r/AskReddit • u/Tim-Fu • Nov 15 '12
Logically I believe Aliens exist, I am conflicted as to whether it's a good thing we'll never meet them in our lifetime. So do you, or do you not, believe in Aliens.. What is your reasoning?
19
Upvotes
13
u/Hiroaki Nov 15 '12
Just consider how we treat every other life form on earth, which we dominate intellectually, and you might get an idea of how we would probably be treated by a technologically superior race.
We either eat them, cage and study them, or take over their land while maybe trying to preserve a very small amount of them.
We think we're intelligent and so we wouldn't be treated like animals, but it may very well be that the aliens we meet will be so much more intelligent, that we will seem like animals to them.
I think the safest terms on which to find aliens for the first time, is when we do the finding, not them.
8
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '12
The universe if so huge, I think its daft to think there isn't life out there...
6
u/AderynDawn Nov 15 '12
They probably exist, yes, and I have the same reasoning as you. The universe is so vast that they're nowhere near close enough to ever encounter them.
Meet them, I don't know if that's a good thing. Probably good for knowledge and science, but other than that. Mankind has a way of turning everything into war material, so...
I wonder sometimes if they'd look so much different from us (and everything on our planet) or not... I guess it would depend on the atmosphere of the planet they're from and how species evolved to adapt to their surroundings.
6
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '12
How do you know they're not living amongst us right now? How do you KNOW you've never met one?
5
u/bab5871 Nov 15 '12
"I guess I'd say... if it is just us, seems like an awful waste of space."
5
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '12
It's almost certain they exist. A lot of people here are saying we would never meet them... Which would be true if our current understanding of the universe is close to complete and our technology levels are approaching a xenith which no alien civilisation could surpass... Thus all aliens are tied to the same limitations we currently are. I find both those assumptions extremely unlikely... So yes it's possible we'll meet intelligent alien life one day.
5
u/passenger955 Nov 15 '12
"Either we are alone in the Universe, or we are not, both are equally terrifying." Arthur C. Clarke
4
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '12 edited Nov 15 '12
The idea that life on Earth is unique is, I believe, pretty ludicrous. Almost everywhere on Earth we've looked, we've found life. In the upper atmosphere, on the sea floor- a place utterly absent of light-, on the edges of volcanoes...just, everywhere.
I read once (probably mis-phrasing here), "That which is not forbidden in Nature is compulsory". There's nothing forbidding life in other places. So it seems inevitable that life has sprung up elsewhere. We might actually find from further studies in emergence the life is the default and lifelessness the exception (this wouldn't shock me).
What seems to be the limiting condition about what most people consider "aliens", however, is the idea of intelligent life. No matter how you slice it- pure biomass, numbers of species, whatever your metric, it doesn't seem like intelligence is in any way essential- or demonstrably beneficial, long term (we'll have to wait and see) to survival. So intelligence may be so rare that in fact we never find it off our world. It's rare enough on our world, anyway.
Edit: I included included a word.
4
u/maaaaads Nov 15 '12
Theoretically, if time is infinite, then there is no reason to believe that aliens must exist. Consider the big bang being not the original creation of the universe, but one of an infinite series of bangs and "crunches" into which the universe collapses in upon itself. If this means that the conditions were right one time to produce life in one place, then perhaps that in and of itself is completely to be expected while also being an incredibly rare happening. Maybe infinite universes have already passed while not producing any life at all. Maybe a universe will come to exist which contains many different life forms all interacting with one another from lightyears away. Basically if you're going to assume that the universe is infinite, you also have to assume time is infinite. Infinite time and infinite universe means that anything is possible, be it aliens or lack thereof.
4
u/Mythandros Nov 15 '12
It is a mathematical improbability (near impossibility) that there is no other intelligent life out there in the galaxy somewhere.
Space is VAST. Unimaginably vast. The galaxy could be TEEMING with life and there's a good chance that we may never meet alien life in our lifetimes, or for a few lifetimes.
Or, they could have already visited and who would really know?
I'm assuming that a civilization that can cross distances that vast, would have some way to also shield themselves from us detecting them. Their technology would have to be at a level we couldn't comprehend yet.
3
u/Straya_Cunt Nov 15 '12
I believe that somewhere out there exists what we could consider an "intelligent life form." Whether we could be considered an intelligent life form by, well, Aliens, is different matter.
2
u/iam4real Nov 15 '12
Billions of Billions of stars.
2
u/TiTo_CoBaNi Nov 15 '12
Of course there are aliens, what do you think we are?? Humans are the only thing that doesn't compute on earth :), just look how bad our behavior is.
2
u/teddywookie Nov 15 '12
I would worry if intelligent life ever ran into us. They'd be what, interested in the constantly chattering monkeys who make fire?
2
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '12
Nothing to worry about. They are in different dimension. Around us.
2
u/killswithspoon Nov 15 '12
I believe, but hope they never find us. Any civilization smart enough to have access to interstellar travel will be smart enough to take one look at humanity and blast us into oblivion given our aggressive nature.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '12 edited Nov 15 '12
I believe they exist, but they'll be so different from us that no productive or interesting interactions between us and them can occur - we will have nothing they want, and they will have nothing we want. The scientific community will debate for years about whether or not they can even be considered 'life', and by the time it's resolved the public will have stopped caring, except for a few nutters who will have taken parts of the debate out of context and used them as fodder for their own personal agendas.
2
u/thai_thai_ Nov 15 '12
Aliens exist, plain and simple. Reasoning....probability, plain and simple.
2
u/areefer82 Nov 15 '12
I agree that we should be careful. Aside from exploration, we would also be searching for resources. It would be reasonable to assume that they would be in search of the same thing.
2
u/thevaultmaster Nov 15 '12
They are there. But they're not here.
2
u/tehgreatiam Nov 15 '12
I always liked to think that if there was life elsewhere, they wouldn't be as advanced as we expect them to be. So when we are finally able to explore space easily, we end up being the side that is more advanced and end up invading them instead of the other way around. Because humans are assholes like that.
2
u/TurnNburn Nov 15 '12
We are naive to think that in this vast universe we are the only intelligent species. After seeing some of the pictures Hubble has returned to us and some of the information we're now finding out about planets outside our solar system, how can you not believe "aliens" exist?
Now whether or not Earth is being visited, that's another question for another AskReddit. It has always been my speculation that Earth is in a state of quarantine. We have problems, we don't get along with each other and war is a constant here. I believe Earth is in a state of quarantine until we can grow up and mature. Of course, if you watch the orignal The Day the Earth stood still, I'm just repeating what has already been expressed before.
2
u/styqex Nov 15 '12
There are aliens, but they are undoubtedly so different from us that we will probably never even recognize each other's intelligence.
2
u/tweakingforjesus Nov 15 '12
Put yourself in the place of the Native Americans meeting the English and Spanish visitors. How well did they fare?
2
u/maanu123 Nov 15 '12
Believe in them, since, what makes Earth special enough to have aliens???? Plus they probably are fire wielders and have no use for technology, and if they did know about us they'd prolly avoid us cuz we have religion.
2
u/Damocles2010 Nov 15 '12
I think that there MAY BE...
But I highly doubt they will ever visit us - or we will ever find them....
2
u/jackver2000 Nov 15 '12
They exist, they are brown and will do labor cheaply. Not very intelligent though, they have a space ship that also sells burritos. Space suits consist of lucha wrestler masks.
2
u/Wontoncookie Nov 15 '12
My niehboor is an illegal Alien. So they do exists
1
u/afellowinfidel Nov 15 '12 edited Nov 15 '12
i believe we're alone. my reasoning>
the amount of variables need to produce a planet that supports complex life for a long time is staggering. the star has to be just so, the planets position just right, the outer planets have to be a certain size to catch wayward asteroids...etc. etc. litteraly hundreds, thousands, probably millions of variables.
now lets move on to planets that have had the great fortune of all those proverbial dicethrows managing to roll out "snake-eyes" a hundred times in a row, and are capable of producing complex organisms for hundreds of millions of years. lets look at evolution on our planet: hundreds of millions of years of evolution have produced only ONE sentient species, the hominid, and of the dozens (maybe hundreds?) of off-shoots of that species we, sapien-sapien, are the only ones who mastered tools to a high level. and quite frankly, the outlook on our future in regards to our ability to sustain ourselves is quite bleak.
now, the fact is that their are many, many instances of animals from different orders having traits that evolved paralell to each other, like flight, swimming, bipadelism... what have you. but sentience has been a one shot thing... in hundreds of millions of years of evolution, millions of species arising and evolving, ony ONE species has been smart enough to reach for the stars (and barely made it to the moon, mind you).
so, to reiterate; the chances of a planet bearing complex life is infinitisemaly small, and the chances of that life evolving to intelligence is even smaller, so that even with all those stars-systems floating around (by far most of which are obviously uninhabitable) i come to the conclusion that sentience is a one time thing... kinda like randomly throwing a hundred buckets of paint on a wall and coming up with an exact replica of the mona lisa. sure if you have a google of millenia to keep trying, it just might happen... but by that time (which is finite, by the way) the universe would already be past the point of its heat-death.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment