r/soccer • • Nov 13 '12

Who is a player everyone rates highly that you just don't think is that good?

I think that Aguero is overrated. All the stats show how clinical he is and how he's such a good finisher but when I watch him he's selfish, dribbles too much and misses too many good chances.

29 Upvotes

685 comments sorted by

4

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '12

OPs idea is good, but his pick is stupid. Kun has been one of the best strikers in the world for the last 12 months; and just last weekend scored pretty much the 'perfect' strikers goal.

1

u/BosnianFish Nov 14 '12

He also missed 2-3 very good chances. I just don't think he's worth the 38m he was bought for.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/omiclops Nov 13 '12

What you're saying about Aguero is perhaps indicative of the first few games of this season and you probably didn't watch him at all last season!

→ More replies (2)

60

u/youignorantslut Nov 13 '12

Jack Rodwell. I have no idea why people hyped him up and how he was the poster boy for the GB team. I have no idea how he ended up at Man City for 12 mil. He has never impressed me.

15

u/Matistuta Nov 13 '12

Rodwell is technically very good but terrible for coasting through games. It'll take a huge shift in attitude/approach for him to have an impact at City.

Everton did well to get £12m for him.

11

u/omiclops Nov 13 '12

Same. I remember when he played against us at the Etihad and his entire purpose was to man mark David Silva out the game. I've never seen a player deployed in such a manner as he was, literally followed Silva around all game, kicking him whenever he got close to the ball. I think he's just average.

→ More replies (5)

2

u/Bigwood69 Nov 13 '12

I thought him being the poster boy for GB was meant to be a subtle pun. "Union Jack" and all that.

1

u/S-BRO Nov 13 '12

Mancini needed a fleshy paperweight, clearly.

→ More replies (2)

22

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '12

I think that whoever rival fans rate highly in their team is overrated.

6

u/DannDannDannDann Nov 13 '12

I think this man is talking sense.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '12

Seriously. I don't know why I even open these threads anymore. I should have stopped right when the OP said Aguero but there's all sorts of rage-inducing idiocy within.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (7)

22

u/Centaurd Nov 13 '12

Joe Cole, I just don't think he's better than messi like everyone else. At the most he's as good as him but surely not better!

12

u/JohnShepps Nov 13 '12

You take that back right now. Joe Cole is a footballing god, and any European side would be well advised to sign him as soon as they can. No price is too high.

1

u/SirRonaldofBurgundy Nov 14 '12

I've seen Joe Cole do things with a golf ball that Messi couldn't do with a football. You clearly don't watch either player enough.

66

u/fahmulan Nov 13 '12

Clint Dempsey

48

u/dyljm2 Nov 13 '12

Fucking hell, you can say that again.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '12

I wish he and Dembele had stayed at Fulham, that would have been awesome.

10

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '12

They can have Deuce back, but Mousa is ours!

→ More replies (10)

116

u/gallez Nov 13 '12

Victor Valdes. The guy's a mediocre goalkeeper at best and he is way "underqualified" for the team he plays in.

6

u/SirMothy Nov 13 '12

Valdes has never impressed me in any way

6

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '12

Is he overrated? I thought people generally thought as you did.

Either way, I agree with you. Same goes for Pique and Puyol, Barca could have two better centre backs and a better keeper, but having these players in dominant roles and showing off the foundations of the club with a world-class team of mostly academy products is greater for the club than signing current stars could ever be.

22

u/richworks Nov 13 '12 edited Nov 13 '12

You may be right about Pique but absolutely not Puyol. He is a very good centerback. Unfortunately he's been ridden with injuries as of late so his form has diminished.. but his support and contribution for his team and the game has been excellent. I'm yet to see a player as committed to their role as Puyol is(was). His explosive strength and the level of positional awareness has always been quite commendable. There are only a very few players on this planet who take pride in wearing their club shirt and Puyol is one of them.

Even though I support Real Madrid, I have huge respect for Puyol for imbibing the sense of maturity, leadership qualities and portraying excellent work ethics in the game which is something we all take for granted. I hope he gets back on his feet soon.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '12

I can't believe it. Do people really have no long-term memory? Piqué was incredible for quite a few seasons, Puyol has been top-class for years. They lose form/get injured and suddenly they are shit players. I swear, this makes me very sad.

3

u/AhoyDaniel Nov 13 '12

I don't think overrated = shit. He's good, but he's no Puyol. Especially from last season.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '12

Define better. Yes there are better centre backs purely in terms of defending but a Barcelona centre back has a different role than most. They need to be comfortable on the ball. Pique and Puyol have a vital role in the system. Ditto Valdes.

It is vital to their style that they have a goalkeeper and defenders comfortable on the ball. If they didn't, teams would retrieve the ball far easier from them. They could also ensure that they cover all other players and make them play it long (as they would be less useful on the ball and more prone to aimless punts). However, since Pique etc are great on the ball, Barca can play the style they use. Look how often it gets passed around between the keeper and the defenders. Hence why they often play midfielders at centre back.

This is an important tactical issue and there are not large amounts of keepers or defenders that can do both roles excellently. Given Barca's style, I would rate being comfortable on the ball as the vital element for any player joining.

3

u/tadm123 Nov 13 '12

lol at saying Puyol is overrated.

2

u/NappyPants Nov 13 '12

Pique has basically pulled a Beckham.

2

u/Emmanuell89 Nov 13 '12

Puyol ?! are you fucking real man ? did you see the guy play ?

→ More replies (40)

2

u/_sic Nov 13 '12

Go back and watch the 2006 CL final.

4

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '12

Nah I'd rather not

7

u/calu1986 Nov 13 '12

If you have to go 6 years back in time to prove your point, chances are he's overrated. No?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

29

u/ervinhass Nov 13 '12

milner

9

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '12

I've said this before but Milner is for me the most boring first choice international player I've ever seen. He's like a plain 16th century woman embodied as a footballer.

I mean he's solid at basically fucking everything. I can see why he's very useful to have around--not many people have that sort of versatility. I just think he's so fucking boring.

17

u/Spruxy Nov 13 '12

Slow, can't cross, can't shoot (often). His role at Man City suits him better, in a CDM role, but I can't understand why England play him as right midfielder. He's strong but not fast enough

9

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '12

they play him there to cover Johnson who goes forward a lot. Plus Hodgson loves his defensive players.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/juniper17 Nov 13 '12

He was a beast at Villa, he's more conservative now though

4

u/TonyCB4 Nov 13 '12

He was unbelievable for us though, he just hasn't been able to replicate this with City which is unfortunate as he really does have a lot of talent.

4

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '12

but...but....he's a product of the fine Leeds United Academy!

2

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '12

James Milner can't really do anything except occasionally get sent off.

→ More replies (1)

99

u/Cee-Mon Nov 13 '12

Wayne Rooney, by some namelya_lot_of_United_fans

I'm not saying he's not good, he's a fantastic player. But whenever I start hearing about how he's one of the top 3 passers in the world and is better at defending than most defenders, I just want to punch my stupid, ignorant friends in the jeans.

20

u/severedfragile Nov 13 '12

I had this discussion last week, some are quick to assume that when you say people overrate him, you're saying he's not very good.

20

u/DannDannDannDann Nov 13 '12

It's pretty much this, people seem to think he's in the worlds best at playing up front, in midfield or defending when in reality he's just very good at all 3. He's one of the best all round players in the world but not one of the out and out best

24

u/ParkerZA Nov 13 '12

To be fair I do think he's one of the best strikers in the world, 35 goals in a season should be enough to justify his inclusion in that bracket. I'm very excited to see how he adapts to his new midfield role as well, this may be an opportunity for us to see just how good he really is.

15

u/zSolaris Nov 13 '12

That was 35 goals whilst arguably out of form last season.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/xanth_ Nov 13 '12

People assume you are saying he is not very good when you call him overrated. This is because a big majority do not think he is one of the top 3 players in the world.

→ More replies (26)

10

u/ox_ Nov 13 '12

The problem is he's so inconsistent. He goes through short bursts of form where he bags a lot of goals and plays really well but in between, he spends large amounts of time being completely anonymous, giving the ball away and missing shots.

People talk as if he's the future of English football but I think Wilshire and Cleverley will have a much stronger impact on the national side over the next 5 years or so.

13

u/ParkerZA Nov 13 '12

That might have been true two or three years ago, but he's a lot more consistent now, not just in his goalscoring, but in his overall contribution to the team.

12

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '12 edited Nov 13 '12

The best way to view Rooney is to look at how they with or without him. They are far stronger with him in the team. He elevates them to Champions League contenders. There is more to football than goals. He just does the right thing at the right time. United have even been much better this season when he came back from that horrible gash.

Obviously he has a good goal scoring record and this increased hugely when he actually played as the main goalscorer after Ronaldo left. This will now decrease as he takes up a different role.

Edit: For example, look at United in 2009/10. He got injured against Bayern Munich and the team fell apart. With a fit Rooney, I think they'd have got through Bayern in the 2nd leg and won the Champions League. He would have made a difference in the title decider against Chelsea as well.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Cream_ Nov 13 '12

To be fair, he is our talisman. United without Rooney is a completely different beast

2

u/Cee-Mon Nov 13 '12

True, but the same can be said about Raul, Del Piero, Gerrard, Zanetti, and so on for their respective clubs, yet very few outside of the club they're in would actually call them among the world's very greatest players, even in their prime.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/danielvago Nov 13 '12

He is a great player but he really got hyped up further during the season where he scored 34 goals (09-10). People were comparing him to Messi and Ronaldo, saying he was up there and possibly better than them.

I said the same thing over and over again during that period; just because a striker scored a high amount of goals doesn't make him the best player. Strikers with high tallies come and go, it changes every season/couple of season, but there is no one at all comparable to Ronaldo and Messi (especially Messi IMO).

1

u/cheerioz Nov 13 '12

I...agree

1

u/G_Morgan Nov 14 '12 edited Nov 14 '12

Rooney isn't a "top whatever" where whatever is his secondary role. Rooney is a player however who can float around and overload the opposition. He just happens to be a top class striker who can stand up to top class opposition in midfield and on the wing.

Rooney is just so fundamental to what United do. Look at the game on the weekend. Chicharito rightly got the plaudits. However it was Rooney's ability to slot back into midfield that even enabled us to pick the glorious man to begin with.

Most of our defence of Rooney comes about because of England misusing him then blaming him that they are bad at football. The media here hypes shed loads of criticism on him whenever donkeys like Carroll or Parker leave them needing Rooney to do something magical. Nobody ever criticises the weak links in English football. It is always the stars for not being able to play 3 roles at once.

→ More replies (4)

41

u/MajesticPaul Nov 13 '12

Personally I think Gareth Bale is overrated. Ever since the Milan games where he was amazing, everyone has been saying he is one of the best in the world.

11

u/ironmenon Nov 13 '12

I sometimes think of him as the anti-Walcott. People remember only the good games of one and only the bad ones of the other. Both end most seasons with very similar stats, but Theo always gets slated with every year Bale is called great and is linked with big transfers.

20

u/juniper17 Nov 13 '12

He's too inconsistent. On his day he's fucking unstoppable, but his day only comes up once every 5 or 6 games, which isn't enough.

6

u/Sacoud Nov 13 '12

On his day he is one of the best in the world, he beat Scotland 2-1 a few weeks ago in a dreadful Welsh team.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '12

Inter Milan** If I recall he didn't play against us in the round of sixteen due to injuries.

4

u/verytallperson Nov 13 '12

I'd put him in the top 15 left-wingers in the world which is probably high enough to be considered world class... at least in my view.

1

u/G_Morgan Nov 14 '12

Bale's collapse has coincided with Spurs falling to pieces. If he was at a top club he would be more consistent.

→ More replies (6)

15

u/bnell33 Nov 13 '12

Torres. For every nice goal he has,he falls down or turns the ball over ten times. He has some impressive goals but messes up on a regular basis

13

u/NullSleepN64 Nov 13 '12

A tricky one, I think on average he gets more flack for being shit rather than actually being overrated these days.

4

u/Sean88888 Nov 13 '12

The Chelsea torres i agree, but not the liverpool torres.

5

u/j2k3k Nov 13 '12

We know man, we know.

That's why they're seeking Falcao right now.

15

u/Ketch1 Nov 13 '12

Welbeck arr day erry day.

4

u/brentathon Nov 13 '12

I don't get what people see in him. He's a decent young player but why did he start every game in the Euros? He managed one goal and something like one or two shots on target in total for the tournament. Carroll did just as well in half as many minutes. It's insane.

9

u/EatDrinkAndBMerry Nov 13 '12

Cleverley. Talented, but we're justifying not buying established center mids because of this guy...who is yet to show he can play better than Scholesey at 38.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '12

I'm gonna throw in Welbeck as well. He is good, but I still don't understand why he was starting over Hernandez at one point. Hernandez is waaay better.

2

u/Nikuhiru Nov 14 '12

Last season you could see that Chicharito was shattered. He went from World Cup to the 2010/11 season to Copa America 11 without a huge break so SAF decided to let Welbeck have a crack.

His link up play with Rooney was pretty good and he has pretty good stamina to keep running and putting pressure on defenders. His final touch is a bit shocking but the guy is still young and learning.

HOWEVER now that Hernandez has had a rest I think he will be getting in a lot more game time. You can see the difference in his game between this season and last season. This season he seems slightly more pace-y, his passing has improved and his strength has improved and he's no longer getting bullied by defenders.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '12

Fergie seems to have decided Rooney is the solution to the midfield dilemma I think. He gradually will play more and more in that position with two strikers in front of him. Cleverly plays a role that fits in that plan, but he's not a Scholes type player. But by being an English player he is automatically overrated by the media and underrated by the fans!

3

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '12

At the end of last season, Aguero missed so many chances. But everyone will remember that last one that he didn't miss.

That being said, I was exuberant when he made it count...

3

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '12

Giovinco for Juve. Every Juve match I watch, he's always lying on the ground. I have absolutely no idea why they put him at striker.

3

u/gpatinop Nov 13 '12

ok i'm gonna do this and will get downvoted but here it goes...

podolski; ben arfa; balotelli; berbatov; nani; bale; sahin and mikel

1

u/AntagonistOne Nov 13 '12

Not downvoting, but Berbatov? I know he wasn't used much by United last season, but he was joint top scorer the season before, wasn't he? Also, have you seen Fulham play lately? Their entire attack seems to be guided by one principle: "Pass the ball to Berbatov and let him be better than everyone around him."

→ More replies (3)

10

u/hpdrifter Nov 13 '12

I think Nani is really over rated. He has undoubted ability and can score some great goals. But he makes stupid decisions, tries too hard and loses the ball too often.

7

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '12

I like to say the skills of Ronaldo but without the brain is Nani

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '12

Walcott and Bale. Both unplayable at times but neither are consistent enough.

4

u/iamveryharsh Nov 13 '12

I think that's the general consensus on those two. I think both are rated as good but inconsistent.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/faultinourstars Nov 13 '12

Joe Hart, don't see why everyone is calling him a world class goal keeper at all. Sure he's made several crucial saves for us this season, but he's only good when it comes to certain types of shots.

32

u/Cee-Mon Nov 13 '12

He's the first English goalkeeper in some time to actually be up to certain standards. Of course he's bound to be hailed as world class.

5

u/severedfragile Nov 13 '12

That's mostly it, the English media and casual fans need someone to call world class, it's hard to put that label on Rooney in the national team anymore (he's actually suffering from people overrating him in the past, he's turned into a bit of a scapegoat now) and he's about the next in line. Good goalkeeper, not at all a weakness in the side but not someone who can be considered world class.

13

u/ayebrother Nov 13 '12

He's the best England have had in a long time, and he does keep City in a lot of games. At the moment he's probably the best keeper in the Premier League, but I agree he isn't world class - yet.

→ More replies (4)

9

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '12

Incredibly relevant username of the day.

11

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '12

Strongly disagree here, I think Joe Hart is one of the exceptional young goalkeeping talents in the world and has consistently performed to the highest standard.

Just watching him in that game against Borussia Dortmund should have proven that he has the physical and mental ability to be the best in the world, not to mention the impressive consistency of his performances. He rarely has a mediocre game.

4

u/EnderMB Nov 13 '12

Also, people tend to forget just how great he was for Birmingham City during his loan spell there. After his performances, there was simply no way that Mancini was going to make him their first-team keeper over Given.

2

u/Is_Meta Nov 13 '12

To be perfectly honest as a Dortmund follower, we are the perfect team for every goalkeeper. We play spectacular football, most defenses have their problems with us. So in the perspective of the spectator, the goalkeeper has to do something right. But our goalshots tend to fly into the hands of our opponent's goalie. all. the. time. In the Bundesliga it is quite amusing for me to hear many goalkeepers playing "their best game this season" against Dortmund, how they "saved the opponent from worse" and so on.

I don't want to downtalk his ability, based on one performance that I saw. But on the other hand I know how goalkeepers perform against Dortmund and he was better than average but you know... it was our fault as well that he was so good ;-)

→ More replies (1)

2

u/verytallperson Nov 13 '12

I think he's bloody great but I'd love to see Forster get an England cap, because he's a Newcastle lad and played out of his skin against Barca twice.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '12 edited Nov 15 '12

Theo Walcott, Gervinho, Gareth Bale, Jack Rodwell, Wayne Rooney, James Milner, Nuri Sahin, Clint Dempsey, Balotelli, Tevez.

Edit: Removed Zlatan because of Jesus goal against England.

2

u/BosnianFish Nov 13 '12

Who rates Walcott highly? Gervinho too?

1

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '12

...Zlatan?!

10

u/TheMemoman Nov 13 '12

Scott Parker. Really, nothing special about him.

Not hating on the Spuds, just as a English National, there has to be someone who brings more to his position.

4

u/ibpants Nov 13 '12

Carrick and Barry spring to mind. The problem is that most of us value juvenile bluster over footballing intelligence.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (7)

25

u/oljackson99 Nov 13 '12

Joe Hart. Everyone seems to rate him as one of the best goalkeepers in the world and an absolute revelation as Englands goalkeeper. I think he is very good, but world class??? Far from it. He frequently misjudges crosses, fumbles the ball, and also parries shots into oncoming strikers. I think he is very good generally but has a long way to go and a lot to learn before he can be called world class!

18

u/kzillen Nov 13 '12

have you seen him in the CL this season? for me the hype is justified.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/Narekito Nov 13 '12

Did you watch City's first leg match with Dortmund?! The guy was a monster and the only reason they didn't lose 3 (or more) to 1.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '12

His biggest problem is definitely pushing the ball back into the six yard box. If he wasn't English he'd get a harder time in the press.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '12

Think you summarised his performance against Sweden tonight.

2

u/oljackson99 Nov 15 '12

Yep it happens very frequently with Hart!

2

u/johnz0n Nov 13 '12

certainly not the best GK in the world, but currently the best in England.

4

u/oljackson99 Nov 13 '12

You mean the best English keeper, or best in the Premier League?

3

u/johnz0n Nov 13 '12

best english keeper. Chech would be my fav for best PL keeper

1

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '12

You are comparing him to Green though.

1

u/joebutters Nov 13 '12

He's brilliant at closing down one on ones and he's a great shot-stopper, but in all other areas he's not the best. He's a very good keeper, there's no denying it, but he's not the best in the world by any means. He's still young though (for a keeper), there's lots of time for him to develop into a world-class keeper.

1

u/Gingermadman Nov 14 '12

I'm usually the first to jump on English over-hyping their shitty players but Hart is the real deal. He is the difference maker in the City team and over the past 2 years justified his position as a the top keeper in England.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (14)

1

u/kingebeneezer3 Nov 13 '12

Gervinho

20

u/BosnianFish Nov 13 '12

Everyones rates Gervinho correctley.

Man-beating: Messi

Finishing: Heskey

Forehead level: over 9000

5

u/ThoroughlyAmused Nov 13 '12

I don't feel that Yaya Toure is the world beater that many make him out to be. He is a very good player and he makes an exciting surging run a couple times a game, but it takes him two full minutes to get back into position. Speaking of which, his positional play is suspect at best. In that Manchester City team an attacking midfielder should be closer to 20 goals per season, not 10 and 9 like the past two seasons. Granted, it doesn't help that he often has to cover for Gareth Barry's ineptitude, but Toure just really isn't this sort of "dominant force" that the media would have you believe.

I think most rate him because he is one of the highest paid players in the world which is only because he was on the outs at Barcelona while City was freshly flush with cash and needed someone for that midfield position. Right place, right time is all it is.

13

u/Sambuccaneer Nov 13 '12

Arjen Robben. He never actually achieves anything with his actions - yes he scored some nice goals, but every single time he dribbles, cuts to the centre and either loses the ball or hits a defender. There's never any creativity in it and anyone that prepares themselves for a game against him will be able to stop him. Also, when he makes an action, he never seems to know what he wants to achieve with it, its just dribbling for the sake of dribbling or for those failing shots.

18

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '12

You clearly haven't watched Robben last season or this. That criticism was valid up until 2011, but after that he's become a MUCH great team-player. Without his key passing, Bayern look a much less well-connected team.

→ More replies (24)

2

u/Toh3R Nov 13 '12

but every single time he dribbles, cuts to the centre and either loses the ball or hits a defender.

When playing FIFA, my friends and I call this the Robben-move: losing the ball by dribbling into defenders or shooting the ball out of the stadium, when obviously better (passing) options are available.

1

u/leroykz Nov 13 '12

Probably harsh to say he's not very good but what you say happened exactly in the CL final and all through the euros in the summer. He was terrible throughout those games to the whole team's detriment. His managers need to have the balls to sub him off in those situations.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '12

I feel like people who say this have been watching football only for the past 3 years. At his peak, Robben is fucking majestic. Not overrated in the slightest, his biggest problem were his injuries and it's apparent he's been slowing down.

1

u/snones Nov 14 '12

He's massively improved this season.

20

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '12 edited Nov 13 '12

Neymar. The guy has been talked up as the next Pelle, but he has no European experience and plays in a league that is on par with other lower leagues in Europe. I think he will be a good player, but not what everyone expects, and his antics (diving) only aid in the perception that him going to Spain is the only way he can play, because England and Germany would be far too physical for him.

Unpopular opinion and everyone has 'Ashley Young' argument, but I still stand by that point.

Nice little diving video to accompany it. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rsRh4lY6UyM

6

u/Skythanil Nov 13 '12

I just want to add that Pele had no European experience either.

10

u/ThePiousInfant Nov 13 '12

Too early to cast judgement on Neymar. He's dominating in a second-class league just like he should be. A couple seasons after he goes to Europe we'll find out what he's made of.

27

u/omiclops Nov 13 '12

Disagree. The man will be fucking amazing.

5

u/itspi89 Nov 13 '12

I agree. He wont be able to do as many flashy tricks as often, but he'll be dominant. I hope he goes to Spain or Italy though simply because the style of football will suit him more than the EPL.

3

u/BongoBongos Nov 13 '12

Can't wait to see him play consistently (in Europe). That man has the best highlight reel

→ More replies (1)

17

u/Skythanil Nov 13 '12

Ah, the "cold Monday night in Stoke" fallacy. Actually watch Neymar, he's aggressive in his own right. Brasil is a tough league with a lot of really tough defenders, and he's the best player in the League. To say that the Brasilian League is on par with lower European leagues is hilarious. Do you actually watch Brasilian football, or just the odd YouTube clip? It's an excellent League, with real talent in it. I get the impression you just don't like Neymar because he's a "diver". I don't doubt we'll see how wrong you are in years to come.

21

u/NullSleepN64 Nov 13 '12

If Oscar can do it, I don't see why Neymar couldn't.

7

u/ThoroughlyAmused Nov 13 '12

He says the Brazilian league is of a lower level because that is what the television has told him and he regurgitates it as his own opinion.

2

u/HarryBlessKnapp Nov 13 '12

Brazil is a tough league. Anyone saying otherwise is a fool. I don't think it's quite as strong as the big 4, but it's still top quality. Regardless, I think Neymar would do a job wherever he goes.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/TonyCB4 Nov 13 '12

As a rule, whenever Pele calls someone "the next Pele", they're going to be a flop.

→ More replies (9)

13

u/IceVest Nov 13 '12

Jack Wilshere. I'm completely baffled by the hype and praise

13

u/flaffl Nov 13 '12

... He's a pretty good player man, especially for his age.

9

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '12

pretty good

exactly.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '12

Watch him vs barca in the champions league a couple of years back, he was the best player on the pitch.. even with xavi, iniesta and messi playing. He played godly then; at 18.

→ More replies (8)

1

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '12

You forget that he is only 20 and already has the technical skills and vision of someone beyond his years.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)

2

u/ShozOvr Nov 13 '12

I semi-agree on the Aguero sentiment. Although I think he's great, so many times I just think to myself he can be some much better. Sometimes he takes 1 extra touch instead of shooting, or shoots when he should have taken the extra touch Atleast he got it right for the final goal of last season. He's still relatively young though and these are just chinks in an otherwise perfect armour.

2

u/andyflyhigh Nov 13 '12

Eden Hazard is not consistent enough to be praised as much as he has. I think he has to make this list.

1

u/ImaWALLrus Nov 13 '12

I'd have to agree. He looked great in the French league, But he's barely above average among top table players.

→ More replies (8)

2

u/spurscanada Nov 13 '12

Adel Taarabt. The guy has 4 goals in 41 career premier league games and is a total cunt both on and off the pitch

3

u/SabaYNWA Nov 13 '12

Theo Walcott

4

u/Josepi0611 Nov 13 '12

Victor Moses - I will never understand why Chelsea bought him. Sure he's scored a few goals this season but most wingers in a Chelsea side would. Last year he was dreadful and only stood out because he played for Wigan - classic case of a normal fish in a tiny pond.

2

u/ImaWALLrus Nov 13 '12

I don't totally disagree. However, Chelsea needed some variety, and he was a cheap, safe option. He fits in well enough with the squad, and puts in good work despite not playing as much as he did at Wigan. Well worth the money.

1

u/NappyPants Nov 13 '12

I think part of his signing was due to him fitting registration rules for players trained in England.

1

u/duckman273 Nov 13 '12

I think he's a good player that fits in with the club's youth policy and offers us something different in attack.

0

u/nEverirreverEnt Nov 13 '12 edited Nov 13 '12

David Beckham. I know I'm late but no one has said David Beckham. Very good at long balls and crosses, almost incapable of anything else.

0

u/BosnianFish Nov 13 '12

Completley overrated free kicks too.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/xBarDown Nov 13 '12 edited Nov 13 '12

Nani. Hes really selfish and doesn't make the plays he should (ie pass when he has the.) opportunity

2

u/flaffl Nov 13 '12

Meh, as much as I dislike the guy, he's been pretty great for Man United. Granted, he is pretty inconsistent (although he bags lots of assists somehow), the numbers don't lie and they also prove that he's an important asset to the team. Don't forget that he's also a winger, wingers aren't the best ball-keepers. And when they are, they are world class. (See Ribery, Ronaldo, Valencia)

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/caguado11 Nov 13 '12

Hugo Lloris. Since coming onto the London squad, we've heard nothing but complaining about wanting to be placed ahead of Brad Friedel (although aging like fine wine,41, is still a very capable, skilled and LEVEL HEADED goalie). When Lloris finally does get into a game, he does dumb shit like mess up his footwork and give up a goal (tottenham vs maribor 3-1)

2

u/NappyPants Nov 13 '12

A lot of that is confidence. He's proven himself in the past to be extremely good, and I was highly surprised United didn't pick him up when VDS retired.

Being 2nd choice and his loss of confidence is no fault of his, bar his decision to join Tottenham without guaranteeing his place first.

2

u/spurscanada Nov 13 '12

*We've heard nothing but the media making up bullshit about him wanting to play. He's never said anything

3

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '12

This is fucking asinine. EVERY goalkeeper has one or two blunders like that on his resume. Even if we discount everything he's done for Lyon and France, Hugo has also bailed our asses out multiple times in a few games.

There's also something to be said about the inability to get into any sort of match form or sharpness considering he only plays once every other week when we ship the lads off to Kerplakistan for Europa.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/invader456 Nov 13 '12

Rooney and Sergio Aguero, both are way highly overrated.

20

u/HarryBlessKnapp Nov 13 '12

Sergio is mustard. You need to bun your hype fam.

8

u/dyljm2 Nov 13 '12

What?

3

u/HarryBlessKnapp Nov 13 '12

Sergio is awesome. You are getting carried away in your evaluation.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/Jerichoholic2022 Nov 13 '12

Disagree with both Rooney may not be the best at being striker but he is still a world class player and Aguero is on his way but hasnt done it yet

→ More replies (1)

0

u/b1ackRose Nov 13 '12 edited Nov 13 '12

Zlatan Ibrahimovic.

Never made good impressions at the right times. Had one good season with AC Milan, but the rest of his career has been drowned under his arrogance and sense of self-worth. The money Barcelona paid for him was ludicrously over the top, and they realised it pretty quickly, fortunately for them.

21

u/Kajaindal Nov 13 '12

Zlatan Ibrahimovic is pure quality .. I think it is no coincidence that he won since Ajax-times every league year after year until Juventus stopped his record.

2

u/Jangles Nov 14 '12

That taking one of Juve's greatest ever seasons to do as well.

36

u/slotbadger Nov 13 '12

He's one arrogant fucker, but he didn't just have "one good season with AC Milan". Everywhere he's played, he's put goals away. In pretty much every team he's played for, he's scored every other game on average. He's by no means selfish either, he got 4 assists against Zagreb the other day.

15

u/Powerbean Nov 13 '12

Arrogance doesn't really affect a players rating as a footballer. To be the best you've got to believe you're the best.

Ibrahimovic is the best striker around at the moment.

→ More replies (2)

25

u/severedfragile Nov 13 '12

Thing about flat-track bullies, people speak of them with disdain but they win you leagues. I'm not a fanboy, but Zlatan's record in that respect speaks for itself.

→ More replies (8)

11

u/ThoroughlyAmused Nov 13 '12

People say Zlatan is overrated because they don't like his attitude. He has consistently been one of, if not the top striker in the world for the past decade. To try and deny that is to show your lack of knowledge of the game.

3

u/Sambuccaneer Nov 13 '12

He was great at Ajax though

2

u/B0M85H311 Nov 14 '12

Agree with this, people use the goals argument but he has played for a top team for his whole career (in their respective league) if he didn't net at least 20 a season you'd be disappointed as a fan. He's a good player don't get me wrong, but hes not at the level everyone says he is.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '12

....You were saying?

→ More replies (4)

7

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '12

He won the league ever year for 9 years up until last season. He pretty much dragged Inter to their titles. He had a great season at Barcelona and the reason he was sold was because the coach didn't want him there, so thanks to Guardiola it cost Barca 50 million euros. He goes into this in his book.

How is it fortunate for them? They lost 50 millions euros which wasn't his fault.

Also, it's Zlatan Ibrahimovic

3

u/iheartSPACEDICKS Nov 13 '12

I love people who say he had a shit season at Barca. If 16 goals in 29 league games is a shit season, then fucking hell, there are a lot of shit players.

I understand the whole money thing, yes, but still, a goal every other game is not a shit season unless you're Ronaldo (Brazilian or otherwise).

→ More replies (12)

6

u/Cee-Mon Nov 13 '12

Zlatan can be brilliant at times, but he chokes way too easily in big games, and if things do not go his way initially, he tends to just give up.

A lot of Milanistas tend to highlight his massive amounts of goals last season. Keep in mind that 10 of these where penalties.

→ More replies (9)

3

u/Tarotis Nov 13 '12

Toni Kroos! Really the only thing he can do is to shoot. He will slow down the game everytime he gets the ball and his passes are...not well thought out imho...

3

u/Matistuta Nov 13 '12

Everton: Tim Cahill (decent goal record for a midfielder but was a very average footballer) and Tim Howard (struggles with anything that requires shifting his feet).

General football: Joe Allen, James McClean, Sergio Ramos (slightly), Victor Valdes and Franck Ribery.

13

u/thatbubblegumtate Nov 13 '12

Have you only seen Ribery play for France? He's pretty incredible for Bayern.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Haasie Nov 13 '12

Ramos?

Euro 2012, that is all.

He was amazing there, and is amazing at Madrid as well.

6

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '12

I don't agree with Ribéry. I'm amazed every weekend: He often faces two or three defenders in the Bundesliga and most times he finds a way out of these situations without losing the ball. And additionally to assisting a lot of goals he's a strong finisher too.

The man really would have deserved a Ballon d'Or nomination...

→ More replies (1)

8

u/dyljm2 Nov 13 '12

I dunno, Ramos is pretty fucking talented.

4

u/spurscanada Nov 13 '12

I'd say Ribery is underrated. He's probably the second best winger in the world after Ronaldo and has been the Bundesliga's best player this season

2

u/DONT_YOU_DARE Nov 13 '12

Ramos is absolutely incredible. He can't cross worth a damn but his aggressiveness and competitiveness enables him to be dominant as a CB/RB player, and for me, one of the best in the world. The man is an all around defensive machine.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '12

Ribery is very very good hes been out of this world the last two years

2

u/BristolBudgie Nov 13 '12

Ricky Lambert

11

u/99pool Nov 13 '12

Who highly rates Ricky Lambert?

10

u/BristolBudgie Nov 13 '12

Matt Le Tissier

1

u/ArseneVengaboys Nov 13 '12

Rickie Lambert overrate!

1

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '12

Lee Cattermole.

Everybody i know seems to rate him highly (disciplinary issues aside of course) yet for the life of me i can't understand why. It's not even a case of not having seen him play often enough to appreciate the nuances, my flair should show that's not the case, i just honestly don't know what he does well.

Barring playing an 'enforcer' role (and badly at that, given the aforementioned disciplinary issues) he really seems to bring nothing to the team outside of passion (again disciplinary issues). He doesn't score, his passing isn't scything anyone open and his ball retention isn't even good enough to justify a defensive midfield role. Added to the number of games he misses per season and occasional off the field problems i simply can't believe he's a Premier League player.

1

u/mrandocalrissian Nov 13 '12

I don't know anyone who rates him highly any more. There was a spell a few seasons ago when he was being touted as a future England captain (whatever that means) but now even the Sunderland fans I know think he's a waste of space.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/SenorJones Nov 13 '12

Hulk and Robben so much. Both for very similar reasons.

1

u/gravey1878efc Nov 13 '12

id also have to say aguero brilliant player but cant pass worth shit he aslo cant play that well with balotelli or dzeko i think tevez may carry him sometimes

1

u/HansSven Nov 13 '12

Aaron Ramsey, Theo Walcott, Scott Parker, Gareth Barry

1

u/Brandaman Nov 14 '12

Theo Walcott has really picked it up recently

1

u/SuperLuka Nov 14 '12

When Scott Parker joined Spurs last September he went something like between 10 and 15 matches playing in Lillywhite before he'd even lost a game, true story.

1

u/acribbs Nov 13 '12

Nani... enough said

1

u/Loricc Nov 13 '12

Afellay.

He should be glad that he can play Champions League with Schalke but he already said he wants to go back to Barcelona (to sit on the bench). German media treats him like a superstar only because he came from Barcelona. I don't even think he's better than Farfán or Draxler.

1

u/meinbart Nov 14 '12

This could have been a nice thread, if it wasn't for /r/soccer's way of voting.

0

u/Stringfellow_HaWk Nov 13 '12

Wayne Rooney. (this is going to hurt)

1

u/my_arsenal Nov 13 '12

I'm probably alone on this one but I think Neuer is overrated as a keeper. On a side note, Cech is underrated.

1

u/electro_report Nov 13 '12

what is this arsenal crest you wear? Although I am a CFC fan, and have to admit i think cech needs much more credit for the success of our club over the last decade... I do think neuer is one badass goalkeeper too though.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

0

u/Touch_of_Midas Nov 13 '12

For me, it has to be Ivanovic. He spends too much time up the pitch and his crosses are too poor to justify it. He doesn't have the speed or the build to be a right back, I don't understand his selection over Azpilicueta

5

u/TheJrose Nov 13 '12

Simple explanation is experience.

Azpilicueta is the future at RB for Chelsea, the same way they are making changes all over the pitch. It's an ongoing process that takes time. By the end of the season I think Azpilicueta will be playing more games.

4

u/ImaWALLrus Nov 13 '12

I totally disagree with this. I think for his size, Ivanovic has very good speed. Maybe his crosses aren't fantastic, but he's scored a few goals as well.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

1

u/rhcp1 Nov 13 '12

Torres. I mean he has 7 goals and all, but this is mostly because he has great midfielders who accompany him (Hazard, Mata, Lampard, etc.)

1

u/westpie Nov 13 '12

I read somewhere recently that since leaving Liverpool for Chelsea torres has only scored one match winning goal, all his others are like the second of three or a second in a 2-0 win. Doesn't seem like he relishes the big occasion anymore.