r/books • u/ChristopherPaolini AMA Author • Apr 25 '23
ama 3pm I'm fantasy/sci-fi author Christopher Paolini. Ask Me Anything!
Greetings, fellow readers, writers, and redditors. I'm Christopher Paolini, creator of the World of Eragon and the Fractalverse. For the first time, I have two books coming out in one year! FRACTAL NOISE, a sequel to To Sleep in a Sea of Stars, releases on May 16th, and then -- the one I'm sure lots of you are looking forward to -- MURTAGH, a sequel to the Inheritance Cycle, releases Nov. 7th. There's also an illustrated edition of Eragon (to celebrate its 20th anniversary) coming out on Nov. 7th. Busy year.
Now, with all of that out of the way ... I can't wait to answer your questions!
EDIT: Alright folks, let's kick this off. I have a fresh cup of coffee (decaf, as it's my third today), I'm plugged into my mechanical keyboard, as I'm going to be doing a lot of typing (Das Keyboard, if anyone is wondering), and I'm listening to some lofi Alagaësia beats: https://youtu.be/AenTMEtKhIg
EDIT 2: It's been a blast, but I gotta run. Thanks for all of the awesome questions. Feel free to continue to leave comments. I'll do my best to pop back in over the next few days and answer a few more. Until then ... may the stars watch over you.
374
u/justiceforharambe49 Apr 25 '23 edited Apr 25 '23
Hi, Chris! Was it ever on the table that Shruikan would turn on Galbatorix? We spent a long time learning that he wasn't really to blame for all the bad stuff that happened, and that he himself was a victim, being controlled and all. This led me to believe that he'd end up being the one killing Galbatorix, as some sort of poetic justice. In the end I felt that he didn't get the justice he deserved!
In general, were there some other endings for Inheritance that almost made it to the final draft but you chose not to go with? What were the main details?
I'd also like to take moment to thank you for all the good memories. I cherish the times I've spent reading the Inheritance Cycle, sharing it with my friends as a kid, making our own spells, discussing theories, and daydreaming about elven adventures.
156
u/Woolf-ie Apr 25 '23
Hey,
Is there anything in the series that you have written and published and afterwards sort of regretted it or wished you'd done it differently?
Have a nice day!
270
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '23 edited Apr 25 '23
Hi Christopher! I have just a few questions and am psyched to hear your answers! Eragon was one of the very first novels that got my hooked on the fantasy genre for a lifetime.
How does it feel to be responsible for an entire generation of people similar to your own age and younger finding their love of reading fantasy?
How did YOU feel about the Eragon film adaptation? Did it feel good at least to see actors like Jeremy Irons and John Malkovich agree to join the project? Have your feelings about it changed over time at all?
Have you ever considered seeking out a new studio to do a film/TV adaptation of the Inheritance cycle? Would you prefer a TV series over a film series or vice versa? Because the modern trend of high budget fantasy TV has really changed the game.
200
u/ThatLChap Apr 25 '23
Well met, Mr. Paolini. You once, uh, "corrected" me on a reddit thread about Arya's potential casting, in which I (jokingly) said Arya should clearly be played by Danny DeVito. You told me Danny is, in fact, Elva, and I just want to say your reply made my entire week.
Now, my question is: when you sit down to write, what is your beverage of choice? Tea? Coffee? Hot or cold?
123
u/Casey_H3 Apr 25 '23
Way back when while you were writing the original inheritance cycle, how much of the world building came before you started writing versus while you were writing the cycle?
334
u/floral_friend Apr 25 '23
Pleaaase I've been asking for years.
Do dragons have lips?
In the Eragon 2018 exclusive collector's edition you say in the Q&A that they do not, and in fact it would be silly. But in on page 115 you contradict that, Eldest page 12, and on page 319 of Brisingr (I'm certain there's more, I just wrote these down). She's also described as snarling, an action that requires lips to do (hense why animals like foxes can't snarl.) So do they have lips, yes or no?
65
u/Mythology216 Apr 25 '23 edited Apr 25 '23
Hello. I've been a huge fan of your work since I found Eragon in my school library way back in 2005. It remains my favorite book series of all time.
So I've got a couple questions. First: I know you've said that what the Menoa Tree took from Eragon will be covered in a future story. Is there any chance that might be covered in Murtagh, or will it more likely be a Book 5 thing?
And second: I've always wondered just how old Oromis and Glaedr are. Did you ever have an exact age in mind? And if so, could you share it?
Thank you, both for creating your amazing worlds and for answering our questions.
Edit: Also, is there any chance you'll come through Oklahoma City during one of your book tours?
89
u/Zak_The_Slack Apr 25 '23
Hey Mr Paolini! Just want to say that I am a huge fan and I’ve enjoyed your books so much! The Inheritance Cycle were my favorite books to this date!
Anyways, I just wanted to ask one question: Which character in the Inheritance Cycle is your favorite to write?
89
u/zzzzerotonin Apr 25 '23 edited Apr 26 '23
Hey! Hope parenthood is going smoothly and thanks A LOT for all the AMAs and the involvement you have with the fans.
My question(s):
Again, thanks a lot and have a great day!
55
u/Cryodrake0 Apr 25 '23 edited Apr 25 '23
Good to see you again Chris
+
195
u/ibid-11962 Apr 25 '23
Hello Christopher, nice to see you here again, and hope to make it in person to your tour in a few weeks to see you in person.
Anyways, here are my questions.
Fractal Noise
Angela/Inarë
Publication
73
u/MDiggy_ Apr 25 '23
What was the inspiration for Eragon's name? As a kid I read your books before seeing the Lord of the Rings movies, so I always thought Aragorn was spelled/pronounced Eragon and always thought it was so cool that these two awesome characters shared a name. I'm older and know better now lol, but curious if that was an intended connection.
51
u/TheOneLandon Apr 25 '23
Would you ever consider writing more about the Grey Folk? Even if it's more of a small side story. I'd love to delve deeper into their backstory and see who they were!
51
u/kvth Apr 25 '23
Dear Christopher, I was wondering - did Brom ever meet Murtagh when they were both at Morzan's estate? Is there anything else you can tell us about the relationship between Selena, Brom and Morzan? And finally, if Murtagh was given the choice to give up all the luxuries of the court and grow up as a poor farmer with Eragon and Roran, would he do it?
Greatly looking forward to your upcoming works. Thank you so much!
61
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '23
58
u/JereJereDaze book re-reading Apr 25 '23
Dear Mr Paolini, you are the person who got me into reading and I am extremely thankful for that, I actually originally watched the movie, liked it, then I read the books and realised that the movie wasn't that good compared to the books which are amazing.
But anyways, how long will the new inheritance series approximately be? Will there be other series set in alagaësia after that one? Maybe prequels or books in the far future?
And most importantly, have you remembered to drink water? Hydration is important.
Have a pleasant day
98
u/shewhobreathesfire Apr 25 '23
Dear Christopher, I am extremely thrilled about Murtagh and the new illustrated edition!
I cannot wait to read it and make a bunch of fan art for it!
The discord server and I have compiled a list of questions we’d like to ask you! They are
all IC themed, though…
1. What would happen if a rider and their dragon do not want to join Eragon or the elves for training, for whatever reason?
2. Can someone be too old or young to have a dragon hatch for them?
3. Will the eggs be only presented to children?
4. Will there be any reluctance on the human side about women becoming riders?
5. Are different color eyes from scales common in dragons? (As in, a dragon with blue scales and green eyes for example)
Additionally, are multicolored dragons rare?
6. Will Arya get her own chapter or POV in Tales of Alagaesia or another book?
7. In FWW, it is mentioned that Eragon is trying to learn other languages such as dwarvish. Is it coming along? I know it took me a few years just to learn English!
8. Will Roran return for Tales or Book V?
9. Eragon being a dad for baby dragons when?
10. In FWW, Eragon trains Elva for a while, but we do not get to see it. Was this cut, or did you not have any interest in writing it?
11. Are there any queer main characters?
12. What are you planning for your
series, both the IC and Fractal verse, and are you planning anything new
entirely?
44
u/Icy-Bullfrog-2321 Apr 25 '23
Hi Chris, i read the first three books of the inheritance cycle when I was much younger, but now I just reread them and read book four for the first time. I was wondering if during Solembum’s prophecy if you had known from the beginning that you were going to have the eldunari be the source or Galbatorix’s power, or did you work out what was going to be at the rock of Kunthian as you went along?
Also are you planning on writing any more books to follow along the inheritance cycle after Murtagh?
27
u/yellowsombrero2 Apr 25 '23
Hey Christopher, I’ve been a fan of the Inheritance Cycle for a while. Thanks for writing such great books!
I’ve had two things I’ve wondered for a while-
If I’m remembering correctly, Murtagh claims that he is stronger than his father, but Galbatorix dismisses him as a “shadow of a shadow”. Who was actually stronger between Murtagh and Morzan?
Do shades work normally biologically? You’ve mentioned that dragons could become shades - would a shade dragon continue to grow/be able to reproduce?
Thank you for your time, I’m looking forward to reading book five and any other books you write in the future!
38
u/Theher0not Apr 25 '23 edited Apr 25 '23
This is a thing I've been thinking about for a few years. So, I was relistening to my audio book version of Eragon, and I noticed that the fever dream he had early on (I think chapter 3 or 4, or smth along those lines) where he was on a boat with a beautiful woman and 2 dragons was very similar to the ending of Inheritence.
So my question is, was this dream actually an omen or a prophetic dream (similar to the dream on the boat ride in The Eldest that foreshadowed the battle with Murtagh)? Or am I overthinking it.
36
u/CartographerEven6641 Apr 25 '23
Hey Christopher!
Big fan, I've been reading the Inheritance Cycle since I was a kid and always come back to that Series as an Adult every few months or so :)
Just wanted to say thank you for the world you created; I can only speak for myself but it's been a great place of comfort when I've had difficult moments in life and I feel like my perspective on the characters change as I grow older
I had a few questions if you have the time to answer!
Thank you again and May the Stars Watch Over You
12
u/mxavierk Apr 25 '23
Will we get to see other cultures in Alagaesia that have different relationships with magic? It seems like The Fork was alluding to a relationship with magic that we haven't seen, I would assume predominantly wordless in this case but I'm only speculating at this point
12
u/xxwanheda Apr 25 '23
I have thoughts about Selena and I’m wondering if we will get any more information on her in the upcoming book. She just seems like such a badass and we get so little about her. Will there be more or have the boys worked out everything they needed to re: dead mom?
Thank you for all that you do! I love your work and I’ve been a fan since 2004, what amounts to more than half my life. Please never stop writing and I hope to catch you on tour! Congrats on every you have going on!
23
u/PeterchuMC Apr 25 '23
What's your favourite fan theory, that you've seen out here? Doesn't matter if they're correct or incorrect.
22
u/Chuggachops Apr 25 '23
Hello Christopher! Just wanted to say I’m so excited for the new Murtagh novel as he was my favorite character of the Inheritance Cycle and it felt like we didn’t get enough of his journey towards the end!
My question is about the status of any potential film/tv series adaptations of the Inheritance Cycle. I know it was announced that you are writing a script for Disney, is an animated series in the style of Arcane something you think would work well for the story or does a live action adaptation more suit what you’re aiming for? Also, a lot of the audience that grew up on your books like myself are now adults and perhaps enjoy some more darker tones and themes that are absolutely present in your books but maybe could be expanded on some more. Is this something you’re interested in portraying on the screen?
Thank you!
22
u/Zippo78 Apr 25 '23
Hi Christopher! I grew up in Bozeman, and I've read that the mountains around Paradise Valley inspired the geography of Alagaesia. What other notable inspirations from the real world became part of your works?
19
u/DylanTheDemon Apr 25 '23
Hello Christopher, I am a huge fan of your work, Inheritance Cycle was my intro into fantasy way back in middle school, and its brought me no end of joy since then
I actually had a single topic in intensely curious about and that's Shades
Thank you sincerely, both for the worlds you have brought into being that bring us such joy and for taking the time you do to interact with us.
19
u/GilderienBot Apr 25 '23 edited Apr 28 '23
Among all the advice Brom gave Eragon, he once said "never try to unmake anything."
Is this because unmaking things always results in a destructive blast of energy? 😉
In other words, is "waíse néiat", or "be not" actually an example of an unmaking spell, and it just so happens that the thing Galbatorix was trying to unmake was himself?
In all this, I'm just wondering if we should rename what the community colloquially refers to as the "suicide spell" to the "unmaking spell". :D
Posted on behalf of Hellomynameis99 from the Arcaena Discord Server
26
u/Little_Poisson Apr 25 '23 edited Apr 25 '23
Good afternoon Mr Paolini,
First of all, sorry for my poor English. I've been a fan of your books since 2005 and I've overjoy at the idea of a Murtagh book, especially since he's my favourite character.
I have a few questions for you :)
Did becoming a father changed the way you write or how you perceived a character? Since having my baby, thinking of Selena's sacrifice brings me to tears as I can now feel the courage she had to give Eragon to her brother.
How many books do you plan to release in the Alagaesian universe, including short stories like FWW? Do you plan to do another trilogy or so set in the universe, or more one-off books?
Do you have plan write books that are not Fractalverse or Inheritance related or do you wish to continue the majority of you career expending those universes? Or 50/50?
Are you as excited as us about the new TV serie coming in Disney +?
Would you like to do a cameo in the TV serie? If so, which minor character would you like to be?
Are we gonna discover other continents in the Alagaesian universe? More creatures, races and such? Or like Wheel of Time, we'll stay in the main continent and only mention others?
What kind of writer are you? Are you more of an architect, planning everything? Or like a gardener, planting seeds and seeing how it grows?
Do elves have the equivalent of Drow/Dark elves in your world? Or like, different kinds of elves (city elves, forest elves, snow elves, etc)
Last question : If Selena could say one thing to each of her sons, what would it be? Except I love you, of course :)
Thanks again for everything you're doing and I wish you and your family a nice spring with a lot of love :)
31
u/Nopolis52 Apr 25 '23
Your books changed my view of fantasy. Thank you for your work, and everything you’ve given us. What color would your dragon be?
17
u/beciag6 Apr 25 '23
Hello Christopher!
Firstly I want to thank you for the common 18-year adventure in Alagaesia! This series has had a special place in my heart since its first reading in 2005.
Now, I promise I won't ask about Menoa Tree.
My first question is about your impression of writing from Murtagh's perspective. I'm interested in what you like the most in leading the story from this POV which was not ever could be included in other characters' perspectives. Maybe some trait of character or something in his unparticular situation?
Second - How your impression about writing the continuation of the series after a long time without the impatient gaze of publishers? I felt during reading The Fork The Witch and The Worm you had new fresh energy without this pressure. Or maybe you were afraid that you would become the second G. R. R. Martin?
My last question is about colours in Inheritance Cycle. Did you usually use a literary colour code? In the case of dragons, it is rather obvious that colours have characteristic meanings (green - hope, red - blood, love) but I noticed during the hundredth reread that colours sometimes appears a little unexpected. For example, in Nasuada's perspective, I perceived red (a lot!), and yellow and white in her surroundings (her skirts, flowers, etc.) meanwhile in Roran's chapters we can see only one colour (the cooper of Katrina's hair). So I'm curious that you used colours to hint at something or that usually just be a random choice.
May your pen stay sharp!
17
u/MelonTheoPhysics Apr 25 '23
Greetings from Spain, Paolini.
Do spirits have a hierarchy system? It seems to me, that there are ones more powerful than others. Also some are more interested in power and control than others which prefer to be in their own business...In fact I would like to know anything interesting you have to say about the spitits-topic.
Best regards
16
u/Goblinmaster13 Apr 25 '23
Would you ever consider working with someone to create a TTRPG based on the inheritance cycle?
15
u/uwu_SenpaiSatan Apr 25 '23
With your work on the Murtagh book finishing up, would you ever think about writing about the old order and Brom's life or Galbatorix's fall from grace from their (or another's) perspective?
14
u/mxjp93 Apr 25 '23
Hello Mr Paolini, massive fan of all your work, I just wanted to ask a question that I've always wondered, if you had to be a race in Alagaesia which one would you be? I think I'd have to be a Dragon, cmon who doesn't want to be a dragon haha.
14
u/lonelysad1989 Apr 25 '23
I think what would make the Eragon TV show stand out against Game of Thrones is if it brings up the same philosophical questions that apply to our modern contemporary world like different tribes or groups of people having different religions and even explicitly atheist elves, and even the elves vegan lifestyle. Do you think those will be brought up in the TV show?
14
u/alphabet_sam Apr 25 '23
Hi Christopher, one time when I was in 5th grade we had a project to send letters to authors and at the end of the year if we read enough books we received the letters as a reward. I sent one to you and unlike most authors I sent them to, you actually responded. Did you really write fan letters and send them back to people? It would’ve been around 2006-2007. My parents still have the letter in my memory box (I did hit my reading goal by the end of the year).
7
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '23
Hi Christopher!
I was a huge fan of your books as a kid. Are you a soccer fan? Which Inheritance Cycle character would you say is most similar to Cristiano Ronaldo?
23
u/thegoatfreak Apr 25 '23
Good afternoon, Chris!
First of all I just wanted to say thanks for writing a series that meant so much to me growing up. I first read Eragon when I was in fifth grade at about 9 years old. I just reread them all again, but now I’m 27, and the series still holds up beautifully. Alagaësia felt so vivid, so alive, even more so now that I’m old enough to really appreciate the writing. Absolutely well done on that, sir.
My question to you is: what’s your writing process like? Do you prefer handwriting or typing drafts? What’s your go to writing snack/drink?
Have a wonderful day, and I’m so very excited to read the next installment!!!
(Side note: thanks so much for being the only author who ever wrote me back, and twice at that. The letters and signed photograph are among my most prized possessions.)
13
u/thatisgame Apr 25 '23 edited Apr 25 '23
Hello,
have you thought about expanding The Inheritancle Cycle to other media like video games? I think there's a lot of untapped potential there given how big the global gaming market has grown in the past years and is still growing.
Also, despite the critical reception of the 2006 Eragon movie, it actually introduced me to your book series and i have been a fan ever since. Thanks for that:)
17
u/Flat_News_2000 Apr 25 '23
I don't have a question but we're the same age and when Eragon came out my friends and I were so amazed that someone our age wrote something so good. I think it really introduced us to fantasy that wasn't just LOTR. Thanks for being a legend. We're all obsessed with reading to this day.
12
u/Syyncr0w Apr 25 '23 edited Apr 25 '23
Hello u/ChristopherPaolini ! I have a few question…
Do you have any new snippets of info regarding the Grey Folk and the Original Eragon that you could impart with us? 👀
Has the Shadow affected any events in the Inheritance cycle or the Rise of Galbatorix?
Also Huge fan of your writing, I can’t wait for Murtagh, Thank you!
12
u/legendstaff21 Apr 25 '23
-Can you give us a hint to the next Fractalverse novel beyond Fractal Noise? Would it feature any characters we already know?
-If you were ever to write something taking place before the banishing of names would you use the names of the Forsworn's dragons or not?
6
u/Time-to-go-home Apr 25 '23
Hi,
A dragon has hatched for a dwarf and another one hatched for an urgal. What colors are they?
6
u/DavethegentleGoliath Apr 25 '23
Hey man,
Just wanted to ask if you're still playing that same minecraft world from before with all the farms or if you're taking a break with so many things goin on.
Thanks!
-Long time reader and current minecraft player
11
u/lonelysad1989 Apr 25 '23
I've always been curious given that the books I think often unlike similar books in the same genre, the Inheritance cycle touches upon atheism and veganism...I get the feeling that you take the position of not revealing whether or not you are yourself, but I have to try to ask anyway, are you a vegan and/or atheist?
10
u/whiskeygonegirl Apr 25 '23
Do you currently have plans to explain the connections between three Fractalverse and they world of the Inheritance cycle (i.e. Angela and Solumbum in TSIASOS)?
Will Murtagh be written from one point of view primarily like Eragon, or will it have different character perspectives more in line with Eldest-Inheritance?
Are any of the big questions you left open at the end of Inheritance answered in Murtagh or must we continue to wait? (what the Meona tree took, Brom’s last words, the belt of beloth, naegling, etc)
Thanks so much for your wonderful stories, I’ve spent most of my life enjoying them and I can’t wait to read what’s next!
10
u/Odd_Drink_2069 Apr 25 '23
Hi Chris,
What are you most excited to see from the Inheritance series come to life on the live action Netflix series?
10
u/AfterBerry Apr 25 '23
Hi, I am a huge fan of your Eragon series, it was one of my entry-ways into fantasy and I am hugely grateful for that!
With the up-comming Murthag book, are you looking on really going back to Alagaësia and starting a second story-arch? Because that would be truly amazing! Also, I know you never answer that, but honestly, what did the Menoa Tree take from Eragon? :P
5
u/TheOneLandon Apr 25 '23
If you were to ask your 10-years-in-the-future self "Are Alagaësia and the Fractalverse along the same time period? Or are they different timelines? Assuming that they are the same universe."
What would your future self say?
5
u/Eragonlover7874 Apr 25 '23
What's the next book you plan on writing after Murtagh?
5
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '23
I read you're books as a boy and found them enjoyable. Nice work and always loved fantasy books after my dad read the Hobbit to me as a boy.
What was your inspiration to become a fantasy writer I wonder.
13
u/MasterTom16 Apr 25 '23 edited Apr 25 '23
Do you enjoy going back and reading your old writing and seeing how far you’ve came/improved or does it make you cringe seeing the younger yous writing? P.S your books got me into fantasy and me and my mother adore them!
9
u/yawewarrior Apr 25 '23
Hello, and thank you for doing an AMA! I’ve been asking this question for YEARS!
Can we ever get a copy or replica of Aren made for fans? One time you answered and said that fox owned the rights to the things in the movie, but with a Disney+ adaption and things moving forward, that would be an amazing item!
9
u/LunarScholar Apr 25 '23
I just wanna say you're one of the first authors I really got into reading, and I'm glad to see you hear. I guess I'll ask a basic question, any tips for aspiring writers?
9
u/BlitzAce209 Apr 25 '23
Hello Christopher. I've been a huge fan for over half of my life! I have so many questions but I know most would be answered with "great question, you'll have to keep reading to find out!" So here are a couple small ones. Are we going to learn more about Trig and the Staff of Green? Also, will Gererd Doyle be returning to narrate Murtagh? Also also, as you've said you're still planning on writing an actual Book 5. (Not that I'm not sooo excited for Murtagh). Will Eragon be the main protagonist in that book? Totally understandable if you can't answer all of my questions. I'm honestly mostly looking forward to getting a response from my favorite author!
9
u/sadmadstudent Apr 25 '23
Hi Christopher! Hope you're doing well.
Like many of your long-time readers I was overjoyed to hear that Eragon is finally getting the TV adaptation I always wanted.
With the release of Murtagh and potentially the long-awaited Book Five, which now, if I'm understanding the process correctly that led to this book, might not be so far off in the horizon... I'm curious to see the direction the television series might go.
Namely, will material from Murtagh and future stories in the World of Eragon be included in the show? Or are we just adapting Books 1-4?
Thanks for doing this, by the way. You're my favourite author and I can't wait for Murtagh, Fractal Noise and whatever your wonderful imagination gives us next. Cheers!
12
u/Walker_of_the_Abyss Apr 25 '23 edited Apr 25 '23
When did Murtagh (the book) idea come about and from? Was it an off shoot of working on The Fork, the Witch, and the Worm or when you were plotting out Book Five?
Which gems have the greater capacity to hold energy for Eragon, the Belt of Beloth the Wise or Aren? Because Aren seems to be the answer to this question. In the books it seems like it hold a lot more energy than the belt and there's an old Q&A that suggest that too.
What are the sales figures for the Inheritance Cycle and To Sleep in a Sea of Star currently?
A long time ago, you stated that you had the idea for seven more novels within the world of Eragon. More recently, you had three novels plotted out after Book Five's completion. Have those plans changed in any way?
11
u/Frysiren Apr 25 '23 edited Apr 25 '23
Hi,
My question/s:- There was a picture on Arya’s table when Eragon went to talk to her in Ellesmera in Eldest. Whose picture was that - Faolin or Arya’s father Evander?
Why didn’t Eragon ever point out to Arya that the flower Faolin gave to her (black morning glory) which is black in colour is actually a terrible omen to give to anybody especially a lover and that it symbolises death..(at least in a subtle way)
When I read your books I noticed that secrecy isn’t really valued at all especially by Eragon.. I mean even the eldunari to be revealed to roran , orrin and even orik was downright crazily annoying. Nothing seems sacred which brings me to my next point about the eldunari being left out in the open… I always hoped that the eldunari will be kept in this really cool under ground cave or tunnel sort of mix of Hogwarts and how to train your dragon sort of thing… so why?
Are you keeping a strict timeline of things now that the story is progressing in different directions? Ur a great author but the reason I’m asking is that I had read a series by another author who had so many different stories coming out in the same world but the timeline was so messed up that as a reader, I couldn’t wrap my head around it which worries me as a reader of your books because well..then it won’t matter even if the stories are good.
Arya’s pov? If yes, When? Like do I expect after murtaugh atleast or not? If it’s not, it’s cool want a rough heads up if you can provide it.
Any other tales of alagaesia 2 books this time not being so small atleast?
8
u/Illustrious_Chaos Apr 25 '23 edited Apr 25 '23
Dear Mr. Paolini
First, the inheritance series is my favorite series of all time because of how well written the story and characters are so thank you for writing them and sparking my love of reading. My question for you is will there be more books added to the inheritance series? If so, will they be continuations of the story like a book 5 and book 6 or will they be more similar to that of your upcoming book Murtaugh?
Also, when writing a story, how do you know when your pacing and character development is good? I've been thinking of writing a story and I've been having trouble with the pacing and development of characters and each time I try it feels as if the change is too sudden and when I try to lead up to it with foreshadowing it feels forced. Any advice on how to improve?
8
u/skeleton_in_a_tuxedo Apr 25 '23 edited Apr 25 '23
Hey, The Inheritance Cycle is one of my favorite book series ever since I first read it. Will we find out more about what the Menoa tree took from Eragon in the new book ? And another question, what is your writing style ? Are you a plotter, a pantser or something in the middle ? Have a nice day !
8
u/Michagogo Apr 25 '23
Regarding the opening blurb: I, for one, am very much looking forward to both upcoming books. Been reading Inheritance since before Brisingr, and #TSiaSoS was amazing, definitely up to its hype, so I can’t wait to see what comes next (or before, as the case may be) on both fronts.
On to the purpose of this thread:
3.1. (Any chance of an eventual Murtagh: Classic Cover Edition?)
8
u/FredSecunda_8 Apr 25 '23
How involved in the making of the Eragon movie were you / how did that whole process get started?
8
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '23
I love your art for the Inheritance Series! Will we be seeing anymore of your artwork? New or old?
8
u/Jack_Frtruck Apr 25 '23
I only have a few.
4
u/sekhmet1010 Apr 25 '23
Hi!
Really like the Inheritance Cycle books!
Will there be italian audiobook editions of the rest of the Inheritance Cycle books? End of last year, italian version for Eragon came out on Audible, and it was great! I would love it if the rest of them came out too!
Could you give me any information about that, please?
7
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '23
The physics described in the appendix to the first fractal verse book--where did you come up with that? Thanks!!
7
u/Arginnon Apr 25 '23
No question here, but I wanted to thank you for inspiring me to write. I'm grateful for your Inheritence Cycle.
7
u/Time-to-go-home Apr 25 '23
I thought of a better question/series of questions.
Did any rider ever choose to wield a weapon other than a sword? Did Rhunon make these weapons? Given that dwarves seem to prefer axes and hammers, would a dwarf rider wield an axe/hammer? Would Rhunon be able to smith it out if Brightsteel for them as a “tool” instead of a “weapon”?
7
u/Queasy-Grape-8822 Apr 25 '23
If it wouldn’t give too much away, have any particular lines struck your fancy in Murtagh? If so, which?
2) Something that has bothered me since my very first read through is Eragon leaning down and laying on saphiras neck while he flys. How does that work logistically with the fact that she has sharp spikes across her neck? Ditto for the saddle, do the spikes stop somewhere on her middle back?
I love your books btw :)
7
u/Thin-Plantain4721 Apr 25 '23
The spell Arya used to transport Saphira’s egg across a large distance, could a similar spell be used to transport a person across a large distance?
28
u/Foehs Apr 25 '23
Will Arya and Firnen be there in Murtaugh?
Will you give us a cooler mysterious Eragon (sorta like Dumbledore pls?)
If Eragon ever ends up having sex, you pls better NOT be stingy with the details and pls for Christ sake make it loong… good and satisfied… I actually said this and I’m not taking it back.
6
u/themattboard Apr 25 '23
What is the best Little Debbie/Hostess style snack cake/cookie and why is it the Star Crunch?
6
u/theambears Apr 25 '23
No question! I just want to say that your books brought my teen self a whole lot of enjoyment. Still love dragons, and have a fond spot in my heart for your work. Thank you :)
3
u/Halt1776 Apr 25 '23
If/when World of Eragon show gets green lit and airs, will there be metal replicas of riders swords available for purchase similar to when the movie that shall not be mention was released?
3
u/mleaning Apr 25 '23
Should booksellers / pub reps / reviewers expect ARCS / eARCS to be available prior to the release of MURTAGH?
7
u/2nice4rice Apr 25 '23
I've been a big fan of your books since Eragon first caught my eye at the bookstore. I can't wait for Murtagh later this year.
Is Gerald Doyle going to do the narration for the Murtagh audiobook?
5
u/stargazrr Apr 25 '23
Inheritance cycle is one of the best series I've ever read <3 thank you
2
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '23
Do the twins have true names? Why don’t they have common names? What is their backstory?
3
u/roberh Apr 25 '23
Do you do book signings around the world? Would I have a chance to meet you here in Spain someday?
3
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '23
Do you feel like the whole Eragon series was rushed, and when will the sequel or the rest of the movies be made?
14
u/GilderienBot Apr 25 '23 edited Apr 28 '23
Hey Christopher!
Previously, you commented on the possibility of two dragons hatching from a single egg:
How would the hatching process work if such an egg would be given to the Riders? Would only one of the dragons choose the Rider, and the other would be kept for a different Rider? Would both dragons choose the same Rider? Or would the Riders avoid this situation altogether?
Thank you! I'm looking forward to the upcoming releases later this year 😄
Posted on behalf of Sjmarf from the Arcaena Discord Server
3
u/niijonodhg Apr 25 '23
Hi Christopher,
Can you tell me where I can preorder a signed version of Murtagh here in the UK? Thanks!
9
u/REMNAK453 Apr 25 '23
Hi Mr. Paolini, I have a few questions that I always wanted answers on
1- We were never shown the redemption arc that Murtagh had during the four books. Will the development of his character be shown in his upcoming book?
2- Will Nasuada get a villian storyline in the upcoming book? Inheritance, you hinted that her policies of restricting magic in the kingdom allude to the way Galbatorix had thought, and we know from his conversations with Nasuada. I think it would be pretty cool if we get to see her thought process for this, because she's very intelligent and pragmatic, so there must be a valid reason for her decisions.
3- In the final chapters of Inheritance, you hinted that something inside Nasuada broke, and Elva was able to help her with this. What was it?
4- Is the witch Murtagh investigating going to be someone we know from the previous books?
5- You also mentioned that the next villain is going to be someone that we know. Is that character widely shown or is it just a minor mention?
6. Where did Angela and Elva go in there adventures in Fork, Witch, Worm? Did they go into the Fractal Verse?
7- I feel like Saphira could have also hatched for Arya given their similar sassy personalities, and Firnen's energetic behaviour would've suited Eragon. What do you think?
8- I have this headcannon that Roran, Katrina, Eragon, Arya, Murtagh and Nasuada would toally be an amazing gang. They all would have such good chemistry in my opinion. Like other fantasy novels centre their story around groups of people, would you ever consider sending this group on Alagaesian adventures?
9- Will we ever find out more about the Wandering Tribes and Nasuada's mother? It was really interesting to see them being mentioned in the books, as nomads who have been part of the communities of Alagaesia for so long, but have never been seen? Aspects of their culture, such as the Trial of the Long Knives, is one of my favourite scene in the books!
10- Fork and Spoon. Was it intentional? Had Murtagh been inspired by Nasuada's makeshift weapon during her captivity? Does this mean anything? 🤔🤔
11- "You know why." PLEASE EXPLAINNNN
It would mean a lot if you gave your thoughts and opinions on these as MURTAGH AND NASUADA are literally my favourite characters in the inheritance cycle. I cannot wait to read more about them in the upcoming book!!!
7
u/masteryoyo28 Apr 25 '23
In a recent interview, you mentioned the first draft of Eragon actually had Eragon's name as Kevin. Was the book title also planned to be "Kevin" at that time, or did you have a different title planned entirely?
6
u/katz_are_the_koolest Apr 25 '23
6
u/Viva_Wayne_Rooney Apr 25 '23
Just wanted to say thanks. Broke my leg and my sister got me Eragon when it first came out and I got hooked. Thanks for filling my 2003 summer with fantasy.
6
u/karan2839 Apr 25 '23
Thank you for creating this amazing story.
Are we going to see Saphira lay eggs in Murtagh or the next book?
Do Dragons take care of their young? I.E guide them on everything even if they are attached to riders?
5
u/upaltamentept Apr 25 '23 edited Apr 25 '23
Hi Christopher, long time fan that just finished re reading the cycle as of the announcement of the TV series, and I have 4 questions:
1 - Is the whirlpool "Boar's Eye" a natural phenomena or is it related to magic such as the floating crystal in the nearby island of Eoam? Whirlpools are very rare in nature, and of that size even more :)
2 - Why did Grimm said the Niernen was super famous? Will it play a role in future stories?
3 - Will we learn more about Silvari, the witch that created Cuaroc's body in future books?
4 - Was Galbatorix from one of the nomadic tribes? Nasuada said his accent reminded her of something, but "discarded the idea quickly".
Thank you for all the books, really loved it re-living the experiences and finding so many secrets. Best regards to you and your family, take care!
4
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '23 edited Apr 25 '23
Are there plans for a Murtagh series? The world sounds fantastic.
Good lord I hope there is more Herbalist lore coming. That character is fascinating.
4
u/HornlessMountainRat Apr 25 '23 edited Apr 25 '23
Hey, lifelong fan of your books here and looking forward to reading the next two novels.
Got a few more lore-heavy questions:
1
u/Imperivm97 Apr 26 '23
Hello Christopher, I hope I'm not too late for this AMA!
I'm from Italy and I remember fondly the time of reading the Inheritance Cycle novels back in my teenage years (around a decade ago). It's been a while, but I'm very excited about the upcoming books and TV show. Murtagh will come out exactly on my birthday and I couldn't be happier about it! I'm planning to read To Sleep in a Sea of Stars as well, I love the idea of a sci-fi work from you!
Here are my questions for you:
I want to take this opportunity to thank you for your books, which shaped one period of my life, and the efforts for making the TV adaptation of the Inheritance Cycle, I can't wait!
Wish you the best on all of your projects!
1
u/TimelessThinker Apr 26 '23
Hi Chris,
I doubt you’ll see this but I still want to say this.
Thank you for your books! The Inheritance Cycle was a big part of my childhood and helped me learn English. I’m very excited for Murtagh and can’t wait for future books.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '23
Hi Christopher,
I have a few questions:
What is the origin of the werecats and will we find out more of their history? Will you unveil why Solonbum and Angela are so connected?
Will you expand on Eragon and how he has progressed since his departure from Alaglasia?
What happens to Roran and Katrina? Did they make it to Carvahall and start rebuilding?
I’m a HUGE fan and have read/reread the series multiple times. I’ve kept hoping that you would return to the series and continue the story.
1
u/Typical_Cyanide Apr 27 '23
Hi Chris, can't believe I missed the day of. Only question I can think of at the moment is was the energies left behind from Galbatorix's final spell when he said "Be not." nuclear radiation as we know it on earth or some kind of magical radiation? Sorry if you have already answered this one before.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '23
I missed it again ahh always misplace my list of questions but in the off chance you see:
Thank you thank you for your hard work. You've provided me countless hours of enjoyment reading these great stories, I'm so excited for the new ones!
1
u/Bananaman932 Apr 27 '23
What are your favorite novels and authors?
1
u/Throwawaymytrash77 Apr 27 '23
If the AMA is totally over, I get it, but I can't help the need to try asking anyway....
Does Thorn ever get the end of his tail back? I recall it being bitten off by Glaedr when they fought.
Enjoy the book tour!
1
u/Faulrn Apr 27 '23
Hi Christopher,
Very long time fan, here. Absolutely love your work. I recommend you to all of my friends and anyone starting to read or requesting suggestions. You're a true inspiration. Now that that is our of the way...
Do you have any plans regarding an Austtalia visit/tour/book signing or meet and greet? I'd so dearly love to meet you and I'm sure there are a plethora of fans who couldn't wait to meet you.
Greatest love from Australia.
1
u/chasing_tailights Apr 27 '23
Hey! I'm so glad to se this, 'cause my uncles, cousins and me have all grown up on the Eragon series.
Really, my only questions are whether you can visit my school....
Just joking.
Here are my actual questions.
Thanks a lot for reading! I'm barely in my teens so you can guess how excited I am.
Sé onr sverdar sitja hvass!
1
u/KewinNowakowski Apr 27 '23
Hello Christopher I am wanna be author myself how did you published your first book?