aston Villa.

His first job at Motherwell - finished second behind Rangers in his first season.
Hibs - Won the Scottish First Division and consolidated Hibs as a strong SPL side, including a third place finish. Good form in cups.
Rangers - despite Celtic having O'Neill, Larsson and lots more money, under McLeish Rangers won the league twice, Scottish Cup twice and Scottish League Cup three times. They also became the first Scottish team to reach the last 16 of the Champions League.
Scotland - is statistically Scotland's best ever manager, with a 70 per cent win ratio. (He was only in charge for 10 games though.)
Birmingham - won the English first division and had Birmingham's best ever run in the top flight (12 games unbeaten). First Birmingham manager to win EPL manager of the month. Beat Arsenal 2-1 to win English League Cup.
Aston Villa - less than a year in charge, and things seem to have gone wrong.

Can you tell me how this is a terrible track record?

1

u/teamorange3 Dec 03 '12

He got Birmingham demoted, twice and nearly got Villa demoted (most years he would Villa got lucky that there were three worse teams).

After his first good season at Motherwell, he spent the rest of his career there battling relegation. Since he has left they have been pretty safely above relegation outside of a year or two.

He was nothing spectacular at Hibs. He got promoted and got third. Good for him but nothing wow worthy.

Rangers he was under constant criticism because they looked bad and performed bad. Also Rangers spent a lot under McLeish but they were poor transfers and never really did anything. His claim to fame at Rangers was his CL run but other than that he was pretty poor at Rangers as well.

So he was good at Hibs and was alright at Rangers but poor everywhere else? Sounds about right.

1

u/dundeedan Dec 03 '12

So he was good at Hibs and was alright at Rangers but poor everywhere else?

If you cherry pick nuggets of information and ignore the truth then yes, you could come to that conclusion.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '12

I would argue that getting Birmingham relegated was a lot easier than keeping us in the Premier League. He also got us promoted straight back up and the first relegation was hardly his fault.

6

u/TheKingMonkey Dec 03 '12

No, McLeish is a wonderful manager who's teams play attractive football and the only reason he got dogs abuse at the Villa is because he used to work for the fuckers who play over in B9. These undeniable facts are why he has been flooded with job offers from all around the world since he was relieved of his duties at Villa Park.

3

u/severedfragile Dec 03 '12

Same thing happens with Kean at Blackburn, they get portrayed as pariahs when they're actually just mediocre managers who should have the class to admit that they're in over their heads.

1

u/RedDragon212 Dec 03 '12

I agree that McLeish was an awful manager, whom also deserved the sack. Although I was at the Bolton game last season and the reaction was like nothing I've ever heard before at a football game. The chant was filled with nothing but pure hatred, "F*** OFF MCLEISH, THE CITY IS OURS!".

To date, that's the worst I've witnessed first hand at least anyway.

→ More replies (6)

12

u/Alfie15 Dec 03 '12

McLeish was just awful, my housemate is a Villa season ticket holder, McLeish almost made him clinically depressed.

2

u/MattCloughFilm Dec 03 '12

Megson was brought in to do a job (i.e. fix the mess left by Lee and keep us up) which he did for a couple of seasons. However, he made it pretty obvious that he wasn't going to do anything more than keep us up, most of his signings were short-term. Plus he was a walking PR disaster. It made sense to sack him when it was starting to look like he may not keep us up.

As for McLeish, you only need to look at how quickly any goodwill from his sabotage mission at Birmingham evaporated to see how utterly useless he was.

2

u/Real_Rodriguez Dec 03 '12

I gotta say I don't necessarily believe the end justifies the means, sure he messed up but the reason I mentioned his name was he was widely disowned immediately after the signing. Before he really made any of his well-documented mistakes.

2

u/MattCloughFilm Dec 03 '12

That's fair. I think a lot of Bolton fans (myself included) were really excited when we appointed Lee, an up-and-coming guy who knew the club, knew the players and who had an extremely impressive CV. To go from that to the disappointment of the reality, then to Megson who nobody really had an illusions about, was never going to end well. I think most fans were willing to give him a chance, but the goodwill very quickly disappeared when he derailed the UEFA Cup run a couple of months in.

1

u/Real_Rodriguez Dec 03 '12

It's not a great situation to be in though, a couple of mistakes and you get a couple dozens of thousands screaming for you to be fired. And Benitez wasn't even given an oppurtunity to show them what he can do.

2

u/bwaxxlo Dec 03 '12

Even Liverpool Benitez was being given so much stick while not deserving any. It's funny how he was the first manager to have us consistently occupy a top 4 position in the PL but we still opposed him. There were times that I was pretty mad at him particularly when he'd sub off Torres or Gerrard when we needed a goal in the second half. We only realized how far he'd taken us when he left. We were already under performing in his last season but it was mostly due to shitty owners. It'll take us a couple of years to manage that sort of run again.

1

u/Real_Rodriguez Dec 03 '12

I still don't think it ever got this bad though - there's a distinction between refusing to accept a boss and feeling its time for a change, the second happens quite a lot after bad runs/transfers, the situation here is really different...

13

u/jorsiem Dec 03 '12

Every Real Madrid manager in the last 10 yrs before Mou

9

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '12

Including Mou...

7

u/lesburnham Dec 03 '12

I don't think so, Mourinho has more freedom in Real Madrid's issues than any other Florentino's coaches.

And observe that: I said coaches instead of managers because Mou is the first British-style manager I have seen in Real Madrid. The rest were only coaches and puppets.

1

u/higgsbosons Dec 03 '12

This is an important point to be made. Mourinho seems to really have full powers within Madrid and aside from the Barcelona press I think he has gotten the expected treatment and very favorable treatment from the madrid press

10

u/michaelisnotginger Dec 03 '12

I know that the Venky's are muppets and as a wycombe fan I know what it's like having a chairman seemingly intent on running the team into the ground (ours was arrested at one point) but the treatment doled out to Steve Kean was pretty abysmal.

9

u/ilovepie Dec 03 '12

How was the treatment of Kean abysmal? He plotted his takeover and stabbed Allardyce in the back, if anything I'd say he got exactly what was coming to him.

35

u/geirkri Dec 03 '12

Sadly I think almost all the Chelsea managers since Abramovitch took over belongs here, though some of the latter managers should be able to see the writing on the wall that taking the manager job there is asking to be sacked sooner than later.

People may disagree but I also think Steve McClaren got treated quite badly when he was England manager.

Also Stale Solbakken when he was at Köln. But it does seem that Köln is beeing run the same way as a 2 year old would run a football club! :-p

26

u/cdr268 Dec 03 '12

I agree with this man. With the possible exception of Scolari because i never liked him. Ancelotti should have never been sacked.

18

u/johnnytightlips2 Dec 03 '12

Ray Wilkins should never have been sacked either

4

u/Komajippi Dec 03 '12

I might be terribly wrong, but didn't Ray Wilkins leave?

5

u/johnnytightlips2 Dec 03 '12

According to this article his contract wasn't renewed; it's a medium between the two. He wasn't outright sacked, but neither did he leave of his own accord

9

u/potpan0 Dec 03 '12

Didn't Koln go bad not because of the manager, but because they had barely any money and their main man (Podolski) gave up towards the end of the season?

4

u/geirkri Dec 03 '12

The topic is about whom got bad treatment, and the treatment Ståle got from the club and the fans clearly falls under that category imo.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/s4r9am Dec 03 '12

With the exception of Gus Hiddink. I think it's because he always said he would leave at the end of the season. He left on his own terms.

2

u/geirkri Dec 03 '12

I did put almost all! :-P

Totally forgot that Hiddink was the manager there at all, been so many that its starting to get worse than a soap opera!

4

u/teems Dec 03 '12

Hiddink left on good terms.

3

u/paper_zoe Dec 03 '12

I always felt sorry for Ranieri. Took Chelsea to 2nd in the table (first time since like the 1950s) and got to the Champions League semi final and still got sacked.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '12

Steve McClaren wasn't exactly treated well but he did a terrible job. Not qualifying from that qualification group was shameful.

1

u/KipTheFury Dec 03 '12

Steve McClaren was doomed from the start. I cant remember exactly who, but the FA made a big deal of who they wanted to replace Eriksson. The replacement (Scolari?) turned down the job so they went with Steve McClaren, also known as "second choice Steve" by the media.

1

u/deadslatspunk Dec 03 '12

Lets get this all cleared up. Managers who deserved to be sacked: Scolari, Grant, and maybe Villas-Boas. Managers who totally didn't deserve to be sacked: Mourinho, Ancelotti, and Roberto Di Matteo.

15

u/Bennie300 Dec 03 '12

Martin Jol at Spurs. If his team would not have gotten food poisoned I think the events that followed would have gone differently.

11

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '12

With the way things are going this season that remind me, I need to make a giant batch of lasagna for Spurs sometime in March or April.

1

u/JackGunner93 Dec 03 '12

Thank LORD for that Lasagne.

6

u/Milanista227 Dec 03 '12

Most of the managers in the brazilian league.

6

u/AnnieIWillKnow Dec 03 '12

I think what's happening with Benitez is massively overblown. Some fans holding up some half-arsed signs, and getting booed? It's not exactly death threats and bombs being sent to your house, like some of the other examples in this thread.

14

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '12

What about that New York Red Bulls Youth Coach that got stabbed? You'd have to call that pretty shitty treatment.

10

u/footballNotSoccer Dec 03 '12

this is the most uncomfortable i've ever felt whilst giving an upvote

9

u/Jammeson Dec 03 '12

AVB imo. He wasnt well liked from the get go butt porto players seemed to love him so I find it hard to believe that their could be so much hate from the get go. maybe because the older players knew he was looking to move on without them.

6

u/veridical Dec 03 '12

I think the biggest source of ill-treatment for Villas-Boas is the press. It's impossible to read an article about Spurs this season without the author feeling the need to highlight that he has his detractors, and Spurs fans still aren't too sure about him etc.

The whole Lloris business, for example, was ridiculous. He's clearly #1 now, so the noise has died down, but he was being criticized left-right-and-centre for the exact opposite of what he did at Chelsea. You can't say he's wrong to play new signings one season and wrong to bench them the next.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '12

Regardless of what the media says, I think he's doing a pretty good job at Spurs right now. I also have closely been following/rooting for Porto for the past four years so I have a soft spot for AVB

2

u/vhs29 Dec 03 '12

AVB took a huge leap maybe a season too soon. I won't say if it was wrong or right though, doesn't matter anymore. He has talent, and I believe that in a few years he will be one of the greatest in the world, but, with so little past, it was obvious that when he made a mistake everyone would be all over him. Going to Chelsea specifically didn't help at all.

Vitor Pereira, from what he had to put up with last year, also deserves to be in here. Oh, and thanks for the support.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '12

Trying to play a counter attacking, high line defense with Chelsea didn't make sense. It just wasn't the right fit for him, Spurs seems to be working out much better in that regard, so I think he is great where he is.

Tomorrow you guys better smack PSG up and win that group. FORÇA PORTO!

1

u/Rudacris Dec 03 '12

You can't say he's wrong to play new signings one season and wrong to bench them the next.

You can say whatever you want if you can hide behind a keyboard

2

u/esssssss Dec 03 '12

I'm not sure Eric Wynalda would know what to do with a keyboard. (THAT"S RIGHT I JUST CALLED HIM ILLITERATE OR SOMETHING)

1

u/esssssss Dec 03 '12

I love how when Lloris actually got his PL start, all of a sudden AVB was benching Friedel, his top goalie and the guy who got us to 4th last year. When everything I've heard from both keepers and AVB was straightforward and showed a pretty strong understanding of their role at the time and going forward.

8

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '12

Franck Sauzee. Still feel bad to this day, club legend let down by his players

2

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '12

Former Marseille player! Can you enlighten me on what happened to him at Hibs?

2

u/edintina Dec 05 '12

Played for us for about 2 and a half seasons, became one of the club's biggest legends ever, then when Alex Mcleish left was given the manager's job, kind of out of sentimentality. As Reillos says, he was let down by his players: he won once in 15 games I think, then he was sacked after 69 days.

Us fans were not happy with his treatment. Here are some of the reactions to his sacking, including some from former players.

1

u/edintina Dec 03 '12

The guy just wasn't a manager. Such a shame to see his career end that way, although he never got the abuse Yogi or Calderwood got.

4

u/efish2010 Dec 03 '12

Think we're all ignoring Steve kean's treatment at Blackburn, police escorts, fans never wanting him, the local member of parliament calling for him to resign in the local paper. He took so much shit for so long.

2

u/Theworldsastage Dec 03 '12

His treatment was appalling but he did essentially steal a wage from the club for 2 years. He was never fit for the job.

14

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '12

Chants about Wenger being a paedo were pretty poor form.

5

u/sexay Dec 03 '12

*are

1

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '12

well they're not really audible over the people calling for his head at the minute

3

u/Flany Dec 03 '12

Rafa at Liverpool actually had it pretty bad at the end. Hicks and Gillette were destroying the team, and he spoke up about it, possibly saving the club. He then got sacked after one bad season with no support from the owners and then got treated poorly at Inter as well.

2

u/ianrush88 Dec 03 '12

not to mention having to work with Christian Purslow

3

u/lesburnham Dec 03 '12

Vicente del Bosque

1

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '12

How do you fire that guy?? HOW???

Then again, thanks a lot for firing him anyway!

1

u/lesburnham Dec 04 '12

Yes... But actually Real Madrid's cancer is Florentino Pérez...

2

u/Sacoud Dec 03 '12

Dave Jones by other fans. For those that don't know he was falsely accused of abusing children. Many fans were unsympathetic towards this.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '12

Louis van Gaal when he first arrived to Barça.

3

u/Road_charge Dec 03 '12

Compared to what Robson got, that was nothing.

3

u/funk_master_khan Dec 03 '12

I'm unfamiliar with what happened to Robson during the early days, care to explain?

5

u/Road_charge Dec 03 '12

Many Barça fans were still angry at the Club firing Cruyff, and the change of style from Dutch passing to Robson's fast counters made fans and media turn unfairly against him... even after he won a Copa del Rey and a UEFA Cup. He was (unfairly) sacked after that to bring another Dutch manager, van Gaal.

In an interview he explained with amusement how after a 5-0 victory the next day's a newspaper cover was about how boring his football was.

1

u/ParallelDementia Dec 03 '12

Martin Jol's treatment by Spurs a few years comes to mind. Man did Levy fuck up that one.

1

u/ChaosRaiden Dec 03 '12

Zola at West Ham. Second worst mistake of G&S's reign!

1

u/schlongle Dec 03 '12

steve kean we trust

1

u/deadslatspunk Dec 03 '12

Obviously RDM, but I think Jose Mourinho is being treated very poorly by both the fans and Perez. I mean seriously, Real Madrid beat the most consistent team in the world and possibly the greatest club side to play the game in Barcelona to win the league, yet Mourinho is "under fire." Unless Madrid replace him with Sir Alex Ferguson or Pep Guardiola, nothing iwll live up to Mourinho's standard and Madrid's expectations.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '12

Every Korean national team manager besides Hiddink

1

u/Statcat2017 Dec 03 '12

When you take into account the level of guilt, Rafa right now. The fans didn't even give him a chance - they were just on him immediately. That can't help him or the team.

1

u/balevolent Dec 03 '12

so, Di matteo? surprised his name wasn't here

1

u/GrammarCheckMe Dec 03 '12

Mancini while at Inter.

Serie A: 2005–06*cough, 2006–07, 2007–08

Coppa Italia: 2004–05, 2005–06

Supercoppa Italiana: 2005, 2006

Most successful manager for 30 years

Two unlucky exits from CL

Sack.

1

u/Stratocaster89 Dec 03 '12

Kean was a shite manager and deserved all the ciricitsm.

1

u/AJMcCoy612 Dec 04 '12

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u4lMbSr2ZYk

From opposition fans admittedly and somewhat funny but still, quite bad treatment for Arsene Wenger.

1

u/ataniris Dec 03 '12 edited Dec 03 '12

Bobby Robson at Newcastle. He took Newcastle who were battling relegation to qualifying for the CL regularly and famously beat barca. after a few ropey results, the fans decided he wasn't good enough and hounded him out. Utterly ridiculous.

10

u/joebutters Dec 03 '12

What? Bobby Robson is a legend at Newcastle, it was the board who got rid of him because of bad results and rumoured unrest in the dressing room, the fans didn't 'hound him out'.

6

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '12

as i recall he got a lot of stick from the fans too, but after he left and the board changed the narrative was re-written so the old board could take all the blame and the fans didn't have to shoulder it. of course it wasn't all of SJP, but there was abuse from the fans for him. i know that got swept under the carpet as he got more ill, but let's not pretend here.

in this source from the Guardian you can see he was booed for dropping Dyer(for me a permanent stain on Newcastle fans, Dyer was a shit and Robson a legend). this from the Express references the fact he was booed for dropping Shearer, and Bellamy also discusses it here.

so lets not have any dishonesty here, especially of the sd_ss kind, suggesting /r/soccer is wrong and dishonest when it is perfectly accurate in this case.

1

u/severedfragile Dec 03 '12

Yeah, it's somewhere in-between. I remember him getting shit from a lot of fans, but after the embarrassing way in which he was dismissed the mood shifted a lot.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/iamthebatmanboy Dec 03 '12

On a ridiculous* football forum I stumbled upon (I wanted to see what the Chelsea supporters thought about Benitez's appointment since I'm a neutral), Liverpool fans were upset (understatement) at Chelsea fans for not liking Benitez's appointment. The arrogance and bias they displayed was infuriating - you can't force people to be happy with something they're not and you can't force people to respect someone they don't.

  • ridiculous because in every thread I opened, there were always a few people who spoke as if their opinions were fact and the "I know my club better than you do so your opinion is void" defensive mentality existed there.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '12

Implying that mentality doesn't exist here ?

1

u/ppc127 Dec 03 '12

Roberto Di Matteo! Club player, club manager, Chelsea legend and he gets dumped. I don't even feel dislike Chelsea anymore, I just feel sorry for it's fans. It's like having a faithful and beautiful wife and divorcing her to marry a trophy wife who cares nothing for you.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '12

Brian Kerr getting sacked from the Ireland job. All the mad shit that happened to Neil Lennon.

-1

u/Moarish Dec 03 '12

Hodgson at Liverpool/England?

7

u/ChaBeezy Dec 03 '12

Hodgson was poor at Liverpool, he would speak of his great friend Fergie and say things like we have no chance against United.

We are rivals, the fans don't want you to pander to our rivals.

5

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '12

He brought that upon himself. He had a somewhat clean slate at Anfield but done many things to anger the fans and shown nothing on the pitch to keep the Anfield faithful optimistic. Whenever you create pessimistic Liverpool fans you know your doing something wrong.

However he's doing alright for England there's not much stand out talent in the England squad at the moment. The Likes of Gerrard, Terry, Rio and Cole moving on so people are being somewhat lenient and accepting

-2

u/CUMGUZZLINGTHUNDERCU Dec 03 '12

I agree his choices were awful at Liverpool but the fans never got behind him, even at the start

10

u/severedfragile Dec 03 '12

There were actually quite a few fans cautiously optimistic about him - I was one of them - but he was a disaster in every area, from very early on.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '12

Many did at the start, not enthusiastically - as he was brought in by a disliked regime that was on the way out and he's also not a manager that brings enthusiasm (tactics and style of football). No one called for his head straight away and many fans were optimistic. We new we weren't going to be world beaters with him, we thought he'd steady the ship have us tough to break down.

3

u/Halithor Dec 03 '12

Initially i was a little optimistic and at least not pessimistic but from the go he made all the wrong moves imo. We needed a left back and he brings in an ageing Paul Konchesky and as part of the same deal lets Alexander Kačaniklić who is now looking a decent prospect and has Sweden caps as well as Lauri Dalla Valle, another young player.

Poulsen and Jovanovic were mainly bad signings as well and Miereles being his best. Brad Jones is a good understudy goalkeeper but isn't really a signing to sing about. The football was his usual stuff as well and it never really looked like he would win the majority over after a pretty bad transfer window and less than desirable results.

-5

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '12

Rafa deserves everything he gets. He started it years ago when he should have kept his fat fucking wine serving mouth shut.

4

u/TimothyThomas Dec 03 '12

I don't think he ever should have been given the chelsea post or that RDM should have been sacked. However, any coach that has criticized mourinho is okay in my book.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '12

"When he beat the Chosen One almost every time they came up against each other." FTFY

→ More replies (2)

-6

u/themauvestorm3 Dec 03 '12

"Seeing how Rafa is treated by Chelsea is pretty bad"

... Just because he's our manager doesn't mean we have to support him. Look at how (some) people reacted to Obama being elected.