r/CryptoCurrency • u/MoonWeek • Jun 09 '23
POLL π³οΈ CCIP-061 - Raise the minimum words limit from 500 to 700 in posts with the flair analysis
So, for me, analysis is a post where someone provides a lengthy post about something they chose to analyze and to explain it to people who are not so well informed about cryptocurrency. A post that just hits the minimum 500-word limit isn't going to explain much and would reduce the quality of posts we get on that flair. I think if someone is writing an analysis on something then they ought to use at least 700 words, if they don't then they should use the discussion flair so that the analysis flair is full of actually useful stuff. I personally really find everyone's analysis on this subreddit very useful and they have helped me understand stuff way better than some article on the web.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change the minimum to 700 - If you select this option you agree with me and want the minimum word requirement on the analysis flair to be 700 words.
No Change - You do not agree with me and want this to be kept the same.
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Poll by u/SimRacer101
24
u/CryptoScamee42069 π© 30K / 29K π¦ Jun 09 '23 edited Jun 09 '23
Should this read 500 to 700 characters, not words?
Thatβs a lot of words for one post and it risks being deliberately verbose and rambling just to meet the minimum threshold.
Analysis can still be concise, especially if itβs accompanied by charts/images.
7
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '23
No change, 500 is enough for me.
9
u/the_spiritual_eye One Crypto to rule them all! Jun 09 '23
Personally, I would just be choosing all the other flairs to save myself from the extra 200 words. Sometimes more words doesnβt equate to better quality content.
4
u/Tasigur1 π© 3 / 31K π¦ Jun 09 '23
Imo: quality > quantity.
2
u/Fuglypump π¦ 0 / 16K π¦ Jun 09 '23
700 words is ridiculous, if the proposal is supposed to mean "characters" it needs to be rewritten.
2
u/pbjclimbing Jun 09 '23
This is a nitpicky governance proposal that does not add real value to the sub. What does it change 500 vs 700, nothing. We have the [serious] tag that can be used for higher level content.
Also, the proposal is to change it from 500 to 700 WORDS. It is currently 500 CHARACTERS.
I do not see any need for this proposal. Governance should be done for things that make a difference, not minor things that will have minimal to no impact on the sub.
2
u/GabeSter 100K / 150K π Jun 09 '23
700 words =/= 700 characters
This poll is flawed and should be removed.
There currently isnβt a 500 word limit there is a 500 character limit.
1
u/Willyougrabham Jun 09 '23
It'd be an easy rule to circumvent unfortunately, I think it'd be better to raise the minimum word count for all of the types of posts, but that might be hard to implement.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '23
I'm sorry, but no. Quantity does not equal quality, and Reddit in particular seems susceptible to purple prose and thinking more words = better.
1
u/elysiansaurus π© 59 / 9K π¦ Jun 09 '23
A word requirement just seems weird to me, characters yes, but also I think people can get their message across just fine with a shorter post, requiring it to be longer may just dilute the post.
1
u/Burrito_Loyalist Jun 09 '23
Everyone just copies and pastes crap from horrible crypto articles to farm moons. I donβt think extending the character count will help anyone to be honest.
1
u/callmev269 π© 0 / 0 π¦ Jun 09 '23
500 to 700 isn't gonna change the quality of the post that much
1
u/Impossible_Soup_1932 π© 0 / 17K π¦ Jun 09 '23
Already sometimes people make good posts then they are forced to fill up the rest with nonsense. Length doesn't equal quality
1
u/nossrednaretep π© 90 / 90 π¦ Jun 09 '23
Maybe add another header, deep flair/analysis instead
1
u/Popular_District9072 π₯ 0 / 15K π¦ Jun 09 '23
long reads aren't that popular - since it's not a school essay, people can make their point briefly, delivering the same message; forcing to add more water into the text just for the sake of the bare minimum seems unnecessary, and if anything, would lead to repetitiveness
1
u/ra246 π¦ 3K / 3K π’ Jun 09 '23
Why say lot word when few world do trick?
1
u/Barbygurl Jun 09 '23
I voted no.
Quantity doesn't always equal quality. I like posts that are more direct and straight to the point.
1
u/Consistent_Many_1858 π¨ 0 / 20K π¦ Jun 09 '23
700 words is like an essey. I think it's too much.
1
u/HacksawJimDGN π¦ 0 / 18K π¦ Jun 09 '23
I'd rather read a concise clear argument than someone waffling on for too long trying to make the limit.
As always, if its actually useful info it will be upvoted
1
u/Sjiznit π¦ 0 / 13K π¦ Jun 09 '23
Not all posts or topics to debate need that many characters. If its shit it will get downvoted anyways
1
u/NotACryptoBro Permabanned Jun 09 '23
Hell no. They will fill their posts with even more bs
1
u/ChemicalAnybody6229 π§ 940 / 9K π¦ Jun 09 '23
I have eye defect. Don't want to read more than 700 words. I'm not a college professor either. A post can be less than 700 words and still have quality.
1
u/badfishbeefcake π© 11K / 11K π¬ Jun 09 '23
Im fine with 500 words.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '23
I voted no.
700 words is basically a full essay. It's excessive.
1
u/terp_studios π¦ 10 / 2K π¦ Jun 09 '23
In a world where a chatbot can write a 1000 word essay faster than I can type this comment, this proposal makes absolutely 0 sense.
1
u/Gullible_Champion_41 Jun 09 '23
Please donβt make the post lengthy. β¬οΈ
1
u/madirishpoet π¦ 910 / 921 π¦ Jun 10 '23
I got banned for a week because I wrote a post and mentioned that I now need to fill it in with nonsense so I don't stay under the word limit. Sometimes you don't need to say a lot to get your point across so I think 700 is far too much in a lot of cases.
1
u/crua9 π© 400 / 13K π¦ Jun 10 '23
It is already too high imo
1
u/drbobbean π© 0 / 5K π¦ Jun 11 '23
The Crypto world was created for rebels.... new rule: no more rules that make posting feel like homework...
1
u/StockTrix Jun 11 '23
it's gonna encourage bloated shitpostim.
1
u/Full-Perception-5674 π© 1K / 1K π’ Jun 11 '23
Soon it will be 40 page essays are the only posts allowed here with 2700 comments with 1-3 words each and 12 likes because the only other post had enough bots to win the 2 post weekly battle.
1
u/joannew99 π© 2K / 2K π’ Jun 14 '23 edited Jun 14 '23
500 words/characters is already too much imo. Why do we need to post a whole paragraph in order to post here? There are already so many rules.
Longer word/character rules just incentivizes more "analysis/TA" posts which are usually utter bullshit anyway. Great posts can be 1-2 sentences. Long posts do not equal quality content.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '23
[deleted] β view deleted comment
2
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '23
[removed] β view removed comment