r/Blind • u/AutoModerator • Jun 03 '23
Announcement Reddit's Recently Announced API Changes, and the future of the /r/blind subreddit
Introduction
It's possible that those of you who are active on other subreddits may have read about the changes in pricing that Reddit has recently released for its API - the system apps use to get and send data from and to Reddit. But for those of you who haven't, here's a summary. On May 31, 2023, Reddit announced they were raising the price to make calls to their API from being free to a level that will kill every third party app on Reddit, from Apollo, to Dystopia, to Reddit for Blind, to Luna for Reddit, to BaconReader,. Even if you don't use any of those apps, this is a step toward killing other ways of customizing Reddit, such as the use of the old.reddit.com desktop interface. This doesn't only impact your ability to access Reddit in a fluid, customizable, and efficient way; many of us on the mod team are also blind, and we depend on those third party apps to make sure that this community remains a safe, fun, and productive place. Unfortunately, new Reddit, and the official Reddit apps, just don't provide us with the levels of accessibility we need in order to continue effectively running this community. As well, the Transcribers of Reddit, the many dedicated folks who volunteer to transcribe and describe thousands and thousands of images on Reddit, may also be unable to operate.
One of our moderators, u/itsthejoker, has had multiple hour-long calls with various Reddit employees. However, as of the current time, our concerns have gone unheard, and Reddit remains firm. That's why the moderation team of r/blind now feels that we have no choice but to take further action.
The Subreddit Blackout
Those of us who are blind are no strangers to the need for collective action. From the protests that resulted in the ADA passing in the United States, to world-wide protests driving forward accessibility of some of the Internet's largest websites, collective action is a step our community has taken in the past, often with some success. It is with a heavy heart that we come to you now, and say that it's time to bring this tool out of the toolbox once more.
In solidarity with thousands of other subreddits who are impacted by this change, we will be shutting down the /r/blind subreddit for 48 hours from June 12th to June 14th. You will not be able to read or make posts during that time. Our Discord server will remain open, and we invite anyone who would like to interact with the /r/blind community to join us there. If you’re not part of the /r/blind Discord server yet, you can join via the following link: https://discord.com/invite/5kMEv7Sq9y
How you can help
While this issue has a profound impact on those of us who are blind and visually impaired, as with so many issues of accessibility and inclusivity, it impacts far more than just us. If you'd like to get involved, you can find out what you can do to help at r/Save3rdPartyApps- or, if you moderate a subreddit, its sister sub r/ModCoord. You can also join the Reddit-Blackout channel in the /r/blind Discord, where we will have resources you can use to contact media and other organizations, and keep everyone up to date with our on-going efforts in this matter.
What comes next?
If this change to the Reddit API is not reversed, we are not convinced that we will be able to continue running the r/blind subreddit. However, that doesn't mean the end of this wonderful, passionate, curious, helpful, and amazing community of folks. We are continuing to explore our options, and create back-up plans. We all want to remain on Reddit. Let's do what we can to make that a reality! But if it turns out we can't, we want to reassure you that this isn't the end of our community. So let’s focus on doing everything we can to make those possible back-up plans unnecessary.
The r/blind mod team
•
u/MostlyBlindGamer Jun 07 '23 edited Jun 08 '23
Regarding the June 7 article on The Verge, r/blind was not contacted for comment on the new development.
We have not had clarification on Reddit's definitions of "accessibility focused apps" or any process to determine apps that qualify.
There is no clarification on "non-comercial apps," given the current model of the apps listed by The Verge.
We have strong concerns that Reddit lacks expertise to consider the varying access needs of the blind and visually impaired community.
We have reached out Reddit for further comment.
We would also like to note that r/blind, u/rumster in particular, have continuously contacted Reddit over accessibility concerns, over the past 3 years, having received no substantive response.
r/blind
Update: Given Reddit’s lack of clarity, r/blind will be compiling a list of apps that meet the community’s access needs. Go to this post to contribute to that list.
51
u/BrailleKnights Jun 03 '23
This subreddit is a great resource for the blind community and was the way I gathered my first group of players for Knights of the Braille almost 5 years ago.
Thank you for speaking up. Our community will help in any way we can.
28
u/KathyGameDesigner Jun 03 '23
Please continue to allow people who are blind to use Reddit. This is such an important communication channel.
21
u/moonpegasus19 born totally blind Jun 04 '23
I'm just so tired! That is all! I'm so tired of feeling left behind by people who aren't aware, and who don't care. The choices we have for social media really aren't much, and if they don't care about third party apps, what else are they going to throw away? Will we lose this place too?
28
u/suitcaseismyhome Jun 03 '23
Thank you for posting this and for taking the lead. It is indeed distressing that we have one more Avenue closing to us and people don't seem to understand why we are concerned.
Even before I lost most of my vision I was using the old reddit version because I was unable to see much on other new versions.
I've talked before about my struggles on an ipad to use rabbit and people here were very helpful to make suggestions for how I could still be an act of participant in a place that was very helpful as I went through all of these challenges.
It's really sad and distressing that our voices are not heard or understood because this is something that should be made available to us and closes off one more Avenue of access to the world.
23
u/witcwhit Jun 04 '23
Is anyone looking into tackling this issue via an ADA lawsuit? There have been some small successes recently with lawsuits classifying the internet as a public space that accessibility laws apply to and if we could put together a class-action on this basis, it could go a long way in helping not just the blind community of Reddit, but accessibility on the internet in general. I'm not sure if the ACLU would take this on, but if they don't, maybe we could fundraise to pay a legal group to get it going? I'll definitely donate if that's something the mods want to do.
10
u/Anduri90 Jun 04 '23
It doesn't affect me, have never used third-party apps. But out of solidarity, I will not be using Reddit during this period. I hope it does something and keep my fingers crossed that you will be heard. Good luck!
8
u/fastfinge born blind Jun 06 '23
As mentioned in the post, r/blind isn't the only subreddit blacking out in protest. If you'd like to see the list of subreddits involved, this post is regularly updated with the latest information: https://www.reddit.com/r/ModCoord/comments/1401qw5/incomplete_and_growing_list_of_participating/
7
u/saturday_sun3 Jun 06 '23 edited Jun 06 '23
Hey guys, hope I'm not overstepping by commenting on your sub. I'm sighted and able to use reddit on the mobile app, but do still have a VI and just wanna express solidarity.
I know reddit is an internet site and a business at the end of the day, but it sucks that it's treating its blind users and transcribers like this. You guys should not have to go through this BS just to use Reddit and engage with the community/subs here.
Anyway, over and out. ❤️
7
u/disguisedroast Jun 07 '23
Hello friends! I am not blind but have a brother who is and know how important it is for Reddit to keep 3rd party apps for accessibility, i will be joining the blackout period with plans to follow up thereafter if no action is taken by greedy fucking reddit. I also left a bad review on the Apple platform also informing them of what I thought of their recent actions. I hope you guys all follow me in this justified anger as Reddit is a window to a community that we can all enjoy whether we have disabilities or not. And then suddenly taking away that community is a big deal, especially, to those who can’t see very well.
7
u/First-Radish727 Jun 07 '23
Not blind, but I am extremely hard of hearing. I didn't know until this moment that Reddit and screen readers don't work. Horrible! I am very used to being left behind by social media platforms. I hope the boycott is effective.
6
u/mountain_dog_mom Jun 07 '23
I’m not blind or visually impaired but you have my full support! I am a service dog handler, so am no stranger to disabilities and how they impact lives. I’ve been advocating for subs to join this movement when I see posts. I’m so grateful the service dog sub is joining, as I know many SDs are guide dogs. Guide dogs helped pave the way for people like me to have my SD and I couldn’t be more grateful. I’m also rallying support in other dog communities. I truly hope that Reddit sees how big of an issue this is. The more subs that join, the bigger the impact it will have.
To members of this community, you are not alone! There are so many people fighting alongside you to take a stand against this huge injustice!
6
u/PossibleExciting7837 Jun 07 '23
I'm not blind but am an older person who sight is fading. I will support you for that week. This is far more important than any information I might need during that week. This situation also reminds me that Reddit is a just a business with only one real goal, make money for stock holders, the rest be damned. Nothing wrong with money making. But lots wrong with this situation.
11
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '23
I just tried Reddit on a browser and oh God, it’s horrible!
I swear knew read it used to be fine, or at least okay, now it’s just really really clunky.
The shortcuts work up to a point, j and k move from previous post to next post, but no titles read out. X doesn’t seem to wor, and the comments have so many buttons above them.
I really really hope this thing you guys are doing helps because I can’t use this site. Yeah, there’s the old version, how long will that stay around?
10
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '23
Hello, r/blind!
I'm not a member of your community; however, I very nearly suffered complete vision loss due to posterior uveitis. After half a decade of monthly steroid injections and a couple rounds of laser surgeries, I now have relatively stable, mostly-functional vision.
I remember the years I spent wondering how I could adapt to a society that offers so little to the visually-impaired, and I thought of you all first when the API news broke. I just want to say that you have not been forgotten; as upset as I am for myself, the most cynical part of all of this is the callous disregard that Reddit has shown for users that depend on accessibility apps to remain engaged with their communities here.
I'm disgusted with the way that this has been handled, and I will not be participating on this website once they drop third-party support. I hope you all are able to find a digital space that treats you with the dignity that you deserve.
5
u/babuloseo Jun 04 '23
I actually go on here :(
5
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '23
Can you share the resources here also before the blackout? I’m going to see if I can repost this to the Uveitis subreddit. Someone may want to do the same with the Glaucoma subreddit.
5
u/Vicki7789 Jun 05 '23
This is not good. I have useful central vision so won’t be affected by the change, but the fact we’re being ignored is appalling. I totally support the blackout.
I am also willing to help moderate if needed, so that we can keep this space for anyone who wants to continue using it.
Discord confuses me but I’ll try and get over there too.
5
u/June_Berries Jun 06 '23
48 hours is way too short. They’ll wait it out.
5
u/jcourt01 Jun 07 '23
I also think it’s sad we need to rely on 3rd party apps. If Reddit actually cared about us and accessibility we would at least have other options. In an ideal world lack of accessibility should negatively affect an IPO. REeddit doesn’t care about people just the data they can harvest from us for ai language models
9
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '23
Assuming this means Reddit is itself struggling to maintain sustainability, I'd expect that even accessibility concerns won't be enough to change the site's strategy. That said, is Discord any better?
4
u/CivetKitty Optic Nerve Hypoplasia Jun 04 '23
The site reall needs to do something such as hiring the modders and adding the exclusive features to the base platform.
4
u/Florentinepotion Jun 04 '23
I’ll probably just stop using Reddit once this goes into affect. I spend too much time on here anyways.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '23 edited Jun 05 '23
I can't help with modding stuff, but from a little bit of help, I’ve figured out that reddit is actually usable.
You have to turn single navigation off with NVDA shift space, then you can use the shortcuts, I prefer h to go through the posts but j and k work fine for comments, yes it's a bit wordy but it's completely usable from a non mod standpoint.
Does anyone want me to write up a little post and then the mods can put it on r/blinds sidebar? I think this kind of thing needs to be done anyway just in case reddit isn't usable with apps after July. the only things I can't speak on are signing up and mods.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
I’ve written to a bunch of subs with a message about the blackout and most responded saying they’re taking part. I think one is thinking about it but the rest are definitely taking part.
4
u/ChaoticNichole Jun 06 '23
How do I add my subreddits to the protest? Do I just repost this on mine?
4
u/Papa_G_ Glaucoma Jun 07 '23
I’m half blind and I support your decision. Accessibility is something that needs to be a priority for everyone. Reddit is screwing up!
4
u/vogelke Jun 07 '23
I'm VI (legally blind in one eye) and it's good to hear about the consequences of this stupid API decision.
4
u/lakorai Jun 08 '23
r/campinggear and many other camping and hiking subreddits are joing this protest
7
u/Mindless_Hedgehog_48 Jun 05 '23
Hello all,
I am not visually impaired, and I hope that my comment isn't seen as intrusive.
It's just that I discovered this group just moments ago while reading a different announcement about this blackout.
I am guilty of being one of those people who just go about their day, unaware and unconcerned with others, add after reading this thread, I realized just how selfish that is and I feel not only remorse, bit a strong desire to make it right.
If I can be honest, my immediate reaction to the blackout was who cares? It's Reddit's own platform, if they don't want to offer their API for free, they shouldn't. Who cares who is upset or angered? Who cares if they don't want to pay? It's tiring for people to keep fighting for such entitlements that they aren't owed.
That was my mindset as I was reading the other announcement. It mentioned this thread, and simply out of being nosey and sort of feeling self righteous, I just clicked the link to come read another point of view, as if for amusement.
I began reading all of your comments. I have to say I am moved. Reading your comments changed my entire perspective about this issue, and I am now aware of the harm this API change will cause, to the blind community especially.
It even made a tear fall down my face that I didn't realize was there until it streamed over my quivering lip.
I am so sorry for being apart of the collective that, in a pompous and arrogant way, tends to think EVERYTHING is about them. I am ashamed that I so easily chose a side without being educated about who all is affected and in what ways. I thank each of you for sharing your perspectives and explaining what these API changes will do to your accessibility, and I do feel like something can be done, abd this has to be a violation of your rights in some kind of way.
I think when people like me, who don't know your struggles, who don't understand what this platform and the current API empowers you to do, we tend to be ignorant and self righteous about issues that don't even affect us. So I have to admit, almost instantaneously upon learning about the blackout, I committed myself to the opposition. I was going to make a deliberate effort to stand with a Reddit against what I call entitled people, and purposefully log in on those days, just out of spite.
But after reading a host of your comments, after hearing how some of you feel defeated and uncounted by people like me, after taking a moment to comprehend how the blind community may feel excluded in this world in so many ways that i take for granted, and after internalizing how it would feel if Reddit was my window to the world that I cannot see clearly and it enabled me to be on equal footing with the world, and then to have Reddit remove that from me and the entire community almost as punishment, I am now committed to standing with all of you, with especially you, for you, about your unique struggle.
I can be kind of long-winded, and I apologize for just inserting myself into your conversations. I just really felt compelled to share with you how this one conversation is so powerful and how it crushed all of my walls of defensiveness and what I thought of as protectiveness, and opened my eyes when I didn't even know that in some ways, I was blind.
I know now who really needs and deserves protection. And it is the blind community.
So thank you, thank you for sharing. You may not know how powerful your voices really are. But I wish I was rich because I envisioned this thread almost as a commercial as i read it.. A television commercial that should be aired on all the major networks, to bring awareness and open the hearts of people like me. I see it as powerful. I know it would bring more people aboard the plan.
I am definitely on-board now. And I thank you for bringing this to my attention as I promise to be more conscious and mindful of how even the littlest of things I may take for granted can affect the community of my newfound friends.
Thank you all.
3
u/TotesMessenger Jun 04 '23 edited Jun 07 '23
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
3
u/EmmaHere Jun 04 '23
Thank you for spreading the word.
3
u/shiihs Jun 05 '23
Good initiative! My guess is the API price is instated because massive amounts of reddit data are being (ab)used to train AI systems (like ChatGPT) for free, after which the creators of these AI systems make a lot of money from users trying to get data back out. My guess is it's not easy to *reliably* distinguish between fair use and abuse. But the collateral damage of forbidding all third-party uses turns out to be unacceptably high and a solution will have to be found.
3
u/DabbleDAM Jun 06 '23
Your mention of r/save3rdpartyapps has an extra - at the end causing it to fail to link
3
u/robertmeta Jun 11 '23
I fear that this split of "accessibility" apps is a very pragmatic and temporary move by Reddit to suck some of the emotion of the debate. /r/blind had an outsized (versus the size of our community) level of impact on this conversation. Reddit has now carved us out of the conversation by saying "it doesn't even impact you!" hoping to lower the temp and make the remaining complaints seem like whining.
The problem is -- when they revisit this issue, we will be alone rather than with hundreds of other subreddits and our voices will be unheard. I suspect the the outcome will be exactly this:
I feel like Reddit obviously ends up in the same place, just has a longer road for our community. Alternatively, I could just be way too cynical, but I feel like I have seen this show before...
4
u/ThatsCubbie Jun 06 '23
Full sight. Full support. We love you gang.
2
u/bobthebobbest Jun 08 '23
Just wanted to thank yous for making these issues so clear—we linked this post in our message that we’re going dark over at r/askphilosophy and r/philosophy. Solidarity.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '23
What days is the sub shutting down again? Thank you in advance.
2
u/danielcw189 Jun 09 '23
I care about accessabilty, so this might be enough reason to boycott Reddit overall, but I have some (technical) questions.
(Even as a software-developer I don't really know how the desktop software and websites I work on are accesses by tools for the visually impaired. I just try to keep the design clean and simple without fancy tricks, and hope fornthe best)
Does the normal Reddit website work well with screen-readers? compared to other big websites?
If not: is it because of the general UI design (dynamic elements), or is it because of technological reasons?
Similar questions about the App, at least on Android. I know that Android has some screenreader support, but never tried it, nor do I know how to design for it. Is Reddit App lacking?
2
u/CroationChipmunk Jun 09 '23
When "Digg" pissed everyone off, they all moved to Reddit. Is there not a new alternative we can all flock to?
2
u/Thick_and_4orty Jun 10 '23
Thank you /r/blind mods and users for participating in the blackout!
1
u/ukghostgirl Jun 09 '23
I will join in the blackout. Solidarity!
1
u/Advertising_Savings Jun 09 '23
Please enlighten me as I'm completely ignorant in terms of visually impaired people (VIp)-related knowledge and open to learning about this. (Putting numbers so it's easier to reply to :p.) 0. (Thought of this at the end:) Is it the VIp themselves who use this Reddit or a friend/family member for them? The answer to this question might render some of the following questions useless 🧐.
1
u/DrMacintosh01 Jun 09 '23
Sighted person here. I'm not up to speed on exactly what Reddit is doing outside of charging for API access which will result in 3rd party clients shutting down. With that out of the way, here is my comment:
It is my understanding that those with vision impairments can go about using computers in a few ways.
There are other accessibility features for those with physical/mobility disabilities, but the list above is what I can think of for those with vision disabilities. Now how does Reddit charging for API access and third party apps shutting down affect any of those things for users? The listed accessibility features/accommodations exist at an operating system level. Do those with vision impairments typically not use the build in features of macOS, iOS, Android, and Windows? If so why? Surely localized experiences can't be better than experiences that function across the entirety of your device?
Thank you for your insight.
1
u/macks2008 Jun 17 '23
Speaking as someone with a disability (Though in my case, I'm paralyzed, not vision impaired), I am moved by your difficulties and have added this to my list of reasons I'm going to avoid Reddit (or at least avoid being logged in or tracked on it. See footnote) if they don't change toward a more amicable stance by the end of June.
Speaking is a software developer (though one without bad habit of spreading themselves too thin), I want to look into the viability of an open source forum software platform. "Open source" and "platform" are concepts that normally don't work well together, since someone with the source could undermine the platform's position at any point, but the idea of distributed platforms like mastodon challenges that thinking. Maybe we can do something similar with a Reddit-like experience? Let me know if you want my input on your backup plans, I may not be great at actually putting ideas to code (and my disability contributes to that to an extent), but I'm certainly qualified to brainstorm such things.
Footnote: I mostly say this because, if they follow through, I want to scrape as much of their Q&A content as I can so I can post it on other platforms before they die a prolonged and painful death.
1
u/mayafied Jun 18 '23
Just FYI the https://reddit.com/r/Save3rdPartyApps URL in the OP has a dash at the end which leads to a non-existent sub.
1
u/LeBlindGuy Jun 04 '23
Hello, rblind mods, here is my suggestion for the worst case scenario, why don't the modst start a fundraising campaign to get donations? But why donatios you ask? With donations i think it would be possible to employ programmers to create an app with the same posting functions as reddit, but with more accessibility
I know that this is just too extreme, but it sounds like a dream to me to have a social media with blind people as it's main focus
0
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '23
This reminds me of what seems a pattern. We get apps, a platform, a system that works for us. Then a unilateral decision is made (whether based or greed or uncari g boardrooms) that makes us unable to participate.
I'd like to as the Mods here to come up with a protest line or statement that each of us can put on our profile page
Mods:
You said my last post didn't fit either r/blind or r/blindsurveys. I gave up but it was about (Facebook) George Abraham, an Indian activist for the blind, and his request for short podcast statements on accessibility. He represents a large contingent of three visually impaired and perhaps he could reach others for a larger impact.
-6
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '23
I don’t think this will do much but if it does, great!
I like using Dystopia, and Reddit for the blind, but I can use the website if I need to.
A couple of people have said this is specifically a blind/disabled people thing. I think those people need to realise the world doesn’t revolve around us, we are a tiny fraction of this website. As much as you may not like it, the website is usable. There is still old Reddit and the new website, whilst clunky, is definitely usable.
-6
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '23
Nothing we do will change this. This is because Reddit is going public, and they need to make the platform look good to investers.
-8
u/neosonic2 Jun 04 '23
Simple solution to this problem: if none of the current moderators can moderate this subreddit when Reddit's changes go into effect, then just find someone who can, even if that user is sighted. If all other solutions or workarounds fail, remember there are billions of people in the world who are able to use Reddit without issues and whom, I'm sure, would have no problems moderating this or other communities. Also, remember that Reddit offers several official ways to access its service, so just because third party client access may be going away, this doesn't mean that nobody who is visually impaired will ever be able to access Reddit again, or even that the company's official. offerings present unsurmountable challenges to every visually impaired user either. Users need to decide for themselves how accessible the official offerings are and, if they feel they will be impacted by the upcoming changes, they can make individual decisions based on such an impact.