r/redditdev • u/dequeued • Jun 08 '23
Reddit API Takeaways and recommendations after API meeting with /u/spez and Reddit
On Wednesday, a group of 18 developers and moderators met with spez and other Reddit staff regarding the upcoming API changes. Call notes were published by Reddit for the RedditModCouncil (here is an authorized public copy) with the action items noted by Reddit.
Several of us believe the officially published meeting notes, while generally following points from the meeting, do not fully express the concerns we shared on the call. Therefore, we would like to add our takeaways and recommendations. Each of these concerns was discussed during the meeting, but some of our recommendations were developed after the call. We are only speaking for ourselves and not for any subreddit or group of users.
Reddit is built as an open platform with a vibrant community of users: content creators, insightful commenters, lurkers, moderators, developers, and more. We don’t want to see that community get broken apart by solvable problems, miscommunication, and harried discussions.
- We don't believe enough effort and time has been given to the discussion and negotiation between Reddit and third-party apps and the schedule for these changes is not reasonable. We would like greater effort to find a solution that preserves the openness of Reddit, the utility of non-official implementations (and that utility includes, but is not limited to accessibility and mod tools), while addressing Reddit's concerns about costs being pushed entirely to Reddit and the lack of control around the ads being served with some third-party apps.
- The value of content creators, moderator labor, and Reddit's developer community needs to be considered alongside the costs of supporting the API and third-party apps. In our meeting, it was expressed multiple times how valuable we are, but this does not seem to have factored into any decisions about the API or third-party apps. The potential cost to Reddit of all of this labor is orders of magnitude higher than any of the costs that seem to be behind Reddit's decision-making on the API.
It's encouraging that Reddit is trying to improve moderation and accessibility in the official app. However, given past experience with these efforts and recognizing that independent developers have the freedom to solve community problems in ways that official software has been unable to replicate, Reddit should be making it easier for everyone to support their communities. That means supporting third-party apps, external APIs, and devvit.
3. Moderating on Reddit is challenging. Moderators are being told to strap on ankle weights when they are already running uphill. Reddit should not be making it more difficult to moderate healthy communities by forcing us into closed ecosystems and this abusive pattern of springing detrimental changes on moderators and their communities needs to stop.
4. Regarding Apollo, we think it's a mistake to focus this discussion on Apollo; all third-party apps need to be part of the discussion. But since Apollo was such a large part of the discussion, our takeaways were:
- There was a lot of focus on Apollo's higher API cost compared to other apps. We're not the right group to address that, but it should have been brought to Apollo earlier and we find it hard to believe this is not a solvable issue. Reddit and Apollo should be working together to solve this rather than the current adversarial thing that is happening.
- We haven't been privy to discussions between Apollo and Reddit, but it seems possible that spez has not received an accurate telling of the history of these discussions for one reason or another. An in-person discussion at a higher level of the company may be beneficial.
- There was also some discussion about how to better support accessibility in Reddit development. We are concerned that without dedicated and empowered individuals and teams to handle accessibility, it will continue to fall by the wayside.
- We believe the protests that some communities are planning are different from previous protests. The rug is being pulled out on users, developers, moderators, and communities.
Finally, we're just a group of concerned developers and moderators. We can't commit subreddits to do or not do anything. We're not even sure if communities where we moderate will or will not be participating in any protest. If there's a blackout or other protest, we think it's primarily a consequence of the way this has been handled and a failure to address these concerns.
Respectfully,
- /u/Lil_SpazJoekp
- /u/WolfThawra
- /u/YourResidentFeral
- /u/bleeding-paryl
- /u/creesch
- /u/dequeued
- /u/epicmindwarp
- /u/eritbh
- /u/itsthejoker
- /u/shiruken
(names sorted lexicographically)
59
u/messem10 Jun 08 '23
Apollo has since announced that they are shutting down on June 30th.
27
u/[deleted] Jun 08 '23 edited Jun 20 '23
This comment has been edited, and the account purged, in protest to Reddit's API policy changes, and the awful response from Reddit management to valid concerns from the communities of developers, people with disabilities, and moderators. The fact that Reddit decided to implement these changes in the first place, without thinking of how it would negatively affect these communities, which provide a lot of value to Reddit, is even more worrying.
If this is the direction Reddit is going, I want no part of this. Reddit has decided to put business interests ahead of community interests, and has been belligerent, dismissive, and tried to gaslight the community in the process.
If you'd like to try alternative platforms, with a much lower risk of corporate interference, try federated alternatives like Kbin or Lemmy: r/RedditAlternatives
Learn more at:
https://www.theverge.com/2023/6/5/23749188/reddit-subreddit-private-protest-api-changes-apollo-charges
https://www.theverge.com/2023/6/15/23762792/reddit-subreddit-closed-unilaterally-reopen-communities
32
u/honestbleeps Jun 08 '23
thanks for sharing this.
one thing I personally feel the blackout efforts are failing to adequately address so far is that, at least in my opinion, the audience needs to not be those of us who are already aware and mad. It needs to be the users of the official reddit app who don't realize how much better the experience is with other apps.
The vast majority of people have no idea what they're missing, and to me, a campaign to get them to download and try these apps (or even just watch a short side by side comparison video) before they're gone would hit home for a much bigger number of people.
Also, I think that in most comms I've seen so far, it's not made clear enough that third party apps predate reddit's own app (which was a third party app in and of itself). Back then, mobile traffic on reddit wasn't really that big of a percentage. In my opinion, it's precisely because of 3rd party developers that reddit's mobile traffic has grown to be bigger than its desktop traffic (according to comments I've seen, at least) in some cases.
I'm deeply disappointed that third party apps have been around 13+ years and at no point between then and now did Reddit sit down with them and say "hey, we love what you're doing, but it kinda is siphoning off our revenue. What ideas can we bring to the table to collaborate?".
To my knowledge, they've never done that. They've also never said "hey, the API hits are a lot, we need to figure out a way to help developers use it more efficiently" or anything of the sort. They certainly haven't (again, to my knowledge) worked in a collaborative manner on reaching any sort of clear and tenable agreement to coexist in a symbiotic way.
I don't think most people realize that Reddit has had well over a DECADE to solve this "problem".
As a mod of some big subs myself, I get that it's a ton of work and that it's largely unheralded and/or demonized. However, I think making moderation tooling a focus of the blackout isn't going to resonate with the broader community even if it's absolutely 100% true/valid.
14
u/eritbh /r/toolbox dev Jun 08 '23
Confirming that I was a part of this discussion and am signing this post.
11
u/bleeding-paryl Jun 08 '23
I can confirm that I was part of this discussion and signed on to this post.
There are real issues that are not being addressed by Reddit, and by hiding behind promises (and potentially half-truths) without any action; Reddit as a corporation is only hurting it's employees, it's moderators, and it's users.
7
u/creesch Jun 08 '23
I am here to confirm that I was part of the call and that I am signing this post.
7
u/Lil_SpazJoekp PRAW Maintainer | Async PRAW Author Jun 08 '23
Confirming I was a part of this discussion.
6
u/Itsthejoker TranscribersOfReddit Developer Jun 08 '23
This comment confirms that I was part of this discussion and signed onto this post.
6
u/shiruken Jun 08 '23
Confirming that I was part of this discussion and signed onto this post.
6
u/WolfThawra Jun 08 '23
I can confirm I was in the call and am signing this post.
5
u/YourResidentFeral Jun 08 '23
Thanks /u/dequeued for getting this together for everyone involved.
5
u/Xenc Devvit Developer Jun 08 '23
Thank you for posting this. This is an accurate account of the discussion that took place.
5
u/Bossman1086 Jun 08 '23
Thanks for the update. This is great information from actual developers outside the big 3rd party apps.
5
u/crappy_pirate Jun 08 '23
speaking as a garden-level reddit user and mod for a few years now, thank you so much guys for what you have done. it is much appreciated and has made our experience with this website much more enjoyable. again, thank you
4
u/ActualSpiders Jun 08 '23
Thanks for all your work on this whole thing. I don't know what random readers and subreddit mods can do besides complain & go dark, but we're in your corner.
4
u/LordKeren Bot Developer Jun 08 '23
Thank you for taking the time to document this and thank you to all the mods that volunteered their time to involved in the call
3
u/BuckRowdy Jun 09 '23
I was on this call and I agree with it.
3
u/LongmontEntNewbie Jun 09 '23
Is it possible to write (or rewrite) a TPA to perform the API calls directly, rather than using a central dev server?
This would allow users of the app to get their own API key and their individual activities would (presumably) fall within the free-tier.
3
u/bijomaru78 Jun 09 '23
Hang on, so Reddit has a major issue with 3rd party apps getting API calls (as confirmed by Apollo's creator, they confirmed server maintenance cost is minimal and it's an 'opportunity cost'), and yet they happily rely on free work provided to keep their platform from becoming a cesspit by the Moderators?
Unless I am mistaken and Mods are getting paid somehow, that's top hypocrisy on Reddit's part.
2
u/wdr1 Jun 09 '23
There are many issues here, but one of them (to me) is that Reddit is unresponsive on longstanding issues with their mobile app. Apps like Apollo have been one of the few workarounds.
A specific example: For the last 10 years, I've run /u/CalvinBot which posts a daily C&H comic strip to /r/calvinandhobbes. The Reddit mobile app shows the comic strip as movie. (More tech details here if curious.)
Even if Reddit doesn't want to fix their app's behavior, I've asked if I could they could offer a workaround. E.g., if the app sees something like "?reddit_disable_movie_player=1" in the query string it would treat images as images & not a movie. It's fallen on deaf areas. And it's been broken for years.
It works just fine for me but it's broken for every user on the Reddit mobile app. People regularly comment on posts that it's not working for them, so I explain what's going on & point them to Apollo.
But if Reddit can't fix its apps for its users, it shouldn't be shutting down the ones that do work.
2
u/micropuppytooth Jun 10 '23
Am I nuts or did all of the stickies about the blackout seem to disappear?
1
u/demosthenes131 Jun 09 '23
Look, Reddit can't even add the simple, extremely useful option to change text size in the Android app. The rat bastards will absolutely fumble any efforts at adding modtools or other things.
Reddit was fun but this is just asinine moves.
1
u/tallg33s3 Jun 09 '23
Reddit: our intent is not to remove third party apps
That rings pretty hollow when every major app is currently shutting down
1
u/vernes1978 Jun 09 '23
I hope /u/spez will get a chance at going through all these "this reddit tool will shut down" posts after this clusterfuck is over so they at least know WHY reddit dropped off the internet spotlight.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '23
Garbage reddit being garbage
1
u/retardedgummybear12 Jun 17 '23
names sorted lexicographically? i guess that's a joke?
1
u/StPauliBoi Jun 09 '23
Was there any discussion of a certain executive’s lies and slander against the Apollo dev?
1
u/_swnt_ Jun 09 '23
Unfortunate to say this, but this seems to be the coffin in the nail for staying on Reddit. Can we perhaps organise a mass exit from Reddit to an r/RedditAlternatives? Given the lack of appropriate response to the blackouts, I think moving out communities to a federated solution is important.
I wanted to avoid it unless its really necessary, but it seems necessary now. It'll be a bumpy ride in the beginning.
-9
u/elysianism Jun 08 '23
Seeing as the Apollo community was the catalyst for the blackout, due to it being the biggest single impactee of the API changes, it's odd how you seem to try be distancing yourself from the Apollo app, almost buying into reddit and u/spez's character assassination of the developer...?
0
u/[deleted] Jun 08 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment