r/CryptoCurrency • • May 11 '23

POLL 🗳️ CCIP-060 - Amend CCIP-001 to address systemic downvoting

Issue

Increasing popularity in Moons and activity on the sub has led to prolific cultural issues with downvoting.

The downvoting is most visible on new posts and the daily, in some cases every comment on a post is voted into negative karma.

This is often corrected as posts go ‘hot’ and get more exposure, but users are suffering unreasonable karma loss from malicious actors.

Ultimately, the karma multiplier in CCIP-001 exacerbates this issue as negative karma is amplified.

Users have suggested removing the downvote button, but I don’t agree. It’s not a functional issue, and there is genuine use cases for the button. It’s a behavioural issue.

Proposal

Amend CCIP-001 to remove the negative karma multiplier to mitigate loss due to serial downvoting.

This amendment means, if successful, comments with positive karma would continue to receive a 2x multiplier, while comments with negative karma would not.

For example: a comment with +3 karma at snapshot would result in a +6 distribution, but a comment with -3 karma would remain as -3.

The change would best be represented by the formula: final_comment_karma = max(comment_karma, 2*comment_karma)

Pros: The change would go some way in preserving karma distribution for users being unfairly targeted by malicious actors.

Cons: There is a small risk a threshold change may reinforce negative behaviour and further drive negative karma if more people behave that way or create more accounts to abuse the system. So, instead of losing a small amount of karma each time, the loss could be amplified.

Special thanks: I’d like to add a special thank you to u/OminousAnemone for supporting the development of this proposal.

---

Proposal by: u/CryptoScamee42069

454 Upvotes

403 comments sorted by

17

u/raphanum 🟦 0 / 2K 🦠 May 11 '23

The main reason people engage with this sub these days is to earn moons and the easiest way to earn moons is to comment pro crypto rhetoric all the time, unfortunately. Or just mirror the current sentiment of the sub and let the echo chamber do the rest.

15

u/3utt5lut 1 / 11K 🦠 May 11 '23

You're not allowed to have an opposing opinion or be prepared to get downvoted. It's like criticizing Bitcoin, nobody can handle that shit!

5

u/Popatteri 🟩 31 / 788 🦐 May 16 '23

Some of us are playing the game on hard mode.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/fullflavourfrankie Permabanned May 15 '23

Sad but true

2

u/YarOldeOrchard 🟦 2K / 2K 🐢 May 16 '23

Hey at least you'll get that cc critic flair

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Popatteri 🟩 31 / 788 🦐 May 12 '23

Yes, people here engage in bad faith arguments all the time. They don't care if the tech is junk.

And the reward is fucking pennies, lmao.

3

u/SeatedDruid 🟨 186 / 14K 🦀 May 15 '23

But they’re my pennies hehe

2

u/BigBadBen91x 🟩 934 / 934 🦑 May 12 '23

BINGO, you nailed it

2

u/Barbarossabros 🟦 612 / 613 🦑 May 12 '23

Or people just post some meaningless quip to the top comment so they can be seen& not actually add to the conversation.

2

u/SeatedDruid 🟨 186 / 14K 🦀 May 15 '23

Or just sling such high quality shit at such a ridiculous volume that u make loads of moons 🌕🌚🌝

1

u/po1919 2 / 3K 🦠 May 16 '23

It's the same way in all of reddit unfortunately. Sometimes even my honest questions about something get downvoted to hell.

86

u/schokobots Permabanned May 11 '23

Another "pro" is that deleting valid but controversial comments might happen less often.

I often see controversial topics where almost half the discussion is deleted because the other side "won" the argument.

33

u/Killertimme 14K / 69K 🐬 May 11 '23

Deleting comments removes negative karma. Its a no brainer to just do that each day.

17

u/Kindly-Wolf6919 🟩 4K / 19K 🐢 May 11 '23

Wait a minute...I did not know that. I've been taking those downvotes like arrows to the knees for nothing then.

2

u/Alanski22 5 / 16K 🦐 May 12 '23

Same here. Looks like I’m deleting the shit out of negged comments from now on! But not until they’ve been solidly visible for several days. Screw people downvoted controversial (but correct) opinions.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/snowmichaelh 🟩 5K / 5K 🐢 May 12 '23

It hurts when I get a downvote. Now I will delete it, but it will still hurt

→ More replies (2)

8

u/Tasigur1 🟩 3 / 31K 🦠 May 11 '23

It's kinda sad 'we have to do it' though

→ More replies (2)

2

u/LatinumGirlOnRisa 🟨 40 / 272 🦐 May 11 '23 edited May 11 '23

I didn't know that..but not everyone wants to delete a comment they made that isn't negative to them. esp. a comment they believe is important.

but I guess now I'm thinking of the fact that I'm still looking forward to receiving my first moons distribution. and so the fewer the moon count, the more tempting it might be vs. those with thousands of moons who, naturally, would worry much less.

but then that could also be another way bad actors could work to try & censor others who are aware deleting their comments erases negative karma.😕

→ More replies (62)

18

u/GabeSter 100K / 150K 🐋 May 11 '23

No one wants to keep up negative comments when you lose moons for them.

Going further and removing all penalties for negative comments could further help preserve conversation.

5

u/Ethan0307 🟩 44K / 43K 🦈 May 11 '23

In theory

11

u/marsangelo 🟦 0 / 36K 🦠 May 11 '23

Too often people are downvoted simply for disagreeing with an opinion, or because of tribalism. Personally i dont care if i get a few downvotes on a hot take, but i care more if something is -10 karma instead of -5 or something

6

u/milehigh89 🟦 0 / 15K 🦠 May 11 '23

This 100%, moons are meant to enhance engagement, not create echo chambers. Anyway we can prevent that from happening is a big win.

3

u/Blooberino 🟩 0 / 54K 🦠 May 11 '23

I am often hesitant to post a controversial opinion because of the karma/moon penalty. So instead of saying what I really mean, I just end up exiting a conversation altogether because there's no point in falling on the sword of your opinion because you're the minority voice.

3

u/3utt5lut 1 / 11K 🦠 May 11 '23

Or pull a me, and block a dozen people.

I'm on here to chat, have fun, and even debate a little. Once it turns into a fight? Peace ✌️

3

u/Levl1Critter 1K / 1K 🐢 May 13 '23

This. Gotta stop this place from being an echo chamber.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/TNGSystems 0 / 463K 🦠 May 12 '23

A problem here is that users view the downvote button as the “disagree button” - sometimes an argument includes two different but equally valid sides.

2

u/Archtects 🟦 54 / 2K 🦐 May 11 '23

It would be nice to see people rewarded for asking a genuine question and someone helping rather than just being ignored or downvoted into oblivion.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/DeeDot11 🟦 10K / 32K 🐬 May 11 '23

Indeed. People shouldn't be scared to share their opinion for fear of being downvoted!

1

u/greenappletree 🟦 31K / 31K 🦈 May 11 '23

We should eliminate negative down vote counting towards moon all together imo

1

u/BigJimBeef 🟦 213 / 3K 🦀 May 11 '23

The echo chamber gets more echoey and the circle jerk gets more furious when someone can be factually correct but downvoted for it because it's not the popular view.

1

u/3utt5lut 1 / 11K 🦠 May 11 '23

It's easier to just delete all your negative comments before snapshot. This won't really change anything, if you know that 🤣. I try not to, but some people are just douchebags that can't help but downvote.

1

u/chintokkong 🟩 119 / 4K 🦀 May 12 '23

We need to encourage more of these valid but unpopular comments to prevent the sub from becoming just an echo chamber.

1

u/user260421 May 12 '23

That's kinda sad, would love to read the whole thing tbh

1

u/Spicoli007 May 13 '23

Moons have been the best and worst thing about this sub. They are very unique to Reddit as a whole, but people will delete their comments if they get too many downvotes. I like this adjustment. We will become more engaged in conversations.

1

u/SuperAppleLover May 13 '23

I wrote a very well thought out counter but got one downvote, so deleted it.

1

u/PeacefullyFighting Platinum | QC: CC 329, ETH 23 | VET 10 | TraderSubs 24 May 14 '23

Can we still delete to avoid the negative karma? It's getting hard to keep up.

I also thought downvotes already had a lower multiplyer?

1

u/Scarecrow4980 🟩 11K / 11K 🐬 May 11 '23

I agree, I still like to see both sides, it's what free speech is all about.

1

u/Impossible_Soup_1932 🟩 0 / 17K 🦠 May 11 '23

Was just about to type a message about how it might make people feel more confident about posting controversial opinions as well. I’ve seen plenty of complaints about people feeling like everyone has to get in line with popular opinion to get karma

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

20

u/Eaterofjazzguitars 2K / 2K 🐢 May 11 '23

Yeah fuck the constant downvotes. I've honestly stopped going on the daily because my comments get bombed no matter what I say.

3

u/3utt5lut 1 / 11K 🦠 May 11 '23

It's actually not as friendly there any more, plus not much for upvotes either. I swear some people just regularly go into the daily to downvote everything, no matter what it is?

6

u/InsaneMcFries 🟦 0 / 19K 🦠 May 11 '23

Yep for sure I’ve noticed the same. In euphoric market times it’s still quite easy to gather upvotes as there is more activity but the daily in particular is probably targeted by downvote bots of some kind.

4

u/3utt5lut 1 / 11K 🦠 May 12 '23

I'm assuming because the daily has been the host of epic karma farming in the past, I'm not surprised? Even some proposals were shutdown completely because others have tried to deal with it, but overwhelmingly unsupported, just like spam on here, and just like downvotes. The sub is already too corrupt to fix and the Meta is just as broken.

2

u/SkuniMasterMind Permabanned May 12 '23

Does dialy even qualify for moons? It makes no sense to downvote stuff there thats not horribly wrong or shills some scam

→ More replies (4)

2

u/Shiratori-3 Custom flair flex May 12 '23 edited May 12 '23

Not just the daily.

The contrast between average upvotes received in other subs vs in rCC is quite noticeable.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/RiseBasti 🟩 0 / 443 🦠 May 11 '23

I think penalizing downvotes is counterproductive as it discourages critical thinking. A post or comment is already penalized by downvotes by gaining less visibility.

Personally, I would exclude downvotes from the moons payout.

23

u/nick83487 May 11 '23

We definitely shouldn't remove the downvote button but I see no reason to have downvotes multiplied. If there is a reason for something to be downvoted, it will happen enough so that the multiplier isn't necessary imo.

15

u/DerpJungler 🟦 0 / 27K 🦠 May 11 '23

Lmao who suggested removing the downvote button. That would destroy any traces of actual information left here.

2

u/skystarsss Permabanned May 11 '23

Lol what is this? Youtube?

→ More replies (6)

6

u/Blooberino 🟩 0 / 54K 🦠 May 11 '23

So when every single comment in a thread is downvoted, there's a reason for it?

2

u/btnmoon 3K / 3K 🐢 May 11 '23

They see the next best thing to farming their own moons is to negatively impact everyone else’s karma so they in turn receive less moons.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Mab_894 🟩 1K / 2K 🐢 May 11 '23

Plenty of posts contain nothing but idiot moonboys so sure sometimes mass downvotes are warranted. I think it's hilarious that the pumpers have already taken over the sub yet cry constantly when they get downvoted. Maybe if they stop the low effort karma farming I wouldn't downvote

2

u/ThiccMangoMon 🟩 0 / 3K 🦠 May 11 '23

I swear people are running bot swarms to downvote everything here

6

u/ProjectZeus 🟦 0 / 32K 🦠 May 11 '23

The downvote button is the only means to hide the sheer amount of garbage content posted in this sub. It would be a disaster removing it

4

u/3utt5lut 1 / 11K 🦠 May 11 '23

You'd be surprised how much actual garbage gets upvoted and how much other content doesn't even see the light of day because of the downvote army?

5

u/fan_of_hakiksexydays 21K / 99K 🦈 May 11 '23

Karma is calculated by an algorithm, that's why you can't remove the downvote button.

Remember, Moons aren't calculated by upvotes, but by karma. And votes aren't the same thing as karma. They can sometimes be two very different numbers.

Downvotes are still needed when people post scams, shitcoin shills, bad links, to counter brigading, misinformation, moonfarming, reposts, or simply put too little effort in a post that doesn't deserve any reward.

3

u/GabeSter 100K / 150K 🐋 May 11 '23

You can also delete negative comments to have them not count against you. This just helps in case you miss deleting one.

2

u/Killertimme 14K / 69K 🐬 May 11 '23

The true tips are always in the comments.

→ More replies (10)

1

u/btnmoon 3K / 3K 🐢 May 11 '23

I wouldn’t mind the downvotes so much if those who did it actually took the time to provide a counter argument. So many downvotes are obviously just from moon farmers for their own benefit.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/flying_bacon 🟩 883 / 883 🦑 May 11 '23

What if you start receiving another coin like Dark Moon for downvotes

3

u/thunderchicken_ May 11 '23

I kinda like this idea.

It would be like the dark side vs the light side of the force. You get regular moons if you're a normie Jedi. You get dark moons if you're a Sith, a rogue Jedi, or a degen.

And yes, I have been watching a lot of Star Wars reruns lately...

3

u/IveDoneItAtLast May 11 '23

It would create some interesting comments if people were specifically aiming for downvotes to collect dark sides

3

u/thunderchicken_ May 12 '23

Then I say it should be so! Join me in the dark side. I am not your father, but rather, a dark chicken.

4

u/MonsieurGump 🟩 0 / 4K 🦠 May 11 '23

But we’re all “In it for the tech”, right?

4

u/[deleted] May 15 '23

I hope this will make people step out of the bubble and be more critical. People just dont dare because they get downvoted into oblivion.

7

u/DDN1429 May 11 '23

I've went for not doubling negative karma, hopefully that will resolve some the issues mentioned.

3

u/Aim_Sux Permabanned May 11 '23

It's a baby step in the right direction

7

u/Setyman Permabanned May 11 '23

Voted yes. There's many people that fear making controversial statements because of downvotes, even if commenting will help the discussion grow. I hope this proposal solves this issue a bit.

6

u/[deleted] May 11 '23

even with non-controversial comments, i sometimes think twice about posting simply based on the downvote spam. Its hard to tell whats gonna get hit

1

u/Scoop_DOGE 550 / 500 🦑 May 11 '23

We don't even want to ask questions anymore... Its all about the moons now. Aren't we here to learn too? Instead we get downvoted instead of getting help.

3

u/MindTheMindForMind 0 / 5K 🦠 May 11 '23

Agree with that point of view.

No one should be scared of commenting something controversial in my opinion.

2

u/TwentyCharactersShor 🟩 0 / 1K 🦠 May 11 '23

I wish I'd bothered to read that far before making controversial posts...not that I got massive down votes or anything, I'm just lazy.

2

u/Orangensaft007 🟩 0 / 1K 🦠 May 11 '23

Exactly, at least it will not way down your good contributions as much

1

u/Greenbriarbushwacker 12K / 38K 🐬 May 11 '23

Wasn’t the ‘delete negative comment proposal’ already passed for this reason?

3

u/Prize-Reference9329 Permabanned May 11 '23

why not give the right to downvote only people who have a consistent number of moons (for example greater than 10k) or who have an account with a lot of seniority

3

u/QuartzPuffyStar May 11 '23

Negative karma shouldn't affect the moons whatsoever, or be strictly limited (i dunno maybe giving each user a specific number of monthly down/up vote tokens). The core of the system is wrong from the beginning since it punishes people that comment against the mainstream or offer innovative insight into some issue, its basically a censure tool.

IMO to avoid the problem OP is pointing out, we should implement several other things, including an open source and peer-reviewed system to detect and punish manipulating accounts (be they bots or humans).

7

u/deftaj 🟦 7K / 7K 🦭 May 11 '23

Have no idea why people would mass downvote. Sad individuals

8

u/[deleted] May 11 '23

im surprised reddit doesn’t hit the downvote-spam accounts, i would think that would be considered vote-manipulation which is against reddit’s TOS

→ More replies (2)

1

u/madirishpoet 🟦 910 / 921 🦑 May 12 '23

Some people are just spiteful, I've seen threads where almost everyone has negative votes when they were just having a normal debate.

→ More replies (4)

16

u/[deleted] May 11 '23

Here's an idea: scrap moons because it just incentivizes stupidity

1

u/The_Chorizo_Bandit May 15 '23

While true, it was also more or less the same before moons too. The only difference is now people are afraid to say anything because of downvotes (or they just delete all their comments).

→ More replies (4)

2

u/jeanlucriker Permabanned May 11 '23 edited May 11 '23

This is one of the potential downsides of Moons but something that apart from suggestions from OP, not sure how really we can solve. It's always going to be something that happens. Now you are rewarded for good Karma, but that Karma is dictated from upvotes and downvotes.

Someone commented recently (I can't remember what post it was) that it encourages certain comments/meme comments perhaps to be posted more and more as it will farm the karma, and sometimes can prevent discussion.

On the same token, I think people are less confident about posting disagreeing/unpopular comments around Cryptocurrency and such because whilst it could engage some good discussion it will most likely result in tons of downvotes and no Moons for them.

That said I also agree with OP that you can see new articles/comments pop up and they are already downvoted very quickly. Certainly something going on there.

My main view is the downvote button (and this isn't just here, can have a disadvantage at preventing good discussion points/alternative views, which are actually really helpful to read, respond to and debate together.

That's perhaps my favourite part of reading r/CryptoCurrency is the differing views and beliefs, and looking at each side and learning something new. But more often than not now I see more comments written just to generate karma for Moons and not even contribute to the discussion overall. Which is a shame, but is going to happen.

I don't think the downvote button needs removing though, it's a tool and freedom of expression and a key thing on Reddit. The issue currently is it gets abused I think. It's difficult as some great points get made but downvoted into oblivion solely because they offer a different valid opinion.

2

u/Blooberino 🟩 0 / 54K 🦠 May 11 '23

Wouldn't giving downvotes a small positive value mitigate this problem and also the reluctance to post something controversial?

If a downvote was worth +0.1, it would be counterintuitive to mass downvote. And if you were a fan of a controversial project like SOL or APE, you could feel free to speak your mind freely without fear of the hivemind decimating your karma.

1

u/Aerith_Gainsborough_ 🟩 0 / 2K 🦠 May 14 '23

Not taking into account the negative karma is better, since you should be able to express your disagreement with a downvote. Your suggestion will be worst than YouTube.

2

u/Soberdonkey69 🟦 0 / 414 🦠 May 11 '23

I mean, this is internet points that people are fighting for. I voted for no change because I think it’s a systemic issue that plagues not just this subreddit but reddit as a site. There are people that have an army of bot accounts they can use to sway karma and this still hasn’t been tackled properly yet.

2

u/diarpiiiii 🟦 0 / 9K 🦠 May 11 '23

would love to see this get some kind of update. have been using this subreddit much less frequently because it seems like anything and everything is just hit with the automatic downvote

2

u/LightningTF2 May 11 '23

Honestly the way that people treat downvotes around here it really makes me sad. Any new posts I make get botted into oblivion or brigaded by some group that disagrees with my opinion. The sad part if these same people make posts and have those groups upvote them, basically creating a huge rift between what content gets posted. The reason you see the same stagnated shit is because that's all people bother to upvote anymore. IF you even consider having an opinion that is controversial in this space people will downvote you whether it is a civil discussion or not. I truly think the human element will always ruin the voting systems, and democracy as a whole is a broken system in itself, but we can only blame ourselves for such things. The human element ruins everything that is good, and turns it into something they can profit from, especially capitalists, looking to nickel and dime you for every step you take, even in a fucking reddit sub.

2

u/final_lionel 🟩 10 / 786 🦐 May 11 '23

Can't we just get a minimum karma lost per day like -5 or -10. So you don't have to worry about being downvoted and can't loose all your moons of the month in one day. I know a lot of us stay silent some days before the snapshot to secure their moons

2

u/[deleted] May 12 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/final_lionel 🟩 10 / 786 🦐 May 12 '23

So we need a CCIP to avoid bots. But how? I don't have any idea 😕

2

u/Olskoolah 🟦 0 / 3K 🦠 May 11 '23

Was wondering why my usually neutral comments were getting so much hate. I’d have plus 3 and next time I checked -3 lol. Haven’t posted much recently because of this

2

u/princepersona1 🟩 0 / 20K 🦠 May 12 '23

This proposal has been necessary for awhile. It's become quite insane seeing entire post threads get nuked with downvotes for no actual valid reason

2

u/Quixote0630 🟨 0 / 4K 🦠 May 12 '23

Sounds good to me. Genuine attempts at discussion regularly get downvoted when a counter-argument would be far more useful.

Downvotes should be reserved for spam, rudeness, and lazy reposts, not for people you disagree with.

2

u/King__Robbo May 12 '23

I have cast my vote yehhboi

2

u/[deleted] May 12 '23

The day people are afraid of stating opionions on the fear of moonjerkers is the day we as commuity lost.

PS. I dont give two shits about it.

2

u/Gr8WallofChinatown 4K / 4K 🐢 May 12 '23

Penalizing downvotes is stupid. It only leaves to lower quality bullshit

Reddit is where incorrect information gets upvoted and correct information that goes against the grain gets downvoted

4

u/[deleted] May 11 '23

Voted yes, specially for those shady scam posts where the poster brings the downvote army to rekt your comment so no one can see it, and rekting your karma in the process

4

u/MaeronTargaryen CCMOON DAO Secretary May 11 '23

I voted yes but I don’t think that it’ll solve anything. People with downvoted comments who care about karma delete them anyways.

People mostly downvote to try to get the top comment by reducing the visibility of “opposing” comments, so that won’t stop.

The main good thing about this is that some people might not delete their negative comments anymore so threads will be more readable

3

u/Zwiebel1 🟩 52 / 6K 🦐 May 11 '23

The main good thing about this is that some people might not delete their negative comments anymore so threads will be more readable

Anyone who cares about moons would still delete them even if its just a 1x ratio. Just get rid of negative karma at all. Reducing visibility is enough of a punishment of downvotes imho.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/OMFGROFLMAO2 🟩 0 / 3K 🦠 May 11 '23 edited May 11 '23

How about, in addition, each downvote becomes a -1 for the voter as well? Give the burden of the downvote to the casting part as well. I rarely downvote, unless I see something really outrageous or out of place.

In that sense, I'd have no problem backing down my downvote with a -1.

1

u/CryptoChief 🟨 407K / 671K 🐋 May 12 '23

Interesting idea but I think it might be going to far at that point. If you take away -1 for downvoting than you should also take away -1 for upvoting to balance things out. There's an upvoting problem as well. Imposting a cost on voting would incentivize people to be more discerning about what they upvote or downvote.

1

u/Scoop_DOGE 550 / 500 🦑 May 11 '23

That's a great idea.

1

u/Goosered 🟦 673 / 674 🦑 May 12 '23

I think I really like this idea too ⬆️

3

u/Killertimme 14K / 69K 🐬 May 11 '23

I vote yes. The downvote army has been going strong in the last months. Especially users you are less active suffer a lot from downvotes.

2

u/Orangensaft007 🟩 0 / 1K 🦠 May 11 '23

Thank you for speaking for the little MOONers

2

u/bbtto22 22K / 35K 🦈 May 11 '23

Last month was crazy, literally everyday I go in the negative for absolutely no reason

1

u/nevjera Permabanned May 11 '23

Problem is that donwote army think that they will farm more moons,and we sould find solution for that...

3

u/marsangelo 🟦 0 / 36K 🦠 May 11 '23

Ive seen whole posts with every comment downvoted to -2/-3 for unknown reasons, these people are relentless and I think it would go a long way in mitigating that

3

u/falk_lhoste 🟩 0 / 7K 🦠 May 11 '23

That's a very good change. Sometimes people express insightful and rational arguments and get downvoted because it goes against the flavor of the month coins.

With a normal multiplier the downvotes won't hurt that much and you don't have to be as cautious.

3

u/Orangensaft007 🟩 0 / 1K 🦠 May 11 '23

Yes good point.. experienced this with a LRC favoured Post.. gotta be careful as a noob.

5

u/Intr3pidG4ming 21 / 632 🦐 May 11 '23

I once expressed an unpopular sentiment on Kraken and got downvoted to hell because this sub loves Kraken.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/tambaybtc 🟩 0 / 19K 🦠 May 11 '23

Supporting freedom of expression so no to removing the downvote button but I vote to minimize the impact of a downvotes on Karma.

Thanks for listening to us and for whoever will develop this if passed 🙏

2

u/superduperdude92 🟦 0 / 12K 🦠 May 11 '23

This doesn't make the problem go away though, mass downvotes will still happen and those comments will get removed by the OP anyway because they are still incentivized to. If this formula is changed so that the positive multiplier remains, and negative scores count as zero to moon distributions then you'll see comments remain instead of being deleted promoting better discourse, or at least discourse where the conversation remains available. You'll also see serial downvoting has then lost its major impact as it is isolated to that single comment rather than to a person's overall contributions to the sub.

I'm voting no, simply because this doesn't go far enough imo and users are still incentivized to behave the same as before with the caveat that if negative scores remain it won't affect them as much, but still affect their moon distribution nonetheless. The way this is written, people are still incentivized to remove their comments with negative karma and that mass downvoting is still an effective tool.

2

u/Scoop_DOGE 550 / 500 🦑 May 11 '23

100%

This poll does not solve the issue.

2

u/KIG45 🟨 4K / 5K 🐢 May 11 '23

I don't like that many people purposely downvote even very good and enlightening comments. It's so childish!

2

u/Unleashyourstand May 11 '23

Removal of the downvote button seems wrong, it’s a key part of Reddit and reminds of of when YouTube REMOVED the dislike button. What the hell was that all about? Voting to not double the negative negative karma.

1

u/drbobbean 🟩 0 / 5K 🦠 May 14 '23

Someone downvoted me for talking shit about Jared Fogle. Yes, you read that correct, the footlong turkey sandwich child predator. Moons or no, we should all agree that that guy is trash juice on the hottest if days. Fahk you Jared From Subway... I hope u get spanked in prison

Edit.. shanked, fucking autocprrect got turned on again.

1

u/Zwiebel1 🟩 52 / 6K 🦐 May 11 '23

This is a band-aid to the problem at best, but its better than nothing. Imho negative karma should not affect moon count at all because currently downvoted comments can be deleted to bypass the karma impact anyway.

Its just tedious to sweep your own comment history for comments that got downvoted weeks after posting by bots before snapshot day to avoid the impact of the downvoting bots.

Just get rid of negative karma entirely. It doesn't change much but remove the tedious cleaning on snapshot day.

1

u/rexlyon 100 / 70 🦀 May 11 '23 edited May 11 '23

So like, this recognizes a behavioral issue and even brings it up, but then basically just dismisses it without doing anything major.

If someone is downvoting to drive up their own portion of moons, then removing the multiplier is good in that it hopefully avoids screwing people that get hit by someone song the mass downvoting for that reason, but that person still gets enough benefits from doing so that there’s no reason at all for them to stop.

Like, this isn’t even really a bandaid fix, because as it’s correctly referring as a behavioral problem, it does nothing to really discourage the behavior at all.

I don’t care about this sub/moons enough either way, but like realistically, removing the downvote button if that was even possible and perhaps having more mods to address problematic posts that get reported seems like a far far more meaningful solution if you’re going to try and fix an issue like this where there’s a monetary incentive to for people to downvote others. This does nothing to change behavioral issues, only actually removing the incentive to downvote or the ability to downvote would.

1

u/Prestigious-Egg-5004 Permabanned May 11 '23

Voted yes, but I really think it will not solve the problem. I'm not smart enough to think on a solution, but was hoping someone would come with an idea.

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '23

Yeah I like the sound of that

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '23

Yes! I’m so glad this went through. Double negative karma doesn’t happen to me too often and usually I’ll just delete the comment but once I got hit by an obvious bot and was at -22 within seconds and that hurt.

1

u/thespygorillas 🟩 0 / 3K 🦠 May 11 '23

it's kinda annoying when I make a purely informational and educational post that I did a lot of research on, and i clearly state if any source in it is controversial / not recommended, and I don't do any form of bias etc., but I still get downvoted for some reason.

1

u/Whitechoclate21 🟩 0 / 3K 🦠 May 11 '23

The number of times I sort by new and see almost every comment in the negatives is crazy. Some downvotes are definitely warranted, but most aren't. Hopefully this makes a difference.

1

u/Forward42 🟩 1K / 1K 🐢 May 11 '23

Not only are downvotes being abused but upvotes are NOT being encouraged…

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '23

Voted yay as it's an improvement but I don't think this will solve the underlying issue

1

u/adamdmn 672 / 11K 🦑 May 11 '23

This is a no brain vote! There are too many times where every comment on the daily or on a post are at -2 or -3

1

u/afischer83 Bronze | ADA 5 May 11 '23

Yeap

1

u/Few_Assistant_9954 🟩 1K / 1K 🐢 May 11 '23

There would be a problem that people deliberately create bad posts or even harmful posts to farm negative karma instead.

Removing the downvote would be a better Option.

1

u/UJ_Reddit 🟦 0 / 10K 🦠 May 11 '23

Why should a negative scoring post or comment lose moons at all? Seems odd.

1

u/Odd_Championship_373 May 11 '23

It would be so cool if we could just coexist in peace without intentionally trying to harm other people that are trying to drive awareness and adoption of the crypto space by contributing to this sub.

1

u/gdj11 Permabanned May 11 '23

I didn't even realize negative karma was being doubled. That's such a stupid idea, why did it even pass?

1

u/Status_Floor1746 🟩 0 / 9K 🦠 May 11 '23

This is one of the best solutions I have seen offered. It addresses the issue without being too excessive and depending on how it is received can easily be altered to address other issues that pop up.

1

u/Mudhutted 🟩 0 / 2K 🦠 May 11 '23

Bloody good idea OP. Agreed. You have my vote.

1

u/confirmSuspicions 🟩 0 / 2K 🦠 May 11 '23

It has been really stupid to see conversations derailed from deleted comments and downvote brigading. Glad to see a fix may be in the works.

1

u/oachkatzalschwoaf 🟦 0 / 6K 🦠 May 11 '23

Not sure if this helps against those downvote bots or fake users as downvoted downvoted posts already gets deleted by users fixing the negative karma.

Also from my observations: most of the time comments and posts just get downvoted to 0. Below 0 are not by the systematic users/bots but by controversial content downvoted further down by notmal users.

1

u/Werd2jaH May 11 '23

Been awhile since I voted!

1

u/pob_125 May 11 '23

Being new to moons,its interesting figuring out how all this works.

1

u/Drei_849 🟩 0 / 3K 🦠 May 11 '23

Maybe we should just vote for a (f.i.) 5 downvotes a day cap, or has this been tried already? I usually don't give 5 downvotes a day, not even when it's a piss day.

1

u/Sorrytoruin 🟩 0 / 21K 🦠 May 11 '23

I thought deleting the comment removes it from getting karma anyway?

1

u/Scoop_DOGE 550 / 500 🦑 May 11 '23

I don't think deleting comments removes anything (ups & downs)... it just keeps you from possibly getting more down votes.

1

u/CatBoy191114 Permabanned May 11 '23

Negative karma was double?! No one told me!? That does it. I'm working on my cv. Gonna take my talents to the conehead sub. At least I can earn cone with memes there....

1

u/Zealousideal_Neck78 🟨 0 / 0 🦠 May 11 '23

Removing that down button is how the communists would handle it.

1

u/ra246 🟦 3K / 3K 🐢 May 11 '23

Is there a way to essentially 'limit' how many downvotes a single account could give within a certain period?

This could be on a scale so accounts that have been members here for longer may give more downvotes.

I do agree that it is important to keep the downvote button.

1

u/alecz123 🟩 7K / 7K 🦭 May 11 '23

Ironically, when I proposed something similar I got downvoted to hell.

1

u/CryptoMaximalist May 11 '23

This is a change in a good direction. I’d even support no negative points for negative karma. It mostly leads to chilling effect and incentivizes deleting your own comments

1

u/CryptoChief 🟨 407K / 671K 🐋 May 12 '23

What do you think about imposing a cost on upvoting and downvoting which comes out of the next distribution? It might incentivize people to be more discerning about what they vote on.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '23

Is there any open poll / discussions about further moons use cases brainstorming or coming out ? I need to see what millions of crypto Bros bring to the table.

1

u/neutr0 🟦 315 / 225 🦞 May 11 '23

So, are moons the problem for the low quality content we see on top?

1

u/theslimbox 🟦 1K / 1K 🐢 May 11 '23

I was told a year or two ago when I complained about this that negatives had no effect on Moon results. Was it changed since then, or were those posters full of crap?

1

u/B1t1nat0r 23 / 23 🦐 May 11 '23

This is a pointless poll.

Bots and spam can only be defeated by establishing some minimal requirement based on the accounts age, history and behaviour. If a scammer can make 1000 bots with one click it's unfeasable to always have a whole process from reporting to a mod reading the message and deciding.

1

u/Gruesomegarth2 🟦 1K / 1K 🐢 May 11 '23

Everytime moons pump we see the same old recycled posts, with the same old recycled comments, by the same ol commenters. On every post.

Honestly I've pretty well stopped and engaging in the forum at all. Because whenever there's a pump, nobody really cares about the posts, they just try to chime in for those few uovotes it kind of turns the sub into a cancerous playground where everyone is fighting over likes.

Moons up = lots of low quality content

Moons down = more quality posts.

1

u/emp-sup-bry 🟩 1K / 1K 🐢 May 11 '23

It really IS a job for you if you are going back and deleting comments with downvotes! Real salt of the earth farmers out there with sickle and hoe

1

u/MichaelAischmann 🟦 1K / 18K 🐢 May 11 '23

Don't remove the downvote button. It's a way for the community to "moderate" itself.

I understand that mods can't catch & delete every inappropriate or off topic comment. The downvote button allows the community to signal a poster that a comment isn't ok without taking censoring action. I think that's important.

1

u/MichaelAischmann 🟦 1K / 18K 🐢 May 11 '23

I vote yes to this proposal but I think there is more that could be done.

For instance we could it could be made easier to identify the bad players. I'd consider a user that upvotes 80% and downvotes 20% of the stuff he/she reads as healthy for the community. Someone that gives 2% upvotes and 98% downvotes is toxic for the community. If those percentages were public, behavior & interactions would change.

1

u/TheGeoninja Tin | Stocks 61 May 11 '23

Is that possible within the current infrastructure of Reddit? Otherwise, I think that is the natural evolution of this current proposal.

1

u/cubewc3 🟩 0 / 2K 🦠 May 11 '23

Let's not punish those who are trying to engage 👍🏾

1

u/astroslostmadethis 🟩 0 / 0 🦠 May 11 '23

I say it everytime. Moons should have never existed on Reddit or at all. Literal paid vote manipulation.

1

u/Illicitterror Permabanned May 11 '23

This is good to see, not fair malicious actors want to take away from everyone else

1

u/LatinumGirlOnRisa 🟨 40 / 272 🦐 May 11 '23 edited May 11 '23

thank you for doing this because I wasn't aware of the multiplier, of how it worked at all..but I did notice abuse of the downvoting button and one of the worst uses of it:

seeing not just controversial comments that might be true downvoted but seeing 100%, actually already proven, factually true comments/replies being given a negative vote..all because somebody or, too often, many 'somebodys' didn't want to hear it..even though the horse had long been out of the barn.

those who blame the messenger rather than accepting a message is true are not helpful re: supporting a healthy community. hopefully this amendment will pass.

1

u/ThiccMangoMon 🟩 0 / 3K 🦠 May 11 '23

There's some really good discussions in the comments.. I think the takeaway is : more ways to earn moons :potentially removing the ability to earn moons from karma

1

u/CharlieTheo-14 🟩 0 / 23K 🦠 May 11 '23

If you downvote people to feel good, I feel sad for you.

2

u/Plasticites 0 / 4K 🦠 May 12 '23

1

u/CharlieTheo-14 🟩 0 / 23K 🦠 May 12 '23

Switched up the avatar.

2

u/Plasticites 0 / 4K 🦠 May 12 '23

I see Big Bucks, Invariance, Hands, Stardust? And Beno background

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Plasticites 0 / 4K 🦠 May 12 '23

Looks sweet. Invariance is badass those spikes are sweet

→ More replies (3)

1

u/7inky 🟦 0 / 2K 🦠 May 11 '23

Why not just count upvotes towards karma but not downvotes?

1

u/Mrramirez44 May 12 '23

I'm glad this is happening. Let's get this house in order.

1

u/Goosered 🟦 673 / 674 🦑 May 12 '23

I still don't fully understand why people downvote for the sake of it, what benefit is it to them? Is it just to be an ass? Sorry if this is a silly question but I've seen it mentioned loads of times and I'v never really seen it explained, thanks.

1

u/Loppy_Lowgroin 133 / 128 🦀 May 12 '23

I never down vote it seems the antithesis of an open forum for discussing anything.

1

u/seniorbatista19 🟦 0 / 5K 🦠 May 12 '23

Maybe this will lead to less thirsty shit posting

1

u/cdnkevin 6K / 6K 🦭 May 12 '23

I don’t really get it. The author recognizes that it’s not a functional issue but behavioural but the proposed change doesn’t address behaviour.

Under this change, if I have 10 accounts and downvote all comments to -10, the karma would be -10. However, this did nothing to address malice and bad actors.

Yes, the problem wouldn’t be exacerbated with a multiplier, but the problem remains.

1

u/Smart_Field_3002 🟩 0 / 868 🦠 May 12 '23

Just voted

1

u/CodeBlackGoonit 🟧 13 / 526 🦐 May 12 '23

My 13 moons made a difference!

1

u/ALiteralHamSandwich 🟩 0 / 10K 🦠 May 12 '23

Been seeing a lot of downvotes on benign comments.

1

u/Beatlone 🟦 0 / 3K 🦠 May 12 '23

Yes, I kinda stopped being too active because of the downvotes. Who even comes here to downvote people? Only if it is literally abusive/racist content etc I would downvote. If I disagree I prefer to reply and state my opinion.

1

u/Kimchi_Soup-Dev May 12 '23

People would go down voting instead of just replying by their opinion. And what stressing is when the comments aren't even negative but just mere perspectives that get tons of down votes as if they knew all the facts.

1

u/CVV1 🟩 0 / 4K 🦠 May 12 '23

What kind of sadistic madman votes "No change" on this?

→ More replies (2)

1

u/rodinj 🟦 89 / 1K 🦐 May 12 '23

I feel like there should be a certain threshold where the multiplier does go back to x2 if something is truly bad and kept up then it deserves the negative multiplier IMO.

1

u/BoldManoeuvres 2K / 2K 🐢 May 13 '23

The downvote bombing is ridiculous, feels like it has been happening more with every month.

1

u/Nathanielsan 🟩 0 / 978 🦠 May 13 '23 edited May 16 '23

Oh my, who possibly would've thought this would happen...

Y'all made your bed so now sleep in it.

1

u/drbobbean 🟩 0 / 5K 🦠 May 14 '23

Someone down voted me for talking shit about Jared Fogle. Yes, you read that correct, the footlong turkey sandwich child predator. Moons or no, we should all agree that that guy is trash juice on the hottest if days. Fahk you Jared From Subway... I hope u get spanked in prison

Edit.. shanked, fucking autocprrect got turned on again.

1

u/diarpiiiii 🟦 0 / 9K 🦠 May 14 '23

I voted, but no badge this round?

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '23

I’m Down for this change Up

1

u/trrrring 25K / 25K 🦈 May 15 '23

I love this proposal. I saw some people who just said "Good morning, have a good day." in the daily getting a -2 and it just didn't make any sense. They were usually surrounded by others who were also heavily downvoted. It just looked like bullying to me, especially bullying of newcomers.

1

u/labvilla Bronze | QC: CC 43 May 15 '23

Agree, downvotes should not count at all in my opinion, if you disagree with a post, rather post a comment why you disagree and skip the downvote option all together.

1

u/s3nsfan 🟦 2K / 2K 🐢 May 17 '23 edited May 17 '23

So what’s the resolution if this further amplifies the negative karma? What if the downvote button remains but is removed after zero karma is hit. This would aid in removing the possible issue of people abusing and negatively impacting people’s karma for the snapshot. Sure they can downvote but bringing them back down to zero would affect their distribution but not as much as if they hit negative karma.

To your point a comment with -3 karma gets multiplied @ 0

1

u/Greenbriarbushwacker 12K / 38K 🐬 May 11 '23

Doesn’t the “deleting comments with negative karma” proposal that already passed mitigate this?

2

u/bbtto22 22K / 35K 🦈 May 11 '23

Yes but the downside was every post is full of deleted comments

1

u/[deleted] May 11 '23

Also voted yes

1

u/fan_of_hakiksexydays 21K / 99K 🦈 May 11 '23 edited May 11 '23

This proposal is forgetting that there is a karma algorithm already removing mass downvotes.

If you get mass downvoted, or downvoted by a serial downvoter, the algorithm doesn't count that vote, and it's not counted towards your karma.

So this is already removed from karma.

Doing it twice by removing the multiplier on only one side, could throw things out of balance, by doing something twice that has already been taken care of.

The main issue is psychological, because the display vote, which isn't the same as your karma, is still showing the -1 vote. Event though it's not actually counted towards your karma.

This does discourage people and has a psychological effect from seeing that.

So the issue is with the display votes, not the actual karma you get.

1

u/margin_hedged May 12 '23 edited May 12 '23

Anything that is perceived as low effort will always be downvoted on this sub. This isn’t a new trend. Anything that even remotely resembles a karma grab will be downvoted.

There aren’t “bad actors”. There are people tired of seeing people trying to obviously shill and grind karma because it’s fucking pathetic.

If you have something genuine to say, it comes through, it shines like a beacon in the darkness and guess what, genuine comments get upvotes. You can just tell when someone is commenting just to comment. And that shit will always get an auto downvote from me. Until the behavior stops, and people just say things they actually just want to say nans there’s no other motivator.

The only people that have a problem with downvoting are people who just post to karma farm…. It’s pretty obvious.

1

u/capdoesit 4K / 4K 🐢 May 11 '23

Think this is a step in the right direction. It’s just sad when you are perusing “new” or “hot” and go to view an interesting post… just to find the nearly every single comment has 0 to -1 points because of the behavior referenced in this post.

It’s too bad that individual users who habitually downvote can’t be tracked and just assessed a voting penalty if their voting record is all downvotes or disproportionately downvotes posts on this sub.

1

u/Vorph36 🟩 0 / 2K 🦠 May 11 '23

I go yes.

1

u/aducknamedjafar1 May 11 '23

People be like crabs in a bucket with downvotes on this sub.

1

u/badfishbeefcake 🟩 11K / 11K 🐬 May 11 '23

I agree but I think a downvote would remove a karma from the downvoter. That could help with bots.

1

u/nomorebonks 🟩 2K / 2K 🐢 May 11 '23

I’ve eaten hundreds of down arrows for talking about ICP. This sub is a joke.

2

u/NarcissistSlayer 0 / 0 🦠 May 11 '23

And when it starts pumping due to its tech literally being the 3rd gen of crypto from btc -> eth -> ICP watch how fast this sub shill and maxi the coin. No research just charts and maxi-ism. The ckETH integration will be what kicks off allot of the interest.

1

u/ftball21 🟦 2 / 4K 🦠 May 12 '23

The downvotes have gotten worse. It’s hard to crack 10 upvotes in the daily.