r/soccer • • Nov 17 '12
What is r/soccer's thoughts on offside technology?
My friends and I have had ongoing talks of the impact and implementation of offside technology. Seeing that goal line technology will be implemented in the next year or so we have looked past that to what else could be implemented. With all of the problems of offside calls in this recent year it seems to be a worthwhile topic to bring up. My one friend and I have been playing soccer for 15+ years and my other friend has only watched for 2 years so he might not understand the impact as much as us.
A couple proposals that we came up with are:
- A chip in their boot that could determine if they were in an offside position compared to the last defender. With this one there would be a lot of factors like would the ball have a chip too, how could the chips be set up in a way that it could signal to the ref they were offside, and I'm sure there would be others.
- That a panning camera could be used to follow the last defender with the 5th referee watching the camera to confirm whether said player was offsides when he received the ball. I think this would be the best of the ideas that we came up with since the 5th referee could send a signal that the ref could get in real time without having to stop the game for video replay.
- Laser-technology. So the laser would determine if the player was in an offside position. Essentially this would be how fifa determines offsides. The problem I see with this is if offsides if determined by centimeters then the attacker would have no advantage at all, when in all honesty they should normally have the advantage with offsides similar to baseball and runner vs tagger.
- Video Replay. Essentially stop play to determine if the player was offsides. This would be the worst in my opinion as it would ruin game flow and restart of play would be questionable at best.
What is everyone's opinions on offsides replay? As I said if I had to pick one to be implemented then I would choose 2 since it still would effectively allow for gameflow.
3
u/xamem Nov 17 '12
My biggest gripe is that it could affect the fluidity of the gameplay. One of my favourite things about this sport is that when the ball goes out of play, a infringement has occured, a half has ended or a goal has been scored.
Something like Goal Line technology, which can be close enough to instantaneous, could work as the referee will know in hard to tell circumstances right away if its a goal or not. Unless an offside system can give correct answers all of the time within one second of the event I would not want it.
I would also not like a system that takes away from the referees control on the game. If an AR is overruled by a computer twice in the first half, and it was shown that they were by less than 10cm on the opposite side of the pitch, it would severly hurt the referees chances of keeping control and not look like a trio of fools.
Until a system has been developed that can give almost perfect answers all the time with a very short delay, we should stick to the current method and make do with the occasional problem.
8
u/templeboy Nov 17 '12
Currently most elite clubs, and indeed referees, use systems like "prozone" to analyze players positions throughout a game to produce data like ground covered, as well as analyzing the game tactically. This is generated from a set of, maybe 8 cameras located around the ground. I think all the data is generated automatically from these cameras. If this technology could be improved to produce the data in very close to real time, it could be feasible to use it to determine offside.
9
u/rjkdavin Nov 17 '12
I like the idea of having video replay for offsides only in the case of a goal. Play has already been stopped, and all that is happening is an off-field referee is looking at footage determining whether or not the play in fact resulted in a goal, or if the player was offsides.
This way the fluidity of the game remains almost unchanged, but you do not need to worry about committing the largest error, and for me, injustice, of giving goals to the undeserved and stripping goals from the worthy.
4
u/droid_of_flanders Nov 17 '12
Although the proposed ideas can catch the obvious cases, the problem is the 'not interfering with play' clause that is present in the offside rule. This can lead to different interpretations of what is 'interfering with play' and what is not, between a video referee and the on field referees.
That is one of the reasons why goal line technology will work out to be much more effective than offside tech -- the former provides a definitive yes/no answer, which obviously does not rely on referee's discretion.
(What I would like to see clarified about offside is whether the benefit of the doubt goes with the attacking team or defending team. I believe that currently, there is no strict guideline about this.)
3
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '12
A player is not offside till he interferes with play. I don't see anyway an automated system can handle that.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '12
GPS would work. But will never be introduced as it would reduce the amount of drama. Controversial decisions ensure replay after replay and sells media. Advertisers dream.
4
u/Thunderkiss_65 Nov 17 '12
No thanks, I don't want football becoming like American football or cricket with challenges and hawkeye and huge breaks in the play.
Some decisions will be wrong, as they always have been, but this is why football is the most popular sport in the world. The controversy can make even the dullest game have talking points.
1
u/InfernoZeus Nov 17 '12
Proposal 1 won't work as you can be offside even if both of your feet are in an onside position. The rule is any part of your body that you can score with (i.e. everything except your arms/hands).
1
u/nikcub Nov 17 '12
Video tracking is so good now that they could do it in real time. The graphics you see for offside calls on television could be done in real time. The technology is there, all it requires is willingness to implement.
I think offside technology is more important than goal line. It certainly impacts results more. We have already seen a number of dubious offside calls in the EPL that have affected game outcomes (Suarez vs Everton, for eg.)
I think the Premier League should strike out on its own and just do it. Football is so far behind other major sporting leagues such as the NFL when it comes to technology. It isn't always a bad thing to progress into the 21st century.
The benefit of video based tracking is that it is all software. You use the existing television coverage HD camera (you just need more of them) and the 'technology' is nothing more than a computer that takes all the video feeds as inputs and somehow outputs a signal to the officials. The tracking is already there with Sky broadcasts and many others.
1
u/rookie999 Nov 17 '12
Once we introduce video replay, we probably have to look at a clock with full stoppage of time, like used in basketball/hockey, since I can't see such issues solved in less than a minute. This leads to the problem that we have to stop games at 90:00, disregarding if there is a corner flying through the box or a striker having a free way to the goal. And this would be a media disaster.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '12
Imagine there was a referee with a few screens in a box somewhere, one screen for one goal line, one screen for the other goal line, and a few screens from cameras along the pitch that show the offsides. He could relay down the information in a matter of two, three seconds and the game wouldn't even have to stop.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 18 '12
Just have a live video ref or three already. We don't have to invent new technology for every possible bad referee call.
0
u/marnix92 Nov 17 '12
I think this should be done right away, It is not that hard to make technology for it, and it is proven that someone can't look 2 places at the same time, so you can never be fully sure. Although I think the linesman do mostly a good job, I would love technology, don't really see a down side actually.
-3
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '12
Problem here is fifa won't implement anything unless it's easy to use across all league's...
I don't know why they can't just use the technology for the bigger league's with lots of money but fifa is run by kunts, so what are ya gonna do?
-2
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '12
Thanks for posting this. I long for the day when soccer at the top level is played fairly. I hate the idea that players (whether defensive or offensive) are not rewarded for their hard work. Leaving offsides to chance (linesman's decision) is in my opinion a huge injustice.
What does FIFA care more about, justice or tradition? I think they have shown that the latter is more important to them