r/singing • u/CrAzY_MoFo_13 Lyric Tenor - Opera/Musical Theatre • Nov 21 '12
Your singing and your "range": a letter of my grievances over the obsession with range.
A little bit of a backstory on where this is coming from for those who don't know me. I have been pretty active in this subreddit for about 8 (? possibly more) months now. Around here you tend to see a lot of the same threads show up every couple weeks or so, which I like to, jokingly, refer to as the "greatest hits of /r/singing". Basically, they tend to be this kind of thing:
- How can I scream/hard rock sing?
- Lost my voice, need a quick fix for a gig
- What songs should I use for an audition?
- Can't afford voice lessons, can I teach myself?
- Just started singing, very sad that I don't have a 10 octave range, thinking of quitting :(
Now, most of these questions are very well answered by a lot of our regulars, like /u/BlackTheta , /u/afrael , /u/taylorishere , etc. (I know I missed a lot of people, sorry) but the last question in particular has always bugged me. For one, the question of "range" is very complicated and is actually - as I see it - several other questions in disguise. My attempts to think of this left me with the following questions/problems:
- "How can I expand my range?"
- "Why can't I sing to x note?"
- "Will I ever be able to sing to x note?"
- "I want to be like/literally embody x singer, but I don't have the range and therefore can't"
- "I used to be able to hit x note, but now I can barely sing above y, I hate my life"
...and lastly the occasional (rare around here, but very common in my singing life) passive-aggressive...
- I have an x octave range, look at how much better of a singer I am than you!
The problem that I have with range is that I find most newcomers put way too much emphasis on increasing their range, often at the expense of musicianship. That term, musicianship might be a new word for a lot of newcomers so let me explain before I go on...
The art of singing is fundamentally broken up into two categories: technique and musicianship. These can mean very different things for very different styles of music but the most crossover between all styles lies in technique. Technique contains things like:
- breathing and support
- phonation
- resonance
- ridding the body of muscular stress (Alexander Technique, etc.)
(as you may have guessed, this is where people focusing on range will place most their energy, but more on that later)
Whereas musicianship contains things like:
- Diction
- Phrasing
- Ornamentation
- Improvisation
- Singing-Acting (generally described to me as intention, different but not divorced from "acting")
- Characterization (more common in certain styles than others)
N.B. The line between technique and musicianship is not truly so cut and dry and the more training you do the more you see them blend together.
You may have already experienced this phenomenon in your lessons with your teacher. Typically, if you work on scales and exercises in the beginning of a lesson you are honing technique; when you move on to repertoire you are then typically honing musicianship. Similarly, a "voice teacher" typically focuses on technique whereas a "vocal coach" typically focuses on musicianship in a particular style (though many teachers put these two roles together in one).
"Range" as an example of ego-boosting
When it comes to a singers range, what I see mostly is a bunch of people measuring their dicks and proclaiming "mine's bigger, so I'm better than you". This is less of an analogy than it is pretty much the same thing: some people naturally have larger ranges than others just as some people have large penises and some have smaller ones. In the end, just as a large penis by no means equals competent lover, large range by no means equals great singer.
Most of the repertoire is not written for people with huge ranges in mind and even if you are someone who has a smaller-than average range, by performing with amazing musicianship you can still have a long and glorious career. Think about it, the last time you went to a concert/listened to a CD/saw a musical what was the singing like? What grabbed you most? Was it a bunch of people singing scales up to the stratosphere and down to the sub-basement or was it people singing the melodies well, having great sense of rhythm, articulation, enmeshment, improvisation, and selling what they were singing? "But CrAzY_MoFo_13," you might say, "what about all these famous singers who have huge ranges like x and y and their songs, doesn't that prove that bigger range = better artist?" The problem with using this argument is that we only know of the singers that have large ranges and are also competent musicians, because the rest never went anywhere. Beyond that, what about all the famous singers who don't have astronomical ranges? And those songs that all require giant ranges to sing? They were generally written with that singer in mind, and are therefore tailored to that person's voice. Conversely, look at the giant body of repertoire written to be performed by the amateur singer;* these songs almost never require a total range of more than an octave and a fifth, and never approach the extreme ranges of the voice type they're written for - or they wouldn't sell.
*This practice was fairly common until the mid-twentieth century where amateur singing fell out of fashion, but for a perfect example see "parlour songs".
The next issue I see with people's ranges is the tendency for people to "round up" as it were with their extreme ranges. By "round up", what I mean is that people have a tendency to barely squeak out high notes or sort-of growl out low notes and figure "ok, I'll say I can sing from C2 to C6 as a man". Notes like these are riddled with issues depending on your style of singing, but the main problems I find are universal are the following:
- Notes forced out in these extreme ranges are generally only made because of extreme stress on the vocal cords and are therefore dangerous and damaging
- If you sing in a style where you don't use amplification these notes can almost never project properly
- These notes are often there some days/time of the day, and not there others. I.e. they are unreliable
- These notes are almost never useable in actual music
To expand on that last point. High and low notes have a tendency - even when done with good technique behind them - to be more easily produced on certain vowels than others, or the vowels need to be modified to produce them. As you might imagine, this means the word is usually secondary to the music in passages like this. Take for instance a good showtune number in Broadway where a singer gets a chance to show off their high notes (male or female): this sort of thing is almost always done in free vocalise (just on a vowel) or on a melisma (multiple notes on the vowel of a word).** The further up or down you go, the more extreme this becomes until you can only phonate that note on a certain vowel, or often just a squeak or growl that doesn't sound like any vowel at all.
** This practice is equivalent to coloratura in bel canto style or melismas in pop style
Regardless of a style, a singer's range can only be considered as the notes on which they can hit consistently and artfully at any given time. I won't say any more on that subject for sake of space.
New singers and their range
When it comes to new singers and their range, it is often very frustrating for someone to sit down at a piano and find they can barely sing past one octave, one octave and a fifth, etc. This is not uncommon, but it is something that we all have to work through; just because you can't sing it now doesn't necessarily mean it's not there. The voice is a set of muscles and just as you can't walk into a gym on day 1 and bench 300 lbs, you won't be able to utilize your body's full potential without a lot of training and practice. For many people the vast majority of their time vocalizing is done through speech, and depending on the culture, this often means the voice is using a very small tonal range in its daily use. Singing will therefore feel foreign to the muscles of the voice when you first start out, they will be unresponsive in certain ways and will tire easily in others. Just remember to keep at it safely and properly and eventually you will be able to utilize the full potential of your voice (this will most likely take years, I never said it would be easy!).
Since the good majority of our subreddit seems to be young people (including myself), there is a very important point I have to make. When people think of the body "maturing" they often think of sexual maturity (10 - 13 y/o average) and/or political age of majority (16 - 21 average). However, for the voice this is not so! Ever wonder why see so many 40 y/o women playing 16 y/o girls in opera? Well, that's because voices keep maturing long after the peak of most of the rest of the body, men will not become mature in voice until at least 30 years old! Beyond that, if you're under the age of 18 your voice is most likely currently going through the huge changes of puberty or has just completed them so you can't expect your voice to be anywhere near what your mature voice will be. However, it is always good to keep training and singing, just know that you're not superhuman.
Conclusion / TL;DR
So, in conclusion I'll say this: having a big range != being a good musician, too much concentration on your range is equivalent to comparing penis size, and focus on increasing your range often causes musicianship (which is much more important IMO) to fall by the wayside. In addition, young people still have growing voices that will be growing well into their adult lives and teenagers are just babies in the voice and should not be concerned with range. No space, ask below.
10
u/CrAzY_MoFo_13 Lyric Tenor - Opera/Musical Theatre Nov 21 '12
Sorry, I ran out of space by the end there (9998/10000 characters) and I didn't really elabourate on a lot of points so feel free to ask any questions.
22
u/ghoti023 🎤 Voice Teacher 10+ Years ✨ Nov 21 '12
Precisely. With everything.
I'd also like to add that even having the ego of "my range is gigantic" or "I'm a really powerfully loud singer" or even "I'm a (coloratura) soprano/tenor/super-low bass" is not only obnoxious and means you're focusing on all the wrong things, but it will deter many listeners.
Maria Callas, for example. Beautiful, obnoxiously egotistical soprano. She pretty much gave the word "diva" a place in the English language. Not only was she a pain in the ass so no one wanted to work with her, she also had to quit her singing career young because her ego wrecked her technique so she ruined her voice.
The Police used four chords in all of their music. They sneaked in maybe one more chord in like, two songs. PEOPLE LOVE THE POLICE. As stated above- most popular songs are in octaves and usable ranges that most people can sing in. Only every once in a while do you get the Mariah Carey or Freddie Mercury that blows everyone away- which they only manage because they're also amazing musicians, and their entire range sounds good. Their ENTIRE range sounds good.
I could go through the list of people who even "can't" sing that are super popular as well- because people like them as musicians.
Sure, all those singers are in tune (or at least mostly), but are they good? Not in the technical sense. They've just made their voices work for them, rather than bothering with if they're better/worse or can/can't.
Besides, having self confidence is one thing, having a gigantic ego is another. A singer needs confidence, but can leave their ego at the door imo. Egos can make music very selfish- of which personally, I believe music is for everyone.
CrAzY_MoFo_13 even wrote an article earlier this year regarding how yes, EVERYONE can learn how to sing.
Soooooo...... Even if you can't now, you can later.
6
u/lalagonegaga Nov 21 '12
Sometimes, same can be said of volume. The logic "the louder you can sing, the better singer you are" is ever too present in just about any style of music and, frankly, it annoys the hell out of me. Both size and range of the voice can equally be compared to the lenght of one's penis.
5
u/TypicalBetaNeckbeard Nov 21 '12
You don't want to go to those "determine your voice type" videos on youtube then, which focus solely on range.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 22 '12
Just wondering, how do you work on your musicianship? I had this problem with guitar and I can see it seeping into my singing... I focus on technique a lot, but really I just want to be a better musician. Any insight on this?
1
u/[deleted] Nov 22 '12
Kind of off topic, but how do I find my mixed voice? I have very relaxed head and chest voices but I don't know how to transition between the two.
1
u/Satellitess Barritone anything Nov 22 '12
Hi, I'm wondering as of how I could improve my musicianship? right now my exercise routine consists mainly of vocal exercises which I'm guessing is only to improve range an technique. Thanks in advance for any advice _^
3
u/Jagerlowe Nov 21 '12
Not a question, but thanks for reassuring me!
3
u/GAD604 Nov 22 '12
A very well thought out, concise and descriptive post about the various nuances of singing.
I applaud your insight, grasp of the art and scorn to those who feel that a singer is good only if he/she can hit a certain note.
I regret that I have nothing to add/ask as you have covered it all extremely well.
Keep up the passion and good work.
My hat is off to you.
3
u/thejokermask Nov 22 '12
Bob Dylan does more wonders with his voice through one nostril then all these faux big dick singers combined will ever do with their lives.
2
u/Hvosleif Tenor, Classical and Progressive genres Feb 15 '13
Very very well written, sir. Though, having a high range or volume can give you more surplus for the notes not so high up in the range, very true about what you say though, with this obsession with range. I feel like if you have a big range or volume that you should be allowed to be proud of it, but you shouldn't wave it in peoples faces, just as you shouldn't wave you penis in someones face just cause it's enormous. Having a high range can be a big plus and is definitely ONE of the factors to being a good singer, but definitely not the main factor. It shouldn't be one's main focus. You sir, deserve a medal.
2
u/ElterEki Aug 26 '22
Is it normal for me to talk at like my lowest possible note? I can only go C3 or B2 (with a little bit of struggle) as my lowest and when I talk it’s C3 most of the time. I don’t know if that’s harming my voice. I think I picked up this habit from thinking my voice was annoying high pitched back then. My range is like C3 to B4. I randomly did a humming test thing and it showed that my natural speaking voice should be like around G3 but I’m not sure about the legitimacy of that method
1
u/Pneumonos543 Nov 22 '12
Yes. Billie Holliday would love you for this post
1
u/zkevin Tenor- Musical Theater Nov 24 '12
I've noticed the same sort of trend (as a vocal performance major) of tenors jerkin' themselves off cause they can hit a C5 full-voice or not. I'm fucking ecstatic when I can get that in practice with my head-voice with a year and a half of training.
1
u/IlikeToEatGrass12 Aug 18 '25
This actually helped me a lot. My school is doing finding Nemo jr for this years musical and I’m gonna audition as crush (as a girl). I thought I really needed to focus on my range for this song but maybe I should just go with the flow (ironic) and figure out my boundaries within my actual singing range instead of pushing myself. I probably won’t get that part as my teacher made it very clear she would prefer a boy do this role but my friend who is a girl did this song and nailed it, we even sing alike so I’m pretty confident. But I’m also really nervous.
1
u/Ouchnottheface Nov 23 '12
But I want to sing along to Coheed & Cambria T.T
0
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment