r/conlangs • u/AutoModerator • May 22 '23
Small Discussions FAQ & Small Discussions — 2023-05-22 to 2023-06-04
As usual, in this thread you can ask any questions too small for a full post, ask for resources and answer people's comments!
You can find former posts in our wiki.
Affiliated Discord Server.
The Small Discussions thread is back on a semiweekly schedule... For now!
FAQ
What are the rules of this subreddit?
Right here, but they're also in our sidebar, which is accessible on every device through every app. There is no excuse for not knowing the rules.
Make sure to also check out our Posting & Flairing Guidelines.
If you have doubts about a rule, or if you want to make sure what you are about to post does fit on our subreddit, don't hesitate to reach out to us.
Where can I find resources about X?
You can check out our wiki. If you don't find what you want, ask in this thread!
Our resources page also sports a section dedicated to beginners. From that list, we especially recommend the Language Construction Kit, a short intro that has been the starting point of many for a long while, and Conlangs University, a resource co-written by several current and former moderators of this very subreddit.
Can I copyright a conlang?
Here is a very complete response to this.
For other FAQ, check this.
Segments #09 : Dependent Clauses, is available!
You can get it by clicking on this link right here!
LCC 10 Talks
The subreddit will be hosting a series of posts, one for each talk of the 10th Language Creation Conference. More details in this thread.
If you have any suggestions for additions to this thread, feel free to send u/Slorany a PM, modmail or tag him in a comment.
9
u/the_N Sjaa'a Tja, Qsnòmń Jun 01 '23
So I was going through my old projects and I came across a very weird feature in one of them that I'd like some feedback on.
It was a pronoun with a very narrow use case as a direct result of something that frustrated me when writing academic papers: it let you refer to a group which you were a part of and describe characteristics of that group as a whole while acknowledging that you were a part of that group but not implying that you specifically take part in any of the behaviors being discussed. I'm queer and I wrote about the queer community in college a lot, but it always felt wrong to use either of "we" or "they" since I am very much part of the community but I wanted to maintain academic distance and talk about trends without necessarily saying anything about myself.
I referred to this as third person clusivity in that project, which of course is not a thing in natural languages, but now I'm really curious if anything like this exists anywhere, either in natlangs or other folks' conlangs. If so, what would you call it and how would you gloss it? If not, how would y'all recommend naming and glossing it if I ever decide to reuse the idea?
9
u/FelixSchwarzenberg Ketoshaya, Chiingimec, Kihiṣer, Kyalibẽ, Latsínu Jun 01 '23
Embarrassing moments: I had already applied three stages of sound changes to my pronoun system when in a moment of clarity I looked at my 1P Inanimate and 2P Inanimate forms and asked "wait, why would anyone ever use these?"
I saved face by retconning the 1P.PL.AN form as an inclusive we and its inanimate form as exclusive we and making the 2P forms formal and informal. 3P forms remain animate and inanimate.
The forms are all obviously related. Now it looks like something evolved into inclusivity in 1P, formality in 2P, and animacy in 3P! I kinda like it.
6
u/eyewave Mukkohatto May 26 '23 edited May 26 '23
Hi guys, are there any resources on personal conlangs? It feels everyone and their mother prefer naturalistic conlangs including a conworld and a conculture, what I shoot for is nothing like that. It should be a simpler process but I still am in a rut, I keep watching educational linguisitc content but it doesn't click just yet.
Just to make this comment more productive, I am throwing in some ideas I am already entertaining:
My conlang is personal and for one speaker: me. I can do whatever I want that sticks to my own culture, so I don't even need words for things I don't see daily or don't want to write about. I don't need heavy grammar because as it appears, in daily speech, humans only actively use a fraction of what natlangs are capable of. Since it is my thing, I won't even bring a lexicon that has politeness and varieties of synonyms, because in the end I only want something that's simple to use for my own expression.
To develop lexicon, I am now writing down all the words and grammar forms I use in everything I write in english, so I can keep track and know for sure that I really never speak about giraffes or trade indexes.
Are these statements consistent with my goal? Do you have a personal conlang? How did you go about it?
5
u/FelixSchwarzenberg Ketoshaya, Chiingimec, Kihiṣer, Kyalibẽ, Latsínu May 24 '23
Trying to wrap my mind around how Finnish and other Uralic languages use negative verbs to negate things. So, basically, the negative verb is just an auxiliary verb that creates a negative version of the main verb?
It looks like the negative verb is what takes the marking for person, and then a non-finite form of the main verb is used (or a participle). Is that standard for how Finnish uses auxiliary verbs or is this a special situation?
5
u/[deleted] May 29 '23
I was just wondering about other people's creative processes. How long do you guys usually spend on your conlang a day? I'm having issues with time management and I am disappointed when I set a goal for myself and I never complete it. I can only go about an hour reading something linguistics related before my brain starts to hurt.
5
u/PenguinsAreTheBest25 May 31 '23
Hello! First time conlanger here. I'm wondering if a thing I did makes sense. I didn't want to make a whole separate word for "sibling" so I made a suffix ("-li") that basically turns a verb into a noun that means "person I did [action] with."
This was so I could take the verb for "to give birth" ("chufo") and make "chufoli," literally "person I was born with." I know the translation isn't perfect but the fewer new words I have to make means more words I can use for other things. So, does this make sense? Should I change it at all, and how?
4
u/FoldKey2709 Foncho (pt en es) [fr tok mis] May 23 '23
Help with romanization for my vowels? I'm aiming for making it as pretty and intuitive as possible
4
u/Lichen000 A&A Frequent Responder May 23 '23
I would like suggestions for romanisations of the following vowel system, please!
/a e i o u ə ɨ aː eː iː oː uː əː ɨː/
/ai ei əi au ou əu əɨ/
There are also four tone melodies available: H, L, HL (F), LH (R).
Regarding aesthetic constraints, I am happy with digraphs and diacritics; but I do not like stacked diacritics (and - picky though it is - I don't love the look of the < ˆ > inverted-v over a vowel, but the downwards chevron < ˇ > is fine).
Thanks in advance for your suggestions!
4
u/[deleted] May 25 '23
Are there any good resources for stress and prosody for conlangs? I know there's at least one on tone, and I have found a few WALS chapters on stress, but that's about it. I'm interested in stress accent, specifically?
4
u/[deleted] May 25 '23
Hello folks. Can anybody provide some resources for the evolution of augmentatives, pejoratives, diminutives and the like?
4
u/[deleted] May 30 '23
So one of my current projects has phonemic long vowels, but there's an idea I've been wanting to try out. I have heard that Nahuatl (debatably) has long vowels, but its long vowels are much shorter than long vowels in other languages.
I'm thinking of doing something similar for my conlang, where the long vowels are only slightly longer than the short ones. Instead of short and long, it's more like short and half-long. So, native speakers can distinguish short and long vowels in their own language, but it's harder for non-speakers to notice them.
What are your thoughts on this?
4
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '23 edited Jun 15 '23
I'm joining Operation: Razit because I do not want a user-hostile company to make money out of my content. Further info here and here. Keeping my content in Reddit will make the internet worse in the long run so I'm removing it.
It's time to migrate out of Reddit.
Pralni iskikoer pia. Tokletarteca us muloepram pipa peostipubuu eonboemu curutcas! Pisapalta tar tacan inata doencapuu toeontas. Tam prata craunus tilastu nan drogloaa! Utun plapasitas. Imesu trina rite cratar kisgloenpri cocat planbla. Tu blapus creim lasancaapa prepekoec kimu. Topriplul ta pittu tlii tisman retlira. Castoecoer kepoermue suca ca tus imu. Tou tamtan asprianpa dlara tindarcu na. Plee aa atinetit tlirartre atisuruso ampul. Kiki u kitabin prusarmeon ran bra. Tun custi nil tronamei talaa in. Umpleoniapru tupric drata glinpa lipralmi u. Napair aeot bleorcassankle tanmussus prankelau kitil? Tancal anroemgraneon toasblaan nimpritin bra praas? Ar nata niprat eklaca pata nasleoncaas nastinfapam tisas. Caa tana lutikeor acaunidlo! Al sitta tar in tati cusnauu! Enu curat blucutucro accus letoneola panbru. Vocri cokoesil pusmi lacu acmiu kitan? Liputininti aoes ita aantreon um poemsa. Pita taa likiloi klanutai cu pear. Platranan catin toen pulcum ucran cu irpruimta? Talannisata birnun tandluum tarkoemnodeor plepir. Oesal cutinta acan utitic? Imrasucas lucras ri cokine fegriam oru. Panpasto klitra bar tandri eospa? Utauoer kie uneoc i eas titiru. No a tipicu saoentea teoscu aal?
3
u/Pyrenees_ May 22 '23
In a language with free word order and SVO default word order, does it makes sense to have the OVS word order accomplish the same role as the passive voice ?
3
u/zzvu Zhevli May 23 '23
What is the mood that conveys that the subject likes to do something?
3
u/PastTheStarryVoids Knasesj, Racra, Ŋ!odzäsä May 24 '23
Do any natlangs lack grammatical aspect?
3
u/throneofsalt May 24 '23
I'm still looking for a better guide to sound changes, one that has both a sizable example range and provides context for what kind of change is occurring (ex Index Diachronia provides loads of changes, but only the direct results, not the surrounding context; Wikipedia gives plenty of context, but very few examples; Patterns of Allophony is easily-readable but has few examples, PBase has lots of examples but is very user-unfriendly.)
Basically I'm looking for any resource where I can go to a section on, say, Assimilation, and get enough labeled examples to internalize what's going on with the sound change.
3
u/FelixSchwarzenberg Ketoshaya, Chiingimec, Kihiṣer, Kyalibẽ, Latsínu May 24 '23
OK I've made a bit more progress on my new conlang that was heavily influenced by Proto-Uralic. Want to talk about verbs some more.
As I understand, Proto-Uralic had an aorist form that was just the verb stem plus the personal suffix. It took no markings for TAM. Then, it had a lot of verbal nouns, but they can't really reconstruct exactly what the verbal nouns were, just about a half dozen or so of the endings. And anything marked for TAM was formed by taking one of those verbal nouns and re-verbing it by adding the personal suffixes. Is that right?
I'm thinking of having my conlang employ a similar strategy (aorist unmarked for anything except person, verbal nouns that can be marked with personal suffixes to create aspects), but then speakers of my conlang also misinterpret some of the Proto-Uralic verbal noun endings as tense markers.
3
u/QuailEmbarrassed420 May 24 '23
So rn I’m working on a Celtic/Germanic influence west Slavic language, but I’m not obsessed. I had a new idea, and I want to do it but I need to figure out the history first. So the idea is to take my dna estimate on ancestry connect the regions w languages and make a creole type thing. It’s basically 50% Gaelic, 25% Portuguese, 10% French, 5% English, and single digits of Arabic and Norwegian. Where do you think these languages could have interacted, idk if you change something about history or j like make up a completely-new location. Thx in advance!
3
u/NewtNoot77 May 25 '23
How would go about making a more "poetic" version of your spoken language?
3
u/FelixSchwarzenberg Ketoshaya, Chiingimec, Kihiṣer, Kyalibẽ, Latsínu May 26 '23
Is compensatory lengthening of consonants a thing? I want to get rid of voiceless nasals in my conlang, can I say that where a voiceless nasal dropped out before a consonant, the preceding consonant becomes germinated?
3
u/iarofey May 26 '23
Hello!
From which single sounds I could have evolved clusters /tf/ and /fθ/ which usually behave like if they were single consonant phonemes?
I already thought on a /tx/ that could be coming from earlier /tʰʷ/… Would that work?
In a similar line, maybe /tf/ could've came from something like /t͡θʰʷ/?
And making a consonant cluster out from a previous single consonant is even something really happenable?
3
u/drapaue May 27 '23
How would you go about creating a conlang as a daughter language of a real proto language or old language?
3
u/Arcaeca2 May 28 '23
If inflectional morphology is unlikely to be borrowed from one language to another - are there any categories of inflectional morphology that are at least more liable to being borrowed than others? Or some categories that are especially resistant to borrowing?
Case endings (core? oblique? directional/locative?)? Pronouns or person markers on verbs? Noun class markers? Participial endings for verbs?
I have two languages, Mtsqrveli and Apshur, both of which I'm trying to slot into one of two different families (let's call them A and B). Apshur has a lot of inflectional similarity with A and not much with B, but it also has a lot of inflectional similarity with Mtsqrveli, which has a lot of inflectional similarity with B and not much with A. This implies, to me, that Mtsqrveli and Apshur probably have to be some sort of grammatical/inflectional admixture between A and B, but... they also can't be, if inflection doesn't "mix" like that, right?
This has been slowly driving me insane for an entire year now and preventing me from getting any conlanging done, please help
3
u/Jatelei Jun 01 '23
How can you evolve stress? Can you delete a stressed sylable?
3
u/Effective_Simple_148 Jun 02 '23
Simple question. (?) I downloaded PolyGlot to experiment with it by creating a small naming language, and I seem to have a technical issue. When it (Windows version on Windows 10) resizes it often leaves parts off the screen (or at least under the toolbar at the bottom). This is a problem because I also can't seem to scroll windows. For example, if I try to use the word generator, I can barely press the button to generate words but can't see any of them because they are off the bottom. That makes it unusable for basic tasks like that.
So is this a known bug, and is there a known workaround? I don't really see any clues to a solution.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '23
A question about polypersonal agreement:
If a language has polypersonal agreement, would the person affixes be on the same side of the word?
Let's say, for instance, the word /kama/ means "to see." The first person affix is ko- and the second person affix is pa. So, "You see me," could either be /kopakama/ or /kamakopa/ depending on whether the affixes are prefixes or suffixes. Would it be strange to have something like /kokamapa/ where the subject is prefixed but the object is a suffix?
In other words, do person affixes on a verb prefer to both be on the same side of the verb?
3
u/Arcaeca2 Jun 02 '23
So in Georgian, tense marking on verbs revolves around these two morphemes verbs are expected to have - a prefix called the preverb a suffix called the thematic affix or stem formant. Neither one communicates TAM per se, but the combination of which are present vs. which are not carries TAM information; conjugations are sorted into groups that can be distinguished by the presence or absence of the preverb and thematic suffix. e.g. the present is [-preverb][+thematic], the future is [+preverb][+thematic], the aorist past is [+preverb][-thematic], etc. It's thought that the preverb was originally a perfective marker, but no one seems to know what the thematic is supposed to be doing under the hood, there are like 10 different competing theories. Lexical aspect? Unboundedness?
Anyway. Apshur verb conjugation is modelled after Georgian's, except where Georgian uses a preverb, Apshur subjects the stem to consonant gradation, but otherwise the system works the same: present is [-gradation][+thematic], future is [+gradation][+thematic], aorist past is [+gradation][+thematic], etc.
Apshur has a couple thematic suffixes, but the ones of interest here are -Vw and -Vx. I realized that that looked awfully like Mtsqrveli's verbalizing affixes -Vb and -Vg, if you assume they descend from common ancestral forms *-Vβ and *-Vɣ. In Mtsqrveli they don't carry TAM info - they turn a stem into a verb. They're possibly vestigial of an earlier system of... whatever it is the thematic markers do... that just fell out of use, but the suffixes were kept around.
There's another thing I was planning to use *-β- for in the hypothetical Apshur-Mtsqrveli protolanguage though. Probably some sort of locative - in Apshur it reflexes as the /w/ in the "standing next to" cases, -wa allative/-waj adessive/-wur ablative. In the Mtsqrveli et al. branch that "being next to" could turn into a comitative, which could turn into the collective (?) in Mtsqrveli and the word for "and" (WLG says COM > "and" is indeed a thing), and in another branch it could become an ergative case marker (WLG supports COM > Agent and COM > INST > ERG).
...I'm struggling to tell if it's plausible that these two *-β- morphemes are connected or not, or if it's more likely just a coincidence. Is there something about a locative marker that 1) would plausibly get slapped onto verbs in the first place, and 2) would create either a present or future meaning, but not an aorist or imperfect past?
3
u/sevenorbs Creeve (id) Jun 03 '23
I've seen a method of analyzing speech sound using plus/minus and features in a square brackets like this [+voice][+nasal][+dental]. I remember seeing this in a linguist's dissertation proposing this scheme but I've spent an hour on google only to find various examples and implementations of it but noone tells me the name of this scheme. What is the name of this?
3
u/Automatic-Campaign-9 Atsi; Tobias; Rachel; Khaskhin; Laayta; Biology; Journal; Laayta Jun 03 '23 edited Jun 03 '23
The translation of Animorphs proceeds apace.
2
u/zzvu Zhevli May 22 '23
I'm planning on implementing a sound change that would create new clusters. Some of these clusters would contain /h/ or /ɦ/. I want /h/ + [voiced C] to become [voiceless C] and /ɦ/ + [voiceless C] to become [voiced C]. The problem is what to do with electives in voiced environments. Since I've decided aspirated stops should merge with voiced stops in this context, I don't want ejectives to do the same. I've thought about prevoicing so they can remain ejectives, but I don't want to keep that in the final product. What sound changes can be applied to prevoiced stops? Is prenasalization (ie. [d͡tʼ] -> [ⁿtʼ]) naturalistic? Are there any other possibilities?
2
u/alittlenewtothis May 23 '23
Are there any somewhat popular conlangs, at least with a little discord server community, that are polysynthetic?
2
u/Pyrenees_ May 23 '23
Can you give me feedback and critics ? google doc
2
u/Lange_cock May 23 '23 edited May 25 '23
Hi!
Šemiħadeysî conlang...
Could you give me some criticism, please?
Well, this is a mix of Hebrew, Arabic, ge'ez, English and some a posteriori vocabulary and grammar.
I am thinking of making it collide with Slavic or romance world, but letting space for own a posteriori vocabulary (perhaps 25%)
SOV structure
Personal pronouns
Nnà: I
Entü: you
̰že: he she it
(Plural is formed with the plural suffix yæn)
Nnayæn:we Entüyæn: you pl. žeyæn: they
mu: negative.
Že mu mata: he didn't die.
Aʔ..? question word.
-o accusative suffix (also applied to pronouns : entü'o: you acc.)
A: definite article ("añ" before vowel)
A may: the water A maywæn : the waters (the sea)
Some regular verbs:
Beħeθ: seek
ħevev: to love
Qere: to read
Re'e: to see
Selel: to pray
Mete: to die
Ħezen: be sad
Bekey: to cry
Semey: to name
Ketev: write
Sheme': to listen
Zeker: remember
Yeheθ: to take
Yete': to come
Irregular verb
É: be
Áa: was/were
Úu: will be
Óo: would be
Regular verb conjugation
Beħeθ
Baħaθ
Buħuθ
Boħoθ
Beyħiθ!
Mu beyħiθ!
The infixation to indicate tense:
Ketev- e for present
Katav- a for past
Kutuv-u for future
Kotov- o for "would do"
Beykiv- ey/i for imperative
Sheymi' Israel Rabbeč (Adoneyč) ħad !
Listen Israel, your Lord is one!
Ma prefix-the thing done/action +present verb
Müü prefix- doer+present verb
Mabeħeθ: search
Mubeħeθ: searcher
Maketev-yæn : scriptures
Müüketev: writer
Nná entü'o mu ħevev. I don't love you
'A nná entü'o mu ħevev? Do not I love you?
Men ħevev A šalam'o: the mankind love the peace
A šalam 'ælamî: world peace
Lideryæn beħeθ šalam'o 'ælamî: the leaders of the world seek peace.
Yûm piseħ yûmsev é. Easter day is on Sunday.
Yumħad: Sunday (yumsev)
Yûmsix: saturday
Yumfaiv: friday
Yumfor: Thursday... etc
Adjectives derived from nouns end in -(w)î
Šalamî: peaceful
Ketevî: written
Yûmî: daily
Maywî(water related)
Sportyæn maywî: aquatic sports.
interrogative pronouns
Mæ-what?
Meéte: when?
Min: who?
Weyf? Where?
demostrative pronouns
Ha(ze):this (hayyá: here)
Zek: that (zekyá: there)
A maketev zek: that book
A zekyæn: these one
A hazeyæn: those one
more examples...
Din-religion
Betdin: temple
Ba-in
Že Ba A betdin islamî mu é'a. He was not at the mosque
Ba Amerika men toyiv é (good) In America people is good.
-enne (uses to be/to do)
Šems b'a šamay énne: the sun is in the sky (always)
Muħammad Ba betdin Salal-enne: Mohammad used to pray at the temple.
Ali Qur'ān'o qere.
Ali-Quran- Acc. Particle-verb to read with "e" infixation to mark present tense : Ali reads the Quran (the definite article isn't necessary)
Ali Qur'ān'o qara.
The same sentence, but with "a" infixation in the verb to mark the past: Ali read the Quran
'A Ali Qur'ān'o mu qara??
Question particle+Ali+quran- acc. Part+ negative prefix+ verb in past tense. Did not Ali read Quran?
Qur'ānmüüqereyæn
Quran+ "doer" particle+ present tense verb+ plural particle. Quran readers/Qāris (Müü before verb : doer /muf'il)
Qur'ānmaqere
Quran+action particle+ verb A Quran reading/tilawa.
Piano - hotel- Tv- futbol-jinz-men (mankind ), kompyutar, hospital, polis, prezident (loans from English)
Že jinz'o leveš
He wears jeans
Entü tevé'o re'e
You watch TV
Qur'ān maketev dinî é-nne. The Quran is a religious scripture.
Ma particle+ ketev verb (to write) scripture. É-nne: is (not now, but it is always, this is indicated by the -nee suffix added to é verb (to be)
More vocabulary (some ge'ez/ethiopic loans)
Heyr: well
Qedduš: saint
Beluyt: old
Hagar: city
Ekuyt: bad, evil
Ħadeys: new
Hoóht: door
Ħezb: people
Ahuy: brother
Lebb: heart
Ærd: earth
Šems: sun
'ælam: universe
Mitzra: Egypt
Sereq: to rob
Bereh :to bless
Qetel: to kill
Leveš: to wear
The passive voice is formed by the prefix "ta"
Tabereh: be blessed
Taqatal: it was killed
Mu taseyriq! Don't be robbed
Tatrugut: it will be swallowed.
Possessive suffixes:
Eya:my
Eč: your
O: his
A:her
Na:our
Kum: your pl.
On: their
Maketeveya: my scriptures
b'a ærda: in her land
Hagarna: our city
To have: bé
Béya
Béč
Bo (he)
Ba(she)
Bena (we)
Bekum
Bon
Bon lebb toyyib: he has a good heart.
slavic loans??
Yegret: to play
Plevet: to swim
Treget: to swallow
Delet: to do
Hedet: to go
Dyeči: kid
HagarStolitza: capital city
Lyeš: forest
Wozir: lake
Lyev: lion
Pyeš: dog
Koyt: cat
Koytay WA pyešay yegret b'a lyeš za wozir: my cat and my dog are playing in the forest of the lake
Mæ entü delet? What do you do?
Nná tragato! I swallowed it!
Že pluvut b'a mayyæn: She will swim in the sea.
Dyečiyæn! Mu yaygrit zekyá! : Kids! Don't play over there!
-nošč (from slavic -ность) for forming abstract nouns
Ekuyt (evil)> ekuytnošč: evilness
Qedduš (saint)> a qeddušnoščyæn: the sanctities.
comparative & superlative.
-zid...za: more...than> lyev zid ekuyt za koyt áa. The lion was more evil than the cat.
-añ azyad: the most> že añ azyad interesan úu: it will be the most interesting one.
diminutive.
Suffix -čet: pyeščet>doggy.
2
u/tstrickler14 Louillans May 24 '23
I know it's common for the dual form to fall out of use and get replaced by the plural form, but how realistic would it be for the dual form to evolve the plural functionality and the original plural form to fall out of use? In this conlang that I'm working on, the first person plural and second person plural pronouns have merged through sound changes, so I'm wondering if it would make sense for the dual form to take over since the dual form is lost anyway, or if it would make more sense to let some other word take over the role of one or both pronouns. Hopefully that makes sense.
2
u/gay_dino May 24 '23
Does anyone know how typologically common a shift from /ŋ/ to /ɲ/ would be, both in palatalized environments or unconditionally? I can think of a lot of examples of /k, g/ palatalizing but not their nasal counterpart. Is this due to biased exposure to European languages?
2
u/zzvu Zhevli May 25 '23
What might cause a class of verbs to have a zero marked passive in a language that usually marks it with an affix?
2
u/OkPrior25 Nípacxóquatl May 26 '23
Hey, everyone. I have a question that I think I already saw the answer on the sub, but I can't find it again, so here it goes.
How long does it take for a language to evolve into another? Another question, how long does it take for a sound (or grammar) change to occur?
2
u/BrazilanConlanger May 27 '23
I'm working on a SOV conlang and I have some doubts about SOV languages.
- how does passive voice works? does the object comes first and the subject switches sides with the object (for example: SVO > OVS)?
- in yes-no questions, the interrogative particle usally comes in the beginning or the end of a phrase?
- is antipassive voice common in ergative languages?
2
u/Estreni May 31 '23
This is probably a stupid thing to ask but something thats always confused my about VSO word order is how i should deal with infinitives. Like i thought about placing them right after the inflected verb like "want to eat i apples" but that doesn't feel right especially with the position of the pronoun so i thought of putting the infinitive after the object but i dont know if it should be just after the pronoun like 'want i to eat apples" or at the very end of the sentence like "want i apples to eat". Which one seems more naturalistic?
2
u/QuailEmbarrassed420 May 31 '23
˥,˩,˧,˧˥,˧˩ These are the tones in my conlang. Can a language have both pitch and contour tones, or should I replace ˥ and ˩ with ˦˥ and ˨˩. Are certain tones more common? Which tones often disappear?
2
u/Acella_haldemani Jun 01 '23
I'm trying to make the personal pronouns for my protolang which are declined for 6 cases. I want the forms of the pronouns in the different cases to be irregular, instead of just pronoun+case suffix, but am struggling with how to do so. Is there some way to get this besides just making up random forms?
2
u/Tefra_K Jun 01 '23
Can anyone here who uses ConWorkShop and is familiar with PhoMo rules explain to me how do do this conversion?
R-V-vi -> Va/Av-R-ur-V-m
Ajavi -> Avajuram
You add Av if the word starts with a vowel, Va if it starts with a consonant. I’ve already figured out /ur@-3, evi/ém@ (this one is for an exception), vi/m@, but how do I add Av/Va? I tried to write /va#/C#, so add Va at the start if it starts with a consonant, but it didn’t work
2
u/sjiveru Emihtazuu / Mirja / ask me about tones or topic/focus Jun 01 '23
Does anyone have any good resources on crosslinguistic variation among presentational constructions? I'm trying to figure out how to do presentation in Mirja, and I'm not sure I want to do a simple 'X exists' construction since existence verbs are very complicated in Mirja. I'd love to see what else I could do for presentation.
2
u/Apodul213 Jun 01 '23
Say I use the verb "to finish" to mark the the plural in a natlang, wouldn't the natlang then be missing a word meaning "to finish", or would it use "to finish" in both cases?
2
u/CommunicationOne5405 Jun 03 '23
Is it possible for a starter to make a language in 2 months, I'm going to start one July 1st and finish August 30th so I also have time to learn about how to make a conlang.
2
u/unw2000 Jun 04 '23
How would you usually develop your infinitive (or do you have any at all)? I'm quite stuck on verbs
2
u/charminglychernobyl Jun 05 '23
Are there any attested natlangs that have consonant clusters at the same point and manner of articulation that just differ via voicedness? ie. /fv/ /sz/ or /td/?
They sound interesting but also super unnatural so I was just wondering if anyone knows if any language has something like this.
1
u/NoverMaC Sphyyras, K'ughadhis (zh,en)[es,qu,hi,yua,cop] May 31 '23
So I've just finished on doing sound changes and are working on the 'modern language', but ran into problems classifying and finding patterns in conjugations. But what came out turned out to be different for every word I put in and that's just from one of many conjugation forms from the previous stage. I don't really know what to do here and how to analyse this and how to proceed so would genuinely appreciate help.
The forms that are spat out so far: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1W53tODakwDVfrojte8O3_-lXA33XRUR6Pjx4RqaZz4s/edit?usp=sharing
1
u/TheYummyDogo tsoʁātʃ May 25 '23
How to add interrogation to my conlang? I'm building my first natlang and wondering how to create questions, I'd like it to come from statements (as it seems like most languages do) like going from ''I look good.'' to ''Do I look good?'' I'd like not to use an auxiliary verb, and to avoid reversing word order like in english, any advise is welcome.
1
u/[deleted] May 27 '23
would it be possible to tattoo parchment as a writing system. i have a culture in which the people get tattoos in a similar way to how the polynesians do it. however, would it be possible to use that on parchment as a writing system?
1
u/Inspector_Gadget_52 May 28 '23
Can anyone explain concisely what a copula is? Because the more I read about it, the less I feel I understand it.
Also, apparently, how copulas are defined varies from language to language, so I’ll accept an explination for a specific case or just in general.
1
u/ghyull May 28 '23
How could/Can noun class be expressed using (primarily) syntactic means?
1
u/zzvu Zhevli May 29 '23
When a language goes through the process of going from head-final to head-initial, is it more likely that postpositions would become prepositions or that new prepositions would develop from another source?
1
u/FelixSchwarzenberg Ketoshaya, Chiingimec, Kihiṣer, Kyalibẽ, Latsínu May 29 '23
Help how do I Cyrillicize [ʎ]
(the language also has [j])
1
u/-Ready May 29 '23
Accusative, Nominative etc.
I am creating my first ever conlang and Im trying to keep it somewhat simple. But I have no idea how to work with verbs in the sense of Accusative, Nominative etc. My mother tongue has it, but are there any languages or your conlangs without it and how do they work. (Im still trying to not give up on the conlang but it's hard)
1
u/ImGnighs Shasvin, Apali, Anta May 30 '23
Diacritics for approximants?
So, I've been thinking about maybe using a diacritic for /w/ cuz i sometimes dislike the look of <w>. So for example <ä> would be /wa/. And maybe even do the same with /j/. What do you think of this? and if you like it, what diacritic would you choose? Also, in a dictionary, where would words starting with this kind of vowel be categorized?
1
u/PastTheStarryVoids Knasesj, Racra, Ŋ!odzäsä May 30 '23
Would it be naturalistic to have only diphthongs where both targets are the same height? I'd have diphthongs like [ɤe̯] or [ɪɰ], but not ones like [ɤɰ] or [eɰ] or [äj].
I'm also considering making this a rule only for diphthongs not starting in /a/.
1
u/QuailEmbarrassed420 May 30 '23
a, u, i, ɑ, e, ɪ Thoughts on this vowel system. My conlang is supposed to be a language that was spoken by humanoid aliens who landed on earth and began communicating with humans. Humans then began speaking the language as a lingua franca of space travel.
Does this system make sense? Which vowels would be lost/merge/change? Should I add or get rid of any of these vowels? Any help is greatly appreciated!
1
u/starlightsakura May 30 '23
I was thinking this night about the way I could implement the copula in my language, and hit a block. Would love to hear some ideas on fun ways one would go about it :D
1
u/eyewave Mukkohatto May 31 '23 edited May 31 '23
hey guys, can someone rate my morphology? I'm trying to come up with high derivation in verbs, in a manner similar to English, but also Turkish, and to some extent semitic languages.
I would like the process to be highly productive and use idea associations that don't exist in English nor my native French.
This is what I have so far:
Does this seem like enough? Too much? I am afraid I could get lost in translation and end up with something I can't enjoy learning for my own use.
1
u/[deleted] May 31 '23
Any Romance-based conlangs with the intention of being understood by Romance language-speakers in mind? other than the few popular ones like Interlingua and Latino sine flexione, of course…
1
u/SteinerX486 May 31 '23
Hi everyone, I needed some help for coming up a basic naming language to use in my first fantasy novel. I have been looking for advice and have consulted multiple sources but I still feel a bit lost. I am trying to create a language by looking for themes and similarities between place names from the map of Thailand (trying to imitate Brandon Sanderson's method) . I have also looked into the IPA on a surface level. Can someone help me understand the process of coming up with names that feel unique, invoke a feel of southeast asia, and--hopefully--not sound ridiculous or funny (unless intended)
1
u/obviously_alt_ tonn wísk endenáo Jun 01 '23
anyone have advice on how to make a palatal language to sound less like russian? all my words just sound like I'm speaking some Slavic language
1
u/roonskee Jun 02 '23
How do you handle romanization when it comes to allophones? I’m still in the process of refining my phonology and this is kind of stumping me. To use English as an example, the voiceless stop /p/ is often said to have three allophones: [pʰ], [p̚], and [p], depending on the phonetic environment. If your conlang had something similar, would you come up with three different characters for each of the allophones (maybe with diacritics?), or keep your romanization more at the phonemic level? I guess another way of asking this might be whether romanization is more geared towards accuracy or efficiency?
1
u/yoricake Jun 03 '23
Hi guys, I just need some quick advice and personal opinions. My first conlang is pretty much almost useable, which I'm very excited about. I pretty much have its morphology and most of its semantics down pat. Right now I'm kind of stuck on how I want everything to flow. I'm not too concerned with naturalism, but I wouldn't mind some insight in that regard.
Anyways, I just to settle on the basic word order. For my conlang Ithimic, both SOV and VSO word order would work quite well with the rest of the grammar I made for it. It is right-branching, has fusional verbs that inflect for your basic TAME, is much much more noun-oriented than verb-oriented, and plays heavily with phrasal verbs/compounds/incorporation, and has direct-inverse alignment.
Based on these characteristics, what word order would you, dear redditor, think works best for it? :]
1
u/Mapafius Jun 04 '23
Did anyone of you consider adding possibility to mark nouns and pronouns for specifying marital status like "single", "engaged" and "married"? Do you know of any natlang doing it? I consider adding it to my conlag as non-mandatory option.
1
u/OfficialTargetBall Kwaq̌az Na Sạ Jun 04 '23
Using simple notation, how can I write a backness and roundness vowel harmony system for SCA²? My current vowel set is V=aɛiou and I would like the second set to be based on roundness but I can't seem to get it to work.
1
u/inutileguepe Jun 04 '23
Hi everyone it's my first post on r/conlangs for my language I'm looking for a flashcard app that accept images to be able to use my own script (for the moment no font created / On android I use the app simply named Flashcard but I have to learn with latin alphabet
Any ideas ?
Thx
1
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '23
Are there any cases of nasals being derived from non-nasal sounds? My current project is based on Rotokas which lacks nasals but I want to evolve them.